Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- This is a little complicated but I’ll try to explain as best as possible. My (34M) twin sister (34F, “Lyla”) has been in a wonderful relationship with her wife (36F, “Effie”) for about 8 years. Shortly after they got married, they both very much wanted to start a family. After discussing their options, they came to a decision that a great way for them to conceive a child that’s biologically “both of theirs” would be through IVF, using my sperm and Effie’s egg (with Effie carrying the baby).
- I was completely okay with that and more than happy to help them out. My own wife and I don’t have or want kids personally, so there wasn’t any subsidiary family drama to consider there, and with Lyla being my twin… it just made sense. They literally could not get any closer to a “traditional” pregnancy as a couple. It was a success, and Lyla and Effie now have a beautiful 3 year old daughter (who, unsurprisingly, looks exactly like Lyla). Everyone is thrilled about her.
- A few months ago they decided they were ready to expand their family. They’d wanted two kids from the beginning, and they’d like the siblings to be fully biological, so Lyla contacted me about donating sperm again and of course I agreed. That is, until, I found out that Effie can no longer safely carry a baby to term. Apparently they’ve known about this since encountering complications during the first pregnancy.
- So, instead, my sister would be the one carrying the baby. A baby that’s technically mine. I immediately told her no. I’m not comfortable with that. I understand that her DNA would not be “mixing” with mine in any way, but something about it still seems really off to me. I do not want to sit across from my pregnant sister at Christmas dinner knowing that *I* put the baby inside of her. I don’t want awkward situations like their kid exclaiming “my mommy gave birth to me and my daddy is her brother!”
- Lyla is extremely upset, saying that I’m being selfish and closed-minded and juvenile. Told me that I’m ruining what would be their perfect family and robbing their daughter of a full blood sibling. There’s absolutely no way they can afford the compensation fees and other costs of a gestational carrier (plus they’re now attached to the idea of them each having carried one sibling). So the only other option would be using a different sperm donor.
- In a way, I can absolutely see her side of things. I realize that I sort of *am* being juvenile. The only thing standing in the way of their dream is that I just can’t shake the “eeewy, incest!” vibes (even though I’m fully aware that in reality, there’s nothing incestuous about it). Is it a selfish move that I can’t just put my feelings aside and let them complete their family? For me it’s simply an uncomfortable thought, but for them it’s a decision that affects their whole family and future. Just need some advice I guess.
- TL;DR: My sister and her wife have previously conceived a child using my sperm and her wife’s egg (with her wife carrying). They want to do it again but with my sister carrying, and I’m not comfortable with that.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment