r8 r3views may-august '19

LIKE:
2018 Speed Run - better variant of a 2018 ep
2018 Art / Synth Pop Excellence - all of these were decently big on the sub, plus all 3 did AMAs which is cute
2000s Guys rate - one of my ideas, neyo is filler but the other two deserve to be rated 100%
2000's Hip Hop starter pack - this would be long but 2000s hip hop is a blind spot that i think would be decently popular
2018 Women in Hip Hop - female rap rate is another blind spot we've had
2010 Faves of Popheads Rate - one of my ideas
2010's Blockbuster Musical Rate - one of my ideas
2015 Alternative Pop Rate - long overdue, would get like 100 participants tbh
ARK Music Factory & Friends Rate - whew the bops jumped
The Lilith Fair Rate - we need more 90s rates
1980s Dancepop Debuts Rate - this is potentially the best idea here
Summer Vibes Rate - omg i love this, v good summer rate idea
2018 UK Main Pop Girls - one of my ideas
Billboard Soundtrack #1s - one of my ideas
2018 Hip Hop: Choose Your Own Rate Edition - one of my ideas
PC Music & Friends Rate - PC music is huge on the sub so i think they deserve a rate finally
The Ultimate Bands Greatest Hits Rate - best greatest hits idea
2017 Electropopflops - this would get a lot of participants
The Ex-Acts Are Back - overdue
Billboard's #1 Songs of the Summer Rate - this is potentially the best idea here [2]
Women Who Rock: Rock-inspired Albums of the 2010’s - i have no preference between this and the 2015 variant
1D Solo Rate - This Is Us 2: The Grudge Match - overdue

MID:
2018 Indie Pop We Liked! - kinda niche
The 2018 EP Rate - i like the other idea better
Indie Synth-Pop Debuts Rate - maybe someday but i don't see this being in high demand rn
deathmatch: charli xcx v. tove lo? - i go back and forth on this one, its cute and novel but i also like other ideas with the 4 albums
The Future of Pop - pop 2 and SOPHIE obv deserve but i think we should wait for a better 3rd
Silly Songs: The ’90s Bubblegum Dance Rate - kinda niche [2]
The Early 2010’s Pop Rock Band Rate - where is onerepublic
Attack Of The Club Boom - where are flo rida or pitbull
Emo Rate II: The Re-Up - its been a long time since the first emo rate but i still dont get the sense that ppl are clamoring for another
Disney's Golden Generation - i think a rate with HSM/etc would be more popular
The Sons of Korea: The 3rd Gen K-Pop Boy Groups Singles - i am not well informed enough on kpop to know if this is good or not
Commercial / Pop House of the 2010s Rate - galantis is a bit niche
Modern Cult-Following Electronic Masterpieces Rate - i personally like this but would people actually do it
Skinny Country Women at the Turn of the Decade (AKA Blonde Yee Haw Ladies' Third Albums Rate) - i think speak now deserves a rate but we fucking want Blown Away and Four The Record instead
Todd in the Shadows' One Hit Wonderland Rate - 80s vh1 >>
2018's Pop-Rock Triumphs - idk how many people would actually sit down and do this
May 2018 Pop Boy Masterpieces - james bay? i like him but does anyone else on the sub
Pop Boys of 2018 - JT doesn't fit Shawn/Charlie imo
Early '10s Dance Pop Divas on Decline - it makes sense but i dont feel like we need a main pop girl rate so desperately that this should be picked
Indie Pop Rock Rate - where is contra (and i don't even like that album!)

DISLIKE:
Popheads Idol - :unamused:
The What Broadway Musical Should I Spend $200 on Rate - nobody would do this
Synthpop Queens Rate - i think its weird that we did CHVRCHES debut vs Purity Ring sophomore and now to do CHVRCHES sophomore vs Purity Ring debut
The Svenskpop Rate - whomstve
Greatest Pop Hits Rate - matchup doesnt make a lot of sense to me, even less than Abba vs Madonna vs Queen did
Self-Titled Sex Symbols - junky
Ladies of 2018 R&B Rate - junky + too short
New Blondes of Pop - let's wait for the albums
00s Billboard Female #1s - glorified all-stars
Minecraft Parody Rate - there are other meme rates that should take precedent
2010s Ultimate Male: Flop Edition - divide and doo wop were extremely successful tho ??
Every Rihanna single ranked. - no
Futuristic Commercial Flops - robyn would destroy
/r/music-core Rate - there are other meme rates that should take precedent [2]
The Ultimate Big Big Beat Rate - wayyy too niche
The Shaken Not Stirred Rate - too long for how niche it is
The Twilight Saga Rate - too long for how niche it is [2]
The Pop Girl Breakouts Rate - glorified all-stars [2]
The "New" Pop Girls Rate - idgi