Advertisement
Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- ---NOTES on "Botany:"---
- GENERAL NOTES:
- MULTIPLE SOURCES following bold claims.
- Etymology explained citing several sources.
- Somewhat lacking citations in history (ONLY IN GENERAL OVERVIEW SECTION)
- Virtually every claim comes with a NEW citations (Indicative of several jorunals coming together to form a collective opinion and neutral standpoint)
- KEY EXAMPLES ARE GIVEN WITH EACH TOPIC
- EARLY BOTANY:
- A few claims on importance given (possible signs of bias, perhaps citations on recognition may mititgate this issue)
- Current talk/discussion:
- - Rated GA-class SEVERAL times (WP Plants, WP Biology, WP HnG, Version 1.0 Editorial Team)
- - Suggestions on adding links to further help
- ---NOTES on "Plant Physiology:"---
- GENERAL NOTES:
- - Severe lack of citations for an article of this magnitude in detail/generalization.
- - Short history section
- - Short section in food production (economic applications)
- - Citations come from dated articles, perhaps some mention on contemporary/current review may mitigate this issue
- "Aims" section:
- - Citations lacking in claims made about plant survival and function/responses. Several examples are given as a means of providing specificity and detail without citation.
- --- "For both of these organs to continue living..."
- --- "Many flowering plants bloom..."
- --- "Stress from water loss..."
- Pigments subsection:
- - Again, lacking several citations in claims, especially ones claiming that specific pigments "have been shown" to perform in a given manner.
- Current talk/discussion:
- - Rated B-class, rated top-importance AS PART OF WIKIPROJECT PLANTS
- - C-Class by the Version 1.0 Editorial Team
- - More references, specific examples, missing sections (e.g. History of photosynthesis investigation, Calvin cycle)
- - Discussion on replacing "irrevelant sections" have been mentioned but without examples of said sections
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement