Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Hello! I operate my streams on a raffle system. Everybody present has the same chance to win. Many people think this is unfair, and have suggestions to improve it.
- Before I answer questions about my raffle, I should explain my goal with the raffle system. I have fans in all time zones. Some have to quit my stream at 2:00p, because this is 2:00a their time. Some cannot join until 3:00p, because this is 9:00a their time. I want all of these kinds of fans to have the same chance of winning, as long as they are watching the stream. I also have two sorts of people who come to my stream; "die-hard fans" and "casual fans". Die-hard fans will wake up early in the morning every time, and stay all day. They are absolutely obsessed and I do not know how they get bored! Casual fans will float into my stream for 2-3 hours, whatever fits their schedule.
- I want all of these kinds of people to have the same chance of winning, as long as they are present. Someone who watches the stream for 1 hour should have 10% as much chance of winning as someone who watches for 10 hours. Someone who watches for two hours in the morning should have the same chance of winning as someone who watches for two hours in the evening. Someone who joins my stream for the first time today should have the same chance of winning as someone who has been watching for a year. That seems the most fair to me.
- ================================================================================
- Q: How about a queue instead of a raffle? You come to the stream and your name goes at the back of the queue.
- A: I currently have about 50-100 people who rotate in and out of my streams from week to week, and I can draw about 3-6 pictures per week. To get through a queue of 100 people, it would take me 50 drawings. Would you want to be at the back of a 3 month queue for free art?
- It is possible your answer is, "Yes! I can wait 3 months for free art!" Unfortunately it is a trick question. If this sort of free art queue were implemented, it would not have 100 people in it: it would have 1,000 people in it. Many of them would be friends-of-friends or duplicate accounts. Many of them would have never come to the stream before. If attendance were somehow mandatory, they would simply come once when their name was called. Many of them would not know my name. This system would be abused, it is not a robust system.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: How about if you don't win all day, you have a better chance to win? Like maybe you get more and more raffle draws as the day goes on?
- A: With your idea, someone who comes at 10:00a has a much better chance to win than someone who comes at 6:00p, even though they are both present for the same amount of time. That is unfair to the person who shows up late.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: How about if you don't win all day, you have a better chance to win... but it carries over into the next stream, to fix the time zone thing?
- A: With your idea, someone who comes for the first time has almost no chance to win, if they happen to be in a room with die-hard fans. This is unfair to new fans.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: How about if someone wins, they're removed from the raffle for the day?
- A: This is an OK idea. But, I think someone who is dedicated enough to watch my stream for 12 hours should not be punished because they won a raffle at 9:00a that morning. It seems unfair to my die-hard fans.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: How about if someone wins, they're removed from just a few raffles?
- A: This is an OK idea, but how many is "a few"? Currently, I don't let people win two raffles consecutively, but that is the only limitation I impose. ...Yes, someone might win 3 raffles in a day. I think it's fun when this happens.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: How about something kind of like one of these other ideas... but less?
- A: That is unfair. But less.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Q: I have been coming to your stream for 3 months and I have not won yet! Can't you change your rules? I have been so unlucky. Can't you make an exception? Just to be compassionate?
- A: This is a good point. Let me tell you something about how RNG works and how human beings work. Give me a moment to collect my thoughts... ... ...
- ................................................................................
- If there are 30 people here and you are present for 5 raffles, what are your chances of winning at least once? ...Well, it is a little over 30%, it is unlikely you will win. Well, what if you are present for 25 raffles? Now you have a 97% chance of winning, it is almost certain. "That's fine," you think, "So if I just wait for about 5 streams I will almost certainly get free art!" Yes, that is how it works statistically. Of course there is a one-in-thirty chance you could wait that long and not get free art. But eventually after 10 streams, 20 streams, it will eventually happen if you are patient.
- Here is something admirable about my fanbase though. There are about 30 people present in my streams, which means there is almost always somebody who has missed out on that 97% chance! It happens. One of my moderators Dreamous did not win a raffle for 2 months, even though he was present almost every time I streamed. So, if there is almost always SOMEONE in chat who has incredibly bad luck... then why is there not almost always someone who is complaining about their terrible luck?
- The reason people do not complain, is that they do not think in terms of free art. They think about the social experience, of getting to watch me create something from scratch and talk to other people about their hobby. Sometimes they even forget I have not technically drawn for them -- Nidoking and Guilmon are their favorite characters, and even though I inadvertently catered to their interests during a stream, they absent-mindedly forget they were not the ones to request those characters. They also contribute in other ways. Sometimes they will come up with a pose or a character which gets picked, even though they did not technically win the raffle. Almost everybody is involved in what I draw, and even when they're not involved they often forget.
- Please do not come to my stream with the mindset of "free art." Be happy when other people win. Encourage them when they are excited about a character you've never heard of. Be inquisitive and make friends. That is really what the stream is about. There is an internet full of free pornography if that is your thing, and if you really want someone to just draw your favorite idea -- you can pay an artist, and they will draw it. But, you cannot pay an artist to be your friend. These close-knit communities where you see the same face on a weekly basis, and interact with artists directly are something special. Let's be friends.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment