CivNat is gay

Nationalism IS tribalism. With few exceptions, civic identity doesn't overcome more obvious tribalism.

Tribalism is the reality, civic identity is the lofty goal. People won't SAY they like tribalism because it's "racist." Their behavior says more than what they consciously say.

This stuff about "inviability" is just a non-sequitur, because we certainly aren't going to see diversity morph into kumbahyah civic identity. That's not a viable goal either. Something will have to give.

Even if thereis no political pathway to either of these goals. It is what it is.

But we know which one we see in the real world.

Tribalism is a reality of human behavior. Some people try to invigorate a particular tribalism which is constantly socially engineered out of the associated people.

The alternative is to socially engineer it out of everyone else. Which is more likely to succeed?

Yeah, they're obligated to tolerate goyish minorities under the conventions of basic human rights. But the state maintains ethnic hegemony for the Jewish people. It's intended to be a Jewish state where Jews rule, and Zionists want it to become more Jewish. It's an ethno-state.