Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Sep 25th, 2023
3,682
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 18.11 KB | None | 0 0
  1.  
  2. Dozens Of Government UFO Whistleblowers Have Given Testimony To Congress, Pentagon, And Inspectors General, Say Sources
  3. Despite the growing number of UFO/UAP whistleblowers, leaders the military and intelligence community are fighting greater disclosure
  4. MICHAEL SHELLENBERGER, ANDREW MOHAR, AND PHOEBE SMITH
  5. SEP 25
  6.  
  7. ∙
  8.  
  9. PAID
  10.  
  11.  
  12.  
  13.  
  14.  
  15.  
  16.  
  17.  
  18.  
  19.  
  20.  
  21.  
  22.  
  23. READ IN APP
  24.  
  25.  
  26.  
  27.  
  28. Thomas A. Monheim, nominee for Inspector General of the Intelligence Community speaks at a hearing with the Senate Select Intelligence Committee on Capitol Hill on July 20, 2021, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)
  29. In August, shortly after U.S. government UFO whistleblower David Grusch gave testimony to Congress about crashed spacecraft and alien “biologics,” many observers wondered how much credence to put in his testimony. After all, Grusch is just a single individual. The other two individuals who testified before Congress were former Navy pilots who said they had no evidence of a government program to retrieve and reverse-engineer spacecraft of exotic and apparently nonhuman origin.
  30. But at least 30 other whistleblowers working for the federal government or government contractors have given testimony, or a “protected disclosure,” to the Office of the Intelligence Community Inspector General (IC IG), the Defense Department Inspector General (DOD IG), or to Congress over the last several months, according to multiple sources interviewed by Public.
  31. When told that whistleblowers had come forward to share information similar to that shared by Grusch with Congress, Mick West, a prominent skeptic of UFOs, said, “It'd be very interesting. You know, more people saying the same thing independently makes it more likely to be true.”
  32. And yet the Inspector General of the Intelligence Community, Thomas A. Monheim, on September 15 appeared to deny, in a letter to Congress, that his office was investigating these claims. Monheim said that his office “has not conducted any audit, inspection, evaluation, or review of alleged UAP programs within responsibility authority of the DNI that would enable … a fulsome response.”
  33. But the way Monheim worded his response suggests he gave himself some wiggle room. Matthew Pines, a civilian intelligence analyst, noted last week that “the official taxonomy for IC IG activities includes: ‘audits, investigations, inspections, and reviews.’ Is it curious that an ‘investigation’ is not denied?... The Investigations Division is structurally separate from the Audit and Inspections & Evaluation Divisions.” 
  34. The fact that dozens of whistleblowers have come forward is not evidence of extraterrestrial life nor of a government conspiracy to cover up a retrieval or reverse-engineering program. And not all of the whistleblowers may be reporting evidence of UAPs. Some may simply be reporting illegal or unethical behavior related to UAP programs.
  35. But the sources, who asked to remain anonymous and are all in a position to know, told Public that, in addition to the whistleblowers reporting wrongdoing, between 30 to 50 government employees or contractors have gone to the DoD’s All-Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) to offer testimony about UAPs.
  36. “Some witnesses/whistleblowers are coming forward directly to AARO, some to the DOD IG, some to the IC IG, and some to Congress,” said Nick Pope, a UAP expert who worked on the issue for the UK’s Ministry of Defense.
  37. Many have speculated as to whether Grusch and other UAP whistleblowers or witnesses might be part of a US government disinformation campaign.
  38. A former US Air Force intelligence officer working at Kirtland Air Force Base in the 1980s through to the first decade of this century admitted to British journalist Mark Pilkington and others that he spread disinformation about UFOs with the aim of misleading civilian UFO investigators in order to cover-up both US military as well as nonhuman technology programs.
  39. But, experts interviewed by Public say it is unlikely that people waging a disinformation campaign would do it through the Office of the Inspector General since doing so puts individuals at risk.
  40. “Considering the broader context, to include Grusch’s allegations, previous reporting by Public, and the extraordinary legislation working its way through Congress,” said Marik von Rennenkampff, a former Pentagon appointee under the Obama administration, “I find it hard to believe that so many individuals would open themselves up to significant legal jeopardy by willfully lying to inspectors general.”
  41. Knowingly giving false testimony to the IC IG is punishable by fines up to $ 10,000, imprisonment for up to five years, or both. If found guilty of lying to Congress, Grusch would face up to five years in prison.
  42. At the same time, the history of past government disinformation campaigns in general, and as they specifically relate to UAPs, involves the mixing of accurate information and inaccurate information, making it difficult or impossible to feel confident in understanding the meaning of fundamental elements of the phenomenon.
  43. That reality and the need to prevent government officials from deliberately misleading journalists, policymakers, and the public make greater transparency and disclosure essential, both UFO skeptics and believers agree.
  44. “It’s either that dozens of highly cleared officials are in the grip of an enduring, bizarre delusion, are witting participants to a broad scale and long-running psychological deception,” said Pines, “or they are relaying factual information on extraordinary covert programs.”
  45. Said West, “I can understand why people would think ufology is frivolous and a waste of government money, and we shouldn't be looking into it. But they don't think we shouldn’t release the secret information about crashed alien craft, you know, something everybody wants to see.”
  46. Extraordinary Claims
  47.  
  48.  
  49.  
  50. Stephanie O'Sullivan during her Senate Select Intelligence confirmation hearing on her nomination to be the principal deputy director of national intelligence, February 5, 2011. (Photo by Scott J. Ferrell/Congressional Quarterly/Getty Images)
  51. Testimony has included both first-hand and second-hand reports of crash retrieval and reverse-engineering programs by US, Russian, and Chinese governments; the testing of materials obtained from retrieved craft; active and ongoing government disinformation operations; kinetic military action with UAPs; contact and collaboration with nonhuman intelligence (NHIs); and the successful reverse-engineering of a triangle-shaped craft with unconventional propulsion.
  52. Several of these whistleblowers spoke to Public on the condition of remaining anonymous. All expressed fear of retaliation for sharing the information but said they felt compelled to do so because of the unethical and illegal behaviors they had witnessed. “People are scared to death,” said one source. “You could be court-martialed or, worse, dropped in the desert and left six feet under.”
  53. In July, we reported a long history of UAP witnesses and whistleblowers reporting having received death threats from military, intelligence, or paramilitary forces around the world.
  54. New legal protections for government whistleblowers have resulted in a historically unprecedented number of individuals coming forward to report unethical or illegal activities relating to the U.S. government’s engagement with unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAP), previously referred to as UFOs.
  55. “Within Congress, some are going to the Senate and others to the House: some to the Armed Services committees, some to the Intelligence committees, and some to the Oversight committees, or the various sub-committees,” Pope explained. “And some of these people have doubtless approached a combination of these bodies. What all this likely means is that it's difficult to give a total figure, but it will be way higher than two dozen.”
  56. Starting on Thursday last week, Public contacted multiple individuals in each of the agencies listed above and confirmed by phone receipt of our emails requesting comments and describing the contents of this article. Not a single agency responded officially. 
  57. Individuals who give testimony do so from within Sensitive Compartmented Information Facilities known as SCIFs. The testimonies are recorded and can last several hours. Government officials, whether in the IC IG, the DoD IG, or Congress, have recorded hundreds of hours of testimonies by whistleblowers and witnesses over the last several months, sources told Public.
  58. The DOD IG is for government employees/servicemen or contractors outside of the intelligence community (IC), and the ICIG is for anyone in the intelligence community. There are specific military service inspectors general, such as the Air Force IG and Army IG. Each IG office handles specific cases that fall within their jurisdiction and elevates them to a higher level when complex allegations of illegality, like those claimed by Grusch and others, span more than one service or agency.
