Candidates for Meta Shield Thursday Night Watch #1: Worst Undertaker Matches

vs. Jimmy Snuka, WrestleMania VII, 4:20, *
vs. Hulk Hogan, Survivor Series '91, 12:45, 1/2*
vs. Giant Gonzalez, WrestleMania IX, 7:33, *1/4
vs. Giant Gonzalez, SummerSlam '93, 8:04, -*
vs. Underfaker, SummerSlam '94, 8:57, -* (Bonus points for being right after a 5-star Bret vs. Owen steel cage match)
vs. Mabel, King of the Ring '95, 10:44, -*1/2 (Bonus points for Mabel going on to beat Savio Vega in the finals, which got -*)
vs. Sycho Sid, WrestleMania 13, 21:19, *1/4 (Bonus points for main eventing over another Bret 5-star match)
vs. Steve Austin, Rock Bottom '98, 21:30, 3/4* (Buried Alive match)
vs. Big Boss Man, WrestleMania XV, 9:46, DUD (Bonus points for HANGING BIG BOSS MAN FROM THE TOP OF THE CELL)
vs. KroniK (w/ Kane), Unforgiven '01, 10:22, -** (Bonus points for beating the guy that trained Eva Marie)
vs. Mr. McMahon, Survivor Series '03, 11:59, * (Triple bonus for Vince literally burying someone, Kane interference, and this match being built on the premise of Vince wanting to hire a motorcycle gang to rape Undertaker's wife)
vs. Dudley Boyz, Great American Bash '04, 14:42, *
vs. Heidenreich, Royal Rumble '05, 13:20, 3/4* ("****3/4, no Jannetty" - SasukeDoctor)
vs. Great Khali, Judgment Day '06, 8:31, *
vs. Big Show, Great American Bash '06, 21:35, -* (Double bonus for Punjabi Prison match and the match being built up by Undertaker being squashed by The Great Khali)
vs. Mark Henry, Unforgiven '07, 11:25, DUD (Bonus points for main eventing over Cena heel turn)
vs. Kane, Hell in a Cell '10, 21:37, 1/2* (Bonus points for, despite being a main event HIAC, continuing the feud three weeks later in a Buried Alive match)