Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Letter to the Chief Justices: Writ of Mandamus to Protect Imran Khan's Life and Dignity
- Dated: 17 November 2026
- To:
- The Honorable Chief Justice of Pakistan, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Constitution Avenue, Islamabad
- The Honorable Chief Justice, Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan, Islamabad
- The Honorable Chief Justice, Islamabad High Court, Islamabad
- Subject: Urgent demand for a writ of mandamus to enforce the Supreme Court's order of 18 August 2026 and to protect the life, health and dignity of Mr. Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi and Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan under Articles 4, 9, 10A, 14 and 25 of the Constitution
- My Lords,
- 1. Why we write
- We write to the three of you together, as the custodians of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, because the life of a former Prime Minister of Pakistan is now in danger, and because an order of the Supreme Court made to protect that life has, for three months, not been carried out.
- On 16 November 2026, Mr. Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi addressed an open letter to each of Your Lordships from Adiala Jail, Rawalpindi, through his counsel Barrister Salman Safdar, following a meeting with him on 11 November 2026. That letter describes the denial of justice to him and to his wife, the denial of his fundamental rights, long periods of total isolation, the denial of access to his family, friends and lawyers, and the devastating effect of all this on his health. In his own words: "At seventy-four, this unrelenting state is taking me to a place from which I may not return alive."
- We do not write to repeat his plea. We write to demand that it be answered, with a writ of mandamus that compels the State to do what the Constitution and the Supreme Court already require of it.
- 2. The Supreme Court's order of 18 August 2026
- On 18 August 2026, a three-member bench of the Supreme Court, headed by Mr. Justice Shahid Waheed and comprising Mr. Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghan and Mr. Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim, directed that:
- Mr. Imran Khan be shifted from Adiala Jail to Shifa International Hospital, Islamabad, within two days, for medical examination and treatment;
- a multidisciplinary medical board be constituted, in coordination with the management of Shifa International Hospital, comprising a physician, a general surgeon, a specialist in internal medicine, an eye specialist and a cardiologist;
- his personal physician, Dr. Faisal Sultan, and his sister, Dr. Uzma Khan, remain associated with his examination and treatment; and
- the authorities facilitate his contact with his family, including weekly family meetings and telephone calls with his sons.
- This order was not a favour. It was the Court's recognition that the right to life under Article 9 had come under threat inside a State prison, and that only independent specialist care could protect it.
- 3. The order has not been implemented
- The order was defeated within its first 72 hours. On the night of 20–21 August 2026, Mr. Imran Khan was taken not to Shifa International Hospital but to the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS), a State-run hospital. Dr. Faisal Sultan was taken separately to Shifa International Hospital, where he waited for nearly three hours for a patient who never arrived. The medical board as ordered, at the hospital ordered and with the personal physician ordered, was never constituted. Mr. Khan was returned to Adiala Jail before dawn.
- The Government's position that the order was "mostly" implemented, with the hospital and the doctor being the only differences, concedes the point. The hospital and the doctor were the substance of the order. An order to provide independent care is not implemented by providing care that is not independent.
- Dr. Uzma Khan filed a contempt petition on 22 August 2026. Applications for its early hearing were declined. On 16 September 2026, the matter was deferred amid a question of jurisdiction. Today, nearly three months after the order was made, it remains unimplemented in every essential respect, and the condition it was meant to address has grown worse.
- 4. The danger to Mr. Imran Khan's life
- According to Mr. Imran Khan's letter of 16 November 2026 and the record before the courts:
- Cardiac and blood pressure crisis. His blood pressure has risen from 130 to 150 and 170, and reached 192 and 193 on 10 November 2026. Doctors have warned him of a serious risk of brain haemorrhage and cardiac arrest, and he states that his heart has already suffered damage.
- Loss of sight. The report of the court-appointed amicus curiae after his visit of 10 February 2026 recorded that Mr. Khan had lost about 85% of the vision in his right eye, attributed to a central retinal vein occlusion that went untreated for months. He was given an intravitreal injection at PIMS as recently as the night of 10–11 November 2026. This is a condition that requires continuous specialist supervision, not episodic night-time transfers.
- Solitary confinement. He states that since 20 December 2025 he has been held in isolation for up to 22 hours a day, with no meaningful human contact, and without books or television.
- Denial of access. He states that he has been allowed only four meetings with his lawyers in 2026; that court-ordered telephone calls with his sons have not been facilitated; and that weekly meetings with his wife have been repeatedly cancelled.
- Medical recommendations ignored. He states that even the jail's own medical board recommended greater family contact and recreation for his mental well-being, and that these recommendations have not been implemented.
- Under the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules), confinement for 22 hours or more a day without meaningful human contact is solitary confinement (Rule 44), and solitary confinement for more than fifteen consecutive days is prolonged solitary confinement, which is prohibited (Rule 43). By his account, Mr. Khan has been held in these conditions for nearly eleven months.
- 5. The danger to Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan
- Mr. Khan's wife, Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan, is also a prisoner of the State. In April 2026 she suffered a retinal complication and underwent complex eye surgery. She now requires a second operation to prevent permanent loss of sight. Her medical records are being withheld from her family and access to her doctors is restricted. She has, according to Mr. Khan's letter, been allowed only one meeting with her lawyers this year. Her own application seeking transfer to a specialised hospital and the release of her full medical record is now before the Islamabad High Court.
- 6. The constitutional duty
- The rights at stake are not privileges of a prisoner. They are guarantees the Constitution makes to every person, and which no conviction, and no executive convenience, can suspend:
- Article 9: No person shall be deprived of life or liberty save in accordance with law. Since Shehla Zia v. WAPDA (PLD 1994 SC 693), the Supreme Court has held that "life" under Article 9 means a life lived with dignity, including access to the conditions necessary for health.
- Article 14(1): The dignity of man is inviolable. Prolonged isolation, the denial of family and the withholding of medical care are assaults on that dignity.
- Article 4: Every person has the inalienable right to enjoy the protection of law and to be treated in accordance with law. Prison authorities may not act outside the law, or outside the orders of the courts.
- Article 10A: The right to a fair trial and due process is hollow when a prisoner cannot meet his lawyers and his appeals are not heard.l
- Article 25: All citizens are equal before law and entitled to its equal protection.
- Articles 187 and 190: The Supreme Court may issue such directions and orders as are necessary for doing complete justice, and those orders are enforceable throughout Pakistan. All executive and judicial authorities throughout Pakistan shall act in aid of the Supreme Court.
- Article 199(1)(a)(i): The High Court may direct any person performing functions in connection with the affairs of the Federation to do what the law requires him to do.
- Pakistan has also ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which protects the right to life (Article 6), prohibits cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment (Article 7), and requires that all persons deprived of liberty be treated with humanity and respect for their inherent dignity (Article 10), and the Convention against Torture.
- Each of Your Lordships has taken the oath set out in the Third Schedule to the Constitution, to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution. That oath is not suspended by a question of which court has jurisdiction. A dispute about forum must not become a gap through which a human life falls. Whatever the allocation of jurisdiction among your courts after the Twenty-Seventh Amendment, the Constitution leaves no doubt that the right to life must be protected by someone, now.
- 7. What we demand
- We respectfully but firmly demand that each of Your Lordships, within your respective constitutional jurisdictions, treat this letter as a petition for the enforcement of fundamental rights and issue a writ of mandamus, or such directions as are necessary, to the Federal Government, the Chief Commissioner Islamabad, the Inspector General of Prisons Punjab and the Superintendent, Central Jail Adiala, Rawalpindi, requiring them:
- To shift Mr. Imran Khan to Shifa International Hospital, Islamabad, within 24 hours, in full compliance with the Supreme Court's order of 18 August 2026, and to keep him there for as long as the medical board advises.
- To constitute the medical board exactly as ordered, in coordination with Shifa International Hospital, including a consultant cardiologist and a consultant ophthalmologist (retina specialist), together with a physician, a general surgeon and a specialist in internal medicine, and to carry out without delay every investigation and treatment the board recommends, including the cardiac investigations already advised.
- To place his examination and treatment under the supervision of his own physician, Dr. Faisal Sultan, and his sister, Dr. Uzma Khan, with full and continuous access throughout, and to provide his complete medical record, not a summary, to them and to his counsel within 24 hours.
- To end his solitary confinement forthwith and to restore his rights under law: weekly meetings with his family, regular telephone calls with his sons, unhindered access to his lawyers, and access to books, newspapers and recreation, as his own jail medical board has recommended.
- To transfer Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan to a specialised eye hospital for her second operation under specialists of her family's choice, and to release her full medical record to her family and counsel.
- To appoint a court officer or local commission to oversee compliance, with a written compliance report to be placed before the Court within seven days.
- To fix the pending contempt petition, and Mr. Imran Khan's and Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan's pending appeals and applications, for urgent hearing, and to hold to account every official responsible for defeating the order of 18 August 2026.
- 8. Conclusion
- My Lords, the Supreme Court has already found that Mr. Imran Khan needs independent specialist care. The executive has chosen not to provide it. Every day that the order remains unimplemented is a day on which the authority of the Court, and the promise of Article 9, are diminished.
- If harm comes to Mr. Imran Khan or to Mrs. Bushra Imran Khan in State custody, the responsibility will rest on the State. But history will also ask what the courts did when they were told, in plain words, that a life was at risk. We appeal to Your Lordships to answer that question now, while it can still be answered with a remedy.
- We have the honour to be,
- Regards,
- [Name]
- [Additional signatories: names and designations]
- Copy to:
- The Attorney General for Pakistan, Islamabad
- The Advocate General, Islamabad Capital Territory
- The Chief Commissioner, Islamabad Capital Territory
- The Inspector General of Prisons, Punjab, Lahore
- The Superintendent, Central Jail Adiala, Rawalpindi
- References:
- Open letter of Mr. Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi dated 16 November 2026
- Order of the Supreme Court of Pakistan dated 18 August 2026
- Contempt petition of Dr. Uzma Khan filed 22 August 2026
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment