Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Let's start right at the top – I am literally the laser-targeted demographic for this game. Someone who is deeply invested in the lore to the point of having read the novels and helped translate the guidebooks. (PS – please read the novels, especially “The Kids Are Alright.”)
- Thus, a lot of the game was me picking up on different notes from across the Compilation, large and small, and generally being excited with where they were going. And the fact that EVERYTHING in the Compilation got some kind of reference was really encouraging for the time of background and continuity they're going for. (But I need to know so much about what all is going on with Avalanche HQ because I have QUESTIONS)
- But... speaking of Continuity...
- So, the whole theme of fighting fate – quite literally – is something that I enjoy and with this particular game where there was that expectation of “the same game but with better graphics, updated mechanics, full voice acting, and maybe a few new characters and story beats” the idea of actively tossing it aside to do something new and surprise people is very much appreciated. It's not the same game as the original – and that's wholly fine with me. I see the original as the outline and the remake as the final draft and given how many times FF7 during the plan stages changed ideas and directions, I’m curious as to where things will go.
- But I like how that crept in – sometimes slowly with little changes until the shifts became too great to ignore until it ends with “Screw it, you'll have no idea guessing what's coming after this.” Still, I appreciated things like the nods to things to come later and the foreshadowing for things that may or may not still matter. But the fact that a lot of the original FF7 crew have a chance to come back to this world, to this story, and maybe do something different this time is really exciting.
- Obviously, given my character preferences, I was really happy to see a lot of the Sephiroth stuff brought to the forefront, even if he himself remained cryptic to the very end. But seeing things like the use of “disposable” bodies in order to interact with the physical world as well as how he manifested as a hallucination before Cloud really helped to better explain the scope of his powers, more so than any other piece of media. (Save - again - The Kids Are Alright, which did a very good job of demonstrating how a Jenova-aligned entity would be frankly terrifying. Also since Degradation was mentioned in game, I'm actually wondering if the slippage into the Sephiroth cult and the desire for Reunion is the S-type SOLDIER type of Degradation and Sephiroth's death only exacerbates things, like how Angeal was able to still influence his own Copies from the Lifestream.)
- And it made sense that within Destiny's Crossroads, he was able to use a good deal of his power to manifest there as he pleased. But also, *the wing* and Advent Children style fighting! I was *slightly* disappointed that there wasn't some sort of player directed Omnislash at the very end but since it wasn't the Actual For Real Final Showdown, I can let that pass.
- But holy hell, I love the surrealness of that final scene with Sephiroth. It leaves so much hanging and wanting and thus leaves me flailing. Also, even though I'm not a Sephiroth/Cloud shipper by trade, I can't deny the amount of queer subtext that exists in like every scene Sephiroth is in. With dialogue that seems specifically written to be homoerotic (“Don't deny me. Embrace me,” along with Sephiroth's offer to Cloud to defy destiny together) it's pretty much impossible to ignore.
- Looping back around on characterization, I really loved how the whole main cast was handled. It was great to see Cloud strike that balance between cool and unaffected but kinda a dork underneath it all, who is relying on this cold-hard merc script/persona to allow him to navigate the world. And Tifa with her balance of both wanting to change things but having guilt over being at the epicenter of so much loss and destruction, of trying to stay strong when you can tell she just wants to leave it all behind. Barret was a pleasant surprise - yah, there’s a lot of bluster and anger but it’s all justified and comes from a very good heart and I liked whenever he would slip a bit of Sunday peacher into his lectures. Also, his comedic moments were really nicely handled and he probably made me laugh more than anyone else.
- Aerith was really a return to form though. I love that they hit just the right sweet and sassy balance with her and that they let her swear and hit people with chairs. Her cryptic side was also intriguing - I like that a number of her powers manifested the same way as Sephiroth’s - from the dream walking to the staticy moments when she maybe took a bit more than a guiding hand towards people. I really like the implication of Cetra and Jenova powers being not so different in some ways. Also having more time between her and Sephiroth is going to be great for contrasting them as foils so I’m excited for that. Oh and also, I loved every bonding/flirting moment between Tifa and Aerith - I think that ship is adorable and I’m glad it got some attention. Also also, I really liked that they FINALLY showed that she did live as a Shinra ward for several years growing up and seeing her room there was a wonderful surprise. Makes me all the more curious about the other company wards, especially Sephiroth.
