Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- PASTEBIN MONDAY: 6 February 2023
- Last night I completed Shadow Hearts II: Covenant, finally completing my series first plays.
- You can find my Full Playthrough HERE: https://www.twitch.tv/collections/1BQ1b94OQBf5wg
- I really enjoyed the game. It is a fantastic sequel to Shadow Hearts 1 and does a good job setting up the events of Shadow Hearts: From the New World. This game easily has the best writing of the 3 games (not including Koudelka, which has the best writing of the entire series). This game is, however, my least favorite of the trilogy.
- In order of Favorite to Least Favorite:
- 1. Shadow Hearts: From the New World
- 2. Shadow Hearts
- 3. Shadow Hearts II: Covenant
- Imgur Album of Clear Save Scores: https://imgur.com/a/xi7mGUs
- tldr:
- SRTA Clear Time (Segmented Real Time)
- (final boss kill): 27:49:18
- Stream Sessions: 10
- Battles Fought: 336
- Ring Successes: 1013/1066
- Ring Success Rate: 95.03%
- Perfect Successes: 857/1048
- Perfect Success Rate: 81.77% (peaked at 85%)
- Combo Ring Successes: 43/44
- Combo Ring Success Rate: 97.73%
- Shop Ring Successes: 34/35
- Shop Ring Success Rate: 97.14%
- Thoughts:
- THE GOOD:
- Story/Writing:
- - This is one of the best direct sequels to a video game that I have ever played. Shadow Hearts 1 must be included in this discussion as it perfectly lays up the plot threads that get expanded upon in Covenant. Covenant takes those bits of backstory from the China and Europe sections, and flawlessly gives ample meaning and weight to them. This gives the player a bunch of "Ahh hah" moments, if you will, when they connect the dots between the first and second game. This felt very similar to how I felt about Persona 1 -> Persona 2 Duology (This is high praise). Best good ending in the series.
- The Ring (as a followup to SH1):
- - They really outdid themselves with the revamped Ring in Covenant. Fixed all the stupid acceleration issues and made all the areas way easier to see. Huge Improvement!
- The Music:
- - Hirota-san continues to do a fantastic job leading the series compositions. I think his Construction really shines with this soundtrack. Credit also goes to other great composers who worked on this game: Yasunori Mitsuda, Tomoko Kobayashi, Kenji Ito, Mio Isamaya, and Ryo Fukuda.
- THE BAD:
- Difficulty:
- - This game for me... was painfully easy. I'm sure for most people this was not a problem at all since most casual players don't take advantage of the more advanced mechanics like technical rings, the Mind's Eyes, or the Extreme. As someone who really appreciates how hard you can make Shadow Hearts: From the New World, this was a huge let down. Here are some of the reasons why.
- The Ring:
- - Technical Rings are usually 3 frame windows in Covenant (with a few exceptions for playable characters later in the game where they have 2 frame Tech Rings). In FtNW, Technical Rings are 2 frames, with a few rings accessible in the 2nd half of the game that can be 1 frame. As a fighting game fan, the 2 frame rings are just more satisfying to hit. I feel that the 2 frame rings fit more thematically with the Shadow Hearts series, as it forces the player to really be engaged with their party (Every ring really counts). In Covenant, the litany of 3 frame rings made the experience a bit more boring by comparison. I barely had to pay attention during fights to hit the perfects.
- - When you get the Extreme (should you meet the incredibly low bar of 65% Ring Perfect Successes), the game is over. There is no more challenge whatsoever. You just win every boss fight in 4 turns or less and it really cheapens the 2nd half of the game.
- Resources:
- - This game gives you so many items. It's kind of insane. By the end of the game I had 2 Fifth Keys and 3 Third Keys without going out of my way to really get any of them besides one.
- Undercooked Mechanics:
- The Combo System:
- - The Combo "System", if you can really call it that, sucks. It really is underdeveloped compared to what they would do with it just a year later in FtNW. This is not to say that it is ALL bad. In fact, pretty much all of the underlying systems that are present in FtNW, are present in Covenant (like how comboing from a high hit count move into a single hit results in the most damage, how combos change each characters Turn Priority, what can combo into what, etc.). The issue lies in the way the player is forced to interact with the combo system as a whole. The game does a terrible job letting the player know if a move can combo into another move. The player is forced to remember the height (Low, Mid, High) state of the last attack they executed before they execute their next move. The game does tell you where your current attack will send the Enemy, but not the current state of the combo. FtNW fixes this by showing the player those states in real time as well as changing the color of the Enemy state UI if the attack will be guaranteed to miss. The system also doesn't give the player the agency to use combos to their full potential. Combos are best utilized to do short bursts of damage from 1 character to another character and rinse and repeat to potentially give the character they are comboing into more turns. Thus, I mostly stuck to using combos only when the game kinda forces you into using them which was kinda lame.
- The Characters:
- - I just found the characters in this game to be far more boring than Koudelka, SH1, and SH:FtNW. Yuri is mostly not a badass like he was in SH1, and the majority of the supporting cast felt like an afterthought. The character interactions are not as fun and campy as they are in FtNW or SH1. That's fine, this is a far more serious game. But I was really hoping to see a return to form of the character interactions in Koudelka.
- OH MY GOD HOW MANY FALSE AFFORDANCES CAN THEY ADD:
- - This is a minor grievance, but I want to address it regardless. There are a bunch of areas that look like you can go to them, but they are blocked off by an invisible wall. SH:FtNW actually addresses this and makes better use of the space in 3D maps.
- Of course. I'm leaving a many things out as I've spent far too much of my time talking about this game.
- I will be playing Covenant 1 more time probably this year on the Japanese only Director's Cut version. It includes 2 sections with playable boss characters, more Items to collect, and several extra dungeons and superbosses to fight (not to mention that it includes a trailer for the best game ever made, Shadow Hearts: From the New World!!!). I plan to do a lot more with the game in that playthrough, and it should be really fun so do look forward to that.
- MY FINAL MESSAGE:
- SHADOW HEARTS
- F O R E V E R
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment