My [30F] husband [30M] “can’t trust me” because I got him a PS5

Because I know it’ll come up: no, we haven’t had trust issues or infidelity before.

We have been married 2 years.

Anyway for Christmas I got my H a PS5. He was asking so many questions leading up to Christmas that I elaborately lied to him by making him a painting (I’m also an artist) and telling him I made him his gift and not to go in the back guest room bc that’s where I was storing it. I was also storing his PS5 back there, which I got online via alert accounts on twitter. Anyway on Christmas morning he believed his “surprise” was the painting (and he loved it) but wasn’t expecting the PS5. A few weeks before Christmas he asked if I was getting him the PS5 and I “broke down” telling him I had tried and had no luck, and please don’t be disappointed. So basically I had an elaborate ruse in which I made him believe I was trying to get a PS5, failed, made him the painting instead, but secretly did have a PS5.

Anyway, while he’s happy with the PS5 he said my acting and lying about the PS5 were so convincing that he knows if I ever cheat on him I’ll be able to cover it up very well. I thought he was kidding but as happy he is with the PS5, he’s genuinely unable to trust me now and is asking if I ever lied about other things, like whether I actuslly think he’s tall or if I think his podcast is bad. Help! I thought this made me a great wife but apparently now I’m just a good liar.