Elick vs Guy .

Guy vs Elick.

Guy posts that dont work : Composit Mechs being this weird amalgam of parts that cant move or fire a weapon. Composites have been allowed in almost every tourney ever and I dont want to set the precedent of "you must stip that your character has seen his composite mech before, and you must stip that he knows how to operate it, and you must stip what he had for lunch last week", its probably a valid point but im not opening that can of worms, sorry.

Turn based gameplay. I understand what Guy was going for here, and while I do agree that the mechs cant be proven to dodge, I dont buy that they will just stand still and wait for there opponents to do an action because its not there turn.

Guy Posts that work : Game play feats being non literal. I wouldnt have bought this argument normally, but Elick concedes that maybe the Ice generator is not instant after spending 2 previous responses arguing that it is. With elick giving up this point it suddenly turns this point from "guy is a crazy loon" into "oh alright maybe Guy knows whats up" and thats not good for Elicks argument.


Aside from these points I think guy asks some damning questions and points out things that make elicks arguments look whack. Why would Elicks characters instantly go for freezing when they have tons of other options? Even if they went for freezing why couldnt guys characters just break out? why would the pilots continually freeze instead of switching to another form of offense? These questions are damning for Elicks entire argument.

Best case scenario for Elick is that the pilots do infact go for freezing, I think this leaves Space Racer perminently Incapped as he doesnt have the physical strength, nor the freeze resistance to actually do anything about it. This is not true with Guys other characters tho who do break out and have the physicals to actually damage the Mechs, Yomi and man with an unspellable name cannot be put down by the Mechs and do actually have a win con.

Guy wins 2-1.