  59. Why did the IC’s Inspector General, Thomas Monheim, appear to suggest his office is not investigating Grusch’s claims?
  60. “It seems like Monheim is boxed in by his duty to protect the confidentiality of these whistleblowers and preserve the integrity of his and maybe other investigations,” said Pines. “But he needed to respond to intense congressional pressure, and so may be dodging and hinting via negativa, giving a classic DC lawyer-speak non-denial denial. He also makes a strong point that he was only looking at the DNI programs under his purview. These legacy [UAP] programs are alleged to sprawl far beyond his remit in the unacknowledged special access programs tucked deep inside DoD and, in particular, the Department of Energy, which has its own classification and clearance system.”
  61. Sources said that special forces programs operated by the U.S. military and intelligence agencies use the cover of conventional programs for the retrieval of downed military craft or test missiles as cover for retrieving UAPs.
  62. The law allows whistleblowers to bypass both the IC IG and the DoD IG and go straight to Congress. Whistleblowers who go to the DoD IG are referred to the Department of the Inspector General for the Air Force. But if multiple agencies are involved, officials direct whistleblowers to the IC IG.
  63. According to the law, if the IC IG finds the whistleblower claims to be “credible” and “urgent,” it must send the whistleblower testimony to Congress. But even if the IC IG doesn’t find the testimony credible and urgent, the whistleblower can ask for an introduction to congressional investigators, and the IC IG must provide it.
  64. Whistleblower Protection Act’s Senior Executive A Directive number 9 says that government agencies must not retaliate against whistleblowers by revoking their security clearance so long as she or he goes through the proper channels.
  65. “The ICIG sees their role as narrowly statutorily defined,” explained Pines, “and they had a proviso [in Monheim’s letter to Congress] saying that, ‘As a matter of discretion, we are responding, but we have a statutory obligation only to provide information to the intelligence committees and have no obligation to make all our findings public or even acknowledge that particular investigations are underway.”
  66. Stephanie O’Sullivan, a former associate deputy director of the CIA and Principal Deputy Director of National Intelligence in the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), is aware of a UAP crash retrieval and reverse-engineering program, people close to the issue say, but denied its existence to Senator Rubio in a private meeting recently.
  67. The Board of Trustees of the Aerospace Corporation, a US government-funded nonprofit research organization, added O’Sullivan in 2017 and named her acting chair in 2021. The Aerospace Corporation offers technical advice to NASA, the United States Space Force, and the National Reconnaissance Office.
  68. In the past, O’Sullivan worked for TRW, now Northrop Grumman, and the Office of Naval Intelligence. She served as deputy director of the CIA’s Directorate of Science and Technology (DS&T), the same office worked in by Kit Green, who has suggested to British author Mark Pilkington that the core UFO crash retrieval and reverse engineering program is real.
  69. In 2020, the New York Times reported that a man named Eric Davis, who works for Aerospace Corporation, said he gave a classified briefing to the Defense Department about retrievals of “off-world vehicles not made on this earth.”
  70. DOD And IC Circle Wagons
  71.  
  72.  
  73.  
  74. U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin arrives for a briefing on Ukraine at the U.S. Capitol on September 20, 2023 in Washington, DC. Leaders from the State Department, Department of Defense and intelligence community briefed Senators on the ongoing Ukrainian war against Russia. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
  75. For months, sources have told Public that the Biden White House favors greater UAP disclosure. Senior Navy officers met Jake Sullivan at the White House and said, “There’s something here that NORAD and the Air Force aren’t telling you about.” From that conversation, the White House created a UAP working group led by Sullivan but also including the Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin.
  76. Sources said the White House likely supported the proposed amendment by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), which would require Defense contractors to disclose UAP crash retrieval and reverse engineering programs. The Schumer Amendment is part of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) and, if it survives a conference committee with the House, would go into effect when the NDAA is signed by President Biden, typically in December.
  77. But little has come out of that UAP working group and now, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin is trying to undermine an amendment, sources say. Austin is telling members of Congress and individuals within the White House that the Schumer amendment would undermine national security if passed, they say.
  78. Sources added that Rep. Mike Turner, who oversees the House Intelligence Committee and is close to the Intelligence Community and Defense contractors, has similarly tried to kill the Schumer amendment. Turner also sought to shut down the congressional UAP hearings after Grusch’s July testimony, they said, while Mark Warner (D-VA) sought to shut down hearings in the Senate, despite bipartisan support for hearings by Senators Marco Rubio and Kirsten Gillibrand.
  79. As for the ICIG Monheim letter to Burchett and Luna, Pines said that it seemed “to be an attempt to get members of Congress—who are not on the intelligence committees the IC IG is legally responsible to—off their back.”
  80. Some of the sources say that what’s needed is something like the 1973 Church Committee commission, which exposed widespread illegal and unethical behavior by US intelligence organizations, including the CIA.
  81. The need for such an investigation may be justified, whether one views the UAPs as nonhuman intelligence, a government disinformation campaign, or something else.
  82. “I'd love to hear more whistleblowers come forward because this is a situation that needs clearing up,” said West. “Extreme accusations have been made. One way or another, I think the American public needs to know what's going on. Is it just a big misunderstanding? Is it some kind of old psyop? Is it some kind of new psyop? I'd like to know. If these whistleblowers have more detail, bring them on.”
  83. Others said something more like a truth and reconciliation commission was required in order to give amnesty for illegal and unethical behaviors in the US government’s UAP special access programs dating back to the period just after World War II.
  84. Still, others simply want better protections for whistleblowers and stronger public oversight.
  85. “There may be an acute concern that if this becomes another Church Committee-level scandal, it would pour kerosene on the burning embers of distrust in the political system,” said Pines. “Whether it’s the worry over technological surprise from strategic competitors like China or that too many people have already spilled the beans, political leadership may feel they have to manage things as much as possible behind the scenes, as they face an unstable geopolitical dynamic and gird for an exceptionally fraught 2024 campaign.”
  86. “One question is whether ICIG is collaborating with other IGs, especially DOD and DOE, to compare notes and to look at allegations of impropriety across agencies that might align with what different whistleblowers are telling them,” said Pines. “That would be a larger effort and may have serious law enforcement implications as well.”
  87. Pines says that the Schumer provision for a review board of former government officials to release UAP information to the public could be viewed as an alternative to having the president take political ownership of this issue too soon.
  88. “I could see them punting everything to this review board to navigate the 2024 elections and deliberately release information drip like the JFK commission, at least until national leadership is prepared to have a difficult conversation with the American and global public. As the Schumer bill says, it’s a ‘controlled disclosure campaign.’ And so that would explain why you’d not want ICIG to openly validate too much of the stuff being deposed to them, behind the scenes, until they get the institutional mechanisms and political frameworks in place.”
  89. “But, as you know,” said Pines, it just takes a few more Gruschs to throw a monkey wrench in that plan.”
  90. “Why wouldn't you want disclosure?” said West. “If there's a secret government program of reverse engineering flying saucers, I would love to know about that… I think if you've got dozens of whistleblowers coming forward, it's pretty hard to put that back in the bottle. That means that there's all this stuff that's being withheld from scientists that we could be studying. There's information about the universe that we don't know, that we should know.”
  91.  
  92.  
  93. A guest post by
  94. Andrew Mohar
  95. Contributor to Public
  96.  
  97. LIKE
  98.  
  99. COMMENT
  100.  
  101. RESTACK
  102.  
  103.  
  104. © 2023 Michael Shellenberger
Public, c/o Michael Shellenberger, P.O. Box 8538
Albany, CA 94707 
Unsubscribe
  105.  
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment