Verlux vs Stronger
I'll basically just say what I thought about the match as a whole since I'm only acting as a tiebreaker.

Response 1
Verlux
Not my favorite Verlux post. I would have much preferred an argument that involved your whole team. Focusing so hard on Preston is a poor move imo. Even though I generally agree with the arguments made, backing them up with more than a single paragraph about your other team members would have been a lot better.

Stronger
A genuinely good response from a first time debater, love to see it.
My biggest suggestion for the future is to focus more on your own characters, and proposing a solid plan for them to win. Jumping straight into countering your opponent generally leaves you on the backfoot for the rest of the debate.

 Verlux wins for the reasons above. He proposed a strategy for his team to follow, and Stronger spent more time saying that Verlux was wrong instead of explaining why they were right.