Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- I'm not skilled and I am a casual gamer so a lot of the more complex items illude me or frustrate me. This review is my personal opinions and it's OK if you have a different one. That's why we're all human and should have that as an inalienable right. If you have a differing opinion, feel free to include it in the comments or your own review.
- Review accurate as of 8/3/25.
- TL;DR Review:
- It's a great game but you need mods to make it actually playable. I also believe that the story has much to be desired but have not completed it at this time. I absolutely love the idea of this game. But you need to play it with mods if you don't want to loose your head in all the little annoyances that causes you to keep loosing progress.
- This game has several parts: Base/City Building; TPS Combat; RPG; Single Player Story; Strategy; Resource Management and Distribution
- As of writing this review, I have NOT finished the story, nor do I feel driven to do so at this time. It's not like Lord Ashbourn's "brigands" have any depth in the first few chapters of the game. I'd much rather work on my Resource Management and Distribution; Base/City Building; and honing my competency in combat with low-level bandits.
- Overall Personal Rating: 6/10 - Great concept and is fun, but needs a lot of work and polish to become fully playable.
- Devs - Please read detailed review below as well as my feedback to you because it is crucial that you take to heart at least some of what is there. <3
- ---------------------
- Detailed Review of each component:
- Base/City Building - 5 of 10 - This component of the game feels very half-baked. Instead of separating the building from that of you as the player, they're tied together. Thus meaning if you're walking around and kick a stump.. well guess what.. you're not moving until you go around the stump. The building elements take a significant amount practice and grind to even understand what components are built in which building. While I understand that most games like this are very "figure it out", I personally feel that this game's audience is slightly different. The audience for this game instead is more that of people who don't regularly have the time to play games but like to casually enjoy them. I also personally enjoy the fact that this is accentuated by that of the Third Person Style rather than Top-Down style. Which is why I wish (like with Starfield) I wish they gave you the option to work in Top-Down or TPS with a button press and I hope in future releases, it will highlight edges of neutral villages and no-build areas as well as disconnecting the player model from the building model.
- NOTE: I am not including bandit raids in this part, rather the TPS part below as you cannot avoid these raids no matter how strong your defense.
- --
- TPS (third person shooter) Combat/Style - 4 of 10 - This component of the game is laughable at how bad it's implemented. While the swords and bows feel good (heavy, realistic) and I have no complaints about that - the whole combat system is "Directional" but there is no clear way to define the direction you want to attack in. This unfortunately is the same problem with logging :(. I personally always use bows so I was very excited to feel the grind of learning to use this world's equipment... However I was quickly disappointed as, with enough money or thoughtful planning on the players part in the early game, you can simply use skill books to change your abilities to wield any weapon or technology. So - Into agility all my points went, and now I can headshot with relative ease.
- Installing mods to reduce the attacks from wild animals while you're out exploring is a must, however as they are everywhere and essentially will always attack, even if you think you are well outside their detection range.
- Bandit Raids are a massive pain in the keester. You may believe you're good or prepared, but get the floor wiped within seconds of facing a bandit group. In addition, there is a bug where after I clear a camp, I cannot claim the flag of the camp, so the bandits respawn indefinitely. While I now see that as a plus (since I have mods and can wipe the floor with even mid-range boss battles), I worry about the implications of the story as I think the game requires you to clear the encampments to progress.
- NOTE: Yes, I know this is a skill issue and I acknowledge that all I need to do is "Get Gud" as the kids these days would say.
- --
- RPG; Single Player Story - 1 of 10 - Okay.. Yes, this game uses AI generated voices and some of the text is also clearly AI generated. I would not mind if the story made sense or was actually good or gave you meaningful choices. To start, the "character creator" is one of like 12 options and you cannot customize anything about these options nor (as far as chapter 2 - Padsdow) cannot change your character's appearance after you've made your choice. The elements are confusing and I frequently find myself lost or not caring about who is around me or their stories. I understand that this is an early access game.. But so was Satisfactory when I bought it back in 2017, but it still had more of a story at the time than this game.
- It is at this point, if you're reading this much, that you should begin to see a pattern emerging: There is too much going on with this title and many components are half-baked to ship a release that is partially broken to enable the devs to earn more money to develop the game further (note, I am not a gamedev but I have some suggestions further below to resolve these issues).
- --
- Strategy; Resource Management and Distribution- 7 of 10 - I will say that sitting down to play this game, I initially approached it like I would Sims, City Skylines, or Skyrim - Just going into it and having fun. If I were to start a new save, however.. I would most likely elect to start with mods out of the gate AND I would have a plan. While fun is a big part of any game, this game is actually most fun when you are racking your brain going.. "how do I get that here?" In Satisfactory, that may mean belting thousands of items across your world using conveyors, depots, trains, and planes (drones). But how do you do that in a mid-century medieval world? Well.. with people, of course! You need to carefully plan expansion, else you may end up snuffing it in a spectacular way super early. Have too many people in a village? Guess what? Your people are going to starve. Have not enough? Guess what? They're gonna die.
- Figuring out strategy and resource management with distribution is a MASSIVE pain in the keester. But it's the most fun I've had in this game. Which leads into...
- --------------
- HOW TO MAKE THE GAME BETTER - Letter to the Devs
- Again, please note that I am NOT a gamedev. But these are some ideas I would strongly encourage the devs to take:
- Focus on the strongest components of the game FIRST and polish them - This means what is the most complete. Finish the game, but not all at once. People will gladly come back more frequently if you elect to piecemeal updates. Don't fix all the components at the same time. Fix bugs as they happen, but focus on polishing features one at a time. This will allow you to put all your efforts into one component instead of all the components.
- Learn from the mistakes (and triumphs) of other game creators like CDPR by enabling and even embracing mods and modders. Communicate with modders and bring them onboard to your team. Some mods fix, help augment, or even completely repair your game. By working with these modders to bring their mods into your game as official code (by properly licensing their code and paying them for their work and not just implementing their code without speaking with them or doing something underhanded) will garner much public support and let the world know your game is a community-driven game. Developers that do not listen to their community, will ALWAYS fail.
- Open a shop with merchandise so the community can continue supporting development of the game. I want to get a Bellwright T-Shirt and mug. I'd love to get it from official channels and support development. Don't become Star Citizen where you just become greedy and start selling in-game components for a paycheck, however. Use the money and actually put it to bettering your game. You can also use the money that fans pay you through donations and merch purchases to pay modders for licenses like I mentioned in the last point above. This will garner much needed support and boost both internal and community moral.
- Host a quarterly (every 3-4 mos or more regularly if it takes off) update live stream on Twitch and YouTube, and leave the recordings public with COMMENTS ENABLED to allow community members to comment and give feedback, submit bug and suggestions, as well as learn from one another. Having a YouTube channel that has video content demonstrating each aspect of the game as a "how to" would also be great. While it's not much, you can earn ad revenue as well as connecting to your merch store to help raise profits while also giving to the community in a knowledgeable and efficient way.
- Finally, consider a 1-, 5-, and 10-year plan for the game, even if you are bored with the concepts or development. This may mean planning on open-sourcing the code or finding a company who can continue the legacy. Development takes a lot of efforts and time (as well as money) and burnout is a serious problem. By planning - just like you ask your players to in your world - and strategizing, you can head off burnout and transitional issues as they arise. Don't plan your next game, instead plan on how to make this game better. Don't plan how to make a million dollars, plan on how to make your customers want to spend a million to keep your game going.
- TL;DR for the devs: Focus on polishing one feature at a time as well as bug updates; work with the community and your modders to enable official support for the features that are in the mods; focus on communications with your community via regular live streams and videos via YouTube and Twitch; monetize with common-sense instead of trying to sell someone horse armour; strategize with your community and internally to head-off burnout by planning expansions and pivots in case something breaks or doesn't work out. Finally - Be as transparent as possible. Even if this means getting on your hands and knees and begging - if it means lowering your honour or even saying things business advisors would tell you never to say. Being overly communicative and transparent with your community and investors will be better than shutting down and not providing anything other than annual updates. Silence is not good. Silence is bad. Devs need to learn this early because it can destroy a game faster than greed or incompetent leadership.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment