Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Showcase of opinions passed as truths in Core A's video "Analysis: The Consequences of Reducing the Skill Gap", showing why the video fails as an analysis, and instead is a opinion piece. Regardless of the statements being true or not, they need to be shown in text to be acceptable as analysis.
- "The most significant moment in fighting game history is the Daigo parry... it has been viewed over 30 million times...." The number 30 million is not backed up, and even by adding the two largest youtube videos together it only makes 8.5 million views. Even with view count there are other videos that are larger than the questionable 30 million views. Street Fighter (1994) the movie has much of the same mentioned accolades that the Daigo parry has, and some are even greater in those metrics.
- "There are a lot of reasons why it was such a big deal, but at the core of it, it was simply because it took a lot of skill" claims without any evidence that the main reason the event was popular is because it took skill. In truth no one can claim to know why it is as popular as it is. Without a representative sample being surveyed, and without knowledge of what spread the video there can only be assumptions as to why it is popular. The other issue is that "it took a lot of skill" is not quantifiable. Through the explanation given in the video that it is 15 parries with a 1/6th of a second timing with a specific pattern and tempo, regardless of how accurate that explanation is, we can gauge it to other events. Other street fighter games, such as 5, have harder input requirements. C.MK xx V, DF+MK(MK ORB), C.HP xx QCF+LP(MP ORB), Walk, S.HP xx QCF+P, C.HP xx QCF+LP(HP Orb), Walk, S.HP xx QCF+P, C.HP xx QCF+LP(HK ORB), Walk, S.HP xx QCF+P, C.HP xx D+V-Skill(LP ORB), QCF+HP(LK ORB), QCF+P, CA as an example is a Menat bread and butter vtrigger 1 confirm, with almost every move having less than 1/6th of a second of leniency. There are plenty more examples in other games and even harder things in third strike itself. As an example, parrying Ibuki's super art 1 often requires the same amount of parries, but due to variable timing on the hits the window is tighter.
- "Competitive games are harder to get into because you can learn a game for hours and still know nothing about it" requires evidence to show that it is true. Plenty of competitive games do not take hours to learn, are easy to play, or use something other than knowledge of the game to support competition.
- "Gamers are older now with real jobs and real responsibilities" Needs a source.
- "... the last thing you do is want to work for your entertainment, but for competitive folk that is the entertainment" Overgeneralized statement on what people find entertaining. It is also an assumption about what the average competitive player thinks and requires a source to be taken as truth.
- Monologue about reducing the skill gap being a goal for fighting game designers needs a source.
- Rewarding legacy skill and dedication vs lowering the skill gap is a false dichotomy.
- "By attempting to satisfy so many different groups, the game itself starts to get shaped by people who don't care about the game other than its potential return on investment..." is saying that no one who cares about investments can also care about the game. This is a no true Scotsman fallacy, unless it can be shown to be true.
- "...or people who think running out the clock with a life lead makes you a douchebag" is also a false claim as many competitive players do think this (I'm not able to find sources at the moment, but look at reactions towards Chris G after he developed morri-doom or to Justin Wong during his early MVC2 days, alternatively look at Mang0 in super smash brothers melee towards Hungrybox's playstyle).
- "it's gotten to the point where highly respected pro players are literally calling the developers of the game retarded" Implies that this is a new thing, despite it almost assuredly not being one (again not sourced, but Adam "TheKeits" Heart has said on twitter that top players would insult him, or accuse him of working against them, while other people like MK Tom Brady have said many times that games like Mortal Kombat vs DC was developed by all sorts of derogatory terms). Side note, the video example of bonchan saying "The guy who created the Boxer, or the concept of the Boxer, is retarded" is not specific to the current boxer in SFV and could be referring to the boxer concept started in SF2.
- "To get to the root of the issue, let's start with the "party game". Drinking games like beer pong can be explained in a few minutes, and it's not uncommon for people playing for the first time to win" Where it is relevant that the game can be explained in a matter of minutes, it is not relevant that a new player can beat someone in their first game. What would be relevant is if new players could beat a highly skilled player in their first game, and that is both not said and not true. As to why a new player would not win is because, like other bar games, in the end it is a hard game to become reliable at. It is simply a less competitive version of a game like pool or darts. Both pool and darts are explained in minutes, but a pro player would not lose to a new player.
- "This is why one of the worst things you can say about a competitive game is that it resembles a party game in some way" Not true in this generalized form. No sources, but I've not seen outrage near the level of the FGC's about poker being called a party game.
- "But luck is actually great for party games because they protect egos. Players can attribute their wins to skill, but blame chance on their losses. No need to accept that you suck, so everyone is happy" Needs a source.
- "With Street Fighter 5's simpler and more lenient combo execution, intermediate players are now able to perform any combo with little to no effort" Misleading, as even in high level play combos are dropped.
- "This lowers combo variety and ultimately hurts the ability of the players to express themselves" Needs to explain why, and combo variety and expression needs to be related to the skill gap in some way.
- Defensive options spiel needs to be explained on why it causes volatility and lowers the skill gap.
- Comeback section is misleading, some of the interview clips were taken out of context and originally were not about the discussion of lowered defensive options, or anything brought up in the video so far.
- "Alongside volatile gameplay, the drastic balance changes have put pro players in a guessing game called, Who does Capcom like?" The thesis is not about SFV, and this has not been tied into the skill gap.
- "Input lag decreases your control over your character, and necessarily rewards prediction over reactions, which creates more uncertainty in outcome" This needs to be developed more. Is it new, intentional, and does prediction over reaction actually decrease the skill gap, and if so in what ways?
- The graph about skill and what players want is needing a source from a representative sample.
- "The excitement you here in this [Daigo parry] video isn't just because there was a comeback. It's because the comeback looked impossible. Making it easy so anyone could be the next 'Diego' profoundly misunderstands what makes Street Fighter exciting and makes the players profoundly sad" Both statements are personal opinions, and can not be treated as representative.
- "And this isn't just Street Fighter. We also saw this when Metal Gear cynically turned into a survival horror game, and when Call of Duty went sci-fi" Both unrelated and not representative. Think of games like Warhammer, Warcraft, Mario, and many others where the series has taken shifts and turns and ended up well loved and popular.
- "Why can't companies work WITH the players to make the game that suits their communities, if they're in it for the long haul? And I don't just mean some out of touch ideas of what you think they might like. I mean actually listening to what the most invested players want, and making a game they'll be excited to share with everyone around them" Shifts from communities to invested players, assuming they are the same. Assumes that his opinion reflects the opinion of the community and the invested players. Assumes that the companies didn't listen to the community when making accessibility changes as well.
- "but is it THAT not worth it to make a game enjoyable for its most dedicated players?" Assumes that the most dedicated players uniformly want one type of game.
- This isn't my opinion on things Core A got wrong, and I agree with some of the point I brought up and argued against. This is only to show that the video itself is not proper analysis and is instead opinions about how games should be. It is a misleading opinion piece that claims to be correct, and states opinions as if they are truths.
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment