GPT4o student writing feedback

Me: "You are a high school computer science teacher teaching a cybersecurity and networking course. Provide students with feedback on the following question. Do not provide a grade value. Provide honest feedback with constructive criticisms but also positive comments on what the student did well. Students are still at the beginner level for the topics in these questions. I will provide student responses in my follow up messages.
The Question: In an organization using Microsoft Intune and Azure for security and device management, strict policies like multi-factor authentication (MFA), conditional access, and Zero Trust enforcement can improve security but may also frustrate employees. How can IT administrators find a balance between security and usability? What strategies or policies could they implement to ensure security without negatively impacting productivity?"

GPT4o: "Absolutely, Ben. Please go ahead and provide the student response, and I will generate clear, constructive, and supportive feedback that matches the student's beginner level while highlighting both strengths and areas for improvement."

Me (student response): "Clearly communicate expectations through policies, training, and
acknowledgments of good behavior to help everyone understand and value the importance of
cybersecurity. The sooner you get policies in place; the sooner employees can start following them and
reducing risk to the business."

GPT4o (feedback):
"**Feedback on Student Response:**

You've made a strong start by focusing on **communication and employee awareness**, which are essential components of maintaining a secure and usable environment. Emphasizing the role of **policies, training, and positive reinforcement** shows that you understand that people—not just technology—are key to effective cybersecurity. This is a mature insight for someone still new to the topic.

What you did well:

* You identified that **clear policies and training** can help users understand and follow security expectations, which is absolutely true.
* Including **acknowledgment of good behavior** shows that you're thinking about motivation and culture, not just rules.
* You recognized that **early implementation** of policies helps reduce risk, which shows awareness of proactive IT management.

Suggestions for improvement:

* Try to directly address the **balance between security and usability** mentioned in the question. For example, how might policies or training reduce frustration with MFA or conditional access?
* You could strengthen your answer by briefly mentioning a **specific strategy** IT admins might use, like allowing remembered devices, single sign-on (SSO), or user feedback loops to adjust security measures.
* The sentence structure is a bit repetitive in tone—consider connecting your ideas with transitions that explain cause and effect more clearly (e.g., "By doing X, IT can achieve Y").

Overall, your response shows strong foundational thinking, and with just a little more detail and focus on the core challenge of balancing security and usability, your answers will grow even more effective. Keep it up!"