Achiee. Have fun.

Lets play a game where we question the integrity of a pastebin!!!

First point is fair - besides the fact that achiee seems to be an on off account.

[https://epicmafia.com/game/6082479/review - achiee & star are town; d2 achiee quickly says "no" "im thinking" when a lynch on star is suggested & overrides it to someone else]
Meaningless.

https://epicmafia.com/game/6082451/review - achiee & star are town; minimal interaction between achiee and star and they end up winning
[Meaningless]

1. d2 achiee clearly explained to star to vote dsmith outside of game. analyze this screenshot if you're unsure.
Nling on lylo is a townloss if you're town as mafia can force a blitz, the screenshot is unindicative, as it's star lynching with mechanics?

d3 achiee leads lynch on star when star is guised If they played as many games with star as you said that's no suprise.

 d4 achiee clearly made up a fake question for dyl because they know from star being dead that dyl is mafia.
Assuming that they're cheating gave this conclusion, the question isn't here nor is it indicative of anything.

achiee hammers correctly in 8 seconds of receiving hammer, less than a minute into the day. he clearly did not try to read much even though they're trophying
Congratulations, speedhammering before you change your mind is now cheating.

they have the most forced interactions and achiee tr's star by saying a single-line reason and then following up that line by stating, literally, "tr". people who actually try to win like normal people don't tr/sr people for single lines. star then says "ok so me and achiee are last blues?" or something similar to that

Two things - Yes people do this, this might be the only suspicious thing in the bin so far. If Star had only said a single line and they were read, beyond cheating it's likely possible meta (EG, star was afk daystart, POE town.) Would look more into this.


achiee & star are town; d3 when star is dead, achiee is quick to conclude that snowieball is mafia (and they are (from achiee's pov, snowie and kami were cc's)) by constantly switching between weak reasons to tunnel a tr on kami, and tunnel a sr on snowie

Winning games with star in graveyard continues to be unindicative unless you're SURE that they are cheating. If this were to be indicative in any way (besides the fact that IT WAS AN OGI VIO.) You would have to prove that achiee was a bad player in games star didn't participate.


achiee is town, star is maf; star was intentionally participating less and acting scummy, even though they have a 53% maf winrate v a 48% town winrate. this also goes for when star was acting extremely towny in all the other games where star/achiee are town together, it is apparent that is not normal for star
This bothers me, this is the only game where Star is mafia in the bin, and a high mafia winrate does not indicate scumminess, I have a 60% scumwinrate and I still think my scumgame is shit. People who towntell tend to SCUMTELL WHEN THEY ARE MAFIA THAT IS COMMON SENSE.


achiee is maf, star is town; like i said before, since star's alignment opposes achiee's, star is intentionally participating less and acting scummy. star leads a lynch on town and then dies, achiee ends up winning etc
No indication of cheating, no way for star to know this. If there was no cheating, star would just auto TR achiee, but since you say that "Star is cheating with achiee, and knows their alignment, acting scummy. That's bullshit.

If you wanted to use this game (might be another suspicious game.) you'd have to compare it with other games on THAT DAY. Hence why this needs to be a day by day analysis of games, people change THEIR READS DAY BY DAY.

 achiee & star are town; d2 achiee is guised, so star is quick to guise test achiee (star apparently knows what achiee's avatar is?). d3 star lynches amark, the ninja, because "if he's ninja then meeko is confirmed" which then ofc confirms meeko and it is town autowin.

It's form fucking pokemon. And winning the game isn't scummy.


This bin is deadass near useless and if you tried to DQ someone with it you're just gonna get flack.

Theres two parts that are in any way meaningful, and it's not looked into at all, what the fuck were you smoking.