- Side characters were also treated really well, I feel. Obviously, we knew that Jessie, Biggs, and Wedge were going to get a lot more love and I personally found thirsty!Jessie amusing. I am curious if she’ll have survived? Seems like that is true for Biggs and maybe also Wedge? (I love that this is even a question!) Also Roche was kinda a surprise for just how flipping horny and disaster bi he was? Like I get it, half of FF7R is a massive amount of people of multiple genders having the hots for Cloud but like, Roche up'ed that ante to a very high degree. I was almost disappointed that he didn't show up for the final motorcycle sequence but given how exhausting that was, I'm pretty glad he didn't.
- The Shinra board was also out in full force. I admit, I broke down laughing during the Shinra Museum part when Hojo sounded *pitch-perfect* for how Orin and I wrote him back in the day. But also, props to making him extra creepy, S-E! I didn't even know that was possible. Everyone else was pretty much as expected - I was not at all surprised when the President's room in the Shinra museum took a moment to show "Hey, he was hot when he was younger" for example, as if we didn't already know that from his kids. Speaking of his kids, shout outs to Rufus who showed up for like 20 minutes max and stole the show with his over the top gun play and smug aura. I’m also okay with renaming Dark Nation to Dark Star and I’m actually happy that we didn’t kill her. (I do want to know about how he could see the Arbiters of Fate though!)
- And there were so many minor characters in the mix that deserve lots of love and attention! Again, since I liked the novels, seeing Kyrie, Mirielle, and Leslie was a lot of fun, especially knowing where their stories end up. I’m a little sad that we didn’t get to see Evan but he was too busy sleeping in warehouses and getting the shit kicked out of him, I guess. New characters like Marle absolutely stole my heart, I loved the amount of bad-ass grandma energy we had in the Slums.
- (Side note on world-building - I loved all the Midgar specific terminology that got carried over from The Kids are Alright. Hearing about Topsiders, Platies, Grounders, the use of Undercity as the politically correct term for the Slums - it really helped make the place feel unique and alive. And just the care that was taken to show the devastation of how the events of the game effected the lives of people in the city - both on and below the Plate - was really well done and added an extra layer of pathos to the story.)
- Anyway, Wall Market characters also get a special shoutout. The Trio were all really fun and eclectic and I appreciated that. From Chocobo Sam’s downhome cowboy realism, to Madame M being graceful on the surface but actually boiling underneath (and also getting so much past the radar with the massage scene), and of course *EVERYTHING* about Andrea. I was really hoping he would be fun and entertaining and I was so happy to be proven right. I’m glad some of the other parts of the Honey Bee Inn were traded for the absolutely over the top fabulous show that we got in their place. I unironically loved the whole sequence - the Busby Berkeley drama of it all along with “Stand Up” as a straight up queer anathem in a middle of the game. Also, I got the best dress for Cloud - which I loved because that corset/goth lolita look worked for him - and my only complaint is that the hair should’ve been down other than in pigtails, but that’s me. (PS - I also noticed that one of the patrons referred to Cloud with they/them pronouns after the show which I thought was a nice touch)
- And very quick bonus shoutout to Scotch and Kotch who I think got the best glow-up of almost any NPCs - They were still creeps who got what they deserved, but their commentary during the tournament and how it shifted according to your actions was so well done that they endeared themselves to me. Another great glow-up was Jules AKA Beautiful Bro - I liked that they kept him as this positive, welcoming presence in the gym and I didn’t even mind that he kicked my ass at the mini-games. And of course, there was Johnny. I got the Full Johnny Experience which was well worth it in my mind. I laughed so hard during the entire Party Never Stops side quest, especially over The Sauce.
- Also a big ole side note here on Voice Work - So I’ve only played in English so far ‘cause I wanted to be able to pick up on things - I only half jokingly refer to it as “Midgar Eavesdropping Simulator” for a reason - and I wish that there wasn’t the whole deal with the recast kinda clouding things. Because I think everyone did a legit amazing job and I wish it didn’t in some ways take away from the work the Compilation cast has done. It’s a really complex thing but I think there is room to appreciate the Remake cast while also disliking the circumstances of why there are new actors. As I replay chapters looking for secrets, I’ll probably play in Japanese this time around to appreciate that cast too.
- But I don’t know how much replaying I’ll do? I want to at least get the one song I missed - and I’m pretty impressed that I got all but one on my first time through - and now that I know that there are mutually exclusive side quests, I want to go poke at those. I’m sorry, I am an Easy Mode scrub when it comes to games like this. Which I am fine with, I enjoyed the game and there was still a little challenge but it was always stuff I could deal with. I don’t like stressing when I’m playing casually after all. I did like the materia system updates and the whole concept with evolving weapons - it was really neat to let us have flexibility in what we could fight with. Also be assured that I did do the true FF7 Speedrunner thing though and I took the stairs in the Shinra building which was 100% worth it, not just for the banter but also for the way the music got weirder and weirder over the climb.
- And just shoutouts to the music all around. All the arrangers and composers did an amazing job on it and I spent a solid amount of time just standing around and listening to songs play. I look forward to getting the OST eventually - but they better give us all the Jukebox tracks or I will straight up riot. Those were some of the best tracks in the whole game. Also, I need the lyrics to the Stamp Theme song yesterday because I have many questions about it as an allegory???
- Just a quick note here on the things I did have issues with (which is really really short, promise!) - I don't know if it was just me and my PS4, but I kept having the low-res textures load instead of the higher ones and it was really disorienting and kinda broke me out of my suspension of disbelief. Also sometimes the lighting engine would do weird things with skin and hair. In characters I didn't like, I found the whole reoccurring bandits thing to be more annoying than anything else. Also, it was super easy to get lost but once I got my minimap settings the way I liked, that proved to be helpful. I did encounter a softlock - my game wouldn't let me back out after listening in on an optional conversation in the air ducts - which was annoying. And in accessibility things, I really wish there was an option to turn flashing effects off - I get it, they're thematic to the original game but the static and sharp cuts and the music already do a fine enough job of signaling of "Weird shit is happening" that they could've been left out.
- Finally, let’s end on the biggest lingering question in this whole thing - Is Zack alive? Because it could honestly go either way and if the defiance of fate is somehow retroactive - which it seems to be??? - then there is a chance that he lived and if so, I NEED to know that story. Like, this game had me flipping tables over the line “Imma go get Kunsel” so you can just imagine how I reacted to the very *possibility* that Zack got to defy destiny too. If S-E gives me the forbidden fruit that is “FF7 AU where Zack lives and it basically becomes a polyship between Zack, Cloud, Aerith, and Tifa” I will probably burst from the seams with happiness. But… well, that’s for the future isn’t it? (Side note, having a shot for shot, line for line remake of the end of Crisis Core with a different English VA was the only time I was really :/ over not having the Compilation cast there because I honestly enjoyed Rick Gomez's performance and Caleb Pierce just didn't appeal to me in the same way. Nothing against him personally, this is just my opinion.)
- And okay, one extra thought - I don’t know if they’d do this, but if I was directing the next game, I’d have it *start* already in the Kalm flashback. Almost no framing around it, just dropping us in there as an extended flashback at the start to let us have an idea of why Cloud and Sephiroth are so entangled with each other. There were already a lot of references there in this game, but I think that would be a very interesting place to start.
- Anyway, thanks for reading this! I probably left out a few details here and there and I’m now happy to discuss things with anyone who wants to. I won’t really do much publicly on social media ‘cause I have friends who are still playing and I don’t want to inadvertently spoil them but privately and in specific channels for spoiler discussion? Oh hell yah, come talk to me.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment