Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Haha, i really like the way you write. Its really engaging. English is not my first language so sorry if I make some mistakes!
- Ok, lets get into it
- "Well-substantiated" theories aren’t automatically true just because they’ve been around a while - I didnt mean this, I meant that the longer a theory resists scientific scrutiny, the stronger it becomes, and the more sure we are that its the closest explanation of reality. When you have genetics, biology, anatomy, archeology, all pointing to the same conclusion of evolution, its hard to think that this has less weight than the word of the bible that has lots of contradictions and its written like a fable more than a rational approach to understand reality. Bah, at the same time you didnt disagree with the fact that 99% of species that ever existed are extinct. You said ”If 99% of old computers are gone, does that mean they weren’t designed? No—it just means decay exists” So all the new species that appear in the history of the world were all created into existence by god at different points in time? Help me understand whats your view. Cause I dont think you believe the universe is 6000 years old, and you agree with trillions of species having existed in the past..
- “And guess what hasn’t been repeated? Chimps turning into humans.” Chimps didnt turn into humans. We have a common ancestor with chimps, 4-5 million years ago. From that ancestor the homo and the pan species emerged. Other human species have existed, u know? No same species has sprung 2 times, because no same individual being has ever been born twice. This variation from generation to generation is what allows for adaptation and evolution. The amount of variables in the gene + external enviromental forces are so big that its almost impossible to reproduce the conditions for the creation of the same species twice.
- Also, I notice how evolution always leans on imagination. “What if humans disappear for 50,000 years?” Cool story, but is that how real science works? Through what-if scenarios and Hollywood-style plots? Sounds more like philosophy class than biology. Evolutionists have basically become the philosophers of our age—telling stories about unobserved pasts and speculative futures, then calling it "science." That’s not science. That’s narrative-building—which must be protected by censorship, not discussion. Because discussion would reveal how flimsy the foundations really are. Factoid.
- Its an example to show how science is closer to truth than the bible or the quran,the torah, the book of mormon, the book of scientology, the hindu Vedas,the egyptian book of the dead Greek mythology, the teachings of the buddha, etc etce etc. These books help distill human universal experiences and struggles, give explanations through stories and try to show a path to understanding and spiritual enlightenment. I think they can be useful for some people. They bring a big sense of relief for people who have lost a loved one, for people who cannot find a sense of purpose in life, for people who need a community and find it in their church, mosque, temple, etc, for people who need direction and discipline in their life. But these texts are not objective truths. They are subjective, prisoners to the contexts of where and when they were written, by whom and for who. Science on the other hand is tested against reality over and over again. We observe evolution in almost all the food we find in the groceries, they have been artificially selected for generations to yield bigger productions at lower costs. The same for animals (domesticated dogs, cows, chickens, pigs, etc). Its horrible, but chickens have been adapted to grow incredibly fast, to the point where they cannot sustain their weights some times. Ok, you are gonna say bananas are still bananas, chickens are still chickens. Modern bananas cannot interbreed with wild bananas species from which we have artficialey evolved them. They have become a different species. The same with dogs and wolves. Or some types of cannabis. U have some bacteria like e coli that have evolved since 1988, developing completely new metabolic capabilities. Mutations that happened between thousands of generations. We observe evolution in the labs, in our genes, in the archeological database. Why is it that species have been becoming more and more complex over time? Seeing clear examples of mutations from species to species?
- You asked: would people still believe the Bible if it vanished? Maybe not. But would they reinvent morality? Likely. Because it's written on the heart (Romans 2:14-15). Conscience is hardwired—though it can be suppressed. But morality alone isn’t the whole message of Scripture. It’s not just “be nice, kids, cuz kindness is a superpower.” It’s about ultimate justice, undeniable truth, and a Creator who reveals Himself—whether we like it or not.
- OK, Morality and consciousness is engrained in our beings. Mechanisms related to the evolution of emotion and social bonding that have permitted animals to form packs, groups, social hierarchies, language (verbal or not), take care of their young so their offspring have a higher chance of survival, etc . We didnt invent morality. Other animals have a sense of morality, justice and altruism as well. What we humans have done is create a more nuanced morality that evolves with time. What was moral in the bible, like genocide, slavery, rape of certain groups is no longer moral. Homosexuality was immoral 80 years ago. It is now accepted as a normal part of any mammal species, were some offspring will be attracted to the same sex.
- Also, you mentioned that most cultures "arrive at the same moral conclusions"—but that’s not quite accurate. Some cultures (like certain reincarnation-based systems) discourage helping the poor because they’re seen as being punished for past lives. That’s not biblical. That’s what happens when man tries to recreate God in his image.
- Do you mean the untouchable cast in india? This is despicable. But I asure you in the crusades, if some christian crusader saw a hindu praying to krishna, they would torture them and punish them for heresy. They believed the same teachings you believed and reached different conclusions that pushed them and enabled them to fullfill heinous acts. I do believe there are different levels of aggression between the teachings of different religions. You can go from a buddhist that wont hurt a fly, to muslims that have a conqueror as a prophet. But humans are humans and I trully believe we are almost all good and kindhearted.
- Let me ask you something:
- Which is more scientifically viable?
- A) A super intelligent being created humans of lesser intelligence
- B) No being and no intelligence created humans of great intelligence from zero intelligence
- Come on now. One of those is fantasy. The other matches cause and effect.
- Let me give you an analogy:
- If a robot shows up in your backyard—functioning, learning, self-repairing—do you assume:
- A) Someone made it
- or
- B) Lightning hit scrap metal 36 million times and voilà, robot?
- Why is design obvious everywhere except in the natural world?
- Answer: Because once you admit nature was designed, now you’re accountable to the Designer. (Might be worth looking into who He is and what He wants from us.)
- B) Humans werent created. They are the descendents of millions of generations that have evolved and adapted. If you want to believe that evolution was guided by the hand of god, I can accept that more (even though I dont believe it). There is some “Design” in nature. Things that have worked due to their design, so they survived and prospered more than others with weaker designs. These Designs are the result of random mutations that happen within the parameters of change organic life permits.
- Let me give you an analogy:
- If a robot shows up in your backyard—functioning, learning, self-repairing—do you assume:
- A) Someone made it
- or
- B) Lightning hit scrap metal 36 million times and voilà, robot?
- Why is design obvious everywhere except in the natural world?
- Answer: Because once you admit nature was designed, now you’re accountable to the Designer. (Might be worth looking into who He is and what He wants from us.)
- In this scenario I would assume someone made it
- We didnt appear evolved from one day to the other. It took 3.6 billion ears of life evolving before us. And we will keep evolving. Also answer B is not a good analogy of evolution. The first life was super simple. Simpler than the simplest cell. It was not from nothing to super complex organism.
- I dont believe Im accountable for a god as immoral as the god of the old testament. I believe I am more moral, less petty and kinder than him. So I owe my accountability to my self, my family, the society with which I live and the earth I inhabit.
- So, you answered “yes”—that 36 million random changes gave us language, morality, and Mozart. Respectfully… that’s not science. That’s faith. A lot of it.
- How so? We observe how the brain produces language. We have a rudimentary understanding of how it evolved. Its a better explanation in my eyes and in the eyes of the smartiest people on earth.
- You said Mozart’s music “evolved” through culture. Sure—but cultural evolution is intelligent, not random. It’s built on memory, learning, creativity, and refinement—design. You just proved my point. Mozart didn’t come out of nowhere—but neither did the mind capable of composing like that. That’s design unfolding over time, not random chance stacking miracles.
- Cultural evolution is a mutation of language, music, customs, rituals, technology over time. It is kind of random. If i were to go back in time and kill baby hitler. Wouldnt this cascade in an inmense cascade of tiny changes that would basically change todays german culture, and in consequence the world as we know it? Each life, each event, each interaction affects the culture. Its the same as changes on genes over generations. It depends who reproduced with whom, where the climate catastrophe happenned that forced all the species that were not fitted to survived died, etc etc. U get what i mean? How is this not random? If it isnt random, then we live in a deterministic universe where we have no free will. Everything is designed and planned to occur a certain way, and theres no other way it could have happened.
- And your line about “genetic constraints” and “design limitations”? Whoa whoa—design? Whose team are you on again? 😄 You can’t describe nature as a designed system, and then pretend design doesn’t exist. That’s like admiring the structure of a cathedral and saying it formed by erosion.
- Also, this: “I assure you a caveman 180,000 years ago couldn’t do any of these things.”
- Uhh… were you there? Science deals in evidence, not “assurances” about the distant unobservable past. But what we can observe from archaeology is that early humans—primitive or not—buried their dead, created art, used tools, made music, and pondered existence. That’s not survival instinct. That’s the image of God expressing itself.
- Hahaha you made me laugh. Yeah, I meant Design in the sense I was using before. Living beings have evolved under the constraints of the laws of chemistry, and physics. There are constraints on what a body can mutate into. Design constraints if you will. And variations are tiffany compared on all the genetic info that is being passed from generation to generation.
- About the caveman. I was referring to “but they’re not writing books, building cities, or sacrificing for strangers”. You are right, assurance is the wrong word. I meant They didnt write books, built cities and I doubt they would sacrifice themself for a stranger. They were modern humans like us, so of course they pondered existence, had tools, music, culture, buried their dead. But the sacrificing themselves for someone outside of their tribe is something that i think would be very unlikely. They would have always prioritizd protecting their family and small tribe, so I believe they would be kind of distrusting of someone they never saw before. But this is just assuming, you are right
- Now… about your mom. First of all, I truly hope she’s recovering and doing better. That’s no small thing.
- Thanks! Yeah, shes doing much better thank god 😋 haha. She can walk no problem, move her arm at 90% and talk at 90% speed as before. 🙂
- But look what you said: she lost her ability to speak due to brain damage. That’s a mutation in action—it broke something. And yet you believe a different random mutation gave humans the ability to speak? That’s like getting a nail in your bike tire and saying, “Maybe this is how bikes learn to go faster.” 🙃
- But it was not a mutation. It was a bloodvessel that burst in her brain and covered part of her brain in blood, leaving it unnable to receive oxigen, thus killing millions of neurons.
- Mutations don’t create—they corrupt. And when things break, we turn to intelligent solutions: doctors, technology, medicine, therapy. I’m guessing your family didn’t just leave your mom’s recovery up to random chance. You trusted intelligently-designed tools to help her. That’s kind of… telling, isn’t it?
- So no—mutations didn’t give us consciousness, logic, and Beethoven’s 5th Symphony. If evolution were true, the highest sound we’d make is a hoot in 4/4 time.
- A mutation is a permanent gene change in the DNA sequence that can be inherited by descendants. Some mutations we can observe in humans are skin color, eye color, hair color, resistance to diseases, lactose tolerance, adaptations to cold climates, adaptation to aquatic lifestyles, adaptation to high altitudes with low oxygen…
- Mutations change. Some mutations can cause disabilities like down syndrome, sickle cell anemia, progeria. Mutations are random. The ones that produce things that are better fitted for their environment will survive and reproduce, others will die away.
- Bottom line?
- You’re describing a world full of order, constraint, refinement, systems, logic, and beauty—and trying to credit chance. But you keep borrowing from the language of design to describe it. That’s like building your whole argument with bricks you’re trying to deny exist.
- No fair. 😄 Give them back—they’re mine.
- Hahaha, nice talk! We have building blocks of life! I agree. The blocks that the laws of reality permit to exist. They have to follow the laws of gravity, thermodynamics, chemistry, physics, etc. This is also a huge limitation on what mutations can happen from generation to generation.
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment