The Scary Jokes songs ranked by RYM

Icicles (4.15)
Catabolic Seed (3.96)
Toynbee Tiles (3.94)
Friends With You (3.91)
Feelin' So Matryoshka (3.91)
Pink Smoke (3.91)
Apple Pie (3.87)
Pleasure Cruise (3.83)
In a Bitter Syrup (3.82)
A Mannequin Adrift (3.80)
Uzumaki (3.76)
Blood From the Concrete (3.73)
A Night at the Movies (3.69)
Death, Thrice Drawn (3.68)
Magic Hat (3.66)
Community Gardens (3.64)
Starstruck (3.64)
Bets Against the Void (3.64)
Jeannie... You're a Tragedy (3.62)
Crushed Out on Soda Beach (3.62)
Our Murderous Descent (3.56)
Forever in You (3.56)
Elephant Foot (3.55)
Pygmalion (3.54)
Emotional Vagrant (3.54)
No Leverage / No Pleasure (3.54)
Retreat to Celestial Bodies (3.54)
Riptide (3.52)
Rage (3.52)
Funny (3.51)
Sylvia's Just a Dying Fad (3.49)
Demons of Accident (3.48)
Jeanine (3.47)
Hold Yourself Tight (3.44)
Admire the Architecture (3.44)
Wrath of the Termite King (3.43)
Parthenogenesis (3.42)
Hello World (3.37)
I'm Too Shy (3.34)
Do You Believe Me (3.30)
Sleepyhead (3.29)
Your Vicious Kin (3.17)
The Ren and Stimpy Show (3.14)
I Wanna Be the Moon (3.13)
Bad at Math (3.08)
Poison Ivy Grows (3.06)
The Daughter of the Fish and the Ram (2.68)