Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- The military, and war in general, has a lot of potential for horror. Hell, I’d wager that while they’re not usually structured the same way, the two genres have more than a couple of similarities in the freedom to show horrific things to its characters, and the best ones know how to drive that feeling of fear into their audiences. Here’s looking to you, Saving Private Ryan and/or Full Metal Jacket and/or Apocalypse Now. In fact, the argument could be made that, since they’re unfortunately grounded in our all-too real world, war movies can hit home a lot harder. A person will not be hunted by an alien Thing in a research base, but someone can very much be stabbed to death during combat by another human. This is an interesting debate, but not quite one here for this review.
- Anyway, 23:59, a Singaporean film from 2011, fails to really capitalize on either. I can’t speak on its authenticity, having neither been to Southeast Asian nor in any military, so when I say ‘it seems realistic enough’ that’s entirely in my ignorant layman terms. It stars a handful of young-ish cadets during their training time on an island military camp as part of their mandatory National Service, facing off against some strange spooks lurking in the jungles. It’s not terrible, but it’s not amazing either.
- It certainly starts off trying, though. There’s the obligatory prologue, a young gentleman, sitting awake in his barracks, as he’s menaced by a bouncing red ball, a menacing young child, and a menacing lady with blood all over her face. Or possibly missing her face entirely. The movie is certainly dark enough, with lots of scenes taking place at night, which does help set the mood. Either way, it was a lady with a messed up face, which is the important part.
- Then it cuts to the opening credits, where my first big gripes hit. Like a lot of horror movies, it does a little show during the credits set to horror mood music, this one being a bunch of sketches of various spooks across a military setting. A few, but not all, feature a tall lady with long hair hiding her face. This was actually a pretty neat sequence, as it gave to mind a military camp loaded with a variety of dark things, ghosts and spirits and other such horror staples. I was expecting the place to be rife with horror, so when the movie boiled down to pretty much one problem going on I ended up rather disappointed. It started to hype me up a little, then failed to really capitalize on it.
- When it starts up proper. Kids telling campfire stories around the fire, okay sure, bit heavy on some of the exposition with how “23:59 is used in so many army scary stories”. It’s midnight. It’s just military time for a second before midnight, which is also an evil hour here, and someone dying just before midnight is particularly evil, though I’d argue that a death is usually bad news at any time of day. In this case, the ghost story in particular is of a suicide that happened at that time, and some kids seeing a ghost of that long-haired lady floating over them. It cuts back and forth between them and the story they’re telling, which is a bit annoying. There’s a lot of flashbacks all across the movie. Usually one or two is handy when necessary, but too many end up messing up the movie’s pacing, as it’s just cutting to a different scene for easy expositing, then cutting back. Don’t want a movie jumping around too much, so that’s another problem here with 23:59.
- There’s a pretty standard first act here. People get introduced. You have Tan, the frightened young shy kid, Jeremy as the older-brother type friend who, as so very conveniently gets mentioned, on a scholarship and the platoon leader. Tan does come off as easily afraid and meek, and Dragon (the bully character) is played out as a bully, but having to outright tell me that Jeremy’s a scholarship smart type is a bit too on the nose. Better to show than tell, they say, and I’d rather a movie demonstrate the character being the leader-type and smart than just outright saying so and expecting me to believe it. Honestly, though, despite my quibbling, the characters are rather well fleshed out here, but more on that later.
- Dragon and his friends act manly and tough while bullying Tan, who is constantly afraid of what spooky monsters he’s seeing in his dream. Sinks turn themselves on, Tan gets scratched by a hand reaching out of the darkness when he’s shoved in the locker. There’s initial spookers going on here that try to hint at Bad Stuff happening, though it doesn’t come off as particularly scary. Trying to explain away lacerations that look like they’re half an inch wide as “coat hangar scratches” is eye-rolling, and a sink turning itself on isn’t terribly scary. Playing out the flashbacks as actual scenes rather than just one character speaking to another didn’t quite work as intended in my humble opinion, as it plays itself up way too hard and jumps the proverbial shark over literally nothing. I get that it’s trying to show off scary stuff early, but when it’s stuff that didn’t actually happen, much like the dream sequence opening, it drains a lot of tension out of the movie even when people do start really dying.
- There’s a Road March, which is from what I can tell where all the cadets have to much a long way through the jungle. It gets hyped up quite a bit, with Tan having a bad feeling about it and Sargeant Kuah saying the date for the march is suspicious. This is another thing that goes back to the gripe concerning the credit sequence. Sargeant Kuah is telling his new to the island superior that certain dates are bad. We don’t have training exercises on certain days of the week. We don’t march through certain graveyards for reasons beyond common courtesy. The island is Bad News, and this is known to the people who work there long enough. It paints a great picture of the island being a hotspot for spooky shit going on, a picture you don’t really see at all. I almost got the sense that it was trying to start off a series of island-centered army horror movies, though if it was then it’s a rocky enough start.
- Also Jeremy has a third eye power that lets him see ghosts, and there’s this whole issue about him being estranged from his so-called con man of a father. Yeah. That’s a thing, and it confused the heck out of me when I saw it too. Kinda came out of left field, which really hurts my overall suspension of disbelief in things.
- The road march happens. With how much people were worried about it, it comes off almost as if it should’ve been the big climactic scene, but it’s just sort of getting the real spooky stuff started properly. The kids get separated, we hear another story about a powerful medium that used to live on the island and her baby was possessed by an evil spirit or something. There was a surprisingly spooky shot of a girl walking past the group, right behind them as they talk. No musical cue or anything, but realizing that they’re being followed gave a rather nice chill down my spine. It’s the best scare of the movie, so it’s downhill from here.
- Some of them reconnect, there’s this mishandled “Everyone put your left hand on someone else’s shoulder and call out” that very obviously is set up to someone they don’t recognize being behind them and holding onto their shoulder, they find Tan’s dead body. There’s a whole hubbub back at camp, Kuah gets insulted for his bad English by a superior officer who’s just as bad at English as he is. Kuah thinks the island is haunted, superior officer doesn’t, same old argument we always hear in these things for drama. Again, I’m an ignorant layman here, but that the kids got split up on this march at all does seem like pretty bad supervision on his part.
- Tan came off as the main character before that, and now Jeremy takes over. More spooks now, though they’re about the same level of not-creepiness as before the road march. Locker shaking, dude sleepwalking, another fucking dream sequence fakeout, which is downright annoying at this point. Saying it was all a dream invalidates a lot of fear or tension you’re trying to build, which is why I wouldn’t recommend having even one in a horror movie, let alone two. Thanks for telling me these scares are fake and making me suspicious of anything I see later on. Between the dreams and the flashbacks there’s way too much cutting away from what’s actually going on here. It’s a weird amount of padding for a movie that’s already as short as it is (an hour and eighteen minutes).
- That being said, there’s a moment where Dragon The Bully actually says that he’s sorry for being mean to Tan. He admits that he was bullied a lot and sheepishly says he did it to Tan because it made him feel stronger, and genuinely comes off as sincerely remorseful. It’s a rather nice moment of characterization in an otherwise bland movie.
- More marching through the jungle, Jeremy sees a lady that he saw during the previous road march that is totally obviously 100% a ghost even though the movie tries to pretend otherwise. Chester seemingly gets possessed, freaks out, laughably bad demonic shouting and laughter. They hire a medium and we have yet another flashback of how Chester and Tan were assaulted by hidden spooks while on guard duty.
- Jeremy asks a girl working at the canteen, an island native, about what the fuck is up with the island and the story they heard about the medium that used to live there, we have another flashback to her deformed ghost-possessed child being shunned and whatnot, and the mean kids started dying off. The child supposedly had this power to control other people, which is obviously about to come into play.
- Next scene, Chester gets up at night and wanders off into the darkness, Jeremy gives chase. Sees the ghost lady thing he’d been seeing, and finds Chester in time to watch his arms contort and he fucking dies while the ghost lady medium looms out of the darkness. If this recounting seems rote and uninteresting, that’s because it comes off that way to me too. Aside from the ghost stories and flashback, there isn’t that much actual spooks happening on screen, which makes things seem rather dull. Tan’s death was off-screen, and Chester’s death was just his arm twisting a bit with nothing touching him. I get the sense that this movie is very, very low-budget, though not as bad as Deadly Detention. You can do scary with a low budget, but they don’t really do that here.
- There’s a chase scene, I guess, ghost medium chasing Jeremy. He twists his ankle in a hilariously outdated horror movie cliché, and that comes off as terribly forced for the sake of tension. He finds a presumably out of the way house with a mostly-decayed corpse in the rocking chair, which starts rocking on its own. Ghost medium catches up to him and says she didn’t kill anyone. It was her deformed possessed child who did. Who’s now a ghost, too.
- The movie more or less ends with Jeremy embracing the fact that ghosts are real and he can act as a medium, and that his father wasn’t actually a con man. He possesses the mother and hugs the ghost daughter, presumably an act of penitance for the way she died on that rocking chair while her daughter was chained to a wall, leading to her death as well. Yep. That’s it. That’s the major climax to the movie. Hugging a ghost while possessed as another ghost. There’s that buildup that the island was major haunted by a whole bunch of stuff, and we focus entirely on one mother and the child. What’s that about the lady with the torn-up face? The kid who committed suicide a year prior? Nothing, they seem unrelated. Red herring horror. There is some parallels between the ghosts’ family issues and Jeremy’s relationship with his own father, but any themes of forgiveness or family are barely touched upon at all. There’s more about bullying in this movie. The spooks barely have anything to do with the army as well, so trying to sell this movie as army spooks doesn’t quite fit as well. There’s army, there’s spooks, the two are mostly separate here, which was disappointing.
- There’s a cut to present day, so the whole fucking movie was apparently a flashback, where more recruits are telling stories. They hear ominous singing and the creeky door opens before cutting to credits. More hinting that this should’ve been a cavalcade of haunted military stuff, all of which was promptly shoved to the background for “horror” that doesn’t have anything to do with the army at all aside from the fact that the kids were cadets at the time it happened.
- Overall, the movie was bland but not offensively so. On a technical level everything seemed passable, I guess, but it wasn’t scary at all. I could see the formula trying to work. It sets up the premise of army cadets surrounded by spookers, then a kid dies, then they are surrounded by more spookers, another kid dies as they learn of the monster behind it, hero confronts monster and defeats it. The scares come off as mostly bland, it doesn’t really deliver on any hype, and there’s too many dream sequences and flashbacks. It functions, but only just so.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment