glkfan is not an intelligent person

glkfan
the concept of "gender" as separate from sex makes no sense
14:21 glkfan
bruce/caitlyn jenner was and will always be male
bonni_g
let's say your gender is female - so why is the sex part left out?
glkfan
getting breast implants and growing your hair out does not make one female
14:22 bonni_g
IKR?
bonni_g
nice pic
bonni_g
chopping one's breasts off and taking testosterone doesn't make one a male
glkfan
UnderCoverNerd, i care because now instead of trying to get society to stop treating women like crap, women are 'transitioning' to escape 'being treated like a woman'
bonni_g
that's right UnderCoverNerd
14:24 EonEcho
glkfan: Which is more important for identity: the qualities of the mind, or physical anatomy?
____ARGIC____ has joined ([email protected])
glkfan
what identity?
bonni_g
and then we have the bathroom issue made famous by Ted Cruz
glkfan
when does identity come in? who cares about identity? no one
EonEcho
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/identity/
EonEcho
Identity is a core concept in philosophy.
bonni_g
I identify as a unicorn - and someone yells WHO CARES
glkfan
no one asks a woman at a bar her gender identity before drugging and raping her
____ARGIC____
but does anyone have a hissy fit when women who transitioned to men go to men's bathrooms?
EonEcho
I put bonni_g on lifelong block.
____ARGIC____
its always the other way around
glkfan
no one asks child brides their gender identity before marrying them off to some creepy 50 year old man
EonEcho
glkfan: Which is more important for identity: the qualities of the mind, or physical anatomy?
__serdar__ has left IRC (Ping timeout)
glkfan
i don't know what you mean by identity
EonEcho
Refusal to give a serious answers results in you being labeled an unserious chatter.
glkfan
UnderCoverNerd, the point is that women are trying to escape treatment like that by 'identifying out' of it
EonEcho
glkfan: A person comes before me and I ponder the question: What is the nature of this person?
glkfan
any woman who correctly identifies that sexism is real will want to escape it
EonEcho
That question can be importantly answered by understanding their identity.
UnderCoverNerd has changed mode: +vvvvv ____ARGIC____ ___ARGIC___ asdad bonni_g Malarkey
EonEcho
To help establish the parameters of this person's identity, I might consider their physical anatomy, as well as various qualities of their mind.
EonEcho
In that process, which of those two will be more important?
glkfan
nonsense question
glkfan
why does one have to be more important?
glkfan
sex is not race
EonEcho
glkfan: Because heterogeneity is a key part of almost all metaphysical systems.
EonEcho
glkfan: Are physical anatomy and mental qualities identical?
EonEcho
If they are not, then I might be able to apply a comparison function to them.
EonEcho
This is a standard cognitive process.
EonEcho puts glkfan on Red Alert
glkfan
all of these questions sound like you're talking about some video game
EonEcho
I put glkfan on block until 2025-01-20.
EonEcho
Reason: Insufficient intelligence.