Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Sep 27th, 2015
320
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 101.01 KB | None | 0 0
  1. 14:12:31 NEW CHATROOM: groupchat-disjunction-nuvr
  2. 14:12:31 |J|#Disjunction
  3. 14:13:29 |raw|<div class="broadcast-red"><b>Moderated chat was set to +!</b><br />Only users of rank + and higher can talk.</div>
  4. 14:14:37 |J|&raseri
  5. 14:15:04 |c|#Disjunction|mont said he'll be here in 2 or 3 minutes
  6. 14:15:12 |c|#Disjunction|idk when holly will show up
  7. 14:15:23 |c|#Disjunction|etc etc everyone johns D:
  8. 14:16:23 |c|&raseri|D:
  9. 14:18:28 |raw|<div class="broadcast-red"><b>Moderated chat was set to %!</b><br />Only users of rank % and higher can talk.</div>
  10. 14:19:56 |J|+Montsegur
  11. 14:20:02 Montsegur was promoted to Room Moderator by Disjunction.
  12. 14:20:02 |N|@Montsegur|montsegur
  13. 14:20:16 |c|@Montsegur|I thought we were waiting for the wood
  14. 14:20:27 |c|@Montsegur|soo I thought I had till like 11:30
  15. 14:20:32 |c|#Disjunction|ya let's wait until
  16. 14:20:36 |c|@Montsegur|which means I could of played some sexbox
  17. 14:20:37 |c|#Disjunction|at least one person shows up
  18. 14:20:39 |c|&raseri|free kiyo
  19. 14:20:44 |c|#Disjunction|free kiyo
  20. 14:20:45 |c|@Montsegur|kiyo is a facade
  21. 14:20:54 |c|@Montsegur|and overthinks things
  22. 14:20:59 |c|@Montsegur|vanilluxe to S
  23. 14:21:06 |c|@Montsegur|what more does this discussion need?
  24. 14:21:08 |raw|<div class="broadcast-blue"><b>vanilluxe to s</b></div>
  25. 14:21:19 |c|@Montsegur|raseri make me RO
  26. 14:21:24 |c|@Montsegur|and yourself
  27. 14:21:27 |c|&raseri|nvr
  28. 14:21:28 |c|&raseri|haha
  29. 14:21:34 |c|@Montsegur|..
  30. 14:22:15 |c|&raseri|//roomowner - This room isn't designed for per-room moderation to be added
  31. 14:22:18 |c|&raseri|i cant
  32. 14:22:21 |c|@Montsegur|o
  33. 14:22:30 |c|@Montsegur|make me RO in art
  34. 14:22:31 |userstats|total:3|guests:0| :0|+:0|%:0|@:1|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:0
  35. 14:22:31 |c|@Montsegur|imo
  36. 14:22:33 |c|@Montsegur|:^)
  37. 14:22:55 |c|#Disjunction|I invited waters and deej over skype
  38. 14:22:59 |c|#Disjunction|idk if they'll show tho
  39. 14:23:06 |c|@Montsegur|when should i Link this
  40. 14:23:08 |c|@Montsegur|haha
  41. 14:23:09 |c|@Montsegur|link
  42. 14:23:20 |c|#Disjunction|I'll link it once we start
  43. 14:23:25 |c|#Disjunction|which is when we get one more person
  44. 14:23:31 |c|#Disjunction|and probably holly
  45. 14:23:38 |c|#Disjunction|I think he'd be pissed if we started without him
  46. 14:25:45 |c|@Montsegur|if he doesn't show up in the next 15 minutes tho
  47. 14:26:20 |c|#Disjunction|if anyone doesn't show up in the next 15 minutes tho*
  48. 14:27:12 |J| Realistic Waters
  49. 14:27:22 |J|+Kiyo
  50. 14:27:27 Kiyo was promoted to Room Moderator by Disjunction.
  51. 14:27:27 |N|@Kiyo|kiyo
  52. 14:27:29 |c|@Kiyo|guys im here
  53. 14:27:31 Realistic Waters was promoted to Room Moderator by Disjunction.
  54. 14:27:31 |N|@Realistic Waters|realisticwaters
  55. 14:27:31 |c|@Kiyo|we can start
  56. 14:27:33 |c|@Realistic Waters|:)
  57. 14:27:34 |c|#Disjunction|thank goodness
  58. 14:27:39 |c|#Disjunction|k I'm going to go and
  59. 14:27:42 |c|@Kiyo|where is holly
  60. 14:27:43 |c|#Disjunction|advertise to the masses
  61. 14:27:47 |c|&raseri|:)
  62. 14:27:49 |c|#Disjunction|he's doing something for work??
  63. 14:27:51 |c|&raseri|free holly
  64. 14:27:53 |c|#Disjunction|idk he should be here soon
  65. 14:27:58 |c|@Kiyo|didnt he say he'd be here around now
  66. 14:28:03 |c|&raseri|give him 10 mins
  67. 14:28:06 |c|&raseri|imo
  68. 14:28:07 |c|@Kiyo|i mean i made u niggas wait while i went to starbucks
  69. 14:28:14 |c|&raseri|kuk fiyo
  70. 14:28:14 |c|@Montsegur|he said he'd be here 20 minutes ago
  71. 14:28:21 |c|@Kiyo|o
  72. 14:28:21 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo we weren't waiting for you
  73. 14:28:23 |c|@Kiyo|nvm then
  74. 14:28:23 |c|&raseri|owell
  75. 14:28:25 |c|@Kiyo|fuck him
  76. 14:28:27 |c|&raseri|D:
  77. 14:28:29 |c|@Montsegur|we were were waiting for someone relevant
  78. 14:28:30 |c|&raseri|what if he pulls
  79. 14:28:32 |c|&raseri|a tennisace
  80. 14:28:34 |c|&raseri|ie: nupl
  81. 14:28:34 |c|@Kiyo|nah start at 11:30 tho
  82. 14:28:39 |c|&raseri|and quits as TL
  83. 14:28:44 |c|&raseri|D:
  84. 14:28:47 |c|@Montsegur|D:
  85. 14:28:49 |J|+Sir Kay
  86. 14:28:50 |c|@Kiyo|raseri im 90% sure i want that
  87. 14:28:58 |c|@Kiyo|10% unsure tho
  88. 14:29:00 |J| Pokeymon Playa
  89. 14:29:01 |c|@Kiyo|D:
  90. 14:29:07 |c|@Montsegur|kiyo
  91. 14:29:08 |c|&raseri|we would have to
  92. 14:29:09 |c|@Montsegur|lets meet up
  93. 14:29:09 |c|&raseri|add a new TL
  94. 14:29:10 |c|#Disjunction|wanna wait for holly, then?
  95. 14:29:12 |c|@Montsegur|in portland
  96. 14:29:13 |c|&raseri|ya
  97. 14:29:16 |c|&raseri|lets wait 10 mins
  98. 14:29:18 |c|@Kiyo|yeah dude im down
  99. 14:29:19 |c|#Disjunction|ok
  100. 14:29:20 |c|&raseri|and build
  101. 14:29:21 |c|&raseri|some hype
  102. 14:29:26 |c|&raseri|Disjunction want to meet up
  103. 14:29:26 |c|@Kiyo|have to find a weekend where i dont have a meet
  104. 14:29:27 |raw|<div class="broadcast-blue"><b>hype</b></div>
  105. 14:29:28 |c|&raseri|in hong kong
  106. 14:29:28 |c|@Montsegur|I can skip things on the weekend
  107. 14:29:31 |c|#Disjunction|y
  108. 14:29:34 |c|&raseri|its inconvenient
  109. 14:29:36 |c|&raseri|for bothy of us
  110. 14:29:37 |c|@Montsegur|so im good whenever just give me a heads up
  111. 14:29:46 |J| BlazikenAltIV
  112. 14:29:51 |c|@Montsegur|as long as Disjunction doesn't have to drive there
  113. 14:29:52 |c|@Realistic Waters|Sir Kay lets meet up
  114. 14:29:55 |c|@Realistic Waters|im only like 2000 miles away xd
  115. 14:29:59 |c|&raseri|xd
  116. 14:29:59 |N| Blaziken1337|blazikenaltiv
  117. 14:30:08 |c|&raseri|no one lives near me
  118. 14:30:09 |c|&raseri|:s
  119. 14:30:20 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction if you fly there I don't think I can fix the front bumper of your plane
  120. 14:30:28 |c|@Montsegur|I'm not familiar with aeronautics
  121. 14:30:30 (Montsegur was demoted to Room Voice by Disjunction.)
  122. 14:30:30 |N|+Montsegur|montsegur
  123. 14:30:32 |c|@Kiyo|raseri where are you alberta?
  124. 14:30:41 |c|@Kiyo|thats only a 200$ plane ride
  125. 14:30:43 |c|&raseri|edmonton area
  126. 14:30:44 Montsegur was promoted to Room Moderator by Disjunction.
  127. 14:30:44 |N|@Montsegur|montsegur
  128. 14:30:48 |c|@Kiyo|err
  129. 14:30:50 |J| FredMercury
  130. 14:30:51 |c|@Kiyo|yeah edmonton
  131. 14:30:51 |c|@Montsegur|lmao
  132. 14:30:53 |c|@Kiyo|thats what i meant
  133. 14:31:00 |c|@Montsegur|where is alberta
  134. 14:31:00 |c|&raseri|im not in edmonton
  135. 14:31:01 |c|&raseri|but im near it
  136. 14:31:04 |c|&raseri|north of montana
  137. 14:31:05 |c|&raseri|!!
  138. 14:31:05 |c|@Montsegur|in relation to vancouver
  139. 14:31:06 |L| FredMercury
  140. 14:31:08 |c|&raseri|east
  141. 14:31:12 |c|&raseri|next province over
  142. 14:31:14 |c|@Kiyo|like 150 miles east
  143. 14:31:20 |c|&raseri|more than that
  144. 14:31:22 |c|@Kiyo|no way.
  145. 14:31:27 |c|@Montsegur|so since vancouver is in canada you can realisticly get there
  146. 14:31:30 |c|@Montsegur|easily
  147. 14:31:34 |c|&raseri|well maybe not
  148. 14:31:35 |c|&raseri|idk
  149. 14:31:36 |c|&raseri|with roads
  150. 14:31:38 |c|&raseri|it would be more
  151. 14:31:42 |c|&raseri|unless you go through USA
  152. 14:31:42 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo I hear we can get beer in canada when we aren't 21
  153. 14:31:43 |c|@Montsegur|:O
  154. 14:31:49 |c|@Kiyo|ok its 700 miles
  155. 14:31:57 |c|@Kiyo|so what i dont know canada
  156. 14:32:02 |c|@Kiyo|but montsegur im 21 D:
  157. 14:32:02 |c|@Montsegur|raseri how far to vancouver is it for you?
  158. 14:32:06 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo im 22
  159. 14:32:10 |c|&raseri|a long time
  160. 14:32:22 |c|@Realistic Waters|free deej dy
  161. 14:32:23 |J| GyRro
  162. 14:32:31 |c|&raseri|12 hour drive
  163. 14:32:31 |userstats|total:9|guests:0| :3|+:1|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:0
  164. 14:32:34 |c|&raseri|but i dont have a car
  165. 14:32:35 |c|&raseri|haha
  166. 14:32:38 |c|#Disjunction|I messaged deej on skype and he hasn't responded D:
  167. 14:32:43 |c|@Montsegur|13 hour drive
  168. 14:32:43 |c|@Kiyo|isnt deej Pokeymon Playa
  169. 14:32:46 |c|#Disjunction|half of council hasn't responded
  170. 14:32:47 |c|#Disjunction|tbf
  171. 14:32:48 |c|&raseri|73 hr bike ride
  172. 14:32:51 |c|&raseri|to vancouvewr
  173. 14:32:56 |c|@Montsegur|you dont have a car
  174. 14:33:12 |c|#Disjunction|73 hours of bike riding
  175. 14:33:13 |c|&raseri|1.5 hr plane ride
  176. 14:33:13 |c|&raseri|but
  177. 14:33:15 |c|&raseri|expensive
  178. 14:33:16 |c|#Disjunction|sounds like honestly a lot of fun
  179. 14:33:23 |c|@Montsegur|227$
  180. 14:33:25 |c|@Montsegur|round trip
  181. 14:33:27 |c|#Disjunction|assuming I can still sleep and eat
  182. 14:33:33 |c|&raseri|actually not that bad
  183. 14:33:37 |c|&raseri|$300 CAD
  184. 14:33:38 |c|&raseri|round trip
  185. 14:33:41 |c|&raseri|our dollar sucks
  186. 14:33:42 |c|&raseri|rn
  187. 14:33:46 |c|@Montsegur|fuck canada's money
  188. 14:34:04 |c|@Montsegur|and when you go to canada and are like i only have dollars they are like pay canadian price
  189. 14:34:17 |c|@Montsegur|which is like 4$ added on
  190. 14:34:24 |c|&raseri|o its cheaper to fly from calgary
  191. 14:34:26 |c|&raseri|use our mo9ney
  192. 14:34:27 |c|&raseri|money
  193. 14:34:28 |c|&raseri|fuker
  194. 14:34:30 |c|&raseri|we dont want yours
  195. 14:34:37 |c|@Montsegur|mine is clean
  196. 14:34:43 |c|@Montsegur|from the cartel
  197. 14:34:53 |c|&raseri|our maple syrup cartel runs the country
  198. 14:34:54 |c|&raseri|:s
  199. 14:35:03 |c|@Montsegur|in case you didn't know I cook and distribute methamphetamines
  200. 14:35:08 |J| Super Sonic Bros
  201. 14:35:15 |c|@Montsegur|I live in New Mexico when I dont go to college now
  202. 14:35:37 |c|&raseri|!
  203. 14:35:48 |L| Super Sonic Bros
  204. 14:35:57 |J| Jariibo
  205. 14:35:59 |c|@Kiyo|my old chemistry teacher moved to new mexico couple years back
  206. 14:36:07 |c|@Kiyo|i heard he has terminal cancer now :/
  207. 14:36:14 |c|&raseri|xd
  208. 14:36:27 |c|@Kiyo|why is cancer funny raseri
  209. 14:36:30 |c|@Kiyo|god i hate you
  210. 14:36:32 |c|&raseri|cause
  211. 14:36:33 |c|@Kiyo|insensitive fuck
  212. 14:36:34 |c|@Montsegur|breaking bad was actually a true story about me
  213. 14:36:36 |c|&raseri|im insensitive
  214. 14:36:39 |c|@Montsegur|I didn't have cancer tho
  215. 14:36:41 |c|&raseri|im autistic
  216. 14:36:42 |c|&raseri|:s
  217. 14:36:44 |c|@Montsegur|they added that in for the flare
  218. 14:36:56 |c|#Disjunction|oh good thinking Kiyo
  219. 14:37:05 |c|#Disjunction|advertising the discussion about the thread
  220. 14:37:07 |c|@Kiyo|i never watched better call saul after ep 4
  221. 14:37:07 |c|#Disjunction|in the thread itself
  222. 14:37:11 |c|#Disjunction|that's next level
  223. 14:37:11 |c|@Montsegur|I was going to post there
  224. 14:37:12 |c|@Kiyo|is it any good?
  225. 14:37:13 |c|@Montsegur|when we started
  226. 14:37:17 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  227. 14:37:18 |c|&raseri|i never watched episode 1
  228. 14:37:21 |c|@Montsegur|better call saul is p good
  229. 14:37:27 |c|@Kiyo|roomban raseri isnt working disjunction
  230. 14:37:29 |c|@Kiyo|HELP
  231. 14:37:42 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction voice raseri
  232. 14:37:43 |c|&raseri|i cant roomban me
  233. 14:37:44 |c|&raseri|either
  234. 14:37:50 |c|@Montsegur|he deserves it
  235. 14:37:59 |c|&raseri|come on holly
  236. 14:38:00 |c|#Disjunction|I would roomban people as a joke but it's a pain to get back to these rooms so I won't D:
  237. 14:38:45 |J|+Megazard
  238. 14:38:47 |J| the tangy
  239. 14:38:55 |N| the tangy|thetangy
  240. 14:39:02 |J| fuck im high69
  241. 14:39:04 |J| ElegyOfVGC
  242. 14:39:06 |J| Frogeggs
  243. 14:39:30 |J| Chef Rice
  244. 14:39:35 |J| thelaughingbrother
  245. 14:39:38 |c|@Kiyo|ok holly isn't here
  246. 14:39:41 |c|@Kiyo|lets get started
  247. 14:39:42 |c|&raseri|^
  248. 14:39:45 |c|@Realistic Waters|^
  249. 14:39:48 |c|@Montsegur|v
  250. 14:39:55 |c|#Disjunction|rip
  251. 14:39:59 |c|#Disjunction|ok
  252. 14:40:08 |c|#Disjunction|so idc about being formal about this
  253. 14:40:14 |c|#Disjunction|so let's just discuss the first topic
  254. 14:40:19 |L| Jariibo
  255. 14:40:21 |c|@Montsegur|pastebin it
  256. 14:40:23 |c|@Montsegur|nigga
  257. 14:40:33 |c|&raseri|:s
  258. 14:40:35 |c|@Kiyo|:s
  259. 14:40:37 |c|@Realistic Waters|s:
  260. 14:41:06 |J|~Hollywood
  261. 14:41:12 |J| Gargamod
  262. 14:41:18 |c|#Disjunction|/announce http://pastebin.com/RpxYmJR8
  263. 14:41:22 |c|#Disjunction|this is our list of topics
  264. 14:41:28 |c|#Disjunction|with my thoughts on it too
  265. 14:41:30 |N|~hollywood|hollywood
  266. 14:41:31 |c|~hollywood|why are you announcing it lol
  267. 14:41:32 |c|#Disjunction|but y'know it's just notes
  268. 14:41:36 |c|#Disjunction|because I like
  269. 14:41:38 |c|#Disjunction|blue text
  270. 14:41:51 |c|&raseri|hi holly
  271. 14:41:59 |c|~hollywood|me
  272. 14:42:03 |c|&raseri|disjunction you lead this
  273. 14:42:08 |c|&raseri|im a follower
  274. 14:42:09 |c|#Disjunction|so the first point of discussion is converting the ranks
  275. 14:42:13 |c|#Disjunction|to the way doubs does theirs
  276. 14:42:31 |userstats|total:18|guests:0| :10|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  277. 14:42:34 |c|@Kiyo|i'm in favor of doing so
  278. 14:42:34 |c|#Disjunction|For reference: http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/doubles-ou-viability-rankings.3535930/
  279. 14:42:34 |N| lolbro|thelaughingbrother
  280. 14:42:37 |c|@Montsegur|I thought the point was there was something wrong
  281. 14:42:38 |c|~hollywood|lol my niece and nephew are watching little einsteins an they just showed a piece of tchaicovsky music and im like why lol
  282. 14:42:39 |c|@Kiyo|i think the current way we rank mons
  283. 14:42:44 |c|@Kiyo|i.e. a, b, c
  284. 14:42:44 |c|&raseri|what i like about the dubs system is it gives a place for pokemon that define a specific playstyle
  285. 14:42:48 |c|&raseri|but arent as useful outside of it
  286. 14:42:51 |c|~hollywood|is exactly the same as the way dubs does?
  287. 14:42:52 |J| BIGHypnotize
  288. 14:42:56 |c|@Kiyo|skews peoples ideas of how good a mon should be
  289. 14:43:04 |c|~hollywood|in what way exactly is a, b, c different from 1, 1.5, 2
  290. 14:43:06 |c|@Kiyo|i think it should be modeled after not exactly the same
  291. 14:43:06 |J| tv4c
  292. 14:43:08 |L| lolbro
  293. 14:43:12 |c|~hollywood|one is numbers one is letters
  294. 14:43:12 |c|@Montsegur|so then why don't we make our own system / adapt definitions
  295. 14:43:21 |c|&raseri|its more of the definitions
  296. 14:43:22 |c|&raseri|i think
  297. 14:43:23 |c|#Disjunction|I don't think there would be much of a change if we swapped to doubs ranks
  298. 14:43:24 |c|@Kiyo|because if you tell someone something is D rank
  299. 14:43:34 |c|@Kiyo|and if you tell them its rank 4
  300. 14:43:38 |c|@Kiyo|rank 4 sounds less harsh
  301. 14:43:39 |c|@Kiyo|imo
  302. 14:43:52 |c|@Montsegur|so then they'd be more likely to use mediocre mons
  303. 14:43:55 |c|@Kiyo|idk its subjective but its better than people using school grades as a basis for what a mon should be
  304. 14:43:57 |c|~hollywood|yes because it's not as easy to understand
  305. 14:43:58 |c|~hollywood|lol
  306. 14:44:02 |c|~hollywood|it should sound harsh
  307. 14:44:03 |c|@Montsegur|which you said was part of the problem
  308. 14:44:05 |c|~hollywood|those pokemon are not very good
  309. 14:44:07 |J| lolbro
  310. 14:44:09 |c|&raseri|i really just prefer the definitions
  311. 14:44:12 |c|&raseri|idc about letters vs numbers
  312. 14:44:16 |c|@Kiyo|but our rankings arent harsh enough right now
  313. 14:44:21 |c|@Montsegur|yah definitions are out of date
  314. 14:44:21 |c|~hollywood|so let's fix that
  315. 14:44:21 |c|@Kiyo|we have fucking 42 A rank mons
  316. 14:44:25 |c|@Kiyo|and we all know
  317. 14:44:36 |c|#Disjunction|Like I said on the paste, I think NU's meta should cater more towards how we have a bigger range of viable options
  318. 14:44:38 |c|@Montsegur|i agree Kiyo, but then you and everyone else says this mon should go up
  319. 14:44:39 |c|@Kiyo|there arent THAT many good mons
  320. 14:44:41 |c|#Disjunction|the Doubs list doesn't do that and just
  321. 14:44:44 |c|#Disjunction|mushes everything together
  322. 14:44:53 |c|&raseri|musharna
  323. 14:44:54 |c|#Disjunction|we could go with less specific ranks
  324. 14:44:59 |c|@Montsegur|there are more good mons in this tier imo then there are in other tiers
  325. 14:45:03 |c|#Disjunction|like A/A-, B/B-
  326. 14:45:09 |c|@Realistic Waters|i like the idea of less specific ranks
  327. 14:45:12 |c|~hollywood|there's an inherent and ignored problem with viability rankings
  328. 14:45:14 |c|~hollywood|which is mainly
  329. 14:45:17 |c|#Disjunction|but that wouldn't address Kiyo's concern
  330. 14:45:19 |L|+Megazard
  331. 14:45:21 |c|#Disjunction|about it sounding harsh
  332. 14:45:21 |c|~hollywood|pokemon aren't directly comparable
  333. 14:45:26 |c|~hollywood|and that's what the VR thread does
  334. 14:45:43 |c|@Kiyo|i tried bringing up a "vr in a vaccuum" philosophy a while ago
  335. 14:45:48 |c|@Kiyo|and it just makes things more difficult
  336. 14:45:48 |c|&raseri|so what can we do to fix that
  337. 14:45:53 |c|@Kiyo|on some level you have to compare mons
  338. 14:45:59 |c|@Montsegur|the vr is based upon the current meta
  339. 14:46:02 |c|~hollywood|there's really no way to do that
  340. 14:46:11 |c|~hollywood|yes but the current meta
  341. 14:46:17 |c|~hollywood|is also subjectiv
  342. 14:46:18 |c|~hollywood|e
  343. 14:46:19 |c|@Montsegur|like rhdyon might be S in this one but not S in a different one
  344. 14:46:26 |c|~hollywood|and constantly changing
  345. 14:46:35 |c|@Kiyo|we could make more objective requirements
  346. 14:46:39 |c|&raseri|so we just need to change things
  347. 14:46:39 |c|#Disjunction|maybe we should be evaluating each mon instead of comparing them
  348. 14:46:42 |c|&raseri|when the meta changes
  349. 14:46:43 |c|&raseri|hm
  350. 14:46:52 |c|~hollywood|well the meta changes
  351. 14:46:56 |c|~hollywood|every game
  352. 14:46:59 |L| BIGHypnotize
  353. 14:47:04 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction I don't compare the mons to the other mons in the rank I compare them to the letter
  354. 14:47:12 |c|@Kiyo|ideally that should work
  355. 14:47:15 |c|@Kiyo|but no one else does that
  356. 14:47:19 |c|@Montsegur|ik
  357. 14:47:35 |J| Jariibo
  358. 14:47:36 |c|#Disjunction|ok ok so we're getting off track from the first topic
  359. 14:47:36 |L| Jariibo
  360. 14:47:38 |c|@Kiyo|we could simply start shooting down requests if they dont meet objective requirements or explain themselves in the post
  361. 14:47:39 |c|~hollywood|i mean even on any given team
  362. 14:47:52 |c|#Disjunction|is the general consensus that changing to the doubs ranks wouldn't fix any inherent problems?
  363. 14:47:54 |c|~hollywood|one pokemon could fit the definition better than another and be lower ranked
  364. 14:48:01 |c|@Kiyo|i mean on any given team a mon can be S rank as well
  365. 14:48:06 |c|#Disjunction|all I've heard in favor of it is that it sounds less harsh
  366. 14:48:23 |c|&raseri|i like that it gives a place for mons that define specific playstyles
  367. 14:48:24 |c|~hollywood|who cares about harshness
  368. 14:48:30 |c|@Montsegur|I don't see how there is really enough of a difference or how its really fixing the real problem
  369. 14:48:30 |c|~hollywood|as long as the rankings are accurate
  370. 14:48:32 |c|@Kiyo|everyone who posts in the vr
  371. 14:48:33 |c|&raseri|but arent as useful outside of that
  372. 14:48:33 |c|@Kiyo|cares
  373. 14:48:39 |c|~hollywood|ok but why
  374. 14:48:45 |J| Pokedots
  375. 14:48:47 |c|@Kiyo|no one actually cares about an accurate representation of the meta
  376. 14:48:50 |c|@Kiyo|and thats the first problem
  377. 14:48:55 |c|~hollywood|why should we not be harsh on relicanth
  378. 14:48:56 |c|#Disjunction|yea it sounds like an aesthetic change to me
  379. 14:49:01 |c|@Kiyo|people only care about there shit mons getting ranks
  380. 14:49:02 |c|~hollywood|or frillish
  381. 14:49:04 |c|~hollywood|etc
  382. 14:49:17 |c|@Kiyo|we should be harsh on relicanth
  383. 14:49:22 |c|@Kiyo|idk why its C+ or w.e it is now
  384. 14:49:25 |c|~hollywood|it's D
  385. 14:49:25 |c|#Disjunction|it's D
  386. 14:49:27 |c|@Realistic Waters|yeah
  387. 14:49:29 |c|~hollywood|that's why i brought it up
  388. 14:49:35 |L| ElegyOfVGC
  389. 14:49:41 |c|#Disjunction|once we address over inflation I'd like to talk about unranking it, though
  390. 14:49:44 |c|@Kiyo|lemme take a look at the vr right quick
  391. 14:49:44 |c|@Montsegur|idc if we do dubs or stick to the current way or make up a new way as long as we are able to show people that certain ranks mean a certain thing
  392. 14:49:46 |c|&raseri|i like relicanth
  393. 14:49:47 |c|&raseri|:s
  394. 14:49:50 |c|@Montsegur|and that they aren't comparable to other mons
  395. 14:49:51 |c|@Realistic Waters|I like Frillish
  396. 14:49:56 |J| METAPHYSICAL
  397. 14:49:58 |c|~hollywood|anything raseri likes should probably be D rank anyways
  398. 14:50:01 |c|&raseri|^
  399. 14:50:06 |c|&raseri|faier
  400. 14:50:07 |c|&raseri|fair
  401. 14:50:11 |c|@Kiyo|like why do we have shit like
  402. 14:50:26 |c|@Kiyo|rapidash ranked at C+
  403. 14:50:43 |c|~hollywood|because on paper it's a fine pokemon
  404. 14:50:46 |c|@Kiyo|like the majority of C- rank
  405. 14:50:48 |c|~hollywood|it fits the definition of C rank
  406. 14:50:50 |c|@Kiyo|deserves to be unranked
  407. 14:50:54 |c|#Disjunction|because comparable to other Pokemon in C+ right now it's effective
  408. 14:51:06 |c|#Disjunction|but if we had a list that was representative of what C should actually be
  409. 14:51:08 |c|&raseri|the d rank mons
  410. 14:51:08 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo I've done that and then you've literally said oh its fine if we rank those mons
  411. 14:51:08 |c|~hollywood|i dont think anything in C- deserves to be unranked
  412. 14:51:09 |c|#Disjunction|it should be D max
  413. 14:51:10 |c|@Montsegur|;;;;
  414. 14:51:11 |c|&raseri|are better than c-
  415. 14:51:16 |c|~hollywood|not exaggerating, none of those pokemon are unviable
  416. 14:51:21 |c|@Kiyo|i mean i would prefer the ranking of more poekmon
  417. 14:51:23 |c|@Kiyo|than less
  418. 14:51:23 |c|~hollywood|and a few of them are good
  419. 14:51:27 |c|@Kiyo|but in order for that to work
  420. 14:51:32 |c|@Montsegur|hollywood i agree, people just think if its not A then its bad
  421. 14:51:32 |c|@Kiyo|we need to expand the rankings
  422. 14:51:39 |c|@Kiyo|cuz we have way mroe "viable shit"
  423. 14:51:48 |c|&raseri|we could add a rank near the bottom for niche choices
  424. 14:51:50 |c|&raseri|that are viable
  425. 14:51:58 |c|@Kiyo|like i agree C- mons can be used and made effective
  426. 14:52:09 |c|@Kiyo|but for the vast majority of teams and circumstances
  427. 14:52:11 |c|@Montsegur|ok so what it sounds like is since we have way more viable shit then other metas we need to come up with a way to convey that
  428. 14:52:12 |c|&raseri|things that can work but you probably shouldnt use unless you really need it
  429. 14:52:12 |c|@Kiyo|they shouldnt be used
  430. 14:52:24 |c|&raseri|kiyo rank
  431. 14:52:28 |J| Luck O' the Irish
  432. 14:52:31 |userstats|total:20|guests:0| :13|+:1|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  433. 14:52:33 |c|#Disjunction|I think what NU is inherently struggling with compared to other tiers is that we have so much shit that could function very well just on the premise of their typing
  434. 14:52:37 |c|~hollywood|we have a way to convey that
  435. 14:52:39 |c|~hollywood|it's called D rank
  436. 14:52:42 |c|@Kiyo|like dude whens the last time you saw anyone use a vullaby
  437. 14:52:48 |c|&raseri|early XY
  438. 14:52:49 |c|@Montsegur|I saw FLCL use one
  439. 14:52:51 |c|@Montsegur|once
  440. 14:52:52 |c|@Kiyo|how often do you have to see a mon used to even know if it works
  441. 14:52:59 |c|~hollywood|i used it on stall a while back
  442. 14:53:02 |c|@Kiyo|like i legitimately have not seen vullaby since early xy
  443. 14:53:04 |c|@Montsegur|its not a bad mon
  444. 14:53:07 |c|~hollywood|it's the best lilligant counter in the tier
  445. 14:53:09 |c|~hollywood|and a defogger
  446. 14:53:11 |c|@Montsegur|its just not good
  447. 14:53:11 |c|~hollywood|also beats shiftry
  448. 14:53:14 |c|@Kiyo|its not a bad mon, but would you ever consider it for a team
  449. 14:53:21 |c|@Montsegur|yes
  450. 14:53:21 |c|@Kiyo|do you think its viable in the meta
  451. 14:53:22 |c|~hollywood|why not
  452. 14:53:22 |c|&raseri|only on very specific teams
  453. 14:53:28 |c|~hollywood|it's pelipper but with different resistances
  454. 14:53:48 |c|@Montsegur|if the team I was building needed soemthing to remove hazards and stop lillligant / shiftry
  455. 14:53:52 |c|@Montsegur|then yes I would use it
  456. 14:53:52 |c|&raseri|nu has to many viable pokemon
  457. 14:53:54 |c|~hollywood|the only reason why i think pelipper is a "better" pokemon outside of the different resistances is because of scald
  458. 14:54:01 |c|~hollywood|but foul play isn'
  459. 14:54:04 |c|~hollywood|t far off
  460. 14:54:05 |c|#Disjunction|yeah NU has tons of viable pokemon
  461. 14:54:11 |c|#Disjunction|so how do we represent that in our list
  462. 14:54:14 |c|@Kiyo|we have plenty of viable pokemon
  463. 14:54:15 |c|#Disjunction|without over inflation
  464. 14:54:16 |L| METAPHYSICAL
  465. 14:54:17 |c|~hollywood|by moving things to D
  466. 14:54:21 |c|&raseri|strict definitions
  467. 14:54:22 |c|&raseri|and using d rank
  468. 14:54:26 |c|@Kiyo|are we trying to represent mons that can be used if they fulfill a specific niche
  469. 14:54:31 |c|@Montsegur|I think we need to expand our rankings and move from a different system
  470. 14:54:33 |c|@Kiyo|or are we accurately trying to represent the metagame
  471. 14:54:34 |c|~hollywood|if that niche is important enough
  472. 14:54:34 |c|~hollywood|sure
  473. 14:54:47 |c|&raseri|something like ban gay rank
  474. 14:54:49 |c|&raseri|ben
  475. 14:54:50 |c|~hollywood|there is no single metagame
  476. 14:54:58 |c|#Disjunction|I remember Nozzle mentioned splitting the list into maybe 2 or 3 separate lists
  477. 14:55:02 |c|~hollywood|tournament metagame is different from high ladder metagame is different from mid ladder metagame
  478. 14:55:07 |c|#Disjunction|like an Offensive VR and a Defensive VR
  479. 14:55:12 |c|~hollywood|and all of those are constantly fluctuating
  480. 14:55:13 |c|@Montsegur|I think that B up is representing the metagame and that even if a mon is bad in the meta but still good it falls to C
  481. 14:55:15 |c|@Kiyo|why are we not just catering to high level play
  482. 14:55:23 |c|@Kiyo|liek why do i give a fuck about low ladder meta
  483. 14:55:25 |c|~hollywood|high level play isnt even just one metagame
  484. 14:55:29 |c|@Montsegur|you can use those mons in high level play
  485. 14:55:40 |c|@Kiyo|high level tour play and high level ladder play are similar to a certain degree
  486. 14:55:42 |c|~hollywood|and we arent necessarily catering to non-high level play
  487. 14:55:47 |c|@Kiyo|but i agree taht tour level play
  488. 14:55:49 |c|~hollywood|my point is that there is no single metagame
  489. 14:55:53 |c|@Kiyo|you'll see way more lower ranked mons
  490. 14:56:06 |c|~hollywood|yea because consistency is less important in tours
  491. 14:56:18 |c|~hollywood|you have to win one game with any given team
  492. 14:56:18 |c|@Kiyo|ok so what is the point of having viability rankings
  493. 14:56:25 |c|#Disjunction|mons that aren't consistent are used in tours for counter picks, though
  494. 14:56:31 |J| HJAD
  495. 14:56:34 |c|#Disjunction|we shouldn't rank a mon because it's a good counter pick to something
  496. 14:56:38 |c|~hollywood|it's still important to have some way of representing what's good and what's not
  497. 14:56:42 |c|#Disjunction|well we shouldn't rate it highly anyways
  498. 14:56:44 |c|~hollywood|i never said we should
  499. 14:56:59 |c|#Disjunction|#Disjunction: I remember Nozzle mentioned splitting the list into maybe 2 or 3 separate lists
  500. 14:57:00 |c|#Disjunction|#Disjunction: like an Offensive VR and a Defensive VR
  501. 14:57:03 |J| Companeros
  502. 14:57:04 |c|&raseri|i dont like splitting it
  503. 14:57:05 |c|&raseri|:s
  504. 14:57:05 |c|~hollywood|but if your opponent spams offensive grass-types vullaby is a pretty high pick
  505. 14:57:07 |c|@Montsegur|me neither
  506. 14:57:14 |c|@Kiyo|i dont like splitting it
  507. 14:57:15 |c|~hollywood|splitting it is a really bad idea
  508. 14:57:20 |c|#Disjunction|how so
  509. 14:57:25 |c|~hollywood|people will be like "ok my team needs a defensive pokemon now"
  510. 14:57:34 |c|~hollywood|"mega audino is s rank in defensive vr so i'll put it on my team"
  511. 14:57:44 |c|&raseri|and it makes things harder for the average user
  512. 14:57:45 |c|~hollywood|it doesnt cater to the people who we are trying to help with the vr thread
  513. 14:57:48 |c|&raseri|having things in different place
  514. 14:58:00 |c|&raseri|it might be helpful for decent players
  515. 14:58:01 |c|&raseri|but
  516. 14:58:05 |c|@Kiyo|who are we trying to help with the vr thread
  517. 14:58:06 |c|&raseri|those are the ppl that dont really need the VR
  518. 14:58:08 |c|&raseri|in the first place
  519. 14:58:17 |c|~hollywood|and defensive teams rely more on synergy than they do using "good pokemon"
  520. 14:58:17 |c|#Disjunction|yeah ok
  521. 14:58:23 |c|@Montsegur|raseri those decent players from other tiers use the vr rankings when making teams
  522. 14:58:24 |L| HJAD
  523. 14:58:26 |c|#Disjunction|we're helping people who are trying to learn the tier
  524. 14:58:27 |c|@Kiyo|cuz by ranking shit like vullaby i dont really see you helping a new user to nu
  525. 14:58:31 |c|@Kiyo|maybe thats just me tho
  526. 14:58:33 |c|#Disjunction|whether they are experienced users looking in
  527. 14:58:36 |c|#Disjunction|or new users altogether
  528. 14:58:37 |c|@Montsegur|I've had ppl thank me for them and the links to the analyses before
  529. 14:58:41 |c|~hollywood|ranking shit like vullaby in C- is helpful
  530. 14:58:53 |c|~hollywood|if it wasn't ranked you might not even know it's a playable mon in the tier
  531. 14:59:04 |c|&raseri|i mean decent at nu @ mont
  532. 14:59:07 |c|@Kiyo|i dont understand why you're for ranking vullaby and not ranking frillish
  533. 14:59:12 |c|~hollywood|they're both ranked
  534. 14:59:13 |c|@Kiyo|theyre essentially on the same level
  535. 14:59:19 |c|~hollywood|but the specifics arent important right now anyways
  536. 14:59:19 |c|@Montsegur|C- conveys to me that in general I woulldn't use Vullaby but it has a specific niche that can fit on enough teams to be semi decent
  537. 14:59:27 |c|@Kiyo|you just said 5 min ago frillish and relicanth shouldnt be ranked
  538. 14:59:28 |c|@Kiyo|lol
  539. 14:59:31 |c|~hollywood|no i didnt
  540. 14:59:31 |c|&raseri|maybe drop vullaby to d or something
  541. 14:59:35 |c|~hollywood|i said they were D
  542. 14:59:39 |c|&raseri|and move muk to s
  543. 14:59:40 |c|~hollywood|and should be judged harshly
  544. 14:59:44 |c|~hollywood|which i still believe to be true
  545. 14:59:55 |c|#Disjunction|ok then I guess maybe a new discussion point should be brought up
  546. 14:59:55 |c|@Kiyo|so are we judging vullaby harshly enough
  547. 14:59:56 |c|&raseri|i think we should just be harsh
  548. 14:59:58 |c|&raseri|witrh everything
  549. 15:00:00 |c|#Disjunction|Should we divide the D Ranks again?
  550. 15:00:02 |c|@Kiyo|because i certainly dont think you are
  551. 15:00:03 |c|~hollywood|it really does not matter right now
  552. 15:00:04 |c|&raseri|no
  553. 15:00:07 |c|@Kiyo|and to be completely honest
  554. 15:00:11 |c|#Disjunction|If we're putting more emphasis on D Rank then it might help
  555. 15:00:14 |c|&raseri|divided d ranks dont help much
  556. 15:00:15 |c|&raseri|hm
  557. 15:00:16 |c|&raseri|good point
  558. 15:00:17 |c|@Kiyo|the community didnt like it when i made a rough new vr rankings
  559. 15:00:23 |c|@Kiyo|that had extremely harsh rankings
  560. 15:00:25 |c|~hollywood|i very well might not be but that's not the point
  561. 15:00:27 |c|&raseri|i liked kiyo rankings
  562. 15:00:46 |c|@Montsegur|cause you had things like 5 lvls were they were and probably at least 3 below where they should be
  563. 15:00:49 |c|&raseri|Disjunction lets talk about rank definitions
  564. 15:00:58 |c|@Montsegur|yah lets do that
  565. 15:01:04 |c|&raseri|its a good point to go through
  566. 15:01:06 |c|@Montsegur|cause I think thats one of the big problems
  567. 15:01:07 |c|&raseri|from here
  568. 15:01:09 |c|&raseri|i agree
  569. 15:01:16 |c|@Montsegur|that and inflation
  570. 15:01:18 |c|&raseri|Pokemon that have a good matchup vs a large portion of the metagame, are either quite powerful or offer great team support, and can fit on almost any team. You can't really go wrong by using these Pokemon.
  571. 15:01:18 |c|&raseri|thats
  572. 15:01:20 |c|@Kiyo|ok what points are we judging mons based on
  573. 15:01:21 |c|&raseri|doubles rank 1
  574. 15:01:25 |c|#Disjunction|the tangy: they didnt like kiyo rankings because he posted questionable things without asking anybody
  575. 15:01:25 |c|#Disjunction|the tangy: not because they were harsh
  576. 15:01:40 |c|@Montsegur|it was a preliminary rankings
  577. 15:01:41 |c|&raseri|Reserved for Pokemon who can sweep or wall significant portions of the metagame with little support, and Pokemon who can support other Pokemon with very little opportunity cost ("free turns").
  578. 15:01:42 |c|&raseri|Also the home of Pokemon who can easily perform multiple roles effectively, increasing their versatility and unpredictability. If the Pokemon in this rank have any flaws, those flaws are thoroughly mitigated by their substantial strengths.​
  579. 15:01:47 |c|&raseri|is ours
  580. 15:01:55 |c|@Kiyo|its not like those rankings i made were official in any way lol
  581. 15:02:00 |c|@Kiyo|why should i have contacted others
  582. 15:02:00 |c|@Montsegur|one option is to delete the definition altogether
  583. 15:02:02 |c|@Kiyo|also raseri
  584. 15:02:03 |c|~hollywood|the only real problem with ours imo are that they're too wordy
  585. 15:02:04 |c|#Disjunction|ok yeah sorry I was looking for Kiyo ranks
  586. 15:02:07 |c|@Montsegur|which was brought up multiple times
  587. 15:02:14 |c|@Kiyo|can we just stop working off of current definitions altogether
  588. 15:02:18 |c|@Kiyo|and make new ones
  589. 15:02:21 |c|&raseri|yes
  590. 15:02:23 |c|~hollywood|deleting the definitions altogether literally makes it just comparing apples to oranges
  591. 15:02:28 |c|&raseri|i like
  592. 15:02:29 |c|~hollywood|it would create more problems and solvenothing
  593. 15:02:31 |c|#Disjunction|I would be all for making new definitions
  594. 15:02:31 |userstats|total:20|guests:0| :13|+:1|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  595. 15:02:31 |c|&raseri|doubles definition
  596. 15:02:35 |c|&raseri|as a starting point
  597. 15:02:37 |c|@Kiyo|we're creating a new definition hollywood
  598. 15:02:39 |c|&raseri|and work from there
  599. 15:02:42 |c|@Montsegur|wait I think we might need more than just -/ /+
  600. 15:02:42 |c|@Kiyo|not getting rid of them altogether
  601. 15:02:42 |c|&raseri|instead of using ours
  602. 15:02:44 |c|@Montsegur|for each letter
  603. 15:02:48 |c|@Kiyo|i just dont want to work off of the current ones
  604. 15:02:49 |c|~hollywood|nigga
  605. 15:02:51 |c|&raseri|what is an s rank mon
  606. 15:02:52 |c|&raseri|?
  607. 15:02:55 |c|~hollywood|@Montsegur: one option is to delete the definition altogether
  608. 15:03:06 |c|@Kiyo|im assuming he means in regards to creating a new one
  609. 15:03:07 |c|@Montsegur|I dont agree with it, it was just brought up in the thread a bunch
  610. 15:03:18 |c|@Kiyo|o thats retarded we're not doing that
  611. 15:03:22 |c|@Montsegur|I think we need a new one
  612. 15:03:25 |c|~hollywood|yea im not crediting it with you just saying that it wouldnt do anything positive
  613. 15:03:25 |c|&raseri|ya
  614. 15:03:31 |c|@Kiyo|we definitely need a new definition
  615. 15:03:31 |c|&raseri|lets work on a new definition
  616. 15:03:34 |c|@Kiyo|so what are the things
  617. 15:03:35 |c|#Disjunction|I also mentioned deleting definitions in the paste because a lot of the time people just ignore them
  618. 15:03:38 |c|@Kiyo|we want to judge mons based on
  619. 15:03:48 |c|@Montsegur|before we do that real quick I think we need more than just -/ /+ for each letter
  620. 15:03:54 |c|@Montsegur|cause its causing over inflation
  621. 15:03:54 |c|&raseri|or
  622. 15:03:56 |c|&raseri|we add more letters
  623. 15:03:58 |c|@Kiyo|^
  624. 15:04:03 |c|~hollywood|or we keep it like it is
  625. 15:04:03 |c|@Montsegur|yah we can add more letters
  626. 15:04:05 |c|@Kiyo|we have more viable mons than every other tier
  627. 15:04:08 |c|~hollywood|and keep in mind overinflation exists
  628. 15:04:09 |c|@Kiyo|why shouldnt we have more ranks
  629. 15:04:14 |c|&raseri|if we need more ranks
  630. 15:04:16 |c|&raseri|we can add them
  631. 15:04:17 |c|&raseri|later
  632. 15:04:17 |c|@Kiyo|overinflation is ruining the ranks tho
  633. 15:04:18 |c|@Kiyo|lol.
  634. 15:04:21 |c|@Montsegur|if we add more letters it would take away the sense of over inflation
  635. 15:04:26 |c|~hollywood|so keep that in mind when we make changes
  636. 15:04:30 |c|&raseri|definitions first
  637. 15:04:31 |c|~hollywood|we've done it before
  638. 15:04:32 |c|&raseri|imo
  639. 15:04:33 |c|#Disjunction|we have the E Rank already
  640. 15:04:34 |c|&raseri|Realistic Waters
  641. 15:04:35 |c|#Disjunction|why not use it
  642. 15:04:42 |c|@Kiyo|what we've done before isnt fucking working tho
  643. 15:04:44 |c|@Kiyo|lol
  644. 15:04:49 |c|~hollywood|it did work for a long time
  645. 15:04:50 |c|@Montsegur|cause E rank is for everything unranked
  646. 15:04:54 |c|~hollywood|in XY zeb fixed the overinflation problem
  647. 15:05:03 |c|~hollywood|but it obviously eventually came back
  648. 15:05:05 |c|&raseri|there wasnt an overinflation problem in BW NU either
  649. 15:05:08 |c|&raseri|afaik
  650. 15:05:12 |c|@Montsegur|BW NU had less mons
  651. 15:05:12 |c|&raseri|well a bit of one
  652. 15:05:13 |c|@Kiyo|so we'll just fix it every 6 months
  653. 15:05:15 |c|&raseri|cause i was stubborn
  654. 15:05:17 |c|@Kiyo|why not fix the fucking root problem
  655. 15:05:17 |c|#Disjunction|Zeb brought up a great point in the thread by saying that D Rank, currently, shows new users that some of their faves are just not great
  656. 15:05:23 |c|&raseri|and wouldnt drop mush
  657. 15:05:28 |c|#Disjunction|if we moved some of those mons to E that'd accomplish the same thing
  658. 15:05:29 |L| Frogeggs
  659. 15:05:32 |c|@Kiyo|but the mons that new players shouldnt be using
  660. 15:05:35 |c|@Kiyo|arent all represented in D
  661. 15:05:40 |c|#Disjunction|but it'd leave D open as a viable rank for at least remotely viable mons
  662. 15:05:41 |c|#Disjunction|like Simipour
  663. 15:05:44 |c|#Disjunction|which is utter trash
  664. 15:05:46 |c|#Disjunction|but has one niche
  665. 15:05:49 |c|&raseri|i prefer d to be for semiviable mons
  666. 15:05:51 |c|&raseri|and e for
  667. 15:05:52 |c|&raseri|things people use
  668. 15:05:54 |c|&raseri|that are trash
  669. 15:05:55 |c|#Disjunction|that makes it worth it sometimes
  670. 15:05:58 |L| the tangy
  671. 15:06:01 |c|@Montsegur|I think there is a stigma with D / E that they're terrible so if we add on another letter I think we could also possibly move over to different symbols or somethin
  672. 15:06:02 |c|#Disjunction|yea that'd be the idea ras
  673. 15:06:16 |c|&raseri|just add a random greek letter
  674. 15:06:18 |c|~hollywood|E should absolutely be the rank for Pokemon that should not see use on any team
  675. 15:06:20 |c|@Kiyo|there is a huge stigma with the rankings
  676. 15:06:26 |c|@Kiyo|thats why i suggested number rankings
  677. 15:06:31 |c|&raseri|whats an example of an
  678. 15:06:32 |c|&raseri|e rank mon
  679. 15:06:35 |c|@Kiyo|like it doesnt actually change anything
  680. 15:06:41 |c|~hollywood|Shroomish
  681. 15:06:41 |c|#Disjunction|if we move to a new ranking there would eventually just be a stigma with that
  682. 15:06:45 |c|@Kiyo|but people have pre concieved notions that D mons are trash
  683. 15:06:46 |c|&raseri|ya there is less stigma with number rankings
  684. 15:06:52 |c|@Kiyo|and wont let their faves fall their
  685. 15:06:55 |c|@Kiyo|even if they deserve it
  686. 15:06:57 |c|~hollywood|except
  687. 15:06:59 |c|~hollywood|it's not up to them
  688. 15:07:03 |c|~hollywood|so they can deal with it
  689. 15:07:14 |c|@Kiyo|its a community run thread at heart
  690. 15:07:15 |c|&raseri|[12:56] &raseri: whats an example of an
  691. 15:07:16 |c|&raseri|[12:56] &raseri: e rank mon
  692. 15:07:16 |c|&raseri|that ppl use
  693. 15:07:19 |c|&raseri|not shroomish
  694. 15:07:33 |c|~hollywood|uh
  695. 15:07:38 |c|#Disjunction|KINGLER
  696. 15:07:39 |c|~hollywood|there's not much
  697. 15:07:44 |c|&raseri|maybe armaldo
  698. 15:07:46 |c|~hollywood|kingler probably isn't e-rank
  699. 15:07:48 |c|&raseri|but even thast can work
  700. 15:07:52 |c|@Montsegur|Armaldo is E
  701. 15:07:53 |c|~hollywood|i dont think armaldo is either
  702. 15:07:54 |c|&raseri|kingler is bad
  703. 15:07:59 |c|&raseri|armaldo is pretty close
  704. 15:07:59 |c|&raseri|to e
  705. 15:08:04 |c|~hollywood|unfezant
  706. 15:08:07 |c|&raseri|it has a small niche i guess
  707. 15:08:09 |c|~hollywood|wobbuffet
  708. 15:08:11 |c|@Realistic Waters|Armaldo is worse than kingler
  709. 15:08:11 |c|@Montsegur|ok so amraldo and kingler both have things that seem like they're desirable
  710. 15:08:11 |c|@Kiyo|ok real talk we need to stop being so fucking nice about this
  711. 15:08:13 |c|~hollywood|wigglytuff
  712. 15:08:18 |c|&raseri|as a spinner on rain that doesnt struggle w/ kanga
  713. 15:08:20 |c|@Kiyo|idgaf if you CAN use armaldo and it has a very small niche
  714. 15:08:23 |c|@Kiyo|you dont fucking use it
  715. 15:08:26 |c|#Disjunction|see we have over inflation because it's so easy to say something isn't E
  716. 15:08:28 |c|&raseri|army of armaldos
  717. 15:08:28 |c|~hollywood|kiyo
  718. 15:08:31 |c|~hollywood|this is a community run thread
  719. 15:08:34 |c|~hollywood|respect my opinion please
  720. 15:08:35 |c|~hollywood|=(
  721. 15:08:37 |c|&raseri|Blaziken1337: regigigas and slaking
  722. 15:08:41 |J| The Idealistic
  723. 15:08:43 |c|&raseri|good e rank
  724. 15:08:44 |c|&raseri|imo
  725. 15:08:47 |c|@Kiyo|like we're not getting anywehere with this
  726. 15:08:47 |c|@Realistic Waters|tru
  727. 15:08:52 |c|@Kiyo|every time we bring up a shit mon
  728. 15:08:53 |c|@Kiyo|someone says
  729. 15:08:56 |c|~hollywood|>unfezant
  730. 15:08:57 |c|~hollywood|>wobbuffet
  731. 15:08:59 |c|@Kiyo|"well it has a small niche"
  732. 15:09:00 |c|#Disjunction|right right ok
  733. 15:09:00 |c|~hollywood|>wigglytuff
  734. 15:09:07 |c|&raseri|>armaldo
  735. 15:09:07 |c|#Disjunction|let's get to definitions
  736. 15:09:09 |c|&raseri|ya
  737. 15:09:13 |c|~hollywood|yes we're talking about pokemon that there is literally no reason to use
  738. 15:09:13 |c|@Kiyo|2/3 have small niches i could argue for
  739. 15:09:14 |c|&raseri|i still support starting with
  740. 15:09:16 |c|@Kiyo|but i know theyre trash
  741. 15:09:16 |c|#Disjunction|I think once we establish definitions we can address this
  742. 15:09:17 |c|&raseri|doubles definitions
  743. 15:09:18 |c|&raseri|and
  744. 15:09:20 |c|@Montsegur|lets switch over to the greek numeral system and add in one more rank
  745. 15:09:20 |c|@Kiyo|and im keeping my mouth shut
  746. 15:09:20 |c|&raseri|working from there
  747. 15:09:22 |c|~hollywood|i can come up with reasons to use armaldo
  748. 15:09:26 |c|@Kiyo|defensive unfezant works
  749. 15:09:28 |c|~hollywood|i cant come up with reasons to use unfezant
  750. 15:09:31 |c|&raseri|i can come up with reasons to use wigglytuff
  751. 15:09:34 |c|&raseri|but
  752. 15:09:35 |c|~hollywood|why would you use it over something else
  753. 15:09:36 |c|&raseri|its still ass
  754. 15:09:36 |c|@Kiyo|wigglytuff is a solid competitive av user
  755. 15:09:41 |c|@Kiyo|like agian
  756. 15:09:44 |c|#Disjunction|it has great coverage
  757. 15:09:47 |c|#Disjunction|and a unique typing
  758. 15:09:48 |c|@Kiyo|idgaf if you can come up with reasons to use a mon
  759. 15:09:48 |c|~hollywood|that niche isn't something that's needed for a team
  760. 15:09:51 |c|@Kiyo|if its ass its ass
  761. 15:09:53 |c|&raseri|ok
  762. 15:09:56 |c|~hollywood|armaldo is a spinner that beats kangaskhan and zangoose
  763. 15:09:56 |c|@Kiyo|and it should be reflected as such
  764. 15:09:56 |c|&raseri|definitions
  765. 15:09:57 |c|&raseri|pls
  766. 15:10:05 |c|~hollywood|that's a much better niche than "av competitive pokemon"
  767. 15:10:15 |c|@Kiyo|again what are the criteria for what we want these mons to meet
  768. 15:10:32 |c|&raseri|idk
  769. 15:10:33 |c|@Kiyo|1.splashability
  770. 15:10:33 |c|@Kiyo|2.reliablility
  771. 15:10:34 |c|@Kiyo|3.consistency
  772. 15:10:35 |c|@Kiyo|what else
  773. 15:10:45 |c|@Montsegur|are we adding in another letter?
  774. 15:10:47 |c|~hollywood|power level probably
  775. 15:10:51 |c|~hollywood|not right now mont
  776. 15:10:52 |c|&raseri|we can discuss that later
  777. 15:10:55 |c|&raseri|if we need it
  778. 15:11:03 |c|@Montsegur|I think that would affect the definitions tho
  779. 15:11:03 |c|@Kiyo|how are you definining power level
  780. 15:11:07 |c|~hollywood|not sure
  781. 15:11:10 |c|@Kiyo|mont we'll get ot that whn we get to it
  782. 15:11:10 |c|~hollywood|but like
  783. 15:11:17 |c|~hollywood|some pokemon are just clearly stronger than others
  784. 15:11:20 |c|~hollywood|whether offensively or not
  785. 15:11:20 |c|&raseri|like sawk
  786. 15:11:24 |c|@Montsegur|there is pure power output
  787. 15:11:28 |c|~hollywood|right
  788. 15:11:35 |c|@Montsegur|but like rampardos has the highest in the game
  789. 15:11:37 |c|@Montsegur|but its not S
  790. 15:11:42 |c|@Kiyo|lets try to make this as objective as possible
  791. 15:11:44 |c|~hollywood|did you listen
  792. 15:11:45 |c|~hollywood|to what i said
  793. 15:11:46 |c|~hollywood|lol
  794. 15:11:48 |c|&raseri|i think those 3 are a good starting point
  795. 15:11:50 |c|~hollywood|by stronger i dont mean
  796. 15:11:53 |c|~hollywood|"hits harder"
  797. 15:11:57 |c|#Disjunction|Pokedots: maybe "threat level" > power level?
  798. 15:12:04 |c|@Kiyo|ok i like that
  799. 15:12:08 |c|~hollywood|that's fine yes
  800. 15:12:08 |c|&raseri|ya
  801. 15:12:12 |c|@Kiyo|how hard a mon is to deal with offensively or defensively
  802. 15:12:12 |c|&raseri|thats good
  803. 15:12:14 |c|@Kiyo|is a good one
  804. 15:12:17 |c|@Kiyo|so thats 4
  805. 15:12:29 |c|&raseri|s rank should have
  806. 15:12:31 |c|&raseri|most of those
  807. 15:12:31 |userstats|total:19|guests:0| :12|+:1|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  808. 15:12:38 |c|@Montsegur|at least 3 if not all 4
  809. 15:12:40 |c|&raseri|idk if they need to be all 4
  810. 15:12:41 |c|&raseri|but
  811. 15:12:43 |c|&raseri|at least 3
  812. 15:12:43 |c|&raseri|for sure
  813. 15:12:51 |c|@Montsegur|I think we should make 5 and then have it be at least 4/5
  814. 15:12:52 |c|@Kiyo|they have all 4 currently
  815. 15:12:53 |c|@Kiyo|imo
  816. 15:12:55 |c|&raseri|and they shouldnt be bad in the 4th
  817. 15:12:56 |c|&raseri|ya rn
  818. 15:13:00 |c|~hollywood|if there is a 5th
  819. 15:13:00 |c|~hollywood|sure
  820. 15:13:00 |c|&raseri|i think they all fit
  821. 15:13:01 |c|&raseri|all 4
  822. 15:13:04 |c|~hollywood|but we dont need to force it
  823. 15:13:07 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  824. 15:13:08 |c|@Kiyo|Blaziken1337:(Private to +Kiyo) what about versatility
  825. 15:13:09 |c|@Kiyo|~hollywood: if there is a 5th
  826. 15:13:15 |c|@Kiyo|do we want to include this
  827. 15:13:17 |c|&raseri|versatility
  828. 15:13:18 |c|&raseri|hmm
  829. 15:13:20 |c|&raseri|its a nice trait
  830. 15:13:21 |c|@Kiyo|like mesprit has 8 sets
  831. 15:13:21 |c|&raseri|to have
  832. 15:13:22 |J| pus shaneghoul
  833. 15:13:23 |c|@Montsegur|versatilityis nice
  834. 15:13:24 |c|@Kiyo|but that doenst make it great
  835. 15:13:29 |c|&raseri|sawk doesnt have a lot of sets
  836. 15:13:29 |c|@Montsegur|like rhydon is versatile
  837. 15:13:30 |c|~hollywood|i dont think versatility really matters
  838. 15:13:31 |c|~hollywood|that much
  839. 15:13:33 |c|&raseri|but its good at everything else
  840. 15:13:33 |c|@Kiyo|^
  841. 15:13:34 |c|~hollywood|i mean it's definitely good
  842. 15:13:37 |c|#Disjunction|I don't think versatility should make a mon
  843. 15:13:37 |c|~hollywood|to have
  844. 15:13:38 |c|@Kiyo|i think we can consider
  845. 15:13:38 |c|&raseri|versatility is a nice
  846. 15:13:39 |c|@Kiyo|it
  847. 15:13:40 |c|&raseri|bonus trait
  848. 15:13:41 |c|@Kiyo|but its like
  849. 15:13:43 |c|@Montsegur|that could be a sub trait
  850. 15:13:43 |c|@Kiyo|a bonus
  851. 15:13:44 |c|@Kiyo|yeah
  852. 15:13:46 |c|~hollywood|but if a pokemon does one thing better than anything else in the tier
  853. 15:13:47 |c|~hollywood|yea
  854. 15:13:49 |c|@Kiyo|its like worth half a point
  855. 15:13:51 |c|&raseri|its a cool thing to have
  856. 15:13:54 |c|&raseri|but you dont need it
  857. 15:14:00 |c|@Montsegur|ok so its a two parter
  858. 15:14:08 |c|~hollywood|like i would credit mesprit with versatility but wouldnt take away from sawk for being mostly one-dimensional
  859. 15:14:10 |J| krices
  860. 15:14:14 |L| pus shaneghoul
  861. 15:14:17 |c|@Montsegur|if its versatile than two of those roles need to not be overshadowed
  862. 15:14:22 |L| krices
  863. 15:14:31 |c|~hollywood|versatility also plays into the other traits
  864. 15:14:42 |J| METAPHYSICAL
  865. 15:14:58 |c|@Kiyo|like sawk has 4 roles
  866. 15:15:01 |c|@Kiyo|you could argue that
  867. 15:15:06 |c|@Kiyo|but if i only use 1 of them
  868. 15:15:10 |c|@Kiyo|like 95% of the time
  869. 15:15:11 |c|@Montsegur|also guys feel free to PM us with ideas for this like pokedots and blaziken did
  870. 15:15:15 |c|&raseri|^
  871. 15:15:20 |J| Steakburgers
  872. 15:15:22 |c|@Kiyo|does the fact that it can run cs, cb, lum, etc matter
  873. 15:15:23 |c|~hollywood|ok i
  874. 15:15:26 |c|~hollywood|gotta run out and get more short for work
  875. 15:15:29 |c|~hollywood|i'll be back in like 20
  876. 15:15:29 |J| buggelz
  877. 15:15:31 |c|&raseri|:o
  878. 15:15:34 |c|&raseri|oki
  879. 15:15:35 |c|@Montsegur|ok, we'll update you
  880. 15:15:37 |c|@Montsegur|when you get back
  881. 15:15:39 |J| FoxxyStyles
  882. 15:15:40 |c|&raseri|lets ruin nu while hes gone
  883. 15:16:01 |c|@Montsegur|anarchy
  884. 15:16:07 |L| FoxxyStyles
  885. 15:16:07 |J| Jizznado
  886. 15:16:07 |c|&raseri|ok so
  887. 15:16:09 |c|@Kiyo|so i like versatility being included
  888. 15:16:10 |c|&raseri|where are we at
  889. 15:16:10 |c|&raseri|now
  890. 15:16:14 |c|#Disjunction|hi sorry got distracted for a sec
  891. 15:16:18 |c|@Kiyo|but its a really low relevance to rank imo
  892. 15:16:19 |c|&raseri|i like versatility being a bonus
  893. 15:16:20 |c|@Montsegur|I think we have main traits and then sub traits
  894. 15:16:22 |c|&raseri|like
  895. 15:16:24 |c|&raseri|we dont punish
  896. 15:16:25 |c|@Kiyo|unless the mon has like 4 great sets
  897. 15:16:26 |c|&raseri|for not having it
  898. 15:16:27 |c|@Kiyo|that all get usage
  899. 15:16:28 |c|#Disjunction|we were discussing what we're looking for in Pokemon when discussing them, right?
  900. 15:16:31 |c|#Disjunction|how can we apply those traits
  901. 15:16:32 |c|@Kiyo|yeah no punish for not having it
  902. 15:16:34 |c|#Disjunction|to a definition
  903. 15:16:39 |c|@Montsegur|sub traits can help a mon get a rank but they dont directly give a mon said rank
  904. 15:16:42 |c|@Kiyo|only reward it if the mons sets actually see use
  905. 15:16:47 |c|&raseri|yaa
  906. 15:16:55 |c|&raseri|idc about RP physcal aurorus
  907. 15:16:58 |c|&raseri|that doesnt count
  908. 15:17:08 |c|@Montsegur|physical aurorus can still tear a team a new one
  909. 15:17:12 |c|&raseri|ya but not RP
  910. 15:17:17 |c|#Disjunction|^
  911. 15:17:18 |c|@Montsegur|but band / specs
  912. 15:17:20 |c|@Kiyo|ya but its usage is like 1/100 auros
  913. 15:17:20 |c|@Montsegur|difference
  914. 15:17:22 |c|&raseri|ok
  915. 15:17:23 |c|@Montsegur|is what I'm saying
  916. 15:17:23 |c|@Kiyo|so is it that relevant
  917. 15:17:24 |c|&raseri|so we have s rank down
  918. 15:17:25 |c|&raseri|yn
  919. 15:17:40 |c|@Kiyo|yeah who wants to write up definitions
  920. 15:17:41 |c|@Montsegur|even if people don't use it I still think if its good enough it should be factored in
  921. 15:17:43 |c|&raseri|not me
  922. 15:17:52 |c|#Disjunction|we could make it an objective criteria
  923. 15:17:56 |c|#Disjunction|like if a mon fulfills
  924. 15:18:01 |c|#Disjunction|4/5 of the criteria
  925. 15:18:01 |c|@Montsegur|my example is that rhydon in XY wasn't used whatsoever but it still held A rank cause it was good
  926. 15:18:06 |c|#Disjunction|it can be safely placed in B
  927. 15:18:09 |c|#Disjunction|or A
  928. 15:18:17 |c|&raseri|1/5 should be threat level for a rank
  929. 15:18:20 |c|@Kiyo|yeah but i rly hated the xy vr's for that reason
  930. 15:18:24 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction I said 4/5 is good but we don't have a 5th definition
  931. 15:18:32 |c|&raseri|meme factor.
  932. 15:18:34 |c|#Disjunction|what were the definitions
  933. 15:18:34 |c|&raseri|xd
  934. 15:18:35 |c|@Montsegur|and we dont wanna force one
  935. 15:18:45 |c|@Kiyo|splashability
  936. 15:18:49 |c|@Kiyo|reliablity
  937. 15:18:52 |c|@Kiyo|consistency
  938. 15:18:59 |c|@Montsegur|fuck
  939. 15:19:00 |c|&raseri|threat level
  940. 15:19:02 |c|@Montsegur|I just copy and pasted
  941. 15:19:05 |c|@Kiyo|threat level
  942. 15:19:07 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  943. 15:19:10 |c|@Kiyo|yeah and versatility
  944. 15:19:13 |c|#Disjunction|what about metagame relevance
  945. 15:19:13 |c|@Montsegur|not necessarily in that order
  946. 15:19:18 |c|#Disjunction|like
  947. 15:19:19 |c|&raseri|doesnt that fit into threat level
  948. 15:19:23 |c|@Kiyo|i think metagame relevance and threat level
  949. 15:19:24 |c|@Montsegur|yah it does
  950. 15:19:27 |c|@Kiyo|should go hand in hand
  951. 15:19:28 |c|#Disjunction|Uxie/Mesprit weren't good in Sneasel meta
  952. 15:19:31 |c|@Kiyo|but realisticly
  953. 15:19:32 |c|@Kiyo|they wont
  954. 15:19:34 |c|@Kiyo|tbch
  955. 15:19:36 |c|&raseri|fair
  956. 15:19:45 |c|#Disjunction|but Rhydon is really good in this meta
  957. 15:19:47 |c|@Montsegur|versatility was agreed that it shouldn't be a main one
  958. 15:19:56 |c|@Montsegur|cause the majority of mons wont hit it
  959. 15:20:02 |c|@Kiyo|yeah i kinda want to tie usage in somehow
  960. 15:20:05 |c|@Kiyo|that isnt just usage
  961. 15:20:10 |c|@Kiyo|so i like metagame relevance
  962. 15:20:11 |c|&raseri|idk if i want to do that
  963. 15:20:15 |c|#Disjunction|I don't
  964. 15:20:17 |J| mazanya
  965. 15:20:19 |c|@Montsegur|ladder is notorious for having things that have high usage that are ass
  966. 15:20:20 |c|&raseri|you get really good mons
  967. 15:20:22 |c|&raseri|people just dont use
  968. 15:20:23 |c|@Montsegur|so thats a no from me
  969. 15:20:47 |J| Void Chrono
  970. 15:20:51 |c|@Kiyo|METAPHYSICAL: and saying these mons are all good / work on one specifc team
  971. 15:20:51 |c|@Kiyo|METAPHYSICAL: doesn't mean they are viable
  972. 15:20:57 |c|@Kiyo|yeah that falls under splashability
  973. 15:21:04 |c|@Kiyo|yn
  974. 15:21:10 |c|&raseri|y
  975. 15:21:12 |c|#Disjunction|y
  976. 15:21:13 |c|&raseri|| 42 | Kangaskhan | 5.55033% | 11902 | 3.797% | 9477 | 3.885% |
  977. 15:21:30 |c|@Kiyo|ok so theres not a way to objectively do it
  978. 15:21:37 |c|@Kiyo|and less subjective shit is better
  979. 15:21:44 |c|&raseri|i dont think we should focus on being purely objective
  980. 15:21:51 |c|#Disjunction|agreed
  981. 15:21:57 |c|#Disjunction|the criteria have room to be subjective
  982. 15:22:00 |c|&raseri|having a subjective bit in the criteria
  983. 15:22:01 |c|&raseri|is fine
  984. 15:22:02 |c|@Kiyo|to an extent i'd prefer more objective requirements tho
  985. 15:22:03 |c|&raseri|and even then
  986. 15:22:06 |c|&raseri|its subjective
  987. 15:22:13 |c|&raseri|like what defines consistent
  988. 15:22:15 |c|&raseri|where is the line drawn
  989. 15:22:16 |c|&raseri|etc
  990. 15:22:17 |c|@Kiyo|like people have told me they dont think they need a normal reisst on every tema
  991. 15:22:22 |c|&raseri|does tauros count as consistent
  992. 15:22:24 |c|&raseri|with rock climb
  993. 15:22:27 |c|@Kiyo|and i say have fun losing to kangaskhan and tauros
  994. 15:22:31 |userstats|total:25|guests:0| :18|+:1|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  995. 15:22:35 |c|@Kiyo|i'd say tauros consistenly does its job
  996. 15:22:38 |c|@Montsegur|there are mons that will hit all these things and just not be good in the meta
  997. 15:22:40 |c|&raseri|85% of the time
  998. 15:22:43 |c|@Montsegur|so some subjectivity is required
  999. 15:23:01 |c|#Disjunction|Splashability, reliability, consistency, threat level, and effect on metagame
  1000. 15:23:07 |c|#Disjunction|all have room for subjectivity
  1001. 15:23:09 |c|@Kiyo|i just dont want the level of subjectivity
  1002. 15:23:11 |c|@Kiyo|to be like
  1003. 15:23:17 |c|@Kiyo|clefairy is C rank material
  1004. 15:23:17 |c|@Montsegur|the first 3 are more objective
  1005. 15:23:19 |c|@Kiyo|cuz its good
  1006. 15:23:20 |c|@Kiyo|haha
  1007. 15:23:23 |c|&raseri|haha
  1008. 15:23:23 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1009. 15:23:26 |c|@Montsegur|i agree
  1010. 15:23:28 |c|@Kiyo|cuz i feel like thats waht half the posts are
  1011. 15:23:29 |c|@Kiyo|rn
  1012. 15:23:32 |c|@Montsegur|which is the issue with overrating things
  1013. 15:23:37 |c|&raseri|i used clefairy on a team recently b- rank pls
  1014. 15:23:38 |c|#Disjunction|like you could easily say CM Clefairy has a high threat level because not every team has a check to it
  1015. 15:23:38 |c|@Montsegur|but I also dont wanna underrate things
  1016. 15:23:49 |c|@Kiyo|&raseri: i used clefairy on a team recently b- rank pls
  1017. 15:23:49 |c|@Kiyo|&raseri: i used clefairy on a team recently b- rank pls
  1018. 15:23:50 |c|@Kiyo|&raseri: i used clefairy on a team recently b- rank pls
  1019. 15:23:50 |c|@Kiyo|&raseri: i used clefairy on a team recently b- rank pls
  1020. 15:23:56 |c|@Kiyo|this is how i read 90% of the noms
  1021. 15:24:03 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction even if you don't have a check to clefairy you have a check to CM pokemon
  1022. 15:24:17 |c|@Montsegur|so good teambuilding will account for it anyways
  1023. 15:24:18 |J| bouff
  1024. 15:24:18 |c|&raseri|unless your check doesnt beat clef
  1025. 15:24:21 |c|&raseri|by chance
  1026. 15:24:29 |c|&raseri|but
  1027. 15:24:32 |c|&raseri|thats not relevant
  1028. 15:24:35 |c|#Disjunction|CM Megadino wouldn't beat CM Stored Power Clef
  1029. 15:24:40 |c|#Disjunction|but yea
  1030. 15:24:40 |c|@Kiyo|#Disjunction: Splashability, reliability, consistency, threat level, and effect on metagame
  1031. 15:24:42 |c|@Montsegur|what doesn't beat clefairy that doesn't beat megadino?
  1032. 15:24:49 |c|@Kiyo|ok so those are the criteria for s atm?
  1033. 15:24:52 |c|@Montsegur|*that does beat dino
  1034. 15:24:53 |c|&raseri|yes
  1035. 15:24:56 |c|&raseri|i suport that
  1036. 15:25:00 |c|@Kiyo|does anyone now how to say splashability so it doesnt sound stupid
  1037. 15:25:05 |c|#Disjunction|I think effect on metagame could be reworded
  1038. 15:25:08 |c|@Kiyo|like ability to work on a number of teams?
  1039. 15:25:09 |c|#Disjunction|but
  1040. 15:25:09 |c|&raseri|!dt magikarp
  1041. 15:25:09 |c|~|/data-pokemon Magikarp
  1042. |raw|<font size="1"><font color=#585858>Dex#:</font> 129&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Gen:</font> 1&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Height:</font> 0.9 m&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Weight:</font> 10 kg <em>(40 BP)</em>&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Dex Colour:</font> Red&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Egg Group(s):</font> Water 2, Dragon&nbsp;|&ThickSpace;<font color=#585858>Evolution:</font> Gyarados (20)</font>
  1043. 15:25:10 |c|@Montsegur|in one word?
  1044. 15:25:13 |c|#Disjunction|it's not super important
  1045. 15:25:21 |c|@Kiyo|ok i'll work on wording rn
  1046. 15:25:23 |c|@Montsegur|or can I use several
  1047. 15:25:25 |c|@Kiyo|you guys can nom shit
  1048. 15:25:33 |c|@Kiyo|that makes this diffreent
  1049. 15:25:35 |J| ShadowDragoon666
  1050. 15:25:36 |c|@Kiyo|from A
  1051. 15:25:44 |c|@Kiyo|fuck i cant speak
  1052. 15:25:53 |c|@Kiyo|make criteria for A mons based on S criteria
  1053. 15:25:56 |c|@Kiyo|while i type
  1054. 15:25:56 |c|@Kiyo|imo
  1055. 15:25:57 |L| buggelz
  1056. 15:26:00 |c|&raseri|ok
  1057. 15:26:06 |c|#Disjunction|my suggestion still stands to make subsequent ranks dependent on filling criteria
  1058. 15:26:18 |J|+King UU
  1059. 15:26:27 |c|#Disjunction|like A Rank fulfills 4/5, B rank fulfills 3/5, C rank fulfills 2/5, D rank fulfills 1/5
  1060. 15:27:10 |c|&raseri|a-rank = fulfulls the majority of the criteria as defined, but is missing in one area, or 2 areas if it defines a great teamstyle
  1061. 15:27:11 |J| grizord
  1062. 15:27:20 |c|&raseri|last bit im not sure of
  1063. 15:27:28 |c|#Disjunction|also unsure
  1064. 15:27:30 |c|&raseri|and 1 of the 5 should be
  1065. 15:27:35 |c|&raseri|threat level
  1066. 15:27:41 |c|#Disjunction|I think "great" could be reworded to "dominate"
  1067. 15:27:42 |c|&raseri|it can also fill them
  1068. 15:27:49 |c|&raseri|to a lesser degree
  1069. 15:27:49 |c|@Montsegur|but there will be some B / C / lower ranks that fill more than 3 and by that definition should be higher
  1070. 15:27:51 |c|&raseri|than s rank
  1071. 15:27:55 |c|&raseri|ya
  1072. 15:27:57 |c|&raseri|when we get lower
  1073. 15:27:59 |c|&raseri|it gets more subjective
  1074. 15:28:18 |c|#Disjunction|that's true
  1075. 15:28:20 |c|@Montsegur|I think we need to expand each one into some sub sections
  1076. 15:28:26 |c|@Montsegur|and then see if they fit from there
  1077. 15:28:28 |c|@Montsegur|for the lower ones
  1078. 15:28:46 |c|&raseri|Blaziken1337: maybe also look at in terms of how much something is outclassed
  1079. 15:28:55 |c|@Montsegur|yah thats a good one
  1080. 15:28:58 |c|#Disjunction|Kiyo wouldn't be happy about that
  1081. 15:29:00 |c|#Disjunction|but I would agree
  1082. 15:29:04 |c|@Montsegur|well
  1083. 15:29:06 |c|@Kiyo|im fine with taht
  1084. 15:29:09 |c|#Disjunction|o
  1085. 15:29:16 |c|@Montsegur|kabutops completely outclasses armaldo imo
  1086. 15:29:19 |c|@Kiyo|i realized a month ago theres no way to do this perfectly
  1087. 15:29:21 |c|@Montsegur|or for the most part
  1088. 15:29:26 |c|@Kiyo|and outclassing something is an ok enough argument
  1089. 15:29:28 |c|#Disjunction|we could come up with negative definitions
  1090. 15:29:29 |c|@Kiyo|for the sake of the thread
  1091. 15:29:32 |c|@Kiyo|^
  1092. 15:29:32 |c|#Disjunction|things that hold a mon back
  1093. 15:29:34 |c|&raseri|a rank should fulfill most of the s rank criteria, but be missing something
  1094. 15:29:36 |c|@Kiyo|i like negative things
  1095. 15:29:38 |c|#Disjunction|such as being outclassed
  1096. 15:29:43 |c|&raseri|Pokedots: I don't think a clear cut 1/5 or 3/5 of the criteria would work that well, I'd just say how they do when judged by each criteria
  1097. 15:29:48 |c|@Kiyo|i think being weak against higher ranked pokemon
  1098. 15:29:49 |c|&raseri|so if we want to be
  1099. 15:29:51 |c|&raseri|objective
  1100. 15:29:51 |c|@Kiyo|should be a criteria
  1101. 15:29:54 |c|&raseri|ya
  1102. 15:29:58 |c|&raseri|1 sec
  1103. 15:29:58 |c|@Kiyo|to a certain extent
  1104. 15:30:01 |c|&raseri|im wording something
  1105. 15:30:06 |J| The Testing Wind
  1106. 15:30:07 |c|@Kiyo|https://titanpad.com/Nxc84zWqD9
  1107. 15:30:08 |L| grizord
  1108. 15:30:08 |c|#Disjunction|negative criteria can work more subjectively
  1109. 15:30:10 |J| grizord
  1110. 15:30:13 |c|@Kiyo|also tahts what i have for S rank rn
  1111. 15:30:15 |c|@Kiyo|it needs work
  1112. 15:30:31 |c|&raseri|if we want to be objective, then maybe each category should be given a rank too,
  1113. 15:30:32 |c|&raseri|like
  1114. 15:30:42 |c|@Kiyo|like threat level is more important
  1115. 15:30:45 |c|&raseri|we acn have 2 pretty consistent mons
  1116. 15:30:49 |c|&raseri|but one is a bit mnore consistent
  1117. 15:30:52 |c|@Kiyo|than variety of teams
  1118. 15:30:53 |c|&raseri|and that needs to be accounted for
  1119. 15:30:53 |c|@Kiyo|or smth
  1120. 15:31:08 |L| The Testing Wind
  1121. 15:31:17 |c|&raseri|ya i like that definition
  1122. 15:31:24 |c|&raseri|threat level is most important
  1123. 15:31:33 |c|#Disjunction|hmm
  1124. 15:31:39 |L| Luck O' the Irish
  1125. 15:31:41 |c|#Disjunction|if we wanted to completely overhaul the thread
  1126. 15:31:50 |c|#Disjunction|we could get rid of categorizing all of the mons
  1127. 15:32:00 |c|#Disjunction|and list their traits
  1128. 15:32:03 |c|#Disjunction|then rank their traits
  1129. 15:32:12 |c|&raseri|that sounds like lots of work
  1130. 15:32:18 |c|#Disjunction|like Rhydon would have S consistency
  1131. 15:32:20 |c|#Disjunction|or something
  1132. 15:32:26 |c|&raseri|in theory that works
  1133. 15:32:31 |userstats|total:27|guests:0| :19|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1134. 15:32:35 |L|~hollywood
  1135. 15:32:37 |c|&raseri|if we dont take into account
  1136. 15:32:38 |c|&raseri|amount of work
  1137. 15:32:41 |c|#Disjunction|that way we can qork on a case by case basis
  1138. 15:32:43 |c|&raseri|a little blurb about the pokemon
  1139. 15:32:44 |c|@Montsegur|in theory that works but when updates roll around it will take way to much time
  1140. 15:32:46 |c|&raseri|could be helpful
  1141. 15:32:56 |c|&raseri|so people know why
  1142. 15:32:58 |c|&raseri|Rhydon is S
  1143. 15:33:00 |c|#Disjunction|and it would help alleviate the problem of mons that are subpar being unrepresented
  1144. 15:33:04 |c|@Montsegur|blurb could be helpful
  1145. 15:33:12 |c|@Kiyo|it would be nice to start ranking each mons traits
  1146. 15:33:14 |c|@Montsegur|I think the blurb could go in a second post under the actual rankings
  1147. 15:33:18 |c|@Kiyo|but i agree thats a project for another ay
  1148. 15:33:25 |c|@Montsegur|cause it would get super cluttered under each mon
  1149. 15:33:32 |c|@Montsegur|we need a to do list
  1150. 15:33:55 |c|&raseri|when are we going to rank pokemon
  1151. 15:34:07 |L| Companeros
  1152. 15:34:09 |c|@Kiyo|after B rank is done imo
  1153. 15:34:11 |c|@Montsegur|after we get the ranks defined
  1154. 15:34:18 |c|@Montsegur|ok we can do that
  1155. 15:34:24 |c|@Montsegur|and then see if we need another letter
  1156. 15:34:28 |c|@Montsegur|at that point in time
  1157. 15:35:14 |c|@Kiyo|so i've been offscreen
  1158. 15:35:18 |c|#Disjunction|so how are we handling definitions then
  1159. 15:35:21 |c|@Kiyo|what have you guys come up with for A rank definitions
  1160. 15:35:43 |c|#Disjunction|we've been discussing objectively ranking mons
  1161. 15:35:56 |c|#Disjunction|vs subjectively to a rank like we have been
  1162. 15:35:57 |L| grizord
  1163. 15:36:03 |c|#Disjunction|then we got on the topic of negative characteristics
  1164. 15:36:07 |c|#Disjunction|and didn't go anywhere with that
  1165. 15:36:23 |c|@Kiyo|ok so lets list some negative things that can be accoutned for
  1166. 15:36:30 |c|@Kiyo|>hazard weakness
  1167. 15:36:35 |c|@Kiyo|>speed
  1168. 15:36:36 |L| tv4c
  1169. 15:36:42 |c|@Kiyo|>general bulk
  1170. 15:36:43 |c|@Montsegur|passivness
  1171. 15:36:45 |c|@Kiyo|^
  1172. 15:36:56 |c|&raseri|poor matchup vs relevant pokemon
  1173. 15:37:00 |c|@Kiyo|^
  1174. 15:37:00 |c|#Disjunction|how much should some of these weigh against the main 5 characteristics, though
  1175. 15:37:05 |c|@Montsegur|outclassed
  1176. 15:37:08 |c|@Kiyo|lolbro: priority
  1177. 15:37:17 |c|@Kiyo|i think that can fall under a speed argument
  1178. 15:37:19 |c|@Montsegur|if we go into moves tho
  1179. 15:37:25 |c|&raseri|ya it fits with speed
  1180. 15:37:25 |c|@Montsegur|then we will have a huge list
  1181. 15:37:26 |J|~hollywood
  1182. 15:37:33 |c|@Kiyo|and passiveness falls under momentum lolbro
  1183. 15:37:47 |c|@Kiyo|err other way around but yh
  1184. 15:38:03 |c|@Montsegur|hi holly, we got threat level as the 5th one and are now making a negative list
  1185. 15:38:06 |J| Adaire
  1186. 15:38:27 |c|@Montsegur|I dont think a mon should be dinged for not having uturn tho
  1187. 15:38:31 |c|@Montsegur|or any other move for that matter
  1188. 15:38:34 |c|@Kiyo|no but a pokemon like prinplup
  1189. 15:38:35 |c|@Montsegur|~~unless its scald~~
  1190. 15:38:41 |c|#Disjunction|passiveness = momentum suck
  1191. 15:38:41 |c|@Kiyo|that literally gives a free turn when you defog
  1192. 15:38:42 |L| Adaire
  1193. 15:38:45 |c|@Kiyo|is a momentum suck
  1194. 15:38:53 |c|@Kiyo|it forces you to switch and take a hit
  1195. 15:38:59 |c|@Kiyo|because you lost momentum
  1196. 15:39:15 |c|@Montsegur|but since it can have things like toxic and defensiveness that can be neutralized
  1197. 15:39:22 |c|@Montsegur|that also has to play into it
  1198. 15:39:22 |c|@Kiyo|to an extent yes
  1199. 15:39:30 |c|~hollywood|setup fodder is bad
  1200. 15:39:33 |c|&raseri|being a momentum sap should let you be dinged
  1201. 15:39:37 |c|#Disjunction|one problem I'm seeing with this system is if we make it too complicated, people who are joining the thread will struggle to make the appropriate noms
  1202. 15:39:39 |c|~hollywood|having u-turn helps not be setup fodder
  1203. 15:39:42 |c|@Kiyo|agree with raseri
  1204. 15:39:51 |c|~hollywood|not having u-turn doesn't make you setup fodder
  1205. 15:39:55 |c|&raseri|ya i dont want a complicated system
  1206. 15:40:02 |c|&raseri|which is why i dont want things to be
  1207. 15:40:04 |c|&raseri|to objective
  1208. 15:40:08 |c|~hollywood|garbodor isn't setup fodder for much
  1209. 15:40:09 |c|~hollywood|mantine is
  1210. 15:40:11 |c|@Kiyo|i dont think having passiveness makes it complicated
  1211. 15:40:14 |c|~hollywood|if it had u-turn it wouldn't be
  1212. 15:40:17 |c|~hollywood|but it doesn't
  1213. 15:40:22 |c|@Kiyo|like hollywood is giving good examples
  1214. 15:40:25 |c|~hollywood|so it's passive and shit that doesnt mind scald sets up on it
  1215. 15:40:32 |c|&raseri|yaa
  1216. 15:40:35 |c|~hollywood|that's not very much and mantine sucks for a number of reasons
  1217. 15:40:36 |c|@Kiyo|most of our defoggers are momentum sucks for example
  1218. 15:40:48 |c|~hollywood|but the point stands that not having u-turn isn't the reason why mantine should be ranked low
  1219. 15:40:52 |c|@Kiyo|^
  1220. 15:40:54 |c|~hollywood|but it sure doesn't help
  1221. 15:41:10 |c|@Kiyo|when talking about momentum we're not specificly talking about u-turn and volt switch for the record
  1222. 15:41:16 |c|@Montsegur|I just think that adding moves as part of the negative list will make it to convoluted
  1223. 15:41:27 |c|@Montsegur|but uturn and that fall under passivness
  1224. 15:41:35 |c|@Kiyo|yeah agreed i wouldnt specifically mention any moves
  1225. 15:41:40 |c|@Kiyo|cuz like holly said
  1226. 15:41:58 |c|@Kiyo|cuz of what holly said*
  1227. 15:42:31 |c|@Montsegur|so we have a p decent negative list right
  1228. 15:42:31 |userstats|total:24|guests:0| :16|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1229. 15:42:41 |c|#Disjunction|ok so for negative definitions (I'm keeping a list) we have passiveness, outclassed, hazard weakness, speed, general bulk
  1230. 15:42:44 |J| Adaire
  1231. 15:42:58 |c|@Kiyo|outclass should be at the top fo the list
  1232. 15:43:02 |c|@Kiyo|hazard weakness on low end
  1233. 15:43:09 |c|@Kiyo|speed and general bulk in between
  1234. 15:43:12 |c|@Kiyo|and passive below that
  1235. 15:43:13 |c|@Kiyo|imo
  1236. 15:43:15 |c|@Montsegur|we can arrange order later imo
  1237. 15:43:22 |c|@Montsegur|for both list
  1238. 15:43:23 |c|@Montsegur|s
  1239. 15:43:26 |c|#Disjunction|that's 5 negative characteristics
  1240. 15:43:26 |L|@Realistic Waters
  1241. 15:43:29 |c|#Disjunction|how should we compare those
  1242. 15:43:31 |c|&raseri|poor matchups
  1243. 15:43:34 |c|&raseri|needs to be on there
  1244. 15:43:37 |c|@Kiyo|o yeah
  1245. 15:43:38 |c|#Disjunction|to mons with plenty of positive characteristics
  1246. 15:43:39 |c|@Kiyo|thats a big one
  1247. 15:43:41 |c|&raseri|^
  1248. 15:43:45 |c|#Disjunction|y
  1249. 15:43:48 |c|#Disjunction|but my point stands
  1250. 15:43:54 |c|&raseri|compare them
  1251. 15:43:55 |c|&raseri|subjectively
  1252. 15:44:01 |c|@Kiyo|strengths outweigh flaws is really subjective
  1253. 15:44:04 |c|@Kiyo|but its best way to do it
  1254. 15:44:09 |c|@Montsegur|should the negative list also be for S rank?
  1255. 15:44:09 |c|@Kiyo|unless someone has another idea
  1256. 15:44:11 |c|&raseri|how much do its negatives
  1257. 15:44:12 |c|&raseri|hurt it
  1258. 15:44:17 |J| Blast Chance
  1259. 15:44:18 |c|@Kiyo|i think it should apply to s rank as well
  1260. 15:44:21 |c|~hollywood|the importance of each quality matters too
  1261. 15:44:21 |c|&raseri|compared to how much the positives help it
  1262. 15:44:23 |c|@Kiyo|like arhc and mag are sr weak
  1263. 15:44:23 |c|@Montsegur|hi blast
  1264. 15:44:24 Blast Chance was promoted to Room Moderator by Disjunction.
  1265. 15:44:24 |N|@Blast Chance|blastchance
  1266. 15:44:25 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction
  1267. 15:44:26 |c|@Montsegur|o
  1268. 15:44:27 |c|&raseri|blast
  1269. 15:44:27 |c|#Disjunction|I gottem
  1270. 15:44:28 |c|&raseri|:)
  1271. 15:44:30 |c|@Kiyo|yeah i agree with hollywood
  1272. 15:44:32 |c|@Blast Chance|helo
  1273. 15:44:36 |c|~hollywood|like
  1274. 15:44:37 |c|@Kiyo|thats why i wanted an order to it
  1275. 15:44:42 |c|@Montsegur|blast ill update you in PM
  1276. 15:44:45 |c|&raseri|we need a negative definition
  1277. 15:44:46 |c|&raseri|VR
  1278. 15:44:49 |c|@Kiyo|liek hazard weakness is a flaw but its not crippling in archeops case
  1279. 15:44:55 |c|&raseri|hazard weakness is a c rank
  1280. 15:44:55 |c|@Kiyo|so its still s rank
  1281. 15:44:56 |c|&raseri|flaw
  1282. 15:44:57 |c|&raseri|haha
  1283. 15:45:11 |c|~hollywood|it's hard to come up with
  1284. 15:45:16 |c|~hollywood|a specific example
  1285. 15:45:19 |c|~hollywood|but like
  1286. 15:45:21 |L| Adaire
  1287. 15:45:48 |J| Companeros
  1288. 15:45:48 |c|@Montsegur|hazard weaknes + no reliable recovery
  1289. 15:45:53 |c|@Montsegur|is crippling
  1290. 15:45:57 |c|@Montsegur|like CB scyther
  1291. 15:45:58 |c|~hollywood|regirock being good against normals is less important because so is rhydon and that threatens more offensively
  1292. 15:45:58 |c|&raseri|to some pokemon
  1293. 15:46:14 |c|&raseri|brb
  1294. 15:46:15 |c|~hollywood|so it's more important to compare it to rhydon in effectiveness than to look at the things it does on paper
  1295. 15:46:16 |c|@Montsegur|and regi is more passive than rhydon
  1296. 15:46:34 |c|#Disjunction|so in that case holly Rhydon's ability to outclass Regi would be more important
  1297. 15:46:58 |c|@Blast Chance|so are we talking about specific pkmn or specific ranks atm
  1298. 15:47:09 |c|@Kiyo|defining ranks
  1299. 15:47:16 |c|@Kiyo|making criteria that mons can meet
  1300. 15:47:18 |c|@Kiyo|to fit into them
  1301. 15:47:34 |c|@Montsegur|but using pokemon as examples
  1302. 15:47:43 |c|@Kiyo|yeah visualization helps
  1303. 15:47:59 |c|@Kiyo|ill brb
  1304. 15:48:01 |c|#Disjunction|I wouldn't mind comparing negative ranks with positive ones subjectively
  1305. 15:48:06 |c|~hollywood|yea i'm trying to come up with examples for everything
  1306. 15:48:09 |c|#Disjunction|but then I can easily see
  1307. 15:48:13 |c|~hollywood|we have S and E hammered out though right?
  1308. 15:48:15 |c|#Disjunction|that the ranks wouldn't change much
  1309. 15:48:26 |c|@Montsegur|[12:16] Pokedots: I think D rank should have a mention of being useful in specific matchups (tours) but aren't consistent (ladder)
  1310. 15:48:31 |c|#Disjunction|in terms of people nominating them
  1311. 15:48:33 |c|@Montsegur|kind of relevant to E
  1312. 15:48:38 |L| Void Chrono
  1313. 15:48:44 |c|~hollywood|well the extremes are the most important to define
  1314. 15:48:48 |c|~hollywood|everything else is pretty simple
  1315. 15:48:49 |c|#Disjunction|^
  1316. 15:49:00 |c|~hollywood|you can just slide down the scale from the two starting points
  1317. 15:49:07 |L| Companeros
  1318. 15:49:07 |c|#Disjunction|I think S, A, and D are most important
  1319. 15:49:08 |c|#Disjunction|right now
  1320. 15:49:11 |c|@Montsegur|I dont want to rank every NFE and PU mon that clearly shouldn't be used tho
  1321. 15:49:33 |c|#Disjunction|we could
  1322. 15:49:40 |c|#Disjunction|move things from D to E
  1323. 15:49:43 |c|#Disjunction|when we want to unrank
  1324. 15:49:48 |c|@Montsegur|!ds nu, nfe
  1325. 15:49:48 |raw|<div class="infobox">Ivysaur, Charmeleon, Wartortle, Metapod, Kakuna, Pidgeotto, Pikachu, Sandslash, Nidorina, Nidorino, and 121 more. <font color=#999999>Redo the search with 'all' as a search parameter to show all results.</font></div>
  1326. 15:49:53 |c|#Disjunction|as a kind of transition to being unranked
  1327. 15:49:56 |c|@Montsegur|that would be over 121 mons
  1328. 15:50:00 |c|~hollywood|nu nfe is all nfes not above nu
  1329. 15:50:12 |c|@Montsegur|oh i forgot pu
  1330. 15:50:16 |c|@Montsegur|!ds nu, pu, nfe
  1331. 15:50:16 |raw|<div class="infobox">Ivysaur, Charmeleon, Wartortle, Metapod, Butterfree, Kakuna, Pidgeotto, Pidgeot, Raticate, Fearow, and 257 more. <font color=#999999>Redo the search with 'all' as a search parameter to show all results.</font></div>
  1332. 15:50:19 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1333. 15:50:19 |c|~hollywood|!ds all, nu, nfe, !nfe
  1334. 15:50:19 |raw|<div class="infobox">A search with the parameter 'all' cannot be broadcast.</div>
  1335. 15:50:23 |c|~hollywood|!ds nu, nfe, !nfe
  1336. 15:50:23 |raw|<div class="infobox">A search cannot both exclude and include a tier.</div>
  1337. 15:50:26 |c|~hollywood|cry
  1338. 15:50:28 |c|@Blast Chance|lol
  1339. 15:50:31 |c|~hollywood|i want
  1340. 15:50:36 |c|~hollywood|nfe but not in the "tier" nfe
  1341. 15:50:59 |c|~hollywood|!ds nu, nfe, !pu
  1342. 15:50:59 |raw|<div class="infobox">Ivysaur, Charmeleon, Wartortle, Metapod, Kakuna, Pidgeotto, Pikachu, Sandslash, Nidorina, Nidorino, and 121 more. <font color=#999999>Redo the search with 'all' as a search parameter to show all results.</font></div>
  1343. 15:51:01 |c|@Montsegur|!ds nu, dark type, !nfe
  1344. 15:51:01 |raw|<div class="infobox">Cacturne, Liepard, Malamar, Pawniard, Shiftry, Skuntank</div>
  1345. 15:51:08 |c|@Montsegur|pawniard gets included
  1346. 15:51:12 |c|~hollywood|well it's not nfe
  1347. 15:51:13 |c|~hollywood|tho
  1348. 15:51:14 |c|~hollywood|it's lc
  1349. 15:51:16 |c|@Montsegur|o
  1350. 15:51:18 |c|~hollywood|by "nfe" definitions
  1351. 15:51:18 |c|@Montsegur|hmm
  1352. 15:51:19 |c|~hollywood|that is
  1353. 15:51:27 |c|~hollywood|!ds nu, bug type, !nfe
  1354. 15:51:27 |raw|<div class="infobox">Crustle, Pinsir, Scyther, Vivillon</div>
  1355. 15:51:30 |c|~hollywood|wont exclude scyther either
  1356. 15:51:33 |c|~hollywood|because it's considered nu
  1357. 15:51:40 |c|#Disjunction|ok so can we get a summary
  1358. 15:51:41 |c|~hollywood|anyways this is mostly unimportant
  1359. 15:51:44 |c|#Disjunction|of all the changes so far?
  1360. 15:51:52 |c|@Montsegur|!ds fighting type, nu, !nfe
  1361. 15:51:52 |raw|<div class="infobox">Combusken, Gurdurr, Hariyama, Hitmonchan, Poliwrath, Primeape, Sawk</div>
  1362. 15:51:59 |c|@Montsegur|gurdurr is there
  1363. 15:52:08 |c|~hollywood|yes i just explained why
  1364. 15:52:27 |c|~hollywood|i think what it boils down to is the niche of D rank mons being important enough to include it
  1365. 15:52:31 |userstats|total:23|guests:0| :15|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1366. 15:52:39 |c|@Montsegur|I think so
  1367. 15:52:52 |c|@Montsegur|I think that caters more to the average / slightly above average player
  1368. 15:52:54 |c|#Disjunction|that and rank definitions
  1369. 15:53:05 |c|@Montsegur|who has gotten used to the top rank mons and is starting to expiriment a bit
  1370. 15:53:59 |c|@Montsegur|should we take a 15 minute coffee break?
  1371. 15:54:09 |c|~hollywood|i just got back -_-
  1372. 15:54:10 |c|#Disjunction|I have to leave in 45
  1373. 15:54:11 |c|@Montsegur|cause kiyo and ras aren't here and blast is busy flying planes
  1374. 15:54:28 |c|@Montsegur|this might need to be a two part discussion :/
  1375. 15:54:41 |c|&raseri|im here
  1376. 15:54:44 |c|&raseri|now
  1377. 15:54:47 |c|&raseri|im tired tho
  1378. 15:54:48 |c|@Kiyo|im here now
  1379. 15:54:48 |c|&raseri|:s
  1380. 15:54:53 |c|@Kiyo|football soon tho
  1381. 15:54:56 |c|&raseri|o
  1382. 15:55:00 |c|@Kiyo|maybe wecan carry into pms?
  1383. 15:55:00 |c|@Montsegur|ok lets continue then and at least get the definitions done today
  1384. 15:55:03 |c|&raseri|ya
  1385. 15:55:07 |c|&raseri|what do we have
  1386. 15:55:08 |c|&raseri|so far
  1387. 15:55:11 |c|@Kiyo|^
  1388. 15:55:15 |c|~hollywood|is there anything else important other than definitions?
  1389. 15:55:22 |c|@Montsegur|inflation
  1390. 15:55:23 |c|~hollywood|reranking i guess but that doesnt need to be done in realtime
  1391. 15:55:29 |c|@Montsegur|and a possible new letter to adjust for that
  1392. 15:55:33 |c|#Disjunction|yeah I think if we got definitions in place we could just re-rank all of the mons
  1393. 15:55:39 |c|#Disjunction|and we'd have an accurate list
  1394. 15:55:56 |c|&raseri|dont put things in ranks higher than they deserve
  1395. 15:56:00 |c|&raseri|dont be hesitant to drop bad shit
  1396. 15:56:07 |c|@Montsegur|inflation is part of the reason why this all happened, and since we have more viable mons that need to be ranked than certain ranks seem over inflated
  1397. 15:56:13 |c|#Disjunction|yea mont is really stingy about dropping blatantly bad shit
  1398. 15:56:15 |c|#Disjunction|like Simipour
  1399. 15:56:19 |c|#Disjunction|>:(
  1400. 15:56:26 |c|@Montsegur|so unrank lapras
  1401. 15:56:27 |c|@Montsegur|got it
  1402. 15:56:30 |c|@Blast Chance|^
  1403. 15:56:31 |c|~hollywood|you know what else would help with overinflation
  1404. 15:56:39 |c|~hollywood|only doing suggested reranks
  1405. 15:56:48 |c|~hollywood|and not just throwing out the list for everyone to comment on
  1406. 15:57:05 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo suggested doing definitions down to B and then start ranking them
  1407. 15:57:12 |c|@Montsegur|and then we can see if overinflation is an issue
  1408. 15:57:17 |c|@Kiyo|i think we need to look at mons more frequently
  1409. 15:57:17 |c|@Montsegur|if it isn't great
  1410. 15:57:26 |c|@Montsegur|if it is then we can fix it when we get there
  1411. 15:57:29 |c|@Kiyo|like there are mons that havent had discussion
  1412. 15:57:31 |c|@Kiyo|since xy
  1413. 15:57:32 |c|~hollywood|i mean like i said defining b/c is less important
  1414. 15:57:35 |c|~hollywood|"less good than a rank"
  1415. 15:57:39 |c|~hollywood|"less good than b rank"
  1416. 15:57:39 |c|@Kiyo|we should re look at each section weekly
  1417. 15:57:58 |L| Blaziken1337
  1418. 15:58:01 |c|~hollywood|yea a full revamp would help with that
  1419. 15:58:01 |c|@Montsegur|I have free weekends now
  1420. 15:58:05 |c|~hollywood|we did the same in bw2
  1421. 15:58:08 |c|~hollywood|and it helped a ton
  1422. 15:58:08 |c|@Montsegur|but thats hard to do with everyones schedule
  1423. 15:58:16 |c|~hollywood|not everyone has to be there
  1424. 15:58:20 |J| LeoLancaster
  1425. 15:58:20 |c|@Montsegur|i think that biweekly is more managble
  1426. 15:58:26 |L| mazanya
  1427. 15:58:28 |c|~hollywood|when we did it in bw2, it was
  1428. 15:58:30 |c|&raseri|free viability council
  1429. 15:58:31 |c|~hollywood|me, ras, ebeast
  1430. 15:58:35 |c|~hollywood|and i think flcl for like half the time
  1431. 15:58:36 |c|@Montsegur|raseri I did that
  1432. 15:58:38 |c|@Kiyo|like even if its 3 people
  1433. 15:58:39 |c|@Montsegur|nerd keep up
  1434. 15:58:42 |c|~hollywood|i even convinced them to put stantler in D
  1435. 15:58:45 |c|@Kiyo|and we just run it by everyone else in a pm
  1436. 15:58:47 |c|&raseri|stantler was good
  1437. 15:58:48 |c|@Kiyo|i think its ok
  1438. 15:58:48 |c|~hollywood|and it stayed there for a couple months
  1439. 15:58:49 |c|~hollywood|:)
  1440. 15:58:50 |c|&raseri|it beat mola
  1441. 15:58:57 |c|~hollywood|best wallbreaker
  1442. 15:59:00 |c|&raseri|i was mainly just a tyrunt
  1443. 15:59:03 |c|&raseri|in bw viability
  1444. 15:59:09 |c|@Montsegur|Kiyo the one issue with the PM is that no one replies in a timely fashion
  1445. 15:59:15 |c|@Montsegur|aside from like hollywood
  1446. 15:59:16 |c|@Kiyo|then fuck em
  1447. 15:59:18 |c|&raseri|^
  1448. 15:59:19 |c|&raseri|fuck em
  1449. 15:59:25 |c|@Montsegur|with the last viability council
  1450. 15:59:27 |c|@Kiyo|if they cant be active they dont get a say
  1451. 15:59:29 |c|&raseri|no reply = no opibion
  1452. 15:59:32 |c|#Disjunction|yea honestly the people who are on right now
  1453. 15:59:36 |c|#Disjunction|are the only people who would respond
  1454. 15:59:38 |c|#Disjunction|+finch
  1455. 15:59:40 |c|@Montsegur|or raseri saying only list the important changes
  1456. 15:59:40 |c|@Montsegur|lol
  1457. 15:59:43 |c|#Disjunction|but finch would just yell
  1458. 15:59:43 |c|#Disjunction|D:
  1459. 15:59:55 |c|@Montsegur|finch is in his rebel stage
  1460. 15:59:57 |c|@Montsegur|as a teenager
  1461. 16:00:03 |c|&raseri|so
  1462. 16:00:05 |L| ShadowDragoon666
  1463. 16:00:06 |c|&raseri|free council
  1464. 16:00:08 |c|&raseri|fuk piratepad
  1465. 16:00:11 |c|@Montsegur|I did that
  1466. 16:00:13 |c|&raseri|it just ends up as memes
  1467. 16:00:17 |c|~hollywood|so do pms
  1468. 16:00:18 |c|~hollywood|lol
  1469. 16:00:18 |c|&raseri|do it again
  1470. 16:00:36 |c|#Disjunction|oh another thing
  1471. 16:00:37 |c|@Montsegur|Ok I'll make a PM after this is done
  1472. 16:00:37 |c|&raseri|and focusing more on things brought up in the thread
  1473. 16:00:37 |c|@Kiyo|new pm
  1474. 16:00:38 |c|#Disjunction|I had on the paste
  1475. 16:00:39 |c|@Kiyo|nice.
  1476. 16:00:42 |c|#Disjunction|was discussing S/S-
  1477. 16:00:44 |c|&raseri|add tennis so we can have
  1478. 16:00:45 |c|&raseri|donuts
  1479. 16:00:50 |c|@Kiyo|we dont need S / S-
  1480. 16:00:52 |c|#Disjunction|:donut:
  1481. 16:00:55 |c|@Kiyo|if a mon is borderline S
  1482. 16:00:57 |c|@Kiyo|its A+
  1483. 16:00:59 |c|@Kiyo|or should be
  1484. 16:01:02 |c|@Kiyo|see: magmortar
  1485. 16:01:03 |c|&raseri|^
  1486. 16:01:08 |c|@Kiyo|should be A+
  1487. 16:01:09 |c|@Blast Chance|ya
  1488. 16:01:13 |c|#Disjunction|I feel like
  1489. 16:01:14 |c|@Kiyo|i took a step back and looked at it
  1490. 16:01:15 |c|@Montsegur|-
  1491. 16:01:15 |c|#Disjunction|we're going around
  1492. 16:01:17 |c|@Blast Chance|no s+ or s-
  1493. 16:01:17 |c|~hollywood|what changed your mind
  1494. 16:01:17 |c|#Disjunction|in circles now
  1495. 16:01:21 |c|@Montsegur|nigga noms it for S
  1496. 16:01:29 |c|@Montsegur|and now that he caught flak wants it in A+
  1497. 16:01:33 |c|~hollywood|yes so you ask him why he changed his mind about it
  1498. 16:01:37 |c|~hollywood|rather than pointing fingers
  1499. 16:01:47 |c|@Montsegur|you asked for me :)
  1500. 16:01:47 |c|#Disjunction|I honestly still support mag for S
  1501. 16:01:50 |c|@Kiyo|it doesnt have the staying power it needs to be effective
  1502. 16:01:52 |c|&raseri|don-don donuts, let's go nuts
  1503. 16:01:55 |c|~hollywood|common courtesy 101: how not to be a dick
  1504. 16:02:15 |c|~hollywood|magmortar is also ugly
  1505. 16:02:21 |c|@Montsegur|its a duck
  1506. 16:02:24 |L| LeoLancaster
  1507. 16:02:26 |c|@Kiyo|its also partially due to the fact aht
  1508. 16:02:31 |userstats|total:20|guests:0| :12|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1509. 16:02:32 |c|@Kiyo|i want to abuse lilligant and vivillon
  1510. 16:02:35 |c|~hollywood|it's not a duck
  1511. 16:02:37 |c|@Kiyo|and idont want people to know mag is good
  1512. 16:02:38 |J| pus shaneghoul
  1513. 16:02:38 |c|&raseri|booburn
  1514. 16:02:38 |c|#Disjunction|Mag is quite splashable, it's consistent no matter which set you use, it's reliable despite its reliance on Focus Blast
  1515. 16:02:44 |c|@Montsegur|wait magmar is the duck
  1516. 16:02:48 |c|~hollywood|i never thought it was reliable
  1517. 16:02:51 |c|@Kiyo|i mean i can still argue it for S
  1518. 16:02:57 |c|@Kiyo|but i think its borderline
  1519. 16:02:59 |c|#Disjunction|and I don't think I even need to talk about its threat level or effect on the meta
  1520. 16:03:02 |c|@Kiyo|im happy with S or A+
  1521. 16:03:02 |c|&raseri|its a+ imo
  1522. 16:03:02 |c|~hollywood|it's matchup-dependent
  1523. 16:03:11 |c|~hollywood|it just so happens that a lot of people in nu dont know how to play non-balance
  1524. 16:03:11 |c|@Montsegur|lets get back to the definitions
  1525. 16:03:12 |c|@Kiyo|its really not matchup dependent
  1526. 16:03:14 |c|@Blast Chance|if it's borderline just put it a+ then
  1527. 16:03:16 |c|@Montsegur|we've got A
  1528. 16:03:17 |c|@Kiyo|it just shits on all playstyles
  1529. 16:03:18 |c|@Kiyo|lol
  1530. 16:03:19 |c|~hollywood|and that's mag's best matchup
  1531. 16:03:21 |c|&raseri|not rain
  1532. 16:03:22 |c|~hollywood|it's sO bad vs offense
  1533. 16:03:23 |c|&raseri|:)
  1534. 16:03:50 |c|#Disjunction|at least this proved that the new criteria is still subjective
  1535. 16:03:54 |c|~hollywood|definitions
  1536. 16:03:59 |c|~hollywood|S rank: hammered out
  1537. 16:03:59 |c|#Disjunction|it'll at least provide structure to posts
  1538. 16:04:00 |c|@Kiyo|nah dude mag functions well vs offense
  1539. 16:04:05 |c|@Kiyo|its just not a free switch in to shit
  1540. 16:04:09 |c|@Kiyo|like it is vs balance
  1541. 16:04:11 |c|~hollywood|A rank: S-rank definitions, just not as S-rank
  1542. 16:04:19 |c|~hollywood|B: replace S with A
  1543. 16:04:21 |c|&raseri|b-rank: worse than a rank but still good
  1544. 16:04:24 |c|~hollywood|C: replace A with B
  1545. 16:04:33 |c|&raseri|d: niche shit
  1546. 16:04:37 |c|&raseri|e: bad shit
  1547. 16:04:46 |c|~hollywood|E: might have a niche but that niche isnt important enough to consider it for a serious team
  1548. 16:04:50 |c|@Montsegur|but C rank mons might fill out 4/5 but not be B
  1549. 16:04:58 |c|&raseri|owell
  1550. 16:05:06 |c|&raseri|if it barely fills 4/5
  1551. 16:05:07 |c|&raseri|it can be c
  1552. 16:05:10 |c|&raseri|we can be subjective
  1553. 16:05:22 |c|~hollywood|a C rank pokemon can't fill 4/5
  1554. 16:05:25 |c|&raseri|the criteria are a starting point
  1555. 16:05:29 |c|&raseri|not an ending point
  1556. 16:05:30 |c|~hollywood|if it does those things but not well
  1557. 16:05:30 |c|&raseri|imo
  1558. 16:05:35 |c|~hollywood|it doesnt really do those things at all does it
  1559. 16:05:43 |c|&raseri|aurorus for s
  1560. 16:05:48 |c|~hollywood|if youd never use that pokemon for that thing
  1561. 16:05:55 |c|~hollywood|then it doesnt really do it
  1562. 16:05:58 |raw|<div class="broadcast-blue"><b>&amp;raseri: aurorus for s</b></div>
  1563. 16:05:58 |c|~hollywood|even if it does
  1564. 16:06:02 |c|~hollywood|stop.
  1565. 16:06:23 |c|~hollywood|what are the criteria we wanted out of S?
  1566. 16:06:25 |c|@Montsegur|ok so we have the definitions that we want to apply to every mon
  1567. 16:06:25 |c|&raseri|ugh fck my headphones are breaking
  1568. 16:06:32 |c|@Montsegur|and we don't wanna change them per rank
  1569. 16:06:43 |c|@Montsegur|or not to a serious extent
  1570. 16:06:50 |c|@Montsegur|just the amount of change you mentioned above
  1571. 16:06:59 |c|@Blast Chance|so what's the definition of s anyway
  1572. 16:07:06 |c|~hollywood|i just asked that
  1573. 16:07:08 |c|#Disjunction|criteria for S should be fulfilling all 5 criteria with a limited number of the negative criteria
  1574. 16:07:09 |c|~hollywood|still wanting it
  1575. 16:07:17 |c|@Montsegur|Disjunction can you list
  1576. 16:07:20 |c|@Montsegur|the pros / cons pls
  1577. 16:07:25 |c|@Montsegur|cause you said you were keeping a list
  1578. 16:07:28 |N| HATE IDIOTS|metaphysical
  1579. 16:07:37 |c|~hollywood|note i also dont think definitions are actually that important
  1580. 16:07:41 |c|~hollywood|you can twist anything to fit anything
  1581. 16:07:44 |c|#Disjunction|passive, outclassed, weak to hazards, speed, general bulk, matchup
  1582. 16:07:52 |c|#Disjunction|for negatives
  1583. 16:07:53 |c|#Disjunction|Splashability, reliability, consistency, threat level, and effect on metagame
  1584. 16:07:55 |c|#Disjunction|for positives
  1585. 16:08:01 |c|@Montsegur|no matter what we do its gonna be somewhat subjective
  1586. 16:08:10 |c|~hollywood|yea like no C rank mon
  1587. 16:08:13 |c|~hollywood|should be splashable and reliable
  1588. 16:08:45 |c|@Blast Chance|definitions are still important for the initial ranks
  1589. 16:08:50 |c|@Blast Chance|after that
  1590. 16:08:57 |c|@Blast Chance|you can just compare the mons
  1591. 16:09:00 |c|@Blast Chance|in those ranks
  1592. 16:09:04 |c|~hollywood|so i guess we can more clearly define the lower ranks
  1593. 16:09:13 |c|~hollywood|i dont expect any C rank pokemon to be splashable or reliable
  1594. 16:09:14 |L| Pokedots
  1595. 16:09:15 |c|~hollywood|if it was it wouldnt be C rank
  1596. 16:09:26 |c|@Montsegur|blast we wanted to avoid doing that though
  1597. 16:09:32 |c|~hollywood|in fact i dont really expect any of those except maybe threat level to apply to C rank
  1598. 16:09:54 |c|#Disjunction|it might have ok levels of consistency
  1599. 16:10:01 |c|@Montsegur|C rank mons can be consistent
  1600. 16:10:07 |c|~hollywood|why?
  1601. 16:10:21 |c|~hollywood|there aren't so many consistent pokemon that we can't fit them all in B or higher
  1602. 16:10:22 |c|@Montsegur|the job that they might be doing might not be warrant a higher rank
  1603. 16:10:32 |c|#Disjunction|Rampardos is very consistent at its job of setting Stealth Rock
  1604. 16:10:36 |c|@Montsegur|like I would argue that miltank is a p consistent pokemon at setting up rocks and paralyzing shit
  1605. 16:10:51 |c|@Montsegur|but I don't think it should be a B mon
  1606. 16:10:58 |c|~hollywood|yes but that doesnt make it a consistent pokemon
  1607. 16:11:07 |c|~hollywood|if you only wanted a consistent stealth rock setter
  1608. 16:11:13 |c|@Montsegur|it consistently sets up rocks and paralyzes stuff?
  1609. 16:11:14 |c|@Blast Chance|I thought c rank was like for things
  1610. 16:11:20 |c|~hollywood|nvm that should really never be a thing
  1611. 16:11:21 |c|~hollywood|lol
  1612. 16:11:21 |c|@Blast Chance|that are consistent
  1613. 16:11:25 |c|@Blast Chance|just not practical
  1614. 16:11:28 |c|@Blast Chance|usually
  1615. 16:11:31 |c|#Disjunction|Blast just try and forget
  1616. 16:11:35 |c|#Disjunction|what VR has been up until now
  1617. 16:11:37 |c|~hollywood|i dont think something can be impractical and consistent
  1618. 16:11:38 |c|#Disjunction|we're trying to rework it
  1619. 16:12:18 |c|@Montsegur|miltank fits some of the more negative criteria though
  1620. 16:12:23 |c|@Montsegur|which is why it should be ranked lower
  1621. 16:12:24 |c|#Disjunction|yes
  1622. 16:12:27 |c|#Disjunction|I was about to say
  1623. 16:12:31 |userstats|total:20|guests:0| :12|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1624. 16:12:36 |c|#Disjunction|we're not only judging them based on the positive criteria
  1625. 16:12:37 |c|~hollywood|yea i'm looking at Cs
  1626. 16:12:44 |c|~hollywood|and i really dont see anything consistent or splashable
  1627. 16:13:04 |c|@Montsegur|I'd say there are a lot of consistent rock setters
  1628. 16:13:05 |c|~hollywood|anything that could be considered either
  1629. 16:13:10 |c|@Montsegur|but a lot of them are either passive
  1630. 16:13:10 |c|#Disjunction|ok how about we make Consistency and Splashability a requirement for B rank and up
  1631. 16:13:11 |c|~hollywood|is much less so than other things in higher ranks
  1632. 16:13:18 |L| Jizznado
  1633. 16:13:28 |c|#Disjunction|that leaves three positive requirements for C Ranks
  1634. 16:13:31 |c|~hollywood|carbink can consistently set stealth rock
  1635. 16:13:35 |c|~hollywood|but that doesnt make it a consistent pokemon
  1636. 16:13:41 |c|@Montsegur|a lot of the positive traits get over shadowed by the mons negative traights
  1637. 16:13:44 |c|&raseri|so can graveller
  1638. 16:13:45 |c|&raseri|:)
  1639. 16:13:52 |c|@Montsegur|which is how it should be in the lower ranks
  1640. 16:13:55 |c|~hollywood|you almost never want a pokemon strictly for the job of getting up stealth rock
  1641. 16:14:34 |c|~hollywood|"consistent rocks setter" is not a role but a trait
  1642. 16:14:50 |c|@Montsegur|like I'd say ninjask can consistently uturn on things, but its crippling rock weakness and somewhat weaker of a uturn makes it a C rank mon
  1643. 16:15:00 |c|~hollywood|yes and "consistent u-turner" is not a role
  1644. 16:15:03 |c|~hollywood|it's a trait
  1645. 16:15:23 |c|#Disjunction|what would your example of a Pokemon that fills the consistent role be, holly?
  1646. 16:15:26 |c|~hollywood|"consistent pokemon" should be all around consistent in the things it does
  1647. 16:15:34 |c|#Disjunction|if "fulfilling its intended purpose" is not what you're looking for
  1648. 16:15:51 |c|~hollywood|fulfilling its intended purpose is what i'm looking for
  1649. 16:15:59 |c|~hollywood|ninjask's intended purpose isnt to use u-turn
  1650. 16:16:10 |c|@Montsegur|its to outpace things and grab momentum
  1651. 16:16:11 |c|~hollywood|rampardos's intended purpose isnt to use stealth rock
  1652. 16:16:19 |c|~hollywood|those things are important parts of them
  1653. 16:16:25 |c|~hollywood|but if that was all they did they would never see use
  1654. 16:16:41 |c|~hollywood|ninjask doesnt hit very hard which is why it uses u-turn so much
  1655. 16:16:46 |c|#Disjunction|the only reason I would use Rampardos is its Stealth Rock set, though
  1656. 16:16:48 |c|~hollywood|so it's not a consistent offensive pokemon in comparison to scyther
  1657. 16:16:56 |c|~hollywood|which hits hard and gets momentum and is fast
  1658. 16:16:59 |c|#Disjunction|I don't care about anything else Rampardos does as long as it gets Stealth Rock
  1659. 16:17:06 |c|@Montsegur|so for below B rank we should just rank it based on how little negatives it fills out?
  1660. 16:17:06 |c|~hollywood|rampardos sets stealth rock but it's also really strong
  1661. 16:17:17 |c|~hollywood|if you just wanted to get up stealth rock you'd be better off using carbink
  1662. 16:17:30 |c|@Montsegur|carbink doesn't have mold breaker
  1663. 16:17:32 |c|#Disjunction|that's not true
  1664. 16:17:43 |c|#Disjunction|if I wanted a dedicated rocker I wouldn't ignore Carbink entirely
  1665. 16:17:45 |c|#Disjunction|and go for Rhydon
  1666. 16:17:54 |c|~hollywood|yes because rhydon is consistent in many ways
  1667. 16:17:56 |c|~hollywood|not just setting stealth rock
  1668. 16:18:01 |c|#Disjunction|so while Carbink has a level of consistency it is entirely outclassed by Rhydon
  1669. 16:18:06 |c|~hollywood|rampardos sees little usage because it's only consistent in one way
  1670. 16:18:12 |c|@Montsegur|but if he needs something to get up rocks against xatu teams then he would go for rampardos
  1671. 16:18:23 |c|~hollywood|so it isn't a "consistent pokemon" even if it is "consistent" in its main intended role
  1672. 16:18:36 |c|@Montsegur|i dont follow
  1673. 16:18:39 |c|@Montsegur|i kind of do
  1674. 16:18:47 |c|&raseri|raspardos
  1675. 16:18:49 |J| geeezeer
  1676. 16:18:52 |c|&raseri|(i dont have anything to contribute)
  1677. 16:18:54 |c|#Disjunction|Rampardos doesn't have the same level as splashability as Rhydon, though
  1678. 16:19:13 |c|#Disjunction|I guess it isn't consistent either
  1679. 16:19:15 |c|#Disjunction|as a Stealth Rocker
  1680. 16:19:19 |c|@Montsegur|but it still consistently sets up rocks
  1681. 16:19:20 |c|#Disjunction|because it only has one shot to do it
  1682. 16:19:23 |c|~hollywood|miltank consistently paralyzes things and sets stealth rock
  1683. 16:19:24 |c|@Montsegur|cept against taunt
  1684. 16:19:24 |c|#Disjunction|it reliably sets them up
  1685. 16:19:27 |c|#Disjunction|but not consistently
  1686. 16:19:32 |c|#Disjunction|reliable =/= consistent
  1687. 16:19:33 |c|~hollywood|however, it's also setup fodder for klinklang and rhydon
  1688. 16:19:42 |c|@Montsegur|I'd argue that things in D / even C- shouldn't be consistent
  1689. 16:19:42 |c|~hollywood|which are two really high threat pokemon in the tier
  1690. 16:19:48 |c|#Disjunction|which would be
  1691. 16:19:50 |c|#Disjunction|its matchup
  1692. 16:19:57 |c|#Disjunction|referring to another negative we have listed
  1693. 16:19:59 |c|~hollywood|so it might be consistent in those roles but other pokemon can fulfill those roles while also beating those things
  1694. 16:20:03 |L| geeezeer
  1695. 16:20:14 |c|~hollywood|everything ranked should be consistent in some way
  1696. 16:20:17 |c|@Montsegur|which means its outclassed
  1697. 16:20:21 |c|~hollywood|that doesnt make everything ranked a consistent pokemon
  1698. 16:20:26 |c|~hollywood|yes, outclassed means inconsistent
  1699. 16:20:34 |c|#Disjunction|I wouldn't say that
  1700. 16:20:38 |c|~hollywood|if it were more consistent in those important roles, it wouldn't be outclassed
  1701. 16:20:48 |c|~hollywood|i guess it ties into splashability
  1702. 16:20:59 |c|@Montsegur|a lot of these things tie into each other
  1703. 16:21:10 |c|~hollywood|yes miltank is consistent in x roles but rhydon is also consistent in those x roles while also being consistent in y roles
  1704. 16:21:11 |c|@Montsegur|we're just trying to make it easier to understand for everyone
  1705. 16:21:16 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1706. 16:21:27 |c|~hollywood|i dont personally consider miltank consistent
  1707. 16:21:30 |c|~hollywood|if i did i'd use it
  1708. 16:21:44 |c|@Montsegur|which ties back to the subjectivity of all of this
  1709. 16:21:46 |c|~hollywood|but it's also definitely not nearly as splashable as higher ranked support pokemon
  1710. 16:22:00 |L| Gargamod
  1711. 16:22:04 |c|~hollywood|and its threat level is minimal vs most teams
  1712. 16:22:09 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1713. 16:22:21 |c|@Montsegur|and it also has negative traits that affect it
  1714. 16:22:24 |c|#Disjunction|I think holly's argument could lead to another positive trait
  1715. 16:22:27 |c|#Disjunction|that some mons should follow
  1716. 16:22:31 |userstats|total:18|guests:0| :10|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1717. 16:22:31 |c|#Disjunction|miltank IS a consistent rocker
  1718. 16:22:34 |c|#Disjunction|but it doesn't do much else
  1719. 16:22:35 |c|~hollywood|volbeat is really consistent in its role
  1720. 16:22:41 |c|#Disjunction|so perhaps number of roles a mon can fill in one slot
  1721. 16:22:42 |c|~hollywood|it's one of, if not THE best, in its job
  1722. 16:22:47 |c|~hollywood|but its job isnt that important
  1723. 16:22:47 |c|#Disjunction|is another positive criteria we could include?
  1724. 16:22:52 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1725. 16:22:54 |c|~hollywood|because the archetype you use it on is not consistent
  1726. 16:22:57 |c|#Disjunction|like Rhydon fills 5/6 defensive niches
  1727. 16:23:02 |c|#Disjunction|along with a couple offensive ones
  1728. 16:23:02 |c|~hollywood|that would be versatility/splashability
  1729. 16:23:08 |N| shaneghoul|pusshaneghoul
  1730. 16:23:11 |c|@Montsegur|like rhydon can be rocks / defensive / specially / CM phsycic check
  1731. 16:23:22 |c|@Montsegur|versatility is like rhydon can be defensive and offensive
  1732. 16:23:28 |c|~hollywood|weak to fighting and dislikes knock off, still beats malamar
  1733. 16:23:31 |c|~hollywood|:-)
  1734. 16:23:33 |c|@Montsegur|ya
  1735. 16:23:42 |c|@Montsegur|so thats a role that you can put onto your team
  1736. 16:23:48 |c|#Disjunction|I'd prefer rewording splashability to versatility then
  1737. 16:23:50 |c|~hollywood|do based on
  1738. 16:23:51 |c|@Montsegur|cause you need some way to beat malamar on a good team
  1739. 16:23:52 |c|#Disjunction|and explicitly defining it
  1740. 16:23:57 |c|~hollywood|splashability/consistency/threat level
  1741. 16:24:00 |c|~hollywood|what are the other ones?
  1742. 16:24:03 |c|@Montsegur|versatility isn't splashability tho
  1743. 16:24:06 |c|@Montsegur|imo
  1744. 16:24:12 |c|~hollywood|if a pokemon is versatile it's splashable
  1745. 16:24:15 |c|#Disjunction|reliability and effect on meta
  1746. 16:24:16 |J| Pokedots
  1747. 16:24:18 |c|~hollywood|the reverse isnt
  1748. 16:24:20 |c|~hollywood|inherently true
  1749. 16:24:26 |c|~hollywood|but it's usually the case
  1750. 16:24:28 |N| pus shaneghoul|shaneghoul
  1751. 16:24:29 |c|@Blast Chance|tauros has one set
  1752. 16:24:41 |c|#Disjunction|yes but that one set fills a number of offensive niches
  1753. 16:24:52 |c|~hollywood|ok so
  1754. 16:24:54 |c|@Montsegur|tauros has 3 sets :(
  1755. 16:24:56 |c|#Disjunction|so its not all about how many different sets a mon can run
  1756. 16:24:58 |c|@Montsegur|its only ranked for one tho
  1757. 16:24:59 |c|~hollywood|checklist for archeops
  1758. 16:25:07 |c|@Montsegur|versatile
  1759. 16:25:09 |c|~hollywood|i think it has a very high threat level
  1760. 16:25:13 |c|@Montsegur|y
  1761. 16:25:21 |c|~hollywood|i dont think any of the others
  1762. 16:25:25 |c|~hollywood|necessarily apply
  1763. 16:25:26 |c|@Montsegur|its pretty splashable across offensive teams
  1764. 16:25:32 |c|~hollywood|i strongly disagree
  1765. 16:25:38 |c|~hollywood|and even if that is the case
  1766. 16:25:40 |c|#Disjunction|it has a strong effect on the meta
  1767. 16:25:42 |c|~hollywood|that's just offensive teams
  1768. 16:25:47 |c|#Disjunction|it forces you to run flying checks
  1769. 16:25:52 |c|~hollywood|i dont think it has that strong of an effect on the meta either
  1770. 16:25:59 |c|~hollywood|that's true, but good teams should have flying checks anywas
  1771. 16:26:03 |c|#Disjunction|you don't run flying checks for any other mons
  1772. 16:26:03 |c|~hollywood|even if archeops wasnt in the tier
  1773. 16:26:11 |c|#Disjunction|it's literally just chops
  1774. 16:26:12 |c|@Montsegur|swellow
  1775. 16:26:17 |c|~hollywood|you run normal checks
  1776. 16:26:19 |c|#Disjunction|swellow doesn't run flying stabs now
  1777. 16:26:22 |c|~hollywood|which are also flying checks
  1778. 16:26:31 |c|@Montsegur|who doesn't run BB on physical swellow
  1779. 16:26:31 |c|#Disjunction|that's not true
  1780. 16:26:34 |c|~hollywood|yes
  1781. 16:26:35 |c|~hollywood|it is
  1782. 16:26:35 |c|#Disjunction|if you're running rocks yea
  1783. 16:26:40 |c|~hollywood|and physical swellow isnt good
  1784. 16:26:40 |c|#Disjunction|but if you're running ghosts or gurdurr
  1785. 16:26:41 |c|~hollywood|=\
  1786. 16:26:44 |c|#Disjunction|as your normal checks
  1787. 16:26:46 |c|~hollywood|you dont run ghosts to check normals
  1788. 16:26:49 |c|#Disjunction|those aren't flying resists
  1789. 16:26:52 |c|~hollywood|because then you get stomped by kanga
  1790. 16:27:01 |c|~hollywood|barring maybe like
  1791. 16:27:02 |c|~hollywood|gourgeist
  1792. 16:27:32 |c|#Disjunction|sometimes my teams are just naturally good against kanga
  1793. 16:27:36 |c|~hollywood|also you run flying checks for scyther too
  1794. 16:27:50 |c|@Blast Chance|yeah idt archeops is that splashable
  1795. 16:27:52 |c|~hollywood|and vivillon
  1796. 16:27:55 |c|~hollywood|because you run rhydon
  1797. 16:27:59 |c|~hollywood|which covers all of these things
  1798. 16:27:59 |c|~hollywood|lol
  1799. 16:28:05 |c|@Blast Chance|all it really does is hit hard
  1800. 16:28:13 |c|~hollywood|i really dont think archeops has a large effect on the metagame/teambuilding
  1801. 16:28:17 |c|@Blast Chance|at least on offense
  1802. 16:28:36 |c|~hollywood|it's also
  1803. 16:28:41 |c|~hollywood|impossible to counter in the teambuilder
  1804. 16:28:43 |c|~hollywood|so you just
  1805. 16:28:46 |c|~hollywood|dont really bother countering it
  1806. 16:29:00 |c|~hollywood|which goes further into power level
  1807. 16:29:04 |c|~hollywood|or whatever wording we decided for that
  1808. 16:29:14 |c|@Montsegur|threat level?
  1809. 16:29:15 |c|@Montsegur|splashability, reliability, consistency, threat level, and effect on metagame
  1810. 16:29:15 |c|~hollywood|but takes away from the other cats
  1811. 16:29:19 |c|~hollywood|yea threat level
  1812. 16:29:32 |c|~hollywood|tauros, on the other hand
  1813. 16:29:34 |c|~hollywood|i think fits all of those
  1814. 16:29:46 |c|~hollywood|effect on the metagame less than the others, but it's still there
  1815. 16:30:00 |c|@Montsegur|ok so if a mon excels really well at one then it can give a boost to the others?
  1816. 16:30:08 |c|~hollywood|i dont think so
  1817. 16:30:18 |c|#Disjunction|I still don't think chops deserves S
  1818. 16:30:21 |c|~hollywood|i dont think archeops should be s
  1819. 16:30:23 |c|@Blast Chance|me neither
  1820. 16:30:25 |c|~hollywood|havent for a while
  1821. 16:30:34 |c|@Blast Chance|but everyone else does haha!
  1822. 16:30:51 |c|~hollywood|i originally got it up there
  1823. 16:30:53 |c|~hollywood|but that was
  1824. 16:30:56 |c|~hollywood|mega steelix meta
  1825. 16:30:57 |c|@Montsegur|and when I moved it down there was a shit storm (partially cause we didn't discuss it)
  1826. 16:31:00 |c|~hollywood|which was a very long time ago
  1827. 16:31:06 |c|~hollywood|yea you should
  1828. 16:31:10 |c|~hollywood|not give into shitstorms
  1829. 16:31:11 |c|@Blast Chance|well yeah we shouldve
  1830. 16:31:12 |c|#Disjunction|but while I don't think it deserves S, it definitely has a strong impact on the meta imo
  1831. 16:31:16 |c|~hollywood|just make sure everyone is on board before you do something
  1832. 16:31:19 |c|~hollywood|then you can pin it on us
  1833. 16:31:28 |c|~hollywood|and they'll get mad at us instead
  1834. 16:31:35 |c|@Montsegur|I do that half the time but I take responsability when i also agree
  1835. 16:31:36 |c|@Blast Chance|lol
  1836. 16:32:03 |c|~hollywood|the problem with archeops is that even offensive teams still want defensive synergy
  1837. 16:32:09 |c|~hollywood|and archeops offers little to none
  1838. 16:32:14 |c|@Montsegur|bulkchops
  1839. 16:32:20 |c|~hollywood|because it cant even switch into most resisted hits without going into defeatist
  1840. 16:32:31 |userstats|total:19|guests:0| :11|+:2|%:0|@:3|★:0|#:1|&:1|~:1
  1841. 16:32:33 |c|~hollywood|bulkychops is ass and has basically always been ass
  1842. 16:32:37 |c|~hollywood|just use offensive defog
  1843. 16:32:47 |c|@Blast Chance|no that sounds even worse
  1844. 16:32:51 |c|~hollywood|nah it's good
  1845. 16:32:56 |c|@Montsegur|i like offensive defog
  1846. 16:32:57 |c|~hollywood|you just dont use it as a dedicated hazard remover
  1847. 16:33:07 |c|~hollywood|helps vs spikes-stack
  1848. 16:33:17 |c|@Montsegur|i like late game defoggers
  1849. 16:33:33 |c|@Montsegur|cause most people think you'll defog right away if you have it
  1850. 16:33:36 |c|~hollywood|you cant really use bulky archeops as a dedicated hazard remover either
  1851. 16:33:44 |c|~hollywood|which is why i like offensive defog so much more
  1852. 16:33:50 |c|#Disjunction|ok well
  1853. 16:33:52 |c|#Disjunction|in any case
  1854. 16:33:57 |c|~hollywood|so hard to find free turns defensively with it
  1855. 16:33:59 |c|#Disjunction|we're decided on the criteria-based system?
  1856. 16:34:00 |c|@Montsegur|i was thinking more of a normal check, which is what it originally was intended for (i think)
  1857. 16:34:01 |c|~hollywood|not hard to do the same offensively
  1858. 16:34:03 |c|~hollywood|i think so
  1859. 16:34:14 |c|#Disjunction|did we want to re-rank everything
  1860. 16:34:20 |c|@Montsegur|not today
  1861. 16:34:25 |c|~hollywood|yea just not now
  1862. 16:34:25 |c|@Montsegur|we can start
  1863. 16:34:32 |c|@Montsegur|I'll make a PM
  1864. 16:34:35 |c|#Disjunction|why not start a piratepad/pm
  1865. 16:34:36 |c|~hollywood|this would be the ideal situation to piratepad
  1866. 16:34:37 |c|@Montsegur|and we can do it over the next week
  1867. 16:34:37 |c|~hollywood|yea
  1868. 16:34:44 |c|#Disjunction|then we can work on it throughout the week
  1869. 16:34:50 |c|~hollywood|because we're not judging based on people's posts
  1870. 16:34:51 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1871. 16:34:55 |c|@Montsegur|**break**
  1872. 16:34:58 |c|@Montsegur|hut hut hike
  1873. 16:35:01 |c|#Disjunction|I gotta go in 5 anyhow
  1874. 16:35:02 |c|~hollywood|gross
  1875. 16:35:06 |c|~hollywood|my dad just turned on football
  1876. 16:35:14 |c|#Disjunction|(puke)
  1877. 16:35:15 |c|~hollywood|football is for BOYS
  1878. 16:35:16 |c|@Montsegur|we still need to include peoples posts
  1879. 16:35:23 |c|~hollywood|boys are ICKY AND HAVE COOTIES
  1880. 16:35:28 |c|~hollywood|yea but it's not the main focus
  1881. 16:35:32 |c|#Disjunction|just not in the preliminary ranks
  1882. 16:35:34 |c|#Disjunction|imo
  1883. 16:35:36 |c|@Montsegur|i would just include the general consensus of the thread as another vote
  1884. 16:35:47 |c|@Montsegur|anyways
  1885. 16:35:56 |c|@Montsegur|tis been fun, ill get the PM up now
  1886. 16:35:57 |c|#Disjunction|ok can I make post now or should we wait til we have ranks hammered out
  1887. 16:36:04 |c|@Montsegur|I'll make a post
  1888. 16:36:05 |c|@Montsegur|you can leave
  1889. 16:36:07 |c|#Disjunction|but I have
  1890. 16:36:08 |c|#Disjunction|logs
  1891. 16:36:09 |c|#Disjunction|nerd
  1892. 16:36:09 |c|@Montsegur|like you need to
  1893. 16:36:09 |c|~hollywood|hey guys vigoroth is rly good
  1894. 16:36:11 |N| shaneghoul|pusshaneghoul
  1895. 16:36:11 |c|~hollywood|read about it
  1896. 16:36:12 |c|~hollywood|http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/oras-nu-viability-rankings.3545276/page-12#post-6449005
  1897. 16:36:24 |L|~hollywood
  1898. 16:36:28 |c|@Blast Chance|(monkey)
  1899. 16:36:44 |c|#Disjunction|oh I guess
  1900. 16:36:47 |c|#Disjunction|I don't have logs
  1901. 16:36:52 |c|#Disjunction|oh well!
  1902. 16:36:55 |c|@Montsegur|yah
  1903. 16:37:00 |c|@Montsegur|hollwood needs to get them
  1904. 16:37:03 |c|@Montsegur|*y
  1905. 16:37:06 |c|@Blast Chance|lol
  1906. 16:37:15 |c|#Disjunction|it's not important
  1907. 16:37:18 |c|#Disjunction|i m o
  1908. 16:37:21 |L| Steakburgers
  1909. 16:37:41 |c|@Montsegur|raseri
  1910. 16:37:43 |c|@Montsegur|grab logs
  1911. 16:37:44 |c|@Montsegur|!
  1912. 16:37:48 |c|&raseri|ok
  1913. 16:38:28 |c|@Montsegur|ty
  1914. 16:38:32 |c|@Montsegur|paste em for me pls
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment