samsteve

Untitled

Apr 18th, 2026
46
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 25.05 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Lab countertop chemical resistance ratings are determined by standardized tests (like SEFA-3) where materials are exposed to acids, bases, and solvents for 24 hours to measure degradation, such as discoloration or pitting. Ratings generally range from Level 0 (no effect) to Level 3 (significant, but often acceptable change), ensuring safety and structural integrity in laboratories.
  2. blog.fundermax.us
  3. blog.fundermax.us
  4. +1
  5. Key Aspects of Lab Countertop Resistance Ratings
  6. Testing Methodologies (SEFA-3): The Scientific Equipment and Furniture Association (SEFA) provides standard tests, often involving a 24-hour exposure to dozens of reagents. Technicians evaluate for surface deterioration.
  7. Rating Levels:
  8. Level 0 - No Effect: No detectable surface change.
  9. Level 1 - Excellent: Slight change in color or gloss, no loss of function.
  10. Level 2 - Good: Discernible change in color/gloss, no significant impairment.
  11. Level 3 - Fair: Discoloration or etching, possibly affecting long-term function.
  12. "Laboratory Grade" Requirement: For a material to be considered high-grade, it usually cannot receive more than four Level 3 results during testing.
  13. Material Performance Comparison:
  14. Epoxy Resin: The top performer, offering supreme, non-porous resistance to heat and harsh, aggressive chemicals.
  15. Phenolic Resin: Lightweight, chemically resistant, and non-porous; excellent for general, high-use labs.
  16. Stainless Steel: Excellent for sterile environments, though stronger acids and chlorates can cause corrosion, particularly in lower-grade steels.
  17. What Resistance Defines: It ensures the surface maintains its integrity (no swelling, cracking, or pits) rather than simply acting as a "stain-proof" surface.
  18.  
  19. How to Choose Chemical-Resistant Countertops for Your Lab
  20.  
  21. Choosing chemical-resistant countertops for your laboratory might seem like a minor detail—but in reality, it’s one of the most critical decisions you can make when setting up or upgrading your lab.
  22.  
  23. Chemical spills, high temperatures, and constant wear and tear are everyday occurrences in scientific environments. The wrong countertop material can quickly degrade, compromise safety, and even affect the integrity of your research.
  24.  
  25. Chemical-resistant countertops are designed to withstand harsh conditions while supporting clean, compliant, and efficient lab operations. But with so many materials and features to choose from, how do you know which option is right for your space?
  26.  
  27. In this article, we’ll break down what to look for when selecting chemical-resistant lab countertops, explore the pros and cons of popular materials, and offer tips to help you make a confident, informed choice—one that supports your work today and for years to come.
  28.  
  29. Why Chemical Resistance Matters in a Lab Setting
  30. Laboratories are high-demand environments where work surfaces face constant exposure to harsh substances—acids, solvents, alkalis, disinfectants, and more. Without the proper chemical-resistant surfaces, even the most sophisticated lab can become compromised.
  31.  
  32. Safety is the number one concern. Countertops that react with chemicals or degrade over time can release harmful fumes, cause burns, or become brittle and unstable. In worst-case scenarios, this could lead to contamination of experiments, equipment damage, or serious accidents.
  33.  
  34. Longevity and cost-efficiency are also key considerations. Materials that aren’t built to withstand regular chemical exposure may need replacing far sooner than expected, driving up long-term costs. Investing in chemical-resistant surfaces from the start helps minimize maintenance, reduce downtime, and extend the lifespan of your lab infrastructure.
  35.  
  36. Compliance with industry standards is another crucial factor. Whether you’re operating in an academic research setting or a pharmaceutical-grade facility, regulatory agencies, like the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), often require materials that meet specific performance and safety benchmarks. Choosing the right chemical-resistant countertop material is part of staying inspection-ready and maintaining a safe, compliant workspace.
  37.  
  38. In short, chemical resistance isn’t a luxury—it’s a lab essential.
  39.  
  40.  
  41.  
  42. Chemical resistant materials for lab countertops
  43.  
  44.  
  45.  
  46. Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Lab Countertops
  47. Selecting the right lab countertop isn’t just about durability—it’s about finding a surface that supports your specific workflow, withstands your daily demands, and stays reliable over time. Here are the most important factors to keep in mind:
  48.  
  49. 1. Chemical Resistance
  50. Chemical-resistant countertops are non-negotiable in most labs. Make sure the countertop material can handle the full range of substances used in your space—acids, bases, solvents, and other corrosive chemicals. Some materials offer broad-spectrum resistance, while others are best suited for milder environments.
  51.  
  52. 2. Durability and Longevity
  53. Look for materials that hold up against scratching, cracking, and regular impact. The harder your surfaces work, the more you’ll need something tough enough to stay intact year after year.
  54.  
  55. 3. Thermal Resistance
  56. Will your work involve high temperatures, open flames, or hot equipment? Not all countertop materials are built to handle heat without warping or degrading. If thermal stress is part of the equation, choose accordingly.
  57.  
  58. 4. Cleanability and Maintenance
  59. Smooth, non-porous surfaces make cleaning quick and effective, reducing the risk of contamination. Some materials are also more resistant to staining or microbial growth—especially important in biology, medical, or food testing labs.
  60.  
  61. 5. Cost vs. Value
  62. It can be tempting to go with a low-cost option, but cheaper materials often have shorter lifespans or limitations that could lead to unexpected expenses. Consider long-term performance and maintenance when weighing cost.
  63.  
  64. 6. Aesthetic and Functionality
  65. Function always comes first—but the visual aspect and layout flexibility of a countertop can still matter. Some materials are available in various colors or finishes, which may be important for matching institutional branding or creating a clean, professional space.
  66.  
  67. By weighing these factors against your lab’s specific needs, you’ll be better equipped to choose a countertop that performs under pressure—and looks good doing it.
  68.  
  69. Additional Reading: Anti-Microbial Lab Surfaces: Reducing Contamination Risks
  70.  
  71.  
  72.  
  73. Blood sample and petri dish on a chemical-resistant stainless steel table
  74.  
  75.  
  76.  
  77. Overview of Common Countertop Materials
  78. Not all lab countertops are created equal. The best chemical-resistant choice depends on your lab’s specific needs—but understanding the pros and cons of each material is a great place to start.
  79.  
  80. 1. Epoxy Resin
  81. The gold standard for chemical labs. Epoxy resin is formed by curing a mixture of resin and hardener into a solid, non-porous surface.
  82.  
  83. Pros: Exceptional chemical resistance, high durability, heat resistance up to 350 °F (177 °C), moisture- and bacteria-resistant
  84. Cons: Heavy and more expensive than some alternatives; professional installation recommended
  85. 2. Phenolic Resin
  86. A popular, lightweight alternative to epoxy resin, made by layering paper or fabric with phenolic resin under heat and pressure.
  87.  
  88. Pros: Good chemical resistance, lighter weight, cost-effective
  89. Cons: Lower heat resistance than epoxy; less durable over time in high-use environments
  90. 3. Stainless Steel
  91. Ideal for labs where sterility and cleanability are top priorities—like pharmaceutical or food testing facilities.
  92.  
  93. Pros: Durable, easy to disinfect, resists corrosion from water-based substances
  94. Cons: Can be scratched or dented; not ideal for strong acids or chlorides
  95. 4. High-Pressure Laminate (HPL)
  96. Constructed from layers of resin-saturated paper, HPL is often used in educational labs or dry environments.
  97.  
  98. Pros: Economical, available in a wide range of colors and styles
  99. Cons: Limited chemical and heat resistance; not suited for high-risk or high-use areas
  100. 5. Ceramic and Stone (e.g., glazed tile, granite)
  101. These surfaces are chemically inert and heat-tolerant, but are more commonly used in specialty labs.
  102.  
  103. Pros: Extremely resistant to heat and chemicals; easy to clean
  104. Cons: Very heavy; can be brittle or prone to chipping; costly to install or replace
  105. 6. Polypropylene
  106. A niche material for highly corrosive environments (e.g., acid digestion labs).
  107.  
  108. Pros: Excellent chemical resistance, especially to acids
  109. Cons: Low heat resistance; limited availability and higher cost
  110. Each material has its own strengths and trade-offs. The key is finding the one that matches your lab’s daily demands—whether it’s a heavy-duty research space or a more budget-conscious teaching lab.
  111.  
  112. Additional Reading: Lab Counters: Selecting the Best Materials and Design for Your Workspace
  113.  
  114.  
  115.  
  116. Steel plates for laboratory worktops
  117.  
  118.  
  119.  
  120. Matching the Material to the Application
  121. With so many options available, the right chemical-resistant countertop material depends on more than just durability—it needs to align with the specific work being done in your lab. Here’s how to narrow it down:
  122.  
  123. Chemistry Labs
  124. Recommended: Epoxy resin or phenolic resin
  125. Why: Frequent exposure to harsh chemicals and heat demands a surface that won’t corrode, crack, or stain. Epoxy offers top-tier resistance, while phenolic can be a good chemical-resistant fit for labs with moderate chemical use.
  126. Biological and Medical Labs
  127. Recommended: Epoxy resin or stainless steel
  128. Why: These labs need surfaces that are easy to sanitize and resistant to bacteria and biohazards. Stainless steel is perfect for sterile environments, while epoxy is a chemical-resistant material for cleaning agents and lab fluids.
  129. Pharmaceutical Labs
  130. Recommended: Stainless steel or epoxy resin
  131. Why: Cleanroom environments require non-porous, easy-to-sanitize materials. As chemical resistant countertops, stainless steel shines here for sterility, while epoxy can handle chemical exposure without compromise.
  132. Educational Labs
  133. Recommended: High-pressure laminate (HPL) or phenolic resin
  134. Why: For classrooms and teaching labs, cost-effective materials like HPL may be sufficient—especially when exposure to harsh chemicals is limited. Phenolic adds an extra layer of durability if needed.
  135. Industrial or Quality Control Labs
  136. Recommended: Epoxy resin, ceramic, or polypropylene (depending on processes)
  137. Why: If the lab handles caustic chemicals or aggressive substances, these materials provide the best resistance to corrosion, temperature, and impact.
  138. By identifying the primary functions of your lab, you can match the surface to the job—ensuring chemical-resistant countertops that provide safety, efficiency, and a better return on your investment.
  139.  
  140.  
  141.  
  142. Chemical-resistant worktop in educational lab
  143.  
  144.  
  145.  
  146. Practical Tips for Selection and Installation
  147. Once you’ve narrowed down your countertop material options, it’s time to turn your attention to the bigger picture—how to choose wisely and set things up for long-term success. Here are some expert tips to guide the process:
  148.  
  149. 1. Consult Lab Design Experts
  150. Every lab is unique, and what works in one environment might fall short in another. Partnering with lab design specialists, like Genie Scientific, ensures your workspace is tailored to your workflow, compliance requirements, and long-term goals.
  151.  
  152. 2. Think Beyond the Surface
  153. Countertops are just one piece of the lab puzzle. Consider how the work surface integrates with cabinetry, ventilation, safety systems, and traffic flow. A well-planned layout improves efficiency and minimizes hazards.
  154.  
  155. 3. Plan for Maintenance and Repairs
  156. Even the most durable materials benefit from regular care. Ask about cleaning guidelines, chemical compatibility charts, and available repair kits—especially if your lab deals with harsh or unpredictable substances.
  157.  
  158. 4. Don’t Forget Future Flexibility
  159. Labs evolve. Whether you’re scaling up, adding new equipment, or adjusting to regulatory changes, choosing modular or adaptable systems can save time and money down the road.
  160.  
  161. 5. Prioritize Professional Installation
  162. Improper installation can lead to poor sealing, instability, or early wear and tear. Make sure your countertops are installed by professionals familiar with lab standards—precision matters.
  163.  
  164. With the right guidance and a bit of foresight, choosing and installing chemical-resistant countertops becomes a smooth, strategic part of building a high-performance lab.
  165.  
  166. How to Choose Lab Work Surfaces: Chemical Resistance
  167.  
  168. The open bench has changed significantly over the last 30 years in wet labs, as have many of the reagents and their usage. These changes give rise to evolving considerations for determining and understanding the need for chemical resistance on lab work surfaces.
  169.  
  170. Various laboratory work surfaces include (but are not limited to) phenolic resin, epoxy resin, polypropylene, solid surface, ceramic, and stainless steel. When comparing these options, there are many important performance criteria to consider, including
  171.  
  172. durability
  173.  
  174. sustainability
  175.  
  176. abrasion & scratch resistance,
  177.  
  178. ease of cleaning,
  179.  
  180. heat / cold resistance (including thermal shock),
  181.  
  182. flammability/ flame spread,
  183.  
  184. impact resistance
  185.  
  186. and arguably the most important criteria: chemical resistance.
  187.  
  188. Generally speaking, phenolic resin countertops are highly chemical-, bacteria-, moisture-, scratch-, and impact-resistant, as well as lightweight and easy to clean. Phenolic resin work surfaces also tend to be very cost efficient. However, it is important to also understand the surface technology used for phenolic resin panels, as this will play a major role in the chemical resistance.
  189.  
  190. Epoxy resin countertops offer high chemical, heat, and moisture resistance but are easily scratched, are extremely heavy, and can be cost prohibitive.
  191.  
  192. Polypropylene work surfaces provide high chemical resistance but are heat sensitive and scratch prone.
  193.  
  194. Stainless steel lab work surfaces offer a good level of chemical resistance but are known for their high levels of bacteria resistance. Stainless steel is, however, prone to scratches.
  195.  
  196. Solid surface work surfaces, depending on the materials used to create the product, can offer a level of chemical resistance and are fairly durable in terms of scratch resistance. However, they can be cost prohibitive.
  197.  
  198. Ceramic work surfaces, depending on the glaze used, offer a high level of chemical resistance and are extremely heat resistant but can be both cost prohibitive and relatively fragile.
  199.  
  200. With so many options, to confidently select the chemical resistant lab panels that will suit your work surface needs, it’s essential to:
  201.  
  202. Identify the test methodologies that can reliably certify a material’s capabilities.
  203.  
  204. Establish the chemical and stain resistant requirements of your particular lab.
  205.  
  206. Determine which material options (including color) are available (within budget) and can withstand harsh cleaning applications.
  207.  
  208.  
  209.  
  210. What is SEFA and Why is it Important?
  211. Any conversation about test methodologies for lab work surfaces begins and ends with SEFA (The Scientific Equipment and Furniture Association). SEFA was organized in 1988 to meet the needs of the lab designers and manufacturers of laboratory furniture. The association has grown from strength to strength since this time. Commenting on the association, David Sutton, JD, CAE, Executive Director and General Counsel said,
  212.  
  213. "Since the time SEFA members began the process of establishing laboratory grade standards for lab furniture and related equipment (such as lab work surfaces) our membership and influence has grown exponentially throughout the world. Perhaps the most important aspect of our laboratory grade standards is the chemical resistance testing for every major lab surface that can be exposed to the many harmful chemicals commonly encountered in a lab environment. No lab should have furniture or related equipment that has not been previously tested to SEFA's standards."
  214.  
  215. SEFA members work closely with laboratory owners, architects, contractors, and others to advance the goal of creating a safe “Laboratory Grade” environment. SEFA strives to
  216.  
  217. stimulate users to consider and define their needs,
  218.  
  219. advance the professionalism, reputation and effectiveness of its members’ participation in the lab design and construction industry,
  220.  
  221. equip users to evaluate materials based on performance characteristics deemed appropriate for a material’s specific use.
  222.  
  223. What is the SEFA Standard?
  224. The SEFA standard related to laboratory surfaces, is SEFA-3, the standard for horizontal laboratory surfaces (i.e., lab work surfaces and countertops). SEFA-3 should not be confused with the chemical test under SEFA-8, for vertical laboratory surfaces (i.e., lab casework and door fronts, etc.).
  225.  
  226. SEFA-3 Standard for Laboratory Work Surfaces (Horizontal)
  227. The SEFA-3 Chemical/Stain Resistance Test evaluates a material’s resistance to chemical spills. The SEFA-3 standard is a longer test than that used in SEFA-8 because a horizontal lab work surface must be durable enough to handle contact with chemicals more than any other laboratory surface.
  228.  
  229. SEFA-3 testing must be performed and documented by a SEFA-approved third-party testing facility. In-house testing is not allowed; this helps keep tests reliable and companies honest. The test results are then sent to SEFA, who then publishes that a material has met the requirements on its website. Material manufacturers that are SEFA members are also held to a high standard of ethics, thus we can’t reiterate enough to only select materials that are listed on the association’s site: https://sefa.memberclicks.net/sefa-compliant-products. Visiting the site will provide additional assurance that the surface selected is both compliant and held to a high standard.
  230.  
  231. Lab planners and designers should select a manufacturer whose materials have passed SEFA-3. However, although manufacturers need only say whether they passed SEFA-3, we believe that users are wise to review a product’s actual SEFA-3 test scores/ratings. (More on this later.)
  232.  
  233. The SEFA 3 list of recommended practices are continually evaluated by the Work Surface Committee. The testing methodologies and RPs are currently being updated to create a standard that architects, lab planners and users can rely on to ensure material tested meets the needs of today’s lab. The committee is also considering revising the rating system to remove potential subjectivity.
  234.  
  235. SEFA-8 Standard for Laboratory Casework (Vertical)
  236. Intended for vertical surfaces like casework, the SEFA-8 chemical test is a 1-hour test – with different pass/fail criterion relative to the material being tested. For instance, polypropylene doesn’t allow any Level 3 failures. This article focuses primarily on horizontal laboratory work surfaces, so we won’t cover SEFA-8 in depth here. However, it is valuable to understand the difference in each testing standard’s focus and purpose.
  237.  
  238. Test Methods for SEFA-3
  239. SEFA-3 tests resistance to 49 different chemicals using one of two test methods. Test method A or B depends on whether the chemical is volatile or non-volatile.[1]
  240.  
  241. Test Method A: Volatile Chemicals
  242. A cotton ball saturated with the test chemical is placed in a one-ounce bottle (10mm x 7mm test tube or similar container). The container is inverted on the test material surface for 24 hours. Temperature of test: 23° +/- 2°C (73° +/- 4°F). This method is used for the organic solvents:
  243.  
  244. Acetate, Amyl
  245.  
  246. Acetate, Ethyl
  247.  
  248. Acetone
  249.  
  250. Alcohol, Butyl
  251.  
  252. Alcohol, Ethyl
  253.  
  254. Alcohol, Methyl
  255.  
  256. Benzene
  257.  
  258. Carbon Tetrachloride
  259.  
  260. Chloroform
  261.  
  262. Cresol
  263.  
  264. Dichloroacetic Acid
  265.  
  266. Dimethylformamide
  267.  
  268. Dioxane
  269.  
  270. Ethyl Ether
  271.  
  272. Formaldehyde, 37%
  273.  
  274. Furfural
  275.  
  276. Gasoline
  277.  
  278. Methyl Ethyl Ketone
  279.  
  280. Methylene Chloride
  281.  
  282. Monochlorobenzene
  283.  
  284. Naphthalene
  285.  
  286. Phenol, 90%
  287.  
  288. Toluene
  289.  
  290. Trichloroethylene
  291.  
  292. Xylene
  293.  
  294. Test Method B: Non-Volatile Chemicals
  295. Five drops (1/4cc) of the test chemical are placed on the test material surface. The chemical is covered with a watch glass (25mm), convex side down for 24 hours. Temperature of test: 23° +/- 2°C (73° +/- 4°F). This method is used for all chemicals other than solvents:
  296.  
  297. Acetic Acid, 98%
  298.  
  299. Acid Dichromate, 5%
  300.  
  301. Ammonium Hydroxide, 28%
  302.  
  303. Chromic Acid, 60%
  304.  
  305. Formic Acid, 90%
  306.  
  307. Hydrochloric, 37%
  308.  
  309. Hydrofluoric Acid, 48%
  310.  
  311. Hydrogen Peroxide, 30%
  312.  
  313. Iodine, Tincture of
  314.  
  315. Nitric Acid, 20%
  316.  
  317. Nitric Acid, 30%
  318.  
  319. Nitric Acid, 70%
  320.  
  321. Phosphoric Acid, 85%
  322.  
  323. Silver Nitrate, Saturated
  324.  
  325. Sodium Hydroxide, 10%
  326.  
  327. Sodium Hydroxide, 20%
  328.  
  329. Sodium Hydroxide, 40%
  330.  
  331. Sodium Hydroxide Flake
  332.  
  333. Sodium Sulfide Saturated
  334.  
  335. Sulfuric Acid, 33%
  336.  
  337. Sulfuric Acid, 77%
  338.  
  339. Sulfuric Acid, 96%
  340.  
  341. Sulfuric Acid, 77% & Nitric Acid, 70% equal parts
  342.  
  343. Zinc Chloride Saturated
  344.  
  345. Test Ratings
  346. For both test methods, after 24 hours of exposure, exposed areas are washed with water, then a detergent solution, and finally with isopropyl alcohol. Materials are then rinsed with distilled water and dried with a cloth. Samples are numerically rated as follows:
  347.  
  348. Level 0 – No Effect – No detectable change in the material surface.
  349.  
  350. Level 1 – Excellent – Slight detectable change in color or gloss but no change in function or life of the surface.
  351.  
  352. Level 2 – Good – A clearly discernible change in color or gloss but no significant impairment of surface life or function.
  353.  
  354. Level 3 – Fair – Objectionable change in appearance due to discoloration or etch, possibly resulting in deterioration of function over an extended period.
  355.  
  356. To pass as “Laboratory Grade,” a material may not receive more than four Level 3 results.
  357.  
  358. The SEFA-3 test results for our chemical resistant lab panels, Fundermax Max Resistance2, as depicted below, highlight that these laboratory grade phenolic panels received no Level 3 results. The surface for black received Level 0 ratings (No Effect – best possible rating) on 37 out of 49 reagents, nine Level 1 ratings (Excellent), and three Level 2 (Good). As a chemical resistant lab panel, this material didn’t just pass SEFA-3 – it passed with flying colors.
  359.  
  360. It is important to note that stains can impact colors differently, and thus the test results pertaining to lightest and/or darkest colors should also be considered. For instance, the white Fundermax RE panel received Level 0 ratings (No Effect – best possible rating) on 39 out of 49 reagents, six Level 1 ratings (Excellent), and four Level 2 (Good).
  361.  
  362. How to Know What Product to Use as Your Work Surface
  363. Platte-2181-RE-mit-Deko-Zuschnitt-jpeg
  364. Laboratories use a wide variety of work surfaces, so the key to knowing what’s right for your lab is clarifying what kind of lab you have and what chemicals will be used (now, and in the future). Since different materials offer different levels of chemical resistance, this knowledge equips you to specify appropriate work surfaces for your lab’s chemical exposure.
  365.  
  366. SEFA-3 certification is an essential baseline for certifying chemical resistance. But remember, chemical and stain resistance is affected by concentration, time, temperature, humidity, housekeeping, and other factors; therefore, users should consider testing samples in their actual environment with the substances they use.
  367.  
  368. For example, researchers may take a Fundermax phenolic panel sample and test it with the chemicals they'll use in the lab, considering all chemical and staining agents they might use on or near the laboratory work surface. We advise choosing the product that offers the most chemical resistance your lab might need, even in the future. The current exposure may be hydrochloric acid, and the lab may use much harsher chemicals in a year or two. It is always wise to utilize the highest level of chemical resistance possible, combined with other important considerations.
  369.  
  370. Other things to keep in mind when selecting a chemical resistant work surface include whether the material is
  371.  
  372. Sustainable
  373.  
  374. Abrasion- and scratch-resistant
  375.  
  376. Non-porous
  377.  
  378. Durable enough for harsh cleaning agents
  379.  
  380. Lab Maintenance
  381. Including maintenance and facilities managers in material specification is crucial to appreciating their role in lab material maintenance. Likewise, in university laboratories, ensure that students are well-advised about their responsibilities pertaining to work surfaces. SEFA offers stringent testing for chemical resistance, but remember that the SEFA-3 testing method is for 24 hours; it remains critical that any type of spills and/or chemicals are cleaned immediately, regardless of the material selected for the work surface.
  382.  
  383. If you are evaluating lab work surfaces, our experts are available to discuss the unique qualities of our phenolic panel lab surface technologies. In addition, our experience in various laboratory applications worldwide allows our team to help support your lab design, ensuring it meets your specific qualifications. We also stock some of our most popular work surfaces in the US, which negates the impact of supply chain issues.
  384.  
  385. In contrast to other compact work surfaces, Max Resistance2 phenolic panels are unaffected by contact with even the most concentrated or aggressive chemicals. You can rely on total chemical resistance; Max Resistance2 not only meets the standards set by SEFA 3, it surpasses them.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment