Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Source : https://islamqa.info/fr/answers/164633/un-juif-qui-dementit-le-coran-et-pretend-que-les-juifs-naffirment-pas-quuzayr-est-le-fis-dallah-ni-que-la-main-dallah-est-fermee
- Tafsir of al-Mawardi (2/353).
- They say: If the incriminated statements came from a group, why did they attribute them to the entire community? It would be answered: it is because those who did not adhere to them did not question them after their revelation in the Qur'an. This is why they were attributed to the community even if only a faction of it uttered them.
- Ibn Hajar in Fath Al Bari (3/359) quotes Sharh at-Tirmidhi by Ibn Al Arabi:
- The Jews of the present times (15th century) denounce the statements according to which Uzayr is the son of Allah. This does not exclude that there were others who said it during the lifetime of the Prophet, because the words were revealed in his time at a time when Jews were living with him in Medina and elsewhere. It has not been reported from any of them that he refuted them or commented on them (critically).
- Al Jassas in Ahkam al-qur'an (4/299).
- It is said that He intended to affirm that a group of them said this. The proof of this is that the Jews at the time of the Prophet heard him say this without denying it. […]
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
