Guy v PB

GuyofEvil vs Potential_Base_5879

Guy wins 3-0

Black Bolt vs Dimiria

First foremost, PLEASE BE SURE TO ESTABLISH YOUR CHARACTERS WITH GOOD SCANS. Potential_Base_5879, the issue I had that you did was having a broken link for Dimiria’s time stop ability. The wording was confusing and the scan you used was broken, in the entire debate Age Seal & Age Scratch were never properly shown. I do not parse into the 6+ RTs that are used in a matchup, so I have no clue who any of these characters are and what they can do. If an ability isn’t properly shown, I won’t take it into account.

PB did really well but was ultimately fighting a losing battle when the entirety of Dimiria’s abilities was put into question. Her only strength feat argued is scaling to Kagura, which I can reasonably see PB’s argument. However, the fact that a single sword clash is shown and there’s nothing else besides cutting a person that had no relevant durability feats is incredibly weak. Her durability is also in question with the only argument being a kick from Wendy in the face and whether or not it scales. Even if we took it at face value, Guy has proven Black Bolt has other esoteric methods that Dimiria has no dura for. With her abilities not properly shown, she’ll be blasted once with whatever and taken out immediately.

Black Bolt wins

Nanoha vs Enerjak

I feel both debaters established their own picks well but ultimately, Guy had a stronger pick. Enerjak’s big explosion is legit strong but I do believe the scan shows that Nanoha has taken similar attacks at point blank range with and without shield. So Nanoha can survive Enerjak’s attacks, but the reverse isn’t true. Even with the optimistic take that Enerjak took the full blow from Super Sonic, Nanoha attacks via piercing and energy attacks. These were not given to Enerjak and it seems unreasonable that he’d survive. The BFR argument is well done, but I do not believe Enerjak will lead with it, nor can he survive long enough to use it.

Nanoha wins

Mihawks vs Acnologia

PB had good arguments, unfortunately Guy is correct in the manga/anime scans department. So Mihawks will in fact send a massive slash in a fairly quick manner. The argument about Acnologia’s transformation is also something that leans in the direction that is slow and will just end up being cut up. This was a fairly short argued debate that if PB’s argument using anime scans were valid, it’d hold water and I’d lean in the other direction, but this is not the case unfortunately

Mihawks wins