Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- 1
- 00:00:33,413 --> 00:00:38,413
- Subtitles by <font color="#ff0000">explosiveskull</font>
- Sync by <font color="#00ffff">NAIM2007</font>
- 2
- 00:01:49,755 --> 00:01:50,798
- I'll give you a boost
- if you want.
- 3
- 00:01:50,881 --> 00:01:52,291
- I don't need your help.
- 4
- 00:01:52,341 --> 00:01:54,351
- Ooh. Hell,
- she got you, buddy.
- 5
- 00:01:54,677 --> 00:01:56,770
- - Toss them beers.
- - Here you go.
- 6
- 00:01:56,887 --> 00:01:59,006
- - You got it?
- - Okay, let's go!
- 7
- 00:01:59,098 --> 00:02:01,692
- All right. All right.
- 8
- 00:02:02,143 --> 00:02:03,227
- Hold up, hold up!
- The beer.
- 9
- 00:02:03,603 --> 00:02:04,854
- Take this. Take this.
- Come on.
- 10
- 00:02:06,939 --> 00:02:07,940
- These damn shoes!
- 11
- 00:02:24,790 --> 00:02:27,627
- - Whoo! Come on in, it's warm!
- - Come on, buddy!
- 12
- 00:02:29,670 --> 00:02:32,489
- Look, you can even wash your hair!
- 13
- 00:02:32,840 --> 00:02:34,642
- I washed mine last month.
- 14
- 00:02:35,676 --> 00:02:37,236
- Whoo!
- 15
- 00:02:43,809 --> 00:02:46,011
- Laura, Keith, come here!
- Look what I found.
- 16
- 00:02:46,687 --> 00:02:47,972
- - Holy shit.
- - What the hell's that?
- 17
- 00:02:47,980 --> 00:02:49,565
- - What is it?
- - The hell you doing?
- 18
- 00:02:50,107 --> 00:02:52,159
- Get out of here, now!
- 19
- 00:02:52,234 --> 00:02:54,311
- - Geez!
- - Come on!
- 20
- 00:02:58,157 --> 00:02:59,900
- Goddamn kids.
- 21
- 00:03:17,134 --> 00:03:18,894
- Turn off the beam, fool!
- 22
- 00:04:27,705 --> 00:04:30,632
- Steve from Dow,
- Ted from Union Carbide...
- 23
- 00:04:30,791 --> 00:04:33,969
- Jerry from Exxon
- and Andy from Allied.
- 24
- 00:04:34,670 --> 00:04:36,805
- Welcome to Taft Law,
- gentlemen.
- 25
- 00:04:37,715 --> 00:04:40,259
- Before we get started,
- a little housekeeping.
- 26
- 00:04:40,342 --> 00:04:42,219
- Um, all of you know
- this young man
- 27
- 00:04:42,303 --> 00:04:44,472
- as the dedicated
- Taft associate
- 28
- 00:04:44,555 --> 00:04:46,407
- who for the past
- eight years has
- 29
- 00:04:47,266 --> 00:04:49,551
- buried himself
- in the Superfund law.
- 30
- 00:04:49,643 --> 00:04:51,153
- I'm not paying
- for that cleanup.
- 31
- 00:04:51,187 --> 00:04:53,889
- Still it is my pleasure
- to share with you
- 32
- 00:04:54,148 --> 00:04:57,318
- that just last week,
- Rob Bilott was welcomed as a partner
- 33
- 00:04:57,401 --> 00:05:00,537
- here at Taft,
- Stettinius & Hollister.
- 34
- 00:05:03,449 --> 00:05:06,268
- Good morning. Taft Law.
- One moment. I'll connect you.
- 35
- 00:05:09,246 --> 00:05:10,839
- Good morning. Taft Law.
- 36
- 00:05:11,540 --> 00:05:12,841
- One moment, please.
- 37
- 00:05:16,587 --> 00:05:19,406
- It's the Governor's office
- calling for uh,
- 38
- 00:05:19,673 --> 00:05:21,041
- calling for Mr. Burke.
- 39
- 00:05:24,011 --> 00:05:25,312
- May I help you?
- 40
- 00:05:25,387 --> 00:05:27,648
- Wilbur Tennant
- calling on Robbie Bilott.
- 41
- 00:05:28,057 --> 00:05:29,934
- EPA has saddled them
- with the whole bill
- 42
- 00:05:30,017 --> 00:05:32,019
- and given your client's
- history at that site,
- 43
- 00:05:32,102 --> 00:05:33,687
- that's a real possibility.
- 44
- 00:05:34,271 --> 00:05:38,250
- - I'll take it back to them.
- - Good. Tab 12, Middletown...
- 45
- 00:05:38,317 --> 00:05:40,544
- I know. I'm sorry.
- 46
- 00:05:40,945 --> 00:05:43,313
- - But they won't leave.
- - Who's they?
- 47
- 00:05:43,906 --> 00:05:46,458
- I don't know.
- They say they know you.
- 48
- 00:05:50,830 --> 00:05:53,590
- - Um...
- - Robert Bilott?
- 49
- 00:05:53,749 --> 00:05:56,310
- Um, yes.
- 50
- 00:05:57,878 --> 00:06:00,831
- They call it a landfill.
- A dump's what it is.
- 51
- 00:06:01,298 --> 00:06:03,843
- They told my brother and me
- no chemicals, just trash.
- 52
- 00:06:03,926 --> 00:06:05,377
- But we ain't stupid.
- 53
- 00:06:05,427 --> 00:06:08,013
- I made them videotapes myself.
- All the proof you need.
- 54
- 00:06:08,097 --> 00:06:09,974
- They're poisonin' the creek,
- killing my animals.
- 55
- 00:06:10,057 --> 00:06:12,101
- - I'm in the middle of a meeting.
- - So, I want a lawyer.
- 56
- 00:06:12,184 --> 00:06:14,812
- Every damn one in Parkersburg's
- too yella to take my case.
- 57
- 00:06:14,895 --> 00:06:16,605
- Rob. He wants you
- back in there.
- 58
- 00:06:16,689 --> 00:06:18,524
- They all scared shitless
- at DuPont.
- 59
- 00:06:18,607 --> 00:06:19,859
- Well, I ain't scared
- of nobody.
- 60
- 00:06:19,942 --> 00:06:21,527
- Okay.
- Kathleen is my paralegal.
- 61
- 00:06:21,610 --> 00:06:23,737
- She's gonna give you
- a directory of lawyers.
- 62
- 00:06:23,821 --> 00:06:25,539
- That's why
- I called your grandma.
- 63
- 00:06:27,575 --> 00:06:29,535
- - What?
- - My neighbor who tells me,
- 64
- 00:06:29,618 --> 00:06:30,986
- call Alma White.
- 65
- 00:06:31,453 --> 00:06:34,756
- Her grandson's some fancy environment
- lawyer down in Cincinnati.
- 66
- 00:06:39,837 --> 00:06:43,490
- Sir, I am a corporate
- defense attorney.
- 67
- 00:06:43,549 --> 00:06:46,110
- - So?
- - I defend chemical companies.
- 68
- 00:06:46,135 --> 00:06:49,171
- - Well, now you can defend me.
- - Rob!
- 69
- 00:06:50,347 --> 00:06:52,424
- Uh, 30 seconds, Tom.
- 70
- 00:06:53,183 --> 00:06:55,402
- - Uh, I'm sorry, Mr...
- - Tennant.
- 71
- 00:06:55,561 --> 00:06:57,229
- I can offer you
- a referral.
- 72
- 00:06:57,313 --> 00:07:00,190
- But I just don't see how I
- can be of any help to you.
- 73
- 00:07:00,274 --> 00:07:02,359
- You can start by watching
- them tapes for one thing.
- 74
- 00:07:02,443 --> 00:07:04,044
- Oh, let's go, Earl.
- 75
- 00:07:04,069 --> 00:07:06,864
- I'm sorry.
- I... I wish you all the luck.
- 76
- 00:07:06,947 --> 00:07:08,157
- I don't need
- your damn luck, boy!
- 77
- 00:07:08,240 --> 00:07:10,117
- - I need your help!
- - Rob!
- 78
- 00:07:13,037 --> 00:07:14,221
- Come on.
- 79
- 00:07:21,337 --> 00:07:23,680
- I'm not arguing
- with the overall analysis.
- 80
- 00:07:23,797 --> 00:07:26,850
- My only point is that
- whatever we decide upon...
- 81
- 00:07:32,222 --> 00:07:33,423
- Thank you, gentlemen.
- 82
- 00:07:35,851 --> 00:07:37,252
- Do you know
- where we're going?
- 83
- 00:07:37,895 --> 00:07:39,747
- There's a place
- right around the corner.
- 84
- 00:07:39,772 --> 00:07:42,215
- - Yeah?
- - What the hell was that all about?
- 85
- 00:07:42,942 --> 00:07:45,502
- - He knows my grandmother.
- - Really?
- 86
- 00:07:45,694 --> 00:07:47,863
- Well, my mom's from
- West Virginia.
- 87
- 00:07:47,947 --> 00:07:50,223
- Uh, from a town,
- Parkersburg.
- 88
- 00:07:50,282 --> 00:07:52,743
- Not us. My...
- my father was Air Force.
- 89
- 00:07:52,826 --> 00:07:54,036
- We...
- We moved around a lot,
- 90
- 00:07:54,119 --> 00:07:55,345
- but we spent
- the summers there.
- 91
- 00:07:55,371 --> 00:07:58,023
- - Come on, Terp. You're buying.
- - Of course I am.
- 92
- 00:07:59,375 --> 00:08:01,410
- You can be
- from West Virginia, Rob.
- 93
- 00:08:02,127 --> 00:08:03,804
- I won't tell anyone.
- 94
- 00:08:09,301 --> 00:08:11,687
- All right, gentlemen.
- Morton's it is.
- 95
- 00:08:13,263 --> 00:08:15,916
- Still deigned to eat
- with us lowly associates?
- 96
- 00:08:18,143 --> 00:08:19,928
- You can't drive
- an American car.
- 97
- 00:08:21,146 --> 00:08:23,983
- Taft-Hartley,
- union busting?
- 98
- 00:08:24,066 --> 00:08:25,934
- We practically invented it.
- 99
- 00:08:25,985 --> 00:08:27,027
- "We?"
- 100
- 00:08:27,111 --> 00:08:28,946
- Besides, I know
- a highly esteemed partner
- 101
- 00:08:29,029 --> 00:08:30,114
- who still drives American.
- 102
- 00:08:30,197 --> 00:08:31,590
- - Some real clunkers too.
- - Okay,
- 103
- 00:08:31,657 --> 00:08:33,425
- yeah, but he
- collects them.
- 104
- 00:08:33,492 --> 00:08:35,119
- That's different.
- Like his
- 105
- 00:08:35,202 --> 00:08:36,704
- no-name college
- and law school.
- 106
- 00:08:36,787 --> 00:08:37,955
- - No offense.
- - Are you listening to this?
- 107
- 00:08:38,038 --> 00:08:39,773
- Hey, you guys go ahead,
- all right?
- 108
- 00:08:39,873 --> 00:08:42,376
- - Look, I didn't mean anything by it.
- - No. I gotta make a call.
- 109
- 00:08:42,459 --> 00:08:43,460
- It's all right.
- I'll see you there.
- 110
- 00:08:43,544 --> 00:08:45,220
- Okay, we'll save you
- a fish log.
- 111
- 00:08:47,756 --> 00:08:50,309
- - You can be such an asshole.
- - Karla, it was a joke.
- 112
- 00:08:50,551 --> 00:08:51,885
- - Yeah.
- - We always joke.
- 113
- 00:08:51,969 --> 00:08:53,804
- Oh, yeah. You guys are
- a couple of jokesters.
- 114
- 00:09:03,355 --> 00:09:06,475
- You've
- reached the residence of Alma White.
- 115
- 00:09:06,734 --> 00:09:08,910
- I can't come to the phone
- right now...
- 116
- 00:09:09,695 --> 00:09:12,431
- He's good. He's home
- early tonight actually.
- 117
- 00:09:13,198 --> 00:09:15,234
- Tell him I
- said, howdy, partner.
- 118
- 00:09:15,534 --> 00:09:16,918
- She says,
- "Howdy, partner."
- 119
- 00:09:17,077 --> 00:09:18,787
- Are we ever gonna
- see him again on Sundays?
- 120
- 00:09:18,871 --> 00:09:20,914
- Yes, he can still come
- to Sunday dinners, Mom.
- 121
- 00:09:20,998 --> 00:09:23,125
- He's a partner,
- not the President of the United States.
- 122
- 00:09:23,208 --> 00:09:25,002
- I wanna make...
- Do you have my Bundt pan?
- 123
- 00:09:25,085 --> 00:09:26,086
- Returned it.
- 124
- 00:09:26,170 --> 00:09:27,212
- Where?
- I looked under the counter.
- 125
- 00:09:27,296 --> 00:09:29,973
- It's the right hand cupboard,
- in the plastic. Yeah.
- 126
- 00:09:30,924 --> 00:09:32,551
- Okay, well,
- we just sat down.
- 127
- 00:09:32,634 --> 00:09:33,635
- All right, dear.
- 128
- 00:09:33,719 --> 00:09:34,803
- So, I gotta go.
- 129
- 00:09:34,887 --> 00:09:35,888
- Love to Rob and Teddy.
- 130
- 00:09:35,971 --> 00:09:37,473
- All right, see you Sunday.
- Love to Dad.
- 131
- 00:09:37,556 --> 00:09:38,557
- Talk to you later.
- 132
- 00:09:38,640 --> 00:09:39,892
- Can you pretend to be
- surprised about the cake?
- 133
- 00:09:39,975 --> 00:09:41,310
- She wants it
- to be very special.
- 134
- 00:09:42,227 --> 00:09:44,229
- Oh, and the granite samples
- came in.
- 135
- 00:09:44,313 --> 00:09:45,773
- Can you pick them up
- on your way home tomorrow?
- 136
- 00:09:45,856 --> 00:09:47,316
- - Mmm.
- - Rob?
- 137
- 00:09:47,566 --> 00:09:48,692
- Hmm? Uh, sure.
- 138
- 00:09:55,574 --> 00:09:56,617
- You okay?
- 139
- 00:09:57,076 --> 00:09:58,077
- Yes.
- 140
- 00:09:58,994 --> 00:10:00,370
- Bless us, our Lord
- and thy gifts
- 141
- 00:10:00,454 --> 00:10:02,081
- which we are about to receive
- from thy bounty
- 142
- 00:10:02,164 --> 00:10:03,373
- through Christ our Lord. Amen.
- 143
- 00:10:03,707 --> 00:10:05,942
- Thank you, God.
- Thank you for our family.
- 144
- 00:11:04,810 --> 00:11:05,911
- Thank you.
- 145
- 00:11:45,767 --> 00:11:50,189
- - Hi, Grammers.
- - What on earth!
- 146
- 00:11:52,316 --> 00:11:53,942
- I tried to call,
- but you weren't picking up.
- 147
- 00:11:54,026 --> 00:11:57,404
- Oh, well, you know me.
- My two fake knees.
- 148
- 00:11:57,487 --> 00:12:00,741
- What are you doing here?
- 149
- 00:12:02,659 --> 00:12:05,746
- A farmer came to see me.
- 150
- 00:12:08,165 --> 00:12:09,458
- Wilbur Tennant?
- 151
- 00:12:09,958 --> 00:12:11,168
- You do know him.
- 152
- 00:12:11,251 --> 00:12:14,338
- I don't socialize with him,
- if that's what you mean.
- 153
- 00:12:16,006 --> 00:12:18,717
- Inez Graham owned the farm
- next to his.
- 154
- 00:12:19,301 --> 00:12:22,054
- I used to take you and Beth
- over there when you were little.
- 155
- 00:12:23,180 --> 00:12:24,264
- That's the place?
- 156
- 00:12:38,278 --> 00:12:39,279
- Hmm.
- 157
- 00:12:41,114 --> 00:12:42,824
- - You rode that pony.
- - Ah!
- 158
- 00:12:44,493 --> 00:12:45,911
- I loved that place.
- 159
- 00:12:47,120 --> 00:12:49,122
- Saw a cow
- for the first time.
- 160
- 00:12:49,998 --> 00:12:51,083
- Learned to milk it.
- 161
- 00:12:51,959 --> 00:12:53,710
- I remember
- you sittin' there for hours
- 162
- 00:12:53,794 --> 00:12:56,255
- making sure you got
- every last drop.
- 163
- 00:12:56,797 --> 00:12:57,923
- Just like you.
- 164
- 00:12:59,758 --> 00:13:00,759
- There.
- 165
- 00:13:01,677 --> 00:13:02,678
- Hmm.
- 166
- 00:13:03,178 --> 00:13:04,471
- So you gonna help him?
- 167
- 00:13:05,472 --> 00:13:06,473
- Huh?
- 168
- 00:13:55,147 --> 00:13:58,608
- You come up the holler,
- dump's up the hill.
- 169
- 00:14:01,903 --> 00:14:04,072
- Since I started
- complaining about my creek,
- 170
- 00:14:04,156 --> 00:14:06,533
- fence goes up.
- All blocked off.
- 171
- 00:14:12,539 --> 00:14:13,832
- Hi, I'm Rob.
- 172
- 00:14:14,583 --> 00:14:15,584
- Sandra.
- 173
- 00:14:17,127 --> 00:14:21,173
- The State, any veterinarian
- I've called in Parkersburg,
- 174
- 00:14:22,424 --> 00:14:24,509
- they will not
- return my phone calls.
- 175
- 00:14:24,593 --> 00:14:26,178
- Like I bite the hand
- that feeds.
- 176
- 00:14:26,261 --> 00:14:28,588
- - No, it's all right. I've already...
- - This here's a gall.
- 177
- 00:14:28,889 --> 00:14:30,182
- Look at the size of it.
- Ain't never seen
- 178
- 00:14:30,265 --> 00:14:32,275
- no gall that big.
- Bigger than the heart.
- 179
- 00:14:33,185 --> 00:14:34,394
- That your cows'?
- 180
- 00:14:34,478 --> 00:14:35,762
- Look at them teeth.
- 181
- 00:14:38,273 --> 00:14:40,684
- Black as night. Here.
- 182
- 00:14:44,237 --> 00:14:46,698
- Hoof, all turned in
- on itself.
- 183
- 00:14:46,782 --> 00:14:48,984
- Half my calves born
- with hooves like that.
- 184
- 00:14:52,371 --> 00:14:54,581
- Tumor, I done
- cut off the back a heifer.
- 185
- 00:14:54,664 --> 00:14:56,249
- How'd ya like
- that on your table?
- 186
- 00:15:00,545 --> 00:15:02,172
- What am I looking for?
- 187
- 00:15:03,256 --> 00:15:04,508
- You blind, boy?
- 188
- 00:15:05,300 --> 00:15:07,886
- Stones as white
- as the hairs on my head.
- 189
- 00:15:09,054 --> 00:15:11,515
- Bleached! That's chemicals,
- I'm telling ya.
- 190
- 00:15:13,141 --> 00:15:16,228
- My animals drink this water.
- Cool off in 'er.
- 191
- 00:15:16,812 --> 00:15:19,648
- Get them bloody welts,
- them dead eyes.
- 192
- 00:15:19,731 --> 00:15:21,733
- Charge at me, crazy-like.
- 193
- 00:15:21,817 --> 00:15:23,860
- Animals that used to eat
- out of my own hand.
- 194
- 00:15:29,366 --> 00:15:30,534
- Where are
- the rest of them?
- 195
- 00:15:32,494 --> 00:15:33,578
- Come on.
- 196
- 00:15:46,258 --> 00:15:49,428
- Beginnin', I'd bury 'em.
- Each one. They're family.
- 197
- 00:15:51,138 --> 00:15:54,182
- It got to be so many,
- pile 'em up, set fire to...
- 198
- 00:15:57,644 --> 00:15:59,855
- How many did you lose?
- 199
- 00:16:00,480 --> 00:16:02,941
- 190.
- 200
- 00:16:04,526 --> 00:16:06,653
- 190 cows?
- 201
- 00:16:06,736 --> 00:16:08,655
- You tell me
- nothing's wrong here.
- 202
- 00:16:16,121 --> 00:16:19,875
- And this landfill
- wasn't always here?
- 203
- 00:16:20,584 --> 00:16:24,963
- No. My brother Jim used to dig
- ditches over at the DuPont plant.
- 204
- 00:16:25,213 --> 00:16:27,591
- Got sick, couldn't
- do it no more.
- 205
- 00:16:27,883 --> 00:16:30,886
- One day they come to him, offering
- to buy his land right up that holler.
- 206
- 00:16:32,179 --> 00:16:34,181
- They promised no chemicals.
- 207
- 00:16:34,389 --> 00:16:37,017
- And I assume you
- reached out to DuPont?
- 208
- 00:16:37,100 --> 00:16:38,977
- DuPont, the State,
- the Feds.
- 209
- 00:16:39,060 --> 00:16:41,438
- I called everybody
- there is dozens of times.
- 210
- 00:16:42,147 --> 00:16:44,566
- - EPA finally comes out here.
- - Oh, they did.
- 211
- 00:16:44,816 --> 00:16:47,569
- - All for some report.
- - What did it say?
- 212
- 00:16:47,903 --> 00:16:49,362
- You think they're
- gonna show me?
- 213
- 00:17:15,263 --> 00:17:16,431
- Okay.
- 214
- 00:17:20,602 --> 00:17:24,856
- He's been like this all day.
- Okay. Go on.
- 215
- 00:17:29,903 --> 00:17:31,988
- Of course, you're
- a perfect angel for Daddy.
- 216
- 00:17:34,699 --> 00:17:38,119
- - Did you get the tile?
- - Um, I'm sorry. No.
- 217
- 00:17:39,371 --> 00:17:40,455
- Rob.
- 218
- 00:17:42,666 --> 00:17:44,334
- I didn't drive into town today.
- I'm sorry.
- 219
- 00:17:45,293 --> 00:17:47,462
- What do you mean
- you didn't drive into town?
- 220
- 00:17:48,088 --> 00:17:49,548
- I had to go
- to Parkersburg.
- 221
- 00:17:50,882 --> 00:17:53,260
- Parkersburg? Why'd you
- have to go to Parkersburg?
- 222
- 00:17:54,636 --> 00:17:56,638
- I may have a client there.
- 223
- 00:17:57,472 --> 00:18:00,517
- In West Virginia? What kind
- of a case would you have?
- 224
- 00:18:01,560 --> 00:18:04,437
- He's a farmer. He knows
- my Grammer. Not well, but...
- 225
- 00:18:05,146 --> 00:18:09,067
- So, you saw her?
- Was your mother there?
- 226
- 00:18:09,150 --> 00:18:12,404
- Oh, come on, Sarah. I didn't
- sneak off to see my mother.
- 227
- 00:18:13,321 --> 00:18:15,657
- - So, why did you sneak off?
- - I didn't.
- 228
- 00:18:18,660 --> 00:18:21,955
- Our speaker tonight's no
- Stranger to the Taft family.
- 229
- 00:18:22,956 --> 00:18:25,750
- Phillip Donnelly,
- Phil to us,
- 230
- 00:18:26,167 --> 00:18:28,878
- serves as in-house
- Corporate Counsel at DuPont.
- 231
- 00:18:29,671 --> 00:18:33,341
- Not only one of America's most
- revered chemical companies,
- 232
- 00:18:34,009 --> 00:18:36,928
- but one of the few
- giants of the industry
- 233
- 00:18:37,012 --> 00:18:40,223
- - that Taft doesn't represent.
- - Not yet anyway!
- 234
- 00:18:40,724 --> 00:18:42,892
- That's the spirit, James.
- 235
- 00:18:44,102 --> 00:18:47,647
- We asked Phil here tonight,
- not just to show him what he's missing,
- 236
- 00:18:48,023 --> 00:18:51,276
- but to hear how a renowned
- leader of our industry
- 237
- 00:18:51,818 --> 00:18:55,780
- stays that way.
- Please welcome Phil Donnelly.
- 238
- 00:18:59,284 --> 00:19:01,369
- - Wish me luck.
- - Go get 'em, Phil!
- 239
- 00:19:01,453 --> 00:19:02,454
- Thank you.
- 240
- 00:19:02,537 --> 00:19:06,041
- At DuPont, we're not producing
- chemicals for chemical's sake.
- 241
- 00:19:06,124 --> 00:19:07,876
- We're producing them
- for people's sake.
- 242
- 00:19:08,126 --> 00:19:10,503
- To make folks' lives easier.
- 243
- 00:19:10,962 --> 00:19:13,048
- Happier, longer.
- 244
- 00:19:14,382 --> 00:19:18,595
- That's why better living
- through chemistry
- 245
- 00:19:19,429 --> 00:19:21,473
- is not just
- a slogan at DuPont.
- 246
- 00:19:23,058 --> 00:19:24,643
- It's our DNA.
- 247
- 00:19:29,731 --> 00:19:31,566
- - Hey, Rob.
- - Hello, Phil.
- 248
- 00:19:31,691 --> 00:19:34,069
- - Is it true what Tom tells me?
- - Yeah, it's true.
- 249
- 00:19:34,152 --> 00:19:36,404
- - Well, good on them. They're lucky to have you.
- - Thanks, Phil.
- 250
- 00:19:36,696 --> 00:19:38,448
- Like I always tell
- my younger associates,
- 251
- 00:19:38,531 --> 00:19:40,784
- just keep your head down
- and do the work.
- 252
- 00:19:40,867 --> 00:19:45,038
- Thanks. Uh, Phil, can I ask
- you sort of an odd question?
- 253
- 00:19:45,246 --> 00:19:46,456
- Shoot.
- 254
- 00:19:46,623 --> 00:19:49,125
- Does the name
- Wilbur Tennant ring a bell?
- 255
- 00:19:50,377 --> 00:19:52,212
- - Tennet, did you say?
- - Tennant.
- 256
- 00:19:52,754 --> 00:19:54,047
- No. Not that I recall.
- 257
- 00:19:54,130 --> 00:19:56,758
- Mr. Tennant's a farmer
- from West Virginia.
- 258
- 00:19:56,841 --> 00:20:00,053
- His property abuts one of
- your landfills, Dry Run.
- 259
- 00:20:00,136 --> 00:20:01,805
- And his cows
- have been getting sick.
- 260
- 00:20:01,888 --> 00:20:05,975
- He thinks possibly because of the
- runoff from the landfill into his creek.
- 261
- 00:20:06,059 --> 00:20:07,811
- You're kidding me.
- How did this come to you?
- 262
- 00:20:07,894 --> 00:20:11,064
- - Hey, Phil!
- - He's a farmer. He's...
- 263
- 00:20:12,023 --> 00:20:14,067
- My grandmother's
- from Parkersburg.
- 264
- 00:20:14,150 --> 00:20:16,236
- Really? Washington Works.
- Great plant.
- 265
- 00:20:16,361 --> 00:20:18,863
- - Right. She knows the Tennants.
- - So Grandma's on your back?
- 266
- 00:20:18,947 --> 00:20:20,699
- Something like that.
- Anyway, uh...
- 267
- 00:20:21,950 --> 00:20:25,537
- The farmer said the EPA came out,
- took a look around. I wondered...
- 268
- 00:20:25,704 --> 00:20:27,580
- - The name of the landfill again?
- - Dry Run.
- 269
- 00:20:28,039 --> 00:20:29,708
- Dry Run. Dry...
- 270
- 00:20:30,041 --> 00:20:32,001
- You know, that does ring a
- bell, now that you mention it.
- 271
- 00:20:32,085 --> 00:20:33,920
- We may have even sent
- some folks out there.
- 272
- 00:20:34,170 --> 00:20:36,131
- If I remember correctly,
- help EPA check it out.
- 273
- 00:20:36,214 --> 00:20:39,467
- That's gotta be it.
- So, I'd love to share whatever came of that
- 274
- 00:20:39,551 --> 00:20:41,594
- with Mr. Tennant.
- Help settle his nerves.
- 275
- 00:20:41,720 --> 00:20:44,514
- Absolutely. Soon as I'm back in
- Wilmington, I'll take a look.
- 276
- 00:20:44,639 --> 00:20:47,475
- - Thanks, Phil. I really appreciate it.
- - Happy to do it.
- 277
- 00:20:47,559 --> 00:20:50,937
- Now, let's get a drink and
- toast you, my friend. You.
- 278
- 00:20:51,896 --> 00:20:53,022
- Okay.
- 279
- 00:21:01,197 --> 00:21:02,449
- Mr. Tennant!
- 280
- 00:21:10,123 --> 00:21:13,001
- Mr. Tennant,
- I have the report.
- 281
- 00:21:15,336 --> 00:21:18,381
- Sons of bitches!
- Who the hell they think they are?
- 282
- 00:21:19,174 --> 00:21:21,176
- - Who gives them the right?
- - It's an evaluation.
- 283
- 00:21:21,259 --> 00:21:24,053
- Evalu, Hatchet
- job's what it is.
- 284
- 00:21:25,054 --> 00:21:28,224
- I been farming my
- entire life. Entire life!
- 285
- 00:21:28,641 --> 00:21:31,519
- You read that. You tell me
- you recognize my farm.
- 286
- 00:21:31,603 --> 00:21:33,062
- - Mr. Tennant...
- - Read it!
- 287
- 00:21:36,441 --> 00:21:38,985
- "The herd health
- investigation revealed
- 288
- 00:21:39,068 --> 00:21:41,362
- "deficiency
- in herd management.
- 289
- 00:21:42,071 --> 00:21:44,657
- "Including poor nutrition,
- 290
- 00:21:45,283 --> 00:21:49,871
- "inadequate veterinary care
- and lack of fly control."
- 291
- 00:21:50,079 --> 00:21:51,664
- You see any flies here?
- 292
- 00:21:52,791 --> 00:21:53,875
- It's snowing.
- 293
- 00:21:54,167 --> 00:21:56,336
- Can't stop making excuses
- for 'em, can you?
- 294
- 00:21:58,087 --> 00:22:00,924
- It could be pests.
- They consulted a vet.
- 295
- 00:22:01,174 --> 00:22:02,759
- Whose vet? DuPont?
- 296
- 00:22:06,095 --> 00:22:09,808
- Look at yourself. Swallowin' whole,
- whatever they been feeding ya.
- 297
- 00:22:09,891 --> 00:22:11,142
- Can't tell truth from lie.
- 298
- 00:22:13,603 --> 00:22:15,063
- You even watch them tapes
- I gave you?
- 299
- 00:22:15,146 --> 00:22:18,358
- - Sir, I am trying to help!
- - Quiet.
- 300
- 00:22:19,025 --> 00:22:21,444
- - Trying to help.
- - Stop movin'.
- 301
- 00:22:29,327 --> 00:22:31,496
- Easy, now. Easy.
- 302
- 00:22:35,083 --> 00:22:37,460
- Get in. Slow.
- 303
- 00:23:03,903 --> 00:23:05,196
- Forgive me, girl.
- 304
- 00:23:29,554 --> 00:23:31,014
- Jesus.
- 305
- 00:24:25,902 --> 00:24:27,779
- Need something to
- warm you up right about now?
- 306
- 00:24:28,529 --> 00:24:30,531
- Well, how about this?
- 307
- 00:24:34,327 --> 00:24:39,040
- Almost heaven, West Virginia
- 308
- 00:24:40,083 --> 00:24:45,922
- Blue Ridge Mountains,
- Shenandoah River
- 309
- 00:24:47,340 --> 00:24:52,303
- Life is old there,
- older than the trees
- 310
- 00:24:52,428 --> 00:24:57,475
- Younger than the mountains
- Blowing like the breeze
- 311
- 00:24:57,642 --> 00:25:03,022
- Country roads, take me home
- 312
- 00:25:03,398 --> 00:25:06,109
- To the place...
- 313
- 00:25:06,442 --> 00:25:09,153
- I belong
- 314
- 00:25:09,320 --> 00:25:11,990
- West Virginia...
- 315
- 00:25:12,198 --> 00:25:14,867
- mountain mama
- 316
- 00:25:15,159 --> 00:25:17,286
- Take me home...
- 317
- 00:25:17,495 --> 00:25:22,458
- ...this cow's eyes are cloudy
- with pink eyes is what they'll call it.
- 318
- 00:25:22,750 --> 00:25:25,128
- Anyway, her eyes are sunk
- way back in her head.
- 319
- 00:25:25,878 --> 00:25:29,007
- She's poor as a whippoorwill.
- 320
- 00:25:30,758 --> 00:25:35,430
- And I'm gonna cut her open and
- find out what caused her to die.
- 321
- 00:25:36,139 --> 00:25:37,932
- Because I was feeding
- her enough feed...
- 322
- 00:25:38,016 --> 00:25:40,393
- that she should've gained
- weight instead of losin' weight.
- 323
- 00:25:41,436 --> 00:25:43,062
- This is what
- her teeth looks like.
- 324
- 00:25:45,648 --> 00:25:47,650
- That's the upper one.
- 325
- 00:25:47,817 --> 00:25:52,405
- But this one here, I've never seen
- anything like it in my lifetime.
- 326
- 00:25:53,781 --> 00:25:55,199
- Even the veterinarian,
- he admitted...
- 327
- 00:25:55,283 --> 00:25:58,870
- he never saw anything like
- this before in his life either.
- 328
- 00:26:08,755 --> 00:26:13,301
- So, what are you
- proposing we do?
- 329
- 00:26:13,468 --> 00:26:17,972
- File a claim, trigger discovery and
- find out what's in that landfill.
- 330
- 00:26:18,931 --> 00:26:20,975
- - You wanna sue DuPont?
- - Targeted.
- 331
- 00:26:22,101 --> 00:26:25,688
- - Property dispute. Routine stuff.
- - Not routine. Not around here.
- 332
- 00:26:25,772 --> 00:26:28,357
- I know, but, Tom,
- if you'd actually seen it.
- 333
- 00:26:28,441 --> 00:26:32,528
- His farm is like a graveyard.
- There's something very wrong.
- 334
- 00:26:32,612 --> 00:26:35,198
- So, he should
- hire a local lawyer.
- 335
- 00:26:35,281 --> 00:26:38,117
- None of them will do it.
- They're all terrified of DuPont.
- 336
- 00:26:38,242 --> 00:26:40,411
- - Well, what does that tell you?
- - We know DuPont.
- 337
- 00:26:41,162 --> 00:26:42,705
- They're gonna wanna hear
- 338
- 00:26:42,789 --> 00:26:45,458
- if some of their local guys
- are screwing something up.
- 339
- 00:26:45,541 --> 00:26:48,544
- Oh, so they're gonna
- thank us for suing.
- 340
- 00:26:48,628 --> 00:26:50,171
- Better us than the EPA.
- 341
- 00:26:50,421 --> 00:26:52,924
- I mean, new partners are supposed
- to bring in business, right?
- 342
- 00:26:53,007 --> 00:26:55,426
- So, your farmer
- can swing 275 an hour?
- 343
- 00:26:55,510 --> 00:26:57,428
- It'd be on contingency.
- 344
- 00:26:58,012 --> 00:27:01,057
- Jesus. What are we,
- coupon chasers now?
- 345
- 00:27:01,140 --> 00:27:04,894
- It's a small matter for a family friend.
- I'll get in and I'll get out.
- 346
- 00:27:06,104 --> 00:27:09,649
- - Help a guy that needs it.
- - Who? The farmer or you?
- 347
- 00:27:30,086 --> 00:27:32,004
- Surgical. You hear me?
- 348
- 00:27:32,088 --> 00:27:33,422
- Absolutely. Thank you.
- 349
- 00:27:35,925 --> 00:27:38,761
- Come on, Rob.
- Of course, I'm gonna take your call.
- 350
- 00:27:39,011 --> 00:27:41,764
- Even though, I was,
- I admit, a little surprised.
- 351
- 00:27:42,056 --> 00:27:44,267
- I mean, getting
- sued by Taft Law.
- 352
- 00:27:45,101 --> 00:27:47,812
- It's not every day.
- Or any day, frankly.
- 353
- 00:27:47,979 --> 00:27:49,313
- I know. I'm sorry.
- 354
- 00:27:49,397 --> 00:27:52,900
- Look, you and I are friends.
- This is a minor issue.
- 355
- 00:27:52,984 --> 00:27:55,194
- No reason it
- should get messy.
- 356
- 00:27:55,278 --> 00:27:59,115
- Thank you. I totally agree.
- Yeah, I'm putting you on speaker phone.
- 357
- 00:28:01,159 --> 00:28:04,412
- So, you wanna know
- if we violated our permits.
- 358
- 00:28:04,704 --> 00:28:05,746
- Pretty much, yeah.
- 359
- 00:28:06,372 --> 00:28:09,000
- Okay, then. I'll have our
- guys send over anything...
- 360
- 00:28:09,083 --> 00:28:11,419
- related to hazardous wastes
- at Dry Run.
- 361
- 00:28:11,502 --> 00:28:14,672
- And I'll tell them to hurry
- it up this time. How's that?
- 362
- 00:28:14,755 --> 00:28:18,301
- - Thank you. That sounds great.
- - And don't stress. I forgive you.
- 363
- 00:28:18,676 --> 00:28:19,719
- Thanks, Phil.
- 364
- 00:28:41,824 --> 00:28:43,284
- You took your baby
- into the office?
- 365
- 00:28:43,367 --> 00:28:46,454
- - I needed a bigger trunk.
- - Why?
- 366
- 00:28:47,079 --> 00:28:49,582
- Discovery for the Tennant
- case came in today.
- 367
- 00:28:49,665 --> 00:28:54,670
- Oh. Oh, you started before me.
- You're so fast! Whoa.
- 368
- 00:28:54,754 --> 00:28:56,547
- Good boy.
- 369
- 00:28:56,631 --> 00:28:58,549
- Rob's missing
- such a lovely day.
- 370
- 00:28:59,508 --> 00:29:02,678
- Law's a jealous mistress, Mom.
- Means it comes with the territory.
- 371
- 00:29:02,762 --> 00:29:04,096
- Let's go over here!
- 372
- 00:29:04,430 --> 00:29:07,350
- Nice! Thank you!
- That's what I'm talking about right there.
- 373
- 00:29:11,270 --> 00:29:13,064
- All right. Let's go. One more.
- One more. All right.
- 374
- 00:29:32,166 --> 00:29:33,292
- Poly...
- 375
- 00:29:33,459 --> 00:29:34,627
- Is that...
- 376
- 00:29:51,435 --> 00:29:52,937
- No.
- 377
- 00:30:00,319 --> 00:30:03,155
- - How's my favorite plaintiff's attorney?
- - Hey, help me out, will ya?
- 378
- 00:30:03,239 --> 00:30:05,616
- You're a run of a mill
- dump, nothing but trash.
- 379
- 00:30:05,783 --> 00:30:07,285
- You sound like
- my first girlfriend.
- 380
- 00:30:08,786 --> 00:30:12,999
- Why a requisition order
- for 55-gallon containers?
- 381
- 00:30:13,374 --> 00:30:15,668
- Conspiracy.
- Standard size drums.
- 382
- 00:30:15,751 --> 00:30:20,798
- Ash, ash-byproduct, glass tubing,
- plastic, paper waste. It's just trash.
- 383
- 00:30:20,965 --> 00:30:23,843
- You pile it onto a truck, drive it away.
- You don't pack it into drums.
- 384
- 00:30:23,968 --> 00:30:26,345
- - So, they've got liquid waste.
- - Not hazardous.
- 385
- 00:30:26,804 --> 00:30:30,141
- Or they'd have to disclose it.
- So, what is killing these cows?
- 386
- 00:30:30,308 --> 00:30:32,727
- - It's not paper and ash.
- - Well, maybe it's human error.
- 387
- 00:30:32,893 --> 00:30:35,146
- They're dumping something in
- there they don't know is toxic.
- 388
- 00:30:35,604 --> 00:30:39,567
- Kim, it's DuPont. They know
- more than the EPA does.
- 389
- 00:30:39,734 --> 00:30:41,652
- Everyone knows more
- than the EPA does.
- 390
- 00:30:41,819 --> 00:30:43,779
- Why else would they
- let us regulate ourselves?
- 391
- 00:30:46,115 --> 00:30:48,868
- - What?
- - Do we?
- 392
- 00:30:49,076 --> 00:30:50,494
- Do we what?
- 393
- 00:30:51,787 --> 00:30:54,874
- The EPA only started
- regulating chemicals in '76.
- 394
- 00:30:54,957 --> 00:30:56,000
- Yeah?
- 395
- 00:30:56,083 --> 00:30:59,670
- They grandfather in every
- existing chemical, non-hazardous,
- 396
- 00:30:59,754 --> 00:31:03,716
- unless they knew it was hazardous
- or a company told them it was.
- 397
- 00:31:03,799 --> 00:31:06,510
- - We're saying the same thing.
- - No, we're not. I'm saying
- 398
- 00:31:06,594 --> 00:31:10,097
- what if
- a company didn't tell?
- 399
- 00:31:11,807 --> 00:31:13,517
- What if
- 400
- 00:31:13,601 --> 00:31:17,396
- the reason Phil Donnelly agreed
- to discovery on hazardous
- 401
- 00:31:17,480 --> 00:31:19,106
- is because he knows
- 402
- 00:31:19,732 --> 00:31:22,818
- whatever's in that landfill
- isn't even regulated?
- 403
- 00:31:23,194 --> 00:31:25,946
- Okay, now you are sounding
- like a plaintiff's attorney.
- 404
- 00:31:26,530 --> 00:31:29,158
- - I've got a meeting.
- - Hey, oh, wait, one second.
- 405
- 00:31:29,367 --> 00:31:33,162
- Have you heard of this,
- um, PFOA?
- 406
- 00:31:34,080 --> 00:31:35,206
- No.
- 407
- 00:31:35,414 --> 00:31:38,709
- You know, it's mentioned here,
- but I can't find anything about it
- 408
- 00:31:38,793 --> 00:31:41,253
- in any of the literature.
- I don't even know if it's a chemical.
- 409
- 00:31:41,837 --> 00:31:44,840
- - Ask Phil.
- - Well, thank you.
- 410
- 00:31:45,508 --> 00:31:48,135
- As I said,
- Mr. Donnelly is still out of town.
- 411
- 00:31:48,302 --> 00:31:51,889
- I called last week and left two messages
- and haven't heard back from him.
- 412
- 00:31:51,972 --> 00:31:53,808
- I'll be sure to tell him
- that you called again.
- 413
- 00:31:53,891 --> 00:31:55,559
- Okay. Damn it.
- 414
- 00:31:56,852 --> 00:31:59,313
- - Your tickets to the Chemical Alliance dinner.
- - Argh...
- 415
- 00:31:59,647 --> 00:32:02,441
- And, no, dark suit is not
- the same as black tie.
- 416
- 00:32:04,026 --> 00:32:05,111
- Wouldn't he be going?
- 417
- 00:32:35,850 --> 00:32:39,019
- I don't know if Rob told you,
- but I was a receptionist at Taft
- 418
- 00:32:39,103 --> 00:32:40,604
- - before law school.
- - Is that right?
- 419
- 00:32:40,688 --> 00:32:42,648
- But well, I think the
- right Bilott ended up there.
- 420
- 00:32:42,731 --> 00:32:44,400
- Harold, you're not
- getting away from me.
- 421
- 00:32:44,483 --> 00:32:46,360
- - Would you excuse me?
- - Sure, it was...
- 422
- 00:32:46,444 --> 00:32:48,821
- - It's great to see you.
- - When is the...
- 423
- 00:32:48,904 --> 00:32:50,865
- That's funny.
- 424
- 00:32:51,615 --> 00:32:54,326
- Right away, I saw a little
- of myself in Rob.
- 425
- 00:32:54,493 --> 00:32:56,620
- - Oh!
- - One black sheep to another.
- 426
- 00:32:56,787 --> 00:32:59,081
- - My dad was a steel worker, you know.
- - Was he?
- 427
- 00:32:59,248 --> 00:33:01,167
- Have you seen Phil?
- 428
- 00:33:01,709 --> 00:33:03,210
- No.
- 429
- 00:33:03,502 --> 00:33:06,881
- - So, you're an attorney?
- - Oh, recovering.
- 430
- 00:33:07,173 --> 00:33:09,675
- I represented employers
- in workmen's comp disputes.
- 431
- 00:33:09,758 --> 00:33:12,011
- But now, I stay at home
- with our baby.
- 432
- 00:33:12,344 --> 00:33:14,889
- Well, that's the thing
- with lady lawyers.
- 433
- 00:33:15,639 --> 00:33:17,141
- I wanna say hi to the Dow folks.
- Have you seen them?
- 434
- 00:33:17,224 --> 00:33:18,642
- No, I've been looking
- for Phil.
- 435
- 00:33:18,726 --> 00:33:20,144
- Did I tell you they
- sent me some work?
- 436
- 00:33:20,311 --> 00:33:23,772
- - Dow? That's great!
- - Just a small project. Like a try-out.
- 437
- 00:33:23,856 --> 00:33:27,151
- But if I impress them,
- can you imagine if I brought on Dow?
- 438
- 00:33:27,234 --> 00:33:29,778
- None for me, thank you.
- 439
- 00:33:30,863 --> 00:33:31,906
- You're not...
- 440
- 00:33:34,074 --> 00:33:35,075
- I'm, uh...
- 441
- 00:33:36,327 --> 00:33:38,245
- You're... She's...
- 442
- 00:33:38,329 --> 00:33:39,997
- I'm...
- 443
- 00:33:40,080 --> 00:33:42,958
- I'm gonna wait as long as I can
- to tell the firm. Obviously.
- 444
- 00:33:43,042 --> 00:33:44,627
- Would you excuse
- us for a moment?
- 445
- 00:33:44,710 --> 00:33:46,795
- These lady lawyers
- need a quick sidebar.
- 446
- 00:33:46,879 --> 00:33:48,255
- - Of course.
- - No. No.
- 447
- 00:33:48,339 --> 00:33:50,424
- - He signs your paycheck. Be nice to him.
- - Don't leave me.
- 448
- 00:33:52,968 --> 00:33:55,387
- - Congratulations.
- - I know. I can't believe it.
- 449
- 00:34:01,310 --> 00:34:02,394
- Excuse me.
- 450
- 00:34:12,112 --> 00:34:13,322
- Rob, how are you?
- 451
- 00:34:13,405 --> 00:34:14,740
- Phil, I've been
- trying to reach you.
- 452
- 00:34:14,823 --> 00:34:16,659
- So sorry, all this traveling.
- How about I give you a shout tomorrow?
- 453
- 00:34:16,742 --> 00:34:18,536
- We're gonna need to broaden
- discovery to everything
- 454
- 00:34:18,619 --> 00:34:20,371
- in that landfill,
- hazardous or not.
- 455
- 00:34:24,542 --> 00:34:25,584
- Excuse me.
- 456
- 00:34:26,669 --> 00:34:28,045
- You kidding me?
- 457
- 00:34:28,128 --> 00:34:29,129
- No.
- 458
- 00:34:31,632 --> 00:34:33,801
- I think whatever's causing
- the problems in there
- 459
- 00:34:33,884 --> 00:34:36,971
- isn't something the EPA
- regulates or knows to regulate.
- 460
- 00:34:37,596 --> 00:34:38,597
- Sorry?
- 461
- 00:34:38,681 --> 00:34:42,017
- I'm seeing things in your
- documents I don't understand.
- 462
- 00:34:42,101 --> 00:34:44,311
- You're seeing ghosts,
- is what you're seeing, and frankly,
- 463
- 00:34:44,395 --> 00:34:45,729
- you're making an
- ass of yourself.
- 464
- 00:34:45,813 --> 00:34:47,481
- Okay, then,
- help me out.
- 465
- 00:34:47,565 --> 00:34:48,816
- I mean, like this.
- 466
- 00:34:48,899 --> 00:34:52,152
- I mean, what is
- this PFOA?
- 467
- 00:34:52,820 --> 00:34:54,488
- What's that stand for?
- 468
- 00:34:56,323 --> 00:34:57,616
- Jesus.
- 469
- 00:34:57,700 --> 00:34:59,994
- You're on a goddamn
- fishing expedition.
- 470
- 00:35:00,619 --> 00:35:03,080
- You wanna flush your
- career down the toilet
- 471
- 00:35:03,163 --> 00:35:04,206
- for some cowhand?
- 472
- 00:35:04,290 --> 00:35:05,874
- Be my guest. I'm
- done helping you.
- 473
- 00:35:05,958 --> 00:35:08,419
- Phil, I need to insist
- on broadening discovery.
- 474
- 00:35:08,752 --> 00:35:09,795
- - Sue me!
- - Uh...
- 475
- 00:35:10,879 --> 00:35:11,922
- I'm already suing you.
- 476
- 00:35:12,006 --> 00:35:13,215
- Welcome, everyone,
- 477
- 00:35:13,299 --> 00:35:16,760
- to the 14th Annual Ohio
- Chemical Alliance...
- 478
- 00:35:16,844 --> 00:35:18,470
- - Fuck you!
- - ...awards dinner.
- 479
- 00:35:21,473 --> 00:35:22,516
- Hick!
- 480
- 00:35:25,978 --> 00:35:28,981
- So, let's
- get the fun started!
- 481
- 00:35:49,918 --> 00:35:51,503
- I'm sorry.
- 482
- 00:35:51,587 --> 00:35:53,547
- You're not the only
- one who's sacrificed.
- 483
- 00:35:59,928 --> 00:36:02,056
- I just hope you know what you're doing.
- 484
- 00:36:08,729 --> 00:36:10,898
- You know the difference between
- business and pleasure, right?
- 485
- 00:36:10,981 --> 00:36:14,610
- So, why on earth would you
- engage in business conversations
- 486
- 00:36:14,693 --> 00:36:16,612
- - at a public function?
- - Tom!
- 487
- 00:36:17,404 --> 00:36:19,948
- He's hiding something.
- You saw his reaction.
- 488
- 00:36:20,032 --> 00:36:21,825
- Yeah, me and everyone
- in that room.
- 489
- 00:36:21,909 --> 00:36:23,786
- Taft in a pissing
- match with DuPont.
- 490
- 00:36:23,869 --> 00:36:25,788
- I am gonna get a court
- order and force them
- 491
- 00:36:25,871 --> 00:36:27,164
- to tell me everything
- that's in that landfill.
- 492
- 00:36:27,247 --> 00:36:29,583
- Jesus Christ! Now you wanna
- actually take them to court.
- 493
- 00:36:29,667 --> 00:36:31,710
- And I'm gonna need local
- counsel in West Virginia.
- 494
- 00:36:31,794 --> 00:36:33,379
- What happened
- to routine stuff?
- 495
- 00:36:33,462 --> 00:36:35,339
- - Ask Phil Donnelly.
- - God!
- 496
- 00:36:36,256 --> 00:36:37,508
- Of course,
- I remember you.
- 497
- 00:36:38,801 --> 00:36:41,095
- Yeah, last time I saw you,
- I think Phil Donnelly was
- 498
- 00:36:41,178 --> 00:36:43,472
- trying to get you to go
- out on the links with us.
- 499
- 00:36:43,555 --> 00:36:44,598
- Yeah.
- 500
- 00:36:47,476 --> 00:36:48,519
- You what?
- 501
- 00:37:02,408 --> 00:37:03,701
- - Sir.
- - Thank you.
- 502
- 00:37:09,998 --> 00:37:10,999
- Good morning.
- 503
- 00:37:14,545 --> 00:37:15,921
- - Good morning, Larry.
- - Morning.
- 504
- 00:37:22,761 --> 00:37:23,762
- Morning, Miss Claire.
- 505
- 00:37:25,055 --> 00:37:26,724
- Don't you look nice.
- 506
- 00:37:26,807 --> 00:37:28,225
- Save it for the
- judge, Mr. Winter.
- 507
- 00:37:32,479 --> 00:37:34,982
- You're suing DuPont.
- 508
- 00:37:37,025 --> 00:37:38,068
- Yes, ma'am.
- 509
- 00:37:38,694 --> 00:37:40,446
- You represent DuPont.
- 510
- 00:37:40,529 --> 00:37:41,530
- My old firm did.
- 511
- 00:37:42,531 --> 00:37:43,866
- I've been out on
- my own for a while.
- 512
- 00:37:45,659 --> 00:37:46,910
- Good luck with that.
- 513
- 00:37:51,457 --> 00:37:53,834
- Just wanted to
- let you know personally
- 514
- 00:37:53,917 --> 00:37:57,254
- that your court-ordered
- discovery is on the way.
- 515
- 00:37:57,337 --> 00:37:58,922
- Thanks, Phil.
- 516
- 00:37:59,006 --> 00:38:01,091
- No, it's my pleasure.
- 517
- 00:38:03,427 --> 00:38:04,511
- Discovery.
- 518
- 00:38:20,402 --> 00:38:21,987
- Son of a bitch.
- 519
- 00:38:22,070 --> 00:38:24,406
- No admission
- of liability.
- 520
- 00:38:25,282 --> 00:38:26,950
- And non...
- 521
- 00:38:29,369 --> 00:38:31,830
- Non-disclosure of
- any and all terms.
- 522
- 00:38:33,624 --> 00:38:34,750
- Pardon me a moment.
- 523
- 00:38:50,015 --> 00:38:51,225
- Thanks.
- 524
- 00:38:52,059 --> 00:38:53,936
- Holy Jesus!
- 525
- 00:38:54,978 --> 00:38:56,313
- - What in the...
- - Thanks.
- 526
- 00:38:58,148 --> 00:38:59,358
- ...world?
- 527
- 00:38:59,441 --> 00:39:01,527
- I guess the
- joke's on me.
- 528
- 00:39:01,610 --> 00:39:02,611
- Yeah.
- 529
- 00:39:04,071 --> 00:39:05,864
- No one can go through all this crap.
- Not in a million years.
- 530
- 00:39:05,948 --> 00:39:07,950
- Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's
- what they're banking on.
- 531
- 00:39:10,619 --> 00:39:12,746
- - Oh, God! Damn it!
- - Oh, God, Rob!
- 532
- 00:39:18,126 --> 00:39:21,213
- - Here, let me...
- - No, no, no, you shouldn't be around this stuff.
- 533
- 00:39:22,548 --> 00:39:25,467
- - You sure?
- - I'm positive. Thank you, though.
- 534
- 00:39:26,218 --> 00:39:27,261
- Yeah.
- 535
- 00:39:28,762 --> 00:39:29,805
- Good luck.
- 536
- 00:39:51,326 --> 00:39:52,786
- 1957.
- 537
- 00:40:57,351 --> 00:40:59,353
- Hey, Sally,
- what is the hold up back here?
- 538
- 00:41:02,147 --> 00:41:03,565
- - Hey, Bobby. How you...
- - What're you having?
- 539
- 00:41:06,026 --> 00:41:07,027
- Usual.
- 540
- 00:41:08,820 --> 00:41:10,530
- Eggs over bacon
- and grits.
- 541
- 00:41:12,157 --> 00:41:13,200
- Same.
- 542
- 00:41:18,163 --> 00:41:20,123
- I need two over,
- grits, fried.
- 543
- 00:41:29,800 --> 00:41:30,926
- Wilbur Tennant.
- 544
- 00:41:31,343 --> 00:41:33,428
- He's not in his office.
- Can I take a message?
- 545
- 00:41:33,512 --> 00:41:36,014
- - I been leaving messages.
- - I know, Mr. Tennant,
- 546
- 00:41:36,098 --> 00:41:38,183
- but he really can't get
- to the phone right now.
- 547
- 00:41:38,266 --> 00:41:39,559
- I want service!
- 548
- 00:41:40,060 --> 00:41:41,436
- I'll let him know that you called again.
- For Christ's sakes.
- 549
- 00:41:44,856 --> 00:41:47,317
- Is she getting accustomed
- to being at Mom and Dad's?
- 550
- 00:41:47,401 --> 00:41:49,152
- You know Grammer.
- She misses her own house.
- 551
- 00:41:49,236 --> 00:41:51,655
- - What?
- - She misses her own house.
- 552
- 00:41:52,489 --> 00:41:54,032
- I have a bad cell.
- 553
- 00:41:54,116 --> 00:41:56,368
- I said Grammer
- misses her own house.
- 554
- 00:41:56,451 --> 00:41:57,911
- Okay, can you...
- 555
- 00:41:58,328 --> 00:41:59,621
- Can I talk to her?
- 556
- 00:41:59,705 --> 00:42:00,956
- She and Mom
- are at the doctor's.
- 557
- 00:42:01,665 --> 00:42:04,334
- - Will you tell Grammers I called?
- - Rob, you're breaking up.
- 558
- 00:42:04,418 --> 00:42:05,502
- And Mom too?
- 559
- 00:42:05,585 --> 00:42:07,129
- - Let's try again on Sunday.
- - All right.
- 560
- 00:42:15,929 --> 00:42:17,180
- "C-8."
- 561
- 00:42:23,437 --> 00:42:25,772
- You know you look like
- a crazy person, right?
- 562
- 00:42:25,856 --> 00:42:28,233
- What was the name of that guy
- that you brought by the...
- 563
- 00:42:28,650 --> 00:42:31,987
- - What guy?
- - The chemistry expert.
- 564
- 00:42:32,070 --> 00:42:33,864
- - The guy who does the models.
- - Gillespie.
- 565
- 00:42:37,034 --> 00:42:38,035
- Here you go.
- 566
- 00:42:39,036 --> 00:42:40,037
- Thank you.
- 567
- 00:42:40,454 --> 00:42:42,205
- Kim Burke
- had an expense account.
- 568
- 00:42:42,831 --> 00:42:45,125
- Oh, sorry. It's not
- that kind of case.
- 569
- 00:42:45,876 --> 00:42:50,005
- Are you familiar
- with something called PFOA?
- 570
- 00:42:51,715 --> 00:42:52,758
- No.
- 571
- 00:42:55,427 --> 00:42:56,762
- - No.
- - No.
- 572
- 00:42:57,429 --> 00:43:01,975
- I did read something recently
- about a PFOS, I think it was.
- 573
- 00:43:02,100 --> 00:43:05,062
- - That sounds related.
- - And what was that?
- 574
- 00:43:05,687 --> 00:43:08,648
- Long-chain fluorocarbon,
- synthetic.
- 575
- 00:43:09,775 --> 00:43:13,070
- I'm sorry. Chemistry was
- my worst class in high school.
- 576
- 00:43:13,987 --> 00:43:15,489
- Boy, you in the wrong
- line of work.
- 577
- 00:43:15,572 --> 00:43:17,949
- Tell me about it. So?
- 578
- 00:43:18,366 --> 00:43:20,827
- So, synthetic. All right?
- Man-made.
- 579
- 00:43:21,912 --> 00:43:23,038
- Frankenstein.
- 580
- 00:43:23,830 --> 00:43:24,915
- And?
- 581
- 00:43:25,624 --> 00:43:29,711
- Long-chain fluorocarbon is a sequence
- of carbon atoms, add a fluoride.
- 582
- 00:43:30,962 --> 00:43:34,758
- - All right. In the lab you take a carbon atom...
- - Mmm-hmm.
- 583
- 00:43:34,841 --> 00:43:38,011
- ...and then you add
- another carbon atom.
- 584
- 00:43:38,553 --> 00:43:39,554
- And then another
- 585
- 00:43:40,388 --> 00:43:42,015
- and another... Look.
- 586
- 00:43:43,600 --> 00:43:46,353
- You're making a chain. Right?
- 587
- 00:43:49,231 --> 00:43:51,233
- - Right?
- - Could it be...
- 588
- 00:43:52,150 --> 00:43:54,111
- Eight? Eight carbons?
- 589
- 00:43:54,194 --> 00:43:56,738
- Well, sure. Yeah, In the lab
- you can do almost anything.
- 590
- 00:43:57,447 --> 00:44:00,659
- And why would you want to?
- Make this, I mean.
- 591
- 00:44:02,702 --> 00:44:06,373
- Well, a chain like that's pretty much
- unbreakable, biochemically speaking.
- 592
- 00:44:06,456 --> 00:44:09,376
- So, uh, industrial uses,
- I imagine.
- 593
- 00:44:10,210 --> 00:44:11,628
- 3M made it.
- 594
- 00:44:12,129 --> 00:44:14,214
- They don't anymore.
- That's what I read.
- 595
- 00:44:14,756 --> 00:44:17,300
- - Why did they stop?
- - Didn't say.
- 596
- 00:44:19,761 --> 00:44:20,762
- What if...
- 597
- 00:44:22,430 --> 00:44:23,932
- What if you drank it?
- 598
- 00:44:26,560 --> 00:44:27,561
- Drank it?
- 599
- 00:44:28,562 --> 00:44:30,230
- - You don't.
- - Well, what if you did?
- 600
- 00:44:30,772 --> 00:44:32,899
- - Ready to order?
- - Yeah, I think I'd like a...
- 601
- 00:44:34,025 --> 00:44:35,193
- But what if you did?
- 602
- 00:44:36,528 --> 00:44:39,072
- That's like saying,
- "What if I swallowed a tire?"
- 603
- 00:44:40,699 --> 00:44:43,118
- I don't know. You wanna be
- the guy that finds out?
- 604
- 00:44:44,786 --> 00:44:45,787
- Tuna melt.
- 605
- 00:45:05,140 --> 00:45:10,187
- Let us all begin with
- hymn number 452 in our hymnal books.
- 606
- 00:45:10,270 --> 00:45:13,231
- "Here I Am, Lord."
- Please rise.
- 607
- 00:45:16,484 --> 00:45:21,031
- I, the Lord of sea and sky
- 608
- 00:45:21,114 --> 00:45:25,535
- I have heard my people cry
- 609
- 00:45:26,036 --> 00:45:30,248
- All who dwell in deepest sin
- 610
- 00:45:30,874 --> 00:45:34,211
- My hand will save
- 611
- 00:45:36,463 --> 00:45:37,756
- Does it makes sounds?
- 612
- 00:45:38,757 --> 00:45:40,175
- Asteroid ahead.
- 613
- 00:45:40,550 --> 00:45:43,303
- You hold like that.
- 614
- 00:45:43,386 --> 00:45:45,555
- Are you ready to blast off?
- 615
- 00:45:58,860 --> 00:46:00,737
- I'm taking off that.
- 616
- 00:46:31,601 --> 00:46:32,978
- You said it had fluoride?
- 617
- 00:46:33,770 --> 00:46:35,397
- What?
- Mr. Bilott, it's Sunday.
- 618
- 00:46:35,480 --> 00:46:38,191
- That chemical, you said
- it had a fluoride atom.
- 619
- 00:46:39,734 --> 00:46:42,737
- It's a fluorocarbon, so, yes.
- Somewhere along the chain...
- 620
- 00:46:42,821 --> 00:46:45,198
- What would it do to your
- teeth if you drank it?
- 621
- 00:46:45,282 --> 00:46:47,367
- Don't tell me if you
- shouldn't, if you did.
- 622
- 00:46:47,450 --> 00:46:49,619
- If you drank a lot of it,
- what would it do to your teeth?
- 623
- 00:46:50,203 --> 00:46:52,497
- Well, in trace amounts
- fluoride hardens teeth.
- 624
- 00:46:52,580 --> 00:46:57,294
- But too much, it's gonna stain 'em.
- I mean, even turn 'em black.
- 625
- 00:46:58,795 --> 00:47:00,672
- So, can I get back
- to my family now?
- 626
- 00:47:05,302 --> 00:47:06,553
- What? Where are you going?
- 627
- 00:47:06,970 --> 00:47:09,514
- - It's in their water.
- - What? What is?
- 628
- 00:47:47,177 --> 00:47:48,470
- How long's
- the coughing been?
- 629
- 00:47:50,096 --> 00:47:52,682
- Couple...
- Couple of months.
- 630
- 00:47:53,224 --> 00:47:54,225
- A year.
- 631
- 00:47:54,684 --> 00:47:58,313
- - You a smoker?
- - No.
- 632
- 00:47:59,064 --> 00:48:00,565
- Roll up your sleeve.
- We're gonna take some blood.
- 633
- 00:48:15,580 --> 00:48:18,458
- - Thought you left him inside.
- - I did.
- 634
- 00:48:23,129 --> 00:48:24,381
- Oh, baby.
- 635
- 00:48:34,182 --> 00:48:35,183
- You move this?
- 636
- 00:48:36,142 --> 00:48:37,143
- What?
- 637
- 00:48:37,227 --> 00:48:39,562
- - Did you go through this?
- - No!
- 638
- 00:48:44,692 --> 00:48:45,693
- They been here.
- 639
- 00:48:47,529 --> 00:48:48,571
- They been here!
- 640
- 00:49:17,434 --> 00:49:18,560
- What happened?
- 641
- 00:49:20,395 --> 00:49:21,396
- Wash up.
- 642
- 00:49:30,697 --> 00:49:31,739
- Dad?
- 643
- 00:49:34,492 --> 00:49:35,535
- - What is it?
- - Quiet.
- 644
- 00:49:45,837 --> 00:49:49,132
- This is my land,
- damn you! You get out of here!
- 645
- 00:49:49,883 --> 00:49:50,925
- Go on!
- 646
- 00:49:52,385 --> 00:49:53,511
- Go on!
- 647
- 00:49:55,221 --> 00:49:59,058
- Sandra, girls, get on!
- Go on, get in! Get in!
- 648
- 00:50:01,144 --> 00:50:02,479
- I know youl!
- 649
- 00:52:14,819 --> 00:52:15,862
- Rob?
- 650
- 00:52:41,638 --> 00:52:45,058
- - Holy crap, Rob!
- - What?
- 651
- 00:52:45,141 --> 00:52:47,935
- I thought someone was breaking
- in, for God's sakes!
- 652
- 00:52:48,019 --> 00:52:49,479
- No, it's just me.
- 653
- 00:52:49,562 --> 00:52:51,397
- Rob, you need to tell me
- what in the hell's going on.
- 654
- 00:52:54,776 --> 00:52:56,110
- We're being poisoned.
- 655
- 00:52:58,988 --> 00:53:00,406
- - Rob.
- - What?
- 656
- 00:53:00,490 --> 00:53:04,160
- I mean it.
- DuPont is knowingly poisoning us.
- 657
- 00:53:04,243 --> 00:53:06,537
- You mean the farmer.
- His land.
- 658
- 00:53:07,372 --> 00:53:08,456
- All of us.
- 659
- 00:53:10,708 --> 00:53:12,126
- Please don't look at me
- like that.
- 660
- 00:53:13,670 --> 00:53:15,421
- They're already poisoning
- the baby.
- 661
- 00:53:17,256 --> 00:53:19,759
- - No. I'm not listening to this.
- - Sarah.
- 662
- 00:53:20,134 --> 00:53:21,761
- Stop it!
- Just stop it, okay?
- 663
- 00:53:22,679 --> 00:53:25,431
- Do you hear yourself?
- You are acting like a crazy person.
- 664
- 00:53:25,515 --> 00:53:28,518
- Tearing up our floor.
- Scaring me half to death.
- 665
- 00:53:28,601 --> 00:53:31,229
- I know it's my job to support
- you, but that does not mean
- 666
- 00:53:31,312 --> 00:53:33,731
- you get to come into our
- home, to our family
- 667
- 00:53:33,815 --> 00:53:36,734
- and tell me that our unborn
- child is being poisoned. No!
- 668
- 00:53:36,818 --> 00:53:39,278
- I'm sorry.
- Can I please explain?
- 669
- 00:53:39,362 --> 00:53:41,114
- - Explain what?
- - All of it.
- 670
- 00:53:41,906 --> 00:53:45,993
- And if you still think I'm crazy,
- I'll drop it. I swear to God.
- 671
- 00:53:48,663 --> 00:53:49,872
- I swear to you.
- 672
- 00:54:06,389 --> 00:54:08,349
- There is a man-made
- chemical
- 673
- 00:54:10,184 --> 00:54:12,603
- that was invented
- during the Manhattan project.
- 674
- 00:54:13,646 --> 00:54:16,149
- It repelled the elements,
- especially water.
- 675
- 00:54:16,774 --> 00:54:21,112
- So they used it to make the first
- ever waterproof coating for tanks.
- 676
- 00:54:21,195 --> 00:54:22,572
- It was indestructible.
- 677
- 00:54:22,655 --> 00:54:26,743
- Then some companies thought,
- "Hey, why just the battlefield?
- 678
- 00:54:26,826 --> 00:54:30,705
- "Why not bring this chemical
- into American homes?"
- 679
- 00:54:30,913 --> 00:54:32,373
- - Rob's here.
- - All right. Good.
- 680
- 00:54:33,291 --> 00:54:34,292
- He'll see you now.
- 681
- 00:54:38,296 --> 00:54:40,089
- DuPont was one
- of those companies.
- 682
- 00:54:41,841 --> 00:54:44,385
- So they took
- this chemical, PFOA.
- 683
- 00:54:45,178 --> 00:54:46,846
- They renamed it C-8.
- 684
- 00:54:47,847 --> 00:54:50,516
- And they made their own
- impenetrable coating,
- 685
- 00:54:50,600 --> 00:54:53,227
- but not for tanks. For pans.
- 686
- 00:54:54,854 --> 00:54:56,606
- They called it Teflon.
- 687
- 00:54:57,190 --> 00:55:00,610
- A shining symbol
- of American ingenuity,
- 688
- 00:55:00,693 --> 00:55:02,904
- made right here in the USA,
- 689
- 00:55:02,987 --> 00:55:05,072
- in Parkersburg, West Virginia.
- 690
- 00:55:06,991 --> 00:55:09,202
- But right from the start,
- something wasn't right.
- 691
- 00:55:09,911 --> 00:55:13,080
- The men, and workers
- who made Teflon
- 692
- 00:55:13,164 --> 00:55:15,666
- were coming down
- with nausea, fevers.
- 693
- 00:55:15,750 --> 00:55:17,168
- DuPont wanted to know why.
- 694
- 00:55:17,835 --> 00:55:20,505
- So they laced cigarettes
- with Teflon.
- 695
- 00:55:20,588 --> 00:55:23,090
- They told a group of their
- workers, "Hey, smoke these."
- 696
- 00:55:23,883 --> 00:55:25,718
- DuPonters did
- as they were told.
- 697
- 00:55:27,261 --> 00:55:29,305
- Almost all of those men
- were hospitalized.
- 698
- 00:55:33,893 --> 00:55:35,436
- That's 1962.
- 699
- 00:55:35,978 --> 00:55:39,941
- One year after Teflon launched
- and already DuPont knew.
- 700
- 00:55:40,566 --> 00:55:44,237
- The dust, they just sent right up the
- smoke stacks, released into the air.
- 701
- 00:55:45,029 --> 00:55:47,615
- The sludge,
- tossed it into the Ohio.
- 702
- 00:55:47,698 --> 00:55:51,911
- Or, uh, packed into drums and
- chucked it into the Chesapeake.
- 703
- 00:55:52,703 --> 00:55:54,872
- But then their drums
- started washing up.
- 704
- 00:55:55,373 --> 00:55:57,792
- So, DuPont starts
- digging ditches
- 705
- 00:55:57,875 --> 00:55:59,836
- on the grounds
- of the Washington Works plant.
- 706
- 00:55:59,919 --> 00:56:02,171
- And in those pits,
- they dumped
- 707
- 00:56:02,255 --> 00:56:05,842
- thousands of tons
- of toxic C-8 sludge and dust.
- 708
- 00:56:06,300 --> 00:56:09,053
- One of the men that they hired
- to dig those ditches
- 709
- 00:56:09,136 --> 00:56:11,806
- was Wilbur Tennant's
- brother Jim.
- 710
- 00:56:12,682 --> 00:56:15,017
- But they weren't the only ones
- covering their tracks.
- 711
- 00:56:15,560 --> 00:56:19,313
- 3M who pioneered these
- chemicals for Scotchgard,
- 712
- 00:56:19,397 --> 00:56:20,773
- they were testing them
- on monkeys.
- 713
- 00:56:21,315 --> 00:56:22,733
- Most of the monkeys died.
- 714
- 00:56:23,359 --> 00:56:25,736
- It wasn't like DuPont
- didn't know that because
- 715
- 00:56:25,820 --> 00:56:28,155
- they were doing
- their own tests on rats.
- 716
- 00:56:29,031 --> 00:56:30,658
- Watched their organs balloon.
- 717
- 00:56:31,909 --> 00:56:33,744
- Now the rats
- are getting cancers.
- 718
- 00:56:34,370 --> 00:56:37,957
- Tested them on pregnant rats
- and watched them give birth
- 719
- 00:56:38,040 --> 00:56:40,334
- to pups
- with deformed eyes.
- 720
- 00:56:41,043 --> 00:56:44,255
- So, they yanked all the young
- women off the Teflon line
- 721
- 00:56:44,755 --> 00:56:46,007
- and never told them why.
- 722
- 00:56:50,344 --> 00:56:55,016
- Sue Bailey's job was scrubbing
- these huge steel vats
- 723
- 00:56:55,099 --> 00:56:58,144
- where they held the liquid C-8.
- She was pregnant.
- 724
- 00:56:58,603 --> 00:57:00,688
- - I love you!
- - Would you stop?
- 725
- 00:57:02,815 --> 00:57:07,194
- She gave birth to a baby with
- one nostril and a deformed eye.
- 726
- 00:57:07,278 --> 00:57:10,823
- Remember how DuPont had seen
- those deformities in the rats?
- 727
- 00:57:14,035 --> 00:57:15,578
- Oh, God.
- What about his eyes?
- 728
- 00:57:16,120 --> 00:57:18,205
- Blue. Just like all newborns.
- 729
- 00:57:18,289 --> 00:57:20,666
- But they're normal,
- the lids, the pupils?
- 730
- 00:57:20,750 --> 00:57:24,211
- Mr. Bilott, relax.
- He's perfect.
- 731
- 00:57:25,004 --> 00:57:27,173
- Hey. Hi, Charlie.
- 732
- 00:57:27,256 --> 00:57:29,842
- So Sue goes to DuPont.
- 733
- 00:57:29,926 --> 00:57:32,678
- She says, "Why did you pull me
- off the Teflon line?
- 734
- 00:57:33,471 --> 00:57:38,100
- "Did C-8 make my baby this
- way?" "No," they tell her.
- 735
- 00:57:38,184 --> 00:57:42,521
- Then all of her records from
- her time at Teflon disappear.
- 736
- 00:57:42,605 --> 00:57:47,318
- One year later,
- they put all of the women back on Teflon
- 737
- 00:57:47,401 --> 00:57:50,154
- and never say a thing.
- 738
- 00:57:56,786 --> 00:57:57,787
- He's here.
- 739
- 00:58:02,041 --> 00:58:03,751
- DuPont knew everything.
- 740
- 00:58:04,752 --> 00:58:08,214
- They knew that the C-8
- they put into the air
- 741
- 00:58:08,297 --> 00:58:10,299
- and buried into the
- ground for decades
- 742
- 00:58:10,383 --> 00:58:12,051
- was causing cancers.
- 743
- 00:58:12,134 --> 00:58:15,888
- They knew that their own workers
- were getting these cancers.
- 744
- 00:58:15,972 --> 00:58:19,016
- They knew that the consumers
- too were being exposed
- 745
- 00:58:19,100 --> 00:58:22,436
- and not just in Teflon.
- In paints,
- 746
- 00:58:22,895 --> 00:58:27,191
- in fabrics, in,
- uh, raincoats, boots.
- 747
- 00:58:28,818 --> 00:58:30,277
- To this day...
- 748
- 00:58:32,321 --> 00:58:36,450
- For 40 years you knew
- C-8 was poison.
- 749
- 00:58:36,534 --> 00:58:39,954
- You knew the "Happy Pan"
- was a ticking time bomb.
- 750
- 00:58:40,538 --> 00:58:43,082
- And you knew exactly why.
- 751
- 00:58:43,249 --> 00:58:45,501
- Because C-8,
- it stays in us forever.
- 752
- 00:58:45,668 --> 00:58:48,295
- Our bodies are incapable
- of breaking it down.
- 753
- 00:58:48,921 --> 00:58:53,175
- And knowing all of this,
- still you did nothing because
- 754
- 00:58:53,759 --> 00:58:56,012
- doing something,
- 755
- 00:58:56,887 --> 00:58:59,849
- "would essentially
- put the long-term viability
- 756
- 00:58:59,932 --> 00:59:03,936
- "of this product's segment
- on the line."
- 757
- 00:59:06,689 --> 00:59:08,983
- You were making
- too much money.
- 758
- 00:59:09,900 --> 00:59:13,112
- One billion dollars a year just in
- profits, just in Teflon.
- 759
- 00:59:14,405 --> 00:59:17,950
- And so you pumped
- millions more pounds
- 760
- 00:59:18,034 --> 00:59:21,203
- of toxic C-8 into the air,
- into the water
- 761
- 00:59:21,454 --> 00:59:24,457
- so much so you could
- actually see it foam.
- 762
- 00:59:25,291 --> 00:59:30,755
- C-8 was everywhere. There was
- nowhere left for you to contaminate.
- 763
- 00:59:34,884 --> 00:59:37,053
- And that's when
- they came to Jim.
- 764
- 00:59:37,720 --> 00:59:41,348
- They knew he was sick and needed
- the money and they needed his land.
- 765
- 00:59:42,058 --> 00:59:45,186
- And when they got it,
- they dug up all the C-8
- 766
- 00:59:45,352 --> 00:59:48,147
- from every single pit
- at Washington Works.
- 767
- 00:59:48,230 --> 00:59:51,567
- Fourteen million pounds
- of toxic C-8 sludge
- 768
- 00:59:51,776 --> 00:59:54,987
- and they dumped it, again.
- This time right up there.
- 769
- 00:59:55,154 --> 00:59:58,157
- Steps from your creek,
- from your house.
- 770
- 00:59:58,991 --> 01:00:02,119
- That's what your cows
- have been drinking, Earl.
- 771
- 01:00:06,499 --> 01:00:08,709
- Put 'em behind bars.
- 772
- 01:00:08,793 --> 01:00:10,503
- Whole damn lot of 'em,
- right in jail.
- 773
- 01:00:10,669 --> 01:00:12,004
- I understand, believe me.
- 774
- 01:00:12,088 --> 01:00:15,091
- But this is a civil case.
- The most we can hope for is damages.
- 775
- 01:00:15,216 --> 01:00:19,220
- Don't want no money!
- Whole damn world need...
- 776
- 01:00:25,559 --> 01:00:28,562
- - Needs to see what they done.
- - You're right. They should.
- 777
- 01:00:30,147 --> 01:00:32,733
- And it kills me
- that they won't.
- 778
- 01:00:33,776 --> 01:00:36,362
- But that would mean
- going to trial
- 779
- 01:00:36,529 --> 01:00:38,948
- and proving
- that C-8 killed your cows.
- 780
- 01:00:39,115 --> 01:00:41,659
- And every scientist who knows
- anything about any of this
- 781
- 01:00:41,826 --> 01:00:43,828
- already works
- for these chemical companies.
- 782
- 01:00:43,953 --> 01:00:46,372
- That's not an accident, Earl.
- 783
- 01:00:46,956 --> 01:00:52,128
- Earl, these companies,
- they have all the money all the time,
- 784
- 01:00:52,211 --> 01:00:53,671
- and they'll use it. Trust me.
- 785
- 01:00:53,796 --> 01:00:55,548
- I know. I was one of them.
- 786
- 01:00:57,007 --> 01:00:59,426
- You're still one of 'em.
- 787
- 01:01:02,555 --> 01:01:06,809
- You can't be serious.
- You know what I put on the line here?
- 788
- 01:01:06,976 --> 01:01:10,146
- You want a prize? Some medal
- 'cause for once in your life
- 789
- 01:01:10,229 --> 01:01:12,648
- you took the side
- of the little guy?
- 790
- 01:01:13,065 --> 01:01:16,318
- Sorry, no prize. All you get is
- your share of this blood money.
- 791
- 01:01:16,610 --> 01:01:19,446
- - And you sleep real good tonight.
- - Talk to your family.
- 792
- 01:01:19,905 --> 01:01:22,158
- It ain't just my cows
- was poisoned.
- 793
- 01:01:22,241 --> 01:01:24,410
- What do you think
- I fed my family on?
- 794
- 01:01:24,618 --> 01:01:27,746
- Wilbur, please.
- 795
- 01:01:29,331 --> 01:01:31,500
- Leave this place!
- 796
- 01:01:32,835 --> 01:01:36,589
- Start over. Give your family
- a fighting chance!
- 797
- 01:01:36,755 --> 01:01:38,757
- Too late for that.
- 798
- 01:01:41,677 --> 01:01:44,013
- We got it, Sandra and me.
- The cancer.
- 799
- 01:01:45,723 --> 01:01:47,725
- Surprise, surprise.
- 800
- 01:02:43,739 --> 01:02:45,491
- In here.
- 801
- 01:02:51,538 --> 01:02:53,332
- How'd it go?
- 802
- 01:02:55,501 --> 01:02:56,752
- What's wrong?
- 803
- 01:02:57,586 --> 01:02:59,046
- Rob?
- 804
- 01:02:59,880 --> 01:03:00,881
- Rob, what is it?
- 805
- 01:03:06,845 --> 01:03:08,555
- What happened?
- What happened?
- 806
- 01:03:09,181 --> 01:03:11,183
- Oh, honey, honey, honey.
- 807
- 01:03:12,935 --> 01:03:15,354
- You saw a man hurting
- and
- 808
- 01:03:17,022 --> 01:03:19,441
- you did the Christian thing.
- You helped him.
- 809
- 01:03:19,942 --> 01:03:24,363
- How? How?
- Either he dies penniless
- 810
- 01:03:24,530 --> 01:03:27,491
- or he lets DuPont just keep
- pillaging his community.
- 811
- 01:03:27,574 --> 01:03:28,993
- How is that helping?
- 812
- 01:03:33,330 --> 01:03:35,332
- Gotta get some sleep.
- 813
- 01:03:47,052 --> 01:03:50,014
- I can't believe a freaking case
- settlement could shut this up.
- 814
- 01:03:52,599 --> 01:03:55,352
- Have you read their
- confidentiality agreements?
- 815
- 01:03:56,228 --> 01:03:58,856
- You've uncovered
- a threat to the public.
- 816
- 01:03:59,440 --> 01:04:01,692
- This goes beyond lawyering.
- 817
- 01:04:01,775 --> 01:04:04,069
- That's...
- That's all I know is lawyering.
- 818
- 01:04:04,153 --> 01:04:06,405
- Fine.
- Then be the lawyer.
- 819
- 01:04:06,947 --> 01:04:08,449
- You know DuPont
- better than anyone.
- 820
- 01:04:08,615 --> 01:04:09,867
- What haven't they thought of?
- 821
- 01:05:09,802 --> 01:05:11,762
- God. Jesus,
- Mary and Joseph.
- 822
- 01:05:12,262 --> 01:05:13,263
- What is that?
- 823
- 01:05:13,347 --> 01:05:16,183
- Uh, a memo
- and 136 exhibits.
- 824
- 01:05:49,091 --> 01:05:51,009
- Wil, Sandra,
- this is your copy.
- 825
- 01:06:11,655 --> 01:06:15,325
- The EPA announced a public hearing
- into this family of chemicals
- 826
- 01:06:15,409 --> 01:06:17,911
- - I've been looking into.
- - I heard about it from Tucker.
- 827
- 01:06:18,162 --> 01:06:20,372
- - Monsanto Tucker?
- - Union Carbide now.
- 828
- 01:06:20,497 --> 01:06:21,498
- He says to me,
- "Is it true
- 829
- 01:06:21,582 --> 01:06:23,125
- "that a Taft lawyer sent a
- phone book's
- 830
- 01:06:23,208 --> 01:06:24,585
- "worth of confidential
- DuPont documents
- 831
- 01:06:24,668 --> 01:06:26,253
- "to the entire
- Federal government?"
- 832
- 01:06:26,336 --> 01:06:28,922
- Internal documents, not confidential.
- Very different.
- 833
- 01:06:29,006 --> 01:06:31,091
- - So you're testifying.
- - I signed up to testify.
- 834
- 01:06:31,175 --> 01:06:32,176
- And the next thing I hear
- 835
- 01:06:32,259 --> 01:06:34,261
- is DuPont has petitioned
- a judge
- 836
- 01:06:34,344 --> 01:06:37,014
- to stop me from testifying,
- from flying to D.C,
- 837
- 01:06:37,097 --> 01:06:38,098
- from even picking up
- the phone
- 838
- 01:06:38,182 --> 01:06:39,266
- They filed for a gag order.
- 839
- 01:06:39,349 --> 01:06:41,101
- Yes! This is what
- we're up against.
- 840
- 01:06:41,185 --> 01:06:42,436
- - Jesus.
- - David.
- 841
- 01:06:42,519 --> 01:06:43,520
- Come on, Tom.
- What do you expect?
- 842
- 01:06:43,604 --> 01:06:44,688
- Where do we stand?
- 843
- 01:06:44,771 --> 01:06:46,607
- Well, the judge rejected
- the gag order,
- 844
- 01:06:46,690 --> 01:06:48,192
- so I fly out Monday.
- 845
- 01:06:48,650 --> 01:06:52,154
- Nice. I guess we'll
- just watch on C-SPAN.
- 846
- 01:06:54,448 --> 01:06:55,949
- You ever do
- anything like this again,
- 847
- 01:06:56,033 --> 01:06:59,703
- I will cut your balls off and
- serve them to DuPont myself.
- 848
- 01:07:00,078 --> 01:07:01,497
- Get out of here.
- 849
- 01:07:04,500 --> 01:07:05,876
- Good luck in Washington.
- 850
- 01:07:07,127 --> 01:07:08,420
- Thanks, Tom.
- 851
- 01:07:08,921 --> 01:07:12,716
- This material
- is a perfluoro...
- 852
- 01:07:12,883 --> 01:07:14,718
- or a PFOA.
- 853
- 01:07:14,885 --> 01:07:18,347
- It's also known
- as FC 143,
- 854
- 01:07:19,306 --> 01:07:22,559
- ammonium perfluorooctanoates.
- 855
- 01:07:22,643 --> 01:07:27,397
- It has been shown
- by DuPont's own science
- 856
- 01:07:28,440 --> 01:07:30,567
- that PFOA C-8
- 857
- 01:07:31,568 --> 01:07:35,656
- is possibly life threatening
- to human health.
- 858
- 01:07:36,073 --> 01:07:41,620
- We are asking this agency
- to do something.
- 859
- 01:08:02,349 --> 01:08:04,601
- ...the Presidential election
- in four decades.
- 860
- 01:08:04,768 --> 01:08:06,520
- Just look at these
- latest polls.
- 861
- 01:08:07,020 --> 01:08:08,522
- Did you forget
- to pay the water bill?
- 862
- 01:08:09,565 --> 01:08:10,732
- What?
- 863
- 01:08:10,816 --> 01:08:12,901
- You forget to pay
- the water bill?
- 864
- 01:08:14,528 --> 01:08:15,862
- No.
- 865
- 01:08:16,697 --> 01:08:18,073
- We got a notice.
- 866
- 01:08:18,615 --> 01:08:19,825
- What's it say?
- 867
- 01:08:21,910 --> 01:08:24,830
- "PFOA is
- a persistent chemical
- 868
- 01:08:24,913 --> 01:08:26,456
- "that is slow
- to be eliminated
- 869
- 01:08:26,540 --> 01:08:29,918
- "from the blood stream of people
- who have been exposed to it.
- 870
- 01:08:30,419 --> 01:08:32,170
- "The DuPont company
- has advised
- 871
- 01:08:32,254 --> 01:08:35,507
- "the Lubeck Water District
- that low concentrations
- 872
- 01:08:35,591 --> 01:08:38,552
- "have been found
- in the district's wells.
- 873
- 01:08:38,635 --> 01:08:39,886
- "DuPont has advised
- the district
- 874
- 01:08:39,970 --> 01:08:43,015
- "that it is confident
- these levels are safe."
- 875
- 01:08:44,182 --> 01:08:46,018
- What the hell does that mean?
- 876
- 01:08:47,853 --> 01:08:49,771
- A letter came last fall.
- 877
- 01:08:50,355 --> 01:08:52,649
- Made no sense to me,
- so I started making calls.
- 878
- 01:08:52,733 --> 01:08:55,027
- I told Joe don't
- kick that hornet's nest.
- 879
- 01:08:55,652 --> 01:08:58,280
- It's not like we didn't know
- what we'd signed up for.
- 880
- 01:08:59,573 --> 01:09:00,699
- What do you mean?
- 881
- 01:09:01,450 --> 01:09:03,452
- Oh, I was married
- before Joe
- 882
- 01:09:04,161 --> 01:09:06,079
- to a chemist
- at DuPont.
- 883
- 01:09:06,622 --> 01:09:08,415
- Dream job.
- Paid real well.
- 884
- 01:09:08,498 --> 01:09:11,501
- And the perks!
- Presents for no reason.
- 885
- 01:09:11,585 --> 01:09:15,047
- We'd get this catalogue.
- Just pick whatever you want.
- 886
- 01:09:16,006 --> 01:09:17,299
- And little stuff.
- 887
- 01:09:17,382 --> 01:09:18,800
- Like he'd bring home
- this soap,
- 888
- 01:09:18,884 --> 01:09:20,469
- this miracle powder.
- 889
- 01:09:20,552 --> 01:09:22,596
- You puttin the washing
- machine or the dishwasher,
- 890
- 01:09:22,679 --> 01:09:24,598
- just wipes stuff clean
- like you would not believe.
- 891
- 01:09:25,641 --> 01:09:28,101
- One day he comes home
- and says,
- 892
- 01:09:28,185 --> 01:09:29,936
- "Can't bring that stuff
- home no more."
- 893
- 01:09:30,020 --> 01:09:31,772
- "Why?" Won't tell me.
- 894
- 01:09:32,105 --> 01:09:34,316
- Then he'd get sick
- for weeks.
- 895
- 01:09:35,108 --> 01:09:37,194
- The Teflon flu,
- the guys would call it.
- 896
- 01:09:37,944 --> 01:09:40,072
- We knew
- something wasn't right.
- 897
- 01:09:40,572 --> 01:09:43,408
- But this house,
- we bought it just by
- 898
- 01:09:43,492 --> 01:09:46,578
- showing the bank
- my husband's DuPont ID.
- 899
- 01:09:46,662 --> 01:09:49,956
- Put both our kids
- through college. Engineers.
- 900
- 01:09:51,583 --> 01:09:54,294
- In this town,
- that doesn't come without a price.
- 901
- 01:09:54,628 --> 01:09:57,339
- My brother Kenny
- didn't know that price.
- 902
- 01:09:57,506 --> 01:09:59,549
- He joined DuPont at 19.
- 903
- 01:09:59,633 --> 01:10:01,968
- Died on the operating table
- two years later.
- 904
- 01:10:02,427 --> 01:10:05,514
- - Ulcerative colitis.
- - Just like Dan Schiller had.
- 905
- 01:10:05,597 --> 01:10:06,890
- Who's Dan?
- 906
- 01:10:07,057 --> 01:10:09,685
- A chemist at DuPont.
- Worked with my ex-husband.
- 907
- 01:10:10,143 --> 01:10:12,896
- And Roger,
- what's his name?
- 908
- 01:10:12,979 --> 01:10:14,481
- Wilkins,
- the foreman.
- 909
- 01:10:14,606 --> 01:10:16,858
- Steven Gellar.
- Randy Field.
- 910
- 01:10:16,942 --> 01:10:19,569
- Randy's was kidney cancer.
- He survived.
- 911
- 01:10:19,653 --> 01:10:22,197
- - His wife didn't.
- - No, June's was thyroid.
- 912
- 01:10:22,280 --> 01:10:23,865
- It was supposed
- to be treatable.
- 913
- 01:10:24,241 --> 01:10:25,575
- They didn't catch it
- in time.
- 914
- 01:10:25,659 --> 01:10:27,911
- But they caught it
- in their son.
- 915
- 01:10:29,955 --> 01:10:32,040
- Were your children
- born healthy?
- 916
- 01:10:32,124 --> 01:10:34,167
- - Yes. Yes, they were.
- - Good.
- 917
- 01:10:34,334 --> 01:10:38,255
- But we wanted
- a third and couldn't.
- 918
- 01:10:38,338 --> 01:10:39,548
- I went to my doctor.
- 919
- 01:10:39,631 --> 01:10:42,342
- He says, "You need a hysterectomy.
- You need it right away."
- 920
- 01:10:44,219 --> 01:10:45,387
- I'm so sorry.
- 921
- 01:10:45,470 --> 01:10:47,055
- Bad luck, I guess.
- 922
- 01:10:48,765 --> 01:10:50,142
- I was 36.
- 923
- 01:10:51,560 --> 01:10:52,769
- Mr. Kiger,
- 924
- 01:10:52,853 --> 01:10:55,063
- you think I could get
- a copy of that letter?
- 925
- 01:11:07,576 --> 01:11:09,536
- What's wrong
- with your hand?
- 926
- 01:11:09,911 --> 01:11:12,080
- Nothing. It's fine.
- 927
- 01:11:17,085 --> 01:11:18,962
- Whoa, Rob?
- 928
- 01:11:21,089 --> 01:11:22,799
- Rob, what are you doing?
- 929
- 01:11:24,760 --> 01:11:27,012
- I mean, it's not enough
- to poison these people?
- 930
- 01:11:27,095 --> 01:11:28,513
- They gotta swindle them too?
- 931
- 01:11:28,597 --> 01:11:30,140
- Okay, calm down. All right?
- 932
- 01:11:30,223 --> 01:11:31,933
- DuPont wrote that letter!
- 933
- 01:11:32,017 --> 01:11:33,977
- - Not the water authority.
- - How do you know that?
- 934
- 01:11:34,060 --> 01:11:36,688
- You think I don't know what a
- DuPont letter looks like by now?
- 935
- 01:11:36,772 --> 01:11:38,106
- Okay. Okay.
- 936
- 01:11:38,565 --> 01:11:39,733
- I mean, Jesus!
- 937
- 01:11:39,816 --> 01:11:41,526
- It's evil, Sarah.
- 938
- 01:11:41,610 --> 01:11:43,570
- It's fucking evil!
- 939
- 01:11:43,653 --> 01:11:45,822
- What's fack?
- 940
- 01:11:46,740 --> 01:11:47,866
- Perfect.
- 941
- 01:11:47,949 --> 01:11:49,701
- It's nothing, sweetie.
- It's nothing. Oh, boy.
- 942
- 01:11:49,785 --> 01:11:51,453
- I'm sorry.
- I'm sorry, honey.
- 943
- 01:11:51,536 --> 01:11:52,913
- Can you give
- Charlie the bottle, please?
- 944
- 01:11:52,996 --> 01:11:55,540
- - Where's his bottle?
- - It's in the bag.
- 945
- 01:11:55,624 --> 01:11:57,876
- - What is all this?
- - It's from Grammer's.
- 946
- 01:11:58,251 --> 01:12:00,337
- It was left
- in her mailbox.
- 947
- 01:12:00,837 --> 01:12:02,881
- - "Medical claims, now and forever"?
- - Here, bud.
- 948
- 01:12:02,964 --> 01:12:04,424
- - "Now and forever."
- - Is that that...
- 949
- 01:12:04,549 --> 01:12:05,592
- That...
- 950
- 01:12:06,343 --> 01:12:08,345
- Medical monitoring.
- Is that...
- 951
- 01:12:10,013 --> 01:12:12,432
- I thought you said
- that wasn't gonna pass?
- 952
- 01:12:14,684 --> 01:12:17,562
- - Morning.
- - Guys.
- 953
- 01:12:23,985 --> 01:12:26,905
- Our lead plaintiff
- is Mr. Joe Kiger.
- 954
- 01:12:26,988 --> 01:12:30,575
- Potential plaintiff,
- if the partnership approves.
- 955
- 01:12:30,659 --> 01:12:32,994
- Mr. Joe Kiger,
- a Phys Ed teacher
- 956
- 01:12:33,078 --> 01:12:35,205
- from Parkersburg,
- West Virginia.
- 957
- 01:12:35,288 --> 01:12:39,793
- On behalf of
- the 70,000 local residents,
- 958
- 01:12:39,876 --> 01:12:42,754
- whose water
- DuPont knowingly poisoned
- 959
- 01:12:42,838 --> 01:12:44,172
- for the last 40 years.
- 960
- 01:12:44,256 --> 01:12:45,257
- A class action?
- 961
- 01:12:45,340 --> 01:12:46,508
- Let him finish.
- 962
- 01:12:46,591 --> 01:12:48,343
- The Kigers were notified
- 963
- 01:12:48,426 --> 01:12:51,763
- by their local water company
- that DuPont had found
- 964
- 01:12:51,847 --> 01:12:55,642
- small concentrations of C-8
- in their water supply,
- 965
- 01:12:55,725 --> 01:12:57,185
- but not to worry
- 966
- 01:12:57,269 --> 01:13:00,647
- because those concentrations
- were safe.
- 967
- 01:13:00,730 --> 01:13:03,650
- Why?
- Because DuPont said so.
- 968
- 01:13:07,988 --> 01:13:10,282
- This is what DuPont
- considers safe.
- 969
- 01:13:10,657 --> 01:13:13,159
- That's something like
- one drop of water
- 970
- 01:13:13,243 --> 01:13:15,328
- in an Olympic size
- swimming pool.
- 971
- 01:13:15,412 --> 01:13:17,914
- In other words,
- even a trace of C-8
- 972
- 01:13:17,998 --> 01:13:19,916
- renders water unsafe.
- 973
- 01:13:20,000 --> 01:13:22,335
- But DuPont told
- the local water authority,
- 974
- 01:13:22,419 --> 01:13:23,461
- "Don't worry.
- 975
- 01:13:23,545 --> 01:13:25,547
- "Your wells have got even
- less than that."
- 976
- 01:13:25,630 --> 01:13:27,716
- - Except that was a lie.
- - A lie?
- 977
- 01:13:27,799 --> 01:13:30,427
- Yes. DuPont has been
- secretly testing
- 978
- 01:13:30,510 --> 01:13:31,845
- these wells for decades.
- 979
- 01:13:31,928 --> 01:13:34,890
- They knew they had
- contaminated those wells
- 980
- 01:13:34,973 --> 01:13:37,893
- up to six times
- that level.
- 981
- 01:13:37,976 --> 01:13:40,645
- And thanks to the Tennant
- case, now we know too.
- 982
- 01:13:40,729 --> 01:13:43,356
- Hold on. This stuff
- is unregulated, right?
- 983
- 01:13:43,440 --> 01:13:44,983
- I mean, as far as
- EPA's concerned,
- 984
- 01:13:45,066 --> 01:13:47,110
- it might as well
- be rose petals.
- 985
- 01:13:47,193 --> 01:13:49,446
- The EPA hasn't
- set a standard, that's true,
- 986
- 01:13:49,529 --> 01:13:51,197
- but DuPont did.
- 987
- 01:13:51,406 --> 01:13:54,242
- And all the law requires
- to win a case like this,
- 988
- 01:13:54,326 --> 01:13:56,578
- is to show
- that DuPont exceeded
- 989
- 01:13:56,661 --> 01:13:59,205
- what DuPont itself
- considers safe.
- 990
- 01:13:59,414 --> 01:14:00,582
- Self-regulation.
- 991
- 01:14:00,707 --> 01:14:02,584
- - If what you're saying is right...
- - It is right.
- 992
- 01:14:02,667 --> 01:14:06,046
- ...then why would DuPont tell this
- water district anything at all?
- 993
- 01:14:06,129 --> 01:14:07,589
- Seems to me
- that they're being
- 994
- 01:14:07,672 --> 01:14:09,424
- a good
- corporate citizen here.
- 995
- 01:14:09,841 --> 01:14:12,844
- That's how long
- you have to file suit.
- 996
- 01:14:13,261 --> 01:14:14,554
- One year from the moment
- 997
- 01:14:14,638 --> 01:14:17,182
- you realize your water's
- been contaminated.
- 998
- 01:14:17,641 --> 01:14:21,728
- This letter looks like it's
- telling people their water is safe.
- 999
- 01:14:21,811 --> 01:14:24,981
- In fact, it's notifying them
- that it isn't.
- 1000
- 01:14:25,065 --> 01:14:26,733
- DuPont has started the clock.
- 1001
- 01:14:27,108 --> 01:14:28,234
- Smart.
- 1002
- 01:14:28,818 --> 01:14:29,945
- We would've
- counseled that.
- 1003
- 01:14:30,028 --> 01:14:32,072
- It was sent
- 11 months ago.
- 1004
- 01:14:32,155 --> 01:14:34,616
- The moment they realized
- we knew.
- 1005
- 01:14:35,283 --> 01:14:37,494
- In 30 days,
- they're home free.
- 1006
- 01:14:37,577 --> 01:14:40,163
- So that's the proposed
- case in brief.
- 1007
- 01:14:40,246 --> 01:14:41,998
- But there's something else
- to consider.
- 1008
- 01:14:42,082 --> 01:14:43,333
- You think?
- 1009
- 01:14:43,625 --> 01:14:44,709
- Rob.
- 1010
- 01:14:44,793 --> 01:14:47,712
- C-8 bio-accumulates.
- It builds up inside of us.
- 1011
- 01:14:48,088 --> 01:14:50,382
- Some class members
- who aren't sick today
- 1012
- 01:14:51,633 --> 01:14:53,093
- will get sick tomorrow.
- 1013
- 01:14:53,176 --> 01:14:55,929
- We need a way to protect
- them into the future.
- 1014
- 01:14:56,012 --> 01:14:58,056
- Jesus, Tom! If you're even thinking
- about using medical monitoring...
- 1015
- 01:14:58,139 --> 01:15:00,475
- Hold on. Hold on.
- 1016
- 01:15:00,558 --> 01:15:04,187
- Medical monitoring
- is a claim now permitted
- 1017
- 01:15:04,270 --> 01:15:05,480
- in West Virginia courts.
- 1018
- 01:15:05,563 --> 01:15:07,524
- - Oh, come on.
- - Let's hear him out.
- 1019
- 01:15:07,607 --> 01:15:10,276
- It say if a company
- exposes a community
- 1020
- 01:15:10,360 --> 01:15:11,987
- to something
- that makes them sick,
- 1021
- 01:15:12,070 --> 01:15:15,281
- they must monitor the health
- of that community indefinitely.
- 1022
- 01:15:15,365 --> 01:15:19,244
- Everybody get that? You're creating
- liability from mere exposure.
- 1023
- 01:15:19,327 --> 01:15:21,037
- It's also unprecedented.
- 1024
- 01:15:21,121 --> 01:15:23,248
- Exactly!
- Which is why not six months ago,
- 1025
- 01:15:23,331 --> 01:15:25,000
- we fought tooth and nail
- against it.
- 1026
- 01:15:25,083 --> 01:15:27,794
- And you lost.
- Our clients have the right
- 1027
- 01:15:27,877 --> 01:15:29,713
- to avail themselves
- of the law.
- 1028
- 01:15:29,796 --> 01:15:32,298
- Potential clients.
- 1029
- 01:15:36,469 --> 01:15:37,470
- Okay.
- 1030
- 01:15:38,096 --> 01:15:41,391
- I know you, Rob.
- I know your passion.
- 1031
- 01:15:42,142 --> 01:15:44,394
- You got a great settlement
- for your farmer.
- 1032
- 01:15:44,477 --> 01:15:45,812
- You should be proud of that.
- 1033
- 01:15:46,771 --> 01:15:50,358
- And perhaps as the newest
- partner at this table,
- 1034
- 01:15:50,442 --> 01:15:51,985
- I should be
- more circumspect.
- 1035
- 01:15:52,068 --> 01:15:56,156
- But what he's
- proposing here is
- 1036
- 01:15:56,781 --> 01:15:59,034
- nothing less
- than a shakedown
- 1037
- 01:15:59,117 --> 01:16:02,120
- - of an iconic American company.
- - We do not represent DuPont.
- 1038
- 01:16:02,203 --> 01:16:04,289
- No, you don't
- represent anyone.
- 1039
- 01:16:05,957 --> 01:16:07,792
- Is this what
- we have become?
- 1040
- 01:16:07,876 --> 01:16:10,628
- Plaintiff's attorneys.
- Ambulance chasers.
- 1041
- 01:16:10,712 --> 01:16:12,630
- Why don't you just admit it?
- Rob, you wanna flip.
- 1042
- 01:16:12,714 --> 01:16:14,841
- You wanna take everything
- that you know
- 1043
- 01:16:14,924 --> 01:16:17,343
- about how
- chemical companies operate
- 1044
- 01:16:17,427 --> 01:16:19,888
- and turn it against DuPont.
- Like an informant.
- 1045
- 01:16:19,971 --> 01:16:21,056
- - That's enough.
- - Isn't that right?
- 1046
- 01:16:21,181 --> 01:16:22,515
- - Okay!
- - Isn't that right?
- 1047
- 01:16:22,599 --> 01:16:23,975
- - Isn't that right?
- - Yes.
- 1048
- 01:16:24,517 --> 01:16:27,937
- Okay, then, I...
- I say we take a vote
- 1049
- 01:16:28,021 --> 01:16:30,148
- and determine whether or not
- 1050
- 01:16:30,231 --> 01:16:31,733
- we continue
- in the tradition
- 1051
- 01:16:31,816 --> 01:16:34,152
- that has distinguished this
- firm from everyone else...
- 1052
- 01:16:34,235 --> 01:16:36,696
- Okay, I'm running
- this meeting. Okay?
- 1053
- 01:16:37,363 --> 01:16:38,364
- You got that?
- 1054
- 01:16:39,365 --> 01:16:41,034
- Has anyone even read
- the evidence
- 1055
- 01:16:41,117 --> 01:16:42,202
- this man has collected?
- 1056
- 01:16:43,411 --> 01:16:45,705
- The willful negligence,
- the corruption?
- 1057
- 01:16:47,165 --> 01:16:48,166
- Read it!
- 1058
- 01:16:48,958 --> 01:16:50,835
- And then tell me we should
- be sitting on our asses!
- 1059
- 01:16:51,628 --> 01:16:55,507
- That's the reason
- why Americans hate lawyers.
- 1060
- 01:16:56,299 --> 01:16:59,344
- This is the crap that fuels
- the Ralph Naders of the world.
- 1061
- 01:16:59,427 --> 01:17:02,138
- We should want
- to nail DuPont.
- 1062
- 01:17:03,014 --> 01:17:04,974
- All of us should!
- 1063
- 01:17:05,058 --> 01:17:07,268
- American business is better
- than this, gentlemen.
- 1064
- 01:17:07,352 --> 01:17:09,979
- And when it's not,
- we should hold them to it.
- 1065
- 01:17:10,063 --> 01:17:12,148
- That's how you build
- faith in the system.
- 1066
- 01:17:13,525 --> 01:17:16,277
- We're always arguing
- that companies are people.
- 1067
- 01:17:17,320 --> 01:17:20,782
- Well, these people
- have crossed the line!
- 1068
- 01:17:21,908 --> 01:17:23,576
- To hell with them!
- 1069
- 01:17:27,288 --> 01:17:28,790
- It may come
- as a surprise
- 1070
- 01:17:28,873 --> 01:17:31,793
- to corporate defense types
- like yourselves,
- 1071
- 01:17:31,876 --> 01:17:33,753
- but there's more to the law
- than just flooding
- 1072
- 01:17:33,837 --> 01:17:35,421
- the other side in papers.
- 1073
- 01:17:35,505 --> 01:17:38,716
- From where I sit,
- you have to touch people.
- 1074
- 01:17:39,467 --> 01:17:41,386
- These girls,
- they handle the calls
- 1075
- 01:17:41,469 --> 01:17:43,638
- from the
- class action members.
- 1076
- 01:17:43,721 --> 01:17:46,182
- And there's thousands of 'em
- on any given case.
- 1077
- 01:17:46,808 --> 01:17:49,894
- And it's here that we come
- to know their pain.
- 1078
- 01:17:49,978 --> 01:17:51,521
- Isn't that right, Hazel?
- 1079
- 01:17:51,604 --> 01:17:54,899
- Yes. We hear it every day
- 1080
- 01:17:54,983 --> 01:17:58,153
- and it's my job to make
- a jury feel that pain.
- 1081
- 01:17:58,236 --> 01:18:00,738
- Not out of pity,
- but out of fear.
- 1082
- 01:18:01,281 --> 01:18:03,616
- Whatever it is
- that happened to my client,
- 1083
- 01:18:03,700 --> 01:18:05,493
- that juror has to think,
- 1084
- 01:18:06,536 --> 01:18:08,079
- "That could happen to me."
- 1085
- 01:18:08,246 --> 01:18:09,664
- You just
- keep hammering it.
- 1086
- 01:18:09,747 --> 01:18:11,916
- One part per billion.
- One part per billion.
- 1087
- 01:18:12,000 --> 01:18:14,419
- It's their own documents.
- Their own scientists.
- 1088
- 01:18:14,502 --> 01:18:15,545
- Absolutely.
- 1089
- 01:18:15,628 --> 01:18:18,047
- They set that standard,
- they have to live with it.
- 1090
- 01:18:18,131 --> 01:18:20,133
- Yeah, I think
- we can relax, Rob,
- 1091
- 01:18:20,216 --> 01:18:23,469
- though, there's no way they're gonna
- prevail with a motion to dismiss.
- 1092
- 01:18:23,553 --> 01:18:25,138
- This is procedural.
- 1093
- 01:18:25,471 --> 01:18:27,390
- It's nonsense.
- We'll get a trial today.
- 1094
- 01:18:30,101 --> 01:18:32,353
- Okay, I'll catch
- you guys in there.
- 1095
- 01:18:35,940 --> 01:18:37,275
- I wouldn't drink that.
- 1096
- 01:18:40,862 --> 01:18:41,863
- Earl.
- 1097
- 01:18:43,990 --> 01:18:45,200
- How ya doing?
- 1098
- 01:18:46,201 --> 01:18:47,410
- Still here.
- 1099
- 01:18:49,245 --> 01:18:50,663
- That's somethin',
- right?
- 1100
- 01:18:51,789 --> 01:18:53,583
- Yes, that's something.
- 1101
- 01:18:54,542 --> 01:18:55,668
- Good to see ya,
- Robbie.
- 1102
- 01:18:59,464 --> 01:19:00,715
- Can't let 'em
- 1103
- 01:19:02,217 --> 01:19:03,426
- shut you down.
- 1104
- 01:19:05,428 --> 01:19:07,889
- I won't. I promise.
- 1105
- 01:19:08,681 --> 01:19:10,016
- Whole world
- 1106
- 01:19:11,684 --> 01:19:13,394
- needs to know.
- 1107
- 01:19:15,521 --> 01:19:18,233
- They will, Earl.
- They will.
- 1108
- 01:19:20,318 --> 01:19:23,196
- Hey, Rob? It's time.
- 1109
- 01:19:25,573 --> 01:19:27,325
- I have to go.
- 1110
- 01:19:43,758 --> 01:19:45,385
- We are here
- on defendant's motion
- 1111
- 01:19:45,468 --> 01:19:49,097
- to dismiss the case
- brought by Mr. Kiger, et al.
- 1112
- 01:19:50,348 --> 01:19:54,060
- Now, which one of you
- is Mr. Wallace?
- 1113
- 01:19:54,811 --> 01:19:56,437
- Edward Wallace,
- Your Honor,
- 1114
- 01:19:56,521 --> 01:19:59,065
- on behalf of the E.I.
- DuPont de Nemours and Company,
- 1115
- 01:19:59,148 --> 01:20:00,608
- better known as DuPont.
- 1116
- 01:20:00,733 --> 01:20:02,235
- Yes, I've heard of it.
- 1117
- 01:20:02,318 --> 01:20:03,987
- - Your motion.
- - Thank you.
- 1118
- 01:20:04,988 --> 01:20:08,866
- Your Honor, we're here today because
- of a uniquely American invention.
- 1119
- 01:20:09,617 --> 01:20:10,618
- Teflon.
- 1120
- 01:20:11,077 --> 01:20:13,788
- Since 1961, Teflon
- has liberated housewives...
- 1121
- 01:20:13,871 --> 01:20:16,916
- - No, no, no.
- - Excuse me. Homemakers...
- 1122
- 01:20:17,000 --> 01:20:19,294
- This is a courtroom,
- Mr. Wallace.
- 1123
- 01:20:19,377 --> 01:20:21,129
- Not the Home Shopping Network.
- 1124
- 01:20:23,298 --> 01:20:25,258
- Plaintiffs have alleged
- that DuPont
- 1125
- 01:20:25,341 --> 01:20:27,385
- did not meet
- its own standard of safety
- 1126
- 01:20:27,468 --> 01:20:29,929
- with regard to
- the level of C-8
- 1127
- 01:20:30,013 --> 01:20:31,306
- in the local water supply.
- 1128
- 01:20:32,140 --> 01:20:33,558
- That's irrelevant,
- Your Honor.
- 1129
- 01:20:34,225 --> 01:20:35,643
- We ask you to dismiss
- on grounds
- 1130
- 01:20:35,727 --> 01:20:37,645
- that the only standard
- that matters,
- 1131
- 01:20:37,729 --> 01:20:40,398
- is the one that elected
- government deems safe.
- 1132
- 01:20:40,481 --> 01:20:41,607
- Not if it's unregulated.
- 1133
- 01:20:41,691 --> 01:20:43,776
- It's government's job
- to make these determinations.
- 1134
- 01:20:43,860 --> 01:20:45,403
- - Not any one company.
- - It's a trap.
- 1135
- 01:20:45,486 --> 01:20:46,863
- They can't revert
- back to...
- 1136
- 01:20:46,946 --> 01:20:48,072
- I got it.
- 1137
- 01:20:48,156 --> 01:20:49,949
- Is there a problem,
- Mr. Deitzler?
- 1138
- 01:20:50,033 --> 01:20:51,743
- Apologies, Your Honor,
- 1139
- 01:20:51,826 --> 01:20:55,496
- but DuPont has been hiding
- the dangers of this chemical
- 1140
- 01:20:55,580 --> 01:20:57,915
- from the government
- for a while now.
- 1141
- 01:20:57,999 --> 01:21:00,460
- And they're asking you
- to let them off the hook
- 1142
- 01:21:00,543 --> 01:21:02,837
- because they've succeeded
- in their strategy.
- 1143
- 01:21:02,920 --> 01:21:05,006
- Government doesn't
- regulate C-8.
- 1144
- 01:21:05,089 --> 01:21:06,132
- Actually,
- that's not true.
- 1145
- 01:21:06,549 --> 01:21:07,550
- No, no.
- 1146
- 01:21:07,633 --> 01:21:09,677
- The West Virginia's
- C-8 Working Group
- 1147
- 01:21:09,761 --> 01:21:11,262
- has just issued
- a standard.
- 1148
- 01:21:11,929 --> 01:21:13,097
- Here with us today,
- 1149
- 01:21:13,181 --> 01:21:14,932
- is the governmental official
- who led that effort,
- 1150
- 01:21:15,475 --> 01:21:17,018
- Dr. Mary Sue Kimball.
- 1151
- 01:21:19,604 --> 01:21:22,106
- And, Dr. Kimball,
- as a senior member
- 1152
- 01:21:22,190 --> 01:21:24,442
- of the State's Department
- of Environmental Protection,
- 1153
- 01:21:24,525 --> 01:21:26,069
- isn't it, in fact,
- your duty,
- 1154
- 01:21:26,194 --> 01:21:27,904
- - to protect the citizens of West Virginia...
- - Mr. Wallace.
- 1155
- 01:21:29,405 --> 01:21:30,531
- I'll cut to the chase.
- 1156
- 01:21:32,200 --> 01:21:33,951
- What is the level of C-8
- in drinking water
- 1157
- 01:21:34,035 --> 01:21:36,204
- that the State
- of West Virginia
- 1158
- 01:21:36,746 --> 01:21:38,498
- has determined to be
- completely safe?
- 1159
- 01:21:38,581 --> 01:21:39,916
- Watch it go from one
- part per billion to?
- 1160
- 01:21:39,999 --> 01:21:41,000
- - Five.
- - Ten?
- 1161
- 01:21:41,084 --> 01:21:42,752
- 150 parts per billion.
- 1162
- 01:21:44,128 --> 01:21:46,881
- - Welcome to West Virginia.
- - The levels found in the wells
- 1163
- 01:21:46,964 --> 01:21:49,967
- of all six water districts
- represented in this suit,
- 1164
- 01:21:50,343 --> 01:21:52,345
- do they fall below
- this maximum level?
- 1165
- 01:21:52,428 --> 01:21:53,429
- Well below.
- 1166
- 01:21:54,639 --> 01:21:55,681
- Nothing else, Your Honor.
- 1167
- 01:21:57,058 --> 01:21:58,726
- Your witness,
- Mr. Deitzler.
- 1168
- 01:21:58,810 --> 01:22:00,269
- Wait. Who's on
- the working group?
- 1169
- 01:22:00,353 --> 01:22:01,687
- DuPont, of course,
- and who else?
- 1170
- 01:22:01,771 --> 01:22:03,106
- - Who did the water testing?
- - Mr. Deitzler?
- 1171
- 01:22:03,189 --> 01:22:04,857
- - When was it done?
- - One moment, Judge.
- 1172
- 01:22:04,941 --> 01:22:06,275
- What was
- the sample size?
- 1173
- 01:22:06,359 --> 01:22:07,402
- We should
- be able to see...
- 1174
- 01:22:07,485 --> 01:22:11,406
- Going once, going twice...
- 1175
- 01:22:11,489 --> 01:22:15,410
- Dr. Kimball, who were
- the members of this cabal
- 1176
- 01:22:15,493 --> 01:22:17,120
- you call the C-8
- working group?
- 1177
- 01:22:17,203 --> 01:22:18,663
- Objection.
- 1178
- 01:22:18,996 --> 01:22:20,540
- Cool it, Mr. Deitzler.
- 1179
- 01:22:22,083 --> 01:22:23,418
- Go ahead, Dr. Kimball.
- 1180
- 01:22:23,876 --> 01:22:25,294
- Agency officials,
- 1181
- 01:22:25,378 --> 01:22:29,048
- representatives of the scientific
- community, um, stakeholders.
- 1182
- 01:22:29,132 --> 01:22:30,883
- Stakeholders?
- Which stakeholders?
- 1183
- 01:22:30,967 --> 01:22:34,429
- Oh, wait, let me guess.
- It rhymes with bouffant?
- 1184
- 01:22:35,596 --> 01:22:37,348
- DuPont is a stakeholder. Yes.
- 1185
- 01:22:37,432 --> 01:22:38,599
- So, I see.
- 1186
- 01:22:38,683 --> 01:22:40,935
- So, don't you find it peculiar
- that on the eve
- 1187
- 01:22:41,436 --> 01:22:43,104
- of a class action lawsuit,
- 1188
- 01:22:43,187 --> 01:22:46,691
- where DuPont might be
- considered liable
- 1189
- 01:22:46,774 --> 01:22:49,277
- for poisoning this community,
- 1190
- 01:22:49,360 --> 01:22:52,196
- they get you
- to come in here suddenly
- 1191
- 01:22:52,280 --> 01:22:56,075
- and reverse decades of their
- so-called heralded science?
- 1192
- 01:22:57,201 --> 01:22:59,162
- That's false.
- I don't work for DuPont.
- 1193
- 01:22:59,245 --> 01:23:00,496
- I didn't say you did.
- 1194
- 01:23:01,330 --> 01:23:03,458
- But now you bring it up,
- we'll check back in a month.
- 1195
- 01:23:03,541 --> 01:23:05,251
- - Your Honor...
- - You honestly, was gonna plan on
- 1196
- 01:23:05,334 --> 01:23:10,173
- telling this community that they
- can drink 150 times more C-8?
- 1197
- 01:23:10,256 --> 01:23:11,966
- I mean, come on,
- people, bottoms up.
- 1198
- 01:23:12,049 --> 01:23:13,050
- Honestly, Judge...
- 1199
- 01:23:13,134 --> 01:23:15,303
- All right,
- Mr. Deitzler, enough.
- 1200
- 01:23:16,554 --> 01:23:18,055
- We'll be unveiling
- the new standard
- 1201
- 01:23:18,139 --> 01:23:19,599
- at an upcoming
- public hearing.
- 1202
- 01:23:20,266 --> 01:23:23,186
- Unveiling. Oh,
- that sounds like a party.
- 1203
- 01:23:24,020 --> 01:23:25,021
- We'll be there!
- 1204
- 01:23:31,027 --> 01:23:33,779
- Their safety standards thing,
- that's all a sham.
- 1205
- 01:23:33,863 --> 01:23:35,615
- Thanks to
- the Judge's decision,
- 1206
- 01:23:35,698 --> 01:23:37,617
- we will have our day
- in court.
- 1207
- 01:23:37,700 --> 01:23:38,910
- Yes, we will!
- 1208
- 01:23:38,993 --> 01:23:41,329
- Because if the state
- of West Virginia
- 1209
- 01:23:41,412 --> 01:23:43,289
- won't stop
- the DuPont Corporation
- 1210
- 01:23:43,372 --> 01:23:45,625
- from literally
- poisoning its citizens,
- 1211
- 01:23:45,708 --> 01:23:49,045
- then we, the citizens,
- will stop them ourselves.
- 1212
- 01:23:51,172 --> 01:23:53,466
- Good
- evening and welcome to 20/20.
- 1213
- 01:23:53,549 --> 01:23:57,845
- Well, it coats the pots you cook
- with so the food doesn't stick.
- 1214
- 01:23:57,929 --> 01:24:01,057
- It protects the carpet
- your baby crawls on.
- 1215
- 01:24:01,140 --> 01:24:02,934
- I miss carpet.
- 1216
- 01:24:03,017 --> 01:24:05,228
- ...your skin lotion,
- even your makeup.
- 1217
- 01:24:05,311 --> 01:24:07,188
- We're talking about Teflon.
- 1218
- 01:24:07,271 --> 01:24:10,274
- And tonight our 20/20
- investigation uncovers
- 1219
- 01:24:10,358 --> 01:24:14,529
- alarming information about
- this much-used material.
- 1220
- 01:24:14,612 --> 01:24:17,156
- It is very alarming, Barbara.
- I cook with Teflon.
- 1221
- 01:24:17,240 --> 01:24:20,368
- I didn't know until I watched this
- report that you're about to see,
- 1222
- 01:24:20,451 --> 01:24:22,161
- that if Teflon
- gets hot enough...
- 1223
- 01:24:22,245 --> 01:24:24,038
- ...millions of people
- have in their homes.
- 1224
- 01:24:24,121 --> 01:24:25,414
- Teflon has become
- such a familiar...
- 1225
- 01:24:25,498 --> 01:24:28,668
- ...Substance that is also used in
- clothing and cars. Even in contact lenses.
- 1226
- 01:24:28,751 --> 01:24:32,088
- ...already found in the blood
- of most Americans.
- 1227
- 01:24:35,424 --> 01:24:38,386
- ...millions of homes across
- Australia. Teflon, a non-stick surface...
- 1228
- 01:24:38,469 --> 01:24:40,555
- The
- Environmental Protection Agency
- 1229
- 01:24:40,638 --> 01:24:45,560
- this morning announced it has opened
- a priority review of the chemical C-8,
- 1230
- 01:24:45,643 --> 01:24:48,271
- currently the subject
- of a class action lawsuit
- 1231
- 01:24:48,354 --> 01:24:50,231
- against the chemical giant
- DuPont.
- 1232
- 01:24:50,314 --> 01:24:51,315
- Joe!
- 1233
- 01:24:53,442 --> 01:24:56,445
- Joe! Oh, my Lord!
- Joe, just wait!
- 1234
- 01:24:56,529 --> 01:24:59,532
- Wait for the fire department,
- please, honey!
- 1235
- 01:24:59,907 --> 01:25:01,909
- Please don't go crazy!
- 1236
- 01:25:01,993 --> 01:25:03,869
- ...have triggered a
- mass panic amongst Chinese consumers.
- 1237
- 01:25:03,953 --> 01:25:06,706
- ...just throw away
- your non-stick pans, many experts...
- 1238
- 01:25:06,789 --> 01:25:09,000
- Are your pans
- making you sick?
- 1239
- 01:25:09,083 --> 01:25:10,793
- That's the question
- being asked...
- 1240
- 01:25:10,876 --> 01:25:14,046
- ...kitchen
- implements coated in Teflon.
- 1241
- 01:25:14,672 --> 01:25:17,675
- The house was empty.
- It belongs to my father.
- 1242
- 01:25:18,050 --> 01:25:20,136
- I don't know
- how it could've started.
- 1243
- 01:25:20,219 --> 01:25:21,470
- His name Kiger?
- 1244
- 01:25:23,097 --> 01:25:25,224
- Think someone might have
- got the wrong house?
- 1245
- 01:25:33,816 --> 01:25:36,944
- All of this
- hullabaloo is just silly.
- 1246
- 01:25:37,862 --> 01:25:41,073
- Teflon is completely safe
- for cooking.
- 1247
- 01:25:41,157 --> 01:25:43,951
- That is why we founded
- the Cook Healthy campaign,
- 1248
- 01:25:44,035 --> 01:25:45,578
- to set the record straight.
- 1249
- 01:25:45,703 --> 01:25:50,625
- And besides being completely safe, it is also...
- 1250
- 01:25:57,882 --> 01:25:59,091
- Copy that.
- 1251
- 01:26:02,094 --> 01:26:03,471
- All the way down.
- 1252
- 01:27:08,202 --> 01:27:09,286
- We're now on the record.
- 1253
- 01:27:09,370 --> 01:27:13,249
- This is the videotaped deposition
- of Charles O. Holliday, Jr.,
- 1254
- 01:27:13,332 --> 01:27:16,293
- taken by the plaintiffs in
- the matter of Kiger et al
- 1255
- 01:27:16,377 --> 01:27:19,588
- v. the E.I. DuPont
- de Nemours and Company.
- 1256
- 01:27:19,672 --> 01:27:21,382
- Raise your right hand.
- 1257
- 01:27:22,091 --> 01:27:24,802
- Do you swear to tell the whole
- truth and nothing but the truth?
- 1258
- 01:27:24,885 --> 01:27:26,011
- I do.
- 1259
- 01:27:27,430 --> 01:27:29,390
- Uh, please state
- your name.
- 1260
- 01:27:30,182 --> 01:27:31,934
- Charles O. Holliday, Jr.
- 1261
- 01:27:32,351 --> 01:27:35,730
- And are you
- presently employed?
- 1262
- 01:27:36,647 --> 01:27:37,815
- Yes.
- 1263
- 01:27:38,274 --> 01:27:40,317
- What is your position?
- 1264
- 01:27:41,277 --> 01:27:44,530
- I'm the chairman and chief executive
- officer of the DuPont Company.
- 1265
- 01:27:45,865 --> 01:27:50,494
- In DuPont's most recent filing with
- the Securities and Exchange Commission,
- 1266
- 01:27:50,578 --> 01:27:54,999
- you state, "Based on over 50
- years of industry experience
- 1267
- 01:27:55,082 --> 01:27:57,334
- "and extensive
- scientific study,
- 1268
- 01:27:57,418 --> 01:28:01,422
- "DuPont believes there is
- no evidence that PFOA causes
- 1269
- 01:28:01,505 --> 01:28:05,926
- "any adverse human health effects
- or harms the environment."
- 1270
- 01:28:06,010 --> 01:28:08,137
- You signed
- that legal filing, correct?
- 1271
- 01:28:08,220 --> 01:28:10,973
- I don't recall the exact statement,
- but that sounds right to me.
- 1272
- 01:28:11,056 --> 01:28:15,102
- Are you aware that DuPont
- has, in its own files,
- 1273
- 01:28:15,186 --> 01:28:20,191
- studies dating back to the 1970s
- that say just the opposite?
- 1274
- 01:28:20,483 --> 01:28:23,402
- That PFOA, or C-8,
- as it's called,
- 1275
- 01:28:23,486 --> 01:28:26,572
- has potentially life-threatening
- effects on human health?
- 1276
- 01:28:26,655 --> 01:28:29,575
- I'm not familiar with the exact
- studies we may have in our files.
- 1277
- 01:28:29,658 --> 01:28:32,953
- Then I'll take you through them.
- Uh, Exhibit 9.
- 1278
- 01:28:38,292 --> 01:28:41,754
- Uh, you were just
- handed Exhibit 9.
- 1279
- 01:28:42,087 --> 01:28:46,175
- - Uh, do you see the date March 13th, 1979?
- - Yes.
- 1280
- 01:28:46,300 --> 01:28:49,011
- - Do you see the DuPont logo at the top?
- - Yes.
- 1281
- 01:28:49,136 --> 01:28:52,848
- - Do you see this word here, highlighted?
- - Yes.
- 1282
- 01:28:52,932 --> 01:28:55,601
- - Would you read it for me, please?
- - "Receptors."
- 1283
- 01:28:56,435 --> 01:29:00,064
- Do you know what that word refers
- to, receptors?
- 1284
- 01:29:00,606 --> 01:29:03,526
- Um, in this context,
- I do not.
- 1285
- 01:29:03,609 --> 01:29:05,236
- It means human beings.
- 1286
- 01:29:05,736 --> 01:29:07,822
- DuPont refers
- to the men and women
- 1287
- 01:29:07,905 --> 01:29:11,659
- that your company
- exposed to C-8 as receptors.
- 1288
- 01:29:11,742 --> 01:29:16,372
- And in these receptors,
- your scientists found,
- 1289
- 01:29:16,455 --> 01:29:20,709
- "significantly higher
- incidents of allergic endocrine
- 1290
- 01:29:20,793 --> 01:29:22,670
- "and metabolic disorders."
- 1291
- 01:29:22,753 --> 01:29:27,383
- As well as, "excess risk of
- developing liver disease."
- 1292
- 01:29:27,466 --> 01:29:29,468
- - Do you see that?
- - Yes.
- 1293
- 01:29:31,136 --> 01:29:34,598
- Moreover, you have
- infertility at Teflon.
- 1294
- 01:29:34,682 --> 01:29:36,934
- Occurrences of leukemia.
- 1295
- 01:29:37,017 --> 01:29:39,311
- You have excess of cancers.
- 1296
- 01:29:39,395 --> 01:29:41,438
- Bladder, kidney,
- oral, pharynx.
- 1297
- 01:29:41,522 --> 01:29:44,024
- Next paragraph. 78.
- 1298
- 01:29:44,108 --> 01:29:46,652
- Do you see that heading?
- Do you see that date? Do you see that?
- 1299
- 01:29:46,735 --> 01:29:49,238
- Exhibit 96. Exhibit 53.
- 1300
- 01:29:49,321 --> 01:29:51,407
- I'd like to move on
- to birth defects.
- 1301
- 01:29:51,490 --> 01:29:52,658
- We've gone
- almost seven hours.
- 1302
- 01:29:52,741 --> 01:29:55,619
- Mr. Holliday, you're aware
- that in 1981
- 1303
- 01:29:55,703 --> 01:29:59,456
- 3M notified DuPont that it
- had conducted studies on rats.
- 1304
- 01:29:59,540 --> 01:30:00,958
- And these studies showed
- 1305
- 01:30:01,041 --> 01:30:04,879
- that sustained C-8 exposure
- can cause facial deformities?
- 1306
- 01:30:04,962 --> 01:30:06,714
- I'm not aware
- of a study by 3M.
- 1307
- 01:30:06,797 --> 01:30:11,385
- How about DuPont's own studies that
- showed the same thing in humans?
- 1308
- 01:30:14,471 --> 01:30:18,267
- That's DuPont's
- pregnancy study from 1981.
- 1309
- 01:30:18,559 --> 01:30:20,144
- Does that look like
- a DuPont document to you?
- 1310
- 01:30:20,227 --> 01:30:21,312
- It looks to be.
- 1311
- 01:30:23,355 --> 01:30:27,026
- Are you aware that DuPont has
- denied that any such study
- 1312
- 01:30:27,109 --> 01:30:29,570
- ever even took place?
- 1313
- 01:30:30,863 --> 01:30:33,532
- I'm not familiar with specific
- statements we've made about that.
- 1314
- 01:30:33,616 --> 01:30:37,286
- Seven pregnant women,
- all DuPont employees,
- 1315
- 01:30:37,369 --> 01:30:39,413
- all from the Teflon line.
- 1316
- 01:30:40,205 --> 01:30:42,291
- Do you see this here?
- 1317
- 01:30:42,374 --> 01:30:46,795
- "Child, four months,
- one nostril,
- 1318
- 01:30:46,879 --> 01:30:49,089
- - "eye defect."
- - Yes.
- 1319
- 01:30:49,173 --> 01:30:52,384
- Two of the seven women,
- nearly 30%, gave birth
- 1320
- 01:30:52,468 --> 01:30:56,347
- to babies that had the exact facial
- deformities that your company
- 1321
- 01:30:56,430 --> 01:30:58,682
- - already knew about.
- - We're done here.
- 1322
- 01:31:00,851 --> 01:31:01,977
- Sir.
- 1323
- 01:31:03,354 --> 01:31:05,189
- His parents named him Bucky.
- 1324
- 01:31:08,901 --> 01:31:10,277
- Bucky Bailey.
- 1325
- 01:31:12,154 --> 01:31:14,531
- This is your receptor.
- 1326
- 01:31:22,998 --> 01:31:24,375
- Now we're done.
- 1327
- 01:33:01,388 --> 01:33:05,100
- The Environmental Protection
- Agency has levied the largest fine
- 1328
- 01:33:05,184 --> 01:33:09,021
- in agency history against
- the chemical giant, DuPont.
- 1329
- 01:33:09,480 --> 01:33:14,109
- The EPA concluded the company failed
- to report the health dangers of C-8
- 1330
- 01:33:14,193 --> 01:33:16,779
- used in the manufacture
- of Teflon.
- 1331
- 01:33:17,279 --> 01:33:21,033
- Dupont will pay the EPA
- 16.5 million.
- 1332
- 01:33:22,326 --> 01:33:26,330
- It earns a billion dollars in
- profits from Teflon each year.
- 1333
- 01:33:33,462 --> 01:33:34,797
- To recap,
- 1334
- 01:33:34,880 --> 01:33:38,092
- we've agreed that DuPont will
- clean local water supplies.
- 1335
- 01:33:38,175 --> 01:33:41,762
- Install infiltration systems
- in all six water districts.
- 1336
- 01:33:42,679 --> 01:33:46,391
- Additionally, DuPont will pay
- 70 million in cash to the Class.
- 1337
- 01:33:46,475 --> 01:33:48,685
- Three days' revenue
- on the Teflon line.
- 1338
- 01:33:49,853 --> 01:33:53,732
- Which leaves our most
- challenging issue. Medical monitoring.
- 1339
- 01:33:53,816 --> 01:33:56,902
- We've agreed to establish
- an independent science panel
- 1340
- 01:33:56,985 --> 01:34:01,532
- comprised of three scientists who
- have no relationship to either side.
- 1341
- 01:34:02,366 --> 01:34:05,828
- This independent panel will
- study the members of this Class
- 1342
- 01:34:05,911 --> 01:34:09,748
- to determine whether C-8 exposure
- has led to increased incidents
- 1343
- 01:34:09,832 --> 01:34:11,834
- of disease in this region.
- 1344
- 01:34:12,626 --> 01:34:15,462
- If the panel finds that there
- are probable scientific links
- 1345
- 01:34:15,546 --> 01:34:18,966
- to a particular disease,
- the health of everyone in the Class
- 1346
- 01:34:19,049 --> 01:34:22,970
- will be monitored for
- that disease in perpetuity
- 1347
- 01:34:23,053 --> 01:34:26,473
- at DuPont's cost,
- up to 235 million.
- 1348
- 01:34:26,557 --> 01:34:29,351
- And any Class member
- who develops that disease
- 1349
- 01:34:29,434 --> 01:34:32,104
- can sue DuPont for damages.
- 1350
- 01:34:32,938 --> 01:34:34,106
- However...
- 1351
- 01:34:34,690 --> 01:34:38,610
- If the science panel fails to
- establish probable scientific links,
- 1352
- 01:34:39,319 --> 01:34:40,487
- then this case is over.
- 1353
- 01:34:40,571 --> 01:34:44,116
- No monitoring.
- No lawsuits. No exceptions.
- 1354
- 01:34:44,908 --> 01:34:48,579
- Good. Well, gentlemen, you are now
- officially in the hands of science.
- 1355
- 01:34:49,913 --> 01:34:54,376
- Well, wouldn't have
- pegged you as a Mai Tai guy.
- 1356
- 01:34:55,252 --> 01:34:57,713
- - It's festive.
- - Wouldn't have pegged you for that either.
- 1357
- 01:34:57,796 --> 01:35:00,549
- We have something to celebrate.
- Yeah?
- 1358
- 01:35:00,632 --> 01:35:01,717
- Do we?
- 1359
- 01:35:03,051 --> 01:35:06,847
- Look, how do we know
- that the panel's gonna prove
- 1360
- 01:35:06,930 --> 01:35:09,558
- that DuPont made
- all these people sick?
- 1361
- 01:35:10,309 --> 01:35:12,811
- I'm no scientist,
- but even I know you'd need
- 1362
- 01:35:12,895 --> 01:35:15,731
- huge amounts of medical data,
- not to mention
- 1363
- 01:35:15,814 --> 01:35:17,482
- thousands of blood samples
- and...
- 1364
- 01:35:17,566 --> 01:35:19,818
- From people
- who don't trust us.
- 1365
- 01:35:19,902 --> 01:35:23,197
- "Hey, folks, we wanna stick you with
- some needles. You won't mind, will ya?"
- 1366
- 01:35:24,364 --> 01:35:26,783
- I know these people,
- you know.
- 1367
- 01:35:27,492 --> 01:35:30,037
- They're gonna
- take the money and run.
- 1368
- 01:35:30,120 --> 01:35:31,246
- Wouldn't you?
- 1369
- 01:35:31,330 --> 01:35:36,001
- I think they want more than just the money.
- I think they...
- 1370
- 01:35:36,960 --> 01:35:39,504
- They wanna know if they're
- gonna get sick or not.
- 1371
- 01:35:39,588 --> 01:35:42,591
- Or if they have C-8 in their
- blood, and what that's gonna do
- 1372
- 01:35:42,674 --> 01:35:45,093
- to them and their families.
- 1373
- 01:35:46,345 --> 01:35:48,847
- So, we're just gonna trust
- that they show up?
- 1374
- 01:35:48,931 --> 01:35:52,392
- - Trust, but verify.
- - What does that mean, Rob?
- 1375
- 01:35:53,685 --> 01:35:56,730
- Well, come in for an exam.
- 1376
- 01:35:56,813 --> 01:36:00,192
- Um, give us a blood sample.
- 1377
- 01:36:00,859 --> 01:36:02,945
- Then, we'll give you
- your check.
- 1378
- 01:36:05,822 --> 01:36:07,908
- On second thought,
- make mine a Mai Tai.
- 1379
- 01:36:07,991 --> 01:36:08,992
- All around, please.
- 1380
- 01:36:10,410 --> 01:36:12,537
- - Rob Bilott.
- - Yeah.
- 1381
- 01:36:12,663 --> 01:36:14,831
- Where'd you pull that out of?
- 1382
- 01:36:15,040 --> 01:36:17,542
- Healthy drinking
- water is vital to all of us.
- 1383
- 01:36:17,626 --> 01:36:20,712
- That's why scientists need
- to know if the chemical C-8
- 1384
- 01:36:20,796 --> 01:36:22,297
- causes any health problems.
- 1385
- 01:36:22,381 --> 01:36:26,176
- Starting today, you can help by completing
- a health questionnaire and having...
- 1386
- 01:36:29,221 --> 01:36:31,014
- Oh, come on!
- 1387
- 01:36:31,098 --> 01:36:32,891
- ...medical van's downtown.
- Well, how about you?
- 1388
- 01:36:32,975 --> 01:36:36,979
- - You gonna get your blood tested?
- - Nah. I hate needles.
- 1389
- 01:36:37,062 --> 01:36:39,106
- It's $400, buddy.
- 1390
- 01:36:39,898 --> 01:36:40,899
- Really?
- 1391
- 01:36:40,983 --> 01:36:43,110
- Got your attention, didn't I?
- 1392
- 01:37:11,722 --> 01:37:15,183
- Okay. Okay.
- All right. All right.
- 1393
- 01:37:15,767 --> 01:37:17,477
- Yeah. That'll work.
- 1394
- 01:37:17,561 --> 01:37:19,229
- We bring them back here.
- 1395
- 01:37:20,355 --> 01:37:22,858
- Draw the blood,
- hand them a check.
- 1396
- 01:37:22,941 --> 01:37:25,193
- - $400?
- - Each.
- 1397
- 01:37:25,277 --> 01:37:27,112
- Lots of money around here.
- 1398
- 01:37:27,279 --> 01:37:29,031
- How many you brought
- with you today, Miss LUAnn?
- 1399
- 01:37:29,114 --> 01:37:31,491
- My husband,
- and my three kids, and me.
- 1400
- 01:37:31,575 --> 01:37:33,035
- $2,000.
- 1401
- 01:37:33,118 --> 01:37:35,954
- - Not too shabby right before Christmas.
- - Yup.
- 1402
- 01:37:36,955 --> 01:37:39,041
- But you ain't
- gonna find nothing.
- 1403
- 01:37:39,124 --> 01:37:42,210
- DuPont's good people.
- You'll see.
- 1404
- 01:37:45,964 --> 01:37:47,424
- Gigi, Gigi, Gigi!
- 1405
- 01:37:47,507 --> 01:37:50,510
- It's your turn to put
- the angel on the top.
- 1406
- 01:37:51,011 --> 01:37:53,388
- - You do it, sweetie.
- - Gigi's too pooped.
- 1407
- 01:37:53,472 --> 01:37:56,433
- Why don't you get your Uncle
- Ben to give you a boost?
- 1408
- 01:37:56,516 --> 01:37:59,478
- - Ooh.
- - Mom, you okay?
- 1409
- 01:37:59,561 --> 01:38:00,562
- Yeah.
- 1410
- 01:38:00,645 --> 01:38:02,147
- Seriously, it's huge.
- 1411
- 01:38:02,230 --> 01:38:04,149
- They're gonna be making you
- partner this year. I know it.
- 1412
- 01:38:04,232 --> 01:38:06,109
- Well, they'd better.
- I mean...
- 1413
- 01:38:06,360 --> 01:38:07,986
- Mommy, come see!
- 1414
- 01:38:08,070 --> 01:38:09,154
- Hey, baby,
- did you hang that ornament?
- 1415
- 01:38:09,237 --> 01:38:11,239
- - Rob, can you get that?
- - Let me see.
- 1416
- 01:38:11,323 --> 01:38:12,532
- Okay, I'm coming.
- 1417
- 01:38:16,536 --> 01:38:17,537
- Hello?
- 1418
- 01:38:17,621 --> 01:38:19,998
- - Rob, you sitting down for this?
- - Larry, what's wrong?
- 1419
- 01:38:20,082 --> 01:38:23,502
- - Sixty-nine thousand.
- - Sixty-nine thousand what?
- 1420
- 01:38:23,585 --> 01:38:26,713
- Sixty-nine thousand people got tested.
- Sixty-nine thousand!
- 1421
- 01:38:26,797 --> 01:38:28,924
- Do you realize
- how much data this is?
- 1422
- 01:38:29,007 --> 01:38:30,342
- It's what we needed, Rob!
- This is it!
- 1423
- 01:38:30,425 --> 01:38:32,928
- - Oh, my God.
- - You were right all along, my friend.
- 1424
- 01:38:33,011 --> 01:38:34,429
- - Merry Christmas!
- - Thank you!
- 1425
- 01:38:34,513 --> 01:38:36,014
- - You bet.
- - Thank you!
- 1426
- 01:38:36,098 --> 01:38:37,391
- Talk real soon.
- 1427
- 01:38:39,101 --> 01:38:41,061
- - Hey, who was that?
- - You won't believe it.
- 1428
- 01:38:41,144 --> 01:38:43,772
- - Daddy, guess what I just did?
- - What? What'd you just do?
- 1429
- 01:38:43,855 --> 01:38:45,690
- I put the angel on the top.
- 1430
- 01:38:45,774 --> 01:38:47,150
- - Yeah?
- - Uncle Ben lifted me.
- 1431
- 01:38:47,234 --> 01:38:49,861
- He did? Like this? Oh!
- 1432
- 01:38:49,945 --> 01:38:53,740
- - Merry Christmas, everyone!
- - Merry Christmas!
- 1433
- 01:39:08,547 --> 01:39:13,093
- We are gathered here today
- in the memory of Wilbur Earl Tennant.
- 1434
- 01:39:13,593 --> 01:39:16,471
- "The Lord is my shepherd,
- I shall not want.
- 1435
- 01:39:17,055 --> 01:39:19,724
- "He makes me lie down
- in green pastures.
- 1436
- 01:39:20,225 --> 01:39:25,063
- "He leads me besides still waters.
- He restoreth my soul.
- 1437
- 01:39:25,147 --> 01:39:28,650
- "Even though I walk through the
- valley of the shadow of death,
- 1438
- 01:39:28,733 --> 01:39:30,902
- "I will fear no evil..."
- 1439
- 01:40:03,477 --> 01:40:05,103
- Quick, everybody.
- Mustard or ketchup?
- 1440
- 01:40:05,187 --> 01:40:07,355
- Teddy, for the tenth
- time, that's my ketchup.
- 1441
- 01:40:07,439 --> 01:40:10,442
- - Charlie, don't start.
- - What? It's mine. I got it.
- 1442
- 01:40:10,525 --> 01:40:13,195
- - He's got his own, okay?
- - You're that lawyer.
- 1443
- 01:40:13,570 --> 01:40:14,738
- Finish up.
- 1444
- 01:40:16,364 --> 01:40:20,118
- My brother's Dale Lamb. You took his blood.
- Said you'd help him.
- 1445
- 01:40:20,869 --> 01:40:23,413
- Yeah, I did. We're...
- We're working on it. I promise.
- 1446
- 01:40:23,497 --> 01:40:24,831
- He's dead.
- 1447
- 01:40:26,583 --> 01:40:28,376
- Testicular cancer.
- 1448
- 01:40:30,420 --> 01:40:33,048
- Left three little boys
- younger than yours.
- 1449
- 01:40:38,261 --> 01:40:40,472
- But you enjoy your family.
- 1450
- 01:40:43,058 --> 01:40:44,059
- Okay. Everybody up.
- 1451
- 01:40:44,142 --> 01:40:45,810
- - I'm not finished.
- - I said up.
- 1452
- 01:41:24,683 --> 01:41:28,228
- Well, Darlene can't even leave
- the house without being harassed!
- 1453
- 01:41:29,521 --> 01:41:33,191
- First, they blame us
- for suing DuPont,
- 1454
- 01:41:33,275 --> 01:41:36,736
- and now they hate on us 'cause
- they ain't seen nothing from it!
- 1455
- 01:41:36,820 --> 01:41:39,823
- - I'm sorry, Joe...
- - Well, that ain't good enough!
- 1456
- 01:41:40,073 --> 01:41:43,618
- And they wonder why in the
- hell it takes four damn years
- 1457
- 01:41:43,702 --> 01:41:47,163
- to read a lousy blood sample,
- and I don't blame 'em!
- 1458
- 01:41:47,581 --> 01:41:51,710
- We trusted you, Rob.
- We put our faith in you.
- 1459
- 01:41:51,793 --> 01:41:54,170
- - I know, Joe. I'm so...
- - All right?
- 1460
- 01:41:58,633 --> 01:42:02,721
- Isn't there just some
- kind of a progress report?
- 1461
- 01:42:02,804 --> 01:42:06,057
- Anything that I can
- share with these folks?
- 1462
- 01:42:06,141 --> 01:42:08,643
- I mean, they...
- They have been waiting.
- 1463
- 01:42:08,727 --> 01:42:10,145
- I'm sorry, Mr. Bilott.
- 1464
- 01:42:10,228 --> 01:42:11,980
- The Panel is still
- in the process of
- 1465
- 01:42:12,063 --> 01:42:13,982
- analyzing complex data
- and modeling
- 1466
- 01:42:14,065 --> 01:42:16,818
- from thousands of samples
- and medical histories.
- 1467
- 01:42:16,943 --> 01:42:20,071
- I'm so sorry. Could you hold a moment?
- 1468
- 01:42:30,248 --> 01:42:32,417
- Charlie,
- don't pick at your food.
- 1469
- 01:42:34,127 --> 01:42:35,378
- What's a hooker?
- 1470
- 01:42:37,339 --> 01:42:39,090
- Where did you learn that?
- 1471
- 01:42:39,174 --> 01:42:41,926
- He told me that
- Mary Magdalene was a hooker.
- 1472
- 01:42:43,678 --> 01:42:46,848
- - What? She was.
- - You're supposed to say prostitute.
- 1473
- 01:42:46,931 --> 01:42:49,351
- And then
- she found God
- 1474
- 01:42:49,434 --> 01:42:52,228
- and became one of Jesus's
- most fervent disciples.
- 1475
- 01:42:53,938 --> 01:42:55,315
- See? I was just
- teaching him the Bible.
- 1476
- 01:42:55,940 --> 01:42:58,401
- I can't today.
- So everybody up.
- 1477
- 01:42:59,027 --> 01:43:00,528
- Everybody up!
- 1478
- 01:43:08,370 --> 01:43:11,581
- - Can we still afford it?
- - What?
- 1479
- 01:43:12,540 --> 01:43:13,833
- Catholic school.
- 1480
- 01:43:29,641 --> 01:43:31,685
- My brother's back in rehab.
- Did you know that?
- 1481
- 01:43:34,646 --> 01:43:37,649
- - No, I'm sorry.
- - Today's...
- 1482
- 01:43:39,317 --> 01:43:41,778
- Today's Mom's first day
- at chemo.
- 1483
- 01:43:42,404 --> 01:43:43,405
- I forgot.
- 1484
- 01:43:43,488 --> 01:43:46,241
- 'Cause it's not
- about your case, Rob.
- 1485
- 01:43:46,491 --> 01:43:47,701
- Car!
- 1486
- 01:43:47,784 --> 01:43:49,077
- - Gosh.
- - Okay. Jimmies.
- 1487
- 01:43:55,083 --> 01:43:58,837
- Teddy forged my signature,
- and Tony's quitting football. Tony.
- 1488
- 01:43:58,920 --> 01:44:00,922
- But how would you
- know about that, right?
- 1489
- 01:44:01,005 --> 01:44:03,091
- Because all you see,
- all that you...
- 1490
- 01:44:03,174 --> 01:44:06,678
- You... The boys have ever seen is
- you, obsessing about this...
- 1491
- 01:44:11,182 --> 01:44:12,892
- Have I ever complained?
- 1492
- 01:44:16,646 --> 01:44:19,524
- Say something,
- for God's sakes, Rob!
- 1493
- 01:44:19,607 --> 01:44:21,568
- - No.
- - No?
- 1494
- 01:44:21,651 --> 01:44:23,445
- - No.
- - No.
- 1495
- 01:44:24,487 --> 01:44:26,531
- Because I knew that
- you needed something.
- 1496
- 01:44:26,614 --> 01:44:29,367
- Some connection...
- Something.
- 1497
- 01:44:29,451 --> 01:44:30,452
- And...
- 1498
- 01:44:30,869 --> 01:44:31,870
- So I took it on.
- 1499
- 01:44:33,037 --> 01:44:37,000
- But if you want to start accounting,
- if you want to start with,
- 1500
- 01:44:37,083 --> 01:44:39,127
- "Oh, can we afford," then...
- 1501
- 01:44:42,464 --> 01:44:44,174
- I don't know, Rob.
- 1502
- 01:44:45,133 --> 01:44:47,886
- Can the boys afford a father who
- can't string two words together?
- 1503
- 01:44:47,969 --> 01:44:50,513
- Can our marriage
- afford 13 years of...
- 1504
- 01:44:50,597 --> 01:44:52,474
- Thirteen years of this?
- 1505
- 01:44:55,143 --> 01:44:58,730
- How about it, Rob? You wanna talk about it?
- About our lives?
- 1506
- 01:45:02,901 --> 01:45:04,235
- Of course not.
- 1507
- 01:45:05,987 --> 01:45:08,198
- I'll tell Mom
- you asked about her.
- 1508
- 01:45:11,159 --> 01:45:14,537
- What in God's name is that Panel
- doing? Why are we still getting bills?
- 1509
- 01:45:14,913 --> 01:45:17,165
- Overhead. Uh...
- 1510
- 01:45:17,248 --> 01:45:18,333
- Local counsel.
- 1511
- 01:45:18,416 --> 01:45:21,002
- - Harry's call center...
- - $1,000 an hour.
- 1512
- 01:45:21,085 --> 01:45:23,421
- That... That was
- a technical expert.
- 1513
- 01:45:23,505 --> 01:45:27,717
- We needed to do filings when DuPont
- started lobbying Washington...
- 1514
- 01:45:27,801 --> 01:45:29,511
- That's Washington's problem,
- not ours.
- 1515
- 01:45:29,594 --> 01:45:31,262
- That's why you got them involved.
- Your memo.
- 1516
- 01:45:31,346 --> 01:45:34,098
- It was just a fine, Tom.
- It's a fine. Sixteen million.
- 1517
- 01:45:34,182 --> 01:45:37,018
- It's... It's nothing for these people.
- It's pocket change.
- 1518
- 01:45:37,101 --> 01:45:39,479
- Yes, but if they get charged with
- criminal concealment, game over.
- 1519
- 01:45:39,604 --> 01:45:42,232
- - You said DOJ was investigating.
- - Not anymore.
- 1520
- 01:45:42,357 --> 01:45:44,192
- - What?
- - They dropped the investigation.
- 1521
- 01:45:44,317 --> 01:45:46,820
- - They dropped... What?
- - They dropped it. No reason given.
- 1522
- 01:45:49,656 --> 01:45:53,493
- Tom, our government is
- captive to DuPont.
- 1523
- 01:45:53,952 --> 01:45:56,788
- This case,
- it's the only hope we have.
- 1524
- 01:45:56,871 --> 01:45:59,290
- They know that, and they're
- trying to make it as expensive
- 1525
- 01:45:59,374 --> 01:46:02,168
- as they can to force you
- to make me stop.
- 1526
- 01:46:04,337 --> 01:46:06,214
- - Just tell me how much longer.
- - I...
- 1527
- 01:46:07,298 --> 01:46:10,760
- I... I can't.
- I... wish I could.
- 1528
- 01:46:12,345 --> 01:46:13,638
- - Tom, I...
- - Are you okay?
- 1529
- 01:46:13,721 --> 01:46:15,265
- Um, I'm fine. I'm just...
- 1530
- 01:46:15,348 --> 01:46:19,727
- Rob, I'm a Managing Partner
- now. I have a firm to run.
- 1531
- 01:46:20,228 --> 01:46:24,065
- I know. And Tom, I think there
- could be a huge payout here...
- 1532
- 01:46:24,148 --> 01:46:25,525
- You think
- I'm in this for money?
- 1533
- 01:46:26,317 --> 01:46:27,443
- - No, I...
- - You think I am...
- 1534
- 01:46:27,527 --> 01:46:31,990
- Letting you drag this firm's
- reputation through a meat grinder
- 1535
- 01:46:32,073 --> 01:46:33,700
- for some kind of
- plaintiff's payoff?
- 1536
- 01:46:36,160 --> 01:46:38,872
- I... I don't know why you're doing it.
- 1537
- 01:46:43,126 --> 01:46:45,420
- Rob, listen, I... I'm sorry,
- 1538
- 01:46:45,503 --> 01:46:48,089
- but you're gonna have to
- take another pay cut.
- 1539
- 01:46:48,172 --> 01:46:51,092
- Tom, that's...
- That's my fourth pay cut.
- 1540
- 01:46:51,175 --> 01:46:54,137
- I... I'm down
- to a third now.
- 1541
- 01:46:54,220 --> 01:46:56,472
- You don't have any clients.
- No one will take your calls.
- 1542
- 01:46:58,182 --> 01:47:02,437
- What am I supposed to do here?
- Now, I'm on your side, but...
- 1543
- 01:47:02,770 --> 01:47:03,771
- Rob?
- 1544
- 01:47:04,689 --> 01:47:07,108
- Amy? Amy!
- 1545
- 01:47:07,191 --> 01:47:09,193
- - Kathleen!
- - Get some help!
- 1546
- 01:47:09,277 --> 01:47:10,737
- - Kathleen!
- - Get some help!
- 1547
- 01:47:11,112 --> 01:47:13,114
- Rob! Rob!
- 1548
- 01:47:23,333 --> 01:47:25,543
- Looks like
- we should, uh, cancel
- 1549
- 01:47:25,627 --> 01:47:28,755
- my 4:00 with Jerry and...
- 1550
- 01:47:28,838 --> 01:47:31,424
- I don't know.
- We're waiting to find out.
- 1551
- 01:47:31,507 --> 01:47:32,592
- It was, uh...
- 1552
- 01:47:35,762 --> 01:47:38,431
- Make... Make sure that,
- uh, Jerry knows that...
- 1553
- 01:47:39,766 --> 01:47:41,309
- I... I have to go.
- 1554
- 01:47:42,185 --> 01:47:43,686
- - Mrs. Bilott?
- - Yes.
- 1555
- 01:47:43,770 --> 01:47:46,981
- We think your husband's
- most likely experienced a TIA.
- 1556
- 01:47:47,065 --> 01:47:49,275
- A transient ischemic attack.
- 1557
- 01:47:49,359 --> 01:47:53,780
- Blood is briefly cut off to the brain,
- mimicking the symptoms of a stroke.
- 1558
- 01:47:55,281 --> 01:47:59,285
- Uh, excuse me. A TIA?
- This wasn't short.
- 1559
- 01:47:59,494 --> 01:48:01,871
- It... It kept going on.
- 1560
- 01:48:01,955 --> 01:48:03,289
- What about poison?
- 1561
- 01:48:03,915 --> 01:48:05,249
- I'm sorry?
- 1562
- 01:48:05,750 --> 01:48:08,002
- Could someone
- be poisoning him?
- 1563
- 01:48:08,086 --> 01:48:11,422
- No, Mrs. Bilott.
- This is neurological.
- 1564
- 01:48:12,090 --> 01:48:13,716
- You just said
- it wasn't a stroke.
- 1565
- 01:48:13,800 --> 01:48:15,593
- Well, not this time.
- 1566
- 01:48:15,677 --> 01:48:17,220
- - What does that mean?
- - Well, it means that
- 1567
- 01:48:17,345 --> 01:48:19,347
- - he needs to never miss his medication.
- - Mmm-hmm.
- 1568
- 01:48:19,430 --> 01:48:22,600
- And needs to reduce all
- sources of stress in his life.
- 1569
- 01:48:22,934 --> 01:48:25,269
- He's under
- enormous pressure at work.
- 1570
- 01:48:25,979 --> 01:48:29,190
- Well, that needs to change.
- But he's a young man.
- 1571
- 01:48:29,273 --> 01:48:30,650
- He shouldn't be
- having these incidences.
- 1572
- 01:48:32,360 --> 01:48:34,320
- He's sedated, but
- you can see him.
- 1573
- 01:48:34,445 --> 01:48:37,699
- - I'll check in on him tomorrow.
- - Thank you. Thank you.
- 1574
- 01:48:45,289 --> 01:48:47,875
- I'll give you
- some privacy.
- 1575
- 01:48:49,752 --> 01:48:52,630
- Anything you
- need, call me.
- 1576
- 01:48:56,009 --> 01:48:58,720
- I need you to stop making
- him feel like a failure.
- 1577
- 01:49:05,184 --> 01:49:09,063
- I appreciate the stress that your
- family must be going through.
- 1578
- 01:49:09,147 --> 01:49:12,608
- Please don't talk to
- me like I'm the wife.
- 1579
- 01:49:16,362 --> 01:49:19,574
- Did Rob ever tell you about
- moving around as a kid?
- 1580
- 01:49:20,366 --> 01:49:21,909
- I...
- 1581
- 01:49:21,993 --> 01:49:24,704
- Ten times before
- senior year.
- 1582
- 01:49:24,787 --> 01:49:26,831
- No friends,
- no ties, no...
- 1583
- 01:49:26,914 --> 01:49:29,459
- Just him, his sister,
- his folks.
- 1584
- 01:49:31,544 --> 01:49:33,796
- Then I came along and
- you came along and...
- 1585
- 01:49:36,257 --> 01:49:38,468
- Taft, it's not
- just a job.
- 1586
- 01:49:38,551 --> 01:49:41,471
- To him it's...
- It's home.
- 1587
- 01:49:45,224 --> 01:49:47,769
- And he was willing
- to risk all that
- 1588
- 01:49:48,061 --> 01:49:50,605
- for a stranger who
- needed his help.
- 1589
- 01:49:52,106 --> 01:49:57,111
- Now, you and I may
- not know what that is,
- 1590
- 01:49:59,322 --> 01:50:01,240
- but it's not failure.
- 1591
- 01:50:35,566 --> 01:50:39,821
- Lord, you have
- searched my heart
- 1592
- 01:50:40,238 --> 01:50:45,243
- And you
- know when I sit and when I stand
- 1593
- 01:50:45,743 --> 01:50:48,955
- Your hand is upon me
- 1594
- 01:50:49,038 --> 01:50:52,500
- Protecting me from death
- 1595
- 01:50:52,667 --> 01:50:57,797
- Keeping me from harm
- 1596
- 01:50:59,715 --> 01:51:05,888
- Oh, Lord, I know
- you are near
- 1597
- 01:51:10,309 --> 01:51:15,231
- Standing always at
- 1598
- 01:51:15,314 --> 01:51:18,484
- My side
- 1599
- 01:51:45,720 --> 01:51:48,014
- Hey, do you
- know the score?
- 1600
- 01:51:49,307 --> 01:51:53,019
- The game? Sorry,
- my radio's busted.
- 1601
- 01:51:54,645 --> 01:51:55,938
- Sorry.
- 1602
- 01:51:56,230 --> 01:51:58,191
- Don't worry about it.
- It'll be a surprise.
- 1603
- 01:51:58,482 --> 01:52:00,151
- Bucky, come on.
- We'll be late.
- 1604
- 01:52:01,986 --> 01:52:03,029
- Have a good one.
- 1605
- 01:53:45,506 --> 01:53:47,842
- Hey,
- Rob, Bill Leary. We haven't met.
- 1606
- 01:53:48,342 --> 01:53:50,094
- I'm the new comptroller
- out of Indianapolis.
- 1607
- 01:53:50,428 --> 01:53:53,723
- Listen, we need to talk about these
- unbilled hours and these unreimbursed...
- 1608
- 01:54:10,406 --> 01:54:12,867
- - Hello?
- - Mr. Bilott?
- 1609
- 01:54:13,492 --> 01:54:14,660
- Yes?
- 1610
- 01:54:14,744 --> 01:54:17,913
- I guess I should start
- by apologizing for taking...
- 1611
- 01:54:18,331 --> 01:54:20,583
- well, seven years to call you.
- 1612
- 01:54:20,666 --> 01:54:22,668
- - Who is this?
- - Oh, yes, of course.
- 1613
- 01:54:22,793 --> 01:54:26,547
- - It's Dr. Karen Frank from the...
- - Science Panel?
- 1614
- 01:54:27,923 --> 01:54:31,719
- Again, I'm so sorry to have kept
- you waiting this long, Mr. Bilott.
- 1615
- 01:54:32,094 --> 01:54:34,847
- - But there was just so much data...
- - Please, Doctor, please,
- 1616
- 01:54:35,181 --> 01:54:36,182
- can you...
- 1617
- 01:54:36,265 --> 01:54:38,476
- Would just please
- tell me what's happened?
- 1618
- 01:54:38,559 --> 01:54:41,270
- What's happening?
- What you've found out?
- 1619
- 01:54:41,354 --> 01:54:44,690
- Yes. You gave us an
- unprecedented amount of data.
- 1620
- 01:54:45,274 --> 01:54:48,277
- The largest epidemiological
- study in human history.
- 1621
- 01:54:49,028 --> 01:54:53,115
- It's irrefutable.
- We have linked sustained exposure to C-8
- 1622
- 01:54:53,199 --> 01:54:56,744
- to six categories of
- serious illness.
- 1623
- 01:55:01,624 --> 01:55:04,794
- Kidney cancer,
- testicular cancer...
- 1624
- 01:55:05,378 --> 01:55:08,130
- thyroid disease,
- preeclampsia...
- 1625
- 01:55:08,214 --> 01:55:10,966
- high cholesterol,
- ulcerative colitis.
- 1626
- 01:55:12,301 --> 01:55:16,097
- 3,635 people in the Class
- already have these diseases.
- 1627
- 01:55:17,014 --> 01:55:18,808
- Many more will
- develop them.
- 1628
- 01:55:20,810 --> 01:55:24,146
- Thanks to you the entire
- Class will be monitored...
- 1629
- 01:55:24,230 --> 01:55:27,525
- and those who get sick
- can seek restitution.
- 1630
- 01:55:29,276 --> 01:55:32,780
- You did a good thing here,
- Mr. Bilott. You did good.
- 1631
- 01:55:35,491 --> 01:55:37,076
- Thank you.
- 1632
- 01:57:30,105 --> 01:57:33,526
- Rob? What happened?
- 1633
- 01:57:37,988 --> 01:57:39,448
- Rob?
- 1634
- 01:57:41,700 --> 01:57:43,452
- DuPont, they're
- reneging.
- 1635
- 01:57:45,788 --> 01:57:48,082
- - Which part?
- - All of it.
- 1636
- 01:57:49,083 --> 01:57:50,626
- They're tearing up
- our agreement.
- 1637
- 01:57:51,001 --> 01:57:52,545
- Rejecting the
- Science Panel.
- 1638
- 01:57:52,628 --> 01:57:55,965
- They're gonna fight
- every claim in court.
- 1639
- 01:57:56,048 --> 01:57:59,552
- Thousands of claims.
- People, sick people, they'll give up.
- 1640
- 01:58:00,219 --> 01:58:01,554
- They can't
- fight DuPont!
- 1641
- 01:58:02,012 --> 01:58:04,765
- How can they
- go back on...
- 1642
- 01:58:04,890 --> 01:58:06,976
- - Sarah.
- - They can't go back on everything.
- 1643
- 01:58:07,059 --> 01:58:08,352
- They're a titan
- of industry.
- 1644
- 01:58:08,435 --> 01:58:09,687
- They can do whatever
- the hell they want.
- 1645
- 01:58:09,770 --> 01:58:10,938
- Nothing else matters.
- 1646
- 01:58:11,021 --> 01:58:12,565
- They can fight
- you all they want.
- 1647
- 01:58:12,648 --> 01:58:14,316
- It doesn't take away
- from what you've done!
- 1648
- 01:58:14,400 --> 01:58:17,653
- Of course, it does.
- That's exactly what it does!
- 1649
- 01:58:19,196 --> 01:58:21,323
- They want to show the world
- that it's no use fighting.
- 1650
- 01:58:21,407 --> 01:58:24,201
- Look, everybody,
- even he can't crack the maze
- 1651
- 01:58:24,285 --> 01:58:25,452
- and he's helped
- build it!
- 1652
- 01:58:26,453 --> 01:58:28,330
- The system is rigged!
- 1653
- 01:58:29,623 --> 01:58:31,500
- They want us to think
- it'll protect us,
- 1654
- 01:58:31,584 --> 01:58:32,668
- but that's a lie.
- 1655
- 01:58:32,751 --> 01:58:34,670
- We protect us. We do.
- 1656
- 01:58:34,920 --> 01:58:36,046
- Nobody else.
- 1657
- 01:58:37,965 --> 01:58:40,676
- Not the companies.
- Not the scientists.
- 1658
- 01:58:40,759 --> 01:58:42,511
- Not the government. Us.
- 1659
- 01:58:45,973 --> 01:58:49,143
- A farmer with a 12th grade
- education told me that.
- 1660
- 01:58:51,437 --> 01:58:55,816
- On day one, he knew
- and I thought he was crazy.
- 1661
- 01:59:03,157 --> 01:59:04,783
- Isn't that crazy?
- 1662
- 01:59:09,079 --> 01:59:11,081
- No.
- 1663
- 02:00:16,647 --> 02:00:18,273
- All rise.
- 1664
- 02:00:18,482 --> 02:00:19,900
- The honorable Timothy Burg...
- 1665
- 02:00:19,983 --> 02:00:23,445
- United States District Judge for the
- Southern District of Ohio presiding.
- 1666
- 02:00:23,529 --> 02:00:26,115
- This court is now in session
- pursuant to the adjournment.
- 1667
- 02:00:26,198 --> 02:00:27,908
- Hear ye, hear ye, hear ye.
- 1668
- 02:00:27,991 --> 02:00:30,369
- All persons having business
- with this honorable court
- 1669
- 02:00:30,619 --> 02:00:33,497
- draw near, give their attention
- and they shall be heard.
- 1670
- 02:00:33,580 --> 02:00:36,333
- God save the United States
- and this honorable court.
- 1671
- 02:00:36,417 --> 02:00:38,001
- Please be seated.
- 1672
- 02:00:38,085 --> 02:00:40,504
- And we're here this
- morning for a jury trial.
- 1673
- 02:00:41,130 --> 02:00:45,592
- So, 3,535 claims.
- 1674
- 02:00:46,135 --> 02:00:48,387
- At a rate of four
- or five cases a year,
- 1675
- 02:00:48,470 --> 02:00:50,472
- we can all expect
- to be here till...
- 1676
- 02:00:51,557 --> 02:00:54,685
- Well, the year 2890.
- If we're lucky.
- 1677
- 02:00:55,561 --> 02:00:56,854
- Guess we'd better
- get started.
- 1678
- 02:00:57,521 --> 02:00:59,440
- Mrs. Johnson, is your
- attorney present?
- 1679
- 02:01:00,733 --> 02:01:01,734
- Good morning, Your Honor.
- 1680
- 02:01:01,817 --> 02:01:03,026
- Rob Bilott for the plaintiff.
- 1681
- 02:01:03,777 --> 02:01:05,863
- Oh, still here, huh?
- 1682
- 02:01:06,822 --> 02:01:07,823
- Still here.
- 1683
- 02:02:04,882 --> 02:02:09,882
- Subtitles by <font color="#ff0000">explosiveskull</font>
- Sync by <font color="#00ffff">NAIM2007</font>
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment