Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- First, on EuroStack. Briefly on what it actually is: EuroStack originated as an industry- and commentator-led initiative that emerged from an event hosted at the European Parliament on 24 September 2024 ("Toward European Digital Independence: Building the EuroStack"). The eponymous EuroStack report was subsequently commissioned by the Bertelsmann Stiftung, and a European Parliament Committee adopted a supportive position in June 2025. I feel that your piece implies that EuroStack is a Commission priority in the formal sense, which would be incorrect. The Commission has engaged with it, EVP Virkkunen may have spoken at EuroStack events or received open letters from its industry coalition, but there has been no formal adoption of EuroStack as a Commission programme. This is a crucial nuance to take note of because the European Parliament has no right of legislative initiative in matters of shared competence like digital matters under Art. 225 TFEU, only the power to request that the Commission act.
- Virkkunen's appointment as EVP for Tech Sovereignty was announced by President von der Leyen a week before the EuroStack launch event. Her portfolio choice follows naturally from several critical points raised in the Draghi report and from the broader sovereignty turn (von der Leyen's 2019 statement used the term "geopolitical Commission") far more than it does any EuroStack advocacy, at least chronologically speaking.
- Secondly, on the proposed joint AI standards working group for high-risk applications, I would cautiously note that this collides with two structural realities. First, the EU's normative pull tends to meet robust Indian resistance. Second, India lacks an AI governance framework in any sense the EU AI Act would recognise, because it approaches risk evaluation from a fundamentally different starting point. The India AI Governance Guidelines released ahead of the India AI Impact Summit are principle-based around seven "sutras" and call for a tailored risk assessment framework that demands real-world evidence of harm. Indeed, the third of these "sutras" calls for innovation to be prioritised over cautionary restraint. Convergence on a shared high-risk classification is therefore unlikely to be a quick win.
- Thirdly, on data, the irreconcilable differences between the DPDPA and the GDPR are well documented (e.g., the DPDPA's blacklist model inverts the GDPR's whitelist/adequacy model). India has no adequacy decision, which, for instance, Japan obtained well in advance of the EU–Japan Digital Partnership. The EDPS' 2024 refusal of an EIB transfer to India was reasoned on similar grounds. They found insufficient evidence that individuals' personal data could be protected at the time in the same way in India as in the EU. Beyond privacy, human rights concerns will inevitably resurface, especially from the ranks of the European Parliament, which has been quite vocal about including and enforcing human rights conditionalities in bilateral relations.
- Fourth, to strengthen your semiconductor point, I would include a comment on CRMs. EU-India cooperation can and should support India's National Critical Minerals Mission alongside broader support for related initiatives like the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC). Waste recycling and urban mining are shared priorities. The TTC lends itself as the institutional home for a dedicated CRM task force.
- Finally, the FTA was arguably the primary motive for institutionalising the TTC in 2023, whose negotiations were successfully concluded in January 2026. The proposed text, however, seems to have delayed the conversation on governance convergence rather than resolved it. Article 17 of Chapter 9 on digital trade of the FTA text reads thus: "The Parties shall reassess within five years of the date of entry into force of this Agreement the need for inclusion of additional provisions, including on the free flow of data, into this Agreement."
- I apologise for how long my comment has gotten and hope that you bore with me till the end. Thank you once again for this article, which helped me update my knowledge just in time before my thesis defence! Curious to hear your thoughts.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment