Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Commenting on:
- https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qOnM6soqMrqZAyA00C0lhjEWgd1cgk2HBjqwym7qtbQ/edit?pageId=100608879203544240864
- 1) You start your videos by talking about "a trained professional" whereas I think "an experienced runner" or something similar would be a lot more appropriate. After all, very few people do speedrunning for a living and I don't think any of them run this game.
- 2) I think you should clarify *in the commentary* whose run you're showing, what their time was, how good that time was back then and what it means now in case things have changed, perhaps when it was done ... some general background information which can be quite useful while also properly attributing the creator. You're creating an entire video using someone else's video, IMO two links in the video description do not suffice in terms of fair credit. I personally wouldn't really like my videos to be used in this way, for example. Also, it makes it hard for me to know what your script is about. :P For the sake of criticism I'll assume it's the Phillotrax run you linked.
- 3) "As soon as *it* loads in", from a grammatical point of view this it isn't referring to anything, but also practically speaking most people won't know what you're talking about. You should clarify that this is about the prologue, especially considering how your other paragraphs do address their respective chapters right away.
- 4) I'd elaborate a bit more on the side-step boost, right now it probably sounds more like a glitch which has something to do with turning the camera than pretty logical behavior if you know how the game works. It's just that when you do a side-jump, you get running speed in the direction you're jumping almost instantly. By turning your camera before you hit the ground again, you can end up looking in the direction you want to run, at running speed, skipping a lot of acceleration.
- 6) "where when you kick off a wall" I think: "where when you kick while doing a wall run" would be more descriptive to newcomers, but it's a nit-pick.
- 7) If you want to use the term "Faith", you need to explain that she is the main/player character, people who don't know the game can't know this.
- 8) You may choose to talk a bit about kick glitch angling, as your description is making kick glitch chaining sound way easier than it is. I've tried doing this initial one you're talking about, I think I've only ever gotten three in a row, partially because I still miss the jump shamefully often, but also because you need to be jumping in exactly the right directions in order to keep this chain up. In certain chains you need to have an angle so straight that you can kick glitch twice on the same wall. There's one in chapter 2 which is so insane that I only ever saw it done in a segmented run.
- 7) "But because the runner is so fast, they have to wait for the helicopter to be in position in order to end the chapter." This is misleading, I'm fairly sure I've already missed the helicopter before I even knew about kick glitches. All that matters is the time in between you crossing the fence and you jumping off the building, if you run in a straight line, which requires no skill whatsoever, I'm fairly sure you'll have to wait too.
- 8) "You may notice that the runner slides into the button" It's important to note that while you're sliding, jumping, breaking glass, ... you also need to be sending a lot of "Use" inputs to the game, usually bound to scroll up.
- 9) "After skipping the cutscene the runner makes their way" This isn't that important, but you could talk about how you're supposed to run all the way around the offices, yet by being fast enough can pretty much jump right over the guards without dying.
- 10) "the back of the building" and "After making their way to the top of the building" This may seem like a nit-pick but I don't think it is since it is genuinely confusing to me. You're just going through the offices, you're in no way near the top of the building and IDK what would constitute "the back". Also, the window you talked about is just an opening to another room, IDK if that can be classified as a window.
- 11) "they jump from this window to the wall where they then jump off the wall back to where they came from." It's important to note that you can't just jump this gap, since you can't do a wall climb across such a large gap. In order to do a climb/run on that wall you need to jump from close enough, using ... the platform from a kick glitch. You need to kick glitch on the "window" frame, kinda straight forward, in order to make it, which I can't even do myself at the moment. It also takes a kick glitch and wall boost *on the same wall* to then get out of the building, which is probably the harder part and why this is considered an advanced strat. A trick worth talking about IMO.
- 12) "This is known as an elevator clip, which saves time over using the elevator normally." I really think you have to elaborate on this, I myself didn't find it very straightforward when I first saw these things. The unexplained pause buffering makes it even more complicated to follow as an unexperienced viewer.
- 13) "Now the runner is on the next part of the level, where at this gap the runner does a similar trick to what they did in the prologue to cancel their fall height" This is not quite right, the right analogy is the kick glitch because all you're really doing is performing a kick glitch without jumping of the platform (or at least, it's not required, Phillotrax uses a side-jump to speed things up). If you try to do the same by kicking while falling straight down, you'll die. I don't know why but the platforms created after rolls, getting hit by barbed wire, wall run-kicking, ... they all don't just reset your speed but are true platforms you can use to get to areas which are normally to low to reach without dying. Fall-kicking may reset your speed and give you a nice animation, but whether or not you die is independent of this animation AFAIK.
- 14) "They then make their way to the end of the chapter, the only really hard part being this kick glitch gap at the very end." That's kinda false, just getting across the gap at the end isn't too hard, learned that a couple of months ago myself, but I still can't do the ground kick glitches which Phillo is using throughout this section to speed things up, while also performing his wall boosts (sometimes chains) a lot better than I. Technically speaking getting across the gap without having to climb is quite hard and something only the advanced runners seem to do, but I doubt you were referring to that detail.
- 15) "to get over the fence much more quickly than normal." It may be worth noting that you're not supposed to be able to across fences like this, but as long as there's walls around there's plenty of ways for speedrunners to do it. ;-)
- 16) "The runner then makes their way down the drains" This part is called the canals, I highly suggest you use that term since the next part is called the storm drains.
- 17) "behind the normal level geometry" Geometry is a strange choice of words which I've never heard people use in this situation, but it's not terribly important.
- 18) "for a full game run" It may be worth mentioning that they mean a full unsegmented run, segmented runs are way riskier of course, however for some reason they're quite rare in this community.
- 19) "The runner does FOUR, yes four, kick glitches in a row." This doesn't make a lot of sense. The run opens on a sextuple chain which you barely talk about, shows a kick glitch and wall boost on the same wall in chapter 1, but now that there's something in between those two you make it sound like it's impossible. :P Of course it's very hard, but the script seems over the top compared to other hard sections.
- 20) "Where they then fall a small ways to get to a checkpoint much later in the level." I assume you mean "a small way", which is a bit of an understatement as the runner is actually jumping across a huge distance in this time. Remember, while chaining kick glitches your speed keeps building. I'd estimate the checkpoint being about 100m away from where Phillo started the chain. It's quite a long way, really, if it was closer they wouldn't have to chain as many kick glitches to get there. ;-)
- 21) "Now in the sewers" Again, would just call it the storm drains, nothing else.
- 22) Since you have a long gap here, I'd talk about something like the trick to get to the gate opening button quickly, looking up to skip the ladder animation, jumping onto pipes/ladders/platforms early to save height.
- 23) More important than all of these, there's this trick he uses twice to climb up out of the storm drains. It may not look like a lot but it's an advanced strat worth talking about.
- 24) "Where the runner takes the level pretty normally until they get to this elevator near the end of the chapter." Well, ignoring all the cool tricks I can't do, sure ... :P I want to do other things today too but if anything I suggest you talk about the kick glitch used in the end to get across the barbed wire (which you're not supposed to be able to do) and the savewarp, since it's the first savewarp in the run.
- 25) "The only exceptions to this rule being this jump on top of the building and this ventilation scaling." And, well, a couple of kick glitches and walking around fences, almost falling of the building, but nothing major indeed. :P
- 26) "to scale the side of the building faster than the game would normally allow." You're not normally able to scale this building whatsoever, you're supposed to go inside, go through the offices and end up on the roof that way.
- 27) "Where they then make their way to the elevator in a normal speedrun fashion." Well, "normal", I still can't do half of the kick glitches Phillo's using ... Anyway, something you may want to mention as a funny thing is that for some reason the guards don't spawn (when the helicopters drops those ropes) when you get to their area too quickly.
- 28) "They make make their way to the crane" You may want to talk about he's kick-glitching off a curved wall, not exactly easy compared to a flat wall since you detach from your wall run almost immediately.
- 29) "Chapter 4, the runner glitches out of bounds immediately" This is not true, the part until the kick-glitch is all in-bounds, though he's using shortcuts.
- 30) "do the good ol’ checkpoint reload to get further than they were supposed to." That's not quite true, with a normal save warp you get hit a checkpoint, reload to the main menu, and you spawn at the checkpoint. This one is harder because it involves a sub-checkpoint, one which you can respawn at when you die but which is lost when you reload your game. As such, to get to this checkpoint, the runner needs to die after touching it, which isn't easy as the void doesn't kill you, it only kills your ears as you fall endlessly. In order to die here, you need to pause buffer at pretty precise times to get the station to load under you, so you can fall to your death on the station floor.
- 31) "and finish the chapter in a normal fashion." The sign skip at the end isn't normal, perhaps "normal speedrunning fashion", but still too funny to not talk about. :P
- 32) "Travelling down the hallways as quick as possible" I get that you're trying to connect these parts for a bit by saying generic things about the stuff in the middle, but in this particular case it ironically turns out to be wrong. XD Phillo goes through the first hallway slowly deliberately, if you pass through it too quickly the elevator at the end of the next one won't load and you have to restart the level. Another one of these many things which you can't tell by watching the run but is definitely there.
- 33) "On a certain frame, the runner does a 180 degree turn to grab the floor above faith to skip having to go slow up stairs." No, it skips taking an elevator ride later on actually, but mostly just running back and forth quite a bit. Also, the turn itself isn't what gets you to the next level, the interesting this is how turning on the right frame fires you off the wall at a ridiculous speed (the frame where you'd otherwise be pushed outside of the beam, hence the name of the glitch, the "beamer").
- 34) "Chapter 8, the runner mostly uses the regular route to get to this elevator where they ride it normally." This is the first time it's required to use a side-jump kick glitch, which isn't really more complicated but a bit harder to get down. I still regularly fail this one. On another note, there's a pretty tricky strat which is literally used in the first second of this chapter, where you do a near-perfect side-jump boost to land on the pipes on the ground and get a good start on the level. Pretty short but it's surprisingly hard.
- 35) "Where again the runner uses a mostly normal route up until this crane." Sure, only two intermediate kick glitches and clipping through some pipes, which I can't get done. :P
- 36) "Where the runner scales the building in an unintentional way, only to use save and reload again." It may be worth stressing that this is one of the harder strats in the run.
- 37) "When the runner gets to this upper story" A technicality, but this is actually the entrance hall as far as I know, either way it's pretty much on the ground level, it's just that the level starts underground, with the machinery and parking garage and such. That being said, I used to think the entrance hall was quite far up too, it does take an elevator ride and such after all ... only figured it out when I got a speedometer. It makes sense though, if you look at the depth of the upcoming elevator shaft, your vertical position during the sniper section, ...
- 38) "Then the runner goes out the elevator to the side using a precise timing using reaction time" Newcomers don't know what reaction time is.
- Tricks you didn't cover but are fairly important IMO:
- 1) Wall boosting: There's no way you can't cover this, these usually get you flying faster than kick-glitches and the chains can be just as insane. They're used constantly.
- 2) Wall climb - side step (- wall boost): used in a lot of places you're not supposed to, earliest appearance around the end of the prologue.
- 3) Coiling to get on top of a lot of things: Perhaps a bit silly, but it can save you so much time over the course of a run (especially after kick glitches/wall boosts). The end of prologue is also quite a decent example of how powerful coiling can be.
- 4) Coil-jumping: since there's no speedometer, this is worth talking about. If you jump at full speed (~25km/h) you'll end up at a constantly ~29km/h as long as you're in the air, coiling makes your jumps a bit longer. Good runners do this constantly, but people like me don't do it nearly as much as you can lose a lot of speed upon landing and it seems as if there's some advanced techniques to minimize that speed loss, or at least recover from it more quickly.
- 5) Ground kick glitches: I still don't know if there's actually more behind this then a normal kick glitches, but I never seem to be able to get them, maybe this is something you can research for yourself.
- 6) Not going straight for your target while jumping: Throughout all kinds of jumps (normal jumps, springboards, wall jumps, ...) you aim a bit off the thing you're trying to jump on, or stop holding forward, in order to make sure you hit the object at your highest point, giving you a better crawling animation. Though you may not notice if you don't run the game, this is used a lot to save a decent portion of time climbing stuff.
- 7) Jumping up stairs/slopes: saves a bit of time compared to being slowed down while running up.
- 8) Jumping across balance beams: skips an awfully slow animation.
- 9) Hidden springboards: I don't know why, but it looks like the springboard mechanics are automatically applied to objects with the right shape, not manually programmed by the developers. As a result, certain boxes, pipes, ... can be used to get a springboard jump on (which you're not supposed to get), allowing you to reach areas you're not supposed to, or just skip other areas.
- All things considered ... I think you may have given yourself an unrealistic challenge by creating this series. I couldn't tell for sure with the other games you've covered, but here it's clear that there's still lots of areas where you lack the knowledge necessary to correctly explain these runs. I'm not saying you're some idiot, it surely looks like you watched a bunch of videos and did some research for this, however unless you spend a decent amount of time running yourself or an enormous amount of time doing research, I'm afraid you'll be spreading misinformation (unless you have someone review the script, like now, but then again I may still have made some mistakes). If you want your commentary to be up to a decent level of quality I think you'll have to slow down this series significantly so you can dig a lot deeper into every game you talk about. Anyway, it's your channel, do what you want with it as long as you properly credit your sources. ;-) Hope this helps.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment