[22:44:57]  Faytl: If a player has been dealt 21 points of combat damage by a particular Commander during the game, that player loses a game. - Official Commander Rules

[22:45:20]  : any cmd dmg is game over i have done gthe numbers, ESpecially in casual

[22:45:40]  Faytl: So you're telling me if I had hit you with my 2/2 commander
Despite ANYTHING the official rules say
You would be dead
That right?

[22:46:03] : t5 or less, its pointless as i can no longer be happy with my win, i would consider myself dead

[22:46:22]  Faytl: So it's only lethal... becaaaaaause you say it is?

[22:46:28]  : its rude of me to stay in the game if i am dead, hence i walked out

[22:46:36]  Faytl: You weren't DEAD yet.

[22:46:38]  : its lethal every time, hence i never swing mine

[22:46:45]  Faytl: It ISN'T, though

[22:46:52]  : do the numbers man
 97% of games where you suffer CMD dmg by turn 5 you will lose.

[22:47:12]  Faytl: Your commander is GISHATH. it literally does nothing without you attacking with it.
 What sense does that make?

[22:47:21]  : at that point staying is pointless and rude
yes, did you notice i exiled her?

[22:47:35]  Faytl: No it's NOT. That doesn't make any SENSE.

[22:47:39] : i had no intention of EVER casting her

[22:47:44]  Faytl: But WHY

[22:47:51]  : she literally cannot be casted due to Casual
i am ok with that

[22:47:59]  Faytl: That's not what Casual MEANS

[22:48:07]  : there is nothing casual about cmd dmg[22:48:21]

Faytl: Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh
YES there is

[22:48:46]  : there should not be a 1 shot kill method in casual edh

[22:49:09]  Faytl: It's NOT a one-shot, he was only dealing 17!
a One-Shot would be if he did 21~

[22:49:44]  : any dmg is 1 shot, hence him swinging with it unless at a walker is just not casual

[22:49:54]  Faytl: There are many decks that attack with their general plenty as part of their game plan, like Hapatra, that almost never actually get even CLOSE to dealing the full 21. You telling me you auto-scoop to 2 commander damage?
DESPITE everything in the actual rules?

[22:50:28]  : this is why i destryed my hapatra deck actually it was never casual

[22:50:43]  Faytl: You just do not make a single piece of sense to me.

[22:50:53]  : i converted it into a Jund -1/-1 deck
I obey Casual.. most people do not, its fine.

[22:51:15]  Faytl: OBEY WHAT
THAT'S LITERALLY NOT A PART OF CASUAL PLAY

[22:51:29]  : the rules of being Casual, and i do not consider cmd casual
i am not a fan of a 1 shot way to ruin a person's win

[22:51:51]  Faytl: WHAT RULES
WHAT ONE SHOT
THERE ARE NO CASUAL RULES, CASUAL JUST MEANS

[22:52:08]: I think we do not agree on the definition of casual, and that is fine

[22:52:10]  Faytl: "DON'T BE AN ASSHOLE"

[22:52:18]  : 1 shoting is not asshole?

[22:52:22]  Faytl: IT
WASN'T
A
ONE
SHOT
YOU DENSE FIRE HYDRANT OF A PERSON

[22:52:44]  : Any cmd on t5 or pre t5 is 1 shot kill, no matter the number
i have done the math and its pointless to stay in the game that You cannot win
if i had stayed in that game i would have been an Asshole.. thus breaking the rules