Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- “It’s normal to aim for a better high school, university, or company. That’s how you live a normal life. That’s why I always go to school even though I’d rather game or stare at the computer all day. Because I don’t want to trouble my parents. Because I don’t want to be called a hikikomori. Because I don’t want to be a freeter. That’s why I’m just gonna get a desk job and call it day. If I wanted to try climbing the corporate ladder, I’m already behind all the people with good grades. That system is only going to be a continuation of school. It’s a future without hope.”
- I’ve never lived in Japan, so its high school system is not part of my lived experience. I don’t really understand what it’s like to see my performance judged against my peers on the regular, year after year. I do know that the opening quote isn’t from Dangaronpa, it’s from Bakuman. The opening issue Mashiro faces is addressed by taking a gamble outside of the college and salaryman path by delving into the world of manga. But those trials aren’t an option worth considering to most. It’s certainly not a stable or healthy lifestyle. Though its cast is Talented, its to the common majority that Danganronpa seeks to connect to, its everyman protagonists serving as a window, a lens of contrast to the larger cast of super talented kids with their life’s course already planned out for them. The anxieties of a typical student like Mashiro are placed in an apocalyptic context. Outside of studying, high school is about the last time the average person is going to be in regular close contact with friends or express themselves through the time they spend. The future as a salaryman working long hours, brown nosing superiors, having your face in the grindstone for years can win something resembling a life of comfort...if you’re lucky. Leaving high school is the end of a world. It doesn’t matter how fun, silly, and goofy the anime is: graduating is always portrayed as bittersweet, as something is being left behind, never to be seen again. It’s completely different from my experience where graduating was a mildly notable event where ‘living’ was expected to start, not end. It’s graduation, or rather, the attempt to achieve it, that marks an end for much of the cast of Danganronpa, and in unpacking it, I think the best place to start would be on Danganronpa’s core mechanics as a game, and also where it separates itself most directly from its high school allegory: the class trials.
- Certainly, if Danganronpa is meant to explore anxieties surrounding high school, then crime and punishment may be a shade off of what one might expect. High school in itself is meant to prepare students for the world beyond. The student council is a clear emulation of bureaucratic structures, children allowed to manage and govern themselves to a degree, down to clubs, budgets, and class representatives. The class trials take this to an even further extreme, as one element of broader society not represented in the school structure as strongly is the ‘zero sum game’. Society isn’t so accommodating as to be designed to make a place for everyone. To survive you need money, to get money you need a job, and to get a job, you need to take a position that someone else might have been vying for. Through no fault of their own, one might continually fall through these cracks until they have nothing left. They played, they lost. There are winners, thus there must be losers. School is an ideal in contrast to this: it’s a place where doing your best might grant you further opportunity, but it won’t mean another will risk losing their place in the whole for it. Junko’s death game takes that ideal school life and makes it so it can only be escaped by graduation. It’s now a game where seeking your own success is at the cost of others. Following an expression of society’s filters, the ‘murderer’ must display a mastery of the systems in place to escape, understanding the rules and where they can toe the line or exploit a loophole. Whether it’s school, law, or politics, you play well or you lose. To win, figuratively, you must kill: grab opportunity not allowed for your competitors and take what they might need as well. As Junko puts it, sometimes the murders that people forgive are more abnormal than the ones they don’t. Her artifice evokes the reality through its exaggeration. To graduate to proper society, where such slow and indirect murder is forgiven, one must be willing to make the transition away from indirect and become complicit. By understanding this, in theory, one can surpass the killing game and enter the world knowing how it works, school’s place in guiding children to adulthood twisted into its darkest reality, those graduates having shown themselves capable in their transition. Most everyone has to play the game in one way or another, or it’s over. And the one skill needed across these areas most of all is logic.
- Logic is the most common tool you’ll utilize in solving the class trials. It’s also core to Enoshima Junko’s character. While her talent of Ultimate Analyst is most thoroughly explored in Danganronpa 0, and comes up in Danganronpa 3, it’s actually well established in the first game. In one of the Monokuma Theaters, she explains that she could understand the best strategies to use in a video game she’d never played or seen before merely from observation. Junko was born into the world in despair. Able to pick it apart endlessly, to recognize all its patterns and lay all possible outcomes bare, the world of logic is where she could make herself its queen of destruction. Logic is everything, after all. Through her Talent, Junko becomes master not just of the Killing Game, but of the world, bringing about its apocalypse through her understanding of humanity, its systems, and its values. Through her absolute knowledge she becomes an analogue of fate. Not as a goddess figure, per sey, but rather because she herself is challenging it. She’s only alive ‘because she doesn’t know if she believes in fate or not’. Retroactive to the events of the first game is the events of Danganronpa 0, where Junko’s scheme becomes a machination of fate for Yasuke. She made his mother lose her memory of him. Junko pulled him out of his isolation after his mother’s death, a failure of the doctors she was entrusted to. Junko had destroyed the sandcastle she made and caused the local uproar. She incited the Reserve Course with the first Killing Game through Kamukura Izuru. She drove the one she loved the most to his deepest despair. But while she spun the webs, he let himself be strung along. She declared that the choice was his, suggesting that he had autonomy, but those choices for Junko’s sake, such as the murder of Murasame and the removal of Junko’s memories, were all for the good of another rather than himself. For his inability to make a choice not for the sake of Junko, for not being able to challenge her, he would be forever trapped deferring the impetus behind his choices to the one who controlled his fate. In his love he tried to cling to his own hope no matter how much doing so would cause pain and death. Logic is Junko’s strength, and yet, the motives of DR0 are those of love. Yasuke’s humanity was not just in his love of Junko, but his ultimate need for logic, everything crumbling to despair once the basis for his worldview was split apart. And in that, I believe the motive carries over to DR1: Junko claims she loves her classmates, something that flies in the face of her horrible death game. Part of this is her desire to experience deeper despair: Yasuke was the one person she loved the most, and in her hope for despair she made him suffer and die. Yet, she also doesn’t fully believe that fate is immutable. While Yasuke ultimately made the choice that cemented him within Junko’s scheme, I believe the events of DR1 are meant to be the same, as Junko puts those she loves in a conflict of logic and emotion to challenge her perception of fate.
- Though Makoto is her counterpoint, the one to ultimately overcome her challenge, the conflict of logic and emotion is much more strongly represented in Kyouko, one who also has her memories altered much like Ryouko. She’s a detective serving as the Holmes to Makoto’s Watson, mentoring him through the game so that he can survive it. In the murder mystery, even without her memory, she’s always on top of it, the systems of logic within her mastery. Yet she’s not blind to emotion or the irrationality of the human mind, ensuring Makoto was aware that Sayaka had tried to protect him in her last moments. She straddles the line between the cold logic that Junko was born into and the warm humanity Makoto embodies. Caught between two extremes, as much as she captures their strengths, she’s just as susceptible to their limits. Logically, she’s held back by her emotion as she’s confronted with the legacy and remains of her father Jin. Having only come to Hope’s Peak to cut her ties with him, she comes to find that Makoto understood him better than she ever had by guessing his password was her full name simply through recognizing the near universality of a parent's love for their child. Kyouko knew the world she’d seen in the deductions she’d made, but her feelings of abandonment tinged her reading in emotional bias and left her blind, even knowing her past self had stayed at the school under Jin for two years despite having come to the school for the same reason. Makoto choosing not to confide in her as a means to protect Sakura legitimately stung, regardless of how good a reason he had, until she got over herself, her emotional response further stressing an already difficult situation. And emotionally, she was held back logically as she faced the world’s end. It made the most sense to remain at the school in comfort while the world continued to smolder. But Makoto paid her back. He’d been pushed forward by her advice before, helping her to remember that not knowing doesn’t mean one can’t try to understand.
- Makoto was able to pull every one of his allies onto the right path. Regardless of the outside world, the only way they could pay forward what they’d been given, the only way they could truly strive for what they wanted was by deciding it for themselves. Makoto is the Ultimate Hope, but while his forward thinking outlook is key, it’s not his only talent, much like Junko isn’t only Ultimate Despair. He is lucky, after all: Nagito might spell the talent out, but the same mechanics are plain as day for Makoto from the first Free time event with Sayaka. His unlucky assignment of animal duty on the day a crane wandered onto campus led to his fortune when Sayaka took notice of him. And never mind the importance of the stuck bathroom door in proving his innocence. While it can be read as a talent Makoto is unaware of for it not being fostered by the school system, there for him to discover on his own beyond the confines of those halls (as a representation of how what one learns about oneself during high school isn’t all defining), it actually goes a bit further. The Worst Day short story (which also includes the unlucky incident that lends to Makoto’s fortune in being accepted at the school) has a statement from a Hope’s Peak board member claiming that luck is a label applied after the fact. The natural order of events taking place. The occurrence of events that have a chance of happening, happening, because they will. And well, it’s not an unreasonable statement. Let’s say we take two draws of five cards each from two respective decks. The odds of getting this royal flush is 4 possible hands out of nearly 2.6 million hands. A probable event, however, will always happen. In truth, both of these hands are just as unique, much like every card in a deck. It’s the rules of poker that alters the value of these equally unique hands. To step back and apply this same idea to the universe, everything is just an assortment of particles. Things just happen as the natural order of events: any assignment of meaning is folly. This nihilistic outlook isn’t just the mindset represented within the school: Junko has never seen anything else. Her world doesn’t have chance, just knowns and unknowns. And even though Nagito has a marked mastery of his talent, the board members being chilled by its subversion of what is known, much like those board members, he feels no value in it at all. The world is interested in genius, talent, and effort, not causality and chance. He’s the complete opposite of Makoto, who stumbles through the trials where Nagito’s deduction is comparable to Kyouko, and his fuckery is second to none. Makoto is unaware of his luck where Nagito’s mastery is impeccable. Nagito rejecting luck is a rejection of his identity, the resultant lack creating a gap to be filled by Junko. But it’s also a rejection of meaning. If, under a nihilistic fatalism, fortune is a lie and falsehood, then chance cannot exist. And yet it does. Humans create circumstances to determine enrolment at an exceptional school. Drawing the bad straw is only lucky or unlucky if one assigns meaning to it. Junko and Nagito may not value that, but the talent has demonstrable affect over reality through chance, through human derived meaning. Even without recognizing his talent, Makoto is capable of accepting himself and all the luck that befalls him, good or bad, in stride.
- Though Makoto, in contrast to Nagito, has so much control over his own path, there’s another difference between him and Nagito that extends to the rest of their respective games. In spite of the systems that aimed to force their actions, Makoto and the remainder of his class is able to graduate on their own terms. There’s a power to that, as they go on to continue to challenge the ruling bodies of power, and eventually take a place at the top to potentially create something better. But they are still within the system, and all of them are those who flourish within it. The Danganronpa cast absolutely has their burdens, but when it comes to their talents, by and large they embrace them fully. But for the cast of DR2, talent, or in Hajime’s case, lack thereof, is a burden in and of itself. It’s directly discussed when Chiaki and Hajime find out about the Ultimate Imposter, lacking an identity and filling that hole through their own talent. Born into that talent, as Nagito describes this is a world that puts excellence and achievement on a pedestal. You either accomplish something amazing or you’re a nobody. The absolute extreme of that, the Imposter was exclusively identified by their talent, and nothing else. Yet to excel in school doesn’t mean one is a fit for all else that school entails. A real life example might be how professional sports and education are so closely tied together, which on paper might promote the education of athletes, but in reality leads to people with different skillsets at risk of being locked off if they don’t seek other methods, and college by no means prepares pro athletes for their lives during and after their careers. Two characters who explore this same concept in the games are Kiyotaka and Mikan. Both of their talents relate to legitimate positions one can hold in Japanese high school: Kiyotaka the Public Morals Committee, and Mikan the Health Committee. While both excel in their respective areas, Kiyotaka’s biggest abrasion with school is his inability to connect to the rest of his classmates due to his obsession with study, something he’s only able to understand through discussion with Makoto. His more pressing demon is his perception of talent and hard work as a dichotomy, born from his grandfather’s struggles as Prime Minister, his failing becoming a lesson for Kiyotaka. His issue with school is rather manageable, as he is a fit for those systems. Mikan however wasn’t merely unable to connect with her peers, she was a heavy victim of bullying, every day having to go to school where she’d meet her abusers again, unable to simply stop going as so much of her future was tied to her education. Her talent is in part a response to those circumstances, the excitement and thrill she gets out of having power over others through medical authority helping her cope with her lack of power in other aspects of her life. One could say that she was able to achieve her talent because of her circumstances, yet it was also a talent she was willing to throw away. She killed her own patient, Ibuki, and then lied during the investigation, abusing the trust placed in her for her talent. Nagito remarked that this was when she no longer deserved to be called an Ultimate Nurse, but Ultimate Despair. Rather than embody the world’s hope in fulfilling her talent, she rejected it for her love of Junko, who accepted her as she was, something no one else had done for her. Kiyotaka isn’t kept from healthy human connection by his talent, or kept from his talent by human connection. It was irrelevant. But for Mikan, her desire for human connection, and the Talent that gave her a place at Hope’s Peak, a place in the world at large, was ultimately, unfitting.
- And so many of the other characters have their own burdens for the positions allowed by their talent. Tanaka connected more easily to animals than people, putting on a persona specifically to keep others away. Teruteru aimed to became a chef, aimed to conform to the world’s idea of a successful culinary artist when he’d discovered his talent at the family diner he cared about so much that he was willing to kill to return home when he believed he otherwise wouldn’t be able to. Fuyuhiko and Peko were kept from friendship by their positions as master and servant, which was the only reason Peko had been placed at his side in the first place. Ibuki stresses to Hajime that the most important thing for a band isn’t playing well, it’s getting along with each other, and that was an aspect she failed at. It may not be universal amongst the cast, but it’s all so key to the most important characters that their talents, their natures, didn’t align with the world around them. Chiaki’s words about the Imposter also apply to herself, a program with limitations, with a defined purpose and reason to exist from the impetus of her creation. And it’s also true of Junko, born into despair without the ability to see anything else. In coming to Hope’s Peak, in exploiting it, Junko comes to connect with fellow talents, fellows like her born into their own personal despair. Those she loved, and those she used.
- While the cold, callous world of Hope’s Peak creates a class that falls utterly to Junko’s schemes, Makoto, confident in himself and able to go with the flow, has his strengths, but the first result of his attitude happened before the game even started, and the results were shown well before the end of Junko’s scheme. Junko’s seeds of her despair, her motives, were meant to twist the world’s hope into giving a school sanctioned murder so they can reclaim that which society offers in its social contract and their phenomenal talent: freedom, esteem, wealth. By twisting everything to despair, Junko achieves that which she cannot predict. And in that lack of prediction her defeat is set into motion, starting when Makoto had a bit of bad luck with a crane, guiding it out of school and earning the eye of Sayaka. To him it was just a bad day, one he still met head on and did as was asked of him. Sayaka didn’t really understand that, but seeing that quality of Makoto’s earned her attention. Though she fell to her own despair and first aimed to exploit the object in her eye, in her last moments, she wrote the name of her killer on the wall. Those numbers recurred in DR2 as a failsafe in the event everything goes wrong: something Makoto installed to protect those of the Neo World Program much like Sayaka once protected him. She instigated the murder in swapping rooms with Makoto and luring in Leon, but when her plan collapsed, inevitable death facing her, she didn’t define herself by her despair, she spent her last moments trying to make up for what she’d done to protect Makoto. Mondo had given into his despair, his burden of pride and masculinity leading to him crushing the life out of one so much stronger than he. But rather than escape a murder scene that shouldn’t have happened, with Chihiro in the boy’s changing room, he created so much of the evidence used to indict him by aiming to protect the secret Chihiro had kept buried for so long. Celeste fully admitted she didn’t see the hope offered in Alter Ego, but moments before her execution she still gave Makoto the key to the locker when she had no reason to. Sakura truly believed that if she could not make up with Touko and Yasuhiro that her life in the school held no value to her friends, only risk. But through her true suicide note and her destruction of the door to the principal’s office, she paved the path her friends would continue to walk down. And in the impossible situation of having to trust one with no logical reason to be trusted, with no expectation of survival, Makoto protected Kyouko’s lie and revealed the rigged game Junko had contrived. Even in Danganronpa 2, those who could so thoroughly be corrupted by Junko still had things to protect. Where Nagito and Mikan had fallen to despair utterly, Chiaki demanded to be accepted as culprit so her friends could live on beyond the horrors they’d enacted on the world. Tanaka and Nekomaru fought so that their cage could be opened and someone, anyone, could go free. Peko protected Fuyuhiko from her own execution, once again saving him from himself. Even Teruteru had aimed to kill a would be killer. Though despair was no doubt a part of their actions, so often these characters also protected some small hope.
- In the face of a faulty system, whether it’s the rules of society or the circumstances around their birth and environment that led to them becoming talented, even in a small way, so many characters surmounted that. Junko’s fate, the world she saw through her talent, through the confines of society, hadn’t been immutable or inescapable. Makoto, a normal person without even recognizing his own potential talent found a position without needing to, his strengths and values so much beyond just his luck. Hajime, so burdened by his lack of talent, found a freedom of potential in a future where any path was possible. School wasn’t the only road, even if it was the safest. The life of a freeter, the life of a high school dropout, was something Junko could not comprehend. That someone would willing go through despair because there might be hope at the end was exactly the unpredictable ending Junko was looking for. And yet, she was never satisfied. She went on and on about wanting and enjoying the unexpected, but exactly as Kamukura Izuru warned, chaos in itself is just another kind of order. She allowed for the seeds of her own failure in DR1, and I have two potential readings for her final execution, both meaningful in themselves. The first is that the machine failing was totally unexpected to her, worth observing because her joy is in the buildup, not the execution. For all her desire to find something new and unexpected, when actually faced with it, she was confused, not happy. The second reading also ties into that of the second game. The final time we see Junko chronologically in the entire franchise isn’t the Monokuma stinger of DR 1, the unceremonious removal of the Junko AI from Kuro and Shiro, or even the destruction of her large avatar. It’s the image of her on a cell phone screen, lamenting that she’s even grown bored of losing. In contrast to DR1, I don’t believe this ending was in her mind as a potential outcome, making her refusal of that outcome all the more impactful. She got exactly what she claimed to have wanted, but never really wanted it. The enjoyment she got from the world was when everything went exactly as planned: she hoped for that despair, and despair was what she got. Makoto was placed in the same sort of faulty system Junko saw fit to mock, yet was able to surmount its extremes. Hajime saw the world through her eyes in a form that represented everything he’d wanted from Hope’s Peak, yet never accepted the world as she saw it, the hope he sought after despair perhaps being what she’d been looking for the whole time. Yet in understanding the infinite potentials of the world, of existence, she rejected it all. A slave to the systems she’d emulated, a slave to her own nature, she only flourished for exactly what she’d sought to dismantle, only ever able to accept despair, so opposed with those who’d died in her machinations unable to accept anything but hope.
- Danganronpa is about a lot of things. Hope and despair can refer to so much. Determinism vs fatalism, subjectivity vs objectivity, emotion vs logic, destroying the system vs challenging the system from within, freedom vs conformity. It’s exactly in that multiplicity that I think the strength of the series lies, and V3 is very much about that. V3, in its discussion of truth and lies also discusses fiction, a lie that still tells its own truths. In doing so it takes so much of the iconography and presentation of Danganronpa and twists it into the same oppressor that Junko embodied. The opening theme, once a song of triumph, becomes a crushing tone aiming to quash the meaning out of Shuichi’s existence. What’s more meaningless then a conflict that wasn’t real in the first place? Hope and despair become empty ideologies of a never ending conflict resulting in very real death acted out for esteem and wealth. But even as it props up effigies of hope and despair only to topple them, I’ve always felt that it never once rejected the messages of the original games. Fiction is powerful and can affect reality through people. Danganronpa is one such work of fiction for me. In dismantling its own symbols and terms, rather than highlight their supposed meaninglessness, to me it heightens what Danganronpa has always been about. Makoto, Hajime, Komaru, and Shuicihi all see the world and act out their own meaning and values within it. What do hope and despair mean? What does the gameplay offer? “Although [man’s] fate is simply to perish, he can triumph over it by inventing ‘purposes’, ‘projects’, which will themselves confer meaning both upon themselves and upon the world of objects- all meaningless otherwise and in themselves.” Man surmounts death by creating purpose and meaning to assert their own existence. Danganronpa is not only an assertion of its own, but by creating and then breaking down its own multifaceted conflicts it demands the reader assert their own values and meanings in their reading of Danganronpa. To a degree I think this is something I believe to be true of all art, of all processes of reading. I don’t believe this reading is the final say, it might not even be my final say, but it is meaning. And to me that ability to assign meaning and value in an uncaring universe so very beautiful.
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment