redditships

I [28f] don't know if The relationship my SO [31m] has with his sister [33f] is normal and if I can deal with it for the rest of my life.

May 13th, 2020
5,990
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 8.78 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Hi Reddit. I am hoping you can help me with this long term issue I am having.
  2.  
  3. Background:
  4.  
  5. I am 28 and have two half siblings that are significantly older than I was. I vaguely remember them around when I was younger, and even now I hardly see them. I grew up on my own for the most part. My oldest sister Katherine lived at home for a couple of years when we were both adults so we saw each other frequently then.
  6.  
  7. My SO, Ryan, is 31 and has a sister who is a couple years older than he is. His parents had a long and messy divorce when they were younger and his sister says she felt like his second mother at times before she left the house at 18 for college. Ryan went to college at 18 and moved back home at 22.
  8.  
  9. Story:
  10.  
  11. Ryan and I have had a solid relationship over the last 5 years. Most of it has been long distance due to my travels for work and relocating a couple of times, but I have been home for the last two years. We decided to take our relationship to the next level and move in together. He has been staying at my house most nights, but I have roommates and we are looking for a space of our own.
  12.  
  13. When I think of our future, I am excited for the most part. I am ready to move forward and see where things go. If I had to say there was one thing holding me back, however, it would be his sister, Jenna.
  14.  
  15. Jenna and I have an okay relationship towards one another. Because I was gone often for the first few years, I didn’t get to know her well outside of holidays and the rare occasion we were both in town at the same time. She lives about 4 hours away from us. We are extremely opposite people in terms of personality, and have little in common with one another. So, our conversations have been very base level and cordial. If I had to guess, she probably didn’t like me at all in the beginning, but she warmed up to me after I showed that her brother and I were in fact serious though I was gone often.
  16.  
  17. I don’t think she liked me much because I was “taking her brother away from her.” She is incredibly territorial with him, and has told me many, many times over the last 5 years that she will always be number one in his life, and anyone else is second. This is why I don’t think she liked me and why she’s opened up more, because I am still around. I’ve been reflecting on this statement she often makes and wonder that that means for Mine + Ryan’s future. I haven’t ever asked Ryan but I think he feels the same – no one will top her. I don’t know if this is a normal sibling relationship but I’m not like that with my half siblings, and I don’t know anyone else who is. Jenna is married too.
  18.  
  19. To add to the above point: When I was traveling for work once, it came up in conversation that Ryan, Jenna, and her husband should come visit for the weekend. I said it would be fun and left it at that. They were planning while I was gone, and Ryan asked again if it would be okay if they came. I said it’s entirely up to them and didn’t matter to me. I think he thought I just wanted to spend alone time with him, because when he told his sister he didn’t want her to go, she stopped talking to him for a few weeks. I tried to do damage control but it was too late. He brought it up to me by saying “Jenna is mad at me because I told her I wanted to go to Dallas alone.”
  20.  
  21. But that does not leave Ryan blameless, either. Ryan can’t make one decision in his life without consulting his sister. From what he should wear, to what he should do for the day, to what he should eat, he is on the phone with her nearly 24/7. He probably calls her 15 times a day, minimum. If something eventful happens, or if I tell him a story just sharing everyday things with him, he always says he has to call and tell his sister. If we are watching television and something funny comes up, he calls her to tell her. Jenna loves it though even though she doesn’t call him as much as he calls her – perhaps because her work schedule is more demanding. So of course, it’s a two way street. Is this normal? None of my other SO’s with siblings were ever like this. He says they’re just close that’s all. But something about it just seems excessive. I don’t see an end to this and it is exhausting.
  22.  
  23. Another thing he does is tell her all of our relationship secrets. Jenna knows nearly everything about myself, Ryan, and then some. He goes to her about issues he’s having before he goes to me. I do trust Jenna’s opinion and she does not always take his side for the sake of being his brother, but I wish he would talk to me about issues instead of assuming things because of an outside opinion. We all have outlets, and when I have issues there are a couple dear friends I confide in too, but there are some hidden secrets that I wish she didn’t know out of embarrassment / respect for me.
  24.  
  25. The one other thing I don’t understand is the physical one. When Jenna is around, they are physically affectionate towards each other in ways that I don’t know are sibling appropriate. I don’t do this with my siblings, but they cuddle in bed together. As in, big spoon and little spoon. One time when we were all going to lunch, they were cuddled in bed and he has nothing but underwear on. If my brother had no pants on I wouldn’t feel comfortable sitting on top of a bed with him, let alone under the sheets with skin contact. They are always holding hands, petting each other, holding one another, etc. They also love to baby-talk to one another. When we vacation together, they are the ones sleeping in a bed together. If people saw the four of us in public, they would never think I was his girlfriend. They would think Jenna is.
  26.  
  27. There have been other comments and things he has said that has made me wonder if I want to deal with this long term, or if I am overreacting. He said our new place has to have a room for her. Not a guest room, but a specific room for Jen. I did not respond to that, but I wanted to tell him that she’s more than welcome to a room if she is willing to pay the additional rent for a space we don’t need.
  28.  
  29. I think Jenna has felt more comfortable to criticize me recently, because all of the times I have seen her, she has made comments about my appearance in a negative way, comments about any blunders or questions I may ask, never wants to get to know me or ask questions about my career, family, etc, but then gets upset if I do not fawn over her life.
  30.  
  31. Many people have commented that I better not get married to Ryan or have a kid before Jenna gets married and has a child or else she would forever hate me. I cannot make one post on Facebook or Instgram without her commenting either on it in a negative way. Example: picture in the office of a small work accomplishment. Her comment was “That’s work I’d never want to do”.
  32.  
  33. Also, if Ryan has any problems, as trivial as a rash, he will always consult her on anything and everything. And anything Jenna tells him he will try and say that she’s right. He’ll never ask for my advice on anything. And if I give him suggestions on stuff, he will always refuse. If Jenna gives him suggestions, he will always seek them out. For example: I suggested a new kitchen gadget for him to use that I think will make his cooking hobbies easier. Multiple times I brought it up and he kept saying no to the point it was irritating to him, so I stopped asking. Jenna mentioned it once and he’s already purchased it, waiting for it to come in the mail. The exact same item. It’s not that he treats me bad at all, but overtime I’ve noticed he treats her, better?
  34.  
  35. My worry is that I’m noticing that the way Jenna treats me isn’t going to get better if it hasn’t over nearly 5 years. I can put up with it and brush most things off, but do I want to deal with this forever? This passive-aggressive behavior that I don’t ask for? Is their behavior towards one another normal or is there something I am missing in normal sibling relationships? And I also fear that Ryan would always prioritize her, even into marriage, where I believe that you become one unit with your spouse and that person is your priority now. I do well on my own and I am independent, but this is such a touchy subject for him that I don’t think I could ever even bring it up without him going ballistic for even questioning his sister. I feel so stuck and I don’t know what to do. I really love Ryan, and this probably sounds insignificant compared to real relationship problems, but It has been keeping me awake these last few weeks and we continue our house search.
  36.  
  37. In the hour it took me to write this, he has called her twice to let her know that it is cold here, and that he’s going to grab some water from the sink.
  38.  
  39. TLDR: My SO has a bizarre relationship with his sister that I don’t know is normal for siblings, and their relationship + the way she treats me makes me question if I want to continue this relationship into marriage, etc.
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment