Gaming: Why is choosing so hard?

LPs
SRW J: I haven't finished this. And it seems that both forums I had posts on have frozen up for various reasons. So continuing would have difficulties, and restarting would have several questions attached, like 'why am I playing this game for the 7th time?'.
New Vegas: Nothing is really stopping me from continuing Latooni's adventures aside from not being in the mood to play New Vegas right now. Would it be a terrible thing to leave it on the back burner a while longer? I do definitely want to get back to this game, the main question is, do you guys still want me to play it for you?
Skyrim: 2 possibilities, one to play as a pure mage who's probably pro-Imperial (And likely a stuck-up nerd because stereotypes are awesome, though new personality ideas would be welcome), and one to play a sneaky archer and backstabber to do the Dark Brotherhood and Theives Guild quests (although theres the question of playing her as a quiet, understated young woman with a streak of nihilism or a psychotic Daedra Worshipper who'll sleep with all the Daedra artifacts in the bed with her).
Fallout 3: I've basically played this game out in terms of content. Only 3 real options remain: Add a fuckton of mods, play an Evil character (Probably with mods), or add a bunch of 'cheat' mods and play as Kamen Rider.
SRW Alpha 2: Basically, a faster, less screenshotty LP where I 'make up' the dialogue. 4 ways it can go:
- Write as it happened: Research the story guide on Gamefaqs along with the series themselves, to 'get it right'.
- Write completely original: Make everything up based solely on what happens on the screen, and my background knowledge.
- Write original Alphaverse: Narrate what happens based on knowledge of the previous Alpha games, giving context to the events and characters given what happened then.
- Write a sequel to my first LP: As above, but basically only assume Alpha Gaiden, and the parts of ALpha 1 that @G directly mentioned, happened. This might not sound that different but it changes how much continuity tangling that I throw into all of this.
Mount and Blade: Options seem to be Vanilla Warband (For Stabbing mans with sharp things, and little else), Expanded Gameplay 3 mod (For a dash of the supernatural, like seasoning), or a total conversion to something like Game of Thrones, LotR, Wheel of Time or, bizarrely, Star Wars (Theres a bunch of historical mods too).
Deus Ex 1: To see if it can do the Cyborg Ninja Boy playthrough that HR wouldn't quite allow.
Master of Orion: Can the Musouquest race triumph over the Galaxy?
A D&D game with edittable party members: To put some familiar faces in the game.
Fallout 1: Will I finally get into this game?
Arcanum: Will Agatina get underway?
Jade Empire: Can I kung fu?

Played for own sake (Althought I'll LP them if you want...)
SRW R: If I'm right and upgrades carry over between plays, I can do the 'Gundam Route' playthrough to see the rest of the game. Not in the greatest rush to do this, since this was a fucker of a game to finish once, but still an option.
OGs/OGG: Mainly just to see the game I played before in better-o-vision, and to see how broken Folka is.
Compact 3: Or I could play this, and also get Betterman and Escaflowne. Primitive gameplay counterbalanced with unique series selection.
L: Delicious Hilde (Although apparently she's in Z2 as well? Thats a temptation, if only PSP emulation could be trusted).
GC/XO: Something about this game appeals to me. At the least I want to see why people complain about the 3D SRWs.
Impact: Does this count as desire for 'game value'?
MX: Only to see what the fuss is about.
Saint's Row 3: To finish it, or at least see how long it takes to crash.
KotOR: To finish it.
WH40K Space Marine: It'd be a change, that's for certain.
Bioshock: To see what the fuss is about.
Planescape Torment: At last.