Nohbody

Prince of Thorns review

Oct 23rd, 2018
143
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 9.88 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Prince of Thorns, for those of you who don't know, is a 2011 fantasy novel by Mark Lawrence. Prince of Thorns, for those of you who do know, is a ridiculously edgy shock story about a fourteen-year old kid who sets out to prove that nobody else in the world is as big a bastard as he is. When I say edgy, I mean it's entirely unashamed about how shitty of people the main characters are, to the point where even the most crawling-in-my-skin thirteen year old would probably step back and think that there was a line somewhere back there they shouldn't have crossed. It's not a book that I'm fond of, and if you're willing to bear with me on this scathing review, I'll explain why.
  2. Straight off the bat, there's the rape murder torture issue the main character and narrator, Prince Jorg, has. One of the hype quotes you get in the first few pages warns me to be careful or else I find myself rooting for the main crew. Twenty pages later, he's raping two women. It doesn't go into explicit detail, but it sure as fuck doesn't gloss over it either. Not only does he taunt a farmer that he's going to hunt down and rape his daughters, but he actively encourages his men to do the same all while burning the village down. When you start off with immediate rape and murder, it's very hard to go back from it, and no amount of oh-so-tragic backstory is ever going to make me sympathize with your character at that point, let alone root for him or his merry band of murderous bandits.
  3. Every single thing Prince Jorg does is accompanied by an internal monologue of how dark and edgy of a monster he is. It's on almost every single page, too. He's constantly jerking himself off to how he isn't like normal people, about how merciless he is, or how utterly convinced he is of how much better and smarter and cooler he is than pretty much everyone around him. By the time I made it to page 50, I was tired of it. By the time I got to 100, reading was an active chore, and I barely managed to drag myself across those final few pages, slogging through yet another rant about how totally knew he was going to be a king before he turns fifteen.
  4. There's no nuance to Jorg as a character, no subtext to his personality. He doesn't ever grow or change as a character throughout Prince of Thorns, he's still the same edgy little fuck he was at the start. There's a few moments that do seem to get to him, but ultimately there's very little that actively challenges him or who he is. He accepts that he's a monster...and that's it. It's not a huge revelation either, where he embraces being a sadistic fuckwad who brags about learning the fine art of torture at the age of ten. That would've been something, at least, but he starts off that way and ends that way. Not once does he question what he does, or if his ends justifies the means, or even have a moment of doubt as to what he's doing. With maybe one or two tiny exceptions, the characters in this book are as flat as Prince Jorg. Nobody goes anywhere, there's no character arcs, everyone stays static and unchanging.
  5. There's a lot of buzz about Prince of Thorns being this clever deconstruction of fantasy, but it isn't. Everything Mark Lawrence tries to do with Jorg, George RR Martin has done a thousand times better, with characters I actually give a shit about. Martin takes the usual epic fantasy fare and shows how they wouldn't hold up in a more realistic scenario, whereas Lawrence just uses Jorg to tear them down- the fantasy tropes and archetypes are there, but they're only there for the him to violently subvert and chuckle about how stupid they are.
  6. This leads into another huge problem that made the book torturous to read and Jorg viciously detestable. Not only does nothing challenge him as a character, nothing is able to challenge him physically either. I get the sense that nothing in this world is allowed to be as cool as Jorg, or as clever as he is, or even attempt to one-up him. Anything that even looks like it might have the upper hand is only there for him to defeat five minutes later, just to prove how much of an edgy bastard coolguy he is. I lost track of how many scenes would present a credible threat, only for Jorg to pull some deft flourish at the last second and pull the rug out from beneath it before on to the next. Prince of Thorns actually gets boring once you spot the pattern, which is a cardinal sin for this kind of shock and awe affair.
  7. Let's compare Jorge to Johnny, from Johnny the Homicidal Maniac. Both are hyper-edgy shock works, both feature psychopathic main characters that are extremely capable in their jobs, both try to act as a subversions to audience expectations. Jorg, and Prince of Thorns in general, still absolutely fails to live up to its predecessor. Even when being advertised as a homicidal Maniac, Johnny isn't a one-note character, unlike Jorg. Johnny shows remorse at times. Johnny goes through a character arc, and his acknowledgment of being a terrible person comes with an intense self-loathing and introspection, rather than boastfulness. One of Johnny's comics has him find a copycat murderer, someone who sees him as a role model and dismembers people in a similar manner. Johnny outright kills him on finding this, because he hates the monster that he is and doesn't want more of it in the world, while I can't help but think that Jorg would do so just to remove the competition. Even though both are despicable monsters, I found myself empathizing with Johnny's struggle as a person, a feeling Jorg utterly fails to garner.
  8. Okay. Maybe you enjoy brutal characters. Maybe you like hyper-edgy "I am what the darkness fears" type assholes. Let's put that aside. Let's call my absolute dislike of Jorg as a character a personal opinion, and set aside the entire issue about the asshole MC aside and edgy nonsense aside.
  9. Prince of Thorns is still an utter mess. The plot is all over the place, the pacing is fucked, and Lawrence fails to build a proper narrative.
  10. First off, the plot. It starts off as a simple revenge quest. Prince Jorg is seeking one Count Rennar, who murdered his mother and younger brother several years prior. Jorg & Co are hunting down his forces, which does make sense. Rather than working towards this over the course of his three hundred pages, Jorg pretty much abandons this quest almost a third of the way through the book, instead deciding that he's going to return home to see his father again. Granted, there's an in-universe explanation for this, but it comes off as tacked on and incredibly shallow. Plus, despite the reason, in a narrative sense this still robs the reader of whatever plot you spent time getting them invested in, makes the story disjointed, and fucks the pacing up entirely as we've now got to establish this whole new secondary plot, one that has nothing to do with Count Renar and barely ties into him. It does get back to Renar...maybe twenty or thirty pages from the end of the book. That "main" plot, one that's incredibly tied into Prince Jorg as a character, the one we start out with and spend dozens of pages following, is tacked on to the very end and resolved in an unsatisfying, rushed manner. Apparently, in his fight to deconstruct the fantasy genre, Lawrence tries to subvert good storytelling as well.
  11. The new plot is Jorg fantasizing about his step-aunt and breaking into a castle to kill some other king for his father. The best I can say about this is that it highlights Prince of Thorns setting (which is surprisingly really cool, credit where credit is due), but it trawls through more of the same with Jorg's inflated ego and last-second powergaming. They barter with some mutants to sneak into an old abandoned weapons vault beneath the castle, and set off an old nuclear bomb to utterly annihilate the area. Now that sounds really cool, and it is, but there's a couple of really huge issues that come along with it.
  12. The first is that they did this entirely by luck. The audience knew sort of what to expect, but Jorg didn't. He ran in blind, with no plan, and lucked out with finding both the armory and something they could set off in such a manner. In order to build a satisfying climax, or even a fight in general, a character should earn it. Coincidence, as it's been said before, is a great tool for getting someone in trouble but a terrible cop-out for getting them out. Jorg does nothing to earn his victory, which to me makes the scene hollow and his triumphant return stolen.
  13. The second is that, since it is such a massive climax, that there's still a big chunk of unresolved plot afterwards, destroys the flow of the novel. Since we still have the 'main' plot to finish, Lawrence is forced to bang out yet another climax, one that is absolutely trivial in comparison to what we just witnessed as readers, and cementing the main plot that's at the core of Jorg's motivation to a mild secondary slapped onto the last twenty pages. Crafting a narrative means charting out the ups and downs of excitement, and a weak final ending is pretty bad form, especially when the story itself is all over the place.
  14. After spending four years nipping at Renar's heels, Jorg zips over to his house in ten seconds, jumps in a melee, and storms his castle, taking it over just by yelling at the right people and barging down the doors. It's really disappointing, after all that build up of everything else.
  15. The post-apocalyptic setting was interesting, and the technical bits are passable, I suppose. Lawrence can write prose decently, even if he's wasting it on unlikable characters and a mess of a story. Unlikable characters means readers don't get attached to them, unattached readers drop the book halfway through and don't pick it up again. You don't have to make them shining pinnacles of morality, but you have to at least give readers something to be interested in. Jorg is a one-trick pony, and therefore there's no reason to give a shit about him or what he does. Overall, Prince of Thorns was written with edge first, storytelling second, and it shows.
  16. Bleggh. Fuck this dumb book.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment