Modest Squirtle analysis (FR any%)

21 iv modest compared to 31 iv mild/rash

1 extra text rival 1		4
route 1 damage				4
1 extra turn weedle			6.5 (can get bubble)
rival 2 bulba range			0.5
rival 3 ivysaur				4.5
oddish						3

TOTAL: 22.5s lost

0 iv modest compared to 31 iv mild/rash

1 extra text rival 1		4
route 1 damage				4
1 extra turn weedle			7.5
rival 2 bulba range			4.5
skip ether					-4
route 6 raticate			1.5
rival 3 ivysaur				12
boat raticate				1
oddish						3
bulbasaur					4
oddish						0.5
ivysaur						0.5

TOTAL: 38.5s lost

Can just consider Bulbasaur as part of the time loss for ID waiting (so 1:10 is like a 1:14)

CONCLUSION: Definitely worth taking all Modests, but Mild and Rash are still slightly better