S-Tier (been here since basically the beginning)

sluttycow
Dibzcraft

A-Tier (not exactly from the beginning, but way before the hype when the community was still small)

Pimpossible
Kacperrutka26
Heralen
Tyler_1290
UnicornAnna
Scope_H3ad
BurningTramps
Smellyburrito42
AnEpicPerson986
insanegguy
Tomathius
Edviin
Hammer_fan
ShutUpBrick
jacobcraft1111
TommySX

B-Tier (joined during the prime of the Reddit community)

LampBro
Hunter6333
ethab1
JordanGlass123
Andyboyonalert
Smeargle123
BadAnt
ElectriCobra
OblivionTU
Rushilton
BushieHalf
Lagoon
SpacepodPrime
thetonyspera

C-Tier (joined from Twitt/Badlion or after those servers got big)

Shadoune666
Defresa
Fezz
SirFluffles
VernonN

D-Tier (may or may not recognize your name, joined post-hype, but not brand new)

Hoookey
Haon
Maxaa30
Guep
Old_Man_Chris
JJL_
ItsColinn
Jqsh
Scartvol

F-Tier (never heard of you, sorry)

Sqahhh
Weeland
Ityoz
Zachf011
Hannahtagggz
Riron
Alexen1_
Bastyflam
Doflamingo
Cnner
Higgy
Nos (unless you’re nospenguin, in which case you are S-tier)