Guest User

M&L Brothership Review

a guest
Jan 10th, 2025
170
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 15.18 KB | None | 0 0
  1. [SPOILERS]
  2.  
  3. For context, I loved the first two M&L games, Bowser’s Inside Story was pretty good, but it didn’t give me as much of a drive to play Dream Team or Paper Jam.
  4.  
  5. I enjoyed playing Brothership and was just happy to play a new mario RPG as the last one I played was way back when I played sticker star which really burned me.
  6.  
  7. I’ll start out with some things I did like about the game.
  8. -The art style was great. It had a cool blend of cartoon and 3D animation. One example that stood out to me was using Bros. Ball which is a very colorful 3D ball and then watching 2D cartoon puffs of dust spit out behind the ball. Little things like that look really nice.
  9. -The overall plot surprised me. I was quite skeptical at first by the title of the game and references throughout about Mario and Luigi being good brothers, but as the plot reached its peak the focus shifted over to something more interesting without totally ditching its theme from the first 75% of the game. Furthermore, the severity of the situation skyrocketed in the last bit of the game and was quite eerie for a Mario game which also surprised me
  10. - The characters are pretty good. I liked Buddy, Connie, Bowser Jr., and some of the lesser important characters like the gossiping ladies and Chilliam/Burnadette.
  11.  
  12.  
  13. Now on to the rant
  14.  
  15. Small things
  16. - Music was good, but not a lot of variety. The songs did not bang enough to keep me from getting annoyed at listening to the same song for hours (like on shipshape)
  17. - Once you finish a sea in the story mode, since you picked up all the lighthouse islands the sea looks pretty barren. It feels so empty. On the other hand, I think it’s kinda badass that your ship is lugging all these islands behind it. On the other OTHER hand, you only see that in action in a few cutscenes.
  18. - People complained about the framerate. As it is a switch game, some framerate issues are expected but it does pretty well aside from shipshape island in its final stage. There were perhaps a few times where I got screwed out of a button command in combat but I don’t know. It might have just been me.
  19.  
  20. Luigi
  21. The most immediate thing you’ll notice is how different Luigi controls in this game, at least in comparison to the older games. Before anyone calls me out, I am aware that you can only put Luigi in front of Mario in superstar saga. Though I do love that mechanic and how who is in front changes the bros moves and whether you have thunder or fire, it is not my issue. My issue is that Luigi is annoying!
  22. - His Luigi Logic thing happens so often towards the start of the game and he just solves puzzles for you whenever he does it. They didn’t need to stop the gameplay after the first iteration because he is going to glow green and have an L button next to his head anyway indicating he can do something.
  23. - The control of Luigi makes no sense. You can’t control much of him at all. You can make him jump and swing his hammer with B but because he follows you (and does not follow closely behind) and there’s no interaction between the bros while in non-bros mode, these don’t do anything. I don’t think enemies can even touch Luigi to engage in a battle. He jumps across gaps on his own anyway so you really just have to control Mario. I’d like to say you can pretty much ignore him BUT there were so many times where Luigi got stuck trying to follow me and it’d stop the game for Mario to go back to Luigi. Sometimes I would reach a ledge with Mario but Luigi didn’t make it and the game would take control of Mario and walk him off the edge and back to Luigi. This is very easily done when spinning from flower pad to flower pad or climbing the beanstalk in Twistee Island. Whenever platforming is involved, you’re constantly feeling like you’re playing a game like Skyrim where if you walk too far in front of an NPC, they’ll stop following you altogether.
  24. - A nitpick: It’s very weird to select Luigi attacks with A instead of B like in other games and then starting your move with a B input. Even in the final area of the game I still tried hitting B a few times. I guess it’s fine if they want to make it more conventional with A confirm, and B back rather than hitting R to cancel. It’s a sensical change but I’d argue it was very charming that you aren’t directly selecting options in combat, you’re actually just making the respective bro jump which hits the combat option’s box.
  25.  
  26. Pacing and such
  27. To start off with a positive, I like that the game focuses on just 4 great lighthouses as key milestones of the game. There are only 4 but there is a lot of content packed into each. I think games like Mario Galaxy suffer from having so many galaxies that I can only remember a handful of them. I think the Brrrning Sea (Sea #3) does a very good job at making the story leading up to that lighthouse all mesh together well. That whole section has a running story throughout the section and they follow the lava and snow based island theme throughout.
  28.  
  29. Having said that, the pacing of the game was not my favorite. The game feels slow to start, doesn’t really pick up until about halfway through, then it felt like it was just dragging on at the end. The game starts out with a lot of cutscenes and dialogue which I understand as it explains the story, introduces the main characters, and provides narrative. I assumed it would die down. It doesn’t really. Even though as I said the game is broken up into 4 great lighthouses, it’s broken up into about 15ish islands. In each of these islands the game needs to introduce you to what “its deal” is. Sometimes you will have to revisit the island in the main story and you will again need to be told what “its deal” is even though you were already explicitly told to go there to solve a problem. Most of the time when you complete a subtask, Snoutlet appears and tells you about the next step, and the camera pans over to where to go next. Maybe it’s because I’m almost 28 playing a children’s game, but it seemed very obvious where to go next after being told the first time. Even if it weren’t clear enough, the game REALLY doesn’t want you to go the wrong way. Sometimes if you wander down the wrong direction just to explore, Snoutlet or some other force will tell you to not go back that way. Most of the time it’s not a natural blockade like, say, security guarding an area. It’s just Snoutlet telling you you should be doing something else right now. If you talk to an NPC with questline information, snoutlet will appear to make sure you understood that this was important info by saying that what the NPC told you was what you need to do. When you enter a big room with a puzzle, you are constantly stopped so you can be shown the whole room… So imagine being in a dungeon, it’s fairly linear so you just follow a path but you know what you are looking for (like the giant sparkplugs), then you come upon a seemingly large room and it stops you to show you the whole room…. Bot only for maybe 4 seconds. It doesn’t give you enough time to actually examine the room. So you might as well just do the puzzles as you see it on your screen. Stopping me for the little camera pan was totally useless and I don’t remember this being the case for the other games aside from a room or two. The game really just stops you from being able to play the game as often as it can.
  30.  
  31. Now for a game that seemingly doesn’t want you to do things, they add in a lot of fluff. Several rhythm minigames, frequently asking you to find someone but also telling you exactly where they are in a place you have already explored previously. The final backtrack to fill up the bonding can was ABSOLUTELY INSANE. The game was already long enough at this point but they sent you to collect bonds. During the cutscene where Connie and Cozette make the first bond, I thought about where I should look to get other potential bonds, but before I gained control of Mario - “hey maybe you should check out Chilliam and Burnadette”. They did the thinking for me and for most of these bonds you just had to go to a place you have already been to before and sit through some half-decent dialogue. The exception to this was the Rumbla backtrack because at least you got to fight a glohmified boss from early on in the game. In a smaller capacity, when Reclusa captures Mario & Luigi in the “happy lonely world”, it felt as though it dragged on for a bit too long. It was a cool idea if executed better like if it was an explorable area at least half the size as a sea, but as I had already lost my patience on finishing the game and I just had to hit a block 5 times with almost identical cutscenes and dialogue happening between each block hit, I just felt like the game was trying to waste my time which is a shame as I think this virtual world thing could have been really cool when done right.
  32.  
  33. Islands
  34. I don’t have much to say on the islands. I thought there was a good variety of islands in them. Bulbfish island’s mystery plotline was extremely mid compared to something like PM64 or TTYD’s mysteries. This game does a lot of handholding and telling you the answer which does not work well when the point of the island is to solve a mystery.
  35.  
  36. Quests/challenges
  37. The quests were fine. Some quests were kind of lame but those often were up front about giving you lame rewards like a Candy and a 1-Up. I decided to do it anyway so that was on me. Some quests gave you really good rewards and I especially liked doing the Glohm Gobblick quest while very underleveled. That was probably my favorite fight of the game.
  38. The challenges gave good rewards too. I sort of messed up by not realizing I could check the challenges on the pause menu until at least halfway into the game. My only complaint was that it gave you the last 2 bros attacks far too late into the game, where I used them almost every chance I got, didn’t avoid any fights in the last dungeon, and still only made about half progress on each of them. It was quite an unfair challenge to throw at you. To my knowledge, across challenges, sidequests, reefs, grampy turnips, those two challenges were the only things I did not complete and my completionist attitude was not enough to make me grind another 20 fights.
  39.  
  40. Combat and related things
  41. I like the flashiness of the attacks and the combat was good enough to hold my attention as I entered hundreds of fairly similar battles.
  42. Enemies - Was it just me or were there less than half as many enemy types compared to any of the first 3 games? There also were not that many bosses/minibosses. They’d have you often just fight 6 Zokket soldiers or something instead of 4 at times.
  43. Plugs - I felt like the combat as a whole could have been made more difficult, however, I am at least happy with the fact that due to battle plugs, you can kind of choose how hard you want to make battles for yourself. I opted to not equip any autohealing or defense plugs or plugs that made countering easier or getting auto excellent attacks. I could have also opted to ban myself from using certain attacking plugs or plugs as a whole but I felt like ignoring a core mechanic designed to make the combat interesting for the sake of increasing difficulty would have been a bit reductive for actually enjoying the game. Planning how you wanted to attack your enemies and combining plugs like the kaboom with surprise iron ball and targeting a specific enemy to maximum damage output was fun. The only real problem I had with battle plugs was that optimizing the plugs mid-battle ends up slowing down the fight a bit much. I probably would have preferred if the plugs could not be switched out mid-battle but I do understand being able to, given that a plugs charge does not replenish between battles and you may start a battle with only 1 charge of something.
  44. Bros. Attacks - Sigh. I really miss when the bros attacks were extensions of your abilities like in superstar saga. It seems like in PiT they changed BP to consumable bros items which was definitely not the play so they went somewhere in the middle where bros items consumed BP. It just seems like a missed opportunity as they could have used UFO spin/vacuum as upgraded versions of splash bros from superstar saga, bros ball is only kind of referenced by getting an Excellent rating using the You Who Cannon or when first striking an enemy with the boost ball. I will give the fire and ice bros a pass as one of the last bros attacks you learn actually implements your ability fairly well.
  45. This may just be my preference but I think all the attacks have gotten too involved. Although all moves look really cool, it feels like normal attacks in Brothership are like bros attacks from superstar saga while bros attacks in Brothership are an entire minigame. I like how in superstar saga, the normal attacks are a basic jump or hammer swing which make the bros attacks really stick out as a flashy and strong attack Then you have the Luigi Logic attacks which is on a whole other level. It’s all too much in my opinion, especially in the Glohm Bowser and Reclusa fights. It is epic but pulls you out of that intense turnbased fight. All that and my normal attacks could deal more damage than some of my bros. attacks so what’s the point in playing this 2 minute minigame? Sometimes a simpler system can work better than one so over the top.
  46. Stats and difficulty - The game tells you at the start that each bro is built to increase certain stats faster than the other. Based off of this note and what I know from superstar saga speedruns, I increased Mario’s POW and Luigi’s STACHE as much as I could. I did not check their stat progression or look it up and this was definitely the way to go. Now, I don’t expect an RPG like this to have very intricate leveling, but it’s tough that the game so clearly wants you to upgrade this way and aside from maybe throwing Luigi some of the power beans and increasing their health if you take lots of hits, there really isn’t any reason to do anything else. This makes the bros extremely powerful. About 50-65% of the way through the game I was one-hit KOing most enemies with a few battle plugs equipped with my “normal” attacks. I beat the final boss in I think 4 turns. It was so busted, and yes, I could have actively decided to make a worse build, but I feel as though picking this high POW build should have had a trade off where my defense, hp, and/or bp stats were low and it just wasn’t at all.
  47. As a final nitpick related to difficulty of combat, the amount of money you can accumulate in this game is absurd. Of course the game should not force you to collect every coin possible and use the coinpiler battle plug whenever it recharges, but I bought new gear pretty frequently, didn’t sell any of my old gear until much later into the game, bought the 25k coin golden POW gloves while in the Brrrning Sea with a good 40k coins to spare, and ended the game with 130k coins… I realized when I had around 90k coins that the golden gloves stop scaling your stats (it stops at 60k) but that didn’t stop me from accumulating another 40k by just playing normally. The game just throws money at you and also throws items at you so often that you won’t even need to spend your money to buy extras.
  48.  
  49. Overall, I enjoyed playing a new Mario & Luigi game and I don’t regret spending close to 50 hours in it, but it left a lot to be desired. 5/10
  50.  
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment