Dark judgments

Coco v Ralton

-	Ralton has two Radioactive Men
-	One Super Skrull
-	Radioactive Men are radioactive and have energy blasts
-	SSkull is basically just the FF4 but without Sue apparently?
-	Sasaki would be one-shot
-	The rest of Ralton’s team has OK defense I guess
-	Ralton’s team has a bunch of heat like this is fucking Durabelle tier again
-	Radioactive Man scales physically to Namor I guess
-	SSkull scales to Thing
-	Sasaki has a sharp ass sword
-	He’s skilled
-	Luffy is strong
-	Luffy is durable
-	Zoro is strong
-	Zoro is also durable
-	Sasaki can definitely cut Ralton’s team
-	Coco thinks the Moriah feat is an outlier
-	Luffy can resist the heat aura stuff
-	Zoro is reasonably capable of resisting heat stuff
-	The range of Radioactive Man’s heat seems extremely vague
-	SSkull’s building busting seems sus
-	SSkull copied powers off an earlier FF4, and they were seemingly weaker at the time
-	One Radioactive Man may literally not exist
-	Radioactive Man seems inconsistent about using his more esoteric abilities and instead prefers to brick
-	Radioactive Man literally doesn’t scale to Namor
-	I was pretty sure this was the case even prior, but rems are a fucking awful measure of lethality
-	Radioactive Man’s blasts may be slow
-	Ralton is saying that Radioactive Man nosells a strike from somebody with a sword that’s below tier, but he visibly takes damage and then just regens
-	Ralton is continuing the Thing scaling with SSkull, but I’m not as confident in it anymore
-	SSkull can at least tank hits from somebody capable of cutting clean through metal
-	SSkull won’t die from having his throat torn out, but nobody on Coco’s team will stop there
-	I don’t really buy Ralton’s counter-argument for Sasaki’s sword, since they pretty much just become a weapon of a specific material
-	SSkull’s skin may be comparable to the Thing, but I don’t know which period of Thing, and Coco’s argument is making this scaling shaky
-	Sasaki may have trouble simulating RMan
-	RMan could probably kill Sasaki with his more esoteric abilities but Ralton’s doing a bad job on the characterization field
-	Ralton is continuing the Thing scaling, as well as the one building feat that’s omega vague
-	Luffy doesn’t scale to Enel’s lightning for heat
-	Luffy’s heat resistance seems worse than first argued
-	The IKEA is as big as it needs to be, so Luffy can probably set up as necessary
-	Zoro’s heat resistance is only vaguely okay but I’m unsure what era any HT scans come from, and RMan seems unlikely to use his shit
-	Ralton actually just posted scans of the Green Namor while calling him Namor, then corrected himself within the same set of posts??
-	Green Namor apparently scales to actual Namor physically
-	Radioactive Man may actually use his burny shit
-	Ralton is saying the rem stuff is fake but isn’t really saying why
-	I still have no idea how SSkull fights, because Ralton has pretty much argued “heat argue and Thing scaling”, which doesn’t lend well to “Sasaki can’t copy him”
-	I’m still pretty sure Sasaki can cut shit in half
-	Luffy is still strong I’m pretty sure
-	Coco’s argument for why Enel can burn Luffy with a weapon is somewhat compelling
-	Zoro can probably cut Rman, and he can do it at range
-	SSkull’s scaling still seems really weak honestly
-	I’m still strongly unsure that Rman would actually use his aura
-	Radioactive Man’s blasts seem very hmmm
-	Honestly Coco’s convinced me, Rman sucks
-	The third response by Ralton is being ignored because it’s BM

Actual Judgement:

Ralton has two Radioactive Men, and one Super Skrull. One Radioactive Man is fake due to being an alt universe RMan with no proven feats, so he’s assumed to be acting as a cheerleader for this match.
Coco has Sasaki, Zoro, and Luffy.
I think Coco did a good job of poking holes in a lot of claims that Ralton made. I remain extremely dubious of how Radioactive Man will fight, except he seems to punch and shit more than not. His heat aura is of extremely vague range. The “sword immunity” scan wasn’t really particularly strong evidence. Radioactive Man is very vaguely maybe possibly in tier physically, but his energy blasts are badly defined and seem to be based off IRL radiation values that are not lethal in a relevant timeframe. His heat aura doesn’t start active, and he seems hesitant to use it in most cases.
SSkull might scale to the tier setter and might scale to a much weaker version. The modern scan that Ralton used is apparently when Thing was weakened, which convinced me that SSkull is too shaky for this specific context. A lot of the heat feats are dubious in when they occurred, and I’m not well versed enough on comics to tell, but Johnny was apparently also weakened at the same time SSkull was said to be equal in a modern comic. Even if SSkull does scale to Johnny for heat purposes, I don’t think they’re good enough to avoid Zoro or Luffy from landing a hit, and Thing was a lot weaker in the past.

As a whole, I think Ralton’s team is too poorly defined, while Coco’s team was reasonably well defined. RMan probably doesn’t use his aura, his blasts are weak, and his physicals are vague. Sasaki doesn’t really matter, but either Luffy or Zoro should be able to kill RMan as argued.

SSkull is a lot better off, but he seems to function off copying a character decades ago and then scaling to that specific version, while being stated to be a peer to the modern versions only when they were weakened. This put a massive issue on a lot of Ralton’s scaling, as he largely just continued to pile that up to cover the deficit. SSkull might be decent if the tier setter was 60s Thing or something, but I don’t think he scales concretely enough to the tier setter, nor does he have good enough independent feats to avoid Luffy or Zoro from landing a single hit and KOing him.

Coco wins