Advertisement
Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- "All truth claims are proved by empirical observation."
- You cannot prove that statement by empirical observation; it is therefore self-refuting.
- We can also easily demonstrate it to be false, because the following cannot be evaluated by empirical observation:
- 1. Existential truth: You cannot empirically prove you aren't "in the matrix".
- 2. Moral truth: You might empirically demonstrate negative consequences, but it cannot prove rape is evil.
- 3. Logical truth: All scientific endeavor must assume Logic from the outset.
- 4. Historical truth: no past event can be empirically tested; history is not repeatable.
- Consider the absurdity: a consistent empiricist cannot consider any event of history to be true; it is therefore irrational.
- Similar to 'strong' atheism, the only way you could actually know the statement to be true (rather than merely blindly believing it to be true) is by being omniscient - an attribute of God. Therefore in order to know this statement to be true, you'd have to be God.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement