Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- "in Christian theology, if a human person has a human soul and a human body, did the Messiah have a human soul as a human person?"
- in Muslim theology, the answer is very simple... this question in Christian theology, however, is an absolute field of landmines.
- Premise 1: Human persons have human bodies and human souls
- Premise 2: "The Messiah, being 'fully human', had a human soul and is a human person" is a proposition that is either true or false by the Law of the Excluded Middle
- Premise 3: Both options are denied by Trinitarians
- Conclusion: The Trinity is illogical and cannot exist in reality
- No = Apollinarianism ; yes = Nestorianism ; Trinity = everything to be human, but not what a human is (human soul, spirit, body, will, but not a human person), which is an incoherence
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment