Advertisement
Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- [03/30/13 00:18:34] * machomuu (442195a6@gateway/web/freenode/ip.68.33.149.166) has joined #pcromhack
- [03/30/13 00:18:43] <BungiePhantom> Hola
- [03/30/13 00:19:27] <machomuu> Hi! Sorry, I wasn't sure if there was a meeting tonight, and I was so busy roleplaying I didn't get Darthatron's message until just recently
- 01[03/30/13 00:19:41] <@Bela> haha hey there
- [03/30/13 00:20:10] <@Darthatron> no problem buddy :)
- [03/30/13 00:20:58] <@Perri> Aww, it's okay. Roleplaying is one of my vices as well ^^'
- 06[03/30/13 00:21:13] * @Bela doesn't roleplay. wait a second...
- 01[03/30/13 00:21:17] <@Bela> lol ;p
- [03/30/13 00:22:58] <@Darthatron> Perri, you here too?
- [03/30/13 00:23:11] <@Perri> Yeah, I'm ready! :)
- 03[03/30/13 00:23:34] * Darthatron sets mode: +o machomuu
- [03/30/13 00:23:39] <@Perri> Beat me to it. XD
- 03[03/30/13 00:24:16] * ChanServ sets mode: -o Bela
- 03[03/30/13 00:24:28] * Darthatron sets mode: +o Bela
- 01[03/30/13 00:25:01] <@Bela> registered my name :p
- [03/30/13 00:26:11] <@machomuu> So, moral decisions, how do we feel about 'em
- 01[03/30/13 00:26:49] <@Bela> they're tough things in life, but they're things we get through
- 01[03/30/13 00:27:12] <@Bela> I don't really want to do too much of it in a hack
- 01[03/30/13 00:27:34] <@Bela> that's more of something you'll find in a visual novel
- [03/30/13 00:28:03] <@Perri> I still like the concept, but I worry about the feasibility of implementing it. We can still touch on the grey nature of morality, but perhaps not in such a player-directed way
- 01[03/30/13 00:29:42] <@Bela> I think it's a neat idea to explore, perhaps with the villains even
- [03/30/13 00:29:54] <@Perri> In other words, as something that comes up organically through the story, rather than having it be a personal choice of the player. That way we avoid split paths and using up all our flags
- [03/30/13 00:30:47] <@Perri> Definitely, it's something we should touch upon I think :)
- [03/30/13 00:32:56] <@Perri> but what is the nature of our setting going to be like? Pokemon regions are always modelled off of places that actually exist, and I was wondering which would be both a. fun and provide a distinct graphical look, and b. would fit the nature of the story
- [03/30/13 00:34:06] <@Perri> Since I live in Las Vegas I couldn't help but wonder how my own city would look as a region - all that neon and brighness and over-the-top glitz combined with rugged desert and shady little towns just beyond the outskirts
- 01[03/30/13 00:34:32] <@Bela> I'll admit I thought of what kind of setting the midwest would make for a game
- [03/30/13 00:34:33] <@Perri> And with our mob history, it seems a prime setting for a "corruption" themed story
- [03/30/13 00:35:06] <@Perri> I assume American midwest...hmm. What state or city in particular? Chicago could be neat
- 01[03/30/13 00:35:07] <@Bela> I live near Illinois, which while I digress it's really any different from other parts of the US, Chicago does get a bad rap for its 'corrupt' politics
- [03/30/13 00:35:11] <@machomuu> I dunno if mobs are the best way to go about a corruption story
- [03/30/13 00:35:36] <@Perri> I was speaking more generally, if we used Bela's story there wouldn't be any mafia involved
- [03/30/13 00:35:43] <@machomuu> Ah
- [03/30/13 00:36:15] <@machomuu> Well, in terms of setting, I'm all for a surreal setting.
- 01[03/30/13 00:36:29] <@Bela> I wouldn't mind making up a place that suits our interests
- [03/30/13 00:36:32] <@Perri> I've only ever been to Chicago briefly, and then I never left O'Hare, so I'm not sure what the region as a whole is like ^^'
- [03/30/13 00:36:46] <@machomuu> We could always have a mesh of places
- [03/30/13 00:36:47] <@Perri> I'd be against making up a region out of whole cloth since Pokemon regions are always based on real settings
- 01[03/30/13 00:36:53] <@Bela> well it's a bunch of land with no real defining characteristics :p
- 01[03/30/13 00:37:08] <@Bela> aside from the great lakes maybe
- [03/30/13 00:37:14] <@machomuu> Well, this isn't particularly a traditional pokemon game
- [03/30/13 00:37:15] <@Perri> and it's one of my favorite parts of Pokemon, really, how it reflects our own world
- [03/30/13 00:37:29] <@machomuu> Hm...
- 01[03/30/13 00:37:31] <@Bela> my hack isn't based on a real world setting
- [03/30/13 00:37:43] <@Perri> So personally I don't support completely disregarding IRL geography
- [03/30/13 00:37:50] <@Perri> But I'm open to the idea my mind could be changed
- 01[03/30/13 00:38:10] <@Bela> I can go either way on it really
- 01[03/30/13 00:38:17] <@Bela> I'm more for taking land and building on it
- [03/30/13 00:38:33] <@Perri> Even SRT is based on an "real" setting, though the landscape has changed so much as result of the war that there's only very subtle clues to hint as to where that is
- [03/30/13 00:38:55] <@Perri> Yeah, it doesn't need to mirror the real location exactly of course XD
- [03/30/13 00:39:21] <@machomuu> Personally, as far as gaming goes, I've always been a fan of games like Dot Hack and Xenoblade that manage to make these surreal and incredibly unique landscapes and societies. It gives an air of predictability to the games.
- 01[03/30/13 00:39:25] <@Bela> like you could give me any space of land and I could make up something :p
- [03/30/13 00:39:32] <@Perri> Hoenn seems more tropical than its IRL counterpart after all
- 01[03/30/13 00:40:49] <@Bela> the US really has gotten quite a bit of treatment for pokemon games anyway
- 01[03/30/13 00:40:57] <@Bela> Colosseum, XD, BW/2
- [03/30/13 00:41:03] <@Perri> One game compared to four based on Japan?
- [03/30/13 00:41:11] <@Perri> It's debatable if those first two are basedon Arizona
- 01[03/30/13 00:41:16] <@Bela> they've said it was
- [03/30/13 00:41:27] <@Perri> I've heard some Japanese location raised as a theory as well...but now I need to look this up
- 01[03/30/13 00:41:40] <@Bela> I've read the interview where they said it was based on Arizona
- 01[03/30/13 00:41:42] <@Bela> :p
- 01[03/30/13 00:42:06] <@Bela> but I'll just say now that I'm all for making up a whole new region
- [03/30/13 00:42:20] <@Perri> You're right, Bulbapedia confirmed that
- [03/30/13 00:42:57] <@Perri> I'm fine with making up a new region obviously, but I'm just don't like the idea of it not having an IRL counterpart
- [03/30/13 00:43:02] <@Perri> *I
- 01[03/30/13 00:43:05] <@Bela> why not :p
- [03/30/13 00:43:31] <@machomuu> I think, if we really wanted to, we could always use real locations as inspiration for locations in game without completely relying on them.
- 01[03/30/13 00:43:41] <@Bela> yeah
- [03/30/13 00:43:44] <@Perri> That's what Pokemon does to begin with though XD
- 01[03/30/13 00:44:00] <@Bela> like instead of grounding yourself to a particular place
- [03/30/13 00:44:08] <@Perri> I mean, Unova is obviously the New York metropolitan area. But it's also Unova
- [03/30/13 00:44:16] <@Perri> a unique place unto itself
- [03/30/13 00:44:32] <@machomuu> Yeah, but I think there's a difference in "making New York Ciry" and "using New York as a model".
- 01[03/30/13 00:44:33] <@Bela> you can just add whatever places you want, and base it on real world places for individual areas
- [03/30/13 00:45:02] <@machomuu> I think Unova was the latter, and they seemed to express that when they talked about it.
- 01[03/30/13 00:45:26] <@Bela> I've heard that the new towns in BW2 were based on places in New Jersey
- [03/30/13 00:45:44] <@Perri> Which I loved, originally being from New Jersey. XD
- 01[03/30/13 00:45:48] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 00:46:02] <@Bela> I wonder what a Pokemonized St. Louis would look like
- [03/30/13 00:46:06] <@Perri> Mainly inspired by North Jersey though, not where I grew up
- [03/30/13 00:46:26] <@Perri> I remember I set my first hack LITERALLY in New Jersey, same town names and everything
- 01[03/30/13 00:46:32] <@Bela> haha
- [03/30/13 00:46:39] <@Perri> But BW didn't exist then
- [03/30/13 00:48:18] <@Perri> For me wanting to have some geographical basis on a real place is mainly personal preference ^^' because it's something I've always loved about the games...but I definitely think we can compromise
- [03/30/13 00:49:45] <@machomuu> So if we were to represent real places, you guys would want to do America?
- 01[03/30/13 00:49:52] <@Bela> I think if we made not based on a particular place, it would make it more relatable to people
- [03/30/13 00:49:55] <@Perri> For example, we could say "Yeah, the game's modeled on Chicago and the surrounding area" but also fill in the blanks with things of our own creation. Chicago or whatever could be the blueprint, but not something to be slavishly adhered to
- 01[03/30/13 00:50:04] <@Bela> the thing about it machomuu
- [03/30/13 00:50:23] <@Perri> Kanto literally being the Kanto prefecture didn't make it any less relatable
- 01[03/30/13 00:50:33] <@Bela> is it seems implicit in making it based on a certain area, that you would have things which relate to that place in the real world in the game
- 01[03/30/13 00:50:51] <@Bela> which would mean
- 01[03/30/13 00:51:15] <@Bela> I could only really make a game based on the US since that's all I can I really say I know very well
- 01[03/30/13 00:51:25] <@Bela> which is why I don't want to do that
- [03/30/13 00:51:29] <@Perri> Like how XY has the Eiffel tower in the background. I'm fine with things like that, in fact I really like them ^^' But that doesn't mean we couldn't also create our own things
- 01[03/30/13 00:51:44] <@Bela> I think XY is going to be based on europe
- [03/30/13 00:51:55] <@Perri> It screams France
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:10] <@Bela> it will at least be based on france
- [03/30/13 00:52:17] <@machomuu> I think making a game based on all of Europe would be difficult -.-'
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:21] <@Bela> but I suspect they'll manage to incorporate all of europe in some form
- [03/30/13 00:52:21] <@Perri> Yeah
- [03/30/13 00:52:25] <@Perri> That would be a huuuuge region
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:37] <@Bela> perhaps france and germany
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:43] <@Bela> and a little bit of england
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:46] <@Bela> I dunno
- 01[03/30/13 00:52:55] <@Bela> I don't really want to make a game using that mindset though
- [03/30/13 00:52:58] <@Perri> I'd guess XY will probably stay limited to France or small slivers of nearby countries
- 06[03/30/13 00:53:16] * @Perri is starting to worry we might never agree*
- 01[03/30/13 00:53:20] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 00:53:30] <@Bela> but machomuu raises a good point
- [03/30/13 00:53:36] <@Perri> It just wouldn't feel right to not use a real place
- 01[03/30/13 00:54:01] <@Bela> the problem is that you and I are both from essentially middle america
- 01[03/30/13 00:54:07] <@Bela> which as a region would probably be nothing but land
- 01[03/30/13 00:54:10] <@Bela> which would be pretty boring ;p
- [03/30/13 00:54:35] <@Perri> Rivers and lakes and mountains
- [03/30/13 00:54:48] <@Perri> forests...land can still be cool. XD
- 01[03/30/13 00:54:50] <@Bela> yes but look at all the other pokemon games
- [03/30/13 00:54:55] <@machomuu> I'm from the East Coast, Maryland specifically. It's largely the reason that, if we were to make a hack representing real places...I'm not sure if America would be my first choice
- 01[03/30/13 00:54:57] <@Bela> and you'll see what I mean
- [03/30/13 00:55:02] <@Perri> Yeah
- [03/30/13 00:55:05] <@Perri> We don't have to pick the US
- 01[03/30/13 00:55:15] <@Bela> I just don't see the point overall in choosing a real world place
- [03/30/13 00:55:18] <@Perri> I was just trying to th ink of visually interesting places which is why I mentioned Las Vegas ^^'
- 01[03/30/13 00:55:26] <@Bela> unless we then contradict what that will mean in terms of story, etc
- [03/30/13 00:56:36] <@machomuu> Personally, I love the idea of using foreign places. They are, in a sense, surreal, much the same way BW would be surreal to a Japanese audience as, save for Akiba, there aren't many places you can find that are like New York or Southern North America
- [03/30/13 00:57:04] <@Perri> I was recently visiting in Germany and Scotland and would be quite happy to use either of those as a base
- [03/30/13 00:57:11] <@Perri> Amazing places
- [03/30/13 00:57:22] <@machomuu> Having said that, it would be harder to recreate what we don't know too much about
- 01[03/30/13 00:57:37] <@Bela> right
- [03/30/13 00:57:52] <@Perri> I'm not against research....but it might be unfair to ask others to do that
- 01[03/30/13 00:57:55] <@Bela> so unless it's just to give you an outline to place cities and routes on
- [03/30/13 00:57:57] <@machomuu> So, before we set this in stone, we need to figure out one thing: is this going to be in-universe?
- [03/30/13 00:58:04] <@Darthatron> I don't mind BASING it on real locations
- [03/30/13 00:58:08] <@Darthatron> but using something real
- [03/30/13 00:58:10] <@Darthatron> is odd
- 01[03/30/13 00:58:17] <@Bela> I really don't want to restrict myself to what a certain place in the world *is*
- [03/30/13 00:58:23] <@machomuu> Yeah
- [03/30/13 00:58:26] <@machomuu> Same here
- [03/30/13 00:58:33] <@Perri> Basically, doing it the same was as a real pokemon region
- 01[03/30/13 00:58:51] <@Bela> Pokemon conquest doesn't use a real region, the Mystery Dungeon games don't either do they
- [03/30/13 00:58:53] <@machomuu> If we're making a region, I say we use the world as our influence
- [03/30/13 00:58:53] <@Perri> I'm not saying we have to do it like my first hack and say "The region is New Jersey. Like, literally, New Jersey." XD
- [03/30/13 00:59:18] <@machomuu> Pokemon Conquest...well that uses Arceus and Japan
- 01[03/30/13 00:59:23] <@Bela> yeah lol
- [03/30/13 00:59:24] <@Perri> Pokemon Conquest is a spinoff for one
- 01[03/30/13 00:59:40] <@Bela> the ranger games use parts of japan
- [03/30/13 00:59:44] <@Perri> PMD....there's so little to base it on
- 01[03/30/13 00:59:46] <@Bela> that the official games don't
- [03/30/13 01:00:00] <@Perri> And yes, Ranger does, as do the Gamecube games
- 01[03/30/13 01:00:02] <@Bela> I'm gonna have to say though
- 01[03/30/13 01:00:24] <@Bela> that ultimately I am uninterested in being beholden to what the official games do
- [03/30/13 01:00:34] <@machomuu> Same here
- [03/30/13 01:00:44] <@Perri> I mostly agree, except on this obviously ^^'
- 01[03/30/13 01:00:46] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:00:55] <@machomuu> I think hacking has a lot of potential, and we are capable of making almost anything out of it
- [03/30/13 01:01:11] <@Darthatron> don't think we have limits for this hack
- [03/30/13 01:01:13] <@Darthatron> there are none
- [03/30/13 01:01:15] <@Perri> since I've always really really loved that Pokeworld is inspired so much geographically by our world
- [03/30/13 01:01:16] <@machomuu> I don't think we should limit ourselves to anything at all
- [03/30/13 01:01:18] <@machomuu> Crap
- [03/30/13 01:01:23] <@machomuu> I typed too slow ;_;
- [03/30/13 01:01:31] <@Darthatron> well I am a programmer
- [03/30/13 01:01:32] <@Darthatron> :P
- 01[03/30/13 01:01:37] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:02:19] <@machomuu> Here's my problem, though
- [03/30/13 01:03:48] <@machomuu> The Pokemon games, as you may have noticed, are so psychologically, logically, culturally, and physically detached from ours, I don't really feel that they're basing their locations on ours is exactly appropriate. I understand it, but at the same time, the differences make the changes seem strange and almost out of place.
- [03/30/13 01:05:01] <@Perri> Maybe it's just based on how differently we interpret the same world
- 01[03/30/13 01:05:14] <@Bela> with Rose I created a new world
- 01[03/30/13 01:05:23] <@Bela> it's not based on any existing place in the world
- 01[03/30/13 01:05:33] <@Bela> I made it up!
- 01[03/30/13 01:05:34] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 01:06:00] <@Bela> part of the fun is invention
- 01[03/30/13 01:06:11] <@Bela> in being able to totally make up what I want
- [03/30/13 01:06:32] <@machomuu> I think the important thing is that we make the location match the hack and not make the hack match the location.
- 01[03/30/13 01:06:41] <@Bela> we just seem to have different philosophies here
- [03/30/13 01:06:42] <@Perri> I guess I like alternate history too much. This is the person who wrote a fanfic based on 1940's Pokeworld - complete with WWII
- [03/30/13 01:07:10] <@Perri> Yeah
- [03/30/13 01:07:11] <@Perri> Definitely
- 01[03/30/13 01:07:24] <@Bela> yeahh I wouldn't go that far into making it match the real world :p
- [03/30/13 01:07:31] <@machomuu> I like it, it's like a sort of dynamic ;D
- [03/30/13 01:07:44] <@Perri> Well that was a fanfic of course XD
- [03/30/13 01:08:13] <@Perri> The setting should seem like it "goes" with the story
- [03/30/13 01:08:31] <@machomuu> I agree!
- 01[03/30/13 01:08:36] <@Bela> yeah
- [03/30/13 01:08:48] <@machomuu> As such, I think that's what we should focus on
- [03/30/13 01:09:09] <@Perri> Maybe we're jumping the gun focusing on setting when we haven't even decided on the story ^^' I was thinking backwards in terms of "get this done so the spriters can work"
- [03/30/13 01:09:18] <@machomuu> If we decide on one, we'll end up limiting the other, and that's not a bad thing
- 01[03/30/13 01:09:30] <@Bela> I think we can set up a region and then continue thinking about a story
- [03/30/13 01:09:33] <@machomuu> I just think that we should decide on the story to limit the setting choices
- 01[03/30/13 01:10:03] <@Bela> do you guys like the story idea I've given you? :P
- [03/30/13 01:10:30] <@machomuu> I do, but we haven't really given it any flesh yet.
- 01[03/30/13 01:10:39] <@Bela> I mean do you like it so far
- 01[03/30/13 01:10:54] <@Bela> or do you totally hate it
- 01[03/30/13 01:10:56] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 01:11:10] <@Bela> cuz if you like it, then that's a start at least
- 01[03/30/13 01:11:36] <@Bela> I think that story could fit a number of possible locations
- [03/30/13 01:11:39] <@Perri> I like aspects of it but there are parts I'm unsure of though I admit that's mainly from a personal "I don't know a lot about politics or business practices I pretty much slept through polisci in college" sort of way
- 01[03/30/13 01:11:42] <@Bela> it really doesn't need a particular setting to work
- [03/30/13 01:11:44] <@Perri> I'm willing to learn though:^_^
- [03/30/13 01:11:46] <@Darthatron> 'straya
- [03/30/13 01:11:52] <@machomuu> I like it. Though, I'm a little embarrassed that I haven't had any ideas on story thus far...
- [03/30/13 01:11:57] <@Perri> Same
- 01[03/30/13 01:12:12] <@Bela> I think that's okay
- [03/30/13 01:12:16] <@Perri> I thought up a gimmick and that's about it
- [03/30/13 01:12:23] <@machomuu> Well, actually, there's a very interesting book that you guys have probably heard of
- 01[03/30/13 01:12:25] <@Bela> I want to make a story where there's lots of character storylines active
- [03/30/13 01:12:33] <@machomuu> 1984, you guys know it?
- 01[03/30/13 01:12:45] <@Bela> I know of it, but I haven't read it
- 01[03/30/13 01:12:49] <@Bela> I read a book that was like it
- 01[03/30/13 01:12:56] <@Bela> Aldous Huxley's Brave New World
- [03/30/13 01:13:02] <@machomuu> I knew it!
- 01[03/30/13 01:13:04] <@Bela> haha
- 01[03/30/13 01:13:33] <@Bela> yeah the "don't fight" thing is like soma in a way lol
- 01[03/30/13 01:13:48] <@Bela> it's that invitation to passivity
- [03/30/13 01:13:54] <@machomuu> Hm...
- 01[03/30/13 01:14:05] <@Bela> which btw is something on its own we could do
- [03/30/13 01:14:13] <@machomuu> So...society, then.
- [03/30/13 01:14:41] <@Perri> Despite being a librarian I've never read any of these books ^^'
- 01[03/30/13 01:14:46] <@Bela> all I would have to do is ask you what you think might contribute to a society becoming apathetic, or passive, or docile
- 01[03/30/13 01:15:08] <@Bela> and I think entertainment is a big factor
- 01[03/30/13 01:15:30] <@Bela> and surely a big contributor to that is all the different gadgets and gizmos we possess now
- 01[03/30/13 01:15:36] <@Bela> like smart phones
- 01[03/30/13 01:15:52] <@Bela> so,
- [03/30/13 01:15:59] <@machomuu> I like it, that would be a great way of reflecting contemporary society
- 01[03/30/13 01:16:00] <@Bela> we could have some element in the story be like that
- 01[03/30/13 01:16:10] <@Bela> maybe the device the player gets is like that
- [03/30/13 01:16:19] <@machomuu> A PokeNav...etch...
- 01[03/30/13 01:16:20] <@Bela> instead of the pokegear/pokenav/poketch, it's a smart phone
- [03/30/13 01:16:31] <@Perri> It might be a bit...bite the hand though
- 01[03/30/13 01:16:40] <@Bela> how so lol
- [03/30/13 01:16:41] <@Perri> To rail against entertainment in a video game. XD
- [03/30/13 01:17:01] <@machomuu> It's the best way to get the message across, though
- 01[03/30/13 01:17:01] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:17:01] <@Perri> People play ROM hacks on their smartphones
- 01[03/30/13 01:17:05] <@Bela> yes
- [03/30/13 01:17:10] <@machomuu> Hiding a message in plain sight
- [03/30/13 01:17:17] <@machomuu> Er...
- [03/30/13 01:17:30] <@machomuu> Well, that's not the best saying for this scenario, but you get what I mean
- 01[03/30/13 01:17:40] <@Bela> yeah :P
- [03/30/13 01:17:43] <@machomuu> Uh...oh!
- 01[03/30/13 01:17:45] <@Bela> what would you call it?
- [03/30/13 01:18:09] <@machomuu> Hold on, I need to backtrack for a second
- 01[03/30/13 01:18:12] <@Bela> kk
- [03/30/13 01:18:21] <@machomuu> Is this gonna be in-universe?
- 01[03/30/13 01:18:34] <@Bela> as in, in the pokemon universe?
- [03/30/13 01:18:35] <@Perri> Which universe, though? Pokemon has so many canons
- [03/30/13 01:18:37] <@machomuu> In-canon universe, I mean
- [03/30/13 01:18:42] <@machomuu> Oh...uh
- 01[03/30/13 01:18:43] <@Bela> sure
- [03/30/13 01:18:49] <@machomuu> ...Any of them.
- 01[03/30/13 01:18:55] <@Bela> if you mean the universe which the main series games takes place
- [03/30/13 01:18:58] <@Perri> In between the dozen or so manga, anime, games....
- 01[03/30/13 01:18:59] <@Bela> I'd like that one :p
- 01[03/30/13 01:19:13] <@Bela> the one that RBY, GSC, DPP, BW took place in :p
- [03/30/13 01:19:22] <@machomuu> Then I propose it takes place in the far future
- [03/30/13 01:19:37] <@Perri> So it wouldn't be a "contemporary" hack at all
- [03/30/13 01:19:42] <@machomuu> Not so much that things are unrecognizably futuristic
- 01[03/30/13 01:19:48] <@Bela> well it wouldn't have to be that much further in the future
- [03/30/13 01:19:51] <@machomuu> Just so that we don't interfere with canon
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:08] <@Bela> hmmm well how would it do that
- [03/30/13 01:20:08] <@machomuu> Well...40 or 50 years?
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:11] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:16] <@Bela> that's way too far!
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:24] <@Bela> how does it interfere with canon
- [03/30/13 01:20:24] <@machomuu> I-is it?
- [03/30/13 01:20:28] <@Perri> It would be kind of sad we couldn't have any actual canon characters cameo in that case though ^^' Ah well
- [03/30/13 01:20:36] <@machomuu> Just that it might cut in with later releases
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:41] <@Bela> lol well
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:43] <@Bela> it's a fan work
- 01[03/30/13 01:20:51] <@Bela> if we're undercut by XY that's just too bad :p
- [03/30/13 01:20:54] <@Perri> It's an AU
- 01[03/30/13 01:21:27] <@Bela> if it's because we have a gadget that's more advanced than the ones that have appeared thusfar, I don't think that's really much of a concern
- 01[03/30/13 01:21:54] <@Bela> that could be something we address within the story
- [03/30/13 01:21:58] <@machomuu> Though, when you think about it, a good number of years would be a great amount of time for the League to pervert into something so corrupt
- [03/30/13 01:22:03] <@machomuu> And for society to do so as well
- 01[03/30/13 01:22:15] <@Bela> unless machomuu, it was a regional issue
- [03/30/13 01:22:24] <BungiePhantom> Qould pollution be a possible issue?
- [03/30/13 01:22:29] <BungiePhantom> *would
- 01[03/30/13 01:22:42] <@Bela> I've thought about having pollution be something that does occur within the story
- [03/30/13 01:22:51] <@machomuu> I think it makes sense
- 01[03/30/13 01:23:06] <@Bela> I don't think you would have to advance time by so much
- 01[03/30/13 01:23:11] <@Bela> you just have to isolate the region in some way
- [03/30/13 01:23:38] <BungiePhantom> Or maybe this device has a horrible side effect via wavelength radiation or wave interference, like the myth with cellphone towers and bees
- [03/30/13 01:23:55] <BungiePhantom> Just throwing suggestions
- [03/30/13 01:24:00] <@machomuu> I didn't think 50 years would be that much :/ Well, maybe...10-20?
- [03/30/13 01:24:05] <@machomuu> Or 5?
- 06[03/30/13 01:24:06] * BungiePhantom continues to lurk
- 01[03/30/13 01:24:13] <@Bela> I think it's unecessary to do that
- 01[03/30/13 01:24:24] <@Bela> maybe 3 years
- [03/30/13 01:24:55] <@machomuu> Or we could leave it ambiguous
- 01[03/30/13 01:25:23] <@Bela> I think your concerns could be resolved in a way which keeps it around the same time any of the other games take place
- [03/30/13 01:25:39] <@machomuu> I don't think the time period is too much of an issue, really
- [03/30/13 01:25:46] <@machomuu> *time lapse
- 01[03/30/13 01:25:55] <@Bela> I wouldn't mind having in-universe characters showing up
- [03/30/13 01:25:57] <@machomuu> **time gap
- 01[03/30/13 01:26:01] <@Bela> but please oh God do not make it Cynthia
- 01[03/30/13 01:26:05] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:26:10] <BungiePhantom> Too bad
- [03/30/13 01:26:13] <@Perri> No, she has Game Freak to push her into everything XD
- 01[03/30/13 01:26:18] <@Bela> she's been in every pokemon game since dp :p
- [03/30/13 01:26:18] <BungiePhantom> Nothing but Cynthia
- [03/30/13 01:26:38] <@machomuu> ...actually
- 01[03/30/13 01:26:39] <@Bela> I bet she'll be in XY too
- [03/30/13 01:26:40] <@Perri> I swear, someone who works there must fap to her or something
- [03/30/13 01:26:42] <@machomuu> There's something there
- 01[03/30/13 01:26:45] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:26:54] <@machomuu> You have something on your hands
- [03/30/13 01:27:04] <@machomuu> ...Er...let me rephrase that
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:04] <@Bela> so did that game at game freak
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:06] <@Bela> ;P
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:09] <@Bela> -guy
- [03/30/13 01:27:09] <@machomuu> You have something there
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:10] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:27:31] <@machomuu> All of the protagonists became champions, correct?
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:35] <@Bela> usually
- 01[03/30/13 01:27:51] <@Bela> or if you're the hero of a game that has a sequel, you disappear
- [03/30/13 01:28:14] <@machomuu> Now, if the Pokemon League was the corrupt one, wouldn't they basically have control of the champion in some way?
- 01[03/30/13 01:28:31] <@Bela> I think they would use them in some way
- [03/30/13 01:28:49] <@Darthatron> they could try
- 01[03/30/13 01:28:55] <@Bela> the champion wouldn't necessarily have to be evil
- [03/30/13 01:29:00] <BungiePhantom> Promotional ads!
- [03/30/13 01:29:03] <@machomuu> I agree
- 01[03/30/13 01:29:13] <@Bela> I think it's even better if the champion has good intentions, but those are used to evil ends
- 01[03/30/13 01:29:21] <@Bela> by others
- [03/30/13 01:29:24] <@machomuu> Also, each protagonist has a lot of renown and influence
- [03/30/13 01:29:29] <@Darthatron> what if the player got to pick?
- [03/30/13 01:29:37] <@machomuu> Pick what?
- [03/30/13 01:29:46] <@Darthatron> whether to be evil or not
- [03/30/13 01:29:52] <@machomuu> Ah
- 01[03/30/13 01:30:15] <@Bela> it's possible to do and still have the same overall story
- 01[03/30/13 01:30:19] <@Bela> what might change is the dialogue
- [03/30/13 01:30:30] <@machomuu> Would that really be worth it?
- 01[03/30/13 01:30:35] <@Bela> dunno
- [03/30/13 01:30:37] <@machomuu> For the player, I mean
- 01[03/30/13 01:30:58] <@Bela> it might be interesting if you're someone who replays hacks to see what would be different about a different path
- 01[03/30/13 01:31:06] <@Bela> .......
- [03/30/13 01:31:51] <@Darthatron> there only need to be one flag about good or evil
- [03/30/13 01:31:57] <@Darthatron> then we can use the same flags
- [03/30/13 01:32:00] <@machomuu> I agree
- [03/30/13 01:32:03] <@Darthatron> so memory wise it's fine
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:05] <@Bela> yeah but it's like
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:10] <@Bela> everything is divergent
- [03/30/13 01:32:14] <@machomuu> We could do a lot with a little
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:21] <@Bela> every event has to be written two ways
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:40] <@Bela> like I'm thinking
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:42] <@Bela> even if you were "evil"
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:48] <@Bela> you'd still be fighting the villains of the story
- 01[03/30/13 01:32:53] <@Bela> so that somehow would have to be justified
- [03/30/13 01:33:06] <@machomuu> Ah, very Knights of the Old Republic
- 01[03/30/13 01:33:33] <@Bela> it might be an interesting play actually
- 01[03/30/13 01:33:39] <@Bela> here's how I see this going down
- [03/30/13 01:33:44] <@machomuu> ...Or Elder Scrolls, that's probably more appropriate
- 01[03/30/13 01:33:50] <@Bela> you beat some gyms
- 01[03/30/13 01:34:04] <@Bela> and the members of the Board take notice
- [03/30/13 01:34:23] <@Perri> Sounds good to me
- 01[03/30/13 01:34:24] <@Bela> and then they start to appear
- 01[03/30/13 01:34:36] <@Bela> now what would be interesting about the good/evil thing
- 01[03/30/13 01:35:09] <@Bela> is depending on which you choose, their dialogue could be either pessimistic (them thinking you're trying to challenge the system) or optimistic (they think you'd make a nice addition to their corrupt fold)
- 01[03/30/13 01:35:37] <@Bela> and it could even overlap at some points
- 01[03/30/13 01:35:52] <@Bela> if only to illustrate that they don't know much about you at that point
- [03/30/13 01:35:55] <@machomuu> But in terms of gameplay, it all plays out the same
- 01[03/30/13 01:35:59] <@Bela> yeah
- 01[03/30/13 01:36:12] <@Bela> I mean, there could be some things that play out differently
- 01[03/30/13 01:36:18] <@Bela> if you think that would be good
- [03/30/13 01:36:36] <@machomuu> Well, I guess that could work if we're going for a single play experience, I'm fine with that.
- 01[03/30/13 01:37:13] <@Bela> the other thing about the good/evil thing is this could also play into having a discussion about morality
- 01[03/30/13 01:37:38] <@Bela> oh and one thing we haven't addressed
- 01[03/30/13 01:37:44] <@Bela> and it seems kinda silly to only ask it now
- 01[03/30/13 01:37:48] <@Bela> is the player going to be silent? :P
- [03/30/13 01:37:52] <@Perri> I say yes
- [03/30/13 01:37:58] <@Darthatron> yes
- [03/30/13 01:38:13] <@Perri> The player can still have a personality distinct from the person controlling them even without words
- 01[03/30/13 01:38:47] <@Bela> okay
- [03/30/13 01:38:49] <@machomuu> I guess that plays into the faux-non-linear sort of conversation options
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:03] <@Bela> yeah
- [03/30/13 01:39:05] <@machomuu> So it makes enough sense that they'd be silent
- [03/30/13 01:39:08] <@Perri> I've played hacks with a talking hero before and it's always come off as tacky to me - not that it couldn't be done well of course, but it's just so easy to get it wrong
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:20] <@Bela> what about their age
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:25] <@Bela> 10 seems too low
- [03/30/13 01:39:30] <@machomuu> Yeah, I've been thinking about that
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:35] <@Bela> what about like, 15
- [03/30/13 01:39:36] <@machomuu> I think it depends on who they are
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:42] <@Bela> that's still pretty young
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:49] <@Bela> I think it would work
- [03/30/13 01:39:55] <@machomuu> Why are they challenging the gyms?
- 01[03/30/13 01:39:57] <@Bela> I mean it's fairly irrelevant
- 01[03/30/13 01:40:02] <@Bela> what their age is
- [03/30/13 01:40:03] <@machomuu> I think that will determine the age.
- [03/30/13 01:40:32] <@Darthatron> I think 15 is okay
- [03/30/13 01:40:36] <@machomuu> They're motives and their morals should make determining their age pretty easy
- [03/30/13 01:40:40] <@Darthatron> the average age of people on PC is like 13
- [03/30/13 01:40:42] <@Perri> I may be applying too much realism, but a troublesome kid would be really quite easy for a group of corrupt people to deal with
- [03/30/13 01:40:45] <@Darthatron> so 15 is viable
- [03/30/13 01:41:34] <@Perri> The protag would need to be older, but then we hit the wall of "well, why are they doing gyms at that age"
- 01[03/30/13 01:41:47] <@Bela> why wouldn't a person at any age
- [03/30/13 01:41:53] <@machomuu> So then this raises another question: why would a 15 year old be going against a corrupt government?
- [03/30/13 01:42:13] <@machomuu> I'm not against it, it's just worth asking
- 01[03/30/13 01:42:20] <@Bela> well, it doesn't have to be their goal in the beginning
- 01[03/30/13 01:42:38] <@Bela> like, this could be cast in the same frame used in the other pokemon stories
- [03/30/13 01:42:47] <@Perri> Hmm...maybe our Trainer doesn't need to be a total newbie
- [03/30/13 01:42:53] <@Perri> Wes wasn't after all
- 01[03/30/13 01:42:54] <@Bela> only in this case, they're just much more sophisticated, connected villains
- [03/30/13 01:43:23] <@machomuu> Would the villains take a 15 year old seriously?
- 01[03/30/13 01:43:36] <@Bela> probably not at first
- 01[03/30/13 01:43:47] <@Bela> that's why I think this
- [03/30/13 01:43:55] <@Perri> Not only would that explain acceptably why they're older, but the fact they have experience behind them could make them (slightly) more believable
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:02] <@Bela> the beginning of the story gives you this illusion of a happy place where nothing is wrong
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:07] <@Bela> and that illusion shattered along the way
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:10] <@Bela> -is
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:25] <@Bela> I do agree with you PPG
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:32] <@Bela> if they were a bit older it might be better
- [03/30/13 01:44:52] <@machomuu> I'm a little scared that we might run into the "JRPG Problem"
- 01[03/30/13 01:44:57] <@Bela> what's that
- [03/30/13 01:45:12] <@Perri> Not the "Justin RPG" problem I hope!
- 01[03/30/13 01:45:21] <@Bela> not sure what EITHER of those are lol
- [03/30/13 01:46:51] <@machomuu> In JRPGs (Japanese Role Playing Games) , you usually play as a teenager or a kid or a group of teenagers or kids, and in the end, even if the villain raises a convincing argument, the adolescent/juvenile will basically say "screw that, what you're saying is just evil".
- [03/30/13 01:47:17] <@machomuu> They're too pure to be able to comprehend any sort of mature mentality
- 01[03/30/13 01:47:36] <@Bela> I would like for something better than that as a reply
- 01[03/30/13 01:47:44] <@Bela> but that's pretty hard to do with a character that doesn't talk ;x
- [03/30/13 01:47:44] <@machomuu> Actually, Black and White did this with Cheren and Bianca in regards to N's philosophy
- [03/30/13 01:48:36] <@Darthatron> hardly
- [03/30/13 01:48:41] <@machomuu> True, but the reason I raise this is because we're saying that, regardless of whether you choose to be good or evil, you still fight the antagonists
- [03/30/13 01:48:42] <@Darthatron> instead of "No, I won't do that"
- [03/30/13 01:48:52] <@Darthatron> it's "What!? You won't do that!?"
- 01[03/30/13 01:48:55] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:49:07] <@machomuu> This is what makes it bait for the "JRPG Problem".
- 01[03/30/13 01:49:25] <@Bela> I don't see that as a real thing
- 01[03/30/13 01:49:34] <@Bela> that sounds like poor writing on the creator's part
- [03/30/13 01:49:52] <@machomuu> The thing is, we might not have a choice
- 01[03/30/13 01:50:14] <@Bela> like, they couldn't come up with a compelling counter argument or didn't want to make a very intellectual interaction
- [03/30/13 01:50:22] <@machomuu> Usually it's done to make previously moral villains seem "downright evil"
- 01[03/30/13 01:50:41] <@Bela> the thing is, this story has villains of various moral shades
- 01[03/30/13 01:50:58] <@Bela> what I said the other day was
- [03/30/13 01:51:05] <@machomuu> Exactly, but what if the player agrees with them?
- 01[03/30/13 01:51:15] <@Bela> it depends entirely upon the content
- 01[03/30/13 01:51:23] <@Bela> I think it would be hard to agree though
- 01[03/30/13 01:51:28] <@Bela> if it's what I'm thinking of
- [03/30/13 01:51:31] <@Darthatron> I hated that I couldn't join Team ROcket in Cerulen in RBY
- 01[03/30/13 01:52:14] <@Bela> okay, but what I was saying yesterday was
- 01[03/30/13 01:52:23] <@Bela> let's have a villain who is like that
- 01[03/30/13 01:52:33] <@Bela> who we can depose as being like that
- 01[03/30/13 01:52:58] <@Bela> so that we can establish the other villains as something which transcends this convention
- 01[03/30/13 01:53:10] <@Bela> I personally think we could have very rich characters for villains
- 01[03/30/13 01:53:21] <@Bela> with different motivations, interests, personalities, etc
- 01[03/30/13 01:53:42] <@Bela> the thought I have right now
- 01[03/30/13 01:54:45] <@Bela> is that the ultimate villain is somebody who you couldn't possibly agree with
- 01[03/30/13 01:55:08] <@Bela> unless you discarded any sense of humanity
- [03/30/13 01:55:31] <@Darthatron> which some people will want to do
- [03/30/13 01:55:32] <@Darthatron> ie me
- 01[03/30/13 01:55:37] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 01:55:47] <@machomuu> lol
- 01[03/30/13 01:55:51] <@Bela> and what if that villain thinks they're better than you
- 01[03/30/13 01:55:55] <@Bela> you'd still want to beat them right :p
- [03/30/13 01:56:33] <@machomuu> Hm...so basically it's not someone you like.
- 01[03/30/13 01:56:46] <@Bela> even if you agreed with him in his philosophy, you'd presuambly contest his pokemon-using skills :p
- 01[03/30/13 01:57:10] <@Bela> well it's someone nobody would like
- 01[03/30/13 01:57:23] <@Bela> if they're an omnicidal maniac that wants to rid the world of humanity
- [03/30/13 01:57:32] <@machomuu> One thing I liked about BW was N
- 01[03/30/13 01:57:34] <@Bela> and will do it with the power of Genesecttt
- 01[03/30/13 01:57:43] <@Bela> yeah I liked him too
- 01[03/30/13 01:57:51] <@Bela> maybe we could put him in here as a cameo :p
- [03/30/13 01:57:51] <@Darthatron> fuck N
- [03/30/13 01:57:54] <@machomuu> Actually, I loved N in that game. As far as villains go in Pokemon, he is undoubtedly my favorite
- [03/30/13 01:58:04] <@machomuu> No, that's not it
- 01[03/30/13 01:58:08] <@Bela> Darthatron: anally :p
- 01[03/30/13 01:58:45] <@Bela> thank you I'll be here all week
- 01[03/30/13 01:58:46] <@Bela> ;p
- [03/30/13 01:58:55] <@machomuu> What I'm trying to say is that, as a villain, he worked because he had a philosophy that the contested the way that the player has gone about the game for years, and it was a convincing one
- [03/30/13 01:59:14] <@machomuu> One that I, personally, have been thinking about for years
- [03/30/13 01:59:24] <@Perri> As far as the main games go BW was definitely my favorite in terms of story
- 01[03/30/13 01:59:31] <@Bela> those two games did try to introduce something resembling a battle of philosophies
- 01[03/30/13 01:59:43] <@Bela> that's not what I'm thinking of here though
- 01[03/30/13 01:59:47] <@Bela> at least not with this particular character
- [03/30/13 01:59:51] <@machomuu> I think that it's because he was so believable as a person as well as so likeable, he worked as a villain
- [03/30/13 02:00:21] <@machomuu> Personally, I wish that N had been
- [03/30/13 02:00:27] <@machomuu> *Spoilers*
- [03/30/13 02:00:39] <@Perri> Of course, we have the liberty of taking things a bit further than BW could do due to not having to cater to children, but the philosophy of deconstruction of things we take for granted seems the same
- [03/30/13 02:00:41] <@machomuu> ...Well, I guess there's no reason to write that here
- [03/30/13 02:00:58] <@machomuu> Of course
- [03/30/13 02:01:08] <@Perri> I do think we shouldn't try to do too much, though
- 01[03/30/13 02:01:10] <@Bela> well we have a pretty simple one we could use already
- 01[03/30/13 02:01:16] <@Bela> is fighting with pokemon wrong
- 01[03/30/13 02:01:39] <@Bela> --that could be what this set of villains uses
- 01[03/30/13 02:01:50] <@Bela> and it would certainly be used insincerely by them
- [03/30/13 02:02:20] <@machomuu> But do they actually believe these things, or are they basically Cyrus?
- [03/30/13 02:02:30] <@Perri> We're a ROM hack after, not the next Pulitzer winner and trying to make too many statements on too many things - especially something that could seem hypocritical like "entertainment is turning us into unquestioning zombies" - is something we should avoid
- 01[03/30/13 02:02:31] <@Bela> no, that's what using it insincerely would mean
- 01[03/30/13 02:02:36] <@Bela> they don't actually believe that
- [03/30/13 02:02:57] <@Perri> We might want to narrow our focus down a little bit, which it seems we're doing now XD
- 01[03/30/13 02:03:00] <@Bela> it's just propaganda to keep trainers from fighting writ large, so they won't challenge institutions like the pokemon gyms or the pokemon league
- [03/30/13 02:03:43] <@machomuu> Actually, I wanna stay on Cyrus for a second, in terms of the big boss of this hack
- 01[03/30/13 02:03:47] <@Bela> ok
- [03/30/13 02:04:34] <@machomuu> Cyrus did have a philosophy, one that was shaped by his experiences growing up. He wanted to rid the world of...spirit, was it?
- [03/30/13 02:04:45] <@machomuu> To avoid war
- 01[03/30/13 02:04:49] <@Bela> yeah, whatever that was supposed to mean
- [03/30/13 02:05:31] <@machomuu> He meant it, too, he really wanted to save the world. From our point of view, however, he was evil because of it.
- 01[03/30/13 02:05:52] <@Bela> this villain could be like that
- [03/30/13 02:06:01] <@machomuu> But I think that, at least in platinum, he was an interesting and in some ways a likable antagonist
- 01[03/30/13 02:06:20] <@Bela> I imagine it as a character who feels ordained in some way to carry this all out
- [03/30/13 02:06:35] <@machomuu> Sounds God-plexy
- 01[03/30/13 02:06:39] <@Bela> well
- [03/30/13 02:06:54] <@machomuu> Though, considering his position, he is technically God.
- 01[03/30/13 02:07:09] <@Bela> if they're the President of the pokemon league, and also the chairman of a corporate that basically owns everything
- 01[03/30/13 02:07:11] <@Bela> he pretty much is yes lol
- [03/30/13 02:07:14] <@machomuu> From a "human power and influence" point of view
- 01[03/30/13 02:07:22] <@Bela> did you ever watch the anime The Big O by any chance
- [03/30/13 02:07:36] <@Perri> I haven't, no ^^'
- [03/30/13 02:07:40] <@machomuu> Whew...that was a while back, but yeah
- 01[03/30/13 02:07:43] <@Bela> ok
- 01[03/30/13 02:07:49] <@Bela> I think he could be like Alex Rosewater
- [03/30/13 02:09:15] <@machomuu> You know...
- [03/30/13 02:10:02] <@machomuu> I think having this sort of god-plexed antagonist would work incredibly well given the framework
- 01[03/30/13 02:10:17] <@Bela> yeah
- [03/30/13 02:10:23] <@Perri> Agreed
- [03/30/13 02:10:30] <@Perri> ...Yes, we all agree! :D
- 01[03/30/13 02:10:38] <@Bela> :D
- [03/30/13 02:10:46] <@machomuu> There really is a first time for everything :D
- 01[03/30/13 02:11:28] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 02:11:38] <@machomuu> So back to the puppet organization.
- 01[03/30/13 02:11:57] <@Bela> well, again I'd like to use something from Big O
- 01[03/30/13 02:12:11] <@Bela> basically it would be the Paradigm Corporation in the way it exists
- 01[03/30/13 02:12:34] <@Bela> I think if the villains who serve the President are all heads of different divisions
- [03/30/13 02:12:53] <@Perri> That only seems logical
- 01[03/30/13 02:12:55] <@Bela> this could give them different stuff to work with
- [03/30/13 02:13:04] <@Perri> And yeah, I like that aspect too
- 01[03/30/13 02:13:07] <@Bela> like have a legal, financial, research, etc groups
- [03/30/13 02:13:23] <@machomuu> Oh, well the reason I asked was actually because...
- [03/30/13 02:13:25] <@Perri> as focusing on different divisions, they could showcase a variety of different perspectives on the same issue
- [03/30/13 02:13:57] <@machomuu> I wanted to know if you guys wanted to go with the normal "team
- [03/30/13 02:14:02] <@machomuu> Ah
- [03/30/13 02:14:16] <@Perri> These guys pretty much ARE the "team"
- 01[03/30/13 02:14:22] <@Bela> yeah lol
- [03/30/13 02:14:24] <@Perri> I'm not sure if we need more than one
- [03/30/13 02:14:25] <@machomuu> "team" framework, innovate on the tried and true concepts, or create something new entirely
- [03/30/13 02:14:35] <@Perri> Oh! Misunderstood what you said there
- 01[03/30/13 02:14:43] <@Bela> I'm not really sure what kind of presence the villains would have outside of these few characters
- 01[03/30/13 02:14:54] <@Bela> maybe they could have henchmen of some kind
- [03/30/13 02:14:55] <@machomuu> Since, technically speaking...yeah, theye guys are the team we often see in the games
- 01[03/30/13 02:15:00] <@Bela> that are like secret police
- [03/30/13 02:15:24] <@machomuu> Personally, I'd like to see what we could do to make these guys something original
- 01[03/30/13 02:15:34] <@Bela> definitely
- [03/30/13 02:15:40] <@Perri> Again, agreed!
- [03/30/13 02:15:48] <@machomuu> :D
- [03/30/13 02:16:09] <@Perri> They're not a typical team - for one, no stupid haircut or fashion no-no uniform - and can't be expected to act that way
- [03/30/13 02:16:27] <@machomuu> Agreed
- 01[03/30/13 02:16:35] <@Bela> I'm thinking in terms of how the game would play--you'd want to be fighting some peeps
- [03/30/13 02:16:45] <@machomuu> Also, I don't think that they should have "Team" in their title
- [03/30/13 02:16:49] <@Perri> Same
- 01[03/30/13 02:16:56] <@Bela> agree
- 01[03/30/13 02:17:12] <@Bela> what should the corporation's name be?
- 01[03/30/13 02:17:43] <@Bela> I've been trying to think of one
- [03/30/13 02:17:47] <@Perri> Definitely not something that gives off an "evil" vibe
- [03/30/13 02:17:53] <@Perri> After all, they're a business
- 01[03/30/13 02:17:54] <@Bela> I was thinking
- 01[03/30/13 02:17:56] <@Bela> Unity Corp
- 01[03/30/13 02:18:25] <@Bela> it sounds very egalitarian
- [03/30/13 02:18:38] <@Perri> The one issue I have with it is that Unova also derives from "unity," a concept those games made a big deal out of
- [03/30/13 02:18:54] <@machomuu> Hm...
- [03/30/13 02:19:17] <@machomuu> To Thesaurus.com!
- 01[03/30/13 02:19:38] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 02:20:00] <@machomuu> Oh, wait. These guys are secret, right?
- [03/30/13 02:20:11] <@Perri> It also might not be "innocent" enough - it's very easy to tilt "Unity" into a negative concept. Everyone being the same and unquestioning. It pretty much says "This is our goal"
- [03/30/13 02:20:47] <@machomuu> Or rather, is the corporation secret?
- 01[03/30/13 02:21:03] <@Bela> their influence is secret
- 01[03/30/13 02:21:06] <@Bela> the corporation isn't
- 01[03/30/13 02:21:14] <@Bela> it's omnipresent
- [03/30/13 02:21:36] <@machomuu> In that case, would they even have a name?
- [03/30/13 02:21:48] <@machomuu> I mean, they hide behind the cover of the League
- 01[03/30/13 02:22:05] <@Bela> no, I think the corporation should have name
- [03/30/13 02:22:08] <@Perri> I suppose giving them a name is easier than having ??? Executive wants to battle! XD
- [03/30/13 02:22:16] <@machomuu> Ah, true
- 01[03/30/13 02:22:32] <@Bela> although I do agree that it would be easy to make the point that the state and business have merged
- [03/30/13 02:22:42] <@Perri> But at the same time, as BW's emphasis on the power of unity indicates, it is a term that can be spun any way you want it to be spun VERY easily
- [03/30/13 02:23:06] <@machomuu> Well what DO they want exactly?
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:12] <@Bela> well
- [03/30/13 02:23:16] <BungiePhantom> Control
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:17] <@Bela> the way I think of it is
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:25] <@Bela> the individual board members
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:29] <@Bela> are each in it for themselves
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:47] <@Bela> it's an opportunity to make money unfettered by oversight
- 01[03/30/13 02:23:55] <@Bela> it would be cool for them to like
- 01[03/30/13 02:24:06] <@Bela> one of them uses the power of say, Kyogre
- 01[03/30/13 02:24:12] <@Bela> in order to flood a region
- 01[03/30/13 02:24:32] <@Bela> so that they can somehow exploit the region as a business opportunity
- 01[03/30/13 02:24:49] <@Bela> and by "region" I only mean an area of land, not necessarily how pokemon uses the word
- [03/30/13 02:25:32] <@machomuu> Eew...if they had control over legends then they really would be the most powerful force in the world
- 01[03/30/13 02:25:37] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 02:25:42] <@Bela> that was just an example
- [03/30/13 02:25:51] <@machomuu> They could get rid of anything they don't like in numerous ways
- 01[03/30/13 02:25:56] <@Bela> although there have been pokemon games where villains having control over legendaries has been done :p
- [03/30/13 02:25:57] <@machomuu> Seriously though, I like it
- 01[03/30/13 02:26:15] <@Bela> that might actually be good though
- 01[03/30/13 02:26:21] <@Bela> as a sign of how powerful they are
- [03/30/13 02:26:26] <@machomuu> Yeah, but this is the Pokemon League, these guys basically decide on everything...period
- 01[03/30/13 02:26:29] <@Bela> it makes them a credible threat
- [03/30/13 02:26:32] <@machomuu> Scary
- [03/30/13 02:26:48] <@machomuu> Definitely, a lot scarier than the teams
- 01[03/30/13 02:26:51] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 02:26:58] <@Bela> except it's the corporation
- [03/30/13 02:27:05] <@machomuu> Very Big Brother
- 01[03/30/13 02:27:09] <@Bela> the League is just the institution they infiltrated
- 01[03/30/13 02:27:13] <@Bela> and basically put to sleep
- [03/30/13 02:27:29] <@Perri> It might be better to go back to a more RBY-esque story in regards to legends. Of course, our ultimate villain has Genesect, but having all these other guys gain all their force and power through a pokemon rather than through anything they've personally done cheapens them a bit
- 01[03/30/13 02:27:57] <@Bela> well maybe only a few of them have that kind of power
- 01[03/30/13 02:28:00] <@Bela> or like one or two of them
- 01[03/30/13 02:28:46] <@Bela> the pokemon ranger games do this all the time
- [03/30/13 02:29:01] <@machomuu> Hm...actually, you do raise a point
- 01[03/30/13 02:29:20] <@Bela> Shadows of Almia features a story about a mega corporation (Altru Inc) and its CEO uses Darkrai
- 01[03/30/13 02:29:38] <@Bela> the first game had its main villain use the GSC beasts
- [03/30/13 02:29:50] <@machomuu> I think we need to do something about the legends. I mean, this corporation is already so powerful. If they wanted the legends...it wouldn't really be a problem
- 01[03/30/13 02:29:53] <@Bela> and I haven't played the others but I know their villains are similar
- [03/30/13 02:30:22] <@machomuu> Ah, the original is about legend...
- [03/30/13 02:30:31] <@machomuu> You just brought back bad memories
- 01[03/30/13 02:30:34] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 02:30:48] <@machomuu> That last battle in the original...*shudder*
- [03/30/13 02:30:51] <@Perri> I loved the first Ranger so much
- [03/30/13 02:31:06] <@machomuu> Zapdos, Moltres, and Articuno, all one after another
- [03/30/13 02:31:14] <@machomuu> Me too :D
- [03/30/13 02:31:16] <@Perri> though part of that love was total bias, since I could run around the entire game with my favorite pokemon following my every step. XD
- 01[03/30/13 02:31:53] <@Bela> Guardian Signs has the villains control Mewtwo
- 01[03/30/13 02:32:31] <@Bela> I haven't beaten the Shadows game yet
- [03/30/13 02:32:33] <@Perri> Yeah, I'm totally fine with legends being involved, I'm just a little worried about overkill - and also that if we rely too much on lengeds these all too human bad guys won't be threatening on their own
- 01[03/30/13 02:32:49] <@Bela> I think we can moderate them in a way
- [03/30/13 02:32:57] <@machomuu> If I may propose something on the radical end, I think that we should consider only giving them weaker legends, the ones with more prominent abilities
- 01[03/30/13 02:33:00] <@Bela> like let's have 4 of these board members + the chairman (who is also the League President)
- [03/30/13 02:33:03] <@Perri> The human animal is the one we should fear most after all
- 01[03/30/13 02:33:18] <@Bela> and among those 4, have a maximum of 2 have access to legendaries
- [03/30/13 02:33:33] <@Perri> That works for me
- 01[03/30/13 02:33:37] <@Bela> and I think you can keep it pretty well regulated
- [03/30/13 02:33:39] <@machomuu> Rather than powerful ones like Entei and Lugia, they have ones that can make controlling society easier, such as Jirachi and Celebi
- [03/30/13 02:33:54] <@machomuu> ...Just an idea, though...
- 01[03/30/13 02:33:56] <@Bela> lol like Kodai and Celebi
- 01[03/30/13 02:34:02] <@Bela> they can see the future
- 01[03/30/13 02:34:06] <@Bela> except if they can see the future
- 01[03/30/13 02:34:13] <@Bela> wouldn't they know of the threat the player would be
- 01[03/30/13 02:34:38] <@Bela> if they have access to ones that are destructive, I think this is better
- [03/30/13 02:34:41] <@Perri> Or even something like Victini. Looks totally harmless.....but its entire gimmick is attracting power, success, victory
- 01[03/30/13 02:34:57] <@Bela> because the whole point of them having them is to use that power to some further end
- 01[03/30/13 02:35:15] <@Bela> but I like the idea of it being grounded in something
- 06[03/30/13 02:35:15] * @Perri nods* The entire Genosect thing
- 01[03/30/13 02:35:23] <@Bela> also I thought about Genesect
- 01[03/30/13 02:35:27] <@Bela> and how much it reminds me of drones
- 01[03/30/13 02:35:28] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 02:35:28] <@machomuu> Well the reason I propose this is because
- [03/30/13 02:35:30] <@machomuu> Generally
- [03/30/13 02:36:10] <@machomuu> Most organizations, such as the mob, the government, and in 1984, Big Brother exhibit their power not through brawn but through influence and control
- 01[03/30/13 02:36:36] <@Bela> I understand that they have subtle forms of manipulation
- 01[03/30/13 02:36:47] <@Bela> this is taking that further
- [03/30/13 02:37:02] <@machomuu> Then...what about a mix?
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:12] <@Bela> what about something like Darkrai
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:19] <@Bela> where
- [03/30/13 02:37:21] <@machomuu> Some of the more power oriented and some of the ability-based legends?
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:27] <@Bela> they use its power to instill fear in people
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:38] <@Bela> like
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:46] <@Bela> let's have a media division
- 01[03/30/13 02:37:58] <@Bela> and somehow they have the ability to broadcast Darkrai's power
- [03/30/13 02:37:58] <@machomuu> It could work, I like it
- 02[03/30/13 02:38:13] * BungiePhantom (~Azul@108-206-192-129.lightspeed.cicril.sbcglobal.net) Quit (Ping timeout: 252 seconds)
- [03/30/13 02:38:18] <@Perri> As do I - Darkrai seems to have that ideal mix of both influence and power
- [03/30/13 02:38:21] <@machomuu> That would certainly be a great way to control everyone
- [03/30/13 02:38:28] <@Perri> and it keeps up from being bogged down with a lot of legends
- 01[03/30/13 02:38:38] <@Bela> and he's a real cool Pokemon :P
- [03/30/13 02:38:46] <@Perri> That too :D
- [03/30/13 02:39:45] <@machomuu> Zapdos, Moltres, and Articuno...or just Castform, could control the weather.
- 01[03/30/13 02:39:54] <@Bela> perhaps the Kyogre-wielding person is somewhat reserved in their character, which could explain why they don't overuse it
- 01[03/30/13 02:39:59] <@Bela> Kyogre could also control the weather ;P
- [03/30/13 02:40:22] <@machomuu> He can?
- [03/30/13 02:40:28] <@Perri> So could Politoed XD (Just joking around, of course)
- 01[03/30/13 02:40:29] <@Bela> it can create rain and storms
- 01[03/30/13 02:40:35] <@Bela> which is all you'd really need
- [03/30/13 02:40:40] <@machomuu> Oh, oh!
- [03/30/13 02:40:51] <@machomuu> What about those 3 shinto god guys!
- [03/30/13 02:40:59] <@Perri> The genie trio?
- 01[03/30/13 02:40:59] <@Bela> Dialga/Palkia/Giratina?
- [03/30/13 02:41:02] <@machomuu> Y'know, Tornadus...um...
- 01[03/30/13 02:41:05] <@Bela> oh
- [03/30/13 02:41:05] <@machomuu> And the other two
- 01[03/30/13 02:41:11] <@Bela> Tornadus, Thundurus, Landorus
- [03/30/13 02:41:26] <@machomuu> Yeah :D
- [03/30/13 02:41:41] <@Perri> Would we be able to use their forme changes? ...Oh do I even need to ask that, with Darth of course we can XD
- [03/30/13 02:41:44] <@machomuu> They could be used to control weather!
- [03/30/13 02:41:55] <@machomuu> XD
- 01[03/30/13 02:41:58] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 02:42:32] <@machomuu> Though I think Groudon and its power over earth would be great for propoganda
- 01[03/30/13 02:42:58] <@Bela> Groudon is another neat possibility
- [03/30/13 02:43:03] <@Perri> I'll be right back guys
- 01[03/30/13 02:43:05] <@Bela> I want to do either Kyogre or Groudon
- 01[03/30/13 02:43:06] <@Bela> and kk
- [03/30/13 02:43:37] <@machomuu> Kotton Kandy?
- 01[03/30/13 02:43:45] <@Bela> yes :P
- [03/30/13 02:43:50] <@machomuu> Oh, kk
- 01[03/30/13 02:43:53] <@Bela> they both have a capacity for natural disasters that seems like a very useful thing for them to have
- [03/30/13 02:43:59] <@machomuu> I didn't notice what Perri said :P
- 01[03/30/13 02:44:09] <@Bela> lol
- 01[03/30/13 02:44:44] <@Bela> hmm
- 01[03/30/13 02:45:00] <@Bela> uses Kyogre/Groudon to flood/cause an earthquake that destroys thousands of homes...
- 01[03/30/13 02:45:08] <@Bela> so that the insurance money can be collected on them
- [03/30/13 02:45:10] <@machomuu> Actually, given all of this power that they have...we're going to have to have a lot of support characters
- 01[03/30/13 02:45:39] <@Bela> probably
- [03/30/13 02:45:50] <@machomuu> I mean, I can't see one 15 year old boy taking down a corporation of this prominence
- [03/30/13 02:46:21] <@machomuu> And with this much power
- 01[03/30/13 02:46:57] <@Bela> unless he's very good at using Pokemon :p
- [03/30/13 02:49:10] <@Perri> XD one thing I'm learning through Super Rising Thunder is that having a lot of support characters can make it difficult to develop them all
- [03/30/13 02:50:21] <@Perri> which is something we'd need to think about. We definitely need some because one kid isn't going to be able to stop this on his own unless he's the most amazing Trainer the world has ever seen (the very best, even. Like no one ever was); but too many and we run the risk of having a bunch of fairly flat and uninteresting people instead of a core group of characters with depth and personality
- 01[03/30/13 02:51:00] <@Bela> maybe you could use some of the gym leaders
- 01[03/30/13 02:51:25] <@Bela> who sort of question what's going on around them and decide to take action
- [03/30/13 02:51:30] <@machomuu> Actually, I'm glad you bring this up, because there's one thing I've seen in media that I've found to be very interesting
- [03/30/13 02:51:50] <@machomuu> This is in terms of side characters
- [03/30/13 02:51:53] <@Perri> That makes me think of the first Spcial arc, actually, where some Gym Leaders were aligned with the heroes and some were associated with Team Rocket
- 01[03/30/13 02:51:59] <@Bela> yes lol
- 01[03/30/13 02:52:09] <@Bela> only this would be a bit more ambiguous
- [03/30/13 02:52:13] <@Perri> Perhaps not all the Gym Leaders are as much of "allies" as they claim
- [03/30/13 02:52:30] <@Perri> I sort of like the idea that one of the player's "friends" may turn around to backstab them
- 01[03/30/13 02:52:31] <@Bela> because there isn't a clear-cut "team" to be on
- [03/30/13 02:52:52] <@machomuu> Given their relation to the League, I'd also suspect that they'd be watched more closely than the average civie
- 01[03/30/13 02:53:12] <@Bela> they may also have more access though
- 01[03/30/13 02:53:25] <@Bela> in whatever form that would manifest in the story
- [03/30/13 02:53:52] <@machomuu> But would they have access to the corporation or just the League?
- 01[03/30/13 02:54:13] <@Bela> well, that depends
- 01[03/30/13 02:54:37] <@Bela> I suspect some of the gym leaders would be in on this conspiracy too
- 01[03/30/13 02:54:48] <@Bela> or at the very least are forced to play ball
- 01[03/30/13 02:55:07] <@Bela> so they could easily serve as characters who could help or hinder the player
- 01[03/30/13 02:55:43] <@Bela> what's so interesting about this is the characters' personalities and beliefs almost entirely form what "side" they're on
- 01[03/30/13 02:56:16] <@Bela> because there is no team as it were
- 01[03/30/13 02:56:29] <@Bela> it's just
- [03/30/13 02:56:29] <@Perri> *nods* I see what you're saying
- 01[03/30/13 02:56:36] <@Bela> do you support or not support the establishment
- 01[03/30/13 02:57:33] <@Bela> and given the setup, just about anyone can be manipulated into either side
- 01[03/30/13 02:58:29] <@Bela> so you have a lot of potential for surprises
- [03/30/13 02:58:34] <@machomuu> ...I think that we should integrate the more prominent members of the corporation into the game somehow...
- [03/30/13 02:58:46] <@machomuu> Uh...or rather...
- 01[03/30/13 02:58:58] <@Bela> maybe they could be like how the Cipher admins existed
- 01[03/30/13 02:59:10] <@Bela> where they have their own domains
- 01[03/30/13 02:59:58] <@Bela> or maybe
- 01[03/30/13 03:00:05] <@Bela> maybe we could showcase them more through cutscenes
- 01[03/30/13 03:01:07] <@Bela> you have the option of only showing things through the main player's perspective
- 01[03/30/13 03:01:21] <@Bela> where only stuff that happens in their immediate surroundings is what is told in the story
- 01[03/30/13 03:01:37] <@Bela> but I think you can do it so you have scenes where the player is not present
- [03/30/13 03:02:28] <@Perri> Of course, the player (as in the character, not the person playing) wouldn't be privy to such information, but it could certainly help to build intrigue if used right
- [03/30/13 03:02:43] <@machomuu> Ah, well what I meant was...maybe we could make them characters in the game that befriend or oppose the character during the game, but they aren't revealed to be members of the corporation until later on.
- 01[03/30/13 03:02:44] <@Bela> yeah that's what I mean
- 01[03/30/13 03:02:55] <@Bela> I think that would remove much of the need to have the make these characters appear out in the open
- 01[03/30/13 03:03:03] <@Bela> -have to make
- [03/30/13 03:03:08] <@Perri> of course, we don't want to use cutscenes to spoil too much, since ultimately we want the player to come to their own conclusions towards whether they agree with the establishment or reject it
- 01[03/30/13 03:04:23] <@Bela> @machomuu - I like that idea
- [03/30/13 03:04:32] <@Perri> Agreed!
- 01[03/30/13 03:04:37] <@Bela> I think you could actually do both
- [03/30/13 03:04:39] <@Perri> Count that as another three way agreement :)
- [03/30/13 03:04:48] <@machomuu> :D
- 01[03/30/13 03:04:53] <@Bela> I know if we had cutscenes with board meetings
- [03/30/13 03:04:56] <@machomuu> I also agree that we could do both
- 01[03/30/13 03:04:59] <@Bela> I would want to keep the chairman concealed
- 01[03/30/13 03:05:02] <@Bela> at the very least
- [03/30/13 03:05:02] <@machomuu> Ooh
- 01[03/30/13 03:05:14] <@Bela> so that way the big reveal that he's also the league president is kept till the end
- [03/30/13 03:05:43] <@machomuu> Actually...not that I'm disagreeing...
- [03/30/13 03:05:52] <@machomuu> But might that be a bit obvious?
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:06] <@Bela> I'm not sure
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:13] <@Bela> it might depend on how it's delivered
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:16] <@Bela> like
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:26] <@Bela> if the story talks about the League President by name
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:36] <@Bela> and then only has the villains talk about their "Boss"
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:46] <@Bela> but you keep these two things mutually exclusive until the end
- 01[03/30/13 03:06:48] <@Bela> I think it might work
- [03/30/13 03:06:57] <@machomuu> Oh, no, that's not what I mean
- 01[03/30/13 03:07:49] <@Bela> then what do you mean :p
- [03/30/13 03:08:02] <@machomuu> I'm saying that...well, if the player were trying to figure out who the antagonist was, they'd probably go immediately to the League president if we actually introduce him.
- 01[03/30/13 03:08:32] <@Bela> I think if we start with introducing him
- [03/30/13 03:08:37] <@machomuu> In other words, because the League is so powerful and we know that they have a president, their minds might go right to him.
- [03/30/13 03:08:40] <@machomuu> Or her
- [03/30/13 03:08:41] <@Perri> Something generic like "boss" also hides the gender of the character. IF they used Mr. or Mrs. or an obviously gendered first name, it could be easily to eliminate part of the cast and eliminate some of the mystery
- [03/30/13 03:08:55] <@Perri> *easily used
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:03] <@Bela> well if you want red herrings
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:06] <@Bela> those are easy to make
- [03/30/13 03:09:14] <@machomuu> Yeah, that's what I mean
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:14] <@Bela> just make the Champion a possible character
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:31] <@Bela> that gives them two possibilities right up until the end
- [03/30/13 03:09:38] <@Perri> Machomuu, we had the same idea there. The president doesn't necessarily have to be male XD
- [03/30/13 03:09:39] <@machomuu> And the puppet organization leader
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:49] <@Bela> it turns out it's Cynthia
- 01[03/30/13 03:09:51] <@Bela> ;P
- [03/30/13 03:09:59] <@Perri> Oh god that cracked me up XD
- [03/30/13 03:10:05] <@machomuu> People would rage :p
- 01[03/30/13 03:10:10] <@Bela> indeed they would :p
- 01[03/30/13 03:10:32] <@Bela> I think it's easier to hate the character if it's a crotchety old man
- [03/30/13 03:11:07] <@machomuu> So...do we not pick the old man because he's so easy to hate?
- [03/30/13 03:11:24] <@Perri> (Cynthia should be the one waiting on Mt. Silver in Crystal Meth, but I digress. XD )
- [03/30/13 03:11:25] <@Perri> A crotchety old man may seem a bit obvious, but after all evil comes in all flavors
- 01[03/30/13 03:11:45] <@Bela> I'm thinking a character like Damon Gant or Alex Rosewater would make a good League president
- [03/30/13 03:12:11] <@machomuu> Generally, it is the old man type or the business man type that controls these types of organizations
- 01[03/30/13 03:12:12] <@Bela> they wouldn't necessarily have to look old and decrepit
- 01[03/30/13 03:12:40] <@Bela> but I do think that having it be "that" kind of person is right, even if they were presumably a "good" character
- [03/30/13 03:12:44] <@machomuu> Well, we could avoid those tropes to add to the unpredictability
- [03/30/13 03:12:59] <@machomuu> Hm...makes sense
- 01[03/30/13 03:13:01] <@Bela> but people could just say you're avoding the trope precisely because that's what it is :P
- 01[03/30/13 03:13:08] <@Bela> -avoiding
- [03/30/13 03:13:08] <@Perri> Tropes aren't always bad
- 01[03/30/13 03:13:18] <@Bela> this is starting to read like a tvtropes page
- 01[03/30/13 03:13:19] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 03:13:20] <@machomuu> Oh, so true
- [03/30/13 03:13:23] <@Perri> XD
- [03/30/13 03:13:50] <@Perri> While an old man may be the "classic" image, a lot of CEOs are older men
- [03/30/13 03:13:53] <@machomuu> I'm just saying we can always consider alternatives
- [03/30/13 03:13:57] <@Perri> It's truth in television...err...ROM hack
- [03/30/13 03:14:05] <@Perri> But that isn't to say we can't subvert it
- [03/30/13 03:14:16] <@Perri> but we shouldn't go so far off the deep end that it looks like we're trying to defy a trope for the sake of defying it
- [03/30/13 03:14:34] <@machomuu> Speaking of that, what is so wrong with having a woman?
- [03/30/13 03:14:41] <@Perri> Nothing at all
- 01[03/30/13 03:14:53] <@Bela> well, it's not that it couldn't be a woman
- [03/30/13 03:14:56] <@machomuu> I've never seen it before, and it's not TOO overboard
- [03/30/13 03:15:10] <@Perri> It could even be an older woman
- [03/30/13 03:15:19] <@Perri> Staying close to the trope, but tweaking it just enough
- [03/30/13 03:15:20] <@machomuu> I definitely wouldn't call it a complete subversion
- [03/30/13 03:15:32] <@machomuu> Oh, that's the other thing
- [03/30/13 03:15:42] <@machomuu> I think they should be middle aged, rather than old
- [03/30/13 03:15:51] <@machomuu> Say...Mad Men aged?
- [03/30/13 03:16:15] <@machomuu> They are the ones that usually gauge what is popular in society and then drive commercialism for it
- [03/30/13 03:16:22] <@Perri> Good points
- 01[03/30/13 03:16:45] <@Bela> that would be good if it were one of the members
- 01[03/30/13 03:16:54] <@Bela> I still think the chair person/president should be a man
- [03/30/13 03:17:05] <@Perri> Too old, and you have the stereotype of being "out of touch". It's what I was trying to get at by saying CEOs tend to be "older" but you're wording it much better than I did ^^'
- 01[03/30/13 03:17:16] <@Bela> not because I'm saying a woman wouldn't be possible, I just think it works better as a man :p
- 01[03/30/13 03:17:33] <@Bela> it seems like
- 01[03/30/13 03:18:38] <@Bela> the characteristics of an old man to have a power structure and all this other antiquated stuff
- [03/30/13 03:18:43] <@machomuu> Men are generally the types to be god-plexed
- 01[03/30/13 03:20:01] <@Bela> maybe among the members there could be women
- 01[03/30/13 03:20:11] <@Bela> and certainly among the gym leaders and the champion
- [03/30/13 03:20:25] <@Perri> Definitely :D
- [03/30/13 03:20:33] <@machomuu> Yupyup
- [03/30/13 03:20:48] <@Perri> And the player will be able to be of both genders, right? I ask because they've been called "he" all evening XD
- 01[03/30/13 03:21:01] <@Bela> No they can only be a male, it's a choice between two males :P
- [03/30/13 03:21:19] <@machomuu> XD
- [03/30/13 03:22:19] <@Perri> And I'm guilty of that, my own hack is a "player character is always male" type of game ^^'
- [03/30/13 03:22:30] <@machomuu> So, having said all of this
- [03/30/13 03:22:43] <@machomuu> Region?
- 01[03/30/13 03:22:50] <@Bela> what's the region gonna look like
- [03/30/13 03:22:53] <@Perri> Circled back around to the start XD
- [03/30/13 03:23:18] <@machomuu> Personally, in terms of representation, I say North America, Central Japan, and Western Europe
- 01[03/30/13 03:23:23] <@Bela> I'm just interested in the region having some amount of coastline and water
- 01[03/30/13 03:23:53] <@Bela> maybe we can create some base land and water combination
- [03/30/13 03:23:56] <@Perri> Hmm....given this is the future, and a region with heavy corporate influence, it's very likely it could be urbanized and built up, even more than Unova
- [03/30/13 03:23:58] <@machomuu> Hmm...North America and Western Europe, then?
- 01[03/30/13 03:24:09] <@Bela> and then we can each take turns making up town/routes
- 01[03/30/13 03:24:16] <@Bela> or compare different setups
- [03/30/13 03:24:24] <@Perri> Not mixing them both together,I'm still against that ^^' It think we should pick just one of those places
- [03/30/13 03:24:31] <@machomuu> Oh, what about cars?
- [03/30/13 03:24:38] <@Perri> I support cars
- [03/30/13 03:24:47] <@machomuu> Wait, you only want one place?
- 01[03/30/13 03:24:52] <@Bela> I think there should still be some amount of rural areas
- [03/30/13 03:24:52] <@machomuu> Hrmmm...
- [03/30/13 03:25:02] <@Perri> We do see quite a few of them in BW after all
- [03/30/13 03:26:05] <@Perri> Yeah, I still very much prefer the idea of using a specific real life area as a base and then expanding and fictionalizing it, the way the games do...but we already had this discussion ^^'
- 01[03/30/13 03:26:24] <@Bela> how about this Perri
- 01[03/30/13 03:26:32] <@Bela> let's pick some expanse of land and water
- 01[03/30/13 03:26:43] <@Bela> and then with that we have a template
- [03/30/13 03:26:46] <@Perri> I'm fine with that
- 01[03/30/13 03:27:01] <@Bela> and with that template, we try to come up with a place for the starting town
- 01[03/30/13 03:27:07] <@Bela> and all the other towns
- 01[03/30/13 03:27:09] <@Bela> and routes
- [03/30/13 03:27:12] <@Perri> Seems a good compromise. We get land, we get water, we get a real-life landmass that can serve as a template
- [03/30/13 03:27:14] <@Perri> :)
- [03/30/13 03:27:16] <@Perri> I'm down with that!
- 01[03/30/13 03:27:37] <@Bela> okay so what should that be :p
- [03/30/13 03:28:00] <@machomuu> Well, that would be either Japan, Europe, Aussie, North America, South America, and Africa
- [03/30/13 03:28:12] <@machomuu> And Asia.
- [03/30/13 03:28:38] <@Perri> XY will be doing Europe, and American and Japan have been pretty well explored (though I suppose there's Canada or Latin America as far as North America are concerned)
- 01[03/30/13 03:29:11] <@Bela> Canada - too cold; Latin America - too hot
- 01[03/30/13 03:29:12] <@Bela> ;p
- [03/30/13 03:29:27] <@machomuu> Well we can still do Europe, they can't possibly do all of it
- 01[03/30/13 03:29:37] <@Bela> and even if they do, it wouldn't matter really
- [03/30/13 03:29:48] <@Perri> Though since XY seems to be focusing on France....Hmm. Looking at the map there's a lot of interesting penisulas
- [03/30/13 03:29:55] <@Perri> (Of Europe, not of France. XD)
- 01[03/30/13 03:30:04] <@Bela> we could do England/Ireland
- 01[03/30/13 03:30:27] <@Bela> the thing is
- 01[03/30/13 03:30:51] <@Bela> for this kind of story
- 01[03/30/13 03:31:02] <@Bela> it's probably going to be out of place no matter what you choose
- [03/30/13 03:31:13] <@Perri> Yeah, we don't need to worry about that too much
- [03/30/13 03:31:25] <@machomuu> I dunno, 1984 took place in Europe, and it worked rather well
- [03/30/13 03:32:01] <@machomuu> Personally, for this type of story, I would think that North America, Western Europe, and Central Japan...or any of China, are the ideal locations.
- 01[03/30/13 03:32:38] <@Bela> I guess what gets me is
- 01[03/30/13 03:32:46] <@Bela> I know Europe isn't nearly as corrupt as the US is lol
- [03/30/13 03:32:59] <@machomuu> You never know
- [03/30/13 03:33:25] <@Perri> THe UK does have an obsession with cameras
- 01[03/30/13 03:33:31] <@Bela> I know Canada is like the least corrupt place ever
- [03/30/13 03:33:32] <@machomuu> Big Brother is in everywhere
- [03/30/13 03:33:38] <@machomuu> Ge's always watching
- [03/30/13 03:33:40] <@Perri> Big Brother watching and all that. XD
- 01[03/30/13 03:33:42] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 03:33:44] <@machomuu> *He's
- 01[03/30/13 03:33:50] <@Bela> I forget which country it is
- 01[03/30/13 03:33:58] <@Bela> I don't think it's Norway
- 01[03/30/13 03:34:15] <@Bela> But one country near it like
- 01[03/30/13 03:34:24] <@Bela> actually prosecuted and put in prison its bankers
- 01[03/30/13 03:34:37] <@Bela> so I know whichever country that is isn't corrupt lol
- 01[03/30/13 03:35:11] <@Bela> but I would be fine choosing some area of land in the UK/western Europe for a region
- [03/30/13 03:35:18] <@Perri> In terms of the UK, the eastern side of Scotland could be a cool region. Zooming into the map there's a bunch of islands and the shape is interesting
- [03/30/13 03:35:38] <@Perri> Looking at the rest of the map it seems to be the most visually interesting area of the country
- 01[03/30/13 03:35:56] <@Bela> okay
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:02] <@Bela> and by visually interesting
- [03/30/13 03:36:12] <@Perri> Just through sheer geography
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:22] <@Bela> because I'm thinking we could still tailor-fit the geography as far as mountains, etc go
- [03/30/13 03:36:28] <@Perri> Yeah, totally
- [03/30/13 03:36:35] <@Perri> Just the shape of the landmass is cool
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:37] <@Bela> then okay
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:40] <@Bela> let's do that
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:45] <@Bela> show me what it looks like if you can :p
- 01[03/30/13 03:36:53] <@Bela> I'll go look it up but
- 01[03/30/13 03:37:11] <@Bela> wanna make sure we're looking at the same subsection
- [03/30/13 03:37:35] <@Perri> I took a screen cap
- [03/30/13 03:37:50] <@Perri> But look for the "Firth of Clyde"
- 01[03/30/13 03:38:21] <@Bela> hmmm
- 01[03/30/13 03:39:15] <@Bela> ah I see
- [03/30/13 03:40:36] <@Perri> http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e57/PinkParkaGirl/scotland_zpsaf70182a.png It seems like it could be a cool shape for a region
- [03/30/13 03:40:46] <@Perri> though of course we can put mountains and such where ever we want them
- 01[03/30/13 03:41:01] <@Bela> lol it reminds me of Kanto almost
- [03/30/13 03:41:24] <@Perri> ...No wonder I liked this spot when I found it on the map
- 01[03/30/13 03:41:24] <@Bela> http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a9/Firthofclydemap.png/531px-Firthofclydemap.png
- 01[03/30/13 03:41:26] <@Bela> well this does
- 01[03/30/13 03:41:27] <@Bela> lol
- [03/30/13 03:41:38] <@Perri> It is very Kanto-esque!
- [03/30/13 03:41:49] <@Perri> Yeah, the map you found looks better than the screencap I took
- 01[03/30/13 03:42:12] <@Bela> I would use what the wikimedia image shows
- 01[03/30/13 03:42:18] <@Bela> but have more land off to the right
- [03/30/13 03:42:19] <@Perri> Yeah :)
- 01[03/30/13 03:42:23] <@Bela> which is what's actually there too
- 01[03/30/13 03:42:34] <@Bela> http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/82/Scotland_in_the_UK_and_Europe.svg
- 01[03/30/13 03:42:41] <@Bela> can you spot where the Firth of Clyde is :P
- [03/30/13 03:43:09] <@Perri> I can! XD
- 01[03/30/13 03:43:11] <@Bela> the way there's land that sorta trails upward
- 01[03/30/13 03:43:18] <@Bela> reminds me of Sinnoh/Hokkaido
- [03/30/13 03:43:34] <@Perri> Yeah :)
- 01[03/30/13 03:43:44] <@Bela> but it'd probably be too far to do that
- 01[03/30/13 03:43:55] <@Bela> and it'd probably just end up looking like Sinnoh if we did that :P
- [03/30/13 03:44:34] <@Perri> The Firth of Clyde looks promising but we can still turn back to the map to find something else of course :)
- 01[03/30/13 03:46:01] <@Bela> the alternative I see there is maybe using Norway and Sweden
- [03/30/13 03:46:11] <@Perri> Taking a look there right now
- [03/30/13 03:47:09] <@Perri> Yeah, the coast of Norway has that same "island and peninsula" thing going on XD
- 01[03/30/13 03:47:14] <@Bela> lol yeah
- [03/30/13 03:47:29] <@Perri> I guess we should just decide whether a UK-inspired region or a Norway-inspired one works better for the story
- 01[03/30/13 03:47:30] <@Bela> I'm fine with what you chose
- [03/30/13 03:47:34] <@Perri> And pick accordingly
- 01[03/30/13 03:47:55] <@Bela> I'm not sure how much of what the landmass we chose will be reflected in the story
- 01[03/30/13 03:48:20] <@Bela> machomuu are you still alive :P
- [03/30/13 03:48:29] <@Perri> Wow, Wikipedia has a category for "Corruption in Norway" ...with a single article. XD
- [03/30/13 03:48:44] <@Perri> And that's true, we're mainly just stealing the landmass shape ^^
- [03/30/13 03:49:22] <@machomuu> Yeah, I'm here
- 01[03/30/13 03:49:33] <@Bela> okay, what do you think about all ^^^^^ this
- 01[03/30/13 03:49:56] <@Bela> and also what would we call such a place
- [03/30/13 03:50:12] <@Perri> Try searching Midfjorden - the surrounding area could also work as a region
- [03/30/13 03:50:30] <@Perri> I suppose we can compare this and the Firth of Clyde and decide which one we like better
- [03/30/13 03:51:11] <@Perri> A lot of islands, but to avoid Hoenn syndrome there could always be bridges or boats along with surfing
- [03/30/13 03:51:22] <@Darthatron> nobody cares if I'm alaive :(
- [03/30/13 03:51:26] <@Perri> D:
- 01[03/30/13 03:51:34] <@Bela> no, I know you're alive ;D
- [03/30/13 03:51:49] <@Darthatron> well if we use the "Natural Overworld Skills"
- [03/30/13 03:51:52] <@Darthatron> then
- [03/30/13 03:51:56] <@Darthatron> who needs those things
- [03/30/13 03:52:09] <@Perri> I think it's more that people hate surfing because WILD TENTACOOL APPEARED
- [03/30/13 03:52:31] <@Darthatron> IF ONLY THERE WAS SOME WAY TO MAKE THAT STOP
- [03/30/13 03:52:34] <@Darthatron> LIKE AN ITEM
- [03/30/13 03:52:37] <@Perri> Indeed~
- [03/30/13 03:52:40] <@Darthatron> TO REPEL THEM
- 01[03/30/13 03:52:59] <@Bela> or wild TENTACHA
- 01[03/30/13 03:53:04] <@Bela> as the Germans would call it
- 01[03/30/13 03:53:40] <@Bela> that's the only one that's different
- 01[03/30/13 03:53:48] <@Bela> the other languages still call it Tentacool
- [03/30/13 03:54:00] <@Perri> I can't imagine the Japanese call it Tentacool...do the? XD
- [03/30/13 03:54:02] <@Perri> *do they?
- 01[03/30/13 03:54:23] <@Bela> no that one's different obv
- 01[03/30/13 03:54:36] <@Bela> I meant the other european releases all call it tentacool
- 01[03/30/13 03:55:15] <@Bela> French/Spanish/Italian
- 01[03/30/13 03:58:09] <@Bela> NAME
- 01[03/30/13 03:58:12] <@Bela> what should the NAME BE
- [03/30/13 03:58:26] <@Perri> Hmm...Midfjorden would be interesting for all the islands, while Firth of Clyde is more balanced between land and water...
- [03/30/13 03:58:38] <@Perri> As for the name...hmm
- 01[03/30/13 03:58:42] <@Bela> The region name is now Midfjdjdfdjfdjfdk
- 01[03/30/13 03:59:11] <@Bela> okay next
- 01[03/30/13 03:59:15] <@Bela> what starters do you get
- 01[03/30/13 03:59:17] <@Bela> ;p
- [03/30/13 03:59:19] <@Perri> The names either reflect the region in some way, whether through literal means (Kanto) or more symbolic (Unova), or...I'm not sure what Hoenn really means come to think of it
- [03/30/13 03:59:39] <@Perri> Our three favorite pokemon? XD Seriously though...hmm.
- [03/30/13 03:59:58] <@machomuu> Are we doing 3?
- [03/30/13 04:00:12] <@Perri> Did we decide if our fifteen year old hero is going to be an established Trainer or a total newbie?
- [03/30/13 04:00:39] <@Perri> If he's established, he could have multiple starters (ala Wes) at a higher level
- 01[03/30/13 04:01:04] <@Bela> or just one maybe
- [03/30/13 04:01:14] <@Perri> Just one is fine too
- [03/30/13 04:01:24] <@machomuu> We could always have the game start at a flashback of when he gained his pokemon.
- [03/30/13 04:01:32] <@machomuu> *Starter
- 01[03/30/13 04:01:38] <@Bela> Dunsparce :p
- [03/30/13 04:02:07] <@machomuu> Or, alternatively, if the games have become more logical and have stopped allowing 10 year olds roam the earth on their own, I say we make him a newb
- 01[03/30/13 04:02:24] <@Bela> the picks are between Dunsparce, Nosepass, and Sunkern
- 01[03/30/13 04:03:14] <@Bela> okay but seriously
- [03/30/13 04:03:24] <@machomuu> Eh, I need to head to bed.
- 01[03/30/13 04:03:29] <@Bela> yeah I'm kinda tired myself
- 01[03/30/13 04:03:33] <@Bela> it's like what, 5 for you?
- [03/30/13 04:03:36] <@Perri> Then we'd have to explain the plothole left behind about why there's no ten year old trainers anymore
- [03/30/13 04:03:40] <@machomuu> Yeah
- [03/30/13 04:03:42] <@Perri> but we can worry about that nother time
- [03/30/13 04:03:44] <@Perri> *another
- 01[03/30/13 04:03:48] <@Bela> okay, goodnight guys
- [03/30/13 04:03:53] <@machomuu> Night!
- 01[03/30/13 04:03:58] <@Bela> this was very productive
- [03/30/13 04:04:05] <@Darthatron> picks between Mewtwo
- [03/30/13 04:04:08] <@machomuu> It was :D
- [03/30/13 04:04:08] <@Darthatron> and that's it
- 01[03/30/13 04:04:12] <@Bela> Mewtwo and Mewtwo
- 01[03/30/13 04:04:18] <@Bela> two Mewtwo
- 02[03/30/13 04:04:20] * @machomuu (442195a6@gateway/web/freenode/ip.68.33.149.166) Quit (Quit: Page closed)
- [03/30/13 04:04:22] <@Perri> Agreed! We have some good ideas, two possible regions, and a LOT of worthwhile discussion :)
- 01[03/30/13 04:04:33] <@Bela> we'll need to meet again
- [03/30/13 04:04:47] <@Perri> Though maybe we should present the two possible regions to the graphics team and let them decide which they'd rathehr do?
- 01[03/30/13 04:04:56] <@Bela> maybe
- [03/30/13 04:04:58] <@Perri> Since it won't make an effect on the story either way which region it is
- [03/30/13 04:05:26] <@Perri> It ony seems fair to give them a voice since they'll be makingit
- 01[03/30/13 04:05:50] <@Bela> I think at some point they or someone related to mapping needs to decide
- [03/30/13 04:05:57] <@Perri> Yeah
- 01[03/30/13 04:06:13] <@Bela> because it's really up to them to decide where towns and routes go
- 01[03/30/13 04:06:28] <@Bela> I would like for more people to be party to this discussion as well
- 01[03/30/13 04:06:55] <@Bela> since at this point it really stops being about the story and it's just about the physical location
- [03/30/13 04:07:21] <@Perri> Yeah, this one is for them to decide, the story is our main concern
- 01[03/30/13 04:07:28] <@Bela> and in that case
- 01[03/30/13 04:07:35] <@Bela> maybe they should be coming up with region on their own
- 01[03/30/13 04:07:53] <@Bela> cuz we don't really have any basis in choosing part of Scotland other than it looks good :p
- [03/30/13 04:08:01] <@Perri> Or Norway XD
- [03/30/13 04:08:17] <@Perri> Yeah, we can present those as ideas but say "Ultimately, the choice is up to you guys"
- 01[03/30/13 04:08:35] <@Bela> yeah, we should continue having these chats
- [03/30/13 04:08:41] <@Perri> Definitely!
- 01[03/30/13 04:08:42] <@Bela> and have it be with those guys now
- [03/30/13 04:09:26] <@Perri> I'm totally for that
- 01[03/30/13 04:09:45] <@Bela> okay, well I'm pretty tired myself
- [03/30/13 04:09:56] <@Darthatron> yeah
- [03/30/13 04:10:03] <@Darthatron> good jon guys
- [03/30/13 04:10:05] <@Darthatron> :)
- [03/30/13 04:10:11] <@Perri> XD
- [03/30/13 04:11:39] <@Perri> And thanks - even when we disagreed, it was always civilly, and things worked out well. I feel accomplished :)
- 01[03/30/13 04:13:08] <@Bela> yep
- [03/30/13 04:16:28] <@Darthatron> go team
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement