Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- In an attempt to properly formulate my thoughts on Stormblood, I'm going to use a pair of plot beats that are very fresh in my mind as an example, in a way that hopefully lays out plainly why I feel the way I do about this expansion's writing and execution, and so strongly.
- The two disparate halves of Stormblood share a lot of elements indicative of the hasty production of, and lack of time a red pen spent highlighting, the overarching script of 61-70 as a whole. On the list of things they share are an outline for a character who is:
- - A member of the culture the Garleans are oppressing in this region
- - A woman whose sex and standing are just two of the things putting their reputation in the mud, driving them to anger
- - A high-ranking commander of the Garlean army known for brutality and cruelty
- - Singlehandedly responsible for an innumerable amount of deaths both on and off camera
- - Who is then put in a position where they are stripped of this power, left weak and spited by the newly liberated public
- - And subsequently given an opportunity to do something about it now that the war is behind us.
- In the Gyr Abanian corner, you're presented with Fordola, who, in the heat of the moment, is presented in what is admittedly a very carefully constructed and subdued way. The viewer is told that she is a traitor, feeding information about the resistance to Zenos and the Garleans, and you are instantaneously greeted with the fallout of her actions, and the slaughter of all the assorted NPCs of Rhalgr's Reach that you had just gotten yourself acquainted to. Real people you could have interacted with are removed from the game entirely; the instance in which this occurs can actually be navigated by gut instinct of 'where were the most innocent people gathered when I was last here'; the imminent frustration of your defeat at the hands of Zenos and the collective shrug of the entire writer's board room when you're told there's nothing to be done and you should head to Doma; the entire situation is a farce, everything is falling apart, and you as an audience member are left knowing that virtually everything that just happened is her fault. It's frustrating, and unfair, and you don't understand how she could be like this, why she would do such a thing, let alone to her own people.
- You then are 'treated' to Yotsuyu a ways into the Doman side of the plot. You're told she is a cruel taskmaster known for abusing her subjects purely out of spite for the entire Doman race, and accordingly shown multiple scenes of her beating and murdering innocents, ordering innocents to be beaten and murdered, beating and sometimes murdering her own subordinates (up to and including Grynewaht, a heretofore comic relief character, now being target of some rather dark themes incredibly dissonant to his character's core), and even in her darkest moments, continuing to be cruel and violent, even when Grynewaht actively shows signs of human emotion and empathy for her. (Reminder that Grynewaht is not Doman and that's his whole problem; the joke of him being here is that he is halfway across the planet from his home)
- Up until Yotsuyu's final moments, where she lay 'dying' in the rubble of Doma Castle, cut down and helpless in front of your party, she is spiteful and bitter. As far as she is aware, her shooting Gosetsu in the back as he holds up the crumbling ceiling will do nothing cosmically for her other than accelerate her own death, and maybe make for a parting shot on one or two other people she hardly knows beyond the simple fact that they stopped her. She is literally seen crying and lamenting, not over any regrets she has, but the fact that her petty gesture didn't kill anyone.
- To continue presentation in the game's chosen batshit nonsense order, you as the Warrior of Light return to the Gyr Abanian front, resuming your struggle against Fordola. You defeat her handily, though she fights to a bitter end and only retreats when confronted with the idea that more of her men are going to die should the fight continue. This choice, however, costs her much; her reputation immediately suffers for giving up such an important Imperial foothold, and Zenos only lets her live on the condition that she become one of their Resonant test subjects and furthermore obey his every last command to the letter.
- It is in the wake of that decision she made that the next major battle unfolds, and she makes a call that got me, as the viewer, confused and angry; she fires the cannon and brings down the tower following the Imperial surrender. This parting shot serves to kill more of her own people than that of the resistance, and she seems to cope by naming to herself those who are about to die and apologizing, stating the tactic was a direct order from Zenos. (This is left assumed to have happened offscreen, which was part of my own confusion.) You then go on to beat her one further time in an instanced battle, taking her prisoner and listening to her fatalist ravings about how the empire can no longer be stopped.
- Now, to dissect something core to the texture of this situation right now when is most convenient, I feel the need to break down the first and most glaring thing; the presentation of these two similar characters as villains.
- Yotsuyu is introduced with, sustained by, and ultimately goes out by showcasing her own personal cruelty. You, the viewer, get shown and told all the vicious, awful things she, personally, says and does. In order to sell you on her evilness, and convince you that she is the villain and it is okay to want to defeat her, you're directly presented with footage of her committing war crimes, and to seal the deal, her character is that she revels in it. She is a sadist who enjoys causing pain because of her tragic past that you're force-fed over the course of one Echo flashback. She hates Domans because Domans were mean to her. She doesn't like people because she thinks people are bad. Her feelings are not complex. Her actions are obvious and direct one-sentence answer-and-response decision-making.
- 'What kind of viceroy is she?' A bad one.
- 'Why is she so bad?' She hurts people.
- 'Why does she hurt people?' Because she thinks it's fun.
- 'Why does she think it's fun?' Because people used to be awful to her.
- 'What do you mean by awful?' They did sex things to her she didn't want.
- Yotsuyu is not presented as a character you should feel complex emotions towards any more than 'an angry dragon demanding virgin sacrifice every new moon is just trying to eat, is that so wrong'. I say her presentation is that of a 'Saturday morning cartoon villain' because she's not provided real, digestible depth. Her presence and her actions don't ask any questions that make me want to answer. Her character is nothing more than a necessity of the plot, that the Doman arc needed an antagonist, and everything surrounding her feels more like it is excusing her existence than fleshing her out further and making a better defined point.
- Fordola, meanwhile, is given far less screentime initially. You as the viewer in your limited scope are sent into the Doma arc with only memories of that horrible incident (both ludonarratively horrible and, honestly, structurally horrible), and the idea that it's all her fault. But to make it abundantly clear: it is her fault, absolutely, but tackled in a less one-dimensional way. Her bodycount was somewhere between 'single digit' and 'zero', compared to the absolute slaughter Zenos himself went through that day. Confronted with the opportunity, she gladly takes her leave of the scene just on the implication of having made a point. This feeds well into the character she is later given time to develop: She is being made do horrible things, and she is following her orders, but as a means to an end. The idea she is clinging to, for this arc of her character, is that if the rebellion is crushed thoroughly enough, then the fighting will stop, and if the fighting stops, then nobody has to be hurt like she was. If nobody is hurting, then nobody will have reason to hate her. No more stones will have to be thrown.
- Now, this all isn't to say that this, on its own, makes for a more compelling character. It's easy to *say* 'this character is doing what they think is right, but they're wrong'. That's just day 2 of Character Writing 101, and not day 1, or summer reading, or whatever the analogy is. What makes Fordola more interesting is what they actually *do* and *say* with this character, now that the narrative has dissected her like this.
- Fordola, as a Resonant, is given the ability to have Echo flashbacks of other people, same as you, but it's strongly implied if not outright stated that these are constant, and not occasional. She can't turn it off. She's constantly being handed these glimpses into lives she's ruined in a way she cannot ignore. The struggle is visible, but at first she can ignore it, and initially that *does* make her less sympathetic. It even comes to a head when she actively sees people who are later revealed to be her best friends, names them all out of respect, and sees them killed by the collapsing tower. At this point of her character, you're *meant* to 'get it' but not actually properly empathize.
- This is because what they do with her character following the final boss of Stormblood is actually designed with that in mind. You're shown her in a cell, in prisoner's clothes, withdrawn in a corner, asking for her own execution. This isn't an especially unique way to redeem a villain on its own; some sort of a turnaround sacrifice or martyrdom by choice is in and of itself cheap. It's only after she's denied that and presented a choice to help your fight against Sri Lakshmi that things take a turn for the interesting.
- She swoops in and saves the day, handed a sword by Lyse and ready to fight. But she doesn't. She spends the entire duration of the fight expressly not hurting things. She uses the power of her Resonance to deflect aether spheres and to shield you from Lakshmi's soft enrage, but she does not attack anyone, at least none of the tempered. She protects you, and she helps protect all the innocents.
- And then when all's said and done, the council Lyse had called returns to see the 'Butcher' was the one who came to their rescue, and their collective reaction is rightfully mixed and apprehensive. The air of the room has an appropriate amount of tension in it because nobody understands what's going on. Nobody is picking one obvious emotion to cling to because the situation is complicated; no rocks are being thrown, or curses being spat, but also nobody is cheering and happy to see her turn face.
- And all she does is drop her sword, look to the guards at her left and right, and she says, "I'm done here. Take me back to my cell."
- This is a complex reaction I honestly adored, because it speaks to the wide array of emotion Fordola has been allowed to experience. She's obviously relieved that nobody was harmed in that attack, but understands none of them are happy to see her. She didn't expect anyone to suddenly be calling her a hero, but she wants to make some sort of statement to tell them that she is done fighting. She no longer thinks she has to die in order to atone, but she does not think the punishment she deserves for her actions is over.
- What sold me on Fordola as a character and as a narrative device the game uses to tell a story is the exchange that happens as she tries to leave. One of the elders looks at her, mouth agape for seconds at a time having watched this happen, trying to sort out what this chain of events makes him feel, and he tells her as plainly as one can put those emotions to words: He does not *forgive* her, because this does not at all on its own change or undo the awful, hideous things that are all her fault. But he has the capacity to thank her for wanting to start making the difference and start trying.
- This is an incredibly strong take on a real, actual theme, 'What does one need do to deserve forgiveness?' It presents this character who is believable, in that she makes choices based on complex internal logic that you the viewer don't necessarily agree with, and has her think, say, and do large-scale atrocities that are her fault entirely, without going so far as to have her be a cackling madwoman to drive the point home. It paints this picture of her, and then asks the rest of the cast, along with you of course, if she is worth ever forgiving, whatever she might do. Is it a matter of lives saved, against lives taken? Is it a moral quandary about 'being the bigger person', and accepting her decision to change with open arms? Or is it about punishment, with some theoretical amount of self-flagellation being the turning point at which we can truly call someone redeemed?
- The simple answer to that question that the game provides, the one that brings Fordola to open tears, is that forgiveness is not the answer at all. Forgiveness is just emotional closure at the end of the rainbow; you don't *need* forgiveness, you *need* to try and be better than the 'you' that did something worth apologizing for. It's the sum of the process, the punishment, the decision to change, the action to support that, and the willingness to make amends, that makes someone a better person, and being sorry and desiring that forgiveness only holds you back by making you think it's that simple.
- All of this complex message is delivered by a dropped sword and three lines of dialogue. And you know what? I fucking admire that. That's the good shit.
- What has me frustrated with Yotsuyu's resolution is that it feels like someone had the idea to tackle this question from a different angle, but had no idea the proper way to ask it, let alone to resolve it.
- Hot off the heels of that power move that I talked up so hard, you're greeted with Gosetsu and Yotsuyu, both somehow not dead after the... gripping climax? at the end of Doma Castle, which saw them both crushed beneath the debris. Supposedly the floor gave out underneath them, then they grabbed a door, then that floated them to a deserted island, who gives a shit, it's incredibly contrived. Yotsuyu is conveniently given amnesia and reduced to the mental capacity of an 8 year old, because Timmy Stormblood likes his women weak and emotionally vulnerable.
- There's a lot of really boring 'dramatic political tension' cutscenes padding out all the potentially interesting ones that actually ask interesting things about this situation, but the summary is that Hien is approached by some douchebag Imperial commander who turns out to be Yotsuyu's secret younger brother, and he's acting all nice and friendly, more than is rationally necessary as an act, but oh no, he secretly hates you a lot and wants you to die! And he wants Yotsuyu to have her memories back so the empire can have its Doman acting viceroy back, because of course he hates her for no well-established reason whatsoever.
- This kid goes very, very far to put up this act, to a degree where it honestly started to feel like when he turned heel, it was because the writer got tired of having a genuinely well-meaning character in the Doman half of Stormblood, and decided to un-twist the twist that an Imperial person in power would ever be nice and seek to make amends in spite of the emperor's orders. Naturally when you get an echo flashback to find out why he's an asshole, it turns out... he liked Zenos a lot because he does the fight good, and he's mad you beat him and he killed himself over it. Reminder: You did not kill Zenos. You beat him in a fight and he went out on his own terms. That's what made that so unbelievably frustrating. So now not only did you not get any satisfaction from killing the character who was designed solely to be a villain and get killed by you, people are still irrational levels of mad at you over his death as if you had killed him yourself. So that's fun.
- To try and get Yotsuyu's memories back though, he goes so far as to bring their parents to visit, just seeing their faces making her flip out, run away screaming and crying, and spiral emotionally hard enough that you next see her in an echo flashback holding a knife to her own throat, tormented by these visions of the Yotsuyu she used to be and how they clash with the Tsuyu she's built around herself in her amnesiac state. The only thing that stops her from committing suicide right there on the spot is the reappearance of her parents.
- Now, I'm not gonna get into how completely unbelievable her parents are. Like the part where her mother *instantaneously* starts calling her heinous things, saying she's worthless and brings shame to the family completely unprovoked. Or how completely and totally nonsensical the idea of that is at this point in time, because she's an acting viceroy, one of the most prestigious positions you can presumably hold because that's like if you were so close to the president that he put you in the oval office while he was on vacation, and thus there is no possible reason why Yotsuyu does anything but give her family a good name with the Garleans, with whom her mother literally says in this cutscene that they live in the lap of luxury in the capital city of Garlemald. Or just... how much of a non-sequitur it is that the first thing her father does is begin sexually harassing her and saying that they should use her to start a whorehouse to earn more money than a *fucking viceroy* and a leading diplomat of international relations can pull in, combined. I'm not gonna talk about any of that. 'Cause I just did and I feel like it speaks for itself how utterly fucking baffling that scene was to watch. It didn't even feel like it was real. It felt like the cameraman was gaslighting me, or like it was a nightmare sequence. None of the characters spoke words like real people, let alone did they say things real people would say, nevermind if any of the logic could ever actually follow through.
- But anyway, the ultimate punchline is that this display of unneeded, completely unwarranted cruelty of man to his fellow man, all for cruelty's sake, brings back Yotsuyu's memories, so she immediately kills them both with a knife. She's then approached by her brother who basically says 'hey, that mirror I gave you can make you into a primal, use that to do more bad things'. This also funnels into an incredibly frustrating scene where she does that, Asahi uses that as a contrived excuse to say the entire plan you the player and all your friends spent 7 quests constructing has failed, and nobody at any point raises a finger to stop any of it. Nothing about this sequence is valuable or enjoyable other than the idea that I'm gonna get to fucking kill this awful character come the next trial.
- Now see, this is all boring and wretched and really sincerely feels like we're back to ~61-66 MSQ Stormblood, which is already a bad place to be. It's also posed right next to the first legitimately unambiguously no strings attached *good* piece of writing this game's had since Heavensward, so that's not great. But what really bends me right over and *fucks me up* is the sheer amount of squandered potential here.
- Unlike the unfortunate circumstance of 'two different Sad People Collectives getting trounced by Zenos right in a row' at the beginning of Stormblood, the extreme likeness that Fordola and Yotsuyu have in concept doesn't feel like unfortunate coincidence to me. In fact, I can actually believe that this part of the game passed by an editor at some point, or that Timmy Stormblood and Artoria Shadowbringer were maybe in the same room talking to each other at some point! That's why I'm willing to believe in the idea that they were *going* for something here. The idea of taking these two ruthlessly awful characters in similar situations that happened on accident apart from each other, and resolving them in different ways to tackle the same idea of 'what if we tried to redeem them'.
- It's in that light that I watched the early cutscenes of an amnesiac Yotsuyu innocently trying to live her life, trying to be friendly with Gosetsu, being afraid of the idea that people hate her. It felt cheap at first that they took the less redeemable character and gave her amnesia, because the cynic in me was saying that 'rather than redeem this character, we'll make a new one and give her the same face'. But I ignored that feeling to give the story the benefit of the doubt after it impressed me so much. And a lot of the scenes were very obvious, but at least they were approaching the issue.
- The scene that comes to mind is her going to Namai and immediately getting screamed at and threatened. Tsuyu, who at this point I will just refer to actively as a different character because she is, only wanted a persimmon, and was suddenly being accosted by all this hate directed towards someone she physically, mentally was not anymore, and she started breaking down. She wanted to be sorry, but she didn't know how; not because the sin was too great, and god only knows where to start with Yotsuyu, but because she genuinely does not know what's going on, other than the implication that these people know something bad she did. It's a much more dumbed down version of the same question Fordola asked, because amnesia can go away, and not having developed emotions because you have an 8 year old's brain is a lot cheaper than actually confronting the conflicting emotions of finding out that you really are the villain you hated most, but it's something.
- And what interested me is that, in those moments before Asahi shows up and makes everything worse with his presence and becomes my new least favorite character in (temporary) absence of Zenos, Tsuyu's memories are flicking back, but her personality is not. She's having these flashes of people beaten on the floor before her, these images of bodies and fire as villages burn, and she's remembering enjoying it, and she very visibly seems to *hate* it. She drops to the floor on her hands and knees, head bowed low, and begs for forgiveness the only way she can think of how, because how do you even begin turning back the clock, trying to make up for having at one point been *Yotsuyu*?
- Well, Timmy Stormblood's answer for Yotsuyu is, you don't. Not because you can't, but because the script isn't good enough.
- Because Hien speaks out *for* Tsuyu, tells everyone 'trust me, I'm the prince, this lady is fine, tolerate her for now'.
- Because a little girl decides she doesn't like seeing people mad and gave her a persimmon.
- Because Tsuyu doesn't ACTUALLY answer this question at all, she instead just regresses into being Yotsuyu at the slightest provocation, murdering her parents because It's Fun And They Deserve It And This Is Who I Am, and then finally literally becoming a big angry scary monster for you to fight.
- The best part is that this one scene I've zeroed in on as the part I found interesting is sandwiched between about 2 and a half hours of various characters looking at Tsuyu and saying to each other 'Hmmmmm, I don't know, maybe she's faking it?????' The pacing gets absolutely *mauled* by these scenes, and they're virtually constant throughout this entire arc of the plot, making it about as lengthy as Fordola's arc, even though that was also broken up by a lot of Raubahn drama and had a much much more engaging instance in it.
- It just disappoints me so much because I can so easily see the way to fix this, and that's just to let Yotsuyu make these decisions on her own in a tragically human way. They could have had her turn into a primal on accident, like what happened with the second Titan, spurned on by the inner turmoil and trauma coming at her from every angle, from Namai to her family to Gosetsu to her own memories and her new feelings about those memories. She could have changed into something actually sincerely meaningful that would have made me feel emotions, but they didn't. They just made her a Saturday morning cartoon villain who you stab because the plot dictates that we have too few Doman primals.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment