Ame's Judgements - GDT9 R1

Ame's Judgements
****

Foxxydarko vs. Jedidiahohlord

As I understand it Jed was accidentally added to the roster after he withdrew from the tribunals, as such his entire response for this round is ~~objective proof that he wins~~ largely a joke.  To give Foxxy some comments though:

Foxxy had decently strong opening argument, providing good evidence why his opponents team was weak/bad, and how his own team exploits said weakness.  He makes a good argument that Nono and Bellcross would be pretty quickly taken care of by his team, making it a 1v3, which Ultraman can't win.

Winner: Foxxy

****

Coconut_Crab vs. Corvette1710

Debate Breakdown: https://pastebin.com/EUSyAnxj

Both debaters showed elements of a good debate, however in the end only one came close to achieving that title.  Throughout his debate Coco was marred by his seeming unwillingness to qualify Krystals numbers (merely throwing them at Corvette and seeing which stick) and lack of quantifying/qualifying scaling (i.e. just linking a scan of one of his characters tanking a hit from Luffy, as if I know how strong Luffy is).  This also applied, to a lesser extent, how he characterized his opponents picks in R1, saying his team was strong, without even taking the minimal effort.  Coco did have a pretty decent formatting throughout the entire debate.

With this in mind, Corvette is also not without his mistakes.  His Brimstone argument is overly reliant on calcs that have murky assumptions, was weak in countering some of Coco's esoteric arguments, meh format, and a few minor bumps.  Corv's first response was very rough, failing to address many of Coco's arguments, however in his second he recovered, addressing many of Coco's claims in R1 and R2.

In the end I have to give them win to Corvette, primarily due to:

* Coco's inability to mount a significant counter against Brimstone's heat for Big Mom and Kaido

* Coco's complete lack of primary/valid secondary evidence proving any of his claims regarding Krystal

* Corvette muddying the water, making Aku and Ryuko seem as if they would be at least semi-effective against Kaido or Big Mom

TL;DR Cite your feats, Corvette wins