Advertisement
Guest User

Untitled

a guest
May 12th, 2016
89
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 12.55 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Jayden Steeves
  2. are dna is 99.9 percent similar to bananas? whats your point?
  3. Noah Rogers
  4. 5/11, 7:22pm
  5. Noah Rogers
  6. ... You're completely disregarding scientists findings that prove you wrong?
  7. I mean, what scientific discipline are you specializing in cuck
  8. Are you going to argue with geneticists and shit?
  9. Jayden Steeves
  10. 5/11, 7:24pm
  11. Jayden Steeves
  12. you understand 1 nucleotide can be the difference between being normal or having lots of disorders
  13. the "not enough variation" doesnt work
  14. Noah Rogers
  15. 5/11, 7:24pm
  16. Noah Rogers
  17. And you understand that what I linked you shows that the genetic ladder in most people, literally negligible variations based on small mutations, is what's proving you wrong here
  18. And that nucleotide thing is only pertinent with the functioning of minute parts of the brain
  19. You're grasping for straws here
  20. Plus, it takes the environment for these genes to come into fruition or to be expressed
  21. They don't just "show up"
  22. Most of them, anyway, the ones that aren't essential
  23. Jayden Steeves
  24. 5/11, 7:28pm
  25. Jayden Steeves
  26. "Although these IQ-based arguments for racialism are often used by white supremacists, taken to its logical conclusion, it would better support Asian or Jewish supremacy than white supremacy." Because I'm not a white supremacist? I know asians have a higher average iq as a race, meaning there is correlation between race and iq and its discernible by race
  27. Noah Rogers
  28. 5/11, 7:28pm
  29. Noah Rogers
  30. Are you familiar with cognitive dissonance Jayden
  31. IQ is directly correlated with the development of education
  32. It is the ability to logically deduce patterns lol
  33. The narrative the alti-right aka Nazis construct is such a bad one that I'm surprised you believe a word of it
  34. IQ as a concept is incoherent and wrong lol
  35. Jayden Steeves
  36. 5/11, 7:34pm
  37. Jayden Steeves
  38. there are more species difference in human types then elk and jaguar, but sub species for the animal called man is ebil racism
  39. Noah Rogers
  40. 5/11, 7:34pm
  41. Noah Rogers
  42. Jayden
  43. Look at the shit I linked, stop strawmanning me to suit your bias, and actually acknowledge when you're wrong instead of just being a "sheep" as Nietzsche would've called you for buying into this racialism crap
  44. Plus regarding race as "species" when there is information in the chat proving you wrong is funny lol
  45. Jayden Steeves
  46. 5/11, 7:36pm
  47. Jayden Steeves
  48. Dude all the wall pasted talked about how its not varied enough
  49. Noah Rogers
  50. 5/11, 7:36pm
  51. Noah Rogers
  52. I posted links to shit for you to read that wasnt excerpts
  53. You cherry picked one and went from there
  54. Jayden Steeves
  55. 5/11, 7:36pm
  56. Jayden Steeves
  57. and implyied i didnt know that asians have higher average, which means u strawmanned to
  58. Noah Rogers
  59. 5/11, 7:36pm
  60. Noah Rogers
  61. That wasn't my point
  62. It was mocking what "race science" calls "science"
  63. I wasn't trying to make a point with it
  64. There aren't any subspecies' with humans either, but I'm glad you're retaining your view from 1725, Linneaus
  65. Jayden Steeves
  66. 5/11, 7:38pm
  67. Jayden Steeves
  68. but there is more genetic variations in human types then elks and elks have subspecies?
  69. Noah Rogers
  70. 5/11, 7:38pm
  71. Noah Rogers
  72. Right, and there is information, in the chat now, that proves you wrong
  73. Quit being dismissive and read it lol
  74. Not the walls of texts, but actual links
  75. To scientists proving I'm wrong
  76. o wait
  77. im not a "race scientist" so im right 8) cuck
  78. Jayden Steeves
  79. 5/11, 7:41pm
  80. Jayden Steeves
  81. Next time you need a blood transfer, be sure not to get the one with sickle cell
  82. Noah Rogers
  83. 5/11, 7:41pm
  84. Noah Rogers
  85. Quit being dismissive and read what I put Jayden
  86. That's non sequitur anyway
  87. And if that doesn't overturn your bias I can find more easily lol
  88. Jayden Steeves
  89. 5/11, 7:45pm
  90. Jayden Steeves
  91. non-sequitur? If sickle cell amneia isn't a considerable genetic difference to matter, then what is?
  92. Noah Rogers
  93. 5/11, 7:45pm
  94. Noah Rogers
  95. not what i said
  96. and im not dealing with any of your selective argumentation shit until you stop being dismissive lol
  97. Cause with you, it's going to go "ugh blaghs GODDEH SIGGLE SELL HAHAHAHA LIBERALS CALL IT RACISD :DDDDD"
  98. I mean yeah liberals are bad, but we think they're bad for two different reasons
  99. Jayden Steeves
  100. 5/11, 7:49pm
  101. Jayden Steeves
  102. It's not dismissive, c'mon noah why won't you transfuse the african american blood? huh? sickle cell? OH come on, you aren't a racist are you?
  103. Noah Rogers
  104. 5/11, 7:49pm
  105. Noah Rogers
  106. You're not dealing with the shit that proves you wrong jayden
  107. Selective argumentation and cognitive dissonance are a common thing with Nazis tbh
  108. Jayden Steeves
  109. 5/11, 7:49pm
  110. Jayden Steeves
  111. What you linked mentions the "small margin" of difference, which in reality is a lot bigger then what you think
  112. Noah Rogers
  113. 5/11, 7:50pm
  114. Noah Rogers
  115. O is it
  116. did u read it
  117. ?????
  118. I mean, The scientists find the differences marginal and mostly a product of national grouping instead of some sub-species but the ones who think it's a subspecies are, well, wannabe-STEM fucks who don't even have formal learning and shit
  119. Jayden Steeves
  120. 5/11, 8:04pm
  121. Jayden Steeves
  122. Yeah all I'm seeing is "small variations"
  123. Noah Rogers
  124. 5/11, 8:04pm
  125. Noah Rogers
  126. You're trying to argue that these small variations constitute "different species of human"
  127. Right?
  128. Jayden Steeves
  129. 5/11, 8:05pm
  130. Jayden Steeves
  131. subspecies
  132. Noah Rogers
  133. 5/11, 8:06pm
  134. Noah Rogers
  135. Then what constitutes as the main species to you lol
  136. Europeans?
  137. Jayden Steeves
  138. 5/11, 8:08pm
  139. Jayden Steeves
  140. homo sapien
  141. wow
  142. Noah Rogers
  143. 5/11, 8:08pm
  144. Noah Rogers
  145. So... you're arguing, that due to what you believe to be isolated development, that this development has caused humans to develop into subspecies that have variations which make them distinct in the development of their culture
  146. I'd also like to pose the question of, what constituted the first "race" of homosapiens, since they all, according to some people, started in the same spot developmentally speaking
  147. and also geographically
  148. Jayden Steeves
  149. 5/11, 8:10pm
  150. Jayden Steeves
  151. I'm not sure where you're getting the culture part from
  152. Noah Rogers
  153. 5/11, 8:10pm
  154. Noah Rogers
  155. Let me rephrase
  156. Since humans, according to what you're saying, developed differently due to genetic variation and mutation and shit, from the homo sapien point, geographically also speaking, would you posit that due to this their "culture" also developed differently according to these claims
  157. And that due to these cultures being developed by different subspecies of human beings, there were achievements in each and also downsides to them, according to this pov
  158. Jayden Steeves
  159. 5/11, 8:13pm
  160. Jayden Steeves
  161. All im saying is that there is a difference
  162. Noah Rogers
  163. 5/11, 8:13pm
  164. Noah Rogers
  165. But would you contend it to be genetic?
  166. These variances in culture and shit
  167. Jayden Steeves
  168. 5/11, 8:17pm
  169. Jayden Steeves
  170. I would assume to some degree?
  171. Noah Rogers
  172. 5/11, 8:18pm
  173. Noah Rogers
  174. So, since humans developed from the same race/species, the homosapien, yet, migrated and developed "isolated", according to this point of view, since they were all the same broadly speaking, this would make that point of view null
  175. Noah Rogers
  176. 5/11, 8:21pm
  177. Noah Rogers
  178. Because the relationships of human beings aren't determined by their genetics, but in the social environment in which they're expressed, much like the phenotype of the genome, really. I.e, the socialization is a huge factor and the phenotype expression will bring of course certain factors into how they go about their relationships with other humans, but it's still a human on human relationship, and not something that developed out of isolation or static development, but in fluidity with other similar cultures that vary very sparingly on geography. To assess the human logically in accordance with their social relationships, which for the most part are not logical, as humans aren't computers, nor the fact that logic does not equal truth, is wrong, and has been proven wrong.
  179. Noah Rogers
  180. 5/11, 8:22pm
  181. Noah Rogers
  182. I do not disagree that there are indeed and 100% have been mutations in certain parts of the world which means that certain groups of people would have a higher chance of having a phenotype resulting in say, schizophrenia, be the resultant. But that doesn't correlate at all with the ethnicity of the person nor does it have significance in the political world either or the sphere of ideology.
  183. Jayden Steeves
  184. 5/11, 8:22pm
  185. Jayden Steeves
  186. Yeah they evolved is contrasting environments developed different traits/genetics/behaviors
  187. Noah Rogers
  188. 5/11, 8:22pm
  189. Noah Rogers
  190. Even then, these subspecies (if they are, according to this pov), would constitute still a small difference in their relationship with other humans.
  191. Behaviors and relationships are strikingly similar with other cultures, they constitute differences in geographic location due to isolation from people far away, yet developed similarly
  192. I mean, why did dozens of cultures create pyramid structures in hierarchical sort of set ups with a slave and lord sort of dichotomy going on?
  193. Noah Rogers
  194. 5/11, 8:24pm
  195. Noah Rogers
  196. It can't possibly be because humans are naturally meant to be ruler or ruler. That's inconsistent with how humans work and reduces their relationships to one or the other, which isn't scientific nor correlates with actual conditions of human existence, or development of relations of humans as a whole
  197. Jayden Steeves
  198. 5/11, 8:33pm
  199. Jayden Steeves
  200. I'm not talking about relationships though.
  201. Noah Rogers
  202. 5/11, 8:34pm
  203. Noah Rogers
  204. To analyze the human being outside of his interactions and development with other humans would just give you
  205. Well
  206. Have you seen those kids that don't get taught anything, are chained in a basement and come out literally almost braindead and shit
  207. Cause that's happened before
  208. Like, they're isolated their entire life and no matter what race or whatever they are they're just like, braindead memers
  209. Jayden Steeves
  210. 5/11, 8:35pm
  211. Jayden Steeves
  212. Yeah their bone structure doesn't change or anything?
  213. you can still tell what race they were
  214. Noah Rogers
  215. 5/11, 8:35pm
  216. Noah Rogers
  217. Yeah I know
  218. Not arguing that they dont become their race, but that because they were isolated, this shit doesn't get expressed and they're just kinda
  219. well
  220. braindead due to their development with other humans being nonexistent, not to mention the 0 relationships leading to them knowing nothing
  221. Jayden Steeves
  222. 5/11, 8:36pm
  223. Jayden Steeves
  224. What about it?
  225. Noah Rogers
  226. 5/11, 8:37pm
  227. Noah Rogers
  228. I'm using it to further my point that how a human being acts and shit is determined by their material/social conditions and not their genetics, despite that sometimes allowing a disorder to be expressed by a phenotype that comes into play when certain conditions socially/anxiety/stress are met
  229. Jayden Steeves
  230. 5/11, 8:41pm
  231. Jayden Steeves
  232. Yeah but race still exists no matter what unnatural treatment happens?
  233. Noah Rogers
  234. 5/11, 8:42pm
  235. Noah Rogers
  236. I know, but you're neglecting my point from earlier. I'm not denying race, but denying it in the sense where you put it wayyyy above social determination.
  237. Jayden Steeves
  238. 5/11, 8:44pm
  239. Jayden Steeves
  240. where did I say that i put it wayyy above "social determination"?
  241. Noah Rogers
  242. 5/11, 8:44pm
  243. Noah Rogers
  244. Well, I just assumed. It's generally where the alt-right people I've talked to before go with their discourse.
  245. Jayden Steeves
  246. 5/11, 8:45pm
  247. Jayden Steeves
  248. "MUH STRAWMANS"
  249. wow
  250. Noah Rogers
  251. 5/11, 8:45pm
  252. Noah Rogers
  253. Nah, was a just a practical assumption based on what the alt-right is predominantly.
  254. Jayden Steeves
  255. 5/11, 8:46pm
  256. Jayden Steeves
  257. lil hypocrisy and assumptions going on here
  258. Noah Rogers
  259. 5/11, 8:46pm
  260. Noah Rogers
  261. You thought I was denying race, and I was just denying that it's a dominant in the social sphere if at all
  262. I mean, to put race before social determination is still incredibly wrong imo
  263. Jayden Steeves
  264. 5/11, 8:48pm
  265. Jayden Steeves
  266. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/unique-everybody-else/201211/cold-winters-and-the-evolution-intelligence
  267. Theres also this
  268. Noah Rogers
  269. 5/11, 8:50pm
  270. Noah Rogers
  271. ill read in a sec
  272. Jayden Steeves
  273. 5/11, 8:52pm
  274. Jayden Steeves
  275. Its a lot easier to die from the cold than the heat in this world, therefore things that have lived in places that are cold or have harsh winters requires a little more intelligence to survive in
  276. things like that
  277. Noah Rogers
  278. 5/11, 8:53pm
  279. Noah Rogers
  280. this article is weird
  281. Like, the guy who the author is debunking is the one going up against race realism.
  282. "However, there are some anomalies in his data and the theory itself is based on questionable assumptions. "
  283. That dude who you linked also wrote this
  284. Noah Rogers
  285. 5/11, 8:57pm
  286. Noah Rogers
  287. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/unique-everybody-else/201210/personality-intelligence-and-race-realism
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement