PlumBath

>you are Anonymous and currently catering a mothpony that’s in your house
>she’s a shy and quiet one, you give her that, and what did Hexferry say her name was? Plum?
>you can see why she is trying to get the two of you to become friends, you’re well, you, and this moth is very reserved.
“H... umm t-the.. hon... honey”
>the moth points at the jar of honey with her pink hoof
>you push the jar to her and she gets to mixing it with her tea as you sip on your own cup
>you seriously have no idea what to do here, the two of you have been sitting in awkward silence for a while now
>Plum herself is trying her hardest to avoid your gaze and not speak at all, and you are trying your hardest to try to get a conversation rolling
>a sudden idea comes to you and you yell it out without thinking
>”Video games!”
>Plum gets scared at this and squeaks in fright, and at the same time accidently spills her tea all over herself
>the poor mare looks absolutely miserable now, her eyes almost looking like they are tearing up from embarrassment
>Dammit, you are going to save this situation even if it kills you
>you get up and immediately slip on some of the spilled tea, bringing the whole table tumbling down with you as you fall on top of Plum, making her squeak in surprise
>as you open your eyes, you are greeted by the sight of Plum beneath you, her hoofs pulled close to her body, her coat and mane covered in honey and tea
>Plum stares at you but then turns her face to face the wall
“U-uh..u...umm...”
>you sigh and get up, lifting Plum with you as she seems shocked
>”All right, let’s get you cleaned up, I can still save this”
>you make your way to your bathroom with the now blushing shy sticky mothpony in your arms and kick the door open
>you place Plum onto the tub and hit the shower for some warm water
>Plum closes her eyes as the stream of water falls onto her and you swiftly and with style remove all your clothing
>you step into the tub as well and start lathering some shampoo onto your hands
>suddenly you hear a gasp and look down to the mothpony whose face is at your crotch level
>Plum is now blushing even harder and has her hoofs in front of her face, eyes closed
>What’s her pro-
>your brain finally catches on
>oh...well, fuck
>you were too focused on saving the situation that you just threw a mothpony into the bathtub and got in with her while naked, and then hold your flaccid cock near her face
>the gears within your brain start to turn
>if Hexferry and the others would hear about this you would be screwed, so you have a plan
>not the best plan but it’s the best you can do at the given moment
>you shall act like it is no big deal
>maybe this Plum will be confused by it and will think that nakedness is a rather everyday thing with humans and by that not mention about this embarrassing encounter as the human was only thinking about her wellbeing by helping her wash off that evil sticky honey off of her coat and mane
>you honestly can’t believe how crappy that plan is but it’s all you’ve got
>as Plum still has her eyes closed, you give her a little heads up so the poor mare won’t have a heart attack
>”Ok so I am now going to start washing your mane”
>not waiting for a reply, you sink your hands onto Plums mane and get to washing
>...
>wow, this feels soft
>really soft
>you start to detour from washing and run your fingers along her golden mane, enjoying how it feels
>man, her mane must be so soft to run your hands trough when it is dry
>suddenly you have the urge to do this sometime
>as you feel a bit of blood travel down south, you remove the idea from your mind and focus more on the washing
>”Don’t open your eyes, I’m going to rinse the shampoo off now”
>there is no response from Plum and you start to sweat as you rinse her mane
>this plan of yours is going down the drain
>and then your now a little bit not so flaccid but still dangly-cock accidently slaps Plum gently on the face
>you freeze
>Plum is not reacting
>you resume the washing, content that Plum did not notice
>”O-ok, next up is washing your b-body,ok”
>Plum nods
>Or did she? You are not sure, you are panicking now and you just want this whole mistake to be over soon
>you quickly grab the shampoo bottle and it slips from your grasp and falls behind Plums well, plum
>you gulp as you try to reach for it and at the same time try to make sure that no part of your body touches her
>you are now posed at an awkward angle
>one slip would cause you to fall against her, and that would be bad
>you reach for the bottle, and notice that Plums plum is in fact, quite nice
>but then you feel one of your feet slip a bit and the back of your hand comes into contact with Plums behind
>Plum squeaks as the back of your hand sinks into her soft flesh
>D-damn that’s softer than you could have ever thought it could be
>your soldier springs up to attention
>you are now starting to regret your no-fap-month experiment in Equestria as your hardon reaches critical mass instantly
>and then it happens
>your dick actually grew so long it poked Plum and she opened her eyes
>before her is you, posed at an awkward angle above and around her, one of your hands pressing into her butt and your raging erection poking her
>Plum scream sand starts to flail around in panic, kicking up water and making you loose your balance, sending the two of you into a wild spin thanks to all the soapy water droplets in the tub
>you thump onto your back and before you even can react, Plum falls against your loins, butt first
>there is a tight wet feeling as your penis slides into something very tight and you cum instantly, closing your eyes in the process
>time seems to freeze and then you open your eyes to process what just happened
>Plum is on your lap, straddling you with her hind legs on each sides of your waist
>There’s a shocked look on her face as she gets up and you feel a grip on your penis
>it can’t be
>your penis falls out from inside Plum and a healthy goop of semen drops out after it
>did you...just cum inside Plum on accident while doing nothing sexual?
>Plums eyes seem teary as she looks at her crotch and just as you are about to say something, anything, she starts crying and flies out of the bathroom and presumably your house
>...
>you just lie back onto the bathtub as the water drops on you
>you are pretty much fucked
>you just lie there, accepting this fact as you feel dead inside
>...
>...
>...
>you are being walked to the altar
>a sad looking Plum is there, wearing a wedding dress
>it actually looks really good on her
>these binds, handcuffs and whatnots around you are making it hard to walk tough
>you look at the angry Hexferry who’s dragging you towards the altar by the chain connected to your neck
>”Hexferry is this really necessary?”
>Hexferry scoffs at you
“We have to keep a wild beast like you chained, we can’t have you impregnating any other poor mothponies against their will”
>you sight
>you walk to the altar like an inmate being sentenced to lifetime
>Plum still refuses to look at you in the eyes, and you honestly have no idea if she’s mad at you or just being shy
>”This is the last time I’ll try to make friends...”