foongus

Untitled

Apr 15th, 2020
142
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 52.13 KB | None | 0 0
  1. [redacted]
  2.  
  3. [30-Mar-20 08:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  4. pony isn’t auto broken without trap
  5.  
  6. [30-Mar-20 08:44 PM] brewfasa#4532
  7. I just feel like that’s a lazy af excuse
  8.  
  9. [30-Mar-20 08:44 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  10. its definitely pretty powerful
  11.  
  12. [30-Mar-20 08:45 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  13. pony in sun basically has no good answers without dig
  14.  
  15. [30-Mar-20 08:45 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  16. morning sun/flare blitz/high horsepower/wow pony is pretty hard to deal with too
  17.  
  18. [redacted]
  19.  
  20. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] levi#6206
  21. Want to vote on rufflet next week?
  22.  
  23. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  24. i think we should wait more
  25.  
  26. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] Ninja#8225
  27. suspect rufflet
  28.  
  29. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] hongli#4483
  30. vote on rufflet as in
  31.  
  32. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] hongli#4483
  33. vote for suspect?
  34.  
  35. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  36. unless we want to keep the lcpl meta the same
  37.  
  38. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  39. the entire time
  40.  
  41. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] brewfasa#4532
  42. it’s def better to suspect ruff
  43.  
  44. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] levi#6206
  45. And if it comes down to a suspect I think I’m coming around to dokas suggestion that we just let it carry through week one of lcpl
  46.  
  47. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] brewfasa#4532
  48. I was being facetious
  49.  
  50. [30-Mar-20 08:46 PM] levi#6206
  51. I’d rather the following weeks of lcpl to be rufflet-free
  52.  
  53. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] levi#6206
  54. Yea, if it’s less than 80% then it’s a suspect
  55.  
  56. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  57. do you think we will see more rufflet usage in SM
  58.  
  59. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] brewfasa#4532
  60. for sure
  61.  
  62. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] hongli#4483
  63. rufflets have to be scarf though
  64.  
  65. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] hongli#4483
  66. in sm
  67.  
  68. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] brewfasa#4532
  69. it’s how that shit goes
  70.  
  71. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  72. i feel like the way people are using rufflet in SS, it could definitely be used the same way in SM
  73.  
  74. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] Serene Grace#5243
  75. The memers in the drifloon suspect ruined it for everyone
  76.  
  77. [30-Mar-20 08:47 PM] brewfasa#4532
  78. the speed tiers tho
  79.  
  80. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  81. Fuck with it dokas right
  82.  
  83. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  84. well webs+rufflet is like the most popular combo
  85.  
  86. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] hongli#4483
  87. ya but
  88.  
  89. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] hongli#4483
  90. gastly
  91.  
  92. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  93. gastly isnt that common
  94.  
  95. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  96. gastly also isnt switching in
  97.  
  98. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] hongli#4483
  99. isnt gastly
  100.  
  101. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] hongli#4483
  102. a top tier mon
  103.  
  104. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  105. in sm?
  106.  
  107. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  108. and gastly doesnt ohko
  109.  
  110. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  111. i mean like its used with abra
  112.  
  113. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  114. gas is v common
  115.  
  116. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  117. exclusively
  118.  
  119. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  120. nah that’s not true
  121.  
  122. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  123. well yeah but id say like 85% of its usage
  124.  
  125. [30-Mar-20 08:48 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  126. is with abra
  127.  
  128. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  129. gastly is super good in theory
  130.  
  131. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  132. on its own
  133.  
  134. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  135. it’s good in practice
  136.  
  137. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  138. but in practice, it usually falls short
  139.  
  140. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  141. as well
  142.  
  143. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  144. false
  145.  
  146. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  147. I
  148.  
  149. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  150. K
  151.  
  152. [30-Mar-20 08:49 PM] Serene Grace#5243
  153. Sup @Luthier nice lcpl sign up post I believe that you have limited availability and are not trying to tank your value
  154.  
  155. [redacted]
  156.  
  157. [30-Mar-20 08:50 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  158. little known fact
  159.  
  160. [30-Mar-20 08:50 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  161. studying for mcat is more than a 40 hour/week job+full time school
  162.  
  163. [redacted]
  164.  
  165. [30-Mar-20 08:50 PM] Pablo#5523
  166. i have limited availability i play pokemon all day no time for lcpl
  167.  
  168. [redacted]
  169.  
  170. [30-Mar-20 08:59 PM] brewfasa#4532
  171. anyways I’m down for as soon as we announce cutie ban, ruff suspect
  172.  
  173. [30-Mar-20 09:00 PM] brewfasa#4532
  174. we can get this done as soon as lcpl hits
  175.  
  176. [30-Mar-20 11:27 PM] jake#8907
  177. https://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/cutiefly-has-been-quickbanned-from-ss-lc.3661908/
  178.  
  179. {Embed}
  180. https://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/cutiefly-has-been-quickbanned-from-ss-lc.3661908/
  181. Announcement - Cutiefly has been quickbanned from SS LC.
  182. Cutiefly has been quickbanned from SS LC.
  183.  
  184. This is an unprecedented situation because of the timing of the quickban. Quickbans normally take place immediately following major metagame changes, such as the release of Pokemon Home. Cutiefly has been available to use throughout t...
  185. https://www.smogon.com/forums/media/twitter.png
  186.  
  187. [30-Mar-20 11:32 PM] jake#8907
  188. ruff will go up tomorrow i think
  189.  
  190. [30-Mar-20 11:34 PM] jake#8907
  191. @brewfasa @levi @BurntZebra @Pablo @Kingler @LilyAC @Luthier @Ninja @Shrug @starmaster please pm me your paragraphs asap
  192.  
  193. [30-Mar-20 11:34 PM] jake#8907
  194. preferably within 24 hours
  195.  
  196. [30-Mar-20 11:35 PM] Kingler#6931
  197. .
  198.  
  199. [30-Mar-20 11:35 PM] Kingler#6931
  200. paragraphs LOL
  201.  
  202. [30-Mar-20 11:35 PM] Pablo#5523
  203. o shit
  204.  
  205. [30-Mar-20 11:35 PM] Pablo#5523
  206. i gotta do this
  207.  
  208. [30-Mar-20 11:36 PM] jake#8907
  209. yes
  210.  
  211. [30-Mar-20 11:36 PM] jake#8907
  212. it doesn't have to be elaborate
  213.  
  214. [30-Mar-20 11:37 PM] jake#8907
  215. but preferably more than "bye bye"
  216.  
  217. [30-Mar-20 11:37 PM] jake#8907
  218. :angery:
  219.  
  220. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  221. smd @jake
  222.  
  223. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  224. also ill do it tomorrow
  225.  
  226. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] jake#8907
  227. ok thanks
  228.  
  229. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  230. but if possible i would appreciate a reminder
  231.  
  232. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  233. that would be super nice
  234.  
  235. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  236. if u could do that
  237.  
  238. [redacted]
  239.  
  240. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  241. ?
  242.  
  243. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] jake#8907
  244. sure
  245.  
  246. [30-Mar-20 11:44 PM] Luthier#1578
  247. ty
  248.  
  249. [31-Mar-20 09:54 AM] Shrug#7659
  250. can i copy from my post
  251.  
  252. [31-Mar-20 10:44 AM] Shrug#7659
  253. https://pastebin.com/EYHw4xPa
  254.  
  255. [31-Mar-20 10:45 AM] hongli#4483
  256. i'd include the parts w ruff too tbh
  257.  
  258. [31-Mar-20 10:46 AM] Coconut#8762
  259. I'd prefer if you copied from your post, actually
  260.  
  261. [31-Mar-20 10:47 AM] hongli#4483
  262. oh i assumed that's what that was
  263.  
  264. [31-Mar-20 10:48 AM] Shrug#7659
  265. i did copy
  266.  
  267. [31-Mar-20 11:32 AM] jake#8907
  268. will add when home
  269.  
  270. [31-Mar-20 11:32 AM] jake#8907
  271. thanks for doing it so quick all
  272.  
  273. [31-Mar-20 12:35 PM] Pablo#5523
  274. will write later today
  275.  
  276. [31-Mar-20 11:01 PM] jake#8907
  277. @Pablo @Luthier @Kingler yours are the only ones i am missing
  278.  
  279. [31-Mar-20 11:26 PM] Pablo#5523
  280. writing rn
  281.  
  282. [31-Mar-20 11:36 PM] jake#8907
  283. thx
  284.  
  285. [01-Apr-20 12:00 AM] jake#8907
  286. any objections to ruff deadline being the same as vulpix
  287.  
  288. [01-Apr-20 12:00 AM] jake#8907
  289. seemed to work out ok last time
  290.  
  291. [01-Apr-20 12:01 AM] jake#8907
  292. (this would end april 10th if it were to match up exactly same dates)
  293.  
  294. [01-Apr-20 12:01 AM] jake#8907
  295. or is the inclusion of two weekends preferable
  296.  
  297. [01-Apr-20 12:01 AM] jake#8907
  298. i don't really have strong feelings either way
  299.  
  300. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] Serene Grace#5243
  301. we could extend it to the 12th, that still gets it before week 1 of lcpl
  302.  
  303. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] Ninja#8225
  304. well
  305.  
  306. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] Ninja#8225
  307. people might not vote
  308.  
  309. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] Ninja#8225
  310. in time
  311.  
  312. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] jake#8907
  313. (it would need to be voted on before week 1 if that's the case)
  314.  
  315. [01-Apr-20 12:02 AM] jake#8907
  316. yea
  317.  
  318. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] jake#8907
  319. i think making sure people have enough time to vote > lcpl week 1
  320.  
  321. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] jake#8907
  322. though both are important
  323.  
  324. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] jake#8907
  325. i think ten days was pretty fair overall last time but
  326.  
  327. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] Serene Grace#5243
  328. two weekends isnt a big deal because of corona
  329.  
  330. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] jake#8907
  331. i don't know everyone's thoughts
  332.  
  333. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] jake#8907
  334. yeah
  335.  
  336. [01-Apr-20 12:03 AM] Serene Grace#5243
  337. I would end it on the 10th
  338.  
  339. [01-Apr-20 12:07 AM] hongli#4483
  340. when would ruff suspect be going up
  341.  
  342. [01-Apr-20 12:07 AM] hongli#4483
  343. in this scenario
  344.  
  345. [01-Apr-20 12:07 AM] jake#8907
  346. now
  347.  
  348. [01-Apr-20 12:07 AM] hongli#4483
  349. uh
  350.  
  351. [01-Apr-20 12:08 AM] levi#6206
  352. Ok let’s do it
  353.  
  354. [01-Apr-20 12:08 AM] hongli#4483
  355. what happened to
  356.  
  357. [01-Apr-20 12:08 AM] hongli#4483
  358. wanting to see how the meta settles after qt ban
  359.  
  360. [01-Apr-20 12:09 AM] jake#8907
  361. i was under the impression we were moving immediately into ruff suspect?
  362.  
  363. [01-Apr-20 12:10 AM] jake#8907
  364. but if that's not the case then i'm ok talking about it
  365.  
  366. [01-Apr-20 12:11 AM] hongli#4483
  367. i'm of the opinion that rufflet will most likely still be broken even without webs
  368.  
  369. [01-Apr-20 12:12 AM] hongli#4483
  370. but like webs were such an integral part of rufflet being so unmanageable that i think it's jumping the gun a bit
  371.  
  372. [01-Apr-20 12:12 AM] hongli#4483
  373. to move immediately to a suspect after the qt ban
  374.  
  375. [01-Apr-20 12:13 AM] hongli#4483
  376. there's a ton of opportunity cost to running band ruff now, and things can more easily revenge sub/bu+2 atks ruff since a bunch of things can actually have the opportunity to outspeed it now
  377.  
  378. [01-Apr-20 12:19 AM] jake#8907
  379. when would you feel it is appropriate to move into a suspect following the cutie ban (or do you think there is potential to not suspect it at all)
  380.  
  381. [01-Apr-20 12:19 AM] jake#8907
  382. i know where i personally stand on it but jc
  383.  
  384. [01-Apr-20 12:20 AM] Serene Grace#5243
  385. The supect is the waiting to see the meta
  386.  
  387. [01-Apr-20 12:20 AM] Serene Grace#5243
  388. we see the new meta in the suspect and we vote based on that
  389.  
  390. [01-Apr-20 12:34 AM] hongli#4483
  391. even if you use the suspect as a testing period for the meta
  392.  
  393. [01-Apr-20 12:34 AM] hongli#4483
  394. perhaps there were innovations being suppressed by cutie's dominance
  395.  
  396. [01-Apr-20 12:34 AM] hongli#4483
  397. that would help keep rufflet in line
  398.  
  399. [01-Apr-20 12:34 AM] hongli#4483
  400. stuff that may take a while to come out and see usage
  401.  
  402. [01-Apr-20 12:35 AM] hongli#4483
  403. i think waiting at least a week
  404.  
  405. [01-Apr-20 12:35 AM] hongli#4483
  406. would be ideal
  407.  
  408. [01-Apr-20 12:39 AM] jake#8907
  409. @Council thoughts when u have the chance
  410.  
  411. [01-Apr-20 01:10 AM] BurntZebra#8147
  412. ideally i think we would wait to do anything with rufflet
  413.  
  414. [01-Apr-20 01:10 AM] BurntZebra#8147
  415. but if we really want to get everything done before lcpl
  416.  
  417. [01-Apr-20 01:13 AM] Kingler#6931
  418. use lcpl as testing grounds imo
  419.  
  420. [01-Apr-20 01:13 AM] Kingler#6931
  421. week 3/4
  422.  
  423. [01-Apr-20 01:13 AM] Kingler#6931
  424. i don't think a possibly contentious test should be done quickly
  425.  
  426. [01-Apr-20 01:13 AM] BurntZebra#8147
  427. yeah personally im fine with the meta changing during lcpl
  428.  
  429. [redacted]
  430.  
  431. [01-Apr-20 01:23 AM] levi#6206
  432. i think rushing to the ruff suspect would be bad but changing the meta half way through lcpl would be even worse
  433.  
  434. [01-Apr-20 01:25 AM] levi#6206
  435. i'd much rather just have the first week of lcpl building down the drain instead of 3-4 bc theres always room to revisit a bad ruff suspect, but it'd be much harder to come back from a demotivated lcpl imo
  436.  
  437. [01-Apr-20 01:26 AM] levi#6206
  438. even if revisiting isnt ideal compared to just getting the suspect right the first time for a few reasons
  439.  
  440. [redacted]
  441.  
  442. [01-Apr-20 01:32 AM] levi#6206
  443. if we had to choose between a suspect half way through lcpl and delaying the ruff suspect entirely i would choose the second option, barring rufflet becoming so overbearing that it becomes a major demotivating factor on its own though i dont think any one mon can do that
  444.  
  445. [01-Apr-20 01:34 AM] levi#6206
  446. having to suddenly shift through a meta during spl was bearable but this would be much worse bc there would be an actual suspect going on to divert attention in a v major way, + that some teams will have dedicated builders and the load on them is going to be much greater than on a single spl player building for themselves
  447.  
  448. [01-Apr-20 01:34 AM] levi#6206
  449. that being said im like 90% confident that starting a ruff suspect within the next day or two would be the more popular move for the avg lcer than waiting out the ruff suspect through lcpl so that's still my first choice
  450.  
  451. [01-Apr-20 08:21 AM] starmaster#8286
  452. Definitely think a test now is a bad idea
  453.  
  454. [01-Apr-20 08:21 AM] starmaster#8286
  455. we just banned the most important mon in the tier
  456.  
  457. [01-Apr-20 08:22 AM] starmaster#8286
  458. I think we for sure need to wait before we do anything
  459.  
  460. [01-Apr-20 08:50 AM] brewfasa#4532
  461. agreed
  462.  
  463. [01-Apr-20 08:50 AM] brewfasa#4532
  464. don’t think it’s responsible to rush into it
  465.  
  466. [01-Apr-20 08:51 AM] brewfasa#4532
  467. esp when the set I keep seeing cited is cb
  468.  
  469. [01-Apr-20 09:58 AM] LilyAC#7887
  470. agree
  471.  
  472. [01-Apr-20 10:04 AM] levi#6206
  473. I think that lcpl should be the most important factor given its presence and making sure it’s smoothly run is much more important to the lc community than a pretty minor/forgettable stretching of tiering scheduling
  474.  
  475. [01-Apr-20 10:05 AM] Shrug#7659
  476. i think i explained in my post why it should go now
  477.  
  478. [01-Apr-20 10:05 AM] Shrug#7659
  479. it is going to define lcpl i think
  480.  
  481. [01-Apr-20 10:05 AM] levi#6206
  482. On those grounds suspecting rufflet now and only losing a week seems better to me than suspecting it after the tour, bc suspecting it after the tour would probably reduce motivation for building slightly for all of the later weeks
  483.  
  484. [01-Apr-20 10:06 AM] Ninja#8225
  485. i think it should be now too, cutiefly almost certainly didn’t need to be as rushed if we were just going to wait
  486.  
  487. [01-Apr-20 10:06 AM] levi#6206
  488. Suspecting it half way through the tour would kill lcpl and is comfortably the worst option
  489.  
  490. [01-Apr-20 10:07 AM] LilyAC#7887
  491. kill lcpl is some extreme exaggeration
  492.  
  493. [01-Apr-20 10:08 AM] levi#6206
  494. Ok slightly kill
  495.  
  496. [01-Apr-20 10:08 AM] LilyAC#7887
  497. our tiers banlist is more important than lcpl
  498.  
  499. [01-Apr-20 10:08 AM] BurntZebra#8147
  500. not being able to reuse teams the entirety of lcpl, how will we survive
  501.  
  502. [01-Apr-20 10:09 AM] Coconut#8762
  503. having a tier that's good is more important than LCPL
  504.  
  505. [01-Apr-20 10:09 AM] Coconut#8762
  506. but these things are not mutually exclusive
  507.  
  508. [01-Apr-20 10:09 AM] levi#6206
  509. I don’t think suspecting ruff rn is damaging enough to the tier for those to be equivalent
  510.  
  511. [01-Apr-20 10:09 AM] levi#6206
  512. To the tier or even to tiering policy
  513.  
  514. [01-Apr-20 10:09 AM] Coconut#8762
  515. other tiers go through meta shifts during their PLs
  516.  
  517. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] Coconut#8762
  518. and it doesn't kill the tour
  519.  
  520. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] levi#6206
  521. Yea and it’s not just a meta shift
  522.  
  523. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] levi#6206
  524. It’s a meta shift that carries a suspect
  525.  
  526. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] Coconut#8762
  527. if anything, it hurts teams that can't adapt to new meta trends
  528.  
  529. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] Coconut#8762
  530. and benefits teams who are active and interested in the meta
  531.  
  532. [01-Apr-20 10:10 AM] levi#6206
  533. It literally hurts teams that have more players who want to get reqs, that’s really bad
  534.  
  535. [01-Apr-20 10:11 AM] Coconut#8762
  536. Does it?
  537.  
  538. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  539. Yes these teams have more people who are publicly playing for reqs
  540.  
  541. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  542. coronapl is on rn we get at least 4 rounds
  543.  
  544. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  545. but these same people will be motivated to build teams
  546.  
  547. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  548. to check out how it goes
  549.  
  550. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  551. we're not banning rufflet for coronapl
  552.  
  553. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  554. thats 12 tour games
  555.  
  556. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  557. absolutely not
  558.  
  559. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  560. of no cutie w rufflet
  561.  
  562. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  563. no im saying
  564.  
  565. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] levi#6206
  566. They can’t use those built teams for at least a couple weeks of lcpl
  567.  
  568. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  569. its 12 tour games
  570.  
  571. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  572. I can't justify that
  573.  
  574. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] levi#6206
  575. If they use them for reqs
  576.  
  577. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Ninja#8225
  578. to see how rufflet fairs in a cutie-free meta
  579.  
  580. [01-Apr-20 10:12 AM] Coconut#8762
  581. as a baseline
  582.  
  583. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Ninja#8225
  584. fares
  585.  
  586. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Coconut#8762
  587. if 2 teams don't bring rufflet
  588.  
  589. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Coconut#8762
  590. for each week
  591.  
  592. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Coconut#8762
  593. the sample size isn't usable
  594.  
  595. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Coconut#8762
  596. or it could potentially trend in favor of rufflet not being banworthy
  597.  
  598. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] levi#6206
  599. But the main thing is that you can’t play 40 games on the ladder with only teams that you don’t plan to save for later wks and come out still completely enthusiastic
  600.  
  601. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Coconut#8762
  602. take your pick
  603.  
  604. [01-Apr-20 10:13 AM] Ninja#8225
  605. well if the usage dies off mayb thats evidence too
  606.  
  607. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Ninja#8225
  608. what the 2nd is fine
  609.  
  610. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Ninja#8225
  611. thats why we would vote
  612.  
  613. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Ninja#8225
  614. on the suspect
  615.  
  616. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Coconut#8762
  617. It's hard to justify which it is
  618.  
  619. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Ninja#8225
  620. it doesnt matter what happens in the games just that they exist
  621.  
  622. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Ninja#8225
  623. why would the 2nd be a bad thing
  624.  
  625. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Coconut#8762
  626. the second one would be fine
  627.  
  628. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Coconut#8762
  629. but we don't know if it's the second one
  630.  
  631. [01-Apr-20 10:14 AM] Coconut#8762
  632. or if metariolu doesn't want to use rufflet bc it misses
  633.  
  634. [01-Apr-20 10:16 AM] Coconut#8762
  635. and levi I agree laddering is a grind
  636.  
  637. [01-Apr-20 10:16 AM] Coconut#8762
  638. and it potentially kills a team that you could have used for future rounds
  639.  
  640. [01-Apr-20 10:16 AM] Coconut#8762
  641. and that sucks
  642.  
  643. [01-Apr-20 10:17 AM] Coconut#8762
  644. but I think a brand new meta could potentially provoke a positive as well as a negative.
  645.  
  646. [01-Apr-20 10:17 AM] Coconut#8762
  647. in that people will become more interested in building in the new meta and trying to find the new meta trend
  648.  
  649. [01-Apr-20 10:17 AM] Coconut#8762
  650. which could potentially result in some very creative teambuilding
  651.  
  652. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Coconut#8762
  653. not only that, every team could potentially be on the same backfoot
  654.  
  655. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Coconut#8762
  656. is that something that we can avoid? is the drawback too severe for the cost?
  657.  
  658. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Ninja#8225
  659. didnt that happen in ekans it wasnt great
  660.  
  661. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Ninja#8225
  662. ig it could be better now
  663.  
  664. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] levi#6206
  665. A brand new metagame is fine provided it’s recognizable
  666.  
  667. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Coconut#8762
  668. ekans was a unique scenario
  669.  
  670. [01-Apr-20 10:18 AM] Coconut#8762
  671. and generally I think from a policy perspective, that ekans was good
  672.  
  673. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Coconut#8762
  674. because it developed the metagame quickly
  675.  
  676. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] levi#6206
  677. A two week suspect test that’s both immediately a diversion of attention and also heavily draining, on top of the issues w a new meta part way through a tour, rlly isn’t
  678.  
  679. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Coconut#8762
  680. well what about a little bit of overlap then
  681.  
  682. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] levi#6206
  683. A new metagame is also better near the start of the tour than half way through
  684.  
  685. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Ninja#8225
  686. i think in the like
  687.  
  688. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Ninja#8225
  689. weeks leading up
  690.  
  691. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Ninja#8225
  692. ppl will reuse heavily
  693.  
  694. [01-Apr-20 10:19 AM] Ninja#8225
  695. bc its like
  696.  
  697. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] levi#6206
  698. Bc it lends more importance to building well from the start
  699.  
  700. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Ninja#8225
  701. oh its getting banned soon i cbf building new good teams
  702.  
  703. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Coconut#8762
  704. If we started this suspect tomorrow
  705.  
  706. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] levi#6206
  707. We would only have one week of ruff meta (provided it gets banned)
  708.  
  709. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Coconut#8762
  710. week 1 could potentially have rufflet still
  711.  
  712. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] levi#6206
  713. That’s better than cutting the tour in half
  714.  
  715. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Coconut#8762
  716. if we get a situation akin to floon
  717.  
  718. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Ninja#8225
  719. it might not get banned
  720.  
  721. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Ninja#8225
  722. but thats fine too
  723.  
  724. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] levi#6206
  725. And if it doesn’t get banned
  726.  
  727. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] Coconut#8762
  728. where the votes take forever
  729.  
  730. [01-Apr-20 10:20 AM] levi#6206
  731. Then there wasn’t an issue at all
  732.  
  733. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  734. the voting deadline should just be
  735.  
  736. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  737. 24 hours
  738.  
  739. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Coconut#8762
  740. really can't justify that
  741.  
  742. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  743. like realistically people know in advance they need to vote and when the suspect deadline is
  744.  
  745. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  746. everyone is online once a day at least
  747.  
  748. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  749. except maybe heysup
  750.  
  751. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Coconut#8762
  752. not everybody
  753.  
  754. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  755. but hes playing corona pl everyday now
  756.  
  757. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  758. like >90% of ppl on smogon are
  759.  
  760. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] levi#6206
  761. He’s online every day too
  762.  
  763. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  764. active players
  765.  
  766. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Ninja#8225
  767. yea just last suspect he went 3 days without logging in
  768.  
  769. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Coconut#8762
  770. for policy reasons related to things like TC
  771.  
  772. [01-Apr-20 10:21 AM] Coconut#8762
  773. we can't do that
  774.  
  775. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Ninja#8225
  776. people know in advance when the deadline is anyway
  777.  
  778. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] levi#6206
  779. If there’s a hard deadline that’s made clear well in advance
  780.  
  781. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] levi#6206
  782. Then they should make it
  783.  
  784. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Ninja#8225
  785. wht about u can still vote afterwards for TC but the result is called after 24 hours
  786.  
  787. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Coconut#8762
  788. gonna look really stupid if this is a close vote
  789.  
  790. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] levi#6206
  791. Just give it a wknd or sth
  792.  
  793. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Coconut#8762
  794. if it's a weekend
  795.  
  796. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Ninja#8225
  797. 2 days is fine maybe
  798.  
  799. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Ninja#8225
  800. the last one was stupidly long from memory
  801.  
  802. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Coconut#8762
  803. 2/3 days is fine
  804.  
  805. [01-Apr-20 10:22 AM] Coconut#8762
  806. but
  807.  
  808. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Ninja#8225
  809. 2 days during the week is fine too
  810.  
  811. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] levi#6206
  812. If they can’t make it over an entire wknd then it’s already an issue
  813.  
  814. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Ninja#8225
  815. ppl can spend 10 seconds making a post
  816.  
  817. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Ninja#8225
  818. that they spent hours qualifying for
  819.  
  820. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Coconut#8762
  821. I'm really reluctant to say voting lasts a day
  822.  
  823. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Coconut#8762
  824. actually
  825.  
  826. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Ninja#8225
  827. the drifloon one lasted over 72 hours
  828.  
  829. [01-Apr-20 10:23 AM] Coconut#8762
  830. can we justify that rufflet is our April Fools Day Joke
  831.  
  832. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Coconut#8762
  833. this could potentially be really fucking good
  834.  
  835. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Coconut#8762
  836. I know this is like a serious bsns discussion but like
  837.  
  838. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] levi#6206
  839. I think it’s banworthy for real...
  840.  
  841. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Coconut#8762
  842. this could be really funny
  843.  
  844. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Ninja#8225
  845. what like suspect nd then backflip if its received poorly
  846.  
  847. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Ninja#8225
  848. and say it was a prnak
  849.  
  850. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] Ninja#8225
  851. prank
  852.  
  853. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] levi#6206
  854. And if it’s well received we push it through
  855.  
  856. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] levi#6206
  857. Oml
  858.  
  859. [01-Apr-20 10:24 AM] levi#6206
  860. This plan has no weaknesses
  861.  
  862. [01-Apr-20 10:25 AM] levi#6206
  863. Let’s do it
  864.  
  865. [01-Apr-20 10:25 AM] levi#6206
  866. @Council
  867.  
  868. [01-Apr-20 10:27 AM] LilyAC#7887
  869. everyone will think its a prank and not get reqs
  870.  
  871. [01-Apr-20 10:27 AM] Ninja#8225
  872. well not if several council people get it first
  873.  
  874. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Ninja#8225
  875. last time on the regen one only levi did it
  876.  
  877. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Ninja#8225
  878. and ig there was no new ladder then when at the time it was a thing
  879.  
  880. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Ninja#8225
  881. the lc 2018 afd prank ahead of its time in suspect laddering
  882.  
  883. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Luthier#1578
  884. this is horrible idea
  885.  
  886. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Luthier#1578
  887. i am very against this
  888.  
  889. [01-Apr-20 10:28 AM] Luthier#1578
  890. problem will arise when we joke about a topic that we should be serious about
  891.  
  892. [01-Apr-20 10:29 AM] Luthier#1578
  893. leading to some people being less serious when we have to be
  894.  
  895. [01-Apr-20 10:29 AM] Luthier#1578
  896. if we want to make an april fools joke do somethign else
  897.  
  898. [01-Apr-20 10:29 AM] Luthier#1578
  899. like idfk ferro or some shit
  900.  
  901. [01-Apr-20 10:32 AM] levi#6206
  902. I can’t believe the plan had weaknesses
  903.  
  904. [redacted]
  905.  
  906. [01-Apr-20 10:43 AM] jake#8907
  907. i am not going to do anything related to rufflet for afd
  908.  
  909. [01-Apr-20 02:00 PM] Luthier#1578
  910. Ty @jake ily
  911.  
  912. [01-Apr-20 02:50 PM] hongli#4483
  913. lcpl starts like
  914.  
  915. [01-Apr-20 02:51 PM] hongli#4483
  916. on the 13th right
  917.  
  918. [01-Apr-20 02:51 PM] hongli#4483
  919. well draft is 10th but
  920.  
  921. [01-Apr-20 02:51 PM] hongli#4483
  922. week 1 starts then
  923.  
  924. [01-Apr-20 02:52 PM] Coconut#8762
  925. Draft is the 11th
  926.  
  927. [01-Apr-20 02:52 PM] hongli#4483
  928. ah
  929.  
  930. [01-Apr-20 02:53 PM] hongli#4483
  931. realistically speaking i still don't see a huge difference in having two/three weeks of rufflet for lcpl over just one
  932.  
  933. [01-Apr-20 02:53 PM] hongli#4483
  934. that still gives an ample amount of time for us to see potential changes within the meta without "wasting" too many weeks
  935.  
  936. [01-Apr-20 02:54 PM] hongli#4483
  937. even though i don't see it necessarily as wasting like levi/others do
  938.  
  939. [01-Apr-20 02:54 PM] hongli#4483
  940. it's not like you can just get away w not building and just reusing anyways
  941.  
  942. [01-Apr-20 02:54 PM] hongli#4483
  943. since qt being gone changes the tier a lot
  944.  
  945. [01-Apr-20 02:56 PM] hongli#4483
  946. and it's really not that big of an effort
  947.  
  948. [01-Apr-20 02:56 PM] hongli#4483
  949. to build one more team
  950.  
  951. [01-Apr-20 02:56 PM] hongli#4483
  952. to use for ladder
  953.  
  954. [01-Apr-20 02:56 PM] jake#8907
  955. i am ok with waiting but i don't wamt to hold off terribly long
  956.  
  957. [01-Apr-20 02:57 PM] jake#8907
  958. esp since it's part of the justification for the cutie qb
  959.  
  960. [01-Apr-20 02:57 PM] jake#8907
  961. want*
  962.  
  963. [01-Apr-20 02:59 PM] LilyAC#7887
  964. +Heysup: are u guys telling me that the cutiefly ban
  965. +Heysup: is not april fools
  966. +Heysup: ???
  967.  
  968. [01-Apr-20 02:59 PM] Coconut#8762
  969. told you guys!!!!!!
  970.  
  971. [01-Apr-20 03:01 PM] brewfasa#4532
  972. lol
  973.  
  974. [01-Apr-20 04:20 PM] levi#6206
  975. Having the suspect end two weeks into the tour would mean that the entire suspect is running alongside lcpl
  976.  
  977. [01-Apr-20 04:22 PM] Coconut#8762
  978. so assuming rufflet got banned it'd be gone by week 3 then
  979.  
  980. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] levi#6206
  981. Running the suspect alongside lcpl and diverting what the playerbase is focusing on goes both ways fwiw, it also means that some active players might not care to do the suspect bc they’d rather focus on lcpl
  982.  
  983. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] levi#6206
  984. I just don’t think that would even be a concern compared to the much worse drawback of people not being able to focus their attention on lcpl
  985.  
  986. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] hongli#4483
  987. couldn't you also say
  988.  
  989. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] hongli#4483
  990. that people in LCPL would be more motivated to do the suspect
  991.  
  992. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] hongli#4483
  993. on the grounds that it could affect their building
  994.  
  995. [01-Apr-20 04:23 PM] levi#6206
  996. I don’t think that’s how it’d work out
  997.  
  998. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] hongli#4483
  999. and if they think they'd do better in a rufflet-less or having-rufflet meta
  1000.  
  1001. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1002. i feel like ladder teams are different from lcpl teams
  1003.  
  1004. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] levi#6206
  1005. For most of the playerbase
  1006.  
  1007. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] hongli#4483
  1008. then they'd get reqs and vote accordingly
  1009.  
  1010. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1011. whenever i tried running lcpl/snake/spl teams etc on ladder
  1012.  
  1013. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1014. the matchup win % was just not good enough
  1015.  
  1016. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1017. +playing fast matches on ladder is optimal for reqs
  1018.  
  1019. [01-Apr-20 04:24 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1020. not really necessary for lcpl
  1021.  
  1022. [01-Apr-20 04:27 PM] levi#6206
  1023. Building is part of it but it’s not the only issue
  1024.  
  1025. [01-Apr-20 04:27 PM] levi#6206
  1026. It’s also that you’re making players grind out 40 extra games that have no immediate benefit to their prep
  1027.  
  1028. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] hongli#4483
  1029. i highkey
  1030.  
  1031. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] hongli#4483
  1032. disagree w that sentiment
  1033.  
  1034. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] hongli#4483
  1035. doing ladder would be very good prep
  1036.  
  1037. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] hongli#4483
  1038. for a lot of ppl that only come in for lcpl/have been away
  1039.  
  1040. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] hongli#4483
  1041. since it would familiarize them w the meta more
  1042.  
  1043. [01-Apr-20 04:28 PM] Coconut#8762
  1044. that's not a large populous
  1045.  
  1046. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] Coconut#8762
  1047. but I do think that people that don't play LC at all
  1048.  
  1049. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] levi#6206
  1050. On a meta that’s potentially about to disappear?
  1051.  
  1052. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] Coconut#8762
  1053. would be more likely to hop on the ladder
  1054.  
  1055. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] Coconut#8762
  1056. we're not gonna disappear LOL
  1057.  
  1058. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1059. rufflet being gone
  1060.  
  1061. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] levi#6206
  1062. No
  1063.  
  1064. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] Coconut#8762
  1065. the meta doesn't drastically warp
  1066.  
  1067. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1068. wouldn't be a high impact ban
  1069.  
  1070. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] levi#6206
  1071. That’s not what I meant
  1072.  
  1073. [01-Apr-20 04:29 PM] Coconut#8762
  1074. with the removal of rufflet
  1075.  
  1076. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] levi#6206
  1077. It really isn’t a high impact ban yea which is why getting it out of the way
  1078.  
  1079. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] levi#6206
  1080. Right now
  1081.  
  1082. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] Coconut#8762
  1083. cutiefly was undoubtedly a higher impact ban than rufflet would be
  1084.  
  1085. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] levi#6206
  1086. When it’s unpopular
  1087.  
  1088. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] levi#6206
  1089. Is so low impact
  1090.  
  1091. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] Coconut#8762
  1092. which is why we're reluctant to rush into this suspect
  1093.  
  1094. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] hongli#4483
  1095. if it's low impact
  1096.  
  1097. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] hongli#4483
  1098. shouldn't that be more reason not to rush it
  1099.  
  1100. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] hongli#4483
  1101. since prep won't be as invalidated
  1102.  
  1103. [01-Apr-20 04:30 PM] hongli#4483
  1104. if it were say qt we were suspecting in the middle of lcpl
  1105.  
  1106. [01-Apr-20 04:31 PM] levi#6206
  1107. It’s low impact but highly unpopular for the same reasons why suspecting it now should be acceptable policy wise
  1108.  
  1109. [01-Apr-20 04:31 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1110. people are still going to run onix a decent amount
  1111.  
  1112. [01-Apr-20 04:31 PM] levi#6206
  1113. The only thing that gets affected by our most recent meta change is the viability of one set, but a dip in viability doesn’t change that every reason we had to originally see it as suspect worthy still exists fully
  1114.  
  1115. [01-Apr-20 04:31 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1116. even w/o rufflet
  1117.  
  1118. [01-Apr-20 04:32 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1119. nothing else remotely handles rufflet
  1120.  
  1121. [01-Apr-20 04:32 PM] levi#6206
  1122. Including its reliance on luck
  1123.  
  1124. [01-Apr-20 04:32 PM] BurntZebra#8147
  1125. so its not like rufflet has really warped the meta around itself
  1126.  
  1127. [01-Apr-20 04:32 PM] levi#6206
  1128. Viability of a couple sets actually but yea
  1129.  
  1130. [01-Apr-20 04:32 PM] hongli#4483
  1131. yes but if there's no immediate urgency to suspect since it wouldn't completely invalidate prep and ladder could actually help prep some players
  1132.  
  1133. [01-Apr-20 04:33 PM] hongli#4483
  1134. then why break protocol and rush a suspect for it
  1135.  
  1136. [01-Apr-20 04:33 PM] Coconut#8762
  1137. I think having the suspect going to week 1
  1138.  
  1139. [01-Apr-20 04:33 PM] Coconut#8762
  1140. is fine
  1141.  
  1142. [01-Apr-20 04:33 PM] Coconut#8762
  1143. anymore than 2 weeks is a burden
  1144.  
  1145. [01-Apr-20 04:33 PM] levi#6206
  1146. I’m reading rufflet as a matter of uncompetitiveness right now
  1147.  
  1148. [01-Apr-20 04:34 PM] levi#6206
  1149. Bc there’s hardly any protocol being broken to begin with
  1150.  
  1151. [01-Apr-20 04:36 PM] levi#6206
  1152. Like we give time to see how a mon is going to adapt, but a) rufflets uncompetitiveness is completely independent of its viability unless we expect cutie being banned to render rufflet unviable, b) even if we’re arguing for its brokenness it’s still a mon we’ve had to become intimately familiar with and half its sets never abused webs to begin w while the other half appreciated but didn’t necessarily require it
  1153.  
  1154. [01-Apr-20 04:37 PM] levi#6206
  1155. Giving time for the meta to settle is like the easiest part of protocol to justify skipping over
  1156.  
  1157. [01-Apr-20 04:38 PM] levi#6206
  1158. And lcpl of all things is probably the single best reason you could possibly find to justify it
  1159.  
  1160. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1161. first off, why are u so focused on the uncompetitive buzzword, like this is some wingull scald situation again
  1162.  
  1163. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1164. and second I don’t rly agree with most of what u just said lmao
  1165.  
  1166. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1167. how is seeing how a metagame is
  1168.  
  1169. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1170. the least important protocol
  1171.  
  1172. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] levi#6206
  1173. Wingull got banned tho
  1174.  
  1175. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1176. it should be the most important
  1177.  
  1178. [01-Apr-20 04:41 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1179. yes what’s ur point
  1180.  
  1181. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1182. this isn’t wingull
  1183.  
  1184. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] levi#6206
  1185. Well u just compared it to wingull
  1186.  
  1187. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] levi#6206
  1188. But ya
  1189.  
  1190. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1191. I’m asking you
  1192.  
  1193. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1194. why ur using the uncompetitive buzzword so much
  1195.  
  1196. [01-Apr-20 04:42 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1197. like this is a wingull situation
  1198.  
  1199. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1200. Where ur hoping for burns
  1201.  
  1202. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] levi#6206
  1203. Bc rufflets primary counterplay isn’t in the builder, it’s in game
  1204.  
  1205. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1206. lmao
  1207.  
  1208. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] levi#6206
  1209. It’s uncounterable
  1210.  
  1211. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1212. then it’s broken
  1213.  
  1214. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] levi#6206
  1215. And it has one hard check
  1216.  
  1217. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1218. it’s too powerful
  1219.  
  1220. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] levi#6206
  1221. No bc it only wins half the time
  1222.  
  1223. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] levi#6206
  1224. Bc it misses
  1225.  
  1226. [01-Apr-20 04:43 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1227. ah there it is
  1228.  
  1229. [01-Apr-20 04:44 PM] levi#6206
  1230. You can’t build against it tho
  1231.  
  1232. [01-Apr-20 04:44 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1233. don’t try and lump this uncompetitive argument with how it has no relation with viability
  1234.  
  1235. [01-Apr-20 04:45 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1236. ur stretching this
  1237.  
  1238. [01-Apr-20 04:45 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1239. just coz it can miss
  1240.  
  1241. [01-Apr-20 04:45 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1242. doesn’t make it some uncompetitive bs, it’s just broken thru sheer power
  1243.  
  1244. [01-Apr-20 04:46 PM] levi#6206
  1245. Well I do think it’s uncompetitive bc its power is unreliable in a manner that neither player has real control over
  1246.  
  1247. [01-Apr-20 04:46 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1248. how does this make it uncompetitive
  1249.  
  1250. [01-Apr-20 04:47 PM] levi#6206
  1251. And if I’m approaching this from an uncompetitiveness aspect then waiting for a meta change obv doesn’t matter at all
  1252.  
  1253. [01-Apr-20 04:47 PM] levi#6206
  1254. It matters more if the argument is that ruff is outright broken though
  1255.  
  1256. [01-Apr-20 04:47 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1257. you shouldn’t be approaching it like that lol
  1258.  
  1259. [01-Apr-20 04:47 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1260. this isn’t moody, it’s not banking on 30% scald
  1261.  
  1262. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1263. it’s like shrug said in his post, ur banking on that move hitting
  1264.  
  1265. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1266. and when it doesn’t sure it costs some games
  1267.  
  1268. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] levi#6206
  1269. Yea
  1270.  
  1271. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1272. but it’s just the opportunity cost of using such a powerful threat
  1273.  
  1274. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] levi#6206
  1275. That’s purely luck based
  1276.  
  1277. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] levi#6206
  1278. I think that’s uncompetitive
  1279.  
  1280. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1281. .....
  1282.  
  1283. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] Coconut#8762
  1284. I don't think a miss from rufflet
  1285.  
  1286. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1287. So let’s ban all 80% moves
  1288.  
  1289. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] hongli#4483
  1290. is stone edge uncompetitive
  1291.  
  1292. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] Coconut#8762
  1293. autolosses some games
  1294.  
  1295. [01-Apr-20 04:48 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1296. wtf are y even talking about
  1297.  
  1298. [01-Apr-20 04:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1299. ur trying to stage an argument u have no basis on
  1300.  
  1301. [01-Apr-20 04:49 PM] Coconut#8762
  1302. yk focus blast is unviable
  1303.  
  1304. [01-Apr-20 04:49 PM] Coconut#8762
  1305. because it misses 70% of the time
  1306.  
  1307. [01-Apr-20 04:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1308. by moving the discussion from ruff being “broken” to uncompetitive
  1309.  
  1310. [01-Apr-20 04:49 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1311. using Levi dictionary again
  1312.  
  1313. [01-Apr-20 04:51 PM] levi#6206
  1314. Is this serious
  1315.  
  1316. [01-Apr-20 04:51 PM] levi#6206
  1317. How many focus blast and stone edge users can guarantee a ko the vast majority of the time they miss an attack
  1318.  
  1319. [01-Apr-20 04:51 PM] levi#6206
  1320. How many focus blast and stone edge users are literally uncounterable
  1321.  
  1322. [01-Apr-20 04:51 PM] Shrug#7659
  1323. in my post i think it said it was a combination of the power and the luck element
  1324.  
  1325. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] levi#6206
  1326. You’re comparing ruff to mons that are probably literally half as strong on average now
  1327.  
  1328. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1329. it’s very serious
  1330.  
  1331. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] Shrug#7659
  1332. as in the power makes the fortune more prominent
  1333.  
  1334. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1335. luck has nothing to do with this lol
  1336.  
  1337. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] hongli#4483
  1338. isnt that an issue of
  1339.  
  1340. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] hongli#4483
  1341. rufflet just being too strong then
  1342.  
  1343. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1344. if this mon doesn’t have doubters
  1345.  
  1346. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1347. counters
  1348.  
  1349. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1350. It’s broken
  1351.  
  1352. [01-Apr-20 04:52 PM] Coconut#8762
  1353. not an issue of uncompetitiveness
  1354.  
  1355. [01-Apr-20 04:53 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1356. again ur playing like it’s hitting
  1357.  
  1358. [01-Apr-20 04:53 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1359. and if it misses cool beans
  1360.  
  1361. [01-Apr-20 04:53 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1362. just opportunity cost
  1363.  
  1364. [01-Apr-20 04:53 PM] Coconut#8762
  1365. picture it like it's own flying move if that helps
  1366.  
  1367. [01-Apr-20 04:53 PM] levi#6206
  1368. It’s uncounterable and unbeatable in the builder but doesn’t actually win more than 50% of the time in game
  1369.  
  1370. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] levi#6206
  1371. Its counterplay is dodging
  1372.  
  1373. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] Coconut#8762
  1374. with 80% accuracy
  1375.  
  1376. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] levi#6206
  1377. This makes it uncompetitive
  1378.  
  1379. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1380. so are u trying to argue against it
  1381.  
  1382. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1383. if in actuality it doesnt win as much
  1384.  
  1385. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] levi#6206
  1386. Well I’m arguing independently of its brokenness right now
  1387.  
  1388. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1389. coz there’s literally no reason to even bring it up
  1390.  
  1391. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] Coconut#8762
  1392. why
  1393.  
  1394. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1395. if otherwise
  1396.  
  1397. [01-Apr-20 04:54 PM] Coconut#8762
  1398. why are we arguing independently of brokeness
  1399.  
  1400. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1401. it’s the same bs dcae tried to spin with hurricane misses
  1402.  
  1403. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] levi#6206
  1404. Because I’m arguing that it’s uncompetitive
  1405.  
  1406. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] Coconut#8762
  1407. but the points you're making
  1408.  
  1409. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] Coconut#8762
  1410. justify that it's broken AND uncompetitive
  1411.  
  1412. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] Coconut#8762
  1413. not that it's uncompetitive
  1414.  
  1415. [01-Apr-20 04:55 PM] Coconut#8762
  1416. you're throwing out the most prominent reason to ban this mon
  1417.  
  1418. [01-Apr-20 04:56 PM] levi#6206
  1419. Rufflet might be broken too but I’m not justifying the suspect off of that train of thought right now
  1420.  
  1421. [01-Apr-20 04:58 PM] Coconut#8762
  1422. the reason it's uncompetitive is because it is broken
  1423.  
  1424. [01-Apr-20 04:58 PM] Coconut#8762
  1425. unless you're trying to say that this mon is not broken (see fatty's point about dcae's point about wingull), I don't see from what standpoint you can argue otherwise
  1426.  
  1427. [01-Apr-20 05:00 PM] levi#6206
  1428. But it could be banworthy for multiple reasons
  1429.  
  1430. [01-Apr-20 05:01 PM] levi#6206
  1431. Like
  1432.  
  1433. [01-Apr-20 05:01 PM] levi#6206
  1434. It could be banworthy on brokenness too but right now I’m trying to say it’s uncompetitive
  1435.  
  1436. [01-Apr-20 05:03 PM] levi#6206
  1437. My argument is that *even* if it’s not broken, i.e. it only wins 50% of the time
  1438.  
  1439. [01-Apr-20 05:04 PM] levi#6206
  1440. Then you would have a mon that has this win ratio but is still almost impossible to deal with in the builder. It negates that part of building skill
  1441.  
  1442. [01-Apr-20 05:04 PM] levi#6206
  1443. The anti rufflet option is instead to rely on dodges
  1444.  
  1445. [01-Apr-20 05:04 PM] levi#6206
  1446. Which is independent of player skill
  1447.  
  1448. [01-Apr-20 05:05 PM] levi#6206
  1449. This makes it uncompetitive
  1450.  
  1451. [01-Apr-20 05:05 PM] levi#6206
  1452. Stone edge isn’t uncompetitive bc every stone edge user is still very very comfortably counterable
  1453.  
  1454. [01-Apr-20 05:05 PM] levi#6206
  1455. Focus blast isn’t uncompetitive bc its users don’t exist
  1456.  
  1457. [01-Apr-20 05:09 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1458. I’m telling u bro no one tiers like this
  1459.  
  1460. [01-Apr-20 05:09 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1461. go ask uu why Durant was banned
  1462.  
  1463. [01-Apr-20 05:09 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1464. not one person will say because it’s it’s uncompetitive
  1465.  
  1466. [01-Apr-20 05:10 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1467. it’s because it has no damn counters
  1468.  
  1469. [01-Apr-20 05:10 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1470. which w/e call that uncompetitive or w/e definition you want
  1471.  
  1472. [01-Apr-20 05:10 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1473. but I know that’s not what ur getting at
  1474.  
  1475. [01-Apr-20 05:11 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1476. ur just trying to think too hard abt it to somehow shoehorn an argument in to justify an early suspect
  1477.  
  1478. [01-Apr-20 05:13 PM] levi#6206
  1479. I literally started a suspect last gen off of an outright weaker version of the same argument
  1480.  
  1481. [01-Apr-20 05:13 PM] levi#6206
  1482. And the suspect resulted in a ban too
  1483.  
  1484. [01-Apr-20 05:13 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1485. Whether it resulted in a ban or not doesn’t mean shit
  1486.  
  1487. [01-Apr-20 05:13 PM] Coconut#8762
  1488. what does that have to do with this
  1489.  
  1490. [01-Apr-20 05:14 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1491. idek what ur referencing tho
  1492.  
  1493. [01-Apr-20 05:14 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1494. atm
  1495.  
  1496. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] levi#6206
  1497. I’m referencing wingull
  1498.  
  1499. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1500. ur gonna argue w/ me
  1501.  
  1502. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1503. abt your wingull logic
  1504.  
  1505. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] levi#6206
  1506. I’m saying that we considered wingull banworthy last gen for the same line of reasoning but that line of reasoning is stronger now
  1507.  
  1508. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] levi#6206
  1509. And you’re accusing me of using this line of reasoning only because I want the rufflet suspect now
  1510.  
  1511. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1512. I already told u how lame that comparison is
  1513.  
  1514. [01-Apr-20 05:15 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1515. and it was terrible logic
  1516.  
  1517. [01-Apr-20 05:16 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1518. during full suspect anyways
  1519.  
  1520. [01-Apr-20 05:16 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1521. gull
  1522.  
  1523. [01-Apr-20 05:16 PM] levi#6206
  1524. Ok I know you disagreed with it
  1525.  
  1526. [01-Apr-20 05:17 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1527. I’m done w/ this anyways I literally don’t get your line of thinking
  1528.  
  1529. [01-Apr-20 05:17 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1530. so don’t see a point
  1531.  
  1532. [01-Apr-20 05:18 PM] brewfasa#4532
  1533. curious if anyone else can help explain what I’m missing
  1534.  
  1535. [01-Apr-20 05:21 PM] hongli#4483
  1536. wingull had decent checks
  1537.  
  1538. [01-Apr-20 05:21 PM] hongli#4483
  1539. the problem w gull was that it could just scald burn through them
  1540.  
  1541. [01-Apr-20 05:21 PM] hongli#4483
  1542. and make them irrelevant
  1543.  
  1544. [01-Apr-20 05:22 PM] hongli#4483
  1545. ruff doesn't need luck to break through its supposed checks
  1546.  
  1547. [01-Apr-20 05:22 PM] hongli#4483
  1548. it needs (un)luck to not get around them
  1549.  
  1550. [01-Apr-20 05:22 PM] hongli#4483
  1551. how's that not just an issue of it being broken rather than uncompetitive
  1552.  
  1553. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] levi#6206
  1554. How are you defining uncompetitiveness
  1555.  
  1556. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Luthier#1578
  1557. i think ruff should be considered as having a 180 BP fighting move and a flying stab
  1558.  
  1559. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Coconut#8762
  1560. with 80% acc
  1561.  
  1562. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Luthier#1578
  1563. that coverage kills everything on the tier
  1564.  
  1565. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Luthier#1578
  1566. ye
  1567.  
  1568. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Coconut#8762
  1569. I can agree with that
  1570.  
  1571. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Luthier#1578
  1572. w 80 acc
  1573.  
  1574. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Coconut#8762
  1575. to an extent
  1576.  
  1577. [01-Apr-20 05:25 PM] Luthier#1578
  1578. but like the thing is
  1579.  
  1580. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] hongli#4483
  1581. the uncompetitive aspect of wingull was that it could easily break through its checks with reasonable RNG
  1582.  
  1583. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1584. lets consider the viability of megatar
  1585.  
  1586. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1587. just for reference
  1588.  
  1589. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1590. if thats cool
  1591.  
  1592. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1593. megatar is basically always running stone edge
  1594.  
  1595. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1596. and it hits like a truck
  1597.  
  1598. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1599. w 100 BP
  1600.  
  1601. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1602. now lets compare the idea of "luck"
  1603.  
  1604. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1605. from there to LC
  1606.  
  1607. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] hongli#4483
  1608. wingull beats its checks 30% or 52% of the time with RNG
  1609.  
  1610. [01-Apr-20 05:26 PM] Luthier#1578
  1611. you are always going to be running stone edge and thats a viable move to click and bank on
  1612.  
  1613. [01-Apr-20 05:27 PM] Luthier#1578
  1614. 80 is high enough where i think it can be considered uncompetitive
  1615.  
  1616. [01-Apr-20 05:27 PM] hongli#4483
  1617. ruff beats its checks 80% of the time if you hit the right move
  1618.  
  1619. [01-Apr-20 05:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1620. is hitting an 80% accurate move really smth we're gonna be considering RNG like with wingull
  1621.  
  1622. [01-Apr-20 05:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1623. darumaka isnt uncompetitive because it has hustle
  1624.  
  1625. [01-Apr-20 05:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1626. it just cant get around its resists the same way ruff can bc of its coverage
  1627.  
  1628. [01-Apr-20 05:29 PM] hongli#4483
  1629. so is it not just an issue of ruff itself being too strong
  1630.  
  1631. [01-Apr-20 05:30 PM] levi#6206
  1632. Well darumaka is also missing every setup set and the typing needed to be completely uncounterable
  1633.  
  1634. [01-Apr-20 05:31 PM] hongli#4483
  1635. so rufflet is only uncompetitive because it's already broken
  1636.  
  1637. [01-Apr-20 05:31 PM] hongli#4483
  1638. to begin with?
  1639.  
  1640. [01-Apr-20 05:31 PM] levi#6206
  1641. If you can argue that it’s viable enough to warrant use and its counters are otherwise unviable though then maybe
  1642.  
  1643. [01-Apr-20 05:31 PM] levi#6206
  1644. Well I’m thinking that darumaka is just outright viable
  1645.  
  1646. [01-Apr-20 05:31 PM] levi#6206
  1647. Wingull wasn’t considered too strong when it was banned either
  1648.  
  1649. [01-Apr-20 05:32 PM] levi#6206
  1650. Though I guess rufflet is also that as well
  1651.  
  1652. [01-Apr-20 05:33 PM] levi#6206
  1653. I’m not seeing how the % matters as long as it’s large enough to reasonably be considered in the average game for uncompetitiveness
  1654.  
  1655. [01-Apr-20 05:33 PM] levi#6206
  1656. Uncompetitiveness is just taking the outcome of the game out of the players hands, in this case through luck
  1657.  
  1658. [01-Apr-20 05:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1659. percent doesn't matter
  1660.  
  1661. [01-Apr-20 05:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1662. excellent point
  1663.  
  1664. [01-Apr-20 05:38 PM] hongli#4483
  1665. idk what else to say without just repeating myself. wingull requires luck to break through its checks, rufflet breaks through its checks regardless
  1666.  
  1667. [01-Apr-20 05:38 PM] levi#6206
  1668. Only 80% of the time
  1669.  
  1670. [01-Apr-20 05:39 PM] levi#6206
  1671. That’s its counterplay
  1672.  
  1673. [01-Apr-20 05:39 PM] hongli#4483
  1674. so if the counterplay is hoping for a lucky miss
  1675.  
  1676. [01-Apr-20 05:39 PM] hongli#4483
  1677. then it's broken in terms of offensive capabilities
  1678.  
  1679. [01-Apr-20 05:40 PM] hongli#4483
  1680. banking on an 80% to hit is not banking on luck
  1681.  
  1682. [01-Apr-20 05:40 PM] hongli#4483
  1683. banking on a 30% like w gull scald is
  1684.  
  1685. [01-Apr-20 05:41 PM] hongli#4483
  1686. also this is all assuming rufflet even uses the correct move anyways on the switch
  1687.  
  1688. [01-Apr-20 05:41 PM] hongli#4483
  1689. since it ties pawn/is slower than onix
  1690.  
  1691. [01-Apr-20 05:41 PM] hongli#4483
  1692. wingull was faster than everything on its own already
  1693.  
  1694. [01-Apr-20 05:51 PM] jake#8907
  1695. what is even the debate here
  1696.  
  1697. [01-Apr-20 05:51 PM] jake#8907
  1698. the merits of suspecting ruff?
  1699.  
  1700. [01-Apr-20 05:52 PM] jake#8907
  1701. suspecting hustle?
  1702.  
  1703. [01-Apr-20 05:52 PM] jake#8907
  1704. i missed the early half of this so apologies if that's a dumb question
  1705.  
  1706. [01-Apr-20 05:54 PM] Coconut#8762
  1707. levi13Today at 4:33 PM
  1708. I’m reading rufflet as a matter of uncompetitiveness right now
  1709. Bc there’s hardly any protocol being broken to begin with
  1710. Like we give time to see how a mon is going to adapt, but a) rufflets uncompetitiveness is completely independent of its viability unless we expect cutie being banned to render rufflet unviable, b) even if we’re arguing for its brokenness it’s still a mon we’ve had to become intimately familiar with and half its sets never abused webs to begin w while the other half appreciated but didn’t necessarily require it
  1711. Giving time for the meta to settle is like the easiest part of protocol to justify skipping over
  1712. And lcpl of all things is probably the single best reason you could possibly find to justify it
  1713.  
  1714. [01-Apr-20 05:54 PM] Coconut#8762
  1715. started there
  1716.  
  1717. [01-Apr-20 06:08 PM] levi#6206
  1718. Ya
  1719.  
  1720. [01-Apr-20 06:09 PM] levi#6206
  1721. I think arguing for ruffs ban on uncompetitiveness is a valid train of thought even if it might -additionally- be broken
  1722.  
  1723. [01-Apr-20 06:21 PM] levi#6206
  1724. Also doka the way you describe it ruff sounds massively broken
  1725.  
  1726. [01-Apr-20 06:21 PM] levi#6206
  1727. But it’s still uncompetitive too
  1728.  
  1729. [01-Apr-20 06:21 PM] hongli#4483
  1730. i do think it's broken
  1731.  
  1732. [01-Apr-20 06:21 PM] hongli#4483
  1733. i just don't think it's uncompetitive in the same way wingull was
  1734.  
  1735. [01-Apr-20 06:22 PM] levi#6206
  1736. Instead of the wingull user relying on luck, the rufflets opponent is the one relying on luck instead
  1737.  
  1738. [01-Apr-20 06:22 PM] levi#6206
  1739. It’s still uncompetitive
  1740.  
  1741. [01-Apr-20 06:22 PM] LilyAC#7887
  1742. wingull wasnt uncompetitive either
  1743.  
  1744. [01-Apr-20 06:24 PM] hongli#4483
  1745. i just really don't think having to rely on 80% accurate moves means its uncompetitive
  1746.  
  1747. [01-Apr-20 06:24 PM] hongli#4483
  1748. tornadus-t relies on 70% accurate hurricane but it's not an issue
  1749.  
  1750. [01-Apr-20 06:24 PM] hongli#4483
  1751. because it doesn't have massive power potential like ruff does
  1752.  
  1753. [01-Apr-20 06:24 PM] LilyAC#7887
  1754. rufflet being able to miss is a reason against banning it if anything
  1755.  
  1756. [01-Apr-20 06:24 PM] hongli#4483
  1757. which is the broken part
  1758.  
  1759. [01-Apr-20 06:25 PM] levi#6206
  1760. Tornadus t’s hurricane isn’t a 1 shot against everything, you can counter tornadus
  1761.  
  1762. [01-Apr-20 06:25 PM] LilyAC#7887
  1763. if it was a 1 shot against everything
  1764.  
  1765. [01-Apr-20 06:25 PM] LilyAC#7887
  1766. then it would be broken not uncompetitive
  1767.  
  1768. [01-Apr-20 06:25 PM] hongli#4483
  1769. not the accuracy
  1770.  
  1771. [01-Apr-20 06:25 PM] hongli#4483
  1772. yeah exactly
  1773.  
  1774. [01-Apr-20 06:26 PM] hongli#4483
  1775. it may have a lower overall WR bc of issues w misses
  1776.  
  1777. [01-Apr-20 06:26 PM] levi#6206
  1778. OHKO clause is a ton more extreme but it’s in the same line of thought, it might not give you a good win rate but it’s uncompetitive
  1779.  
  1780. [01-Apr-20 06:27 PM] hongli#4483
  1781. but that doesn't mean it's not still broken on account of pure dmg and team building strain
  1782.  
  1783. [01-Apr-20 06:28 PM] levi#6206
  1784. But like even if you think the switch from the user of the bird being reliant on the smaller chance to the opponent of the bird being reliant on the smaller chance excludes it from being uncompetitive (which I still don’t agree with)
  1785.  
  1786. [01-Apr-20 06:28 PM] levi#6206
  1787. Why would we need to wait a week to confirm that rufflet indeed is still uncounterable and misses
  1788.  
  1789. [01-Apr-20 06:31 PM] hongli#4483
  1790. well there r a lot more drawbacks to using ruff without webs
  1791.  
  1792. [01-Apr-20 06:32 PM] hongli#4483
  1793. it can actually be outsped so things like ponyta/onix threaten it
  1794.  
  1795. [01-Apr-20 06:32 PM] hongli#4483
  1796. and so the variant that most teams can fit on most easily is scarf
  1797.  
  1798. [01-Apr-20 06:33 PM] hongli#4483
  1799. which is easier to deal with than others
  1800.  
  1801. [01-Apr-20 06:33 PM] levi#6206
  1802. I’m not comfortable reading pony as a serious ruff answer at all
  1803.  
  1804. [01-Apr-20 06:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1805. well if you're outsped by pony
  1806.  
  1807. [01-Apr-20 06:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1808. then you get burned
  1809.  
  1810. [01-Apr-20 06:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1811. i just mean
  1812.  
  1813. [01-Apr-20 06:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1814. more things can soft check ruff
  1815.  
  1816. [01-Apr-20 06:34 PM] hongli#4483
  1817. without webs
  1818.  
  1819. [01-Apr-20 06:35 PM] hongli#4483
  1820. so is that not reason to see if in this meta it's potentially not broken
  1821.  
  1822. [01-Apr-20 06:35 PM] levi#6206
  1823. Ya I get that the band set and maybe some bu bj sets get more soft checkable
  1824.  
  1825. [01-Apr-20 06:35 PM] levi#6206
  1826. Well
  1827.  
  1828. [01-Apr-20 06:35 PM] levi#6206
  1829. Rkillable not soft checkable
  1830.  
  1831. [01-Apr-20 06:35 PM] levi#6206
  1832. None of them can switch in obv
  1833.  
  1834. [01-Apr-20 06:38 PM] levi#6206
  1835. I guess none of this works if you aren’t convinced that the reasoning for wingull was valid though
  1836.  
  1837. [01-Apr-20 06:38 PM] levi#6206
  1838. My argument for its uncompetitiveness mostly rests on its case for that being stronger than sm wingulls
  1839.  
  1840. [01-Apr-20 06:41 PM] hongli#4483
  1841. do you mean smth along the lines of
  1842.  
  1843. [01-Apr-20 06:42 PM] hongli#4483
  1844. wingull may have been more rng-reliant but the rng that occurs around ruff is more impactful because of how much stronger it is
  1845.  
  1846. [01-Apr-20 06:42 PM] hongli#4483
  1847. and so it's uncompetitive?
  1848.  
  1849. [01-Apr-20 06:43 PM] hongli#4483
  1850. i wouldn't agree bc i would still view that as a facet of ruff just being flat out broken but ig i could understand what you're saying then
  1851.  
  1852. [01-Apr-20 06:46 PM] levi#6206
  1853. Rufflet is equally rng reliant
  1854.  
  1855. [01-Apr-20 06:47 PM] levi#6206
  1856. In wingulls case the wingull user is doing the lucking, in rufflets case the rufflet users opponent is doing the lucking
  1857.  
  1858. [01-Apr-20 06:47 PM] levi#6206
  1859. But that doesn’t matter wrt the actual degree of rng involved
  1860.  
  1861. [01-Apr-20 06:48 PM] levi#6206
  1862. And then it’s additionally more impactful ya
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment