Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Hey Sabina,
- Thanks again for the talk. I really appreciate you taking the time to listen to my concerns in regards of the future of SRC.
- As promised, here is a list of things I personally would change in order to make the community happy.
- It will be a big list, so I don't expect you to fix it all at once, maybe take it more as a roadmap.
- The most important part is that someone in charge reads this, so you can pass it to the team.
- I will attach screenshots to the points I am talking about.
- 1: The ads (https://i.imgur.com/AZfSwNH.png)
- I understand that running such a popular website is very expensive. But as you and I agreed, the ads do not look good. It makes SRC look like ad-ware. 4 ads and an auto-playing video is not a good look.
- I don't know much about this kind of thing, so I don't know how expensive it would be to cover the server costs, etc. But maybe set up a donation kind of thing, rewarding the people who donate.
- You have more experience with these kind of things, so I will leave this to you and your team to figure out.
- For such a community driven website, profit really shouldn't be a priority, so I hope that we both can agree on that the ads need to go.
- 2: The categories (https://i.imgur.com/AwGLZJS.png / https://i.imgur.com/V1jRPT1.png)
- Categories are the most important aspect when it comes to a speedrun. So making the categories as visible as possible is very important.
- Hiding them behind arrows or drop-down menus is very anti-consumer.
- I know there is a lot of edge cases with some games only having a few categories, and some games having a lot of them, so I understand that it's hard to make it work for everyone, while still looking clean.
- Here is an example of someone on how they would fix the categories: https://twitter.com/furious_/status/1448718742498779136
- 3: The leaderboards
- The text is way too small. I am at 110% in Chrome, and it's kinda hard to read the text.
- The recent runs section makes no sense. I've already shown you, and I think you took a note of it, but I wanted to point it out again.
- The run I highlighted is an IL run, but is shown as an Any% run. Would be difficult to fix for ILs with longer names, but with how it is right now, it's very confusing: https://i.imgur.com/N4RRsYi.png
- The time section is also broken (https://i.imgur.com/txiSkQi.png). I tried fixing the "Default timing method" in the setting of the game, but it always defaults back to "Real time without loads".
- After changing that, it always shows None.
- Moderators are way on the bottom now, kinda hard to find.
- Overall, I think giving the community more options to customize their boards might be a good option.
- Maybe custom CSS could be implemented?
- Like we all know, your small team can't make the leaderboards look good for every single game, that's impossible. So with the option of custom CSS they can customize stuff to their liking.
- 4: The comments
- I am very on the fence when it comes to the comment section. I am glad that we both agreed that the feature was rushed.
- I don't know if it really adds anything to the experience. Most of the people who submit their runs, exported their videos to Youtube, where you can already comment on the run.
- The biggest problem is, that no one gets notifications for a comment. Not the runner, and not the moderators.
- But should the moderators even get notifications for it? I think it would just add a lot more work for the moderators, where some already have hundreds of runs to look at.
- Another big problem is: Someone submits a run, the comments on the game are not disabled, the runner stops using SRC and then the comments will be an unmoderated mess.
- If it were up to me, I would remove the comment feature. It doesn't really improve the experience, and are just more work for everyone involved.
- I asked on Twitter, and most of the people would also want the comment section removed.
- 5: The WR History graph (https://i.imgur.com/ldIea0b.png / https://i.imgur.com/eeJMQLv.png)
- They are an absolute mess for everything with more than 3 categories.
- The dots are hard to click, and for games with more than 10, the graph is completely gone. This needs a major overhaul.
- 6: How to avoid all this in the future
- I think for the future, it's really important that you don't roll out such a bad working update again.
- I don't dislike the update, I think the fresh look is really nice, especially because before this update, the website hasn't really changed since 2014.
- So your intentions were good, but the execution was not.
- To avoid this kind of thing, I have 2 ideas:
- Idea 1: You either have a team of dedicated speedrunners as a Beta tester team. You can tell them what you are about to change, and what they think. These can be volunteers, because I think a lot of people in the speedrunning community would be willing to volunteer for such a thing.
- Idea 2: Have a Beta website. For example beta.speedrun.com. On that site, you can implement your new ideas, you then let the community know about the new beta version on the website, and they can send you feedback through a form or something.
- Another idea to implement features that the community REALLY wants, is to setup a Feature Request site, similar to Discord's.
- Someone can present an idea, and people can up/downvote it.
- If you then see a feature request with a lot of upvotes, you can then try to implement it.
- I also mentioned it, but the redirect to SpeedRunsLive is also broken since their update.
- It should redirect to: https://www.speedrunslive.com/profile/USER instead of https://www.speedrunslive.com/profiles#!/USER
- 7: Other leaderboards
- As we've also already talked about it, communities such as DKC, MegaMan and Super Metroid have their leaderboards on their own website, which is of course fine. We can't force them to use SRC.
- But here's the problem: New people go onto SRC, and then they check out the leaderboards for MM1. The leaderboards are way out of date and not accurate in any way.
- People of the community know to use https://megamanleaderboards.net/ instead, but newer runners will submit to their SRC site.
- I think you should try to contact these communities. Try to either mirror their leaderboards on SRC, or make a redirect, instead of having inaccurate boards on SRC.
- Here's a list of big communities with external leaderboards:
- https://dkcspeedruns.com/Main_Page
- https://megamanleaderboards.net/
- https://haloruns.com/
- https://deertier.com/
- The page when submitting a run is also still the old design: https://i.imgur.com/anglENu.png
- Here is also a tweet with a bunch of good feedback: https://twitter.com/ashskyevee/status/1448832062962741261
- Most of the feedback on one of SRC's tweet is also helpful: https://twitter.com/speedruncom/status/1448690070333140993
- When submitting a bug report, you never get feedback if it's being worked on or not. So it seems pointless to even submit a bug report, because a lot of bugs won't be fixed.
- Overall, I think the sidebar from the old design is way cleaner (https://i.imgur.com/loWCGPT.png).
- The links to everything important are way easier to find. Putting everything on top with such a small font is really annoying.
- A few communities were on blackout, because they were not happy with the update (https://i.imgur.com/kBsnTCH.png).
- So with everything I mentioned, I think Elo's main focus should be to be more transparent and communicative with the community.
- Be more transparent on what's about to change, and more importantly, listen to the community!
- You said you care a lot about the speedrunning community, so if you really want to make a good website for them, you need to listen to their feedback.
- Kind regards,
- Florian
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment