judgements for wolf

#Kirbin vs Ame

* Kirbin is OOT

######Ame wins

#Embrace vs Ralton

*Embrace*

* "Can transform instantly" no citation
* "Can make mountains of ice to trap" no real citation
* "Casually reduce temperatures to -89c" again no real citation
* "Completely freeze with sustained contact" no timeframe provided

* 'Gandharva's striking is good, being able to break a Closed Space of Sierra with a headbutt, and a lower ranked magician of Brilith could maintain a closed space that withstood mountain busting blasts' bruh
* Projectiles capable of breaking large amounts of geography
* le fake

I just want to open a kubera scan and come away knowing more instead of less about it

*Ralton*

* SuperDoom exists and you die
 * Heat
 * Toxic
* Heat vision exists and they die
* Can fly fast and bust mountains, "Surface Area exists btw and your durability is trash"
* "The transformation takes an unquantified time frame." yea
 * in character thing I won't judge, but this seems "not invalid" at absolute worst
* Freezing sucks
* The striking feat sucks
* Projectiles suck
* Superdoom is stronger shut up

This is generally a very tight response, it opens with the most overwhelmingly relevant things, my only complaint is that I think the formatting is too busy with quotes etc

*Embrace*

This response is ass. It reads like it barely actually addresses most of the major points put forth and just repeats **what it said before** but **bolded** like a **comic character** talking, it overwhelmingly relies on the evidence that a single panel means literally 0.000000000... seconds and not "vague time", "I challenge you to find an example of non-instant Kubera transformation." is an awful counter that reads like it's only being said because Ralton said something similar, but ralton literally just had a panel of "SuperDoom is stronger", in addition becoming Doomsday being an amp is more obvious than a transformation taking again literally no time, the claims of the transformation speed not being tenable vs the claim of superdoom being stronger aren't really comparable.

 If we're going to call something fake, it's assuming something takes place in literally no time because it happened offscreen. The response does not provide anything but extremely tangential points for actual surviving essentially every piece of offense Superdoom passively emits much less offense that can be enacted in the timeframe of abilities being used.

I don't need to judge Ralton's next response. Superdoom exists and his opponent dies instantly, causing **Ralton** to win.

######RALTON WINS

#Josh vs FJ

Bambina isn't OOT here, he jumps fast but doesn't hit more/hit faster/avoid more punches in a meaningful sense. However tier Hulk is not capable of jumping into space, making josh a smelly  idiot


*FJ*

* Speedfreek fast, Bambina has no ranged attacks so he can't stop this out of melee range, he cuts people more durable than Bambina

*Josh*

* Bambina kills speedfreek by breathing, bambina moving kills speedfreek
* Bambina has range
* Hit big
* Bambina can jump really fast so Speedfreek won't hit him
 * 'and oh by the way is also in space." what
* Speedfreek's claws aren't as provably sharp and by extension as potent as Wolverine
* Skill bullshit

Basically everything continued from here is in the context of these claims, with the additional significant factor of FJ arguing IC actions.

* It is questionable if Speedfreek has been strictly proven to display piercing as good as Wolverine due to lacking specific "sharpness feats", however I think Speedfreek piercing Bambina is a relatively tenable position

Bambina has characterization that pretty consistently seems to be "he wants to play", so I think the condition of Bambina just fucking around is pretty valid, even "Bambina opens by fighting" was "playing." The actual problem with this as a win condition is that how Bambina plays vs fight is irrelevant to Speedfreek's durability, Bambina and Speedfreek both have to react to move and if Bambina does like any one of a few passive things like "sniffles" Speedfreek is literally redmisted, making **Josh** win.

######JOSH WINS

#Verlux vs Crim

I've been going back and forth on how detailed I want to make this judgement, eventually I decided to try and share my thoughts on the most relevant factors and remain open for questions

I don't buy the "monochrome resistance" scan in response 1, and so little time being spent on Tian's trump card and the absolutely most relevant part of his being there seems like a misstep. Naruto organs being weak is something that is directly supported, blood spear is pretty much defaulted to a land on a slower opponent, Tian kills Naruto. I can't understand weebshit well enough to address the speed amp claims meaningfully on my own.

The reason I didn't go more in depth is that I feel while a lot of the claims present are not actually irrelevant to the match for the purpose of either person being able to win, they don't matter while other factors are true. I think the spear hits and I think the spear kills so I think **Verlux wins.**

######VERLUX WINS