Something's that you say are not believed by me,like the mention of the need for constructive decision. However , the vast majority of us believe, either that the room is constructive now, or that the room will be constructive if it becomes a private room. We had a goal of making it become private, and we focused, rightly or wrongly, upon the prerequisites. PokeIndia still had a couple of visitors , as you could have seen in the logs, like one person who wanted to know where Hindi could be learnt. We had a rather constructive discussion, and maybe (I dont know smogon procedure all that well, so what I am saying may just be nonsense)you could ban or limit the number of trivia games or something, to get your goal of constructive discussion