Butterscotch x Anon

>The final bell of the day rings and everyone rushes to their lockers so they can start spring break as fast as possible.
>You would run out there but being trampled doesn't seem like an ideal way to go into the weekend.
>Instead you sit in class with the seven girls you call friends.
“So, what's everyone got planned this next week?”
>Dash unsurprisingly is the first to speak up.
>”Well, we're all gonna have a sleepover a Butters’ place. How about you?”
“I dunno, probably just what I normally do when there's no school and you all are busy.”
>”Come on Anon, I'm sure you've got more planned than jerkin off and sleeping.”
“Dash dude”
>All the girls look at her in surprise that she'd actually go far enough to say it.
>”Relax, I'm joking.”
>She looks back at the girls, and back at you with a smile. Don't worry, I'm sure some plans will fall into your lap.”
>That was weird but you ignore it
>After a bit the hallways clear out and you all make your way to your lockers.
>You put in your combo, open up and a sealed green letter floats out onto the floor.
>You pick it up and look at the glittery B crafted on the front.
>Who could this possibly be from?
>You open it and the card inside with a dumb smile on your face
>”You're invited to my spring break sleepover. Come over after school..y'know… i-...if you want to..”
>She's even shy in her letters, how adorable.
>Although
>It's weird that she'd invite a guy to an all girl sleepover.
>You shoot her a quick text to make sure you were supposed to get an invite but for now you stash it and start your walk home.
>A few minutes into your walk your phone buzzes.
>You look at Scotch’s reply
>”Y-yeah you can come”
>”If you want me too”
>”Don't feel like you have too”
>You text her that you'd love to come over and after you pack a bag you'll be there.

>You throw some pj pants and a toothbrush into a bag and make your way to B’s house.
>You ring the bell and she answers the door
>”H-Hiya Anon.”
“What's up?”
>She steps to the side letting you in her cheeks srawberry red
>”N-Nothing much, um all the girls are already upstairs. You can sit your bag up there i-if you want.”
“Alrighty, thanks again for inviting me.”
>”N-no problem.”
>As you follow her around to her room you look around.
>For as many animals as she has you'd think her house would be a hell of a lot messier.
>Eventually you get to her room and greet the girls.
>The night goes on without a hitch and one by one each of the girls tap out to Mr.Sandman.
>Even Dash didn't make it all night.
>The final two ended up being you and Butters.
>You just shoot the shit for a while.
>As you talk you can feel her warm up more and more to you.

“Hey B?”
>”Y-yeah?”
“Can I ask you something?”
>”Yes o-of course Anon”
“What made you invite me?”
>”Well w-we're all good friends and I figured y-you’d have fun.”
“Hey um..”
>You sigh
>Just ask her Anon. It couldn't hurt.
“Would you um..Would you like to uh go out sometime?”
>Her cyan eyes light up like you've never seen before and she nods violently.
>You can't stop yourself from snickering at her cuteness.
>You pat the spot next to you and she scoots over and lays her head on your shoulder.
“We should probably get some sleep huh?”
>She intertwines her fingers in yours making your heart explode.
>”Yeah.”
“Night B.”
>”Night Anon”
>And that's how it all started about six months ago.

>Your alarm bunny hops on the bed waking you up.
>You brush your long pink hair out of your eyes and pet the fluffy creature on your chest.
“Well good morning Angel. Are you hungry?”
>The small rabbit taps his feet in impatience.
>You pick him up along with your phone and head to the kitchen.
>Once you're done making everyone including yourself breakfast, you check your phone an see a text from Anon.
>”Happy 4 month Anni sweetheart<3”
>Your heart melts through your chest and you squeal.
>Quickly you send him back one.
>Happy 4 months Nonny <3
>You make your way back upstairs and find something to put on.
>Anon does love it when you wear tights or yoga pants.
>Not that you mind when he gets a little handsy
>You feel the blood rush to your cheeks and…
>Other places
>You tuck yourself between your legs and squeeze into a pair of tights and a short green skirt and a tank top.
>After you're finished getting dressed you say your goodbye’s to your pets and head to school.


>You arrive at school a little earlier than normal so you can see B before school starts.
>After a little bit you see your pink haired love round the corner and sprint towards you.
>Scotchy jumps and you catch her in your arms, spinning her around to soften the momentum before sitting her down
“Hey there hot stuff.”
>She blushes and twirls a strand of her hair.
>”H-hi big guy.”
>You lean in and give her a long deep kiss
>After a bit she pulls back with a smile on her lips and her eyes half glazed over.
“So, where do you wanna go for our anniversary tonight?”
>”I-i was thinking maybe we could relax at my house.”
>”If that's okay with you that is.”
>You tussle her long velvet hair
“Of course it is, you know I’m happy as long as we get to hang out.”
>She smiles tangles her fingers with yours.”
>”I-I love you.”
>You kiss her on the forehead
“I love you too”
“Ohh ohhhhh!”
>You accidentally scare Butters making her jump.
“Oopsie I’m sorry sweetheart, I just remembered.”
>She giggles
>”It’s okay, what’d you remember?”
>You reach into your coat pocket and grab the long pink box inside
“It’s all yours.”
>She grabs it with a bright glint of excitement in her eyes
>After a little fiddling with the wrapping she pulls out a long strap of leather broken up in the middle by a hollow metal heart

>”Anon, you shouldn't have I-I don't deserve this.”
“I know you wanted one, so I figured why not. Plus maybe it'll have some use later on.
>You can see her blush and bite her lip.
>You put it on her before sitting and talking for a bit as people start showing up.
>Before long the first bell rings and you two split your ways.
>With your mind occupied the day flies past.
>Even Scotchy doesn't want to stick around with the girls and excuses both of you before almost dragging you out the door.
>It doesn't take long to get to her house.
>Once you're both inside you take everything slow and gently.
>Kissing, rubbing her sides, chest and legs.
>Butters squeaks and her breath hitches with each new spot your hands glide over.
>”Mmm Anon ahhh.”
>You can't help but smile at her.
“Let's get this cute little skirt off.”
>”Mhm”
>You lay Butters back and lock her in a kiss as you pull her skirt off and throw it across the room.
>As you run your hand up her leg you feel a lump causing you to pull back.
>You look down to see a bulge barely restrained by the tights it's trapped under.
”What the fuck?!”
>Quickly Butter’s eyes go from pleasure to shock and horror.
>She..no
>He
>He retracts his legs
>“A-Anon I-I-I can-”
“You can explain? Explain to me that I've been lied to and tricked into dating a dude for four fucking months?!”
>Tears trickle down his face.
>”You can explain that this is some sick god damn joke?”
>“I-I’m so sorry Nonny..”
“So am I”
>You gather up your stuff and walk out slamming the door behind you.
>You feel warmness streak down your face as you walk.

>When you get home you throw your bag off in some corner and hop into bed.
>You're brain is mush
>Why
>Why why why.
>You don't know how to feel at this point.
>You're happiest relationship so far was nothing but a lie.
>After a bit of moaning and groaning you roll over and pass out till tomorrow
>The morning sun peers through your window robbing you of sleeping your problems away.
>You moan and groan but eventually drag yourself out of bed and to school.
>You don't stop by the fountain, or wait for the girls.
>You just drag yourself straight to class.
>The day's just a blur.
>You don't see “him” till lunch
>He shows up halfway through, his hair an absolute rats nest.
>Butterscotch stands across from you but avoids eye contact.
>”H-here...y-you should have these back…”
>The girls stare at you two with wide eyes.
>Butters takes off your hoodie you gave him and lays it on the table along with the necklace.
>”i-i’ll leave you alone..sorry for everything…”
>He waves to the girls and solemnly drags his feet to the external door and leaves.
>”Anon? What was all that about darling?”
>You bunch the hoodie up and lay your head on it.
>It smells sweet, like strawberries and vanilla.
“Doesn't matter at this point.”
>”Ah reckon it does, none of us has ever seen Butters skip school or look so bummed.”
>The rest of the girls goad you on till you can't take it.
“Ugh, fine. I'll give you the short, then will you leave me alone?”
>The girls look at each other and then back at you and nod.

“The short of it is I don't date dudes.”
>”Anon, what a horrible thing to say. You've known her for h-”
>Dash stop Twilight mid sentence.
>”No.”
>She sighs and groans.
>”He's not lying. Butters is a guy. I promised I wouldn't tell anyone but...Anon being upset isn't unjustified.”
>The girls look back and forth bewildered.
>You lay your head back into the sweet scent of the hoodie.
>The rest of the day is drowned out.
>So are the next couple of days.
>You see Butters every now and then.
>He looks a little worse each time you do.
>You'd be lying to yourself if you said it didn't hurt.
>Yeah he's a guy and lied to you but…
>All those nights and feelings were genuine.
>You notice more and more he stops wearing shorts or shirts.
>Eventually you don't see him in anything other than a ratty long sleeve shirt and sweatpants.
>Even on days where it's 80+ degrees out.
>He used to do this back when you first met, so you know the real reason.
>It's not to just be comfy
>After a while you can't take it.
>So one day during lunch as soon as he is about to sit down you grab his hand and pull him aside.
>You drag him to the guys locker room since there was no gym this period.
“Look, B. You can't be doing this again.
>He shrugs
>”D-doing what?”
“Roll up your sleeves.”
>He shakes his head.
“Please, or I'll do it for you.”
>He remains silent but shakes his head.
>You gently grab his wrists with one hand and roll the sleeves up with the other.
>The under side is full of small pink tick marks.
>You blow out a long breath
“C’mere.”
>You wrap your arms around him.
>It first you feel him tense up but quickly he relaxes.

“You're a mess, you know that?”
>You feel his head hang down against you
“But so am I. I've had a bit to think and yknow. You may have lied about being a girl and all but but but, everything else was genuine right?”
>”O-of course.”
“Pinkie promise?”
>He goes through the motions.
“And promise you won't hide anything else from me?”
“He nods.”
“I think we should start over, from the beginning. So, Butterscotch. Would you like to go out sometime?”
>He looks up with a teary eyed smile.
>”I-I’d love too.”
“I'm glad. Oh, um. How should I refer to you I guess?”
>”Whatever makes you feel comfortable Nonny.”
“Alrighty.”
>You pick him up and sling him over one shoulder.
>When you get back to the table the girls all have curious smiles.
>You sit your cutie in a chair and sit next to him.
“Oh, here. Close your eyes.”
>You slip the heart ring collar out of your pocket and place it back where it belongs.
>You hook a finger in the heart and pull him into a kiss.
>Its short but sweet

>”So darlings, you're back together then?”
>You run your fingers through his long pink hair.
“Yeah, I guess we are.”
>He coos and squirms as you scratch lightly at the back of his neck.
>“Well it's nice to see you two smile again.”
>”It's nice to smile again.”
>The rest of the day you too are inseparable.
>You may or may not also sneak him into a few study halls
>The day flies past and before you know it the school day winds down and ends.
>You leave with Butters as soon as the final bell rings.
>He keeps his arms wrapped around yours and his petite fingers locked between your own.
>His fingernails gently scratch against your skin and he rest his head against you for the rest walk to his house.
>Thankfully he lives close and the two of you can relax together.
>Once inside you stretch out across the couch and he quickly fills up his pet's food bowls before sitting by your feet on the couch.
>He fidgets side to side slightly.
“Something wrong?”
>”No um I just..I know we’re restarting our relationship a-and I didn't know how...comfortable you were with m-me..”
>You drop foot onto the floor and sit up enough to grab his hand before laying back and pulling him onto you.
>His squeak of surprise is absolutely adorable.
>Your honestly surprised how well you’re taken everything but, at the end of the day it’s still the same person you loved.
>He nuzzles his head into your chest and scrunches your shirt with his hand.
>You run your fingers through his long pink hair and feel him shiver with goosebumps.
>”Hey..Nonny..?”
“Yeah?”
>”Th-thank you”
“For?”
>”Staying with me..even though i’m...well...me”
>You gently tilt his head to look up to you.
“I mean, it's gonna take some getting used to the whole you being a guy thing but, you're still my Scotchy.”
>He nuzzles back into your chest
>”I’m glad”

>The sun blazing through the blinds wakes you.
>The clock on the cable box says it's almost ten.
>Welp, there goes school.
>You gently shake the the pink poof ball curled up on top of you.
>Two turquoise orbs find your face and produce a smile and a blush beneath them
“Hiya.”
>He rolls over and curls back up.
>”Good morning”
>You chuckle
“You know we slept in right?”
>”Did we?”
“Just a little”
>He snuggles his way between you and the couch for maximum warmth.
>”Comfy”
>At this point you can't hold back your laughter.
“You're so damn adorable.”
>You kiss the top of his head.
“We should get up cutey.”
>”I don't wanna”
“Pleeeease?”
>He rolls over and intertwines his legs around one of yours and gives you a kiss on the cheek.


>”Okay”
>He sits up, yawns and stretches his back making his shirt rise up and expose his soft, slender stomach and v-line making you blush
“So whaddya wanna do for the day?”
>”I-I don’t know, I’ve never skipped school before.”
“How about we go to the mall or something?”
>Butters makes his way into the kitchen and starts filling up the food bowls placed around the apartment.
>”Oh, I don’t want us to get caught or anything but... I wouldn’t mind...spending the day with you.”
>You walk up behind him and rest your arms on his shoulder and your chin on the top of his head.
“Buuut if you’re scared of getting trouble I guesss I could just go.”
>”Nonono, I-I wanna go.”
>You spin him around and give him a quick kiss.
“Good boy.”
>A smile spreads across his face like you’ve never seen before and he nuzzles his face into your chest making you laugh.
“What?”
>”P-please do that m-more?”
>You ruffle his long pink hair and chuckle
“Sure thing”
>You give him a squeeze
>”If we’re going out I should shower.”
“Ohhh so that smell was you”
>He playfully pushes you
>”You’re so mean Nonny.”
“You love it”
>He kisses you on the cheek
 >”I do”

>You pass the time while he showers by playing with the animals and watching TV.
>After a bit you hear footsteps from the stairs.
>Butters rounds the corner in an adorable outfit.
>He's got on a pink beanie, a white tee and some short shorts with leggings underneath and some converse.
>”Hiya.”
“Wow, that's an outfit I haven't seen you in, in a while.”
>He giggles and blushes.
>”H-how do I look?”
>You pick him up under his shoulders and give him a short kiss.
“Adorable, but you knew that. Read to get going?”
>He grabs your hand and intertwines your fingers with his before hugging your arm.
>”Mhm”
>It's a bit of a walk but eventually both of you make it to the mall and go the the food court.
>”Whatchya gonna get Nonny?”
“Some mo-fuckin cinnabons.”
>Butters lightly hits his hand against your chest and giggles.
>”You're silly.”
“No, I'm Anon.”
>”Did you just?”
“Oh god I did.”
>You look at each other for a second before bursting out laughing.

>After you both calm down you walk over and buy two huge cinnamon buns and find somewhere sit.
>Scotchy picks his apart into bite sized pieces.
>”Are you sure this is alright to eat just this for breakfast?”
>You look down at the empty napkin and cover up what may or may not be a bite out of it.
“Come on Scotchy, live a little.”
>You would tussle his hair but your hands are too messy so instead you opt for a sticky kiss on his cheek
>”Ew Nonny, you got me sticky.”
>You shrug
“At least I took you out to eat first.”
>He starts to blush.
>”N-not like that.”
“I know. Ugh, I'm gonna go wash my hands. I'll be right back cutie.”
>”Okay.”
>You quickly make your way to the bathroom, wash your hands and grab some wet paper towels before heading back.
>Once you get back to the food court you see a girl get up and leave from your table.
>You walk back and sit next to Butters.
“Who was that?”
>”N-no one.”
“Gimme your hands.”
>You take the wet paper towels and start to wipe the frosting off of his hands.
“Come on Scotchy, you know you can talk to me.”
>”She...she's an ex of mine..”
>He let's his hair droop in front of his eyes.
“Don't wanna talk about it?”
>”Please?”
>You put a finger under his chin and gently make him look at you.
“Hey, just remember you're all mine now. Nobody can change that okay?”
>He stretches up for a kiss and you gladly oblige.
>”I'm glad.”