daily pastebin goal
7%
SHARE
TWEET

Untitled

a guest Jan 29th, 2017 127 Never
Upgrade to PRO!
ENDING IN00days00hours00mins00secs
 
  1. Mon Jan 23 14:41:23 2017  
  2. Mon Jan 23 14:41:23 2017  
  3. Mon Jan 23 14:41:23 2017  Msieve v. 1.52 (SVN unknown)
  4. Mon Jan 23 14:41:23 2017  random seeds: 3a0f3474 b17d2155
  5. Mon Jan 23 14:41:23 2017  factoring 1374250293977900524006825181025041222391785962418349198188752592542556833408706796147779390990626204883096007787340300959668458776589915992783964729160514357520386806570509 (172 digits)
  6. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
  7. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  commencing number field sieve (172-digit input)
  8. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  R0: -1214784946281755925158360658293296
  9. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  R1: 18303130010379613
  10. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A0: -23481671787104319711626620457547467037375
  11. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A1: 1029230367426047271940304894097130
  12. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A2: 3146916195524283581740271732
  13. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A3: 123748321202088763083
  14. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A4: -51331470267154
  15. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  A5: 519480
  16. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  skew 8648943.40, size 9.864e-17, alpha -6.365, combined = 2.829e-13 rroots = 5
  17. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  
  18. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  commencing relation filtering
  19. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  setting target matrix density to 140.0
  20. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  estimated available RAM is 15888.6 MB
  21. Mon Jan 23 14:41:24 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 1
  22. Mon Jan 23 14:43:08 2017  error -15 reading relation 16802143
  23. Mon Jan 23 14:44:04 2017  error -15 reading relation 25595384
  24. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028429
  25. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028466
  26. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28029447
  27. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030449
  28. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -1 reading relation 28030866
  29. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030949
  30. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034064
  31. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 28034102
  32. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034900
  33. Mon Jan 23 14:44:19 2017  error -9 reading relation 28035134
  34. Mon Jan 23 14:46:25 2017  error -1 reading relation 49162215
  35. Mon Jan 23 14:46:27 2017  error -15 reading relation 49535773
  36. Mon Jan 23 14:47:54 2017  error -15 reading relation 64446614
  37. Mon Jan 23 14:48:00 2017  error -15 reading relation 65376789
  38. Mon Jan 23 14:49:05 2017  error -1 reading relation 75290332
  39. Mon Jan 23 14:50:08 2017  error -1 reading relation 86413805
  40. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99959556
  41. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99963811
  42. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964293
  43. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964330
  44. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964368
  45. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964666
  46. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99965447
  47. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -1 reading relation 99965485
  48. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99966582
  49. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99967695
  50. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968437
  51. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968692
  52. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968774
  53. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968863
  54. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968945
  55. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -5 reading relation 99969029
  56. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969105
  57. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969477
  58. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969561
  59. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969920
  60. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970098
  61. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970135
  62. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970374
  63. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970450
  64. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970488
  65. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970525
  66. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970562
  67. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970599
  68. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970636
  69. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970673
  70. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970710
  71. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970747
  72. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970784
  73. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970821
  74. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970896
  75. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970934
  76. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970971
  77. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971008
  78. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971045
  79. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971082
  80. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971119
  81. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971156
  82. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971193
  83. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971230
  84. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 99971305
  85. Mon Jan 23 14:51:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971544
  86. Mon Jan 23 14:53:16 2017  error -15 reading relation 118254421
  87. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -9 reading relation 118710093
  88. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -15 reading relation 118712486
  89. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -15 reading relation 118714681
  90. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -15 reading relation 118715852
  91. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -9 reading relation 118717968
  92. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718734
  93. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718773
  94. Mon Jan 23 14:53:20 2017  error -9 reading relation 118719858
  95. Mon Jan 23 14:53:40 2017  error -15 reading relation 122210799
  96. Mon Jan 23 14:54:23 2017  error -15 reading relation 129701885
  97. Mon Jan 23 14:54:25 2017  error -9 reading relation 130133944
  98. Mon Jan 23 14:54:32 2017  error -9 reading relation 131455526
  99. Mon Jan 23 14:54:35 2017  error -9 reading relation 131885884
  100. Mon Jan 23 14:55:05 2017  error -1 reading relation 137388768
  101. Mon Jan 23 14:56:33 2017  error -1 reading relation 152337354
  102. Mon Jan 23 14:56:51 2017  error -15 reading relation 155316846
  103. Mon Jan 23 15:00:02 2017  error -15 reading relation 187008707
  104. Mon Jan 23 15:01:57 2017  error -15 reading relation 205569550
  105. Mon Jan 23 15:02:29 2017  error -9 reading relation 210673655
  106. Mon Jan 23 15:03:11 2017  error -15 reading relation 217287951
  107. Mon Jan 23 15:04:19 2017  error -1 reading relation 228881041
  108. Mon Jan 23 15:04:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 229021968
  109. Mon Jan 23 15:04:39 2017  error -15 reading relation 232694555
  110. Mon Jan 23 15:04:44 2017  error -15 reading relation 233364961
  111. Mon Jan 23 15:05:00 2017  error -15 reading relation 236153836
  112. Mon Jan 23 15:06:27 2017  error -9 reading relation 251353235
  113. Mon Jan 23 15:06:54 2017  error -9 reading relation 256124405
  114. Mon Jan 23 15:06:57 2017  error -15 reading relation 256595253
  115. Mon Jan 23 15:06:59 2017  error -15 reading relation 256965280
  116. Mon Jan 23 15:07:00 2017  error -15 reading relation 257033864
  117. Mon Jan 23 15:07:57 2017  error -15 reading relation 266442272
  118. Mon Jan 23 15:08:38 2017  error -1 reading relation 272282639
  119. Mon Jan 23 15:08:49 2017  error -15 reading relation 274526202
  120. Mon Jan 23 15:11:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 299540640
  121. Mon Jan 23 15:11:57 2017  error -9 reading relation 306117543
  122. Mon Jan 23 15:11:59 2017  error -15 reading relation 306329572
  123. Mon Jan 23 15:12:00 2017  error -15 reading relation 306521623
  124. Mon Jan 23 15:12:00 2017  error -15 reading relation 306693363
  125. Mon Jan 23 15:12:00 2017  error -9 reading relation 306704536
  126. Mon Jan 23 15:12:01 2017  error -15 reading relation 306773193
  127. Mon Jan 23 15:12:12 2017  error -9 reading relation 308883659
  128. Mon Jan 23 15:12:16 2017  error -15 reading relation 309379254
  129. Mon Jan 23 15:12:16 2017  error -9 reading relation 309380105
  130. Mon Jan 23 15:12:38 2017  error -15 reading relation 313071101
  131. Mon Jan 23 15:13:12 2017  error -9 reading relation 319053697
  132. Mon Jan 23 15:13:25 2017  error -1 reading relation 321394982
  133. Mon Jan 23 15:13:54 2017  error -9 reading relation 326513986
  134. Mon Jan 23 15:14:06 2017  error -1 reading relation 328842589
  135. Mon Jan 23 15:14:07 2017  error -15 reading relation 328991100
  136. Mon Jan 23 15:14:15 2017  error -9 reading relation 330363605
  137. Mon Jan 23 15:14:16 2017  error -15 reading relation 330446232
  138. Mon Jan 23 15:14:30 2017  error -1 reading relation 333088633
  139. Mon Jan 23 15:14:30 2017  error -9 reading relation 333172340
  140. Mon Jan 23 15:14:30 2017  error -15 reading relation 333172497
  141. Mon Jan 23 15:14:33 2017  error -9 reading relation 333705063
  142. Mon Jan 23 15:14:34 2017  error -15 reading relation 333789370
  143. Mon Jan 23 15:14:39 2017  error -15 reading relation 334671313
  144. Mon Jan 23 15:14:39 2017  error -1 reading relation 334780823
  145. Mon Jan 23 15:14:44 2017  error -1 reading relation 335651448
  146. Mon Jan 23 15:14:46 2017  error -15 reading relation 336160012
  147. Mon Jan 23 15:14:46 2017  error -1 reading relation 336242728
  148. Mon Jan 23 15:14:49 2017  error -15 reading relation 336681059
  149. Mon Jan 23 15:15:16 2017  error -5 reading relation 341735822
  150. Mon Jan 23 15:15:20 2017  error -15 reading relation 342430620
  151. Mon Jan 23 15:15:20 2017  error -9 reading relation 342476075
  152. Mon Jan 23 15:15:21 2017  error -1 reading relation 342759593
  153. Mon Jan 23 15:15:21 2017  error -15 reading relation 342793786
  154. Mon Jan 23 15:15:26 2017  error -9 reading relation 343754727
  155. Mon Jan 23 15:15:27 2017  error -15 reading relation 343822227
  156. Mon Jan 23 15:15:35 2017  error -9 reading relation 345235511
  157. Mon Jan 23 15:15:40 2017  skipped 1 relations with b > 2^32
  158. Mon Jan 23 15:15:40 2017  found 67282127 hash collisions in 346101466 relations
  159. Mon Jan 23 15:16:08 2017  added 121891 free relations
  160. Mon Jan 23 15:16:08 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 2
  161. Mon Jan 23 15:18:33 2017  found 60910482 duplicates and 285312875 unique relations
  162. Mon Jan 23 15:18:33 2017  memory use: 2387.0 MB
  163. Mon Jan 23 15:18:33 2017  reading ideals above 150011904
  164. Mon Jan 23 15:18:33 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  165. Mon Jan 23 15:50:53 2017  memory use: 5512.0 MB
  166. Mon Jan 23 15:50:53 2017  reading all ideals from disk
  167. Mon Jan 23 15:51:10 2017  memory use: 4790.3 MB
  168. Mon Jan 23 15:51:25 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  169. Mon Jan 23 15:51:37 2017  begin with 285312875 relations and 174534413 unique ideals
  170. Mon Jan 23 15:53:27 2017  reduce to 242526750 relations and 129697787 ideals in 9 passes
  171. Mon Jan 23 15:53:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  172. Mon Jan 23 15:53:40 2017  reading ideals above 720000
  173. Mon Jan 23 15:53:41 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  174. Mon Jan 23 16:30:37 2017  memory use: 3012.0 MB
  175. Mon Jan 23 16:30:37 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  176. Mon Jan 23 16:32:25 2017  keeping 132564221 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 14021982
  177. Mon Jan 23 16:34:30 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  178. Mon Jan 23 16:34:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  179. Mon Jan 23 16:34:37 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 132564221 unique ideals
  180. Mon Jan 23 16:35:02 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 132564131 ideals in 3 passes
  181. Mon Jan 23 16:35:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  182. Mon Jan 23 16:35:46 2017  removing 6612611 relations and 4612611 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  183. Mon Jan 23 16:35:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  184. Mon Jan 23 16:35:56 2017  begin with 235914049 relations and 132564131 unique ideals
  185. Mon Jan 23 16:36:46 2017  reduce to 235709098 relations and 127744086 ideals in 6 passes
  186. Mon Jan 23 16:36:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  187. Mon Jan 23 16:37:29 2017  removing 5469859 relations and 3469859 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  188. Mon Jan 23 16:37:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  189. Mon Jan 23 16:37:39 2017  begin with 230239239 relations and 127744086 unique ideals
  190. Mon Jan 23 16:38:25 2017  reduce to 230109913 relations and 124143591 ideals in 6 passes
  191. Mon Jan 23 16:38:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  192. Mon Jan 23 16:39:05 2017  removing 5187561 relations and 3187561 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  193. Mon Jan 23 16:39:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  194. Mon Jan 23 16:39:15 2017  begin with 224922352 relations and 124143591 unique ideals
  195. Mon Jan 23 16:40:02 2017  reduce to 224819584 relations and 120852267 ideals in 6 passes
  196. Mon Jan 23 16:40:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  197. Mon Jan 23 16:40:45 2017  removing 5028623 relations and 3028623 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  198. Mon Jan 23 16:40:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  199. Mon Jan 23 16:40:54 2017  begin with 219790961 relations and 120852267 unique ideals
  200. Mon Jan 23 16:41:36 2017  reduce to 219698623 relations and 117730404 ideals in 5 passes
  201. Mon Jan 23 16:41:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  202. Mon Jan 23 16:42:15 2017  removing 4910869 relations and 2910869 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  203. Mon Jan 23 16:42:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  204. Mon Jan 23 16:42:24 2017  begin with 214787754 relations and 117730404 unique ideals
  205. Mon Jan 23 16:43:01 2017  reduce to 214705417 relations and 114736393 ideals in 5 passes
  206. Mon Jan 23 16:43:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  207. Mon Jan 23 16:43:40 2017  removing 4849549 relations and 2849549 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  208. Mon Jan 23 16:43:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  209. Mon Jan 23 16:43:49 2017  begin with 209855868 relations and 114736393 unique ideals
  210. Mon Jan 23 16:44:34 2017  reduce to 209780786 relations and 111811010 ideals in 6 passes
  211. Mon Jan 23 16:44:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  212. Mon Jan 23 16:45:12 2017  removing 4772571 relations and 2772571 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  213. Mon Jan 23 16:45:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  214. Mon Jan 23 16:45:21 2017  begin with 205008215 relations and 111811010 unique ideals
  215. Mon Jan 23 16:45:58 2017  reduce to 204936429 relations and 108965905 ideals in 5 passes
  216. Mon Jan 23 16:45:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  217. Mon Jan 23 16:46:34 2017  removing 4716236 relations and 2716236 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  218. Mon Jan 23 16:46:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  219. Mon Jan 23 16:46:43 2017  begin with 200220193 relations and 108965905 unique ideals
  220. Mon Jan 23 16:47:17 2017  reduce to 200151762 relations and 106180474 ideals in 5 passes
  221. Mon Jan 23 16:47:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  222. Mon Jan 23 16:47:51 2017  removing 4710020 relations and 2710020 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  223. Mon Jan 23 16:47:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  224. Mon Jan 23 16:48:00 2017  begin with 195441742 relations and 106180474 unique ideals
  225. Mon Jan 23 16:48:34 2017  reduce to 195379025 relations and 103407061 ideals in 5 passes
  226. Mon Jan 23 16:48:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  227. Mon Jan 23 16:49:06 2017  removing 4622239 relations and 2622239 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  228. Mon Jan 23 16:49:10 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  229. Mon Jan 23 16:49:15 2017  begin with 190756786 relations and 103407061 unique ideals
  230. Mon Jan 23 16:50:02 2017  reduce to 190691694 relations and 100718991 ideals in 7 passes
  231. Mon Jan 23 16:50:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  232. Mon Jan 23 16:50:34 2017  removing 4644124 relations and 2644124 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  233. Mon Jan 23 16:50:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  234. Mon Jan 23 16:50:42 2017  begin with 186047570 relations and 100718991 unique ideals
  235. Mon Jan 23 16:51:14 2017  reduce to 185989534 relations and 98016163 ideals in 5 passes
  236. Mon Jan 23 16:51:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  237. Mon Jan 23 16:51:44 2017  removing 4579719 relations and 2579719 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  238. Mon Jan 23 16:51:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  239. Mon Jan 23 16:51:52 2017  begin with 181409815 relations and 98016163 unique ideals
  240. Mon Jan 23 16:52:23 2017  reduce to 181350146 relations and 95376075 ideals in 5 passes
  241. Mon Jan 23 16:52:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  242. Mon Jan 23 16:52:53 2017  removing 4561678 relations and 2561678 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  243. Mon Jan 23 16:52:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  244. Mon Jan 23 16:53:00 2017  begin with 176788468 relations and 95376075 unique ideals
  245. Mon Jan 23 16:53:31 2017  reduce to 176731326 relations and 92756552 ideals in 5 passes
  246. Mon Jan 23 16:53:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  247. Mon Jan 23 16:54:01 2017  removing 4532746 relations and 2532746 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  248. Mon Jan 23 16:54:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  249. Mon Jan 23 16:54:07 2017  begin with 172198580 relations and 92756552 unique ideals
  250. Mon Jan 23 16:54:34 2017  reduce to 172147657 relations and 90172297 ideals in 5 passes
  251. Mon Jan 23 16:54:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  252. Mon Jan 23 16:55:03 2017  removing 4544432 relations and 2544432 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  253. Mon Jan 23 16:55:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  254. Mon Jan 23 16:55:10 2017  begin with 167603225 relations and 90172297 unique ideals
  255. Mon Jan 23 16:55:37 2017  reduce to 167554022 relations and 87578122 ideals in 5 passes
  256. Mon Jan 23 16:55:37 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  257. Mon Jan 23 16:56:05 2017  removing 4473180 relations and 2473180 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  258. Mon Jan 23 16:56:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  259. Mon Jan 23 16:56:12 2017  begin with 163080842 relations and 87578122 unique ideals
  260. Mon Jan 23 16:56:39 2017  reduce to 163013544 relations and 85036873 ideals in 5 passes
  261. Mon Jan 23 16:56:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  262. Mon Jan 23 16:57:04 2017  removing 4454494 relations and 2454494 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  263. Mon Jan 23 16:57:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  264. Mon Jan 23 16:57:11 2017  begin with 158559050 relations and 85036873 unique ideals
  265. Mon Jan 23 16:57:35 2017  reduce to 158496393 relations and 82518953 ideals in 5 passes
  266. Mon Jan 23 16:57:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  267. Mon Jan 23 16:58:01 2017  removing 4443648 relations and 2443648 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  268. Mon Jan 23 16:58:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  269. Mon Jan 23 16:58:07 2017  begin with 154052745 relations and 82518953 unique ideals
  270. Mon Jan 23 16:58:31 2017  reduce to 153999451 relations and 80021244 ideals in 5 passes
  271. Mon Jan 23 16:58:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  272. Mon Jan 23 16:58:57 2017  removing 4466626 relations and 2466626 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  273. Mon Jan 23 16:58:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  274. Mon Jan 23 16:59:03 2017  begin with 149532825 relations and 80021244 unique ideals
  275. Mon Jan 23 16:59:28 2017  reduce to 149481549 relations and 77502674 ideals in 6 passes
  276. Mon Jan 23 16:59:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  277. Mon Jan 23 16:59:53 2017  removing 4440829 relations and 2440829 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  278. Mon Jan 23 16:59:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  279. Mon Jan 23 16:59:59 2017  begin with 145040720 relations and 77502674 unique ideals
  280. Mon Jan 23 17:00:19 2017  reduce to 144994192 relations and 75014707 ideals in 5 passes
  281. Mon Jan 23 17:00:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  282. Mon Jan 23 17:00:41 2017  removing 4436545 relations and 2436545 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  283. Mon Jan 23 17:00:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  284. Mon Jan 23 17:00:47 2017  begin with 140557647 relations and 75014707 unique ideals
  285. Mon Jan 23 17:01:10 2017  reduce to 140513110 relations and 72532998 ideals in 5 passes
  286. Mon Jan 23 17:01:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  287. Mon Jan 23 17:01:32 2017  removing 4366944 relations and 2366944 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  288. Mon Jan 23 17:01:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  289. Mon Jan 23 17:01:38 2017  begin with 136146166 relations and 72532998 unique ideals
  290. Mon Jan 23 17:02:00 2017  reduce to 136083431 relations and 70102564 ideals in 5 passes
  291. Mon Jan 23 17:02:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  292. Mon Jan 23 17:02:20 2017  removing 4375604 relations and 2375604 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  293. Mon Jan 23 17:02:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  294. Mon Jan 23 17:02:26 2017  begin with 131707827 relations and 70102564 unique ideals
  295. Mon Jan 23 17:02:45 2017  reduce to 131650738 relations and 67669140 ideals in 5 passes
  296. Mon Jan 23 17:02:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  297. Mon Jan 23 17:03:05 2017  removing 4382083 relations and 2382083 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  298. Mon Jan 23 17:03:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  299. Mon Jan 23 17:03:11 2017  begin with 127268655 relations and 67669140 unique ideals
  300. Mon Jan 23 17:03:31 2017  reduce to 127221497 relations and 65239316 ideals in 5 passes
  301. Mon Jan 23 17:03:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  302. Mon Jan 23 17:03:48 2017  removing 4381340 relations and 2381340 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  303. Mon Jan 23 17:03:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  304. Mon Jan 23 17:03:53 2017  begin with 122840157 relations and 65239316 unique ideals
  305. Mon Jan 23 17:04:08 2017  reduce to 122792808 relations and 62810088 ideals in 4 passes
  306. Mon Jan 23 17:04:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  307. Mon Jan 23 17:04:26 2017  removing 4332215 relations and 2332215 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  308. Mon Jan 23 17:04:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  309. Mon Jan 23 17:04:30 2017  begin with 118460593 relations and 62810088 unique ideals
  310. Mon Jan 23 17:04:50 2017  reduce to 118401034 relations and 60417489 ideals in 5 passes
  311. Mon Jan 23 17:04:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  312. Mon Jan 23 17:05:06 2017  removing 4351404 relations and 2351404 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  313. Mon Jan 23 17:05:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  314. Mon Jan 23 17:05:11 2017  begin with 114049630 relations and 60417489 unique ideals
  315. Mon Jan 23 17:05:32 2017  reduce to 114002107 relations and 58017959 ideals in 5 passes
  316. Mon Jan 23 17:05:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  317. Mon Jan 23 17:05:47 2017  removing 4317717 relations and 2317717 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  318. Mon Jan 23 17:05:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  319. Mon Jan 23 17:05:52 2017  begin with 109684390 relations and 58017959 unique ideals
  320. Mon Jan 23 17:06:07 2017  reduce to 109626692 relations and 55641800 ideals in 5 passes
  321. Mon Jan 23 17:06:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  322. Mon Jan 23 17:06:22 2017  removing 4310978 relations and 2310978 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  323. Mon Jan 23 17:06:24 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  324. Mon Jan 23 17:06:27 2017  begin with 105315714 relations and 55641800 unique ideals
  325. Mon Jan 23 17:06:44 2017  reduce to 105262285 relations and 53276723 ideals in 5 passes
  326. Mon Jan 23 17:06:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  327. Mon Jan 23 17:06:59 2017  removing 4310244 relations and 2310244 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  328. Mon Jan 23 17:07:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  329. Mon Jan 23 17:07:03 2017  begin with 100952041 relations and 53276723 unique ideals
  330. Mon Jan 23 17:07:19 2017  reduce to 100888475 relations and 50902078 ideals in 5 passes
  331. Mon Jan 23 17:07:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  332. Mon Jan 23 17:07:32 2017  removing 4288640 relations and 2288640 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  333. Mon Jan 23 17:07:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  334. Mon Jan 23 17:07:36 2017  begin with 96599835 relations and 50902078 unique ideals
  335. Mon Jan 23 17:07:49 2017  reduce to 96531048 relations and 48543664 ideals in 5 passes
  336. Mon Jan 23 17:07:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  337. Mon Jan 23 17:08:03 2017  removing 4262223 relations and 2262223 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  338. Mon Jan 23 17:08:05 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  339. Mon Jan 23 17:08:07 2017  begin with 92268825 relations and 48543664 unique ideals
  340. Mon Jan 23 17:08:19 2017  reduce to 92208673 relations and 46220478 ideals in 5 passes
  341. Mon Jan 23 17:08:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  342. Mon Jan 23 17:08:32 2017  removing 4295142 relations and 2295142 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  343. Mon Jan 23 17:08:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  344. Mon Jan 23 17:08:35 2017  begin with 87913531 relations and 46220478 unique ideals
  345. Mon Jan 23 17:08:49 2017  reduce to 87837162 relations and 43847859 ideals in 5 passes
  346. Mon Jan 23 17:08:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  347. Mon Jan 23 17:09:00 2017  removing 4255141 relations and 2255141 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  348. Mon Jan 23 17:09:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  349. Mon Jan 23 17:09:04 2017  begin with 83582021 relations and 43847859 unique ideals
  350. Mon Jan 23 17:09:17 2017  reduce to 83515479 relations and 41525237 ideals in 5 passes
  351. Mon Jan 23 17:09:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  352. Mon Jan 23 17:09:28 2017  removing 4274421 relations and 2274421 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  353. Mon Jan 23 17:09:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  354. Mon Jan 23 17:09:31 2017  begin with 79241058 relations and 41525237 unique ideals
  355. Mon Jan 23 17:09:44 2017  reduce to 79182252 relations and 39191188 ideals in 5 passes
  356. Mon Jan 23 17:09:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  357. Mon Jan 23 17:09:54 2017  removing 4285840 relations and 2285840 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  358. Mon Jan 23 17:09:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  359. Mon Jan 23 17:09:57 2017  begin with 74896412 relations and 39191188 unique ideals
  360. Mon Jan 23 17:10:08 2017  reduce to 74845503 relations and 36853879 ideals in 4 passes
  361. Mon Jan 23 17:10:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  362. Mon Jan 23 17:10:17 2017  removing 4295305 relations and 2295305 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  363. Mon Jan 23 17:10:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  364. Mon Jan 23 17:10:21 2017  begin with 70550198 relations and 36853879 unique ideals
  365. Mon Jan 23 17:10:30 2017  reduce to 70473274 relations and 34480556 ideals in 5 passes
  366. Mon Jan 23 17:10:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  367. Mon Jan 23 17:10:38 2017  removing 4249429 relations and 2249429 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  368. Mon Jan 23 17:10:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  369. Mon Jan 23 17:10:41 2017  begin with 66223845 relations and 34480556 unique ideals
  370. Mon Jan 23 17:10:51 2017  reduce to 66106872 relations and 32111989 ideals in 5 passes
  371. Mon Jan 23 17:10:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  372. Mon Jan 23 17:10:59 2017  removing 4214177 relations and 2214177 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  373. Mon Jan 23 17:11:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  374. Mon Jan 23 17:11:01 2017  begin with 61892695 relations and 32111989 unique ideals
  375. Mon Jan 23 17:11:10 2017  reduce to 61755028 relations and 29757189 ideals in 5 passes
  376. Mon Jan 23 17:11:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  377. Mon Jan 23 17:11:18 2017  removing 4217564 relations and 2217564 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  378. Mon Jan 23 17:11:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  379. Mon Jan 23 17:11:21 2017  begin with 57537464 relations and 29757189 unique ideals
  380. Mon Jan 23 17:11:31 2017  reduce to 57381853 relations and 27380239 ideals in 6 passes
  381. Mon Jan 23 17:11:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  382. Mon Jan 23 17:11:37 2017  removing 4222485 relations and 2222485 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  383. Mon Jan 23 17:11:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  384. Mon Jan 23 17:11:40 2017  begin with 53159368 relations and 27380239 unique ideals
  385. Mon Jan 23 17:11:46 2017  reduce to 52984063 relations and 24977586 ideals in 5 passes
  386. Mon Jan 23 17:11:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  387. Mon Jan 23 17:11:52 2017  removing 4224171 relations and 2224171 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  388. Mon Jan 23 17:11:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  389. Mon Jan 23 17:11:55 2017  begin with 48759892 relations and 24977586 unique ideals
  390. Mon Jan 23 17:12:01 2017  reduce to 48560283 relations and 22547259 ideals in 5 passes
  391. Mon Jan 23 17:12:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  392. Mon Jan 23 17:12:07 2017  removing 4246519 relations and 2246519 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  393. Mon Jan 23 17:12:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  394. Mon Jan 23 17:12:09 2017  begin with 44313764 relations and 22547259 unique ideals
  395. Mon Jan 23 17:12:16 2017  reduce to 44105989 relations and 20085286 ideals in 6 passes
  396. Mon Jan 23 17:12:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  397. Mon Jan 23 17:12:22 2017  removing 4265365 relations and 2265365 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  398. Mon Jan 23 17:12:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  399. Mon Jan 23 17:12:24 2017  begin with 39840624 relations and 20085286 unique ideals
  400. Mon Jan 23 17:12:29 2017  reduce to 39620796 relations and 17591224 ideals in 5 passes
  401. Mon Jan 23 17:12:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  402. Mon Jan 23 17:12:34 2017  removing 4277203 relations and 2277203 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  403. Mon Jan 23 17:12:35 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  404. Mon Jan 23 17:12:36 2017  begin with 35343593 relations and 17591224 unique ideals
  405. Mon Jan 23 17:12:40 2017  reduce to 35114175 relations and 15074392 ideals in 5 passes
  406. Mon Jan 23 17:12:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  407. Mon Jan 23 17:12:45 2017  removing 4282277 relations and 2282277 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  408. Mon Jan 23 17:12:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  409. Mon Jan 23 17:12:46 2017  begin with 30831898 relations and 15074392 unique ideals
  410. Mon Jan 23 17:12:50 2017  reduce to 30598547 relations and 12547963 ideals in 6 passes
  411. Mon Jan 23 17:12:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  412. Mon Jan 23 17:12:54 2017  removing 3826245 relations and 2041161 ideals in 1785084 cliques
  413. Mon Jan 23 17:12:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  414. Mon Jan 23 17:12:56 2017  begin with 26772302 relations and 12547963 unique ideals
  415. Mon Jan 23 17:12:59 2017  reduce to 26564401 relations and 10289270 ideals in 5 passes
  416. Mon Jan 23 17:12:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  417. Mon Jan 23 17:13:03 2017  removing 26070 relations and 16439 ideals in 9631 cliques
  418. Mon Jan 23 17:13:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  419. Mon Jan 23 17:13:04 2017  begin with 26538331 relations and 10289270 unique ideals
  420. Mon Jan 23 17:13:05 2017  reduce to 26538185 relations and 10272685 ideals in 3 passes
  421. Mon Jan 23 17:13:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  422. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 6324572
  423. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 13229873
  424. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 5673341
  425. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1176044
  426. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 129395
  427. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 4107
  428. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 853
  429. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 0
  430. Mon Jan 23 17:13:06 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  431. Mon Jan 23 17:13:11 2017  reduce to 21658391 relation sets and 5392891 unique ideals
  432. Mon Jan 23 17:13:11 2017  commencing full merge
  433. Mon Jan 23 17:13:32 2017  memory use: 643.1 MB
  434. Mon Jan 23 17:13:33 2017  found 16265500 cycles, need 14022182
  435. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  weight of 14022182 cycles is about 383500034 (27.35/cycle)
  436. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  437. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  1 relations: 6324572
  438. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  2 relations: 4503070
  439. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  3 relations: 2367914
  440. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  4 relations: 825987
  441. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  5 relations: 639
  442. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  6 relations: 0
  443. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  7 relations: 0
  444. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  8 relations: 0
  445. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  9 relations: 0
  446. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  10+ relations: 0
  447. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  heaviest cycle: 5 relations
  448. Mon Jan 23 17:13:36 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  449. Mon Jan 23 17:13:37 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  450. Mon Jan 23 17:15:39 2017  keeping 133762044 ideals with weight <= 25, target excess is 12824159
  451. Mon Jan 23 17:17:43 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  452. Mon Jan 23 17:17:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  453. Mon Jan 23 17:17:51 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 133762044 unique ideals
  454. Mon Jan 23 17:18:19 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 133761954 ideals in 3 passes
  455. Mon Jan 23 17:18:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  456. Mon Jan 23 17:19:05 2017  removing 6640878 relations and 4640878 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  457. Mon Jan 23 17:19:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  458. Mon Jan 23 17:19:15 2017  begin with 235885782 relations and 133761954 unique ideals
  459. Mon Jan 23 17:20:13 2017  reduce to 235681839 relations and 128914670 ideals in 6 passes
  460. Mon Jan 23 17:20:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  461. Mon Jan 23 17:20:55 2017  removing 5491806 relations and 3491806 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  462. Mon Jan 23 17:20:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  463. Mon Jan 23 17:21:05 2017  begin with 230190033 relations and 128914670 unique ideals
  464. Mon Jan 23 17:21:57 2017  reduce to 230060542 relations and 125292090 ideals in 6 passes
  465. Mon Jan 23 17:21:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  466. Mon Jan 23 17:22:38 2017  removing 5184872 relations and 3184872 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  467. Mon Jan 23 17:22:41 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  468. Mon Jan 23 17:22:48 2017  begin with 224875670 relations and 125292090 unique ideals
  469. Mon Jan 23 17:23:41 2017  reduce to 224771706 relations and 122002270 ideals in 6 passes
  470. Mon Jan 23 17:23:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  471. Mon Jan 23 17:24:19 2017  removing 5032596 relations and 3032596 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  472. Mon Jan 23 17:24:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  473. Mon Jan 23 17:24:28 2017  begin with 219739110 relations and 122002270 unique ideals
  474. Mon Jan 23 17:25:06 2017  reduce to 219647316 relations and 118876985 ideals in 5 passes
  475. Mon Jan 23 17:25:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  476. Mon Jan 23 17:25:46 2017  removing 4945101 relations and 2945101 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  477. Mon Jan 23 17:25:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  478. Mon Jan 23 17:25:55 2017  begin with 214702215 relations and 118876985 unique ideals
  479. Mon Jan 23 17:26:36 2017  reduce to 214623736 relations and 115852689 ideals in 5 passes
  480. Mon Jan 23 17:26:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  481. Mon Jan 23 17:27:15 2017  removing 4828078 relations and 2828078 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  482. Mon Jan 23 17:27:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  483. Mon Jan 23 17:27:24 2017  begin with 209795658 relations and 115852689 unique ideals
  484. Mon Jan 23 17:28:07 2017  reduce to 209717970 relations and 112946066 ideals in 6 passes
  485. Mon Jan 23 17:28:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  486. Mon Jan 23 17:28:44 2017  removing 4787913 relations and 2787913 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  487. Mon Jan 23 17:28:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  488. Mon Jan 23 17:28:53 2017  begin with 204930057 relations and 112946066 unique ideals
  489. Mon Jan 23 17:29:32 2017  reduce to 204856914 relations and 110084299 ideals in 5 passes
  490. Mon Jan 23 17:29:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  491. Mon Jan 23 17:30:08 2017  removing 4739440 relations and 2739440 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  492. Mon Jan 23 17:30:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  493. Mon Jan 23 17:30:17 2017  begin with 200117474 relations and 110084299 unique ideals
  494. Mon Jan 23 17:30:52 2017  reduce to 200051683 relations and 107278364 ideals in 5 passes
  495. Mon Jan 23 17:30:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  496. Mon Jan 23 17:31:26 2017  removing 4684364 relations and 2684364 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  497. Mon Jan 23 17:31:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  498. Mon Jan 23 17:31:34 2017  begin with 195367319 relations and 107278364 unique ideals
  499. Mon Jan 23 17:32:12 2017  reduce to 195302057 relations and 104528034 ideals in 5 passes
  500. Mon Jan 23 17:32:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  501. Mon Jan 23 17:32:48 2017  removing 4668105 relations and 2668105 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  502. Mon Jan 23 17:32:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  503. Mon Jan 23 17:32:56 2017  begin with 190633952 relations and 104528034 unique ideals
  504. Mon Jan 23 17:33:40 2017  reduce to 190571634 relations and 101796942 ideals in 6 passes
  505. Mon Jan 23 17:33:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  506. Mon Jan 23 17:34:16 2017  removing 4606381 relations and 2606381 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  507. Mon Jan 23 17:34:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  508. Mon Jan 23 17:34:25 2017  begin with 185965253 relations and 101796942 unique ideals
  509. Mon Jan 23 17:35:07 2017  reduce to 185903879 relations and 99128471 ideals in 6 passes
  510. Mon Jan 23 17:35:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  511. Mon Jan 23 17:35:41 2017  removing 4574274 relations and 2574274 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  512. Mon Jan 23 17:35:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  513. Mon Jan 23 17:35:50 2017  begin with 181329605 relations and 99128471 unique ideals
  514. Mon Jan 23 17:36:24 2017  reduce to 181270419 relations and 96494324 ideals in 5 passes
  515. Mon Jan 23 17:36:24 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  516. Mon Jan 23 17:36:56 2017  removing 4579063 relations and 2579063 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  517. Mon Jan 23 17:36:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  518. Mon Jan 23 17:37:03 2017  begin with 176691356 relations and 96494324 unique ideals
  519. Mon Jan 23 17:37:37 2017  reduce to 176633073 relations and 93856297 ideals in 5 passes
  520. Mon Jan 23 17:37:37 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  521. Mon Jan 23 17:38:10 2017  removing 4550837 relations and 2550837 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  522. Mon Jan 23 17:38:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  523. Mon Jan 23 17:38:18 2017  begin with 172082236 relations and 93856297 unique ideals
  524. Mon Jan 23 17:38:50 2017  reduce to 172028232 relations and 91250830 ideals in 5 passes
  525. Mon Jan 23 17:38:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  526. Mon Jan 23 17:39:20 2017  removing 4508416 relations and 2508416 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  527. Mon Jan 23 17:39:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  528. Mon Jan 23 17:39:28 2017  begin with 167519816 relations and 91250830 unique ideals
  529. Mon Jan 23 17:39:59 2017  reduce to 167468347 relations and 88690294 ideals in 5 passes
  530. Mon Jan 23 17:39:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  531. Mon Jan 23 17:40:31 2017  removing 4519577 relations and 2519577 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  532. Mon Jan 23 17:40:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  533. Mon Jan 23 17:40:38 2017  begin with 162948770 relations and 88690294 unique ideals
  534. Mon Jan 23 17:41:09 2017  reduce to 162899777 relations and 86121160 ideals in 5 passes
  535. Mon Jan 23 17:41:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  536. Mon Jan 23 17:41:39 2017  removing 4451051 relations and 2451051 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  537. Mon Jan 23 17:41:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  538. Mon Jan 23 17:41:47 2017  begin with 158448726 relations and 86121160 unique ideals
  539. Mon Jan 23 17:42:16 2017  reduce to 158382706 relations and 83603269 ideals in 5 passes
  540. Mon Jan 23 17:42:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  541. Mon Jan 23 17:42:43 2017  removing 4447898 relations and 2447898 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  542. Mon Jan 23 17:42:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  543. Mon Jan 23 17:42:49 2017  begin with 153934808 relations and 83603269 unique ideals
  544. Mon Jan 23 17:43:20 2017  reduce to 153876927 relations and 81096755 ideals in 6 passes
  545. Mon Jan 23 17:43:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  546. Mon Jan 23 17:43:48 2017  removing 4427540 relations and 2427540 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  547. Mon Jan 23 17:43:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  548. Mon Jan 23 17:43:55 2017  begin with 149449387 relations and 81096755 unique ideals
  549. Mon Jan 23 17:44:22 2017  reduce to 149395929 relations and 78615086 ideals in 5 passes
  550. Mon Jan 23 17:44:22 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  551. Mon Jan 23 17:44:49 2017  removing 4445344 relations and 2445344 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  552. Mon Jan 23 17:44:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  553. Mon Jan 23 17:44:55 2017  begin with 144950585 relations and 78615086 unique ideals
  554. Mon Jan 23 17:45:21 2017  reduce to 144899846 relations and 76118286 ideals in 5 passes
  555. Mon Jan 23 17:45:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  556. Mon Jan 23 17:45:46 2017  removing 4419980 relations and 2419980 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  557. Mon Jan 23 17:45:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  558. Mon Jan 23 17:45:53 2017  begin with 140479866 relations and 76118286 unique ideals
  559. Mon Jan 23 17:46:18 2017  reduce to 140431887 relations and 73649725 ideals in 5 passes
  560. Mon Jan 23 17:46:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  561. Mon Jan 23 17:46:42 2017  removing 4419172 relations and 2419172 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  562. Mon Jan 23 17:46:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  563. Mon Jan 23 17:46:49 2017  begin with 136012715 relations and 73649725 unique ideals
  564. Mon Jan 23 17:47:13 2017  reduce to 135967662 relations and 71184950 ideals in 5 passes
  565. Mon Jan 23 17:47:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  566. Mon Jan 23 17:47:36 2017  removing 4369315 relations and 2369315 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  567. Mon Jan 23 17:47:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  568. Mon Jan 23 17:47:42 2017  begin with 131598347 relations and 71184950 unique ideals
  569. Mon Jan 23 17:48:09 2017  reduce to 131541367 relations and 68757974 ideals in 6 passes
  570. Mon Jan 23 17:48:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  571. Mon Jan 23 17:48:29 2017  removing 4354470 relations and 2354470 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  572. Mon Jan 23 17:48:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  573. Mon Jan 23 17:48:35 2017  begin with 127186897 relations and 68757974 unique ideals
  574. Mon Jan 23 17:48:59 2017  reduce to 127129278 relations and 66345132 ideals in 5 passes
  575. Mon Jan 23 17:48:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  576. Mon Jan 23 17:49:19 2017  removing 4360751 relations and 2360751 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  577. Mon Jan 23 17:49:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  578. Mon Jan 23 17:49:24 2017  begin with 122768527 relations and 66345132 unique ideals
  579. Mon Jan 23 17:49:44 2017  reduce to 122719027 relations and 63934244 ideals in 5 passes
  580. Mon Jan 23 17:49:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  581. Mon Jan 23 17:50:05 2017  removing 4370333 relations and 2370333 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  582. Mon Jan 23 17:50:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  583. Mon Jan 23 17:50:11 2017  begin with 118348694 relations and 63934244 unique ideals
  584. Mon Jan 23 17:50:31 2017  reduce to 118301971 relations and 61516642 ideals in 5 passes
  585. Mon Jan 23 17:50:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  586. Mon Jan 23 17:50:49 2017  removing 4320926 relations and 2320926 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  587. Mon Jan 23 17:50:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  588. Mon Jan 23 17:50:54 2017  begin with 113981045 relations and 61516642 unique ideals
  589. Mon Jan 23 17:51:12 2017  reduce to 113918698 relations and 59132601 ideals in 5 passes
  590. Mon Jan 23 17:51:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  591. Mon Jan 23 17:51:30 2017  removing 4323312 relations and 2323312 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  592. Mon Jan 23 17:51:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  593. Mon Jan 23 17:51:35 2017  begin with 109595386 relations and 59132601 unique ideals
  594. Mon Jan 23 17:51:55 2017  reduce to 109541519 relations and 56754773 ideals in 5 passes
  595. Mon Jan 23 17:51:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  596. Mon Jan 23 17:52:12 2017  removing 4322794 relations and 2322794 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  597. Mon Jan 23 17:52:14 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  598. Mon Jan 23 17:52:16 2017  begin with 105218725 relations and 56754773 unique ideals
  599. Mon Jan 23 17:52:34 2017  reduce to 105164987 relations and 54377595 ideals in 5 passes
  600. Mon Jan 23 17:52:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  601. Mon Jan 23 17:52:50 2017  removing 4285596 relations and 2285596 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  602. Mon Jan 23 17:52:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  603. Mon Jan 23 17:52:55 2017  begin with 100879391 relations and 54377595 unique ideals
  604. Mon Jan 23 17:53:13 2017  reduce to 100819918 relations and 52031740 ideals in 5 passes
  605. Mon Jan 23 17:53:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  606. Mon Jan 23 17:53:29 2017  removing 4296866 relations and 2296866 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  607. Mon Jan 23 17:53:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  608. Mon Jan 23 17:53:33 2017  begin with 96523052 relations and 52031740 unique ideals
  609. Mon Jan 23 17:53:48 2017  reduce to 96459795 relations and 49670798 ideals in 4 passes
  610. Mon Jan 23 17:53:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  611. Mon Jan 23 17:54:04 2017  removing 4282402 relations and 2282402 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  612. Mon Jan 23 17:54:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  613. Mon Jan 23 17:54:08 2017  begin with 92177393 relations and 49670798 unique ideals
  614. Mon Jan 23 17:54:24 2017  reduce to 92108430 relations and 47318494 ideals in 5 passes
  615. Mon Jan 23 17:54:24 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  616. Mon Jan 23 17:54:39 2017  removing 4267269 relations and 2267269 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  617. Mon Jan 23 17:54:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  618. Mon Jan 23 17:54:43 2017  begin with 87841161 relations and 47318494 unique ideals
  619. Mon Jan 23 17:54:58 2017  reduce to 87776426 relations and 44985563 ideals in 5 passes
  620. Mon Jan 23 17:54:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  621. Mon Jan 23 17:55:12 2017  removing 4264577 relations and 2264577 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  622. Mon Jan 23 17:55:14 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  623. Mon Jan 23 17:55:16 2017  begin with 83511849 relations and 44985563 unique ideals
  624. Mon Jan 23 17:55:31 2017  reduce to 83441025 relations and 42649104 ideals in 5 passes
  625. Mon Jan 23 17:55:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  626. Mon Jan 23 17:55:44 2017  removing 4265836 relations and 2265836 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  627. Mon Jan 23 17:55:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  628. Mon Jan 23 17:55:47 2017  begin with 79175189 relations and 42649104 unique ideals
  629. Mon Jan 23 17:55:59 2017  reduce to 79095887 relations and 40302698 ideals in 5 passes
  630. Mon Jan 23 17:55:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  631. Mon Jan 23 17:56:10 2017  removing 4251000 relations and 2251000 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  632. Mon Jan 23 17:56:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  633. Mon Jan 23 17:56:14 2017  begin with 74844887 relations and 40302698 unique ideals
  634. Mon Jan 23 17:56:27 2017  reduce to 74768162 relations and 37973807 ideals in 5 passes
  635. Mon Jan 23 17:56:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  636. Mon Jan 23 17:56:38 2017  removing 4255301 relations and 2255301 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  637. Mon Jan 23 17:56:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  638. Mon Jan 23 17:56:41 2017  begin with 70512861 relations and 37973807 unique ideals
  639. Mon Jan 23 17:56:52 2017  reduce to 70441223 relations and 35645811 ideals in 5 passes
  640. Mon Jan 23 17:56:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  641. Mon Jan 23 17:57:02 2017  removing 4267142 relations and 2267142 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  642. Mon Jan 23 17:57:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  643. Mon Jan 23 17:57:06 2017  begin with 66174081 relations and 35645811 unique ideals
  644. Mon Jan 23 17:57:18 2017  reduce to 66107502 relations and 33311257 ideals in 5 passes
  645. Mon Jan 23 17:57:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  646. Mon Jan 23 17:57:27 2017  removing 4274955 relations and 2274955 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  647. Mon Jan 23 17:57:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  648. Mon Jan 23 17:57:30 2017  begin with 61832547 relations and 33311257 unique ideals
  649. Mon Jan 23 17:57:40 2017  reduce to 61733041 relations and 30935114 ideals in 5 passes
  650. Mon Jan 23 17:57:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  651. Mon Jan 23 17:57:48 2017  removing 4240987 relations and 2240987 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  652. Mon Jan 23 17:57:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  653. Mon Jan 23 17:57:50 2017  begin with 57492054 relations and 30935114 unique ideals
  654. Mon Jan 23 17:58:00 2017  reduce to 57353717 relations and 28552769 ideals in 5 passes
  655. Mon Jan 23 17:58:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  656. Mon Jan 23 17:58:08 2017  removing 4227263 relations and 2227263 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  657. Mon Jan 23 17:58:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  658. Mon Jan 23 17:58:10 2017  begin with 53126454 relations and 28552769 unique ideals
  659. Mon Jan 23 17:58:18 2017  reduce to 52963209 relations and 26158227 ideals in 5 passes
  660. Mon Jan 23 17:58:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  661. Mon Jan 23 17:58:25 2017  removing 4239020 relations and 2239020 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  662. Mon Jan 23 17:58:26 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  663. Mon Jan 23 17:58:28 2017  begin with 48724189 relations and 26158227 unique ideals
  664. Mon Jan 23 17:58:36 2017  reduce to 48536925 relations and 23726708 ideals in 6 passes
  665. Mon Jan 23 17:58:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  666. Mon Jan 23 17:58:43 2017  removing 4255802 relations and 2255802 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  667. Mon Jan 23 17:58:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  668. Mon Jan 23 17:58:45 2017  begin with 44281123 relations and 23726708 unique ideals
  669. Mon Jan 23 17:58:52 2017  reduce to 44065906 relations and 21248751 ideals in 5 passes
  670. Mon Jan 23 17:58:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  671. Mon Jan 23 17:58:58 2017  removing 4270197 relations and 2270197 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  672. Mon Jan 23 17:59:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  673. Mon Jan 23 17:59:00 2017  begin with 39795709 relations and 21248751 unique ideals
  674. Mon Jan 23 17:59:07 2017  reduce to 39544302 relations and 18717308 ideals in 6 passes
  675. Mon Jan 23 17:59:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  676. Mon Jan 23 17:59:13 2017  removing 4293367 relations and 2293367 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  677. Mon Jan 23 17:59:14 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  678. Mon Jan 23 17:59:15 2017  begin with 35250935 relations and 18717308 unique ideals
  679. Mon Jan 23 17:59:20 2017  reduce to 34975212 relations and 16135505 ideals in 5 passes
  680. Mon Jan 23 17:59:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
  681. Mon Jan 23 17:59:26 2017  removing 4320562 relations and 2320562 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  682. Mon Jan 23 17:59:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  683. Mon Jan 23 17:59:27 2017  begin with 30654650 relations and 16135505 unique ideals
  684. Mon Jan 23 17:59:31 2017  reduce to 30364022 relations and 13508827 ideals in 5 passes
  685. Mon Jan 23 17:59:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  686. Mon Jan 23 17:59:36 2017  removing 4291599 relations and 2312429 ideals in 1979170 cliques
  687. Mon Jan 23 17:59:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  688. Mon Jan 23 17:59:38 2017  begin with 26072423 relations and 13508827 unique ideals
  689. Mon Jan 23 17:59:42 2017  reduce to 25773635 relations and 10880478 ideals in 6 passes
  690. Mon Jan 23 17:59:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  691. Mon Jan 23 17:59:45 2017  removing 48230 relations and 31098 ideals in 17132 cliques
  692. Mon Jan 23 17:59:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  693. Mon Jan 23 17:59:47 2017  begin with 25725405 relations and 10880478 unique ideals
  694. Mon Jan 23 17:59:49 2017  reduce to 25724981 relations and 10848956 ideals in 4 passes
  695. Mon Jan 23 17:59:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  696. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 5241339
  697. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 12196244
  698. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 6515265
  699. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1541560
  700. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 218101
  701. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 11279
  702. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 1193
  703. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 0
  704. Mon Jan 23 17:59:50 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  705. Mon Jan 23 17:59:55 2017  reduce to 20646648 relation sets and 5770623 unique ideals
  706. Mon Jan 23 17:59:55 2017  commencing full merge
  707. Mon Jan 23 18:00:21 2017  memory use: 645.8 MB
  708. Mon Jan 23 18:00:22 2017  found 14876017 cycles, need 12824359
  709. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  weight of 12824359 cycles is about 390936106 (30.48/cycle)
  710. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  711. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  1 relations: 5241339
  712. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  2 relations: 3600166
  713. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  3 relations: 2330812
  714. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  4 relations: 1323454
  715. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  5 relations: 328257
  716. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  6 relations: 331
  717. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  7 relations: 0
  718. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  8 relations: 0
  719. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  9 relations: 0
  720. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  10+ relations: 0
  721. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  heaviest cycle: 6 relations
  722. Mon Jan 23 18:00:26 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  723. Mon Jan 23 18:00:28 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  724. Mon Jan 23 18:02:25 2017  keeping 134568336 ideals with weight <= 30, target excess is 12017867
  725. Mon Jan 23 18:04:26 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  726. Mon Jan 23 18:04:26 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  727. Mon Jan 23 18:04:33 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 134568336 unique ideals
  728. Mon Jan 23 18:05:03 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 134568246 ideals in 3 passes
  729. Mon Jan 23 18:05:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  730. Mon Jan 23 18:05:48 2017  removing 6663258 relations and 4663258 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  731. Mon Jan 23 18:05:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  732. Mon Jan 23 18:06:00 2017  begin with 235863402 relations and 134568246 unique ideals
  733. Mon Jan 23 18:06:55 2017  reduce to 235659777 relations and 129698890 ideals in 6 passes
  734. Mon Jan 23 18:06:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  735. Mon Jan 23 18:07:40 2017  removing 5495821 relations and 3495821 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  736. Mon Jan 23 18:07:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  737. Mon Jan 23 18:07:51 2017  begin with 230163956 relations and 129698890 unique ideals
  738. Mon Jan 23 18:08:43 2017  reduce to 230034426 relations and 126072287 ideals in 6 passes
  739. Mon Jan 23 18:08:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  740. Mon Jan 23 18:09:28 2017  removing 5199831 relations and 3199831 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  741. Mon Jan 23 18:09:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  742. Mon Jan 23 18:09:39 2017  begin with 224834595 relations and 126072287 unique ideals
  743. Mon Jan 23 18:10:28 2017  reduce to 224730789 relations and 122767648 ideals in 6 passes
  744. Mon Jan 23 18:10:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  745. Mon Jan 23 18:11:09 2017  removing 5043764 relations and 3043764 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  746. Mon Jan 23 18:11:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  747. Mon Jan 23 18:11:19 2017  begin with 219687025 relations and 122767648 unique ideals
  748. Mon Jan 23 18:12:02 2017  reduce to 219595848 relations and 119631831 ideals in 5 passes
  749. Mon Jan 23 18:12:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  750. Mon Jan 23 18:12:44 2017  removing 4943348 relations and 2943348 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  751. Mon Jan 23 18:12:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  752. Mon Jan 23 18:12:55 2017  begin with 214652500 relations and 119631831 unique ideals
  753. Mon Jan 23 18:13:35 2017  reduce to 214572445 relations and 116607666 ideals in 5 passes
  754. Mon Jan 23 18:13:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  755. Mon Jan 23 18:14:16 2017  removing 4834038 relations and 2834038 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  756. Mon Jan 23 18:14:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  757. Mon Jan 23 18:14:25 2017  begin with 209738407 relations and 116607666 unique ideals
  758. Mon Jan 23 18:15:04 2017  reduce to 209659647 relations and 113694030 ideals in 5 passes
  759. Mon Jan 23 18:15:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  760. Mon Jan 23 18:15:43 2017  removing 4808293 relations and 2808293 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  761. Mon Jan 23 18:15:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  762. Mon Jan 23 18:15:52 2017  begin with 204851354 relations and 113694030 unique ideals
  763. Mon Jan 23 18:16:32 2017  reduce to 204783161 relations and 110816815 ideals in 5 passes
  764. Mon Jan 23 18:16:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  765. Mon Jan 23 18:17:10 2017  removing 4731325 relations and 2731325 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  766. Mon Jan 23 18:17:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  767. Mon Jan 23 18:17:19 2017  begin with 200051836 relations and 110816815 unique ideals
  768. Mon Jan 23 18:18:03 2017  reduce to 199985034 relations and 108017960 ideals in 6 passes
  769. Mon Jan 23 18:18:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  770. Mon Jan 23 18:18:40 2017  removing 4685521 relations and 2685521 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  771. Mon Jan 23 18:18:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  772. Mon Jan 23 18:18:49 2017  begin with 195299513 relations and 108017960 unique ideals
  773. Mon Jan 23 18:19:35 2017  reduce to 195233372 relations and 105265599 ideals in 6 passes
  774. Mon Jan 23 18:19:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  775. Mon Jan 23 18:20:12 2017  removing 4667450 relations and 2667450 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  776. Mon Jan 23 18:20:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  777. Mon Jan 23 18:20:21 2017  begin with 190565922 relations and 105265599 unique ideals
  778. Mon Jan 23 18:20:56 2017  reduce to 190505111 relations and 102536668 ideals in 5 passes
  779. Mon Jan 23 18:20:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  780. Mon Jan 23 18:21:31 2017  removing 4598737 relations and 2598737 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  781. Mon Jan 23 18:21:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  782. Mon Jan 23 18:21:40 2017  begin with 185906374 relations and 102536668 unique ideals
  783. Mon Jan 23 18:22:19 2017  reduce to 185843724 relations and 99874577 ideals in 6 passes
  784. Mon Jan 23 18:22:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  785. Mon Jan 23 18:22:52 2017  removing 4607952 relations and 2607952 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  786. Mon Jan 23 18:22:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  787. Mon Jan 23 18:23:01 2017  begin with 181235772 relations and 99874577 unique ideals
  788. Mon Jan 23 18:23:36 2017  reduce to 181179015 relations and 97209211 ideals in 5 passes
  789. Mon Jan 23 18:23:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  790. Mon Jan 23 18:24:10 2017  removing 4556189 relations and 2556189 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  791. Mon Jan 23 18:24:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  792. Mon Jan 23 18:24:18 2017  begin with 176622826 relations and 97209211 unique ideals
  793. Mon Jan 23 18:24:51 2017  reduce to 176565642 relations and 94595179 ideals in 5 passes
  794. Mon Jan 23 18:24:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  795. Mon Jan 23 18:25:24 2017  removing 4535230 relations and 2535230 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  796. Mon Jan 23 18:25:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  797. Mon Jan 23 18:25:33 2017  begin with 172030412 relations and 94595179 unique ideals
  798. Mon Jan 23 18:26:09 2017  reduce to 171972793 relations and 92001615 ideals in 5 passes
  799. Mon Jan 23 18:26:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  800. Mon Jan 23 18:26:44 2017  removing 4530008 relations and 2530008 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  801. Mon Jan 23 18:26:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  802. Mon Jan 23 18:26:52 2017  begin with 167442785 relations and 92001615 unique ideals
  803. Mon Jan 23 18:27:22 2017  reduce to 167388873 relations and 89417009 ideals in 5 passes
  804. Mon Jan 23 18:27:22 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  805. Mon Jan 23 18:27:55 2017  removing 4491527 relations and 2491527 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  806. Mon Jan 23 18:27:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  807. Mon Jan 23 18:28:02 2017  begin with 162897346 relations and 89417009 unique ideals
  808. Mon Jan 23 18:28:33 2017  reduce to 162846785 relations and 86874279 ideals in 5 passes
  809. Mon Jan 23 18:28:33 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  810. Mon Jan 23 18:29:04 2017  removing 4488902 relations and 2488902 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  811. Mon Jan 23 18:29:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  812. Mon Jan 23 18:29:11 2017  begin with 158357883 relations and 86874279 unique ideals
  813. Mon Jan 23 18:29:39 2017  reduce to 158307489 relations and 84334359 ideals in 5 passes
  814. Mon Jan 23 18:29:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  815. Mon Jan 23 18:30:07 2017  removing 4445991 relations and 2445991 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  816. Mon Jan 23 18:30:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  817. Mon Jan 23 18:30:14 2017  begin with 153861498 relations and 84334359 unique ideals
  818. Mon Jan 23 18:30:42 2017  reduce to 153799812 relations and 81825951 ideals in 5 passes
  819. Mon Jan 23 18:30:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  820. Mon Jan 23 18:31:10 2017  removing 4433967 relations and 2433967 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  821. Mon Jan 23 18:31:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  822. Mon Jan 23 18:31:16 2017  begin with 149365845 relations and 81825951 unique ideals
  823. Mon Jan 23 18:31:42 2017  reduce to 149312562 relations and 79338031 ideals in 5 passes
  824. Mon Jan 23 18:31:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  825. Mon Jan 23 18:32:08 2017  removing 4426563 relations and 2426563 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  826. Mon Jan 23 18:32:10 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  827. Mon Jan 23 18:32:15 2017  begin with 144885999 relations and 79338031 unique ideals
  828. Mon Jan 23 18:32:41 2017  reduce to 144832565 relations and 76857356 ideals in 5 passes
  829. Mon Jan 23 18:32:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  830. Mon Jan 23 18:33:05 2017  removing 4423391 relations and 2423391 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  831. Mon Jan 23 18:33:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  832. Mon Jan 23 18:33:11 2017  begin with 140409174 relations and 76857356 unique ideals
  833. Mon Jan 23 18:33:36 2017  reduce to 140357764 relations and 74381906 ideals in 5 passes
  834. Mon Jan 23 18:33:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  835. Mon Jan 23 18:34:01 2017  removing 4406023 relations and 2406023 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  836. Mon Jan 23 18:34:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  837. Mon Jan 23 18:34:07 2017  begin with 135951741 relations and 74381906 unique ideals
  838. Mon Jan 23 18:34:32 2017  reduce to 135904913 relations and 71928476 ideals in 5 passes
  839. Mon Jan 23 18:34:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  840. Mon Jan 23 18:34:55 2017  removing 4394673 relations and 2394673 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  841. Mon Jan 23 18:34:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  842. Mon Jan 23 18:35:01 2017  begin with 131510240 relations and 71928476 unique ideals
  843. Mon Jan 23 18:35:20 2017  reduce to 131463711 relations and 69486702 ideals in 4 passes
  844. Mon Jan 23 18:35:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  845. Mon Jan 23 18:35:42 2017  removing 4350705 relations and 2350705 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  846. Mon Jan 23 18:35:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  847. Mon Jan 23 18:35:48 2017  begin with 127113006 relations and 69486702 unique ideals
  848. Mon Jan 23 18:36:11 2017  reduce to 127054190 relations and 67076397 ideals in 5 passes
  849. Mon Jan 23 18:36:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  850. Mon Jan 23 18:36:31 2017  removing 4348857 relations and 2348857 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  851. Mon Jan 23 18:36:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  852. Mon Jan 23 18:36:37 2017  begin with 122705333 relations and 67076397 unique ideals
  853. Mon Jan 23 18:36:58 2017  reduce to 122649344 relations and 64670846 ideals in 5 passes
  854. Mon Jan 23 18:36:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  855. Mon Jan 23 18:37:19 2017  removing 4345431 relations and 2345431 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  856. Mon Jan 23 18:37:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  857. Mon Jan 23 18:37:24 2017  begin with 118303913 relations and 64670846 unique ideals
  858. Mon Jan 23 18:37:47 2017  reduce to 118253512 relations and 62274437 ideals in 5 passes
  859. Mon Jan 23 18:37:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  860. Mon Jan 23 18:38:06 2017  removing 4352438 relations and 2352438 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  861. Mon Jan 23 18:38:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  862. Mon Jan 23 18:38:11 2017  begin with 113901074 relations and 62274437 unique ideals
  863. Mon Jan 23 18:38:30 2017  reduce to 113852169 relations and 59872538 ideals in 5 passes
  864. Mon Jan 23 18:38:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  865. Mon Jan 23 18:38:48 2017  removing 4309101 relations and 2309101 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  866. Mon Jan 23 18:38:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  867. Mon Jan 23 18:38:53 2017  begin with 109543068 relations and 59872538 unique ideals
  868. Mon Jan 23 18:39:14 2017  reduce to 109481434 relations and 57501033 ideals in 5 passes
  869. Mon Jan 23 18:39:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  870. Mon Jan 23 18:39:31 2017  removing 4311628 relations and 2311628 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  871. Mon Jan 23 18:39:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  872. Mon Jan 23 18:39:36 2017  begin with 105169806 relations and 57501033 unique ideals
  873. Mon Jan 23 18:39:54 2017  reduce to 105114627 relations and 55133479 ideals in 5 passes
  874. Mon Jan 23 18:39:54 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  875. Mon Jan 23 18:40:11 2017  removing 4313918 relations and 2313918 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  876. Mon Jan 23 18:40:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  877. Mon Jan 23 18:40:16 2017  begin with 100800709 relations and 55133479 unique ideals
  878. Mon Jan 23 18:40:33 2017  reduce to 100745592 relations and 52763744 ideals in 5 passes
  879. Mon Jan 23 18:40:33 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  880. Mon Jan 23 18:40:49 2017  removing 4274680 relations and 2274680 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  881. Mon Jan 23 18:40:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  882. Mon Jan 23 18:40:54 2017  begin with 96470912 relations and 52763744 unique ideals
  883. Mon Jan 23 18:41:09 2017  reduce to 96408125 relations and 50425428 ideals in 5 passes
  884. Mon Jan 23 18:41:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  885. Mon Jan 23 18:41:24 2017  removing 4287545 relations and 2287545 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  886. Mon Jan 23 18:41:26 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  887. Mon Jan 23 18:41:28 2017  begin with 92120580 relations and 50425428 unique ideals
  888. Mon Jan 23 18:41:43 2017  reduce to 92058303 relations and 48074783 ideals in 5 passes
  889. Mon Jan 23 18:41:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  890. Mon Jan 23 18:41:57 2017  removing 4276316 relations and 2276316 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  891. Mon Jan 23 18:41:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  892. Mon Jan 23 18:42:01 2017  begin with 87781987 relations and 48074783 unique ideals
  893. Mon Jan 23 18:42:15 2017  reduce to 87713689 relations and 45729243 ideals in 5 passes
  894. Mon Jan 23 18:42:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  895. Mon Jan 23 18:42:28 2017  removing 4259745 relations and 2259745 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  896. Mon Jan 23 18:42:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  897. Mon Jan 23 18:42:32 2017  begin with 83453944 relations and 45729243 unique ideals
  898. Mon Jan 23 18:42:45 2017  reduce to 83385279 relations and 43399873 ideals in 5 passes
  899. Mon Jan 23 18:42:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  900. Mon Jan 23 18:42:58 2017  removing 4251315 relations and 2251315 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  901. Mon Jan 23 18:42:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  902. Mon Jan 23 18:43:02 2017  begin with 79133964 relations and 43399873 unique ideals
  903. Mon Jan 23 18:43:15 2017  reduce to 79059521 relations and 41072989 ideals in 5 passes
  904. Mon Jan 23 18:43:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  905. Mon Jan 23 18:43:26 2017  removing 4259111 relations and 2259111 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  906. Mon Jan 23 18:43:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  907. Mon Jan 23 18:43:30 2017  begin with 74800410 relations and 41072989 unique ideals
  908. Mon Jan 23 18:43:44 2017  reduce to 74714391 relations and 38726442 ideals in 5 passes
  909. Mon Jan 23 18:43:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  910. Mon Jan 23 18:43:54 2017  removing 4238605 relations and 2238605 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  911. Mon Jan 23 18:43:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  912. Mon Jan 23 18:43:58 2017  begin with 70475786 relations and 38726442 unique ideals
  913. Mon Jan 23 18:44:09 2017  reduce to 70390099 relations and 36400736 ideals in 5 passes
  914. Mon Jan 23 18:44:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  915. Mon Jan 23 18:44:20 2017  removing 4247771 relations and 2247771 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  916. Mon Jan 23 18:44:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  917. Mon Jan 23 18:44:23 2017  begin with 66142328 relations and 36400736 unique ideals
  918. Mon Jan 23 18:44:34 2017  reduce to 66055248 relations and 34064420 ideals in 5 passes
  919. Mon Jan 23 18:44:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  920. Mon Jan 23 18:44:43 2017  removing 4253031 relations and 2253031 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  921. Mon Jan 23 18:44:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  922. Mon Jan 23 18:44:46 2017  begin with 61802217 relations and 34064420 unique ideals
  923. Mon Jan 23 18:44:56 2017  reduce to 61717343 relations and 31725131 ideals in 5 passes
  924. Mon Jan 23 18:44:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  925. Mon Jan 23 18:45:04 2017  removing 4264235 relations and 2264235 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  926. Mon Jan 23 18:45:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  927. Mon Jan 23 18:45:08 2017  begin with 57453108 relations and 31725131 unique ideals
  928. Mon Jan 23 18:45:16 2017  reduce to 57362425 relations and 29368696 ideals in 5 passes
  929. Mon Jan 23 18:45:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  930. Mon Jan 23 18:45:24 2017  removing 4263872 relations and 2263872 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  931. Mon Jan 23 18:45:25 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  932. Mon Jan 23 18:45:27 2017  begin with 53098553 relations and 29368696 unique ideals
  933. Mon Jan 23 18:45:36 2017  reduce to 52956371 relations and 26959531 ideals in 6 passes
  934. Mon Jan 23 18:45:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  935. Mon Jan 23 18:45:43 2017  removing 4241756 relations and 2241756 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  936. Mon Jan 23 18:45:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  937. Mon Jan 23 18:45:46 2017  begin with 48714615 relations and 26959531 unique ideals
  938. Mon Jan 23 18:45:52 2017  reduce to 48538199 relations and 24536960 ideals in 5 passes
  939. Mon Jan 23 18:45:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  940. Mon Jan 23 18:45:59 2017  removing 4256148 relations and 2256148 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  941. Mon Jan 23 18:46:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  942. Mon Jan 23 18:46:01 2017  begin with 44282051 relations and 24536960 unique ideals
  943. Mon Jan 23 18:46:08 2017  reduce to 44075664 relations and 22068194 ideals in 5 passes
  944. Mon Jan 23 18:46:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  945. Mon Jan 23 18:46:14 2017  removing 4281853 relations and 2281853 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  946. Mon Jan 23 18:46:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  947. Mon Jan 23 18:46:16 2017  begin with 39793811 relations and 22068194 unique ideals
  948. Mon Jan 23 18:46:23 2017  reduce to 39553569 relations and 19537739 ideals in 6 passes
  949. Mon Jan 23 18:46:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  950. Mon Jan 23 18:46:30 2017  removing 4308514 relations and 2308514 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  951. Mon Jan 23 18:46:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  952. Mon Jan 23 18:46:32 2017  begin with 35245055 relations and 19537739 unique ideals
  953. Mon Jan 23 18:46:39 2017  reduce to 34960526 relations and 16932951 ideals in 6 passes
  954. Mon Jan 23 18:46:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  955. Mon Jan 23 18:46:44 2017  removing 4329753 relations and 2329753 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  956. Mon Jan 23 18:46:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  957. Mon Jan 23 18:46:46 2017  begin with 30630773 relations and 16932951 unique ideals
  958. Mon Jan 23 18:46:51 2017  reduce to 30300897 relations and 14256136 ideals in 6 passes
  959. Mon Jan 23 18:46:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
  960. Mon Jan 23 18:46:55 2017  removing 4367497 relations and 2367497 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  961. Mon Jan 23 18:46:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  962. Mon Jan 23 18:46:56 2017  begin with 25933400 relations and 14256136 unique ideals
  963. Mon Jan 23 18:47:00 2017  reduce to 25588786 relations and 11523409 ideals in 6 passes
  964. Mon Jan 23 18:47:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  965. Mon Jan 23 18:47:04 2017  removing 311515 relations and 186864 ideals in 124651 cliques
  966. Mon Jan 23 18:47:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  967. Mon Jan 23 18:47:05 2017  begin with 25277271 relations and 11523409 unique ideals
  968. Mon Jan 23 18:47:09 2017  reduce to 25265316 relations and 11324483 ideals in 6 passes
  969. Mon Jan 23 18:47:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  970. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 4479756
  971. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 11495937
  972. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 7159748
  973. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1833012
  974. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 278774
  975. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 16952
  976. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 1135
  977. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 2
  978. Mon Jan 23 18:47:14 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  979. Mon Jan 23 18:47:19 2017  reduce to 19998327 relation sets and 6057494 unique ideals
  980. Mon Jan 23 18:47:19 2017  commencing full merge
  981. Mon Jan 23 18:47:46 2017  memory use: 651.7 MB
  982. Mon Jan 23 18:47:47 2017  found 13940804 cycles, need 12018067
  983. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  weight of 12018067 cycles is about 404653565 (33.67/cycle)
  984. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  985. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  1 relations: 4479756
  986. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  2 relations: 3008434
  987. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  3 relations: 2236636
  988. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  4 relations: 1364921
  989. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  5 relations: 874457
  990. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  6 relations: 53798
  991. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  7 relations: 65
  992. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  8 relations: 0
  993. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  9 relations: 0
  994. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  10+ relations: 0
  995. Mon Jan 23 18:47:50 2017  heaviest cycle: 7 relations
  996. Mon Jan 23 18:47:51 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  997. Mon Jan 23 18:47:52 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  998. Mon Jan 23 18:50:11 2017  keeping 135185902 ideals with weight <= 35, target excess is 11400301
  999. Mon Jan 23 18:52:24 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  1000. Mon Jan 23 18:52:24 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1001. Mon Jan 23 18:52:32 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 135185902 unique ideals
  1002. Mon Jan 23 18:53:02 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 135185812 ideals in 3 passes
  1003. Mon Jan 23 18:53:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1004. Mon Jan 23 18:53:47 2017  removing 6683871 relations and 4683871 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1005. Mon Jan 23 18:53:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1006. Mon Jan 23 18:53:58 2017  begin with 235842789 relations and 135185812 unique ideals
  1007. Mon Jan 23 18:54:54 2017  reduce to 235639741 relations and 130296437 ideals in 6 passes
  1008. Mon Jan 23 18:54:54 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1009. Mon Jan 23 18:55:40 2017  removing 5501131 relations and 3501131 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1010. Mon Jan 23 18:55:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1011. Mon Jan 23 18:55:51 2017  begin with 230138610 relations and 130296437 unique ideals
  1012. Mon Jan 23 18:56:43 2017  reduce to 230009441 relations and 126664923 ideals in 6 passes
  1013. Mon Jan 23 18:56:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1014. Mon Jan 23 18:57:25 2017  removing 5217159 relations and 3217159 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1015. Mon Jan 23 18:57:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1016. Mon Jan 23 18:57:36 2017  begin with 224792282 relations and 126664923 unique ideals
  1017. Mon Jan 23 18:58:31 2017  reduce to 224688886 relations and 123343377 ideals in 6 passes
  1018. Mon Jan 23 18:58:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1019. Mon Jan 23 18:59:15 2017  removing 5038960 relations and 3038960 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1020. Mon Jan 23 18:59:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1021. Mon Jan 23 18:59:25 2017  begin with 219649926 relations and 123343377 unique ideals
  1022. Mon Jan 23 19:00:04 2017  reduce to 219559092 relations and 120212730 ideals in 5 passes
  1023. Mon Jan 23 19:00:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1024. Mon Jan 23 19:00:49 2017  removing 4934557 relations and 2934557 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1025. Mon Jan 23 19:00:53 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1026. Mon Jan 23 19:01:00 2017  begin with 214624535 relations and 120212730 unique ideals
  1027. Mon Jan 23 19:01:43 2017  reduce to 214542969 relations and 117195819 ideals in 5 passes
  1028. Mon Jan 23 19:01:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1029. Mon Jan 23 19:02:26 2017  removing 4851839 relations and 2851839 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1030. Mon Jan 23 19:02:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1031. Mon Jan 23 19:02:36 2017  begin with 209691130 relations and 117195819 unique ideals
  1032. Mon Jan 23 19:03:21 2017  reduce to 209613552 relations and 114265631 ideals in 5 passes
  1033. Mon Jan 23 19:03:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1034. Mon Jan 23 19:04:01 2017  removing 4797676 relations and 2797676 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1035. Mon Jan 23 19:04:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1036. Mon Jan 23 19:04:10 2017  begin with 204815876 relations and 114265631 unique ideals
  1037. Mon Jan 23 19:04:52 2017  reduce to 204746903 relations and 111398272 ideals in 5 passes
  1038. Mon Jan 23 19:04:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1039. Mon Jan 23 19:05:31 2017  removing 4744665 relations and 2744665 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1040. Mon Jan 23 19:05:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1041. Mon Jan 23 19:05:40 2017  begin with 200002238 relations and 111398272 unique ideals
  1042. Mon Jan 23 19:06:15 2017  reduce to 199934769 relations and 108585410 ideals in 5 passes
  1043. Mon Jan 23 19:06:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1044. Mon Jan 23 19:06:53 2017  removing 4677383 relations and 2677383 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1045. Mon Jan 23 19:06:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1046. Mon Jan 23 19:07:02 2017  begin with 195257386 relations and 108585410 unique ideals
  1047. Mon Jan 23 19:07:38 2017  reduce to 195191904 relations and 105841792 ideals in 5 passes
  1048. Mon Jan 23 19:07:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1049. Mon Jan 23 19:08:15 2017  removing 4668007 relations and 2668007 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1050. Mon Jan 23 19:08:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1051. Mon Jan 23 19:08:24 2017  begin with 190523897 relations and 105841792 unique ideals
  1052. Mon Jan 23 19:09:09 2017  reduce to 190461808 relations and 103111049 ideals in 6 passes
  1053. Mon Jan 23 19:09:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1054. Mon Jan 23 19:09:43 2017  removing 4604250 relations and 2604250 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1055. Mon Jan 23 19:09:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1056. Mon Jan 23 19:09:52 2017  begin with 185857558 relations and 103111049 unique ideals
  1057. Mon Jan 23 19:10:29 2017  reduce to 185797068 relations and 100445639 ideals in 6 passes
  1058. Mon Jan 23 19:10:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1059. Mon Jan 23 19:11:03 2017  removing 4609223 relations and 2609223 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1060. Mon Jan 23 19:11:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1061. Mon Jan 23 19:11:11 2017  begin with 181187845 relations and 100445639 unique ideals
  1062. Mon Jan 23 19:11:44 2017  reduce to 181129831 relations and 97777766 ideals in 5 passes
  1063. Mon Jan 23 19:11:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1064. Mon Jan 23 19:12:18 2017  removing 4560924 relations and 2560924 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1065. Mon Jan 23 19:12:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1066. Mon Jan 23 19:12:26 2017  begin with 176568907 relations and 97777766 unique ideals
  1067. Mon Jan 23 19:13:01 2017  reduce to 176512818 relations and 95160121 ideals in 5 passes
  1068. Mon Jan 23 19:13:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1069. Mon Jan 23 19:13:33 2017  removing 4546599 relations and 2546599 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1070. Mon Jan 23 19:13:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1071. Mon Jan 23 19:13:40 2017  begin with 171966219 relations and 95160121 unique ideals
  1072. Mon Jan 23 19:14:13 2017  reduce to 171910974 relations and 92557589 ideals in 5 passes
  1073. Mon Jan 23 19:14:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1074. Mon Jan 23 19:14:46 2017  removing 4523428 relations and 2523428 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1075. Mon Jan 23 19:14:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1076. Mon Jan 23 19:14:54 2017  begin with 167387546 relations and 92557589 unique ideals
  1077. Mon Jan 23 19:15:26 2017  reduce to 167332769 relations and 89978684 ideals in 5 passes
  1078. Mon Jan 23 19:15:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1079. Mon Jan 23 19:15:57 2017  removing 4483171 relations and 2483171 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1080. Mon Jan 23 19:15:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1081. Mon Jan 23 19:16:04 2017  begin with 162849598 relations and 89978684 unique ideals
  1082. Mon Jan 23 19:16:34 2017  reduce to 162796337 relations and 87441598 ideals in 5 passes
  1083. Mon Jan 23 19:16:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1084. Mon Jan 23 19:17:03 2017  removing 4490635 relations and 2490635 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1085. Mon Jan 23 19:17:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1086. Mon Jan 23 19:17:11 2017  begin with 158305702 relations and 87441598 unique ideals
  1087. Mon Jan 23 19:17:41 2017  reduce to 158255609 relations and 84900254 ideals in 5 passes
  1088. Mon Jan 23 19:17:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1089. Mon Jan 23 19:18:09 2017  removing 4471413 relations and 2471413 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1090. Mon Jan 23 19:18:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1091. Mon Jan 23 19:18:16 2017  begin with 153784196 relations and 84900254 unique ideals
  1092. Mon Jan 23 19:18:45 2017  reduce to 153731317 relations and 82375337 ideals in 5 passes
  1093. Mon Jan 23 19:18:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1094. Mon Jan 23 19:19:13 2017  removing 4423679 relations and 2423679 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1095. Mon Jan 23 19:19:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1096. Mon Jan 23 19:19:20 2017  begin with 149307638 relations and 82375337 unique ideals
  1097. Mon Jan 23 19:19:47 2017  reduce to 149248951 relations and 79892247 ideals in 5 passes
  1098. Mon Jan 23 19:19:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1099. Mon Jan 23 19:20:13 2017  removing 4420315 relations and 2420315 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1100. Mon Jan 23 19:20:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1101. Mon Jan 23 19:20:20 2017  begin with 144828636 relations and 79892247 unique ideals
  1102. Mon Jan 23 19:20:47 2017  reduce to 144775449 relations and 77418012 ideals in 5 passes
  1103. Mon Jan 23 19:20:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1104. Mon Jan 23 19:21:13 2017  removing 4415204 relations and 2415204 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1105. Mon Jan 23 19:21:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1106. Mon Jan 23 19:21:19 2017  begin with 140360245 relations and 77418012 unique ideals
  1107. Mon Jan 23 19:21:45 2017  reduce to 140307608 relations and 74949488 ideals in 5 passes
  1108. Mon Jan 23 19:21:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1109. Mon Jan 23 19:22:08 2017  removing 4400041 relations and 2400041 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1110. Mon Jan 23 19:22:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1111. Mon Jan 23 19:22:14 2017  begin with 135907567 relations and 74949488 unique ideals
  1112. Mon Jan 23 19:22:39 2017  reduce to 135857499 relations and 72498714 ideals in 5 passes
  1113. Mon Jan 23 19:22:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1114. Mon Jan 23 19:23:00 2017  removing 4396342 relations and 2396342 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1115. Mon Jan 23 19:23:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1116. Mon Jan 23 19:23:06 2017  begin with 131461157 relations and 72498714 unique ideals
  1117. Mon Jan 23 19:23:23 2017  reduce to 131412778 relations and 70053354 ideals in 4 passes
  1118. Mon Jan 23 19:23:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1119. Mon Jan 23 19:23:44 2017  removing 4377642 relations and 2377642 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1120. Mon Jan 23 19:23:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1121. Mon Jan 23 19:23:50 2017  begin with 127035136 relations and 70053354 unique ideals
  1122. Mon Jan 23 19:24:14 2017  reduce to 126987559 relations and 67627528 ideals in 5 passes
  1123. Mon Jan 23 19:24:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 32
  1124. Mon Jan 23 19:24:34 2017  removing 4328213 relations and 2328213 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1125. Mon Jan 23 19:24:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1126. Mon Jan 23 19:24:40 2017  begin with 122659346 relations and 67627528 unique ideals
  1127. Mon Jan 23 19:25:00 2017  reduce to 122598570 relations and 65237717 ideals in 5 passes
  1128. Mon Jan 23 19:25:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 31
  1129. Mon Jan 23 19:25:21 2017  removing 4343056 relations and 2343056 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1130. Mon Jan 23 19:25:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1131. Mon Jan 23 19:25:27 2017  begin with 118255514 relations and 65237717 unique ideals
  1132. Mon Jan 23 19:25:47 2017  reduce to 118200068 relations and 62838442 ideals in 5 passes
  1133. Mon Jan 23 19:25:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 31
  1134. Mon Jan 23 19:26:06 2017  removing 4334313 relations and 2334313 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1135. Mon Jan 23 19:26:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1136. Mon Jan 23 19:26:12 2017  begin with 113865755 relations and 62838442 unique ideals
  1137. Mon Jan 23 19:26:32 2017  reduce to 113814698 relations and 60452466 ideals in 5 passes
  1138. Mon Jan 23 19:26:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 31
  1139. Mon Jan 23 19:26:50 2017  removing 4338602 relations and 2338602 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1140. Mon Jan 23 19:26:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1141. Mon Jan 23 19:26:55 2017  begin with 109476096 relations and 60452466 unique ideals
  1142. Mon Jan 23 19:27:13 2017  reduce to 109426103 relations and 58063269 ideals in 5 passes
  1143. Mon Jan 23 19:27:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  1144. Mon Jan 23 19:27:31 2017  removing 4298015 relations and 2298015 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1145. Mon Jan 23 19:27:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1146. Mon Jan 23 19:27:36 2017  begin with 105128088 relations and 58063269 unique ideals
  1147. Mon Jan 23 19:27:54 2017  reduce to 105066118 relations and 55702500 ideals in 5 passes
  1148. Mon Jan 23 19:27:54 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  1149. Mon Jan 23 19:28:11 2017  removing 4302319 relations and 2302319 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1150. Mon Jan 23 19:28:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1151. Mon Jan 23 19:28:15 2017  begin with 100763799 relations and 55702500 unique ideals
  1152. Mon Jan 23 19:28:32 2017  reduce to 100706689 relations and 53342333 ideals in 5 passes
  1153. Mon Jan 23 19:28:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  1154. Mon Jan 23 19:28:49 2017  removing 4297569 relations and 2297569 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1155. Mon Jan 23 19:28:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1156. Mon Jan 23 19:28:54 2017  begin with 96409120 relations and 53342333 unique ideals
  1157. Mon Jan 23 19:29:10 2017  reduce to 96351694 relations and 50986554 ideals in 5 passes
  1158. Mon Jan 23 19:29:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  1159. Mon Jan 23 19:29:25 2017  removing 4268405 relations and 2268405 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1160. Mon Jan 23 19:29:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1161. Mon Jan 23 19:29:29 2017  begin with 92083289 relations and 50986554 unique ideals
  1162. Mon Jan 23 19:29:46 2017  reduce to 92019451 relations and 48653478 ideals in 5 passes
  1163. Mon Jan 23 19:29:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  1164. Mon Jan 23 19:30:00 2017  removing 4276452 relations and 2276452 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1165. Mon Jan 23 19:30:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1166. Mon Jan 23 19:30:04 2017  begin with 87742999 relations and 48653478 unique ideals
  1167. Mon Jan 23 19:30:20 2017  reduce to 87677065 relations and 46310159 ideals in 5 passes
  1168. Mon Jan 23 19:30:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  1169. Mon Jan 23 19:30:34 2017  removing 4267397 relations and 2267397 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1170. Mon Jan 23 19:30:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1171. Mon Jan 23 19:30:38 2017  begin with 83409668 relations and 46310159 unique ideals
  1172. Mon Jan 23 19:30:50 2017  reduce to 83338469 relations and 43970522 ideals in 4 passes
  1173. Mon Jan 23 19:30:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  1174. Mon Jan 23 19:31:02 2017  removing 4251256 relations and 2251256 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1175. Mon Jan 23 19:31:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1176. Mon Jan 23 19:31:05 2017  begin with 79087213 relations and 43970522 unique ideals
  1177. Mon Jan 23 19:31:18 2017  reduce to 79015139 relations and 41646167 ideals in 5 passes
  1178. Mon Jan 23 19:31:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  1179. Mon Jan 23 19:31:30 2017  removing 4247376 relations and 2247376 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1180. Mon Jan 23 19:31:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1181. Mon Jan 23 19:31:34 2017  begin with 74767763 relations and 41646167 unique ideals
  1182. Mon Jan 23 19:31:47 2017  reduce to 74689473 relations and 39319368 ideals in 5 passes
  1183. Mon Jan 23 19:31:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  1184. Mon Jan 23 19:31:57 2017  removing 4251878 relations and 2251878 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1185. Mon Jan 23 19:31:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1186. Mon Jan 23 19:32:01 2017  begin with 70437595 relations and 39319368 unique ideals
  1187. Mon Jan 23 19:32:14 2017  reduce to 70346386 relations and 36974750 ideals in 5 passes
  1188. Mon Jan 23 19:32:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  1189. Mon Jan 23 19:32:25 2017  removing 4232676 relations and 2232676 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1190. Mon Jan 23 19:32:26 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1191. Mon Jan 23 19:32:28 2017  begin with 66113710 relations and 36974750 unique ideals
  1192. Mon Jan 23 19:32:39 2017  reduce to 66018081 relations and 34644851 ideals in 5 passes
  1193. Mon Jan 23 19:32:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  1194. Mon Jan 23 19:32:49 2017  removing 4244389 relations and 2244389 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1195. Mon Jan 23 19:32:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1196. Mon Jan 23 19:32:52 2017  begin with 61773692 relations and 34644851 unique ideals
  1197. Mon Jan 23 19:33:00 2017  reduce to 61671722 relations and 32296655 ideals in 4 passes
  1198. Mon Jan 23 19:33:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  1199. Mon Jan 23 19:33:09 2017  removing 4246063 relations and 2246063 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1200. Mon Jan 23 19:33:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1201. Mon Jan 23 19:33:12 2017  begin with 57425659 relations and 32296655 unique ideals
  1202. Mon Jan 23 19:33:25 2017  reduce to 57321748 relations and 29944741 ideals in 6 passes
  1203. Mon Jan 23 19:33:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  1204. Mon Jan 23 19:33:33 2017  removing 4257559 relations and 2257559 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1205. Mon Jan 23 19:33:35 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1206. Mon Jan 23 19:33:36 2017  begin with 53064189 relations and 29944741 unique ideals
  1207. Mon Jan 23 19:33:45 2017  reduce to 52958650 relations and 27579735 ideals in 5 passes
  1208. Mon Jan 23 19:33:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  1209. Mon Jan 23 19:33:53 2017  removing 4270009 relations and 2270009 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1210. Mon Jan 23 19:33:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1211. Mon Jan 23 19:33:55 2017  begin with 48688641 relations and 27579735 unique ideals
  1212. Mon Jan 23 19:34:03 2017  reduce to 48543276 relations and 25161076 ideals in 5 passes
  1213. Mon Jan 23 19:34:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  1214. Mon Jan 23 19:34:11 2017  removing 4266219 relations and 2266219 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1215. Mon Jan 23 19:34:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1216. Mon Jan 23 19:34:13 2017  begin with 44277057 relations and 25161076 unique ideals
  1217. Mon Jan 23 19:34:23 2017  reduce to 44085608 relations and 22698200 ideals in 6 passes
  1218. Mon Jan 23 19:34:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1219. Mon Jan 23 19:34:30 2017  removing 4281756 relations and 2281756 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1220. Mon Jan 23 19:34:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1221. Mon Jan 23 19:34:33 2017  begin with 39803852 relations and 22698200 unique ideals
  1222. Mon Jan 23 19:34:40 2017  reduce to 39571651 relations and 20176905 ideals in 6 passes
  1223. Mon Jan 23 19:34:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1224. Mon Jan 23 19:34:45 2017  removing 4313255 relations and 2313255 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1225. Mon Jan 23 19:34:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1226. Mon Jan 23 19:34:48 2017  begin with 35258396 relations and 20176905 unique ideals
  1227. Mon Jan 23 19:34:55 2017  reduce to 34983076 relations and 17577673 ideals in 6 passes
  1228. Mon Jan 23 19:34:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1229. Mon Jan 23 19:35:01 2017  removing 4347651 relations and 2347651 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1230. Mon Jan 23 19:35:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1231. Mon Jan 23 19:35:03 2017  begin with 30635425 relations and 17577673 unique ideals
  1232. Mon Jan 23 19:35:08 2017  reduce to 30305557 relations and 14884503 ideals in 6 passes
  1233. Mon Jan 23 19:35:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  1234. Mon Jan 23 19:35:12 2017  removing 4379299 relations and 2379299 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1235. Mon Jan 23 19:35:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1236. Mon Jan 23 19:35:14 2017  begin with 25926258 relations and 14884503 unique ideals
  1237. Mon Jan 23 19:35:18 2017  reduce to 25547253 relations and 12103820 ideals in 6 passes
  1238. Mon Jan 23 19:35:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  1239. Mon Jan 23 19:35:22 2017  removing 543608 relations and 324525 ideals in 219083 cliques
  1240. Mon Jan 23 19:35:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1241. Mon Jan 23 19:35:24 2017  begin with 25003645 relations and 12103820 unique ideals
  1242. Mon Jan 23 19:35:28 2017  reduce to 24975695 relations and 11750968 ideals in 5 passes
  1243. Mon Jan 23 19:35:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
  1244. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 3881541
  1245. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 10831236
  1246. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 7653838
  1247. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 2199560
  1248. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 378630
  1249. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 29166
  1250. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 1718
  1251. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 6
  1252. Mon Jan 23 19:35:33 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  1253. Mon Jan 23 19:35:39 2017  reduce to 19675631 relation sets and 6450904 unique ideals
  1254. Mon Jan 23 19:35:39 2017  commencing full merge
  1255. Mon Jan 23 19:36:11 2017  memory use: 669.4 MB
  1256. Mon Jan 23 19:36:12 2017  found 13224507 cycles, need 11400501
  1257. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  weight of 11400501 cycles is about 425787024 (37.35/cycle)
  1258. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  1259. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  1 relations: 3881541
  1260. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  2 relations: 2563549
  1261. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  3 relations: 2062464
  1262. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  4 relations: 1382905
  1263. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  5 relations: 911292
  1264. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  6 relations: 590921
  1265. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  7 relations: 7819
  1266. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  8 relations: 10
  1267. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  9 relations: 0
  1268. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  10+ relations: 0
  1269. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  heaviest cycle: 8 relations
  1270. Mon Jan 23 19:36:15 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  1271. Mon Jan 23 19:36:17 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  1272. Mon Jan 23 19:38:50 2017  keeping 135771654 ideals with weight <= 40, target excess is 10814549
  1273. Mon Jan 23 19:41:24 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  1274. Mon Jan 23 19:41:24 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1275. Mon Jan 23 19:41:33 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 135771654 unique ideals
  1276. Mon Jan 23 19:42:00 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 135771564 ideals in 3 passes
  1277. Mon Jan 23 19:42:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1278. Mon Jan 23 19:42:46 2017  removing 6701848 relations and 4701848 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1279. Mon Jan 23 19:42:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1280. Mon Jan 23 19:42:57 2017  begin with 235824812 relations and 135771564 unique ideals
  1281. Mon Jan 23 19:43:46 2017  reduce to 235622388 relations and 130864862 ideals in 6 passes
  1282. Mon Jan 23 19:43:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1283. Mon Jan 23 19:44:28 2017  removing 5519673 relations and 3519673 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1284. Mon Jan 23 19:44:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1285. Mon Jan 23 19:44:38 2017  begin with 230102715 relations and 130864862 unique ideals
  1286. Mon Jan 23 19:45:28 2017  reduce to 229975022 relations and 127216290 ideals in 6 passes
  1287. Mon Jan 23 19:45:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1288. Mon Jan 23 19:46:10 2017  removing 5214715 relations and 3214715 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1289. Mon Jan 23 19:46:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1290. Mon Jan 23 19:46:20 2017  begin with 224760307 relations and 127216290 unique ideals
  1291. Mon Jan 23 19:47:10 2017  reduce to 224656907 relations and 123897205 ideals in 6 passes
  1292. Mon Jan 23 19:47:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1293. Mon Jan 23 19:47:52 2017  removing 5042098 relations and 3042098 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1294. Mon Jan 23 19:47:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1295. Mon Jan 23 19:48:02 2017  begin with 219614809 relations and 123897205 unique ideals
  1296. Mon Jan 23 19:48:52 2017  reduce to 219523060 relations and 120762494 ideals in 5 passes
  1297. Mon Jan 23 19:48:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1298. Mon Jan 23 19:49:35 2017  removing 4937772 relations and 2937772 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1299. Mon Jan 23 19:49:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1300. Mon Jan 23 19:49:45 2017  begin with 214585288 relations and 120762494 unique ideals
  1301. Mon Jan 23 19:50:30 2017  reduce to 214503941 relations and 117742564 ideals in 5 passes
  1302. Mon Jan 23 19:50:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1303. Mon Jan 23 19:51:13 2017  removing 4856075 relations and 2856075 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1304. Mon Jan 23 19:51:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1305. Mon Jan 23 19:51:23 2017  begin with 209647866 relations and 117742564 unique ideals
  1306. Mon Jan 23 19:52:08 2017  reduce to 209570909 relations and 114808756 ideals in 5 passes
  1307. Mon Jan 23 19:52:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1308. Mon Jan 23 19:52:50 2017  removing 4804727 relations and 2804727 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1309. Mon Jan 23 19:52:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1310. Mon Jan 23 19:53:01 2017  begin with 204766182 relations and 114808756 unique ideals
  1311. Mon Jan 23 19:53:51 2017  reduce to 204697091 relations and 111934210 ideals in 5 passes
  1312. Mon Jan 23 19:53:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1313. Mon Jan 23 19:54:31 2017  removing 4736996 relations and 2736996 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1314. Mon Jan 23 19:54:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1315. Mon Jan 23 19:54:41 2017  begin with 199960095 relations and 111934210 unique ideals
  1316. Mon Jan 23 19:55:19 2017  reduce to 199891635 relations and 109128060 ideals in 5 passes
  1317. Mon Jan 23 19:55:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1318. Mon Jan 23 19:55:57 2017  removing 4685928 relations and 2685928 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1319. Mon Jan 23 19:56:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1320. Mon Jan 23 19:56:07 2017  begin with 195205707 relations and 109128060 unique ideals
  1321. Mon Jan 23 19:56:50 2017  reduce to 195140296 relations and 106375987 ideals in 5 passes
  1322. Mon Jan 23 19:56:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1323. Mon Jan 23 19:57:29 2017  removing 4652675 relations and 2652675 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1324. Mon Jan 23 19:57:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1325. Mon Jan 23 19:57:39 2017  begin with 190487621 relations and 106375987 unique ideals
  1326. Mon Jan 23 19:58:24 2017  reduce to 190425416 relations and 103660438 ideals in 6 passes
  1327. Mon Jan 23 19:58:24 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1328. Mon Jan 23 19:59:00 2017  removing 4642474 relations and 2642474 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1329. Mon Jan 23 19:59:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1330. Mon Jan 23 19:59:09 2017  begin with 185782942 relations and 103660438 unique ideals
  1331. Mon Jan 23 19:59:44 2017  reduce to 185724278 relations and 100958588 ideals in 5 passes
  1332. Mon Jan 23 19:59:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1333. Mon Jan 23 20:00:19 2017  removing 4588560 relations and 2588560 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1334. Mon Jan 23 20:00:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1335. Mon Jan 23 20:00:28 2017  begin with 181135718 relations and 100958588 unique ideals
  1336. Mon Jan 23 20:01:06 2017  reduce to 181077325 relations and 98310986 ideals in 5 passes
  1337. Mon Jan 23 20:01:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1338. Mon Jan 23 20:01:42 2017  removing 4570788 relations and 2570788 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1339. Mon Jan 23 20:01:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1340. Mon Jan 23 20:01:51 2017  begin with 176506537 relations and 98310986 unique ideals
  1341. Mon Jan 23 20:02:27 2017  reduce to 176449918 relations and 95682933 ideals in 5 passes
  1342. Mon Jan 23 20:02:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1343. Mon Jan 23 20:03:01 2017  removing 4536802 relations and 2536802 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1344. Mon Jan 23 20:03:05 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1345. Mon Jan 23 20:03:10 2017  begin with 171913116 relations and 95682933 unique ideals
  1346. Mon Jan 23 20:03:45 2017  reduce to 171857707 relations and 93090060 ideals in 5 passes
  1347. Mon Jan 23 20:03:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1348. Mon Jan 23 20:04:17 2017  removing 4515921 relations and 2515921 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1349. Mon Jan 23 20:04:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1350. Mon Jan 23 20:04:26 2017  begin with 167341786 relations and 93090060 unique ideals
  1351. Mon Jan 23 20:05:01 2017  reduce to 167285619 relations and 90517272 ideals in 5 passes
  1352. Mon Jan 23 20:05:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  1353. Mon Jan 23 20:05:33 2017  removing 4502079 relations and 2502079 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1354. Mon Jan 23 20:05:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1355. Mon Jan 23 20:05:40 2017  begin with 162783540 relations and 90517272 unique ideals
  1356. Mon Jan 23 20:06:11 2017  reduce to 162729420 relations and 87960441 ideals in 5 passes
  1357. Mon Jan 23 20:06:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  1358. Mon Jan 23 20:06:41 2017  removing 4470754 relations and 2470754 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1359. Mon Jan 23 20:06:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1360. Mon Jan 23 20:06:48 2017  begin with 158258666 relations and 87960441 unique ideals
  1361. Mon Jan 23 20:07:16 2017  reduce to 158206332 relations and 85436688 ideals in 5 passes
  1362. Mon Jan 23 20:07:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  1363. Mon Jan 23 20:07:47 2017  removing 4470833 relations and 2470833 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1364. Mon Jan 23 20:07:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1365. Mon Jan 23 20:07:54 2017  begin with 153735499 relations and 85436688 unique ideals
  1366. Mon Jan 23 20:08:28 2017  reduce to 153685156 relations and 82914920 ideals in 5 passes
  1367. Mon Jan 23 20:08:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  1368. Mon Jan 23 20:09:00 2017  removing 4426304 relations and 2426304 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1369. Mon Jan 23 20:09:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1370. Mon Jan 23 20:09:07 2017  begin with 149258852 relations and 82914920 unique ideals
  1371. Mon Jan 23 20:09:38 2017  reduce to 149199656 relations and 80428680 ideals in 5 passes
  1372. Mon Jan 23 20:09:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  1373. Mon Jan 23 20:10:06 2017  removing 4430101 relations and 2430101 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1374. Mon Jan 23 20:10:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1375. Mon Jan 23 20:10:13 2017  begin with 144769555 relations and 80428680 unique ideals
  1376. Mon Jan 23 20:10:41 2017  reduce to 144716467 relations and 77944817 ideals in 5 passes
  1377. Mon Jan 23 20:10:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 37
  1378. Mon Jan 23 20:11:09 2017  removing 4403337 relations and 2403337 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1379. Mon Jan 23 20:11:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1380. Mon Jan 23 20:11:15 2017  begin with 140313130 relations and 77944817 unique ideals
  1381. Mon Jan 23 20:11:36 2017  reduce to 140261219 relations and 75488878 ideals in 4 passes
  1382. Mon Jan 23 20:11:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 36
  1383. Mon Jan 23 20:12:02 2017  removing 4403642 relations and 2403642 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1384. Mon Jan 23 20:12:05 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1385. Mon Jan 23 20:12:09 2017  begin with 135857577 relations and 75488878 unique ideals
  1386. Mon Jan 23 20:12:36 2017  reduce to 135805932 relations and 73032924 ideals in 5 passes
  1387. Mon Jan 23 20:12:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 36
  1388. Mon Jan 23 20:13:02 2017  removing 4386369 relations and 2386369 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1389. Mon Jan 23 20:13:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1390. Mon Jan 23 20:13:08 2017  begin with 131419563 relations and 73032924 unique ideals
  1391. Mon Jan 23 20:13:33 2017  reduce to 131370384 relations and 70596723 ideals in 5 passes
  1392. Mon Jan 23 20:13:33 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1393. Mon Jan 23 20:13:56 2017  removing 4376967 relations and 2376967 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1394. Mon Jan 23 20:13:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1395. Mon Jan 23 20:14:03 2017  begin with 126993417 relations and 70596723 unique ideals
  1396. Mon Jan 23 20:14:28 2017  reduce to 126943929 relations and 68169612 ideals in 5 passes
  1397. Mon Jan 23 20:14:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1398. Mon Jan 23 20:14:52 2017  removing 4370069 relations and 2370069 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1399. Mon Jan 23 20:14:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1400. Mon Jan 23 20:14:58 2017  begin with 122573860 relations and 68169612 unique ideals
  1401. Mon Jan 23 20:15:23 2017  reduce to 122525241 relations and 65750322 ideals in 5 passes
  1402. Mon Jan 23 20:15:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1403. Mon Jan 23 20:15:44 2017  removing 4319641 relations and 2319641 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1404. Mon Jan 23 20:15:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1405. Mon Jan 23 20:15:50 2017  begin with 118205600 relations and 65750322 unique ideals
  1406. Mon Jan 23 20:16:14 2017  reduce to 118146017 relations and 63370308 ideals in 5 passes
  1407. Mon Jan 23 20:16:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1408. Mon Jan 23 20:16:34 2017  removing 4327830 relations and 2327830 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1409. Mon Jan 23 20:16:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1410. Mon Jan 23 20:16:39 2017  begin with 113818187 relations and 63370308 unique ideals
  1411. Mon Jan 23 20:16:58 2017  reduce to 113762987 relations and 60986563 ideals in 4 passes
  1412. Mon Jan 23 20:16:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  1413. Mon Jan 23 20:17:18 2017  removing 4325163 relations and 2325163 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1414. Mon Jan 23 20:17:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1415. Mon Jan 23 20:17:23 2017  begin with 109437824 relations and 60986563 unique ideals
  1416. Mon Jan 23 20:17:45 2017  reduce to 109384928 relations and 58607838 ideals in 5 passes
  1417. Mon Jan 23 20:17:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  1418. Mon Jan 23 20:18:04 2017  removing 4320023 relations and 2320023 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1419. Mon Jan 23 20:18:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1420. Mon Jan 23 20:18:10 2017  begin with 105064905 relations and 58607838 unique ideals
  1421. Mon Jan 23 20:18:28 2017  reduce to 105012932 relations and 56235186 ideals in 5 passes
  1422. Mon Jan 23 20:18:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1423. Mon Jan 23 20:18:46 2017  removing 4288047 relations and 2288047 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1424. Mon Jan 23 20:18:49 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1425. Mon Jan 23 20:18:52 2017  begin with 100724885 relations and 56235186 unique ideals
  1426. Mon Jan 23 20:19:10 2017  reduce to 100662251 relations and 53883682 ideals in 5 passes
  1427. Mon Jan 23 20:19:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1428. Mon Jan 23 20:19:27 2017  removing 4291438 relations and 2291438 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1429. Mon Jan 23 20:19:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1430. Mon Jan 23 20:19:32 2017  begin with 96370813 relations and 53883682 unique ideals
  1431. Mon Jan 23 20:19:47 2017  reduce to 96311548 relations and 51532207 ideals in 4 passes
  1432. Mon Jan 23 20:19:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1433. Mon Jan 23 20:20:03 2017  removing 4281033 relations and 2281033 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1434. Mon Jan 23 20:20:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1435. Mon Jan 23 20:20:07 2017  begin with 92030515 relations and 51532207 unique ideals
  1436. Mon Jan 23 20:20:21 2017  reduce to 91969258 relations and 49189167 ideals in 5 passes
  1437. Mon Jan 23 20:20:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  1438. Mon Jan 23 20:20:36 2017  removing 4261045 relations and 2261045 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1439. Mon Jan 23 20:20:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1440. Mon Jan 23 20:20:40 2017  begin with 87708213 relations and 49189167 unique ideals
  1441. Mon Jan 23 20:20:55 2017  reduce to 87641883 relations and 46860898 ideals in 5 passes
  1442. Mon Jan 23 20:20:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 31
  1443. Mon Jan 23 20:21:09 2017  removing 4265541 relations and 2265541 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1444. Mon Jan 23 20:21:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1445. Mon Jan 23 20:21:14 2017  begin with 83376342 relations and 46860898 unique ideals
  1446. Mon Jan 23 20:21:29 2017  reduce to 83305806 relations and 44523843 ideals in 5 passes
  1447. Mon Jan 23 20:21:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  1448. Mon Jan 23 20:21:41 2017  removing 4260165 relations and 2260165 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1449. Mon Jan 23 20:21:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1450. Mon Jan 23 20:21:45 2017  begin with 79045641 relations and 44523843 unique ideals
  1451. Mon Jan 23 20:21:59 2017  reduce to 78971142 relations and 42188090 ideals in 5 passes
  1452. Mon Jan 23 20:21:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  1453. Mon Jan 23 20:22:11 2017  removing 4243175 relations and 2243175 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1454. Mon Jan 23 20:22:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1455. Mon Jan 23 20:22:15 2017  begin with 74727967 relations and 42188090 unique ideals
  1456. Mon Jan 23 20:22:29 2017  reduce to 74650117 relations and 39865946 ideals in 5 passes
  1457. Mon Jan 23 20:22:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  1458. Mon Jan 23 20:22:41 2017  removing 4241698 relations and 2241698 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1459. Mon Jan 23 20:22:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1460. Mon Jan 23 20:22:44 2017  begin with 70408419 relations and 39865946 unique ideals
  1461. Mon Jan 23 20:22:56 2017  reduce to 70323589 relations and 37538074 ideals in 5 passes
  1462. Mon Jan 23 20:22:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  1463. Mon Jan 23 20:23:07 2017  removing 4244868 relations and 2244868 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1464. Mon Jan 23 20:23:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1465. Mon Jan 23 20:23:11 2017  begin with 66078721 relations and 37538074 unique ideals
  1466. Mon Jan 23 20:23:23 2017  reduce to 65980258 relations and 35193009 ideals in 5 passes
  1467. Mon Jan 23 20:23:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  1468. Mon Jan 23 20:23:32 2017  removing 4230351 relations and 2230351 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1469. Mon Jan 23 20:23:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1470. Mon Jan 23 20:23:35 2017  begin with 61749907 relations and 35193009 unique ideals
  1471. Mon Jan 23 20:23:45 2017  reduce to 61643302 relations and 32854110 ideals in 5 passes
  1472. Mon Jan 23 20:23:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  1473. Mon Jan 23 20:23:53 2017  removing 4243809 relations and 2243809 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1474. Mon Jan 23 20:23:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1475. Mon Jan 23 20:23:57 2017  begin with 57399493 relations and 32854110 unique ideals
  1476. Mon Jan 23 20:24:07 2017  reduce to 57280994 relations and 30489412 ideals in 5 passes
  1477. Mon Jan 23 20:24:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  1478. Mon Jan 23 20:24:15 2017  removing 4243462 relations and 2243462 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1479. Mon Jan 23 20:24:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1480. Mon Jan 23 20:24:18 2017  begin with 53037532 relations and 30489412 unique ideals
  1481. Mon Jan 23 20:24:27 2017  reduce to 52912316 relations and 28118146 ideals in 5 passes
  1482. Mon Jan 23 20:24:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  1483. Mon Jan 23 20:24:34 2017  removing 4257588 relations and 2257588 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1484. Mon Jan 23 20:24:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1485. Mon Jan 23 20:24:37 2017  begin with 48654728 relations and 28118146 unique ideals
  1486. Mon Jan 23 20:24:47 2017  reduce to 48522410 relations and 25725339 ideals in 6 passes
  1487. Mon Jan 23 20:24:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  1488. Mon Jan 23 20:24:55 2017  removing 4278671 relations and 2278671 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1489. Mon Jan 23 20:24:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1490. Mon Jan 23 20:24:57 2017  begin with 44243739 relations and 25725339 unique ideals
  1491. Mon Jan 23 20:25:05 2017  reduce to 44096884 relations and 23296354 ideals in 5 passes
  1492. Mon Jan 23 20:25:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  1493. Mon Jan 23 20:25:11 2017  removing 4297308 relations and 2297308 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1494. Mon Jan 23 20:25:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1495. Mon Jan 23 20:25:13 2017  begin with 39799576 relations and 23296354 unique ideals
  1496. Mon Jan 23 20:25:19 2017  reduce to 39590533 relations and 20783753 ideals in 6 passes
  1497. Mon Jan 23 20:25:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1498. Mon Jan 23 20:25:25 2017  removing 4314631 relations and 2314631 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1499. Mon Jan 23 20:25:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1500. Mon Jan 23 20:25:28 2017  begin with 35275902 relations and 20783753 unique ideals
  1501. Mon Jan 23 20:25:36 2017  reduce to 35012177 relations and 18195995 ideals in 6 passes
  1502. Mon Jan 23 20:25:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1503. Mon Jan 23 20:25:41 2017  removing 4354283 relations and 2354283 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1504. Mon Jan 23 20:25:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1505. Mon Jan 23 20:25:43 2017  begin with 30657894 relations and 18195995 unique ideals
  1506. Mon Jan 23 20:25:49 2017  reduce to 30336322 relations and 15505998 ideals in 6 passes
  1507. Mon Jan 23 20:25:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1508. Mon Jan 23 20:25:54 2017  removing 4398582 relations and 2398582 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1509. Mon Jan 23 20:25:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1510. Mon Jan 23 20:25:56 2017  begin with 25937740 relations and 15505998 unique ideals
  1511. Mon Jan 23 20:26:00 2017  reduce to 25544732 relations and 12692787 ideals in 6 passes
  1512. Mon Jan 23 20:26:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1513. Mon Jan 23 20:26:04 2017  removing 756208 relations and 449140 ideals in 307068 cliques
  1514. Mon Jan 23 20:26:05 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1515. Mon Jan 23 20:26:05 2017  begin with 24788524 relations and 12692787 unique ideals
  1516. Mon Jan 23 20:26:08 2017  reduce to 24738861 relations and 12193087 ideals in 5 passes
  1517. Mon Jan 23 20:26:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1518. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 3336636
  1519. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 10067543
  1520. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 8053036
  1521. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 2688805
  1522. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 536290
  1523. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 53135
  1524. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 3358
  1525. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 58
  1526. Mon Jan 23 20:26:13 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  1527. Mon Jan 23 20:26:18 2017  reduce to 19449880 relation sets and 6904106 unique ideals
  1528. Mon Jan 23 20:26:18 2017  commencing full merge
  1529. Mon Jan 23 20:26:55 2017  memory use: 695.5 MB
  1530. Mon Jan 23 20:26:56 2017  found 12544235 cycles, need 10814749
  1531. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  weight of 10814749 cycles is about 457930709 (42.34/cycle)
  1532. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  1533. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  1 relations: 3336636
  1534. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  2 relations: 2159657
  1535. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  3 relations: 1818461
  1536. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  4 relations: 1310972
  1537. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  5 relations: 966496
  1538. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  6 relations: 675004
  1539. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  7 relations: 497644
  1540. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  8 relations: 49707
  1541. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  9 relations: 172
  1542. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  10+ relations: 0
  1543. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  heaviest cycle: 9 relations
  1544. Mon Jan 23 20:26:59 2017  commencing cycle optimization
  1545. Mon Jan 23 20:27:07 2017  start with 31120437 relations
  1546. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  pruned 1681635 relations
  1547. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  memory use: 1123.1 MB
  1548. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  1549. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  1 relations: 3336636
  1550. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  2 relations: 2301156
  1551. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  3 relations: 2033696
  1552. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  4 relations: 1408210
  1553. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  5 relations: 937612
  1554. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  6 relations: 523184
  1555. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  7 relations: 255325
  1556. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  8 relations: 18883
  1557. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  9 relations: 47
  1558. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  10+ relations: 0
  1559. Mon Jan 23 20:27:24 2017  heaviest cycle: 9 relations
  1560. Mon Jan 23 20:27:29 2017  RelProcTime: 20765
  1561. Mon Jan 23 20:27:29 2017  
  1562. Mon Jan 23 20:27:29 2017  commencing linear algebra
  1563. Mon Jan 23 20:27:37 2017  read 10814749 cycles
  1564. Mon Jan 23 20:27:44 2017  cycles contain 20802041 unique relations
  1565. Mon Jan 23 20:30:30 2017  read 20802041 relations
  1566. Mon Jan 23 20:30:51 2017  using 20 quadratic characters above 2147476128
  1567. Mon Jan 23 20:32:20 2017  building initial matrix
  1568. Mon Jan 23 20:35:13 2017  memory use: 3186.2 MB
  1569. Mon Jan 23 20:35:16 2017  read 10814749 cycles
  1570. Mon Jan 23 20:35:18 2017  matrix is 10794942 x 10814749 (2134.5 MB) with weight 670963348 (62.04/col)
  1571. Mon Jan 23 20:35:18 2017  sparse part has weight 429781408 (39.74/col)
  1572. Mon Jan 23 20:36:55 2017  filtering completed in 3 passes
  1573. Mon Jan 23 20:36:57 2017  matrix is 10492459 x 10492656 (2092.5 MB) with weight 657437976 (62.66/col)
  1574. Mon Jan 23 20:36:57 2017  sparse part has weight 422621939 (40.28/col)
  1575. Mon Jan 23 20:37:15 2017  matrix starts at (0, 0)
  1576. Mon Jan 23 20:37:16 2017  matrix is 10492459 x 10492656 (2092.5 MB) with weight 657437976 (62.66/col)
  1577. Mon Jan 23 20:37:16 2017  sparse part has weight 422621939 (40.28/col)
  1578. Mon Jan 23 20:37:16 2017  saving the first 48 matrix rows for later
  1579. Mon Jan 23 20:37:17 2017  matrix includes 64 packed rows
  1580. Mon Jan 23 20:37:18 2017  matrix is 10492411 x 10492656 (1987.6 MB) with weight 473639128 (45.14/col)
  1581. Mon Jan 23 20:37:18 2017  sparse part has weight 416118940 (39.66/col)
  1582. Mon Jan 23 20:37:18 2017  using block size 8192 and superblock size 1474560 for processor cache size 15360 kB
  1583. Mon Jan 23 20:37:46 2017  commencing Lanczos iteration (6 threads)
  1584. Mon Jan 23 20:37:46 2017  memory use: 1577.7 MB
  1585. Mon Jan 23 20:39:00 2017  linear algebra at 0.0%, ETA 135h35m
  1586. Mon Jan 23 20:39:24 2017  checkpointing every 80000 dimensions
  1587. Thu Jan 26 10:32:35 2017  lanczos halted after 165922 iterations (dim = 10492333)
  1588. Thu Jan 26 10:32:42 2017  lanczos error: only trivial dependencies found
  1589. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  BLanczosTime: 223514
  1590. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  
  1591. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  commencing square root phase
  1592. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  handling dependencies 1 to 64
  1593. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  reading relations for dependency 1
  1594. Thu Jan 26 10:32:43 2017  error: read_cycles can't open dependency file
  1595. Thu Jan 26 19:20:39 2017  
  1596. Thu Jan 26 19:20:39 2017  
  1597. Thu Jan 26 19:20:39 2017  Msieve v. 1.52 (SVN unknown)
  1598. Thu Jan 26 19:20:39 2017  random seeds: 531a6599 80c06d9d
  1599. Thu Jan 26 19:20:39 2017  factoring 1374250293977900524006825181025041222391785962418349198188752592542556833408706796147779390990626204883096007787340300959668458776589915992783964729160514357520386806570509 (172 digits)
  1600. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
  1601. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  commencing number field sieve (172-digit input)
  1602. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  R0: -1214784946281755925158360658293296
  1603. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  R1: 18303130010379613
  1604. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A0: -23481671787104319711626620457547467037375
  1605. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A1: 1029230367426047271940304894097130
  1606. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A2: 3146916195524283581740271732
  1607. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A3: 123748321202088763083
  1608. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A4: -51331470267154
  1609. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  A5: 519480
  1610. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  skew 8648943.40, size 9.864e-17, alpha -6.365, combined = 2.829e-13 rroots = 5
  1611. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  
  1612. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  commencing relation filtering
  1613. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  setting target matrix density to 140.0
  1614. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  estimated available RAM is 15888.6 MB
  1615. Thu Jan 26 19:20:40 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 1
  1616. Thu Jan 26 19:22:13 2017  error -15 reading relation 16802143
  1617. Thu Jan 26 19:23:18 2017  error -15 reading relation 25595384
  1618. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028429
  1619. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028466
  1620. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28029447
  1621. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030449
  1622. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -1 reading relation 28030866
  1623. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030949
  1624. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034064
  1625. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -15 reading relation 28034102
  1626. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034900
  1627. Thu Jan 26 19:23:31 2017  error -9 reading relation 28035134
  1628. Thu Jan 26 19:25:40 2017  error -1 reading relation 49162215
  1629. Thu Jan 26 19:25:43 2017  error -15 reading relation 49535773
  1630. Thu Jan 26 19:27:34 2017  error -15 reading relation 64446614
  1631. Thu Jan 26 19:27:41 2017  error -15 reading relation 65376789
  1632. Thu Jan 26 19:28:55 2017  error -1 reading relation 75290332
  1633. Thu Jan 26 19:30:10 2017  error -1 reading relation 86413805
  1634. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99959556
  1635. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99963811
  1636. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964293
  1637. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964330
  1638. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964368
  1639. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964666
  1640. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99965447
  1641. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -1 reading relation 99965485
  1642. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99966582
  1643. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99967695
  1644. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968437
  1645. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968692
  1646. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968774
  1647. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968863
  1648. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968945
  1649. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -5 reading relation 99969029
  1650. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969105
  1651. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969477
  1652. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969561
  1653. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969920
  1654. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970098
  1655. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970135
  1656. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970374
  1657. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970450
  1658. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970488
  1659. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970525
  1660. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970562
  1661. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970599
  1662. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970636
  1663. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970673
  1664. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970710
  1665. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970747
  1666. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970784
  1667. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970821
  1668. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970896
  1669. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970934
  1670. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970971
  1671. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971008
  1672. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971045
  1673. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971082
  1674. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971119
  1675. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971156
  1676. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971193
  1677. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971230
  1678. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -9 reading relation 99971305
  1679. Thu Jan 26 19:31:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971544
  1680. Thu Jan 26 19:33:47 2017  error -15 reading relation 118254421
  1681. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -9 reading relation 118710093
  1682. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -15 reading relation 118712486
  1683. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -15 reading relation 118714681
  1684. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -15 reading relation 118715852
  1685. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -9 reading relation 118717968
  1686. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718734
  1687. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718773
  1688. Thu Jan 26 19:33:50 2017  error -9 reading relation 118719858
  1689. Thu Jan 26 19:34:14 2017  error -15 reading relation 122210799
  1690. Thu Jan 26 19:35:06 2017  error -15 reading relation 129701885
  1691. Thu Jan 26 19:35:08 2017  error -9 reading relation 130133944
  1692. Thu Jan 26 19:35:15 2017  error -9 reading relation 131455526
  1693. Thu Jan 26 19:35:17 2017  error -9 reading relation 131885884
  1694. Thu Jan 26 19:35:47 2017  error -1 reading relation 137388768
  1695. Thu Jan 26 19:37:27 2017  error -1 reading relation 152337354
  1696. Thu Jan 26 19:37:43 2017  error -15 reading relation 155316846
  1697. Thu Jan 26 19:41:31 2017  error -15 reading relation 187008707
  1698. Thu Jan 26 19:43:43 2017  error -15 reading relation 205569550
  1699. Thu Jan 26 19:44:20 2017  error -9 reading relation 210673655
  1700. Thu Jan 26 19:45:09 2017  error -15 reading relation 217287951
  1701. Thu Jan 26 19:46:21 2017  error -1 reading relation 228881041
  1702. Thu Jan 26 19:46:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 229021968
  1703. Thu Jan 26 19:46:51 2017  error -15 reading relation 232694555
  1704. Thu Jan 26 19:46:55 2017  error -15 reading relation 233364961
  1705. Thu Jan 26 19:47:10 2017  error -15 reading relation 236153836
  1706. Thu Jan 26 19:48:44 2017  error -9 reading relation 251353235
  1707. Thu Jan 26 19:49:07 2017  error -9 reading relation 256124405
  1708. Thu Jan 26 19:49:09 2017  error -15 reading relation 256595253
  1709. Thu Jan 26 19:49:11 2017  error -15 reading relation 256965280
  1710. Thu Jan 26 19:49:11 2017  error -15 reading relation 257033864
  1711. Thu Jan 26 19:49:57 2017  error -15 reading relation 266442272
  1712. Thu Jan 26 19:50:26 2017  error -1 reading relation 272282639
  1713. Thu Jan 26 19:50:40 2017  error -15 reading relation 274526202
  1714. Thu Jan 26 19:53:33 2017  error -15 reading relation 299540640
  1715. Thu Jan 26 19:54:23 2017  error -9 reading relation 306117543
  1716. Thu Jan 26 19:54:24 2017  error -15 reading relation 306329572
  1717. Thu Jan 26 19:54:25 2017  error -15 reading relation 306521623
  1718. Thu Jan 26 19:54:27 2017  error -15 reading relation 306693363
  1719. Thu Jan 26 19:54:27 2017  error -9 reading relation 306704536
  1720. Thu Jan 26 19:54:28 2017  error -15 reading relation 306773193
  1721. Thu Jan 26 19:54:38 2017  error -9 reading relation 308883659
  1722. Thu Jan 26 19:54:41 2017  error -15 reading relation 309379254
  1723. Thu Jan 26 19:54:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 309380105
  1724. Thu Jan 26 19:54:59 2017  error -15 reading relation 313071101
  1725. Thu Jan 26 19:55:32 2017  error -9 reading relation 319053697
  1726. Thu Jan 26 19:55:51 2017  error -1 reading relation 321394982
  1727. Thu Jan 26 19:56:18 2017  error -9 reading relation 326513986
  1728. Thu Jan 26 19:56:34 2017  error -1 reading relation 328842589
  1729. Thu Jan 26 19:56:35 2017  error -15 reading relation 328991100
  1730. Thu Jan 26 19:56:44 2017  error -9 reading relation 330363605
  1731. Thu Jan 26 19:56:44 2017  error -15 reading relation 330446232
  1732. Thu Jan 26 19:56:58 2017  error -1 reading relation 333088633
  1733. Thu Jan 26 19:56:58 2017  error -9 reading relation 333172340
  1734. Thu Jan 26 19:56:58 2017  error -15 reading relation 333172497
  1735. Thu Jan 26 19:57:02 2017  error -9 reading relation 333705063
  1736. Thu Jan 26 19:57:03 2017  error -15 reading relation 333789370
  1737. Thu Jan 26 19:57:08 2017  error -15 reading relation 334671313
  1738. Thu Jan 26 19:57:09 2017  error -1 reading relation 334780823
  1739. Thu Jan 26 19:57:15 2017  error -1 reading relation 335651448
  1740. Thu Jan 26 19:57:19 2017  error -15 reading relation 336160012
  1741. Thu Jan 26 19:57:20 2017  error -1 reading relation 336242728
  1742. Thu Jan 26 19:57:22 2017  error -15 reading relation 336681059
  1743. Thu Jan 26 19:57:46 2017  error -5 reading relation 341735822
  1744. Thu Jan 26 19:57:49 2017  error -15 reading relation 342430620
  1745. Thu Jan 26 19:57:49 2017  error -9 reading relation 342476075
  1746. Thu Jan 26 19:57:51 2017  error -1 reading relation 342759593
  1747. Thu Jan 26 19:57:51 2017  error -15 reading relation 342793786
  1748. Thu Jan 26 19:57:55 2017  error -9 reading relation 343754727
  1749. Thu Jan 26 19:57:56 2017  error -15 reading relation 343822227
  1750. Thu Jan 26 19:58:02 2017  error -9 reading relation 345235511
  1751. Thu Jan 26 19:58:07 2017  skipped 1 relations with b > 2^32
  1752. Thu Jan 26 19:58:07 2017  found 67294299 hash collisions in 346223357 relations
  1753. Thu Jan 26 19:58:38 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 2
  1754. Thu Jan 26 20:01:22 2017  found 60910482 duplicates and 285312875 unique relations
  1755. Thu Jan 26 20:01:22 2017  memory use: 2387.0 MB
  1756. Thu Jan 26 20:01:22 2017  reading ideals above 150011904
  1757. Thu Jan 26 20:01:22 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  1758. Thu Jan 26 20:39:15 2017  memory use: 5512.0 MB
  1759. Thu Jan 26 20:39:15 2017  reading all ideals from disk
  1760. Thu Jan 26 20:39:29 2017  memory use: 4790.3 MB
  1761. Thu Jan 26 20:39:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1762. Thu Jan 26 20:40:01 2017  begin with 285312875 relations and 174534413 unique ideals
  1763. Thu Jan 26 20:42:16 2017  reduce to 242526750 relations and 129697787 ideals in 9 passes
  1764. Thu Jan 26 20:42:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  1765. Thu Jan 26 20:42:33 2017  reading ideals above 720000
  1766. Thu Jan 26 20:42:34 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  1767. Thu Jan 26 21:20:26 2017  memory use: 3012.0 MB
  1768. Thu Jan 26 21:20:27 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  1769. Thu Jan 26 21:22:09 2017  keeping 132564221 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 14021982
  1770. Thu Jan 26 21:23:52 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  1771. Thu Jan 26 21:23:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1772. Thu Jan 26 21:23:58 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 132564221 unique ideals
  1773. Thu Jan 26 21:24:21 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 132564131 ideals in 3 passes
  1774. Thu Jan 26 21:24:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1775. Thu Jan 26 21:25:02 2017  removing 6612611 relations and 4612611 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1776. Thu Jan 26 21:25:05 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1777. Thu Jan 26 21:25:12 2017  begin with 235914049 relations and 132564131 unique ideals
  1778. Thu Jan 26 21:25:58 2017  reduce to 235709098 relations and 127744086 ideals in 6 passes
  1779. Thu Jan 26 21:25:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1780. Thu Jan 26 21:26:37 2017  removing 5469859 relations and 3469859 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1781. Thu Jan 26 21:26:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1782. Thu Jan 26 21:26:46 2017  begin with 230239239 relations and 127744086 unique ideals
  1783. Thu Jan 26 21:27:28 2017  reduce to 230109913 relations and 124143591 ideals in 6 passes
  1784. Thu Jan 26 21:27:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1785. Thu Jan 26 21:28:06 2017  removing 5187561 relations and 3187561 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1786. Thu Jan 26 21:28:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1787. Thu Jan 26 21:28:14 2017  begin with 224922352 relations and 124143591 unique ideals
  1788. Thu Jan 26 21:28:58 2017  reduce to 224819584 relations and 120852267 ideals in 6 passes
  1789. Thu Jan 26 21:28:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1790. Thu Jan 26 21:29:36 2017  removing 5028623 relations and 3028623 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1791. Thu Jan 26 21:29:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1792. Thu Jan 26 21:29:45 2017  begin with 219790961 relations and 120852267 unique ideals
  1793. Thu Jan 26 21:30:19 2017  reduce to 219698623 relations and 117730404 ideals in 5 passes
  1794. Thu Jan 26 21:30:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1795. Thu Jan 26 21:30:55 2017  removing 4910869 relations and 2910869 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1796. Thu Jan 26 21:30:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1797. Thu Jan 26 21:31:03 2017  begin with 214787754 relations and 117730404 unique ideals
  1798. Thu Jan 26 21:31:39 2017  reduce to 214705417 relations and 114736393 ideals in 5 passes
  1799. Thu Jan 26 21:31:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1800. Thu Jan 26 21:32:14 2017  removing 4849549 relations and 2849549 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1801. Thu Jan 26 21:32:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1802. Thu Jan 26 21:32:22 2017  begin with 209855868 relations and 114736393 unique ideals
  1803. Thu Jan 26 21:33:00 2017  reduce to 209780786 relations and 111811010 ideals in 6 passes
  1804. Thu Jan 26 21:33:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1805. Thu Jan 26 21:33:35 2017  removing 4772571 relations and 2772571 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1806. Thu Jan 26 21:33:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1807. Thu Jan 26 21:33:43 2017  begin with 205008215 relations and 111811010 unique ideals
  1808. Thu Jan 26 21:34:15 2017  reduce to 204936429 relations and 108965905 ideals in 5 passes
  1809. Thu Jan 26 21:34:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1810. Thu Jan 26 21:34:47 2017  removing 4716236 relations and 2716236 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1811. Thu Jan 26 21:34:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1812. Thu Jan 26 21:34:55 2017  begin with 200220193 relations and 108965905 unique ideals
  1813. Thu Jan 26 21:35:26 2017  reduce to 200151762 relations and 106180474 ideals in 5 passes
  1814. Thu Jan 26 21:35:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1815. Thu Jan 26 21:35:59 2017  removing 4710020 relations and 2710020 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1816. Thu Jan 26 21:36:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1817. Thu Jan 26 21:36:08 2017  begin with 195441742 relations and 106180474 unique ideals
  1818. Thu Jan 26 21:36:41 2017  reduce to 195379025 relations and 103407061 ideals in 5 passes
  1819. Thu Jan 26 21:36:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1820. Thu Jan 26 21:37:15 2017  removing 4622239 relations and 2622239 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1821. Thu Jan 26 21:37:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1822. Thu Jan 26 21:37:22 2017  begin with 190756786 relations and 103407061 unique ideals
  1823. Thu Jan 26 21:38:03 2017  reduce to 190691694 relations and 100718991 ideals in 7 passes
  1824. Thu Jan 26 21:38:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1825. Thu Jan 26 21:38:33 2017  removing 4644124 relations and 2644124 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1826. Thu Jan 26 21:38:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1827. Thu Jan 26 21:38:40 2017  begin with 186047570 relations and 100718991 unique ideals
  1828. Thu Jan 26 21:39:08 2017  reduce to 185989534 relations and 98016163 ideals in 5 passes
  1829. Thu Jan 26 21:39:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1830. Thu Jan 26 21:39:39 2017  removing 4579719 relations and 2579719 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1831. Thu Jan 26 21:39:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1832. Thu Jan 26 21:39:46 2017  begin with 181409815 relations and 98016163 unique ideals
  1833. Thu Jan 26 21:40:16 2017  reduce to 181350146 relations and 95376075 ideals in 5 passes
  1834. Thu Jan 26 21:40:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1835. Thu Jan 26 21:40:45 2017  removing 4561678 relations and 2561678 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1836. Thu Jan 26 21:40:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1837. Thu Jan 26 21:40:52 2017  begin with 176788468 relations and 95376075 unique ideals
  1838. Thu Jan 26 21:41:20 2017  reduce to 176731326 relations and 92756552 ideals in 5 passes
  1839. Thu Jan 26 21:41:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1840. Thu Jan 26 21:41:48 2017  removing 4532746 relations and 2532746 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1841. Thu Jan 26 21:41:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1842. Thu Jan 26 21:41:54 2017  begin with 172198580 relations and 92756552 unique ideals
  1843. Thu Jan 26 21:42:23 2017  reduce to 172147657 relations and 90172297 ideals in 5 passes
  1844. Thu Jan 26 21:42:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1845. Thu Jan 26 21:42:52 2017  removing 4544432 relations and 2544432 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1846. Thu Jan 26 21:42:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1847. Thu Jan 26 21:42:59 2017  begin with 167603225 relations and 90172297 unique ideals
  1848. Thu Jan 26 21:43:25 2017  reduce to 167554022 relations and 87578122 ideals in 5 passes
  1849. Thu Jan 26 21:43:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1850. Thu Jan 26 21:43:51 2017  removing 4473180 relations and 2473180 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1851. Thu Jan 26 21:43:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1852. Thu Jan 26 21:43:58 2017  begin with 163080842 relations and 87578122 unique ideals
  1853. Thu Jan 26 21:44:22 2017  reduce to 163013544 relations and 85036873 ideals in 5 passes
  1854. Thu Jan 26 21:44:22 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1855. Thu Jan 26 21:44:47 2017  removing 4454494 relations and 2454494 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1856. Thu Jan 26 21:44:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1857. Thu Jan 26 21:44:54 2017  begin with 158559050 relations and 85036873 unique ideals
  1858. Thu Jan 26 21:45:16 2017  reduce to 158496393 relations and 82518953 ideals in 5 passes
  1859. Thu Jan 26 21:45:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1860. Thu Jan 26 21:45:41 2017  removing 4443648 relations and 2443648 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1861. Thu Jan 26 21:45:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1862. Thu Jan 26 21:45:47 2017  begin with 154052745 relations and 82518953 unique ideals
  1863. Thu Jan 26 21:46:11 2017  reduce to 153999451 relations and 80021244 ideals in 5 passes
  1864. Thu Jan 26 21:46:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1865. Thu Jan 26 21:46:37 2017  removing 4466626 relations and 2466626 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1866. Thu Jan 26 21:46:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1867. Thu Jan 26 21:46:43 2017  begin with 149532825 relations and 80021244 unique ideals
  1868. Thu Jan 26 21:47:13 2017  reduce to 149481549 relations and 77502674 ideals in 6 passes
  1869. Thu Jan 26 21:47:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1870. Thu Jan 26 21:47:36 2017  removing 4440829 relations and 2440829 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1871. Thu Jan 26 21:47:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1872. Thu Jan 26 21:47:42 2017  begin with 145040720 relations and 77502674 unique ideals
  1873. Thu Jan 26 21:48:03 2017  reduce to 144994192 relations and 75014707 ideals in 5 passes
  1874. Thu Jan 26 21:48:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1875. Thu Jan 26 21:48:25 2017  removing 4436545 relations and 2436545 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1876. Thu Jan 26 21:48:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1877. Thu Jan 26 21:48:30 2017  begin with 140557647 relations and 75014707 unique ideals
  1878. Thu Jan 26 21:48:52 2017  reduce to 140513110 relations and 72532998 ideals in 5 passes
  1879. Thu Jan 26 21:48:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1880. Thu Jan 26 21:49:13 2017  removing 4366944 relations and 2366944 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1881. Thu Jan 26 21:49:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1882. Thu Jan 26 21:49:18 2017  begin with 136146166 relations and 72532998 unique ideals
  1883. Thu Jan 26 21:49:39 2017  reduce to 136083431 relations and 70102564 ideals in 5 passes
  1884. Thu Jan 26 21:49:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1885. Thu Jan 26 21:50:01 2017  removing 4375604 relations and 2375604 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1886. Thu Jan 26 21:50:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1887. Thu Jan 26 21:50:06 2017  begin with 131707827 relations and 70102564 unique ideals
  1888. Thu Jan 26 21:50:26 2017  reduce to 131650738 relations and 67669140 ideals in 5 passes
  1889. Thu Jan 26 21:50:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1890. Thu Jan 26 21:50:45 2017  removing 4382083 relations and 2382083 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1891. Thu Jan 26 21:50:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1892. Thu Jan 26 21:50:50 2017  begin with 127268655 relations and 67669140 unique ideals
  1893. Thu Jan 26 21:51:09 2017  reduce to 127221497 relations and 65239316 ideals in 5 passes
  1894. Thu Jan 26 21:51:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1895. Thu Jan 26 21:51:28 2017  removing 4381340 relations and 2381340 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1896. Thu Jan 26 21:51:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1897. Thu Jan 26 21:51:33 2017  begin with 122840157 relations and 65239316 unique ideals
  1898. Thu Jan 26 21:51:47 2017  reduce to 122792808 relations and 62810088 ideals in 4 passes
  1899. Thu Jan 26 21:51:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  1900. Thu Jan 26 21:52:04 2017  removing 4332215 relations and 2332215 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1901. Thu Jan 26 21:52:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1902. Thu Jan 26 21:52:09 2017  begin with 118460593 relations and 62810088 unique ideals
  1903. Thu Jan 26 21:52:25 2017  reduce to 118401034 relations and 60417489 ideals in 5 passes
  1904. Thu Jan 26 21:52:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1905. Thu Jan 26 21:52:42 2017  removing 4351404 relations and 2351404 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1906. Thu Jan 26 21:52:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1907. Thu Jan 26 21:52:46 2017  begin with 114049630 relations and 60417489 unique ideals
  1908. Thu Jan 26 21:53:03 2017  reduce to 114002107 relations and 58017959 ideals in 5 passes
  1909. Thu Jan 26 21:53:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1910. Thu Jan 26 21:53:19 2017  removing 4317717 relations and 2317717 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1911. Thu Jan 26 21:53:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1912. Thu Jan 26 21:53:23 2017  begin with 109684390 relations and 58017959 unique ideals
  1913. Thu Jan 26 21:53:38 2017  reduce to 109626692 relations and 55641800 ideals in 5 passes
  1914. Thu Jan 26 21:53:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1915. Thu Jan 26 21:53:53 2017  removing 4310978 relations and 2310978 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1916. Thu Jan 26 21:53:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1917. Thu Jan 26 21:53:58 2017  begin with 105315714 relations and 55641800 unique ideals
  1918. Thu Jan 26 21:54:12 2017  reduce to 105262285 relations and 53276723 ideals in 5 passes
  1919. Thu Jan 26 21:54:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1920. Thu Jan 26 21:54:26 2017  removing 4310244 relations and 2310244 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1921. Thu Jan 26 21:54:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1922. Thu Jan 26 21:54:30 2017  begin with 100952041 relations and 53276723 unique ideals
  1923. Thu Jan 26 21:54:44 2017  reduce to 100888475 relations and 50902078 ideals in 5 passes
  1924. Thu Jan 26 21:54:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1925. Thu Jan 26 21:54:57 2017  removing 4288640 relations and 2288640 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1926. Thu Jan 26 21:54:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1927. Thu Jan 26 21:55:01 2017  begin with 96599835 relations and 50902078 unique ideals
  1928. Thu Jan 26 21:55:14 2017  reduce to 96531048 relations and 48543664 ideals in 5 passes
  1929. Thu Jan 26 21:55:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1930. Thu Jan 26 21:55:27 2017  removing 4262223 relations and 2262223 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1931. Thu Jan 26 21:55:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1932. Thu Jan 26 21:55:30 2017  begin with 92268825 relations and 48543664 unique ideals
  1933. Thu Jan 26 21:55:42 2017  reduce to 92208673 relations and 46220478 ideals in 5 passes
  1934. Thu Jan 26 21:55:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1935. Thu Jan 26 21:55:55 2017  removing 4295142 relations and 2295142 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1936. Thu Jan 26 21:55:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1937. Thu Jan 26 21:55:58 2017  begin with 87913531 relations and 46220478 unique ideals
  1938. Thu Jan 26 21:56:10 2017  reduce to 87837162 relations and 43847859 ideals in 5 passes
  1939. Thu Jan 26 21:56:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  1940. Thu Jan 26 21:56:21 2017  removing 4255141 relations and 2255141 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1941. Thu Jan 26 21:56:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1942. Thu Jan 26 21:56:25 2017  begin with 83582021 relations and 43847859 unique ideals
  1943. Thu Jan 26 21:56:36 2017  reduce to 83515479 relations and 41525237 ideals in 5 passes
  1944. Thu Jan 26 21:56:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1945. Thu Jan 26 21:56:47 2017  removing 4274421 relations and 2274421 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1946. Thu Jan 26 21:56:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1947. Thu Jan 26 21:56:50 2017  begin with 79241058 relations and 41525237 unique ideals
  1948. Thu Jan 26 21:57:00 2017  reduce to 79182252 relations and 39191188 ideals in 5 passes
  1949. Thu Jan 26 21:57:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1950. Thu Jan 26 21:57:10 2017  removing 4285840 relations and 2285840 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1951. Thu Jan 26 21:57:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1952. Thu Jan 26 21:57:13 2017  begin with 74896412 relations and 39191188 unique ideals
  1953. Thu Jan 26 21:57:21 2017  reduce to 74845503 relations and 36853879 ideals in 4 passes
  1954. Thu Jan 26 21:57:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1955. Thu Jan 26 21:57:31 2017  removing 4295305 relations and 2295305 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1956. Thu Jan 26 21:57:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1957. Thu Jan 26 21:57:34 2017  begin with 70550198 relations and 36853879 unique ideals
  1958. Thu Jan 26 21:57:43 2017  reduce to 70473274 relations and 34480556 ideals in 5 passes
  1959. Thu Jan 26 21:57:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  1960. Thu Jan 26 21:57:51 2017  removing 4249429 relations and 2249429 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1961. Thu Jan 26 21:57:53 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1962. Thu Jan 26 21:57:55 2017  begin with 66223845 relations and 34480556 unique ideals
  1963. Thu Jan 26 21:58:03 2017  reduce to 66106872 relations and 32111989 ideals in 5 passes
  1964. Thu Jan 26 21:58:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  1965. Thu Jan 26 21:58:11 2017  removing 4214177 relations and 2214177 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1966. Thu Jan 26 21:58:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1967. Thu Jan 26 21:58:14 2017  begin with 61892695 relations and 32111989 unique ideals
  1968. Thu Jan 26 21:58:21 2017  reduce to 61755028 relations and 29757189 ideals in 5 passes
  1969. Thu Jan 26 21:58:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  1970. Thu Jan 26 21:58:29 2017  removing 4217564 relations and 2217564 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1971. Thu Jan 26 21:58:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1972. Thu Jan 26 21:58:32 2017  begin with 57537464 relations and 29757189 unique ideals
  1973. Thu Jan 26 21:58:40 2017  reduce to 57381853 relations and 27380239 ideals in 6 passes
  1974. Thu Jan 26 21:58:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  1975. Thu Jan 26 21:58:47 2017  removing 4222485 relations and 2222485 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1976. Thu Jan 26 21:58:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1977. Thu Jan 26 21:58:49 2017  begin with 53159368 relations and 27380239 unique ideals
  1978. Thu Jan 26 21:58:56 2017  reduce to 52984063 relations and 24977586 ideals in 5 passes
  1979. Thu Jan 26 21:58:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  1980. Thu Jan 26 21:59:03 2017  removing 4224171 relations and 2224171 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1981. Thu Jan 26 21:59:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1982. Thu Jan 26 21:59:05 2017  begin with 48759892 relations and 24977586 unique ideals
  1983. Thu Jan 26 21:59:11 2017  reduce to 48560283 relations and 22547259 ideals in 5 passes
  1984. Thu Jan 26 21:59:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  1985. Thu Jan 26 21:59:17 2017  removing 4246519 relations and 2246519 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1986. Thu Jan 26 21:59:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1987. Thu Jan 26 21:59:19 2017  begin with 44313764 relations and 22547259 unique ideals
  1988. Thu Jan 26 21:59:26 2017  reduce to 44105989 relations and 20085286 ideals in 6 passes
  1989. Thu Jan 26 21:59:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  1990. Thu Jan 26 21:59:32 2017  removing 4265365 relations and 2265365 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1991. Thu Jan 26 21:59:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1992. Thu Jan 26 21:59:34 2017  begin with 39840624 relations and 20085286 unique ideals
  1993. Thu Jan 26 21:59:38 2017  reduce to 39620796 relations and 17591224 ideals in 5 passes
  1994. Thu Jan 26 21:59:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  1995. Thu Jan 26 21:59:43 2017  removing 4277203 relations and 2277203 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  1996. Thu Jan 26 21:59:44 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  1997. Thu Jan 26 21:59:45 2017  begin with 35343593 relations and 17591224 unique ideals
  1998. Thu Jan 26 21:59:49 2017  reduce to 35114175 relations and 15074392 ideals in 5 passes
  1999. Thu Jan 26 21:59:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2000. Thu Jan 26 21:59:54 2017  removing 4282277 relations and 2282277 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2001. Thu Jan 26 21:59:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2002. Thu Jan 26 21:59:56 2017  begin with 30831898 relations and 15074392 unique ideals
  2003. Thu Jan 26 21:59:59 2017  reduce to 30598547 relations and 12547963 ideals in 6 passes
  2004. Thu Jan 26 21:59:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2005. Thu Jan 26 22:00:03 2017  removing 3826245 relations and 2041161 ideals in 1785084 cliques
  2006. Thu Jan 26 22:00:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2007. Thu Jan 26 22:00:05 2017  begin with 26772302 relations and 12547963 unique ideals
  2008. Thu Jan 26 22:00:07 2017  reduce to 26564401 relations and 10289270 ideals in 5 passes
  2009. Thu Jan 26 22:00:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2010. Thu Jan 26 22:00:11 2017  removing 26070 relations and 16439 ideals in 9631 cliques
  2011. Thu Jan 26 22:00:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2012. Thu Jan 26 22:00:11 2017  begin with 26538331 relations and 10289270 unique ideals
  2013. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  reduce to 26538185 relations and 10272685 ideals in 3 passes
  2014. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2015. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 6324572
  2016. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 13229873
  2017. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 5673341
  2018. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1176044
  2019. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 129395
  2020. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 4107
  2021. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 853
  2022. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 0
  2023. Thu Jan 26 22:00:13 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  2024. Thu Jan 26 22:00:18 2017  reduce to 21658391 relation sets and 5392891 unique ideals
  2025. Thu Jan 26 22:00:18 2017  commencing full merge
  2026. Thu Jan 26 22:00:39 2017  memory use: 643.1 MB
  2027. Thu Jan 26 22:00:40 2017  found 16265500 cycles, need 14022182
  2028. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  weight of 14022182 cycles is about 383500034 (27.35/cycle)
  2029. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  2030. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  1 relations: 6324572
  2031. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  2 relations: 4503070
  2032. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  3 relations: 2367914
  2033. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  4 relations: 825987
  2034. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  5 relations: 639
  2035. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  6 relations: 0
  2036. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  7 relations: 0
  2037. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  8 relations: 0
  2038. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  9 relations: 0
  2039. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  10+ relations: 0
  2040. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  heaviest cycle: 5 relations
  2041. Thu Jan 26 22:00:43 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  2042. Thu Jan 26 22:00:45 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  2043. Thu Jan 26 22:02:29 2017  keeping 133762044 ideals with weight <= 25, target excess is 12824159
  2044. Thu Jan 26 22:04:15 2017  memory use: 5116.3 MB
  2045. Thu Jan 26 22:04:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2046. Thu Jan 26 22:04:21 2017  begin with 242526750 relations and 133762044 unique ideals
  2047. Thu Jan 26 22:04:45 2017  reduce to 242526660 relations and 133761954 ideals in 3 passes
  2048. Thu Jan 26 22:04:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2049. Thu Jan 26 22:05:28 2017  removing 6640878 relations and 4640878 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2050. Thu Jan 26 22:05:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2051. Thu Jan 26 22:05:38 2017  begin with 235885782 relations and 133761954 unique ideals
  2052. Thu Jan 26 22:06:23 2017  reduce to 235681839 relations and 128914670 ideals in 6 passes
  2053. Thu Jan 26 22:06:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2054. Thu Jan 26 22:07:03 2017  removing 5491806 relations and 3491806 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2055. Thu Jan 26 22:07:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2056. Thu Jan 26 22:07:13 2017  begin with 230190033 relations and 128914670 unique ideals
  2057. Thu Jan 26 22:07:57 2017  reduce to 230060542 relations and 125292090 ideals in 6 passes
  2058. Thu Jan 26 22:07:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2059. Thu Jan 26 22:08:39 2017  removing 5184872 relations and 3184872 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2060. Thu Jan 26 22:08:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2061. Thu Jan 26 22:08:48 2017  begin with 224875670 relations and 125292090 unique ideals
  2062. Thu Jan 26 22:09:34 2017  reduce to 224771706 relations and 122002270 ideals in 6 passes
  2063. Thu Jan 26 22:09:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2064. Thu Jan 26 22:10:12 2017  removing 5032596 relations and 3032596 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2065. Thu Jan 26 22:10:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2066. Thu Jan 26 22:10:22 2017  begin with 219739110 relations and 122002270 unique ideals
  2067. Thu Jan 26 22:10:56 2017  reduce to 219647316 relations and 118876985 ideals in 5 passes
  2068. Thu Jan 26 22:10:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2069. Thu Jan 26 22:11:33 2017  removing 4945101 relations and 2945101 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2070. Thu Jan 26 22:11:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2071. Thu Jan 26 22:11:42 2017  begin with 214702215 relations and 118876985 unique ideals
  2072. Thu Jan 26 22:12:15 2017  reduce to 214623736 relations and 115852689 ideals in 5 passes
  2073. Thu Jan 26 22:12:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2074. Thu Jan 26 22:12:51 2017  removing 4828078 relations and 2828078 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2075. Thu Jan 26 22:12:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2076. Thu Jan 26 22:13:00 2017  begin with 209795658 relations and 115852689 unique ideals
  2077. Thu Jan 26 22:13:41 2017  reduce to 209717970 relations and 112946066 ideals in 6 passes
  2078. Thu Jan 26 22:13:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2079. Thu Jan 26 22:14:16 2017  removing 4787913 relations and 2787913 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2080. Thu Jan 26 22:14:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2081. Thu Jan 26 22:14:24 2017  begin with 204930057 relations and 112946066 unique ideals
  2082. Thu Jan 26 22:14:57 2017  reduce to 204856914 relations and 110084299 ideals in 5 passes
  2083. Thu Jan 26 22:14:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2084. Thu Jan 26 22:15:36 2017  removing 4739440 relations and 2739440 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2085. Thu Jan 26 22:15:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2086. Thu Jan 26 22:15:46 2017  begin with 200117474 relations and 110084299 unique ideals
  2087. Thu Jan 26 22:16:20 2017  reduce to 200051683 relations and 107278364 ideals in 5 passes
  2088. Thu Jan 26 22:16:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2089. Thu Jan 26 22:16:55 2017  removing 4684364 relations and 2684364 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2090. Thu Jan 26 22:16:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2091. Thu Jan 26 22:17:03 2017  begin with 195367319 relations and 107278364 unique ideals
  2092. Thu Jan 26 22:17:34 2017  reduce to 195302057 relations and 104528034 ideals in 5 passes
  2093. Thu Jan 26 22:17:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2094. Thu Jan 26 22:18:08 2017  
  2095. Thu Jan 26 22:18:08 2017  
  2096. Thu Jan 26 22:18:08 2017  Msieve v. 1.52 (SVN unknown)
  2097. Thu Jan 26 22:18:08 2017  random seeds: ab4559d3 92e718fa
  2098. Thu Jan 26 22:18:08 2017  factoring 1374250293977900524006825181025041222391785962418349198188752592542556833408706796147779390990626204883096007787340300959668458776589915992783964729160514357520386806570509 (172 digits)
  2099. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
  2100. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  commencing number field sieve (172-digit input)
  2101. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  R0: -1214784946281755925158360658293296
  2102. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  R1: 18303130010379613
  2103. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A0: -23481671787104319711626620457547467037375
  2104. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A1: 1029230367426047271940304894097130
  2105. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A2: 3146916195524283581740271732
  2106. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A3: 123748321202088763083
  2107. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A4: -51331470267154
  2108. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  A5: 519480
  2109. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  skew 8648943.40, size 9.864e-17, alpha -6.365, combined = 2.829e-13 rroots = 5
  2110. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  
  2111. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  commencing relation filtering
  2112. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  setting max relations to 310000000
  2113. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  setting target matrix density to 140.0
  2114. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  estimated available RAM is 15888.6 MB
  2115. Thu Jan 26 22:18:09 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 1
  2116. Thu Jan 26 22:19:39 2017  error -15 reading relation 16802143
  2117. Thu Jan 26 22:20:27 2017  error -15 reading relation 25595384
  2118. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028429
  2119. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -15 reading relation 28028466
  2120. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28029447
  2121. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030449
  2122. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -1 reading relation 28030866
  2123. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28030949
  2124. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034064
  2125. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -15 reading relation 28034102
  2126. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28034900
  2127. Thu Jan 26 22:20:41 2017  error -9 reading relation 28035134
  2128. Thu Jan 26 22:22:30 2017  error -1 reading relation 49162215
  2129. Thu Jan 26 22:22:32 2017  error -15 reading relation 49535773
  2130. Thu Jan 26 22:23:48 2017  error -15 reading relation 64446614
  2131. Thu Jan 26 22:23:53 2017  error -15 reading relation 65376789
  2132. Thu Jan 26 22:24:45 2017  error -1 reading relation 75290332
  2133. Thu Jan 26 22:25:44 2017  error -1 reading relation 86413805
  2134. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99959556
  2135. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99963811
  2136. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964293
  2137. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964330
  2138. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -5 reading relation 99964368
  2139. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99964666
  2140. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99965447
  2141. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -1 reading relation 99965485
  2142. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99966582
  2143. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99967695
  2144. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968437
  2145. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968692
  2146. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968774
  2147. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99968863
  2148. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99968945
  2149. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -5 reading relation 99969029
  2150. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969105
  2151. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969477
  2152. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969561
  2153. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99969920
  2154. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970098
  2155. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970135
  2156. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970374
  2157. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970450
  2158. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970488
  2159. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970525
  2160. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970562
  2161. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970599
  2162. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970636
  2163. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970673
  2164. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970710
  2165. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970747
  2166. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970784
  2167. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970821
  2168. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99970896
  2169. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970934
  2170. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99970971
  2171. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971008
  2172. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971045
  2173. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971082
  2174. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971119
  2175. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971156
  2176. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971193
  2177. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971230
  2178. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 99971305
  2179. Thu Jan 26 22:26:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 99971544
  2180. Thu Jan 26 22:28:26 2017  error -15 reading relation 118254421
  2181. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -9 reading relation 118710093
  2182. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -15 reading relation 118712486
  2183. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -15 reading relation 118714681
  2184. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -15 reading relation 118715852
  2185. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -9 reading relation 118717968
  2186. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718734
  2187. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -1 reading relation 118718773
  2188. Thu Jan 26 22:28:28 2017  error -9 reading relation 118719858
  2189. Thu Jan 26 22:28:48 2017  error -15 reading relation 122210799
  2190. Thu Jan 26 22:29:25 2017  error -15 reading relation 129701885
  2191. Thu Jan 26 22:29:28 2017  error -9 reading relation 130133944
  2192. Thu Jan 26 22:29:35 2017  error -9 reading relation 131455526
  2193. Thu Jan 26 22:29:37 2017  error -9 reading relation 131885884
  2194. Thu Jan 26 22:30:07 2017  error -1 reading relation 137388768
  2195. Thu Jan 26 22:31:26 2017  error -1 reading relation 152337354
  2196. Thu Jan 26 22:31:42 2017  error -15 reading relation 155316846
  2197. Thu Jan 26 22:34:32 2017  error -15 reading relation 187008707
  2198. Thu Jan 26 22:36:07 2017  error -15 reading relation 205569550
  2199. Thu Jan 26 22:36:32 2017  error -9 reading relation 210673655
  2200. Thu Jan 26 22:37:06 2017  error -15 reading relation 217287951
  2201. Thu Jan 26 22:38:01 2017  error -1 reading relation 228881041
  2202. Thu Jan 26 22:38:02 2017  error -15 reading relation 229021968
  2203. Thu Jan 26 22:38:20 2017  error -15 reading relation 232694555
  2204. Thu Jan 26 22:38:23 2017  error -15 reading relation 233364961
  2205. Thu Jan 26 22:38:37 2017  error -15 reading relation 236153836
  2206. Thu Jan 26 22:39:58 2017  error -9 reading relation 251353235
  2207. Thu Jan 26 22:40:22 2017  error -9 reading relation 256124405
  2208. Thu Jan 26 22:40:24 2017  error -15 reading relation 256595253
  2209. Thu Jan 26 22:40:26 2017  error -15 reading relation 256965280
  2210. Thu Jan 26 22:40:27 2017  error -15 reading relation 257033864
  2211. Thu Jan 26 22:41:16 2017  error -15 reading relation 266442272
  2212. Thu Jan 26 22:41:44 2017  error -1 reading relation 272282639
  2213. Thu Jan 26 22:41:55 2017  error -15 reading relation 274526202
  2214. Thu Jan 26 22:44:04 2017  error -15 reading relation 299540640
  2215. Thu Jan 26 22:44:36 2017  error -9 reading relation 306117543
  2216. Thu Jan 26 22:44:37 2017  error -15 reading relation 306329572
  2217. Thu Jan 26 22:44:37 2017  error -15 reading relation 306521623
  2218. Thu Jan 26 22:44:38 2017  error -15 reading relation 306693363
  2219. Thu Jan 26 22:44:38 2017  error -9 reading relation 306704536
  2220. Thu Jan 26 22:44:39 2017  error -15 reading relation 306773193
  2221. Thu Jan 26 22:44:49 2017  error -9 reading relation 308883659
  2222. Thu Jan 26 22:44:52 2017  error -15 reading relation 309379254
  2223. Thu Jan 26 22:44:52 2017  error -9 reading relation 309380105
  2224. Thu Jan 26 22:44:55 2017  found 56730780 hash collisions in 309999892 relations
  2225. Thu Jan 26 22:44:55 2017  commencing duplicate removal, pass 2
  2226. Thu Jan 26 22:46:50 2017  found 50838220 duplicates and 259161672 unique relations
  2227. Thu Jan 26 22:46:50 2017  memory use: 1449.5 MB
  2228. Thu Jan 26 22:46:50 2017  reading ideals above 146997248
  2229. Thu Jan 26 22:46:50 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  2230. Thu Jan 26 23:12:40 2017  memory use: 5512.0 MB
  2231. Thu Jan 26 23:12:42 2017  reading all ideals from disk
  2232. Thu Jan 26 23:12:54 2017  memory use: 4352.4 MB
  2233. Thu Jan 26 23:13:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2234. Thu Jan 26 23:13:20 2017  begin with 259161672 relations and 171089496 unique ideals
  2235. Thu Jan 26 23:14:57 2017  reduce to 210293644 relations and 119337487 ideals in 9 passes
  2236. Thu Jan 26 23:14:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 72
  2237. Thu Jan 26 23:15:09 2017  reading ideals above 720000
  2238. Thu Jan 26 23:15:10 2017  commencing singleton removal, initial pass
  2239. Thu Jan 26 23:42:19 2017  memory use: 3012.0 MB
  2240. Thu Jan 26 23:42:19 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  2241. Thu Jan 26 23:43:45 2017  keeping 123147225 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 12758677
  2242. Thu Jan 26 23:45:17 2017  memory use: 5075.6 MB
  2243. Thu Jan 26 23:45:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2244. Thu Jan 26 23:45:23 2017  begin with 210293649 relations and 123147225 unique ideals
  2245. Thu Jan 26 23:45:50 2017  reduce to 210293385 relations and 123146961 ideals in 4 passes
  2246. Thu Jan 26 23:45:50 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2247. Thu Jan 26 23:46:29 2017  removing 7315109 relations and 5315109 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2248. Thu Jan 26 23:46:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2249. Thu Jan 26 23:46:38 2017  begin with 202978276 relations and 123146961 unique ideals
  2250. Thu Jan 26 23:47:19 2017  reduce to 202713223 relations and 117563349 ideals in 6 passes
  2251. Thu Jan 26 23:47:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2252. Thu Jan 26 23:47:57 2017  removing 5861287 relations and 3861287 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2253. Thu Jan 26 23:48:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2254. Thu Jan 26 23:48:06 2017  begin with 196851936 relations and 117563349 unique ideals
  2255. Thu Jan 26 23:48:46 2017  reduce to 196678838 relations and 113526965 ideals in 6 passes
  2256. Thu Jan 26 23:48:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2257. Thu Jan 26 23:49:24 2017  removing 5520187 relations and 3520187 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2258. Thu Jan 26 23:49:27 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2259. Thu Jan 26 23:49:32 2017  begin with 191158651 relations and 113526965 unique ideals
  2260. Thu Jan 26 23:50:08 2017  reduce to 191016854 relations and 109863476 ideals in 6 passes
  2261. Thu Jan 26 23:50:08 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2262. Thu Jan 26 23:50:42 2017  removing 5341252 relations and 3341252 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2263. Thu Jan 26 23:50:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2264. Thu Jan 26 23:50:50 2017  begin with 185675602 relations and 109863476 unique ideals
  2265. Thu Jan 26 23:51:24 2017  reduce to 185555214 relations and 106400486 ideals in 6 passes
  2266. Thu Jan 26 23:51:24 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2267. Thu Jan 26 23:51:58 2017  removing 5160495 relations and 3160495 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2268. Thu Jan 26 23:52:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2269. Thu Jan 26 23:52:05 2017  begin with 180394719 relations and 106400486 unique ideals
  2270. Thu Jan 26 23:52:40 2017  reduce to 180273132 relations and 103116998 ideals in 6 passes
  2271. Thu Jan 26 23:52:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2272. Thu Jan 26 23:53:14 2017  removing 5135146 relations and 3135146 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2273. Thu Jan 26 23:53:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2274. Thu Jan 26 23:53:22 2017  begin with 175137986 relations and 103116998 unique ideals
  2275. Thu Jan 26 23:53:53 2017  reduce to 175036131 relations and 99878800 ideals in 6 passes
  2276. Thu Jan 26 23:53:53 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2277. Thu Jan 26 23:54:25 2017  removing 4992109 relations and 2992109 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2278. Thu Jan 26 23:54:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2279. Thu Jan 26 23:54:32 2017  begin with 170044022 relations and 99878800 unique ideals
  2280. Thu Jan 26 23:55:04 2017  reduce to 169934326 relations and 96775732 ideals in 6 passes
  2281. Thu Jan 26 23:55:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2282. Thu Jan 26 23:55:35 2017  removing 4983468 relations and 2983468 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2283. Thu Jan 26 23:55:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2284. Thu Jan 26 23:55:41 2017  begin with 164950858 relations and 96775732 unique ideals
  2285. Thu Jan 26 23:56:15 2017  reduce to 164856829 relations and 93697020 ideals in 6 passes
  2286. Thu Jan 26 23:56:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2287. Thu Jan 26 23:56:44 2017  removing 4906071 relations and 2906071 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2288. Thu Jan 26 23:56:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2289. Thu Jan 26 23:56:50 2017  begin with 159950758 relations and 93697020 unique ideals
  2290. Thu Jan 26 23:57:20 2017  reduce to 159852921 relations and 90691800 ideals in 6 passes
  2291. Thu Jan 26 23:57:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2292. Thu Jan 26 23:57:48 2017  removing 4847629 relations and 2847629 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2293. Thu Jan 26 23:57:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2294. Thu Jan 26 23:57:54 2017  begin with 155005292 relations and 90691800 unique ideals
  2295. Thu Jan 26 23:58:17 2017  reduce to 154906240 relations and 87743765 ideals in 5 passes
  2296. Thu Jan 26 23:58:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2297. Thu Jan 26 23:58:44 2017  removing 4835734 relations and 2835734 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2298. Thu Jan 26 23:58:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2299. Thu Jan 26 23:58:50 2017  begin with 150070506 relations and 87743765 unique ideals
  2300. Thu Jan 26 23:59:14 2017  reduce to 149978544 relations and 84814846 ideals in 5 passes
  2301. Thu Jan 26 23:59:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2302. Thu Jan 26 23:59:40 2017  removing 4828062 relations and 2828062 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2303. Thu Jan 26 23:59:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2304. Thu Jan 26 23:59:46 2017  begin with 145150482 relations and 84814846 unique ideals
  2305. Fri Jan 27 00:00:12 2017  reduce to 145061736 relations and 81896846 ideals in 6 passes
  2306. Fri Jan 27 00:00:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2307. Fri Jan 27 00:00:38 2017  removing 4756936 relations and 2756936 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2308. Fri Jan 27 00:00:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2309. Fri Jan 27 00:00:44 2017  begin with 140304800 relations and 81896846 unique ideals
  2310. Fri Jan 27 00:01:12 2017  reduce to 140213096 relations and 79046936 ideals in 6 passes
  2311. Fri Jan 27 00:01:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2312. Fri Jan 27 00:01:38 2017  removing 4744739 relations and 2744739 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2313. Fri Jan 27 00:01:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2314. Fri Jan 27 00:01:43 2017  begin with 135468357 relations and 79046936 unique ideals
  2315. Fri Jan 27 00:02:05 2017  reduce to 135373291 relations and 76205738 ideals in 5 passes
  2316. Fri Jan 27 00:02:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2317. Fri Jan 27 00:02:29 2017  removing 4722413 relations and 2722413 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2318. Fri Jan 27 00:02:31 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2319. Fri Jan 27 00:02:34 2017  begin with 130650878 relations and 76205738 unique ideals
  2320. Fri Jan 27 00:02:56 2017  reduce to 130558563 relations and 73389573 ideals in 6 passes
  2321. Fri Jan 27 00:02:56 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2322. Fri Jan 27 00:03:19 2017  removing 4703171 relations and 2703171 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2323. Fri Jan 27 00:03:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2324. Fri Jan 27 00:03:24 2017  begin with 125855392 relations and 73389573 unique ideals
  2325. Fri Jan 27 00:03:42 2017  reduce to 125765323 relations and 70594911 ideals in 5 passes
  2326. Fri Jan 27 00:03:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2327. Fri Jan 27 00:04:05 2017  removing 4695244 relations and 2695244 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2328. Fri Jan 27 00:04:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2329. Fri Jan 27 00:04:10 2017  begin with 121070079 relations and 70594911 unique ideals
  2330. Fri Jan 27 00:04:29 2017  reduce to 120982888 relations and 67811061 ideals in 5 passes
  2331. Fri Jan 27 00:04:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2332. Fri Jan 27 00:04:52 2017  removing 4674950 relations and 2674950 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2333. Fri Jan 27 00:04:54 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2334. Fri Jan 27 00:04:56 2017  begin with 116307938 relations and 67811061 unique ideals
  2335. Fri Jan 27 00:05:12 2017  reduce to 116225463 relations and 65052336 ideals in 5 passes
  2336. Fri Jan 27 00:05:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2337. Fri Jan 27 00:05:32 2017  removing 4664205 relations and 2664205 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2338. Fri Jan 27 00:05:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2339. Fri Jan 27 00:05:37 2017  begin with 111561258 relations and 65052336 unique ideals
  2340. Fri Jan 27 00:05:52 2017  reduce to 111466006 relations and 62291443 ideals in 5 passes
  2341. Fri Jan 27 00:05:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2342. Fri Jan 27 00:06:12 2017  removing 4570502 relations and 2570502 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2343. Fri Jan 27 00:06:14 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2344. Fri Jan 27 00:06:16 2017  begin with 106895504 relations and 62291443 unique ideals
  2345. Fri Jan 27 00:06:35 2017  reduce to 106758766 relations and 59581707 ideals in 6 passes
  2346. Fri Jan 27 00:06:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2347. Fri Jan 27 00:06:54 2017  removing 4612021 relations and 2612021 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2348. Fri Jan 27 00:06:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2349. Fri Jan 27 00:06:58 2017  begin with 102146745 relations and 59581707 unique ideals
  2350. Fri Jan 27 00:07:15 2017  reduce to 102037074 relations and 56857999 ideals in 6 passes
  2351. Fri Jan 27 00:07:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2352. Fri Jan 27 00:07:34 2017  removing 4614661 relations and 2614661 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2353. Fri Jan 27 00:07:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2354. Fri Jan 27 00:07:38 2017  begin with 97422413 relations and 56857999 unique ideals
  2355. Fri Jan 27 00:07:55 2017  reduce to 97313251 relations and 54132068 ideals in 6 passes
  2356. Fri Jan 27 00:07:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2357. Fri Jan 27 00:08:11 2017  removing 4626291 relations and 2626291 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2358. Fri Jan 27 00:08:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2359. Fri Jan 27 00:08:15 2017  begin with 92686960 relations and 54132068 unique ideals
  2360. Fri Jan 27 00:08:29 2017  reduce to 92574788 relations and 51391342 ideals in 6 passes
  2361. Fri Jan 27 00:08:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2362. Fri Jan 27 00:08:45 2017  removing 4617331 relations and 2617331 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2363. Fri Jan 27 00:08:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2364. Fri Jan 27 00:08:48 2017  begin with 87957457 relations and 51391342 unique ideals
  2365. Fri Jan 27 00:09:00 2017  reduce to 87850572 relations and 48665006 ideals in 5 passes
  2366. Fri Jan 27 00:09:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2367. Fri Jan 27 00:09:15 2017  removing 4609518 relations and 2609518 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2368. Fri Jan 27 00:09:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2369. Fri Jan 27 00:09:19 2017  begin with 83241054 relations and 48665006 unique ideals
  2370. Fri Jan 27 00:09:30 2017  reduce to 83124645 relations and 45936560 ideals in 5 passes
  2371. Fri Jan 27 00:09:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2372. Fri Jan 27 00:09:43 2017  removing 4556458 relations and 2556458 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2373. Fri Jan 27 00:09:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2374. Fri Jan 27 00:09:47 2017  begin with 78568187 relations and 45936560 unique ideals
  2375. Fri Jan 27 00:10:01 2017  reduce to 78417937 relations and 43226483 ideals in 6 passes
  2376. Fri Jan 27 00:10:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2377. Fri Jan 27 00:10:15 2017  removing 4563342 relations and 2563342 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2378. Fri Jan 27 00:10:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2379. Fri Jan 27 00:10:18 2017  begin with 73854595 relations and 43226483 unique ideals
  2380. Fri Jan 27 00:10:28 2017  reduce to 73697529 relations and 40502485 ideals in 5 passes
  2381. Fri Jan 27 00:10:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2382. Fri Jan 27 00:10:40 2017  removing 4611951 relations and 2611951 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2383. Fri Jan 27 00:10:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2384. Fri Jan 27 00:10:43 2017  begin with 69085578 relations and 40502485 unique ideals
  2385. Fri Jan 27 00:10:54 2017  reduce to 68949341 relations and 37751101 ideals in 6 passes
  2386. Fri Jan 27 00:10:54 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  2387. Fri Jan 27 00:11:05 2017  removing 4609280 relations and 2609280 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2388. Fri Jan 27 00:11:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2389. Fri Jan 27 00:11:08 2017  begin with 64340061 relations and 37751101 unique ideals
  2390. Fri Jan 27 00:11:18 2017  reduce to 64171091 relations and 34968729 ideals in 6 passes
  2391. Fri Jan 27 00:11:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  2392. Fri Jan 27 00:11:30 2017  removing 4581642 relations and 2581642 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2393. Fri Jan 27 00:11:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2394. Fri Jan 27 00:11:33 2017  begin with 59589449 relations and 34968729 unique ideals
  2395. Fri Jan 27 00:11:44 2017  reduce to 59395897 relations and 32188164 ideals in 6 passes
  2396. Fri Jan 27 00:11:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  2397. Fri Jan 27 00:11:54 2017  removing 4629161 relations and 2629161 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2398. Fri Jan 27 00:11:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2399. Fri Jan 27 00:11:57 2017  begin with 54766736 relations and 32188164 unique ideals
  2400. Fri Jan 27 00:12:06 2017  reduce to 54561620 relations and 29347647 ideals in 6 passes
  2401. Fri Jan 27 00:12:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2402. Fri Jan 27 00:12:15 2017  removing 4610531 relations and 2610531 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2403. Fri Jan 27 00:12:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2404. Fri Jan 27 00:12:18 2017  begin with 49951089 relations and 29347647 unique ideals
  2405. Fri Jan 27 00:12:27 2017  reduce to 49721195 relations and 26499874 ideals in 7 passes
  2406. Fri Jan 27 00:12:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2407. Fri Jan 27 00:12:36 2017  removing 4664208 relations and 2664208 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2408. Fri Jan 27 00:12:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2409. Fri Jan 27 00:12:38 2017  begin with 45056987 relations and 26499874 unique ideals
  2410. Fri Jan 27 00:12:46 2017  reduce to 44788416 relations and 23557356 ideals in 7 passes
  2411. Fri Jan 27 00:12:46 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
  2412. Fri Jan 27 00:12:55 2017  removing 4691224 relations and 2691224 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2413. Fri Jan 27 00:12:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2414. Fri Jan 27 00:12:57 2017  begin with 40097192 relations and 23557356 unique ideals
  2415. Fri Jan 27 00:13:02 2017  reduce to 39854463 relations and 20614444 ideals in 6 passes
  2416. Fri Jan 27 00:13:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  2417. Fri Jan 27 00:13:09 2017  removing 4794925 relations and 2794925 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2418. Fri Jan 27 00:13:10 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2419. Fri Jan 27 00:13:11 2017  begin with 35059538 relations and 20614444 unique ideals
  2420. Fri Jan 27 00:13:16 2017  reduce to 34835974 relations and 17588359 ideals in 7 passes
  2421. Fri Jan 27 00:13:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2422. Fri Jan 27 00:13:22 2017  removing 4825649 relations and 2825649 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2423. Fri Jan 27 00:13:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2424. Fri Jan 27 00:13:23 2017  begin with 30010325 relations and 17588359 unique ideals
  2425. Fri Jan 27 00:13:27 2017  reduce to 29635055 relations and 14367368 ideals in 6 passes
  2426. Fri Jan 27 00:13:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 13
  2427. Fri Jan 27 00:13:32 2017  removing 1089908 relations and 622287 ideals in 467621 cliques
  2428. Fri Jan 27 00:13:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2429. Fri Jan 27 00:13:33 2017  begin with 28545147 relations and 14367368 unique ideals
  2430. Fri Jan 27 00:13:36 2017  reduce to 28459987 relations and 13657712 ideals in 6 passes
  2431. Fri Jan 27 00:13:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 12
  2432. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 4895659
  2433. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 13812834
  2434. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 8454602
  2435. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1194785
  2436. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 97867
  2437. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 4171
  2438. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 69
  2439. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 0
  2440. Fri Jan 27 00:13:42 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  2441. Fri Jan 27 00:13:48 2017  reduce to 19577238 relation sets and 4774963 unique ideals
  2442. Fri Jan 27 00:13:48 2017  commencing full merge
  2443. Fri Jan 27 00:14:05 2017  memory use: 597.1 MB
  2444. Fri Jan 27 00:14:07 2017  found 14802275 cycles, need 12758877
  2445. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  weight of 12758877 cycles is about 405879444 (31.81/cycle)
  2446. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  2447. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  1 relations: 4895659
  2448. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  2 relations: 3189359
  2449. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  3 relations: 2730531
  2450. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  4 relations: 1734923
  2451. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  5 relations: 208404
  2452. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  6 relations: 1
  2453. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  7 relations: 0
  2454. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  8 relations: 0
  2455. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  9 relations: 0
  2456. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  10+ relations: 0
  2457. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  heaviest cycle: 6 relations
  2458. Fri Jan 27 00:14:09 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  2459. Fri Jan 27 00:14:11 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  2460. Fri Jan 27 00:16:05 2017  keeping 124251161 ideals with weight <= 25, target excess is 11654741
  2461. Fri Jan 27 00:17:57 2017  memory use: 5075.6 MB
  2462. Fri Jan 27 00:17:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2463. Fri Jan 27 00:18:04 2017  begin with 210293649 relations and 124251161 unique ideals
  2464. Fri Jan 27 00:18:36 2017  reduce to 210293385 relations and 124250897 ideals in 4 passes
  2465. Fri Jan 27 00:18:36 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2466. Fri Jan 27 00:19:18 2017  removing 7350682 relations and 5350682 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2467. Fri Jan 27 00:19:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2468. Fri Jan 27 00:19:27 2017  begin with 202942703 relations and 124250897 unique ideals
  2469. Fri Jan 27 00:20:05 2017  reduce to 202679541 relations and 118633625 ideals in 6 passes
  2470. Fri Jan 27 00:20:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2471. Fri Jan 27 00:20:43 2017  removing 5901359 relations and 3901359 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2472. Fri Jan 27 00:20:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2473. Fri Jan 27 00:20:51 2017  begin with 196778182 relations and 118633625 unique ideals
  2474. Fri Jan 27 00:21:32 2017  reduce to 196608319 relations and 114560446 ideals in 6 passes
  2475. Fri Jan 27 00:21:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2476. Fri Jan 27 00:22:09 2017  removing 5536677 relations and 3536677 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2477. Fri Jan 27 00:22:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2478. Fri Jan 27 00:22:17 2017  begin with 191071642 relations and 114560446 unique ideals
  2479. Fri Jan 27 00:23:04 2017  reduce to 190930536 relations and 110881182 ideals in 7 passes
  2480. Fri Jan 27 00:23:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2481. Fri Jan 27 00:23:42 2017  removing 5316515 relations and 3316515 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2482. Fri Jan 27 00:23:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2483. Fri Jan 27 00:23:50 2017  begin with 185614021 relations and 110881182 unique ideals
  2484. Fri Jan 27 00:24:34 2017  reduce to 185488802 relations and 107438103 ideals in 7 passes
  2485. Fri Jan 27 00:24:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2486. Fri Jan 27 00:25:09 2017  removing 5212370 relations and 3212370 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2487. Fri Jan 27 00:25:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2488. Fri Jan 27 00:25:17 2017  begin with 180276432 relations and 107438103 unique ideals
  2489. Fri Jan 27 00:25:45 2017  reduce to 180160812 relations and 104108776 ideals in 5 passes
  2490. Fri Jan 27 00:25:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2491. Fri Jan 27 00:26:18 2017  removing 5095866 relations and 3095866 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2492. Fri Jan 27 00:26:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2493. Fri Jan 27 00:26:25 2017  begin with 175064946 relations and 104108776 unique ideals
  2494. Fri Jan 27 00:26:58 2017  reduce to 174959092 relations and 100905755 ideals in 6 passes
  2495. Fri Jan 27 00:26:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2496. Fri Jan 27 00:27:31 2017  removing 5038749 relations and 3038749 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2497. Fri Jan 27 00:27:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2498. Fri Jan 27 00:27:38 2017  begin with 169920343 relations and 100905755 unique ideals
  2499. Fri Jan 27 00:28:09 2017  reduce to 169816470 relations and 97761894 ideals in 6 passes
  2500. Fri Jan 27 00:28:09 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2501. Fri Jan 27 00:28:40 2017  removing 4964638 relations and 2964638 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2502. Fri Jan 27 00:28:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2503. Fri Jan 27 00:28:46 2017  begin with 164851832 relations and 97761894 unique ideals
  2504. Fri Jan 27 00:29:16 2017  reduce to 164752905 relations and 94697028 ideals in 6 passes
  2505. Fri Jan 27 00:29:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2506. Fri Jan 27 00:29:45 2017  removing 4910126 relations and 2910126 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2507. Fri Jan 27 00:29:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2508. Fri Jan 27 00:29:52 2017  begin with 159842779 relations and 94697028 unique ideals
  2509. Fri Jan 27 00:30:16 2017  reduce to 159743483 relations and 91686321 ideals in 5 passes
  2510. Fri Jan 27 00:30:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2511. Fri Jan 27 00:30:45 2017  removing 4895317 relations and 2895317 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2512. Fri Jan 27 00:30:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2513. Fri Jan 27 00:30:51 2017  begin with 154848166 relations and 91686321 unique ideals
  2514. Fri Jan 27 00:31:20 2017  reduce to 154759239 relations and 88700947 ideals in 6 passes
  2515. Fri Jan 27 00:31:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2516. Fri Jan 27 00:31:49 2017  removing 4818847 relations and 2818847 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2517. Fri Jan 27 00:31:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2518. Fri Jan 27 00:31:55 2017  begin with 149940392 relations and 88700947 unique ideals
  2519. Fri Jan 27 00:32:20 2017  reduce to 149844148 relations and 85784550 ideals in 5 passes
  2520. Fri Jan 27 00:32:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2521. Fri Jan 27 00:32:47 2017  removing 4816803 relations and 2816803 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2522. Fri Jan 27 00:32:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2523. Fri Jan 27 00:32:53 2017  begin with 145027345 relations and 85784550 unique ideals
  2524. Fri Jan 27 00:33:17 2017  reduce to 144935093 relations and 82874183 ideals in 5 passes
  2525. Fri Jan 27 00:33:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2526. Fri Jan 27 00:33:44 2017  removing 4772586 relations and 2772586 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2527. Fri Jan 27 00:33:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2528. Fri Jan 27 00:33:50 2017  begin with 140162507 relations and 82874183 unique ideals
  2529. Fri Jan 27 00:34:11 2017  reduce to 140072509 relations and 80010310 ideals in 5 passes
  2530. Fri Jan 27 00:34:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2531. Fri Jan 27 00:34:38 2017  removing 4743896 relations and 2743896 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2532. Fri Jan 27 00:34:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2533. Fri Jan 27 00:34:44 2017  begin with 135328613 relations and 80010310 unique ideals
  2534. Fri Jan 27 00:35:07 2017  reduce to 135236343 relations and 77172793 ideals in 6 passes
  2535. Fri Jan 27 00:35:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2536. Fri Jan 27 00:35:34 2017  removing 4728559 relations and 2728559 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2537. Fri Jan 27 00:35:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2538. Fri Jan 27 00:35:40 2017  begin with 130507784 relations and 77172793 unique ideals
  2539. Fri Jan 27 00:36:04 2017  reduce to 130416200 relations and 74351212 ideals in 6 passes
  2540. Fri Jan 27 00:36:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2541. Fri Jan 27 00:36:29 2017  removing 4705183 relations and 2705183 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2542. Fri Jan 27 00:36:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2543. Fri Jan 27 00:36:35 2017  begin with 125711017 relations and 74351212 unique ideals
  2544. Fri Jan 27 00:36:53 2017  reduce to 125618099 relations and 71551657 ideals in 5 passes
  2545. Fri Jan 27 00:36:53 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2546. Fri Jan 27 00:37:17 2017  removing 4668930 relations and 2668930 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2547. Fri Jan 27 00:37:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2548. Fri Jan 27 00:37:23 2017  begin with 120949169 relations and 71551657 unique ideals
  2549. Fri Jan 27 00:37:48 2017  reduce to 120852127 relations and 68784145 ideals in 6 passes
  2550. Fri Jan 27 00:37:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2551. Fri Jan 27 00:38:10 2017  removing 4689027 relations and 2689027 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2552. Fri Jan 27 00:38:12 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2553. Fri Jan 27 00:38:15 2017  begin with 116163100 relations and 68784145 unique ideals
  2554. Fri Jan 27 00:38:32 2017  reduce to 116073897 relations and 66004431 ideals in 5 passes
  2555. Fri Jan 27 00:38:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2556. Fri Jan 27 00:38:53 2017  removing 4639677 relations and 2639677 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2557. Fri Jan 27 00:38:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2558. Fri Jan 27 00:38:58 2017  begin with 111434220 relations and 66004431 unique ideals
  2559. Fri Jan 27 00:39:17 2017  reduce to 111343338 relations and 63272389 ideals in 6 passes
  2560. Fri Jan 27 00:39:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2561. Fri Jan 27 00:39:38 2017  removing 4663415 relations and 2663415 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2562. Fri Jan 27 00:39:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2563. Fri Jan 27 00:39:43 2017  begin with 106679923 relations and 63272389 unique ideals
  2564. Fri Jan 27 00:39:59 2017  reduce to 106590883 relations and 60518518 ideals in 5 passes
  2565. Fri Jan 27 00:39:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  2566. Fri Jan 27 00:40:18 2017  removing 4613768 relations and 2613768 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2567. Fri Jan 27 00:40:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2568. Fri Jan 27 00:40:24 2017  begin with 101977115 relations and 60518518 unique ideals
  2569. Fri Jan 27 00:40:41 2017  reduce to 101861296 relations and 57786901 ideals in 6 passes
  2570. Fri Jan 27 00:40:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2571. Fri Jan 27 00:40:59 2017  removing 4577974 relations and 2577974 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2572. Fri Jan 27 00:41:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2573. Fri Jan 27 00:41:03 2017  begin with 97283322 relations and 57786901 unique ideals
  2574. Fri Jan 27 00:41:20 2017  reduce to 97156617 relations and 55079788 ideals in 6 passes
  2575. Fri Jan 27 00:41:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2576. Fri Jan 27 00:41:38 2017  removing 4599031 relations and 2599031 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2577. Fri Jan 27 00:41:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2578. Fri Jan 27 00:41:42 2017  begin with 92557586 relations and 55079788 unique ideals
  2579. Fri Jan 27 00:41:59 2017  reduce to 92442990 relations and 52363836 ideals in 6 passes
  2580. Fri Jan 27 00:41:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2581. Fri Jan 27 00:42:15 2017  removing 4603165 relations and 2603165 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2582. Fri Jan 27 00:42:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2583. Fri Jan 27 00:42:19 2017  begin with 87839825 relations and 52363836 unique ideals
  2584. Fri Jan 27 00:42:33 2017  reduce to 87722180 relations and 49640484 ideals in 6 passes
  2585. Fri Jan 27 00:42:33 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  2586. Fri Jan 27 00:42:48 2017  removing 4608176 relations and 2608176 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2587. Fri Jan 27 00:42:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2588. Fri Jan 27 00:42:52 2017  begin with 83114004 relations and 49640484 unique ideals
  2589. Fri Jan 27 00:43:06 2017  reduce to 82993612 relations and 46909394 ideals in 6 passes
  2590. Fri Jan 27 00:43:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  2591. Fri Jan 27 00:43:20 2017  removing 4606757 relations and 2606757 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2592. Fri Jan 27 00:43:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2593. Fri Jan 27 00:43:24 2017  begin with 78386855 relations and 46909394 unique ideals
  2594. Fri Jan 27 00:43:39 2017  reduce to 78263844 relations and 44176968 ideals in 6 passes
  2595. Fri Jan 27 00:43:39 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  2596. Fri Jan 27 00:43:53 2017  removing 4608048 relations and 2608048 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2597. Fri Jan 27 00:43:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2598. Fri Jan 27 00:43:57 2017  begin with 73655796 relations and 44176968 unique ideals
  2599. Fri Jan 27 00:44:10 2017  reduce to 73526906 relations and 41437109 ideals in 6 passes
  2600. Fri Jan 27 00:44:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  2601. Fri Jan 27 00:44:23 2017  removing 4563925 relations and 2563925 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2602. Fri Jan 27 00:44:25 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2603. Fri Jan 27 00:44:26 2017  begin with 68962981 relations and 41437109 unique ideals
  2604. Fri Jan 27 00:44:38 2017  reduce to 68796409 relations and 38702646 ideals in 6 passes
  2605. Fri Jan 27 00:44:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  2606. Fri Jan 27 00:44:51 2017  removing 4571493 relations and 2571493 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2607. Fri Jan 27 00:44:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2608. Fri Jan 27 00:44:53 2017  begin with 64224916 relations and 38702646 unique ideals
  2609. Fri Jan 27 00:45:05 2017  reduce to 64040157 relations and 35941618 ideals in 7 passes
  2610. Fri Jan 27 00:45:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  2611. Fri Jan 27 00:45:17 2017  removing 4617803 relations and 2617803 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2612. Fri Jan 27 00:45:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2613. Fri Jan 27 00:45:19 2017  begin with 59422354 relations and 35941618 unique ideals
  2614. Fri Jan 27 00:45:29 2017  reduce to 59251427 relations and 33148542 ideals in 6 passes
  2615. Fri Jan 27 00:45:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2616. Fri Jan 27 00:45:40 2017  removing 4638195 relations and 2638195 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2617. Fri Jan 27 00:45:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2618. Fri Jan 27 00:45:43 2017  begin with 54613232 relations and 33148542 unique ideals
  2619. Fri Jan 27 00:45:51 2017  reduce to 54417155 relations and 30308986 ideals in 6 passes
  2620. Fri Jan 27 00:45:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2621. Fri Jan 27 00:46:01 2017  removing 4615672 relations and 2615672 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2622. Fri Jan 27 00:46:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2623. Fri Jan 27 00:46:03 2017  begin with 49801483 relations and 30308986 unique ideals
  2624. Fri Jan 27 00:46:11 2017  reduce to 49558299 relations and 27442371 ideals in 6 passes
  2625. Fri Jan 27 00:46:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2626. Fri Jan 27 00:46:20 2017  removing 4679715 relations and 2679715 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2627. Fri Jan 27 00:46:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2628. Fri Jan 27 00:46:22 2017  begin with 44878584 relations and 27442371 unique ideals
  2629. Fri Jan 27 00:46:31 2017  reduce to 44622972 relations and 24498090 ideals in 7 passes
  2630. Fri Jan 27 00:46:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  2631. Fri Jan 27 00:46:39 2017  removing 4681913 relations and 2681913 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2632. Fri Jan 27 00:46:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2633. Fri Jan 27 00:46:41 2017  begin with 39941059 relations and 24498090 unique ideals
  2634. Fri Jan 27 00:46:48 2017  reduce to 39650821 relations and 21514793 ideals in 7 passes
  2635. Fri Jan 27 00:46:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2636. Fri Jan 27 00:46:56 2017  removing 4760054 relations and 2760054 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2637. Fri Jan 27 00:46:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2638. Fri Jan 27 00:46:58 2017  begin with 34890767 relations and 21514793 unique ideals
  2639. Fri Jan 27 00:47:02 2017  reduce to 34564854 relations and 18414827 ideals in 6 passes
  2640. Fri Jan 27 00:47:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2641. Fri Jan 27 00:47:09 2017  removing 4838126 relations and 2838126 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2642. Fri Jan 27 00:47:10 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2643. Fri Jan 27 00:47:11 2017  begin with 29726728 relations and 18414827 unique ideals
  2644. Fri Jan 27 00:47:15 2017  reduce to 29442566 relations and 15280804 ideals in 7 passes
  2645. Fri Jan 27 00:47:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
  2646. Fri Jan 27 00:47:20 2017  removing 1516948 relations and 874686 ideals in 642262 cliques
  2647. Fri Jan 27 00:47:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2648. Fri Jan 27 00:47:21 2017  begin with 27925618 relations and 15280804 unique ideals
  2649. Fri Jan 27 00:47:25 2017  reduce to 27803896 relations and 14281385 ideals in 6 passes
  2650. Fri Jan 27 00:47:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 14
  2651. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 3997153
  2652. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 12815705
  2653. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 9197504
  2654. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 1596383
  2655. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 184635
  2656. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 12230
  2657. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 284
  2658. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 2
  2659. Fri Jan 27 00:47:31 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  2660. Fri Jan 27 00:47:37 2017  reduce to 18911308 relation sets and 5388797 unique ideals
  2661. Fri Jan 27 00:47:37 2017  commencing full merge
  2662. Fri Jan 27 00:47:56 2017  memory use: 612.9 MB
  2663. Fri Jan 27 00:47:57 2017  found 13522488 cycles, need 11654941
  2664. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  weight of 11654941 cycles is about 417084489 (35.79/cycle)
  2665. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  2666. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  1 relations: 3997153
  2667. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  2 relations: 2507433
  2668. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  3 relations: 2397028
  2669. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  4 relations: 1695994
  2670. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  5 relations: 1055253
  2671. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  6 relations: 2080
  2672. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  7 relations: 0
  2673. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  8 relations: 0
  2674. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  9 relations: 0
  2675. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  10+ relations: 0
  2676. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  heaviest cycle: 6 relations
  2677. Fri Jan 27 00:48:00 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  2678. Fri Jan 27 00:48:01 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  2679. Fri Jan 27 00:49:46 2017  keeping 124994840 ideals with weight <= 30, target excess is 10911062
  2680. Fri Jan 27 00:51:30 2017  memory use: 5075.6 MB
  2681. Fri Jan 27 00:51:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2682. Fri Jan 27 00:51:37 2017  begin with 210293649 relations and 124994840 unique ideals
  2683. Fri Jan 27 00:52:12 2017  reduce to 210293385 relations and 124994576 ideals in 4 passes
  2684. Fri Jan 27 00:52:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2685. Fri Jan 27 00:52:55 2017  removing 7372632 relations and 5372632 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2686. Fri Jan 27 00:52:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2687. Fri Jan 27 00:53:05 2017  begin with 202920753 relations and 124994576 unique ideals
  2688. Fri Jan 27 00:53:47 2017  reduce to 202658505 relations and 119356241 ideals in 6 passes
  2689. Fri Jan 27 00:53:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2690. Fri Jan 27 00:54:26 2017  removing 5919843 relations and 3919843 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2691. Fri Jan 27 00:54:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2692. Fri Jan 27 00:54:35 2017  begin with 196738662 relations and 119356241 unique ideals
  2693. Fri Jan 27 00:55:18 2017  reduce to 196569269 relations and 115265047 ideals in 6 passes
  2694. Fri Jan 27 00:55:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2695. Fri Jan 27 00:55:57 2017  removing 5544479 relations and 3544479 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2696. Fri Jan 27 00:56:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2697. Fri Jan 27 00:56:05 2017  begin with 191024790 relations and 115265047 unique ideals
  2698. Fri Jan 27 00:56:42 2017  reduce to 190883006 relations and 111577242 ideals in 6 passes
  2699. Fri Jan 27 00:56:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2700. Fri Jan 27 00:57:19 2017  removing 5344540 relations and 3344540 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2701. Fri Jan 27 00:57:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2702. Fri Jan 27 00:57:27 2017  begin with 185538466 relations and 111577242 unique ideals
  2703. Fri Jan 27 00:58:10 2017  reduce to 185413607 relations and 108106445 ideals in 7 passes
  2704. Fri Jan 27 00:58:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2705. Fri Jan 27 00:58:45 2017  removing 5200623 relations and 3200623 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2706. Fri Jan 27 00:58:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2707. Fri Jan 27 00:58:53 2017  begin with 180212984 relations and 108106445 unique ideals
  2708. Fri Jan 27 00:59:21 2017  reduce to 180097695 relations and 104789223 ideals in 5 passes
  2709. Fri Jan 27 00:59:21 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2710. Fri Jan 27 00:59:57 2017  removing 5110763 relations and 3110763 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2711. Fri Jan 27 01:00:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2712. Fri Jan 27 01:00:04 2017  begin with 174986932 relations and 104789223 unique ideals
  2713. Fri Jan 27 01:00:43 2017  reduce to 174879171 relations and 101569374 ideals in 6 passes
  2714. Fri Jan 27 01:00:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2715. Fri Jan 27 01:01:18 2017  removing 5049876 relations and 3049876 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2716. Fri Jan 27 01:01:21 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2717. Fri Jan 27 01:01:26 2017  begin with 169829295 relations and 101569374 unique ideals
  2718. Fri Jan 27 01:01:59 2017  reduce to 169731203 relations and 98420253 ideals in 6 passes
  2719. Fri Jan 27 01:01:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2720. Fri Jan 27 01:02:31 2017  removing 4955483 relations and 2955483 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2721. Fri Jan 27 01:02:34 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2722. Fri Jan 27 01:02:40 2017  begin with 164775720 relations and 98420253 unique ideals
  2723. Fri Jan 27 01:03:11 2017  reduce to 164673275 relations and 95360987 ideals in 6 passes
  2724. Fri Jan 27 01:03:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2725. Fri Jan 27 01:03:42 2017  removing 4932600 relations and 2932600 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2726. Fri Jan 27 01:03:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2727. Fri Jan 27 01:03:49 2017  begin with 159740675 relations and 95360987 unique ideals
  2728. Fri Jan 27 01:04:20 2017  reduce to 159647014 relations and 92333496 ideals in 6 passes
  2729. Fri Jan 27 01:04:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2730. Fri Jan 27 01:04:50 2017  removing 4879136 relations and 2879136 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2731. Fri Jan 27 01:04:53 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2732. Fri Jan 27 01:04:58 2017  begin with 154767878 relations and 92333496 unique ideals
  2733. Fri Jan 27 01:05:25 2017  reduce to 154672740 relations and 89357952 ideals in 5 passes
  2734. Fri Jan 27 01:05:25 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2735. Fri Jan 27 01:05:55 2017  removing 4808986 relations and 2808986 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2736. Fri Jan 27 01:05:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2737. Fri Jan 27 01:06:01 2017  begin with 149863754 relations and 89357952 unique ideals
  2738. Fri Jan 27 01:06:29 2017  reduce to 149768015 relations and 86451844 ideals in 6 passes
  2739. Fri Jan 27 01:06:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2740. Fri Jan 27 01:06:58 2017  removing 4831870 relations and 2831870 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2741. Fri Jan 27 01:07:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2742. Fri Jan 27 01:07:04 2017  begin with 144936145 relations and 86451844 unique ideals
  2743. Fri Jan 27 01:07:29 2017  reduce to 144849135 relations and 83531687 ideals in 5 passes
  2744. Fri Jan 27 01:07:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2745. Fri Jan 27 01:07:58 2017  removing 4792771 relations and 2792771 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2746. Fri Jan 27 01:08:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2747. Fri Jan 27 01:08:04 2017  begin with 140056364 relations and 83531687 unique ideals
  2748. Fri Jan 27 01:08:26 2017  reduce to 139966237 relations and 80647561 ideals in 5 passes
  2749. Fri Jan 27 01:08:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2750. Fri Jan 27 01:08:54 2017  removing 4728970 relations and 2728970 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2751. Fri Jan 27 01:08:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2752. Fri Jan 27 01:09:01 2017  begin with 135237267 relations and 80647561 unique ideals
  2753. Fri Jan 27 01:09:27 2017  reduce to 135143902 relations and 77823892 ideals in 6 passes
  2754. Fri Jan 27 01:09:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  2755. Fri Jan 27 01:09:53 2017  removing 4736691 relations and 2736691 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2756. Fri Jan 27 01:09:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2757. Fri Jan 27 01:09:58 2017  begin with 130407211 relations and 77823892 unique ideals
  2758. Fri Jan 27 01:10:18 2017  reduce to 130315883 relations and 74994508 ideals in 5 passes
  2759. Fri Jan 27 01:10:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  2760. Fri Jan 27 01:10:43 2017  removing 4683963 relations and 2683963 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2761. Fri Jan 27 01:10:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2762. Fri Jan 27 01:10:49 2017  begin with 125631920 relations and 74994508 unique ideals
  2763. Fri Jan 27 01:11:15 2017  reduce to 125539491 relations and 72216581 ideals in 6 passes
  2764. Fri Jan 27 01:11:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  2765. Fri Jan 27 01:11:40 2017  removing 4700816 relations and 2700816 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2766. Fri Jan 27 01:11:42 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2767. Fri Jan 27 01:11:45 2017  begin with 120838675 relations and 72216581 unique ideals
  2768. Fri Jan 27 01:12:04 2017  reduce to 120746422 relations and 69422091 ideals in 5 passes
  2769. Fri Jan 27 01:12:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  2770. Fri Jan 27 01:12:27 2017  removing 4663251 relations and 2663251 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2771. Fri Jan 27 01:12:29 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2772. Fri Jan 27 01:12:32 2017  begin with 116083171 relations and 69422091 unique ideals
  2773. Fri Jan 27 01:12:51 2017  reduce to 115986650 relations and 66660725 ideals in 5 passes
  2774. Fri Jan 27 01:12:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  2775. Fri Jan 27 01:13:13 2017  removing 4665658 relations and 2665658 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2776. Fri Jan 27 01:13:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2777. Fri Jan 27 01:13:17 2017  begin with 111320992 relations and 66660725 unique ideals
  2778. Fri Jan 27 01:13:37 2017  reduce to 111226664 relations and 63899147 ideals in 5 passes
  2779. Fri Jan 27 01:13:37 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  2780. Fri Jan 27 01:13:59 2017  removing 4632544 relations and 2632544 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2781. Fri Jan 27 01:14:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2782. Fri Jan 27 01:14:04 2017  begin with 106594120 relations and 63899147 unique ideals
  2783. Fri Jan 27 01:14:20 2017  reduce to 106501613 relations and 61172467 ideals in 5 passes
  2784. Fri Jan 27 01:14:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  2785. Fri Jan 27 01:14:41 2017  removing 4657161 relations and 2657161 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2786. Fri Jan 27 01:14:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2787. Fri Jan 27 01:14:45 2017  begin with 101844452 relations and 61172467 unique ideals
  2788. Fri Jan 27 01:15:00 2017  reduce to 101753069 relations and 58422406 ideals in 5 passes
  2789. Fri Jan 27 01:15:00 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  2790. Fri Jan 27 01:15:18 2017  removing 4611264 relations and 2611264 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2791. Fri Jan 27 01:15:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2792. Fri Jan 27 01:15:23 2017  begin with 97141805 relations and 58422406 unique ideals
  2793. Fri Jan 27 01:15:37 2017  reduce to 97031120 relations and 55698551 ideals in 5 passes
  2794. Fri Jan 27 01:15:37 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  2795. Fri Jan 27 01:15:55 2017  removing 4569727 relations and 2569727 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2796. Fri Jan 27 01:15:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2797. Fri Jan 27 01:16:00 2017  begin with 92461393 relations and 55698551 unique ideals
  2798. Fri Jan 27 01:16:15 2017  reduce to 92330890 relations and 52995758 ideals in 5 passes
  2799. Fri Jan 27 01:16:15 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  2800. Fri Jan 27 01:16:31 2017  removing 4589213 relations and 2589213 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2801. Fri Jan 27 01:16:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2802. Fri Jan 27 01:16:35 2017  begin with 87741677 relations and 52995758 unique ideals
  2803. Fri Jan 27 01:16:49 2017  reduce to 87619316 relations and 50281693 ideals in 5 passes
  2804. Fri Jan 27 01:16:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  2805. Fri Jan 27 01:17:04 2017  removing 4584651 relations and 2584651 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2806. Fri Jan 27 01:17:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2807. Fri Jan 27 01:17:08 2017  begin with 83034665 relations and 50281693 unique ideals
  2808. Fri Jan 27 01:17:22 2017  reduce to 82908884 relations and 47568586 ideals in 6 passes
  2809. Fri Jan 27 01:17:22 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  2810. Fri Jan 27 01:17:37 2017  removing 4608754 relations and 2608754 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2811. Fri Jan 27 01:17:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2812. Fri Jan 27 01:17:41 2017  begin with 78300130 relations and 47568586 unique ideals
  2813. Fri Jan 27 01:17:54 2017  reduce to 78172089 relations and 44828981 ideals in 6 passes
  2814. Fri Jan 27 01:17:54 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
  2815. Fri Jan 27 01:18:07 2017  removing 4602738 relations and 2602738 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2816. Fri Jan 27 01:18:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2817. Fri Jan 27 01:18:10 2017  begin with 73569351 relations and 44828981 unique ideals
  2818. Fri Jan 27 01:18:23 2017  reduce to 73437976 relations and 42091925 ideals in 6 passes
  2819. Fri Jan 27 01:18:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  2820. Fri Jan 27 01:18:36 2017  removing 4614947 relations and 2614947 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2821. Fri Jan 27 01:18:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2822. Fri Jan 27 01:18:39 2017  begin with 68823029 relations and 42091925 unique ideals
  2823. Fri Jan 27 01:18:53 2017  reduce to 68682354 relations and 39332976 ideals in 6 passes
  2824. Fri Jan 27 01:18:53 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2825. Fri Jan 27 01:19:06 2017  removing 4598557 relations and 2598557 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2826. Fri Jan 27 01:19:08 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2827. Fri Jan 27 01:19:10 2017  begin with 64083797 relations and 39332976 unique ideals
  2828. Fri Jan 27 01:19:19 2017  reduce to 63923169 relations and 36569708 ideals in 5 passes
  2829. Fri Jan 27 01:19:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2830. Fri Jan 27 01:19:31 2017  removing 4577451 relations and 2577451 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2831. Fri Jan 27 01:19:33 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2832. Fri Jan 27 01:19:34 2017  begin with 59345718 relations and 36569708 unique ideals
  2833. Fri Jan 27 01:19:44 2017  reduce to 59145836 relations and 33786917 ideals in 6 passes
  2834. Fri Jan 27 01:19:44 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  2835. Fri Jan 27 01:19:54 2017  removing 4611017 relations and 2611017 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2836. Fri Jan 27 01:19:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2837. Fri Jan 27 01:19:57 2017  begin with 54534819 relations and 33786917 unique ideals
  2838. Fri Jan 27 01:20:06 2017  reduce to 54322902 relations and 30957831 ideals in 6 passes
  2839. Fri Jan 27 01:20:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  2840. Fri Jan 27 01:20:16 2017  removing 4661512 relations and 2661512 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2841. Fri Jan 27 01:20:17 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2842. Fri Jan 27 01:20:18 2017  begin with 49661390 relations and 30957831 unique ideals
  2843. Fri Jan 27 01:20:26 2017  reduce to 49452014 relations and 28080714 ideals in 6 passes
  2844. Fri Jan 27 01:20:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
  2845. Fri Jan 27 01:20:35 2017  removing 4671029 relations and 2671029 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2846. Fri Jan 27 01:20:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2847. Fri Jan 27 01:20:37 2017  begin with 44780985 relations and 28080714 unique ideals
  2848. Fri Jan 27 01:20:45 2017  reduce to 44521171 relations and 25141008 ideals in 7 passes
  2849. Fri Jan 27 01:20:45 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  2850. Fri Jan 27 01:20:53 2017  removing 4703182 relations and 2703182 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2851. Fri Jan 27 01:20:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2852. Fri Jan 27 01:20:55 2017  begin with 39817989 relations and 25141008 unique ideals
  2853. Fri Jan 27 01:21:02 2017  reduce to 39524397 relations and 22132895 ideals in 7 passes
  2854. Fri Jan 27 01:21:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
  2855. Fri Jan 27 01:21:09 2017  removing 4735906 relations and 2735906 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2856. Fri Jan 27 01:21:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2857. Fri Jan 27 01:21:12 2017  begin with 34788491 relations and 22132895 unique ideals
  2858. Fri Jan 27 01:21:17 2017  reduce to 34443540 relations and 19036919 ideals in 6 passes
  2859. Fri Jan 27 01:21:17 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  2860. Fri Jan 27 01:21:23 2017  removing 4818646 relations and 2818646 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2861. Fri Jan 27 01:21:25 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2862. Fri Jan 27 01:21:25 2017  begin with 29624894 relations and 19036919 unique ideals
  2863. Fri Jan 27 01:21:30 2017  reduce to 29238986 relations and 15813252 ideals in 7 passes
  2864. Fri Jan 27 01:21:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2865. Fri Jan 27 01:21:35 2017  removing 1842955 relations and 1074053 ideals in 768902 cliques
  2866. Fri Jan 27 01:21:36 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2867. Fri Jan 27 01:21:36 2017  begin with 27396031 relations and 15813252 unique ideals
  2868. Fri Jan 27 01:21:41 2017  reduce to 27229270 relations and 14567262 ideals in 7 passes
  2869. Fri Jan 27 01:21:41 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
  2870. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 3373528
  2871. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 11588443
  2872. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 9656324
  2873. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 2309041
  2874. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 278536
  2875. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 22629
  2876. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 760
  2877. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 9
  2878. Fri Jan 27 01:21:46 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  2879. Fri Jan 27 01:21:53 2017  reduce to 18321561 relation sets and 5659553 unique ideals
  2880. Fri Jan 27 01:21:53 2017  commencing full merge
  2881. Fri Jan 27 01:22:18 2017  memory use: 626.3 MB
  2882. Fri Jan 27 01:22:19 2017  found 12661805 cycles, need 10911262
  2883. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  weight of 10911262 cycles is about 445775083 (40.85/cycle)
  2884. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  2885. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  1 relations: 3373528
  2886. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  2 relations: 2062135
  2887. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  3 relations: 1927887
  2888. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  4 relations: 1573004
  2889. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  5 relations: 1149963
  2890. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  6 relations: 784224
  2891. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  7 relations: 40521
  2892. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  8 relations: 0
  2893. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  9 relations: 0
  2894. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  10+ relations: 0
  2895. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  heaviest cycle: 7 relations
  2896. Fri Jan 27 01:22:21 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  2897. Fri Jan 27 01:22:22 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  2898. Fri Jan 27 01:24:24 2017  keeping 125584727 ideals with weight <= 35, target excess is 10321175
  2899. Fri Jan 27 01:26:20 2017  memory use: 5075.6 MB
  2900. Fri Jan 27 01:26:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2901. Fri Jan 27 01:26:27 2017  begin with 210293649 relations and 125584727 unique ideals
  2902. Fri Jan 27 01:27:01 2017  reduce to 210293385 relations and 125584463 ideals in 4 passes
  2903. Fri Jan 27 01:27:01 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2904. Fri Jan 27 01:27:44 2017  removing 7395151 relations and 5395151 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2905. Fri Jan 27 01:27:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2906. Fri Jan 27 01:27:54 2017  begin with 202898234 relations and 125584463 unique ideals
  2907. Fri Jan 27 01:28:38 2017  reduce to 202637189 relations and 119924838 ideals in 6 passes
  2908. Fri Jan 27 01:28:38 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2909. Fri Jan 27 01:29:17 2017  removing 5927989 relations and 3927989 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2910. Fri Jan 27 01:29:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2911. Fri Jan 27 01:29:26 2017  begin with 196709200 relations and 119924838 unique ideals
  2912. Fri Jan 27 01:30:06 2017  reduce to 196539092 relations and 115824789 ideals in 6 passes
  2913. Fri Jan 27 01:30:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2914. Fri Jan 27 01:30:45 2017  removing 5553233 relations and 3553233 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2915. Fri Jan 27 01:30:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2916. Fri Jan 27 01:30:53 2017  begin with 190985859 relations and 115824789 unique ideals
  2917. Fri Jan 27 01:31:35 2017  reduce to 190844947 relations and 112129090 ideals in 6 passes
  2918. Fri Jan 27 01:31:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2919. Fri Jan 27 01:32:13 2017  removing 5356399 relations and 3356399 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2920. Fri Jan 27 01:32:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2921. Fri Jan 27 01:32:21 2017  begin with 185488548 relations and 112129090 unique ideals
  2922. Fri Jan 27 01:33:10 2017  reduce to 185364790 relations and 108647566 ideals in 7 passes
  2923. Fri Jan 27 01:33:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2924. Fri Jan 27 01:33:47 2017  removing 5207301 relations and 3207301 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2925. Fri Jan 27 01:33:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2926. Fri Jan 27 01:33:55 2017  begin with 180157489 relations and 108647566 unique ideals
  2927. Fri Jan 27 01:34:28 2017  reduce to 180043260 relations and 105324739 ideals in 5 passes
  2928. Fri Jan 27 01:34:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2929. Fri Jan 27 01:35:03 2017  removing 5117486 relations and 3117486 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2930. Fri Jan 27 01:35:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2931. Fri Jan 27 01:35:11 2017  begin with 174925774 relations and 105324739 unique ideals
  2932. Fri Jan 27 01:35:47 2017  reduce to 174818216 relations and 102098395 ideals in 6 passes
  2933. Fri Jan 27 01:35:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2934. Fri Jan 27 01:36:21 2017  removing 5041017 relations and 3041017 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2935. Fri Jan 27 01:36:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2936. Fri Jan 27 01:36:28 2017  begin with 169777199 relations and 102098395 unique ideals
  2937. Fri Jan 27 01:37:02 2017  reduce to 169676271 relations and 98955251 ideals in 6 passes
  2938. Fri Jan 27 01:37:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2939. Fri Jan 27 01:37:36 2017  removing 4966702 relations and 2966702 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2940. Fri Jan 27 01:37:38 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2941. Fri Jan 27 01:37:43 2017  begin with 164709569 relations and 98955251 unique ideals
  2942. Fri Jan 27 01:38:11 2017  reduce to 164608021 relations and 95885670 ideals in 5 passes
  2943. Fri Jan 27 01:38:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2944. Fri Jan 27 01:38:45 2017  removing 4935984 relations and 2935984 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2945. Fri Jan 27 01:38:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2946. Fri Jan 27 01:38:52 2017  begin with 159672037 relations and 95885670 unique ideals
  2947. Fri Jan 27 01:39:23 2017  reduce to 159578774 relations and 92855199 ideals in 6 passes
  2948. Fri Jan 27 01:39:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2949. Fri Jan 27 01:39:54 2017  removing 4869248 relations and 2869248 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2950. Fri Jan 27 01:39:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2951. Fri Jan 27 01:40:01 2017  begin with 154709526 relations and 92855199 unique ideals
  2952. Fri Jan 27 01:40:32 2017  reduce to 154614225 relations and 89889394 ideals in 6 passes
  2953. Fri Jan 27 01:40:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2954. Fri Jan 27 01:41:02 2017  removing 4859242 relations and 2859242 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2955. Fri Jan 27 01:41:04 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2956. Fri Jan 27 01:41:08 2017  begin with 149754983 relations and 89889394 unique ideals
  2957. Fri Jan 27 01:41:32 2017  reduce to 149665380 relations and 86939306 ideals in 5 passes
  2958. Fri Jan 27 01:41:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2959. Fri Jan 27 01:42:01 2017  removing 4792389 relations and 2792389 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2960. Fri Jan 27 01:42:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2961. Fri Jan 27 01:42:07 2017  begin with 144872991 relations and 86939306 unique ideals
  2962. Fri Jan 27 01:42:31 2017  reduce to 144778903 relations and 84051454 ideals in 5 passes
  2963. Fri Jan 27 01:42:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2964. Fri Jan 27 01:43:00 2017  removing 4785326 relations and 2785326 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2965. Fri Jan 27 01:43:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2966. Fri Jan 27 01:43:06 2017  begin with 139993577 relations and 84051454 unique ideals
  2967. Fri Jan 27 01:43:32 2017  reduce to 139901316 relations and 81172545 ideals in 6 passes
  2968. Fri Jan 27 01:43:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2969. Fri Jan 27 01:43:59 2017  removing 4761239 relations and 2761239 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2970. Fri Jan 27 01:44:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2971. Fri Jan 27 01:44:05 2017  begin with 135140077 relations and 81172545 unique ideals
  2972. Fri Jan 27 01:44:32 2017  reduce to 135050422 relations and 78320273 ideals in 6 passes
  2973. Fri Jan 27 01:44:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  2974. Fri Jan 27 01:44:58 2017  removing 4713346 relations and 2713346 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2975. Fri Jan 27 01:45:00 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2976. Fri Jan 27 01:45:04 2017  begin with 130337076 relations and 78320273 unique ideals
  2977. Fri Jan 27 01:45:31 2017  reduce to 130244990 relations and 75513433 ideals in 6 passes
  2978. Fri Jan 27 01:45:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 34
  2979. Fri Jan 27 01:45:59 2017  removing 4717301 relations and 2717301 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2980. Fri Jan 27 01:46:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2981. Fri Jan 27 01:46:05 2017  begin with 125527689 relations and 75513433 unique ideals
  2982. Fri Jan 27 01:46:31 2017  reduce to 125435952 relations and 72702869 ideals in 6 passes
  2983. Fri Jan 27 01:46:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  2984. Fri Jan 27 01:46:56 2017  removing 4675217 relations and 2675217 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2985. Fri Jan 27 01:46:59 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2986. Fri Jan 27 01:47:02 2017  begin with 120760735 relations and 72702869 unique ideals
  2987. Fri Jan 27 01:47:23 2017  reduce to 120667418 relations and 69932826 ideals in 5 passes
  2988. Fri Jan 27 01:47:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  2989. Fri Jan 27 01:47:45 2017  removing 4675644 relations and 2675644 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2990. Fri Jan 27 01:47:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2991. Fri Jan 27 01:47:50 2017  begin with 115991774 relations and 69932826 unique ideals
  2992. Fri Jan 27 01:48:11 2017  reduce to 115897837 relations and 67161652 ideals in 6 passes
  2993. Fri Jan 27 01:48:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  2994. Fri Jan 27 01:48:33 2017  removing 4653072 relations and 2653072 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  2995. Fri Jan 27 01:48:35 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  2996. Fri Jan 27 01:48:38 2017  begin with 111244765 relations and 67161652 unique ideals
  2997. Fri Jan 27 01:48:58 2017  reduce to 111147137 relations and 64409403 ideals in 6 passes
  2998. Fri Jan 27 01:48:58 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  2999. Fri Jan 27 01:49:20 2017  removing 4647047 relations and 2647047 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3000. Fri Jan 27 01:49:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3001. Fri Jan 27 01:49:25 2017  begin with 106500090 relations and 64409403 unique ideals
  3002. Fri Jan 27 01:49:47 2017  reduce to 106401925 relations and 61662488 ideals in 6 passes
  3003. Fri Jan 27 01:49:47 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 32
  3004. Fri Jan 27 01:50:09 2017  removing 4615830 relations and 2615830 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3005. Fri Jan 27 01:50:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3006. Fri Jan 27 01:50:14 2017  begin with 101786095 relations and 61662488 unique ideals
  3007. Fri Jan 27 01:50:32 2017  reduce to 101688085 relations and 58946890 ideals in 6 passes
  3008. Fri Jan 27 01:50:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 32
  3009. Fri Jan 27 01:50:51 2017  removing 4643604 relations and 2643604 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3010. Fri Jan 27 01:50:53 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3011. Fri Jan 27 01:50:55 2017  begin with 97044481 relations and 58946890 unique ideals
  3012. Fri Jan 27 01:51:12 2017  reduce to 96948736 relations and 56205836 ideals in 6 passes
  3013. Fri Jan 27 01:51:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 31
  3014. Fri Jan 27 01:51:30 2017  removing 4611744 relations and 2611744 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3015. Fri Jan 27 01:51:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3016. Fri Jan 27 01:51:34 2017  begin with 92336992 relations and 56205836 unique ideals
  3017. Fri Jan 27 01:51:51 2017  reduce to 92227883 relations and 53483049 ideals in 6 passes
  3018. Fri Jan 27 01:51:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  3019. Fri Jan 27 01:52:08 2017  removing 4568084 relations and 2568084 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3020. Fri Jan 27 01:52:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3021. Fri Jan 27 01:52:12 2017  begin with 87659799 relations and 53483049 unique ideals
  3022. Fri Jan 27 01:52:27 2017  reduce to 87525975 relations and 50778454 ideals in 6 passes
  3023. Fri Jan 27 01:52:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  3024. Fri Jan 27 01:52:43 2017  removing 4585022 relations and 2585022 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3025. Fri Jan 27 01:52:45 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3026. Fri Jan 27 01:52:47 2017  begin with 82940953 relations and 50778454 unique ideals
  3027. Fri Jan 27 01:53:02 2017  reduce to 82810433 relations and 48060116 ideals in 6 passes
  3028. Fri Jan 27 01:53:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  3029. Fri Jan 27 01:53:17 2017  removing 4582075 relations and 2582075 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3030. Fri Jan 27 01:53:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3031. Fri Jan 27 01:53:21 2017  begin with 78228358 relations and 48060116 unique ideals
  3032. Fri Jan 27 01:53:35 2017  reduce to 78095482 relations and 45342178 ideals in 6 passes
  3033. Fri Jan 27 01:53:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  3034. Fri Jan 27 01:53:49 2017  removing 4598701 relations and 2598701 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3035. Fri Jan 27 01:53:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3036. Fri Jan 27 01:53:53 2017  begin with 73496781 relations and 45342178 unique ideals
  3037. Fri Jan 27 01:54:05 2017  reduce to 73357509 relations and 42601024 ideals in 6 passes
  3038. Fri Jan 27 01:54:05 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3039. Fri Jan 27 01:54:19 2017  removing 4605502 relations and 2605502 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3040. Fri Jan 27 01:54:20 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3041. Fri Jan 27 01:54:22 2017  begin with 68752007 relations and 42601024 unique ideals
  3042. Fri Jan 27 01:54:35 2017  reduce to 68605720 relations and 39845748 ideals in 6 passes
  3043. Fri Jan 27 01:54:35 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3044. Fri Jan 27 01:54:48 2017  removing 4610767 relations and 2610767 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3045. Fri Jan 27 01:54:50 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3046. Fri Jan 27 01:54:51 2017  begin with 63994953 relations and 39845748 unique ideals
  3047. Fri Jan 27 01:55:02 2017  reduce to 63841635 relations and 37077890 ideals in 6 passes
  3048. Fri Jan 27 01:55:02 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3049. Fri Jan 27 01:55:14 2017  removing 4625142 relations and 2625142 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3050. Fri Jan 27 01:55:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3051. Fri Jan 27 01:55:17 2017  begin with 59216493 relations and 37077890 unique ideals
  3052. Fri Jan 27 01:55:28 2017  reduce to 59051277 relations and 34283287 ideals in 6 passes
  3053. Fri Jan 27 01:55:28 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3054. Fri Jan 27 01:55:39 2017  removing 4604998 relations and 2604998 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3055. Fri Jan 27 01:55:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3056. Fri Jan 27 01:55:42 2017  begin with 54446279 relations and 34283287 unique ideals
  3057. Fri Jan 27 01:55:51 2017  reduce to 54238787 relations and 31464797 ideals in 6 passes
  3058. Fri Jan 27 01:55:51 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  3059. Fri Jan 27 01:56:01 2017  removing 4616951 relations and 2616951 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3060. Fri Jan 27 01:56:02 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3061. Fri Jan 27 01:56:03 2017  begin with 49621836 relations and 31464797 unique ideals
  3062. Fri Jan 27 01:56:11 2017  reduce to 49374489 relations and 28592682 ideals in 6 passes
  3063. Fri Jan 27 01:56:11 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  3064. Fri Jan 27 01:56:21 2017  removing 4678490 relations and 2678490 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3065. Fri Jan 27 01:56:22 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3066. Fri Jan 27 01:56:23 2017  begin with 44695999 relations and 28592682 unique ideals
  3067. Fri Jan 27 01:56:31 2017  reduce to 44448152 relations and 25658135 ideals in 7 passes
  3068. Fri Jan 27 01:56:31 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
  3069. Fri Jan 27 01:56:40 2017  removing 4722971 relations and 2722971 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3070. Fri Jan 27 01:56:41 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3071. Fri Jan 27 01:56:42 2017  begin with 39725181 relations and 25658135 unique ideals
  3072. Fri Jan 27 01:56:48 2017  reduce to 39440083 relations and 22639526 ideals in 6 passes
  3073. Fri Jan 27 01:56:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  3074. Fri Jan 27 01:56:55 2017  removing 4754700 relations and 2754700 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3075. Fri Jan 27 01:56:57 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3076. Fri Jan 27 01:56:57 2017  begin with 34685383 relations and 22639526 unique ideals
  3077. Fri Jan 27 01:57:03 2017  reduce to 34345891 relations and 19530666 ideals in 7 passes
  3078. Fri Jan 27 01:57:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  3079. Fri Jan 27 01:57:10 2017  removing 4796267 relations and 2796267 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3080. Fri Jan 27 01:57:11 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3081. Fri Jan 27 01:57:12 2017  begin with 29549624 relations and 19530666 unique ideals
  3082. Fri Jan 27 01:57:16 2017  reduce to 29141852 relations and 16306196 ideals in 7 passes
  3083. Fri Jan 27 01:57:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  3084. Fri Jan 27 01:57:22 2017  removing 2094545 relations and 1231453 ideals in 863092 cliques
  3085. Fri Jan 27 01:57:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3086. Fri Jan 27 01:57:24 2017  begin with 27047307 relations and 16306196 unique ideals
  3087. Fri Jan 27 01:57:27 2017  reduce to 26850569 relations and 14871272 ideals in 6 passes
  3088. Fri Jan 27 01:57:27 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
  3089. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 2879031
  3090. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 10586271
  3091. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 9976474
  3092. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 2953381
  3093. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 412809
  3094. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 40596
  3095. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 1965
  3096. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 42
  3097. Fri Jan 27 01:57:34 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  3098. Fri Jan 27 01:57:40 2017  reduce to 18090151 relation sets and 6110854 unique ideals
  3099. Fri Jan 27 01:57:40 2017  commencing full merge
  3100. Fri Jan 27 01:58:08 2017  memory use: 653.8 MB
  3101. Fri Jan 27 01:58:09 2017  found 11978009 cycles, need 10321375
  3102. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  weight of 10321375 cycles is about 483068180 (46.80/cycle)
  3103. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  3104. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  1 relations: 2879031
  3105. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  2 relations: 1721995
  3106. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  3 relations: 1581588
  3107. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  4 relations: 1380210
  3108. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  5 relations: 1143939
  3109. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  6 relations: 848066
  3110. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  7 relations: 617519
  3111. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  8 relations: 149023
  3112. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  9 relations: 4
  3113. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  10+ relations: 0
  3114. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  heaviest cycle: 9 relations
  3115. Fri Jan 27 01:58:11 2017  matrix not dense enough, retrying
  3116. Fri Jan 27 01:58:13 2017  reading large ideals from disk
  3117. Fri Jan 27 01:59:59 2017  keeping 126190562 ideals with weight <= 40, target excess is 9715340
  3118. Fri Jan 27 02:01:51 2017  memory use: 5075.6 MB
  3119. Fri Jan 27 02:01:51 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3120. Fri Jan 27 02:02:00 2017  begin with 210293649 relations and 126190562 unique ideals
  3121. Fri Jan 27 02:02:34 2017  reduce to 210293385 relations and 126190298 ideals in 4 passes
  3122. Fri Jan 27 02:02:34 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3123. Fri Jan 27 02:03:21 2017  removing 7419885 relations and 5419885 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3124. Fri Jan 27 02:03:24 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3125. Fri Jan 27 02:03:31 2017  begin with 202873500 relations and 126190298 unique ideals
  3126. Fri Jan 27 02:04:16 2017  reduce to 202613179 relations and 120506715 ideals in 6 passes
  3127. Fri Jan 27 02:04:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3128. Fri Jan 27 02:04:59 2017  removing 5934645 relations and 3934645 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3129. Fri Jan 27 02:05:03 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3130. Fri Jan 27 02:05:09 2017  begin with 196678534 relations and 120506715 unique ideals
  3131. Fri Jan 27 02:05:49 2017  reduce to 196508645 relations and 116400242 ideals in 6 passes
  3132. Fri Jan 27 02:05:49 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3133. Fri Jan 27 02:06:29 2017  removing 5554494 relations and 3554494 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3134. Fri Jan 27 02:06:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3135. Fri Jan 27 02:06:38 2017  begin with 190954151 relations and 116400242 unique ideals
  3136. Fri Jan 27 02:07:20 2017  reduce to 190813129 relations and 112703222 ideals in 6 passes
  3137. Fri Jan 27 02:07:20 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3138. Fri Jan 27 02:07:58 2017  removing 5364329 relations and 3364329 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3139. Fri Jan 27 02:08:01 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3140. Fri Jan 27 02:08:06 2017  begin with 185448800 relations and 112703222 unique ideals
  3141. Fri Jan 27 02:08:43 2017  reduce to 185325335 relations and 109214100 ideals in 6 passes
  3142. Fri Jan 27 02:08:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3143. Fri Jan 27 02:09:20 2017  removing 5220045 relations and 3220045 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3144. Fri Jan 27 02:09:23 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3145. Fri Jan 27 02:09:28 2017  begin with 180105290 relations and 109214100 unique ideals
  3146. Fri Jan 27 02:09:59 2017  reduce to 179992737 relations and 105880248 ideals in 5 passes
  3147. Fri Jan 27 02:09:59 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3148. Fri Jan 27 02:10:34 2017  removing 5116141 relations and 3116141 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3149. Fri Jan 27 02:10:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3150. Fri Jan 27 02:10:43 2017  begin with 174876596 relations and 105880248 unique ideals
  3151. Fri Jan 27 02:11:18 2017  reduce to 174768325 relations and 102654505 ideals in 6 passes
  3152. Fri Jan 27 02:11:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3153. Fri Jan 27 02:11:52 2017  removing 5047839 relations and 3047839 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3154. Fri Jan 27 02:11:55 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3155. Fri Jan 27 02:12:00 2017  begin with 169720486 relations and 102654505 unique ideals
  3156. Fri Jan 27 02:12:33 2017  reduce to 169618673 relations and 99503658 ideals in 6 passes
  3157. Fri Jan 27 02:12:33 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3158. Fri Jan 27 02:13:06 2017  removing 4973115 relations and 2973115 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3159. Fri Jan 27 02:13:09 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3160. Fri Jan 27 02:13:14 2017  begin with 164645558 relations and 99503658 unique ideals
  3161. Fri Jan 27 02:13:40 2017  reduce to 164544632 relations and 96428361 ideals in 5 passes
  3162. Fri Jan 27 02:13:40 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3163. Fri Jan 27 02:14:12 2017  removing 4930597 relations and 2930597 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3164. Fri Jan 27 02:14:15 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3165. Fri Jan 27 02:14:19 2017  begin with 159614035 relations and 96428361 unique ideals
  3166. Fri Jan 27 02:14:57 2017  reduce to 159519167 relations and 93401689 ideals in 6 passes
  3167. Fri Jan 27 02:14:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3168. Fri Jan 27 02:15:28 2017  removing 4888333 relations and 2888333 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3169. Fri Jan 27 02:15:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3170. Fri Jan 27 02:15:35 2017  begin with 154630834 relations and 93401689 unique ideals
  3171. Fri Jan 27 02:16:06 2017  reduce to 154538241 relations and 90419561 ideals in 6 passes
  3172. Fri Jan 27 02:16:06 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 40
  3173. Fri Jan 27 02:16:36 2017  removing 4851895 relations and 2851895 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3174. Fri Jan 27 02:16:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3175. Fri Jan 27 02:16:43 2017  begin with 149686346 relations and 90419561 unique ideals
  3176. Fri Jan 27 02:17:12 2017  reduce to 149594819 relations and 87474860 ideals in 6 passes
  3177. Fri Jan 27 02:17:12 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  3178. Fri Jan 27 02:17:43 2017  removing 4797669 relations and 2797669 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3179. Fri Jan 27 02:17:46 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3180. Fri Jan 27 02:17:51 2017  begin with 144797150 relations and 87474860 unique ideals
  3181. Fri Jan 27 02:18:16 2017  reduce to 144702939 relations and 84581665 ideals in 5 passes
  3182. Fri Jan 27 02:18:16 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  3183. Fri Jan 27 02:18:45 2017  removing 4788963 relations and 2788963 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3184. Fri Jan 27 02:18:47 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3185. Fri Jan 27 02:18:51 2017  begin with 139913976 relations and 84581665 unique ideals
  3186. Fri Jan 27 02:19:18 2017  reduce to 139824910 relations and 81702334 ideals in 6 passes
  3187. Fri Jan 27 02:19:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 39
  3188. Fri Jan 27 02:19:46 2017  removing 4764851 relations and 2764851 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3189. Fri Jan 27 02:19:48 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3190. Fri Jan 27 02:19:52 2017  begin with 135060059 relations and 81702334 unique ideals
  3191. Fri Jan 27 02:20:14 2017  reduce to 134970172 relations and 78846223 ideals in 5 passes
  3192. Fri Jan 27 02:20:14 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 38
  3193. Fri Jan 27 02:20:41 2017  removing 4706726 relations and 2706726 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3194. Fri Jan 27 02:20:43 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3195. Fri Jan 27 02:20:47 2017  begin with 130263446 relations and 78846223 unique ideals
  3196. Fri Jan 27 02:21:13 2017  reduce to 130171571 relations and 76046211 ideals in 6 passes
  3197. Fri Jan 27 02:21:13 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 38
  3198. Fri Jan 27 02:21:38 2017  removing 4718526 relations and 2718526 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3199. Fri Jan 27 02:21:40 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3200. Fri Jan 27 02:21:44 2017  begin with 125453045 relations and 76046211 unique ideals
  3201. Fri Jan 27 02:22:10 2017  reduce to 125361694 relations and 73234817 ideals in 6 passes
  3202. Fri Jan 27 02:22:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 38
  3203. Fri Jan 27 02:22:35 2017  removing 4703885 relations and 2703885 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3204. Fri Jan 27 02:22:37 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3205. Fri Jan 27 02:22:41 2017  begin with 120657809 relations and 73234817 unique ideals
  3206. Fri Jan 27 02:23:03 2017  reduce to 120567063 relations and 70438737 ideals in 6 passes
  3207. Fri Jan 27 02:23:03 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 37
  3208. Fri Jan 27 02:23:26 2017  removing 4656477 relations and 2656477 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3209. Fri Jan 27 02:23:28 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3210. Fri Jan 27 02:23:31 2017  begin with 115910586 relations and 70438737 unique ideals
  3211. Fri Jan 27 02:23:53 2017  reduce to 115816940 relations and 67687079 ideals in 6 passes
  3212. Fri Jan 27 02:23:53 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 37
  3213. Fri Jan 27 02:24:16 2017  removing 4661485 relations and 2661485 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3214. Fri Jan 27 02:24:18 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3215. Fri Jan 27 02:24:21 2017  begin with 111155455 relations and 67687079 unique ideals
  3216. Fri Jan 27 02:24:42 2017  reduce to 111059752 relations and 64928235 ideals in 6 passes
  3217. Fri Jan 27 02:24:42 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 36
  3218. Fri Jan 27 02:25:04 2017  removing 4636948 relations and 2636948 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3219. Fri Jan 27 02:25:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3220. Fri Jan 27 02:25:10 2017  begin with 106422804 relations and 64928235 unique ideals
  3221. Fri Jan 27 02:25:29 2017  reduce to 106322748 relations and 62189563 ideals in 6 passes
  3222. Fri Jan 27 02:25:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  3223. Fri Jan 27 02:25:50 2017  removing 4630571 relations and 2630571 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3224. Fri Jan 27 02:25:52 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3225. Fri Jan 27 02:25:55 2017  begin with 101692177 relations and 62189563 unique ideals
  3226. Fri Jan 27 02:26:10 2017  reduce to 101588801 relations and 59453783 ideals in 5 passes
  3227. Fri Jan 27 02:26:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  3228. Fri Jan 27 02:26:30 2017  removing 4614667 relations and 2614667 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3229. Fri Jan 27 02:26:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3230. Fri Jan 27 02:26:35 2017  begin with 96974134 relations and 59453783 unique ideals
  3231. Fri Jan 27 02:26:55 2017  reduce to 96872846 relations and 56736028 ideals in 6 passes
  3232. Fri Jan 27 02:26:55 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 35
  3233. Fri Jan 27 02:27:14 2017  removing 4618397 relations and 2618397 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3234. Fri Jan 27 02:27:16 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3235. Fri Jan 27 02:27:18 2017  begin with 92254449 relations and 56736028 unique ideals
  3236. Fri Jan 27 02:27:32 2017  reduce to 92150488 relations and 54011790 ideals in 5 passes
  3237. Fri Jan 27 02:27:32 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 33
  3238. Fri Jan 27 02:27:50 2017  removing 4617224 relations and 2617224 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3239. Fri Jan 27 02:27:53 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3240. Fri Jan 27 02:27:55 2017  begin with 87533264 relations and 54011790 unique ideals
  3241. Fri Jan 27 02:28:10 2017  reduce to 87426513 relations and 51285792 ideals in 5 passes
  3242. Fri Jan 27 02:28:10 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 32
  3243. Fri Jan 27 02:28:28 2017  removing 4561875 relations and 2561875 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3244. Fri Jan 27 02:28:30 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3245. Fri Jan 27 02:28:33 2017  begin with 82864638 relations and 51285792 unique ideals
  3246. Fri Jan 27 02:28:48 2017  reduce to 82723512 relations and 48579922 ideals in 6 passes
  3247. Fri Jan 27 02:28:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 32
  3248. Fri Jan 27 02:29:04 2017  removing 4580212 relations and 2580212 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3249. Fri Jan 27 02:29:06 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3250. Fri Jan 27 02:29:08 2017  begin with 78143300 relations and 48579922 unique ideals
  3251. Fri Jan 27 02:29:23 2017  reduce to 78006273 relations and 45859641 ideals in 6 passes
  3252. Fri Jan 27 02:29:23 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
  3253. Fri Jan 27 02:29:39 2017  removing 4591862 relations and 2591862 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3254. Fri Jan 27 02:29:41 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3255. Fri Jan 27 02:29:43 2017  begin with 73414411 relations and 45859641 unique ideals
  3256. Fri Jan 27 02:29:57 2017  reduce to 73274780 relations and 43124921 ideals in 6 passes
  3257. Fri Jan 27 02:29:57 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
  3258. Fri Jan 27 02:30:11 2017  removing 4587248 relations and 2587248 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3259. Fri Jan 27 02:30:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3260. Fri Jan 27 02:30:14 2017  begin with 68687532 relations and 43124921 unique ideals
  3261. Fri Jan 27 02:30:26 2017  reduce to 68534898 relations and 40381388 ideals in 6 passes
  3262. Fri Jan 27 02:30:26 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
  3263. Fri Jan 27 02:30:40 2017  removing 4619358 relations and 2619358 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3264. Fri Jan 27 02:30:41 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3265. Fri Jan 27 02:30:43 2017  begin with 63915540 relations and 40381388 unique ideals
  3266. Fri Jan 27 02:30:52 2017  reduce to 63756516 relations and 37599029 ideals in 5 passes
  3267. Fri Jan 27 02:30:52 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  3268. Fri Jan 27 02:31:05 2017  removing 4613064 relations and 2613064 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3269. Fri Jan 27 02:31:07 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3270. Fri Jan 27 02:31:08 2017  begin with 59143452 relations and 37599029 unique ideals
  3271. Fri Jan 27 02:31:18 2017  reduce to 58971668 relations and 34809653 ideals in 6 passes
  3272. Fri Jan 27 02:31:18 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
  3273. Fri Jan 27 02:31:30 2017  removing 4639344 relations and 2639344 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3274. Fri Jan 27 02:31:32 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3275. Fri Jan 27 02:31:33 2017  begin with 54332324 relations and 34809653 unique ideals
  3276. Fri Jan 27 02:31:43 2017  reduce to 54142464 relations and 31975165 ideals in 6 passes
  3277. Fri Jan 27 02:31:43 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3278. Fri Jan 27 02:31:54 2017  removing 4661235 relations and 2661235 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3279. Fri Jan 27 02:31:56 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3280. Fri Jan 27 02:31:57 2017  begin with 49481229 relations and 31975165 unique ideals
  3281. Fri Jan 27 02:32:07 2017  reduce to 49274999 relations and 29101457 ideals in 6 passes
  3282. Fri Jan 27 02:32:07 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
  3283. Fri Jan 27 02:32:18 2017  removing 4649454 relations and 2649454 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3284. Fri Jan 27 02:32:19 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3285. Fri Jan 27 02:32:20 2017  begin with 44625545 relations and 29101457 unique ideals
  3286. Fri Jan 27 02:32:29 2017  reduce to 44360784 relations and 26178107 ideals in 7 passes
  3287. Fri Jan 27 02:32:29 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
  3288. Fri Jan 27 02:32:38 2017  removing 4694847 relations and 2694847 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3289. Fri Jan 27 02:32:39 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3290. Fri Jan 27 02:32:40 2017  begin with 39665937 relations and 26178107 unique ideals
  3291. Fri Jan 27 02:32:48 2017  reduce to 39358224 relations and 23163645 ideals in 7 passes
  3292. Fri Jan 27 02:32:48 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
  3293. Fri Jan 27 02:32:56 2017  removing 4780342 relations and 2780342 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3294. Fri Jan 27 02:32:58 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3295. Fri Jan 27 02:32:58 2017  begin with 34577882 relations and 23163645 unique ideals
  3296. Fri Jan 27 02:33:04 2017  reduce to 34253393 relations and 20045271 ideals in 6 passes
  3297. Fri Jan 27 02:33:04 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
  3298. Fri Jan 27 02:33:12 2017  removing 4812119 relations and 2812119 ideals in 2000000 cliques
  3299. Fri Jan 27 02:33:13 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3300. Fri Jan 27 02:33:13 2017  begin with 29441274 relations and 20045271 unique ideals
  3301. Fri Jan 27 02:33:19 2017  reduce to 29030051 relations and 16801553 ideals in 7 passes
  3302. Fri Jan 27 02:33:19 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  3303. Fri Jan 27 02:33:25 2017  removing 2348681 relations and 1389978 ideals in 958703 cliques
  3304. Fri Jan 27 02:33:26 2017  commencing in-memory singleton removal
  3305. Fri Jan 27 02:33:26 2017  begin with 26681370 relations and 16801553 unique ideals
  3306. Fri Jan 27 02:33:30 2017  reduce to 26461093 relations and 15183467 ideals in 7 passes
  3307. Fri Jan 27 02:33:30 2017  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
  3308. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 0 large ideals: 2412909
  3309. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 1 large ideals: 9557129
  3310. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 2 large ideals: 10176905
  3311. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 3 large ideals: 3622623
  3312. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 4 large ideals: 609656
  3313. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 5 large ideals: 76167
  3314. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 6 large ideals: 5493
  3315. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  relations with 7+ large ideals: 211
  3316. Fri Jan 27 02:33:37 2017  commencing 2-way merge
  3317. Fri Jan 27 02:33:44 2017  reduce to 17947858 relation sets and 6670232 unique ideals
  3318. Fri Jan 27 02:33:44 2017  commencing full merge
  3319. Fri Jan 27 02:34:20 2017  memory use: 692.4 MB
  3320. Fri Jan 27 02:34:21 2017  found 11268993 cycles, need 9715540
  3321. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  weight of 9715540 cycles is about 537475928 (55.32/cycle)
  3322. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  3323. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  1 relations: 2412909
  3324. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  2 relations: 1401511
  3325. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  3 relations: 1254898
  3326. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  4 relations: 1148733
  3327. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  5 relations: 1025676
  3328. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  6 relations: 848322
  3329. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  7 relations: 691521
  3330. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  8 relations: 509414
  3331. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  9 relations: 383307
  3332. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  10+ relations: 39249
  3333. Fri Jan 27 02:34:23 2017  heaviest cycle: 11 relations
  3334. Fri Jan 27 02:34:24 2017  commencing cycle optimization
  3335. Fri Jan 27 02:34:31 2017  start with 36552084 relations
  3336. Fri Jan 27 02:34:53 2017  pruned 2297283 relations
  3337. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  memory use: 1258.2 MB
  3338. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  distribution of cycle lengths:
  3339. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  1 relations: 2412909
  3340. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  2 relations: 1481914
  3341. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  3 relations: 1387498
  3342. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  4 relations: 1288344
  3343. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  5 relations: 1142046
  3344. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  6 relations: 873198
  3345. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  7 relations: 611500
  3346. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  8 relations: 342758
  3347. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  9 relations: 163518
  3348. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  10+ relations: 11855
  3349. Fri Jan 27 02:34:54 2017  heaviest cycle: 10 relations
  3350. Fri Jan 27 02:35:02 2017  RelProcTime: 15413
  3351. Fri Jan 27 02:35:06 2017  
  3352. Fri Jan 27 02:35:06 2017  commencing linear algebra
  3353. Fri Jan 27 02:35:06 2017  read 9715540 cycles
  3354. Fri Jan 27 02:35:14 2017  cycles contain 22299952 unique relations
  3355. Fri Jan 27 02:37:39 2017  read 22299952 relations
  3356. Fri Jan 27 02:38:03 2017  using 20 quadratic characters above 2147483648
  3357. Fri Jan 27 02:39:28 2017  building initial matrix
  3358. Fri Jan 27 02:42:30 2017  memory use: 3188.3 MB
  3359. Fri Jan 27 02:42:32 2017  read 9715540 cycles
  3360. Fri Jan 27 02:42:33 2017  matrix is 9708874 x 9715540 (2333.9 MB) with weight 731272182 (75.27/col)
  3361. Fri Jan 27 02:42:33 2017  sparse part has weight 495233970 (50.97/col)
  3362. Fri Jan 27 02:43:59 2017  filtering completed in 3 passes
  3363. Fri Jan 27 02:44:00 2017  matrix is 9585498 x 9585698 (2315.1 MB) with weight 725103222 (75.64/col)
  3364. Fri Jan 27 02:44:00 2017  sparse part has weight 491864781 (51.31/col)
  3365. Fri Jan 27 02:44:18 2017  matrix starts at (0, 0)
  3366. Fri Jan 27 02:44:19 2017  matrix is 9585498 x 9585698 (2315.1 MB) with weight 725103222 (75.64/col)
  3367. Fri Jan 27 02:44:19 2017  sparse part has weight 491864781 (51.31/col)
  3368. Fri Jan 27 02:44:19 2017  saving the first 48 matrix rows for later
  3369. Fri Jan 27 02:44:20 2017  matrix includes 64 packed rows
  3370. Fri Jan 27 02:44:21 2017  matrix is 9585450 x 9585698 (2213.2 MB) with weight 549027267 (57.28/col)
  3371. Fri Jan 27 02:44:21 2017  sparse part has weight 484317010 (50.52/col)
  3372. Fri Jan 27 02:44:21 2017  using block size 8192 and superblock size 1474560 for processor cache size 15360 kB
  3373. Fri Jan 27 02:44:41 2017  commencing Lanczos iteration (6 threads)
  3374. Fri Jan 27 02:44:41 2017  memory use: 1783.4 MB
  3375. Fri Jan 27 02:45:31 2017  linear algebra at 0.0%, ETA 83h54m
  3376. Fri Jan 27 02:45:47 2017  checkpointing every 120000 dimensions
  3377. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  lanczos halted after 88622 iterations (dim = 5603909)
  3378. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  BLanczosTime: 123044
  3379. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  
  3380. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  commencing square root phase
  3381. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  handling dependencies 1 to 64
  3382. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  reading relations for dependency 1
  3383. Sat Jan 28 12:45:50 2017  error: read_cycles can't open dependency file
  3384. Sat Jan 28 12:46:05 2017  
  3385. Sat Jan 28 12:46:05 2017  
  3386. Sat Jan 28 12:46:05 2017  Msieve v. 1.52 (SVN unknown)
  3387. Sat Jan 28 12:46:05 2017  random seeds: 951dda4e 86e97336
  3388. Sat Jan 28 12:46:05 2017  factoring 1374250293977900524006825181025041222391785962418349198188752592542556833408706796147779390990626204883096007787340300959668458776589915992783964729160514357520386806570509 (172 digits)
  3389. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
  3390. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  commencing number field sieve (172-digit input)
  3391. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  R0: -1214784946281755925158360658293296
  3392. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  R1: 18303130010379613
  3393. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A0: -23481671787104319711626620457547467037375
  3394. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A1: 1029230367426047271940304894097130
  3395. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A2: 3146916195524283581740271732
  3396. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A3: 123748321202088763083
  3397. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A4: -51331470267154
  3398. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  A5: 519480
  3399. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  skew 8648943.40, size 9.864e-17, alpha -6.365, combined = 2.829e-13 rroots = 5
  3400. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  
  3401. Sat Jan 28 12:46:06 2017  commencing linear algebra
  3402. Sat Jan 28 12:46:07 2017  matrix starts at (0, 0)
  3403. Sat Jan 28 12:46:08 2017  matrix is 9585498 x 9585698 (2315.1 MB) with weight 725103222 (75.64/col)
  3404. Sat Jan 28 12:46:08 2017  sparse part has weight 491864781 (51.31/col)
  3405. Sat Jan 28 12:46:08 2017  saving the first 48 matrix rows for later
  3406. Sat Jan 28 12:46:09 2017  matrix includes 64 packed rows
  3407. Sat Jan 28 12:46:10 2017  matrix is 9585450 x 9585698 (2213.2 MB) with weight 549027267 (57.28/col)
  3408. Sat Jan 28 12:46:10 2017  sparse part has weight 484317010 (50.52/col)
  3409. Sat Jan 28 12:46:10 2017  using block size 8192 and superblock size 1474560 for processor cache size 15360 kB
  3410. Sat Jan 28 12:46:29 2017  commencing Lanczos iteration (6 threads)
  3411. Sat Jan 28 12:46:29 2017  memory use: 1783.4 MB
  3412. Sat Jan 28 12:46:29 2017  restarting at iteration 88622 (dim = 5603909)
  3413. Sat Jan 28 12:46:51 2017  linear algebra at 58.5%, ETA 16h 0m
  3414. Sat Jan 28 12:46:59 2017  checkpointing every 260000 dimensions
  3415. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  lanczos halted after 88682 iterations (dim = 5607705)
  3416. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  BLanczosTime: 77
  3417. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  
  3418. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  commencing square root phase
  3419. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  handling dependencies 1 to 64
  3420. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  reading relations for dependency 1
  3421. Sat Jan 28 12:47:23 2017  error: read_cycles can't open dependency file
  3422. Sat Jan 28 12:47:30 2017  
  3423. Sat Jan 28 12:47:30 2017  
  3424. Sat Jan 28 12:47:30 2017  Msieve v. 1.52 (SVN unknown)
  3425. Sat Jan 28 12:47:30 2017  random seeds: ff6244cb 483957c1
  3426. Sat Jan 28 12:47:30 2017  factoring 1374250293977900524006825181025041222391785962418349198188752592542556833408706796147779390990626204883096007787340300959668458776589915992783964729160514357520386806570509 (172 digits)
  3427. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
  3428. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  commencing number field sieve (172-digit input)
  3429. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  R0: -1214784946281755925158360658293296
  3430. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  R1: 18303130010379613
  3431. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A0: -23481671787104319711626620457547467037375
  3432. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A1: 1029230367426047271940304894097130
  3433. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A2: 3146916195524283581740271732
  3434. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A3: 123748321202088763083
  3435. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A4: -51331470267154
  3436. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  A5: 519480
  3437. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  skew 8648943.40, size 9.864e-17, alpha -6.365, combined = 2.829e-13 rroots = 5
  3438. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  
  3439. Sat Jan 28 12:47:31 2017  commencing linear algebra
  3440. Sat Jan 28 12:47:32 2017  matrix starts at (0, 0)
  3441. Sat Jan 28 12:47:33 2017  matrix is 9585498 x 9585698 (2315.1 MB) with weight 725103222 (75.64/col)
  3442. Sat Jan 28 12:47:33 2017  sparse part has weight 491864781 (51.31/col)
  3443. Sat Jan 28 12:47:33 2017  saving the first 48 matrix rows for later
  3444. Sat Jan 28 12:47:33 2017  matrix includes 64 packed rows
  3445. Sat Jan 28 12:47:34 2017  matrix is 9585450 x 9585698 (2213.2 MB) with weight 549027267 (57.28/col)
  3446. Sat Jan 28 12:47:34 2017  sparse part has weight 484317010 (50.52/col)
  3447. Sat Jan 28 12:47:34 2017  using block size 8192 and superblock size 1474560 for processor cache size 15360 kB
  3448. Sat Jan 28 12:47:54 2017  commencing Lanczos iteration (10 threads)
  3449. Sat Jan 28 12:47:54 2017  memory use: 1783.5 MB
  3450. Sat Jan 28 12:47:54 2017  restarting at iteration 88682 (dim = 5607705)
  3451. Sat Jan 28 12:48:09 2017  linear algebra at 58.5%, ETA 10h54m
  3452. Sat Jan 28 12:48:18 2017  checkpointing every 360000 dimensions
  3453. Sun Jan 29 01:15:40 2017  lanczos halted after 151591 iterations (dim = 9585437)
  3454. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  recovered 25 nontrivial dependencies
  3455. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  BLanczosTime: 44897
  3456. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  
  3457. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  commencing square root phase
  3458. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  handling dependencies 1 to 64
  3459. Sun Jan 29 01:15:48 2017  reading relations for dependency 1
  3460. Sun Jan 29 01:15:49 2017  read 4793470 cycles
  3461. Sun Jan 29 01:15:53 2017  cycles contain 11092044 unique relations
  3462. Sun Jan 29 01:17:46 2017  read 11092044 relations
  3463. Sun Jan 29 01:18:28 2017  multiplying 11092044 relations
  3464. Sun Jan 29 01:29:27 2017  multiply complete, coefficients have about 653.04 million bits
  3465. Sun Jan 29 01:29:30 2017  initial square root is modulo 722479
  3466. Sun Jan 29 01:41:27 2017  sqrtTime: 1539
  3467. Sun Jan 29 01:41:27 2017  prp62 factor: 46205165266133662482948385141378840157279684813622824070309817
  3468. Sun Jan 29 01:41:27 2017  prp110 factor: 29742352095538657419873460130787243208882192833790233431382969850597187601711543963363200375101906633497733877
  3469. Sun Jan 29 01:41:27 2017  elapsed time 12:53:57
RAW Paste Data
We use cookies for various purposes including analytics. By continuing to use Pastebin, you agree to our use of cookies as described in the Cookies Policy. OK, I Understand
 
